Studies on antigenic competition. Efforts to identify the cellular basis of competition using a cell transfer system

Antigenic competition was studied in a cell transfer system. The effect of reconstituting lethally irradiated mice with various numbers of thymus or bone marrow cells on the extent of antigenic competition was evaluated. Brucella or burro erythrocytes both caused inhibition of the immune response (Plaque-forming cell) to sheep erythrocytes when given two days prior to the test antigen. Varying the dose of thymus cells, or of bone marrow cells did not alter the degree of competition. Competition was observed even when the competing antigen was injected with bone marrow cells alone two days before the test antigen and thymus cells. The results suggest that mechanisms other than T-cell activation alone must be considered as operative in some models of antigenic competition.     

Mechanism of antigenic competition. II. Induction by specific T cell products

Since previous work had indicated that the mechanism of antigenic competition induced by the injection of red cells was due to a reversible block of cooperation at the surface of the macrophage, the possibility that the inhibitor was complexes of IgT and antigen resulting from the previous response (to red cells) was investigated. Macrophages were incubated with supernatants from activated T cells (ATC), containing, or deprived of, IgT by incubation with anti-mouse Ig-coated sepharose beads. Macrophages incubated with ATC supernatants were immunogenic for the corresponding antigen, but were not capable of binding a second ATC supernatant, of different antigenic specificity, in an immunogenic way. In contrast, if IgT was previously removed, the macrophages were not immunogenic and were not blocked. These results support the concept that this form of antigenic competition is due to blockage of macrophage receptor sites for IgT.     

Dissociation of influenza virus hemagglutinin and neuraminidase eliminates their intravirionic antigenic competition.

When presented together on the intact influenza virus particle, the external hemagglutinin (HA) and neuraminidase (NA) antigens are competitive, with HA dominant over NA in both T- and B-cell priming (B. E. Johansson, T. M. Moran, and E. D. Kilbourne, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 84:6869-6873, 1987). Dissociation and purification of HA and NA from virus and their injection separately or in combination into BALB/c mice eliminates their antigenic competition as measured by antibody response, confirming that it is their structural association that leads to what we have termed intravirionic antigenic competition. We discuss this phenomenon with respect to previously described intermolecular antigenic competition and with regard to its probable mechanism. Our findings are relevant to contemporary interest in viral vaccine vectors and multicomponent vaccines.     

Proliferation of hemolysin-plaque-forming cells in nude mice and normal littermates subjected to antigenic competition.

The increase of PFC per spleen and the development of hemolytic foci were examined to clarify the patterns of clonal expansion of B-lymphocytes in athymic nude mice (nu/nu) and normal littermates (nu/+) subjected to the procedure for antigenic competition between horse erythrocytes (HRBC) and sheep erythrocytes (SRBC). In normal littermates without pretreatment with HRBC, a small number of PFC and hemolytic foci of small size were detected 2-days after the challenge with SRBC. The number of PFC increased progressively from day 2 to day 4, and hemolytic foci increased in the number and size during the period. In nude mice, a small number of PVFC were detected on day 2 and the number increased only slightly from day 2 to day 4. No large hemolytic foci were detected during the period. In normal littermates subjected to the procedure for antigenic competition, the patterns of increase of PFC and development of hemolytic foci were similar to those in nude mice. In nude mice, the procedure for antigenic competition exerted almost no effect on the patterns.     

Antigenic competition and genetic control of the immune response. A hypothesis for intramolecular competition

A study has been made of antigenic competition between the (Phe,Glu) and Pro-Lys regions of three synthetic multichain polypeptides, (Phe,Glu)-Ala-Lys, (Tyr,Glu)-Pro-Lys and (Phe,Glu)-Pro-Lys. Two strains of mice have been compared, C3H/HeJ, potentially high responders to both (Phe,Glu) and Pro-Lys, and DBA/1, high responders to (Phe,Glu), but genetic low responders to Pro-Lys. In C3H/HeJ, both intramolecular competition, within the (Phe,Glu)-Pro-Lys molecule, and intermolecular competition, with mixtures of (Tyr,Glu)-Pro-Lys and (Phe,Glu)-Ala-Lys occur. In general, Pro-Lys is the dominant determinant and suppresses the response to (Phe, Glu). In DBA/1, on the other hand, intramolecular competition is absent, but intermolecular competition is still present. The injection of the polyribonucleotide poly (A)·poly (U) corrects the low response to Pro-Lys in DBA/1, and at the same time restores intramolecular competition. Intramolecular competition is, therefore, related to the level of the antibody response to the dominant antigenic region, Pro-Lys. In contrast, intermolecular competition is independent of the antibody response to Pro-Lys, but is related to the ratio of the antigens (Tyr,Glu)-Pro-Lys and (Phe,Glu)-Ala-Lys in the mixture injected.A model is suggested in which intramolecular competition is a result of competition between specific B cells for limiting antigen. The model relates competition to original antigenic sin and the enhancement and suppression mediated by antibody. Intermolecular competition seems to have a different mechanism and to be a T cell effect. The relevance of these findings to studies on the genetic control of the immune response is discussed.     

The migration of lymphocytes into rat popliteal lymph nodes during antigenic promotion or competition between heterologous erythrocytes

The injection of chicken and sheep red blood cells (CRBC and SRBC) into rat popliteal lymph nodes either together or sequentially 2, 4, 6, or 8 days apart resulted in an enhanced immune response when the second antigen was injected 2 or 4 days after the injection of the first antigen (antigenic promotion) or a suppressed immune response when the second antigen was injected 6 days after the injection of the first antigen (antigenic competition). The immune response to either antigen was dependent upon the time of administration of the second antigen with respect to the first antigen. Lymphocyte migration into antigenically stimulated lymph nodes was greater when the two antigens were injected sequentially rather than together. Further, the migration of lymphocytes into the lymph node was enhanced when the second antigen was injected during the inductive or suppressive phase of the immune response to the first antigen (CRBC) regardless of whether the same (CRBC) or an antigenically unrelated antigen (SRBC) was used as the second antigen. While antigenic promotion may in part be explained by the increased rate at which lymphocytes migrate into lymph nodes, lymphocyte migration is also enhanced during antigenic competition. This suggests that while suppressor cells/factors may regulate the effector phase of an immune response they do not directly modulate the migration of blood-borne lymphocytes into the lymph node.     

The ecology of antigenic variation

A detailed molecular analysis using recombinant DNA technologies is extremely important to our understanding of the phenomena of antigenic variation in the African trypanosomes; however, by itself, it may not completely explain antigenic variation as it occurs in vivo. Several laboratories have demonstrated the ability of one variant population to replace another in vivo as well as the presence of heterogeneous populations of trypanosomes within an individual animal. These two phenomena do not permit us to explain antigen variation solely on the basis of the molecular regulation of variant antigen expression. In addition to studies in molecular biology, it will be necessary to define clearly the differences in growth rates of variant populations and the role of competition between these variants in a single anatomical site. It will also be necessary to determine the influence of various physiological environments on growth rates and the competition between the different variants of a single repertoire. It is concluded that the phenomenon of antigenic variation is a complex problem in ecology and population dynamics as well as molecular regulation. This paper is designated to examine a variety of the ecological parameters presumably involved in antigenic variation.     

A mouse plasma cell surface antigenic determinant (PLKB) recognized by xenoantiserum. Its relationship to the PC.1 antigenic determinant.

The specificities of the xenoantisera made against mouse myeloma cells have been compared to those recognized by alloantiserum by studying patterns of cytotoxicity on both normal and malignant plasma cells. Goat antiserum obtained by immunization with Balb/c mouse myeloma ADJ-PC-22A cells and purified by in vivo absorption could detect cell surface antigenic determinants present on plasma cells and on cells of liver, kidney, and brain (PLKB antigen), as we had previously reported for a similarly prepared rabbit antiserum. In spite of an apparent similarity between the tissue representation of the PLKB determinant and that of PC.1 antigenic determinants which were detected by DBA/2 anti-ADJ-PC-22A cell alloantiserum, the PLKB antigenic determinant is not identical with the PC.1 antigenic determinant, since the former is found on the tissues of PC.1-negative as well as PC.1-positive strains of mice. However, it was deduced that the PLKB antigenic determinant and the PC.1 antigenic determinant reside in close proximity on the cell surface or maybe even on the same molecule, since Fab fragments of antiserum against either PLKB or PC.1 blocked the cytotoxicity against both antigens. On the other hand, these Fab fragments did not inhibit the cytotoxicity of anti-H-2 antiserum, indicating that neither PLKB nor PC.1 antigenic determinants are in close proximity to H-2 antigens. Association of PLKB and PC.1 determinants was further supported by the finding that the loss of the PLKB determinant in a variant of myeloma MOPC-70A corresponds to the loss of PC.1 determinant on the same cells.     

Antigenic competition among different 'O' antigens of Salmonella enterica subspecies enterica serovars during hyperimmunization in pony mares

The present study on antigenic competition among somatic 'O' antigens of different Salmonella groups (A, B, C1, C2, D and E1) in mares revealed that the immune response to most of the antigens was not (A, B, C2) or little (C1, D) affected by antigenic competition. However, E1 group antigen, which induced high antibody titres (Avg. 12967.3) when given alone, produced almost 3.5 log2 lower antibody titres on giving with other antigens, indicating the antigenic competition among some Salmonella group antigens. The antigenic competition varied for different antigens even of the similar chemical nature. Therefore, antigens belonging to different somatic groups should not be given together for the purpose of raising polyvalent serum or for immunization using multivalent Salmonella vaccines prepared from strains of different 'O' groups revealing antigenic competition.     

Marked differences in the antigenic structure of human respiratory syncytial virus F and G glycoproteins.

Monoclonal antibodies directed against the glycoproteins of human respiratory syncytial virus were used in competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays for topological mapping of epitopes. Whereas epitopes of the F glycoprotein could be ascribed to five nonoverlapping antigenic sites, anti-G antibodies recognized unique epitopes, many of whose competition profiles overlapped extensively. Variant viruses selected with a neutralizing (47F) anti-F antibody lost the binding for only 47F and 49F antibodies, which mapped in the same antigenic area. In contrast, viruses selected with an anti-G antibody lost the capacity to bind most of the anti-G antibodies, and their G protein was not recognized by an anti-virus antiserum, indicating major changes in the antigenic structure of the G molecule. Finally, we found great antigenic variation of the G protein among viral isolates. This occurred even within viruses of the same subtype with only limited divergence of amino acid sequence between strains. All of these data indicate marked differences in the antigenic organization of the G and F glycoproteins of respiratory syncytial virus; we discuss these differences in terms of the chemical structure of the glycoproteins.     

Understanding original antigenic sin in influenza with a dynamical system

Original antigenic sin is the phenomenon in which prior exposure to an antigen leads to a subsequent suboptimal immune response to a related antigen. Immune memory normally allows for an improved and rapid response to antigens previously seen and is the mechanism by which vaccination works. I here develop a dynamical system model of the mechanism of original antigenic sin in influenza, clarifying and explaining the detailed spin-glass treatment of original antigenic sin. The dynamical system describes the viral load, the quantities of healthy and infected epithelial cells, the concentrations of naïve and memory antibodies, and the affinities of naïve and memory antibodies. I give explicit correspondences between the microscopic variables of the spin-glass model and those of the present dynamical system model. The dynamical system model reproduces the phenomenon of original antigenic sin and describes how a competition between different types of B cells compromises the overall effect of immune response. I illustrate the competition between the naïve and the memory antibodies as a function of the antigenic distance between the initial and subsequent antigens. The suboptimal immune response caused by original antigenic sin is observed when the host is exposed to an antigen which has intermediate antigenic distance to a second antigen previously recognized by the host''s immune system.     

Structural proteins of mammalian RNA tumor viruses: relatedness of the interspecies antigenic determinants of the major internal protein.

The relatedness of antigenic determinants of purified major core proteins of the murine, feline, RD 114/baboon, and woolly monkey/gibbon ape groups of RNA tumor viruses was examined by competition radioimmunoassay. In assay systems of a homologous antigen and antiserum, high affinity competition for binding to all of the antibodies was observed only with the homologous unlabeled protein; the core proteins of other groups of viruses showed only low affinity binding of a small fraction of antibodies, presumably those reactive with the interspecies determinants, at concentrations of competing protein 10- to 100-fold greater than that of the labeled antigen. The cross-reactive (interspecies) antigens of every two viruses were selectively examined by precipitating the purified 125-I-labeled protein with antiserum against each of the other proteins. The extent to which these shared determinants were common to the other viruses was then tested by the effectiveness of the proteins of each virus to compete for antibody binding. Several classes of interspecies determinants were distinguished: those common to two of the groups of viruses, others to three, and some to all four. Moreover, an even greater variety of interspecies determinants was indicated by differences in the affinity of the individual proteins for antibody binding, supporting the hypothesis that there are at least several, if not many, different interspecies determinants with a broad spectrum of antigenic cross-reactivity. These studies suggest that the murine and feline viruses are closely related as they contain cross-reactive antigenic determinants not shared with the other viruses, that the feline virus is more closely related to the woolly monkey virus than to RD 114, and that the RD 114 and woolly monkey viruses retain interspecies determinants shared relatively equally with each of the other viruses.     

Epitopes of herpes simplex virus type 1 glycoprotein gC are clustered in two distinct antigenic sites.

Epitopes of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) strain KOS glycoprotein gC were identified by using a panel of gC-specific, virus-neutralizing monoclonal antibodies and a series of antigenic variants selected for resistance to neutralization with individual members of the antibody panel. Variants that were resistant to neutralization and expressed an antigenically altered form of gC were designated monoclonal antibody-resistant (mar) mutants. mar mutants were isolated at frequencies of 10(-3) to 10(-5), depending on the antibody used for selection. The epitopes on gC were operationally grouped into antigenic sites by evaluating the patterns of neutralization observed when a panel of 22 antibodies was tested against 22 mar mutants. A minimum of nine epitopes was identified by this process. Three epitopes were assigned to one antigenic site (I), and six were clustered in a second complex site (II) composed of three distinct subsites, IIa, IIb, and IIc. The two antigenic sites were shown to reside in physically distinct domains of the glycoprotein, by radioimmunoprecipitation of truncated forms of gC. These polypeptides lacked portions of the carboxy terminus and ranged in size from approximately one-half that of the wild-type molecule to nearly full size. Antibodies recognizing epitopes in site II immunoprecipitated the entire series of truncated polypeptides and thereby demonstrated that site II resided in the N-terminal half of gC. Antibodies reactive with site I, however, did not immunoprecipitate fragments smaller than at least two-thirds the size of the wild-type polypeptide, suggesting that site I was located in the C-terminal portion. Sites I and II were also shown to be spatially separate on the gC polypeptide by competition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay with monoclonal antibodies representative of different site I and site II epitopes.     

Histamine release from cultured human basophils: lack of histamine resynthesis after antigenic release.

Human peripheral basophils can be maintained in cultured for up to 72 hr. These cells retain their functional integrity as judged by total histamine content and by their ability to release histamine by an IgE-mediated reaction in response to a specific antigen challenge. Cells cultured after suboptimal antigenic challenge could be activated to release histamine upon the addition of antigen. In contrast, cells culture after supra-optimal antigenic challenge did not fully recover their ability to release histamine even after 24 hr. With a variety of culture conditions, it was impossible to demonstrate any net synthesis of histamine in cells. Cells cultured after depletion of their stores by reaction with antigen did not show any net histamine formation. The experiments suggest that the basophil in peripheral blood is functionally an end-stage cell and can participate in the histamine release reaction only once.     

Isofocusing of antigenic small nuclear ribonucleoproteins. I. Compositional analysis

This report describes the behavior of antigenic small nuclear ribonucleoproteins (snRNPs) in native isofocusing gels. These RNA-protein complexes exhibited true isofocusing characteristics only when in the complexed form. Deproteinized snRNAs migrated to pH ranges which varied according to the pH of the application site. Immunological assays using lupus sera which recognized the La, Sm, and RNP determinants on these snRNPs established that the La and the Sm/RNP antigens segregated to pH 4.7-4.9 and 5.5-7.5, respectively. RNase digestion of these snRNPs did not alter the isofocusing migration of either the Sm or the La determinants. These antigenically active fractions contained the appropriate protein and RNA species shown by immunoprecipitation studies to associate with these antigenic determinants. The isofocusing fractions containing the uridylic acid-snRNPs were fully immunoprecipitable by anti-Sm sera, confirming their particulate integrity after isofocusing.     

Human glomerular basement membrane. Heterogeneity of antigenic determinants.

Human glomerular basement membrane was solubilized by digestion with proteolytic enzymes and immunoreactive components were quantitated and characterized by using rabbit antibodies raised against the particulate membrane. A number of antigens were demonstrated but they did not separate on gel filtration. However, two antigenic components in a collagenase digest of the membrane could be separated and isolated by Sepharose 6B chromatography. Chemical characterization suggests that both fragments are noncollagenous glycopeptides (molecular weights approx. 1,000,000 and 60,000--200,000, respectively).     

Evaluation of the antigenic structural changes in the rat liver after a single carcinogenic exposure]

A single injection of hepatocarcinogen (4-dimethylaminoazobenzene) to rats resulted in antigenic rearrangement in rat liver, typical of hepatocellular tumors, whereas the treatment with a non-carcinogen isomere (4-diethylaminoazobenzene) did not have the same effect. It is assumed that antigenic rearrangement in hepatocytes caused by 4-dimethylaminoazobenzene might be due to its carcinogenity.     

Structural factors modulate the activity of antigenic poliovirus sequences expressed on hybrid hepatitis B surface antigen particles.

We have studied the functional expression of antigenic poliovirus fragments carried by various hybrid hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) particles. Several constructions were made by using two different insertion sites in the HBsAg molecule (amino acid positions 50 and 113) and two different sequences, one derived from poliovirus type 1 (PV-1) and the other from PV-2. The inserted fragments each encompassed residues 93 to 103 of the capsid protein VP1, a segment which includes the linear part of the neutralization antigenic site 1 of the poliovirus. The antigenicity and immunogenicity of the hybrid particles were evaluated and compared in terms of poliovirus neutralization. A high level of antigenic and immunogenic activity of the PV-1 fragment was obtained by insertion at position 113 but not at position 50 of HBsAg. However, a cooperative effect was observed when two PV-1 fragments were inserted at both positions of the same HBsAg molecule. Antibodies elicited by the PV-2 fragment inserted at amino acid position 113 did not bind or neutralize the corresponding poliovirus strain. They did, however, bind a chimeric poliovirus in which the homologous antigenic fragment of PV-1 had been replaced by that of PV-2. The only virions that were neutralized by these antibodies were certain mutants carrying amino acid substitutions within the PV-2 fragment. These results show that position, constraints from the carrier protein, and nature of the inserted sequences are critically important in favoring or limiting the expression of antigenic fragments as viral neutralization immunogens.     

Class I major histocompatibility gene products of the brown Norway rat display two major antigenic regions

Sixteen Lewis anti-Brown Norway monoclonal antibodies and sera from alloimmunized Lewis rats were used to study the topographic relationships of antigenic determinants on class I major histocompatibility gene products. Only two independent antigenic regions were identified in competition binding assays. The first region is composed of a set of overlapping epitopes that are conserved in class I major histocompatibility products of mice and humans, as well as rats. In contrast, the second antigenic region appears in a restricted number of inbred rat strains and is not detected in other species. The data provide serologic confirmation, at the monoclonal and serum alloantibody level, of conserved polymorphisms in the major histocompatibility gene products of different species, a finding that is consistent with the amino acid sequences of these molecules.     

Human glomerular basement membrane. Heterogeneity of antigenic determinants

Human glomerular basement membrane was solubilized by digestion with proteolytic enzymes and immunoreactive components were quantitated and characterized by using rabbit antibodies raised against the particulate membrane. A number of antigens were demonstrated but they did not separate on gel filtration. However, two antigenic components in a collagenase digest of the membrane could be separated and isolated by Sepharose 6B chromatography. Chemical characterization suggests that both fragments are noncollagenous glycopeptides (molecular weights approx. 1 000 000 and 60 000–200 000, respectively).