Genetic variation in clonal traits of Trifolium repens and species interactions

Plants exhibit a great variety of types of clonal growth. Moderate variation in clonal traits often exists even within species. The consequences of these variations for species interaction are of great interests to ecologists. In this paper, I address the small-leaved (phalanx) to large-leaved (guerrilla) variation in white clover ( Trifolium repens ), and discuss its consequences for species and genotype coexistence. I also address the clonal and sexual resource allocation variants within the large-leaved type. Small-leaved and large-leaved genotypes differ in various aspects of clonal growth. The large-leaved genotype displays greater phenotypic plasticity but is less physiologically integrated than the small-leaved genotype. We examined the consequences in a grazed sward, where white clover and zoysia grass coexist. In this sward, white clover is patchily distributed. We first tested the hypothesis that the large-leaved genotype is more advantageous in growth than the small-leaved genotype. Results from both common garden and competition experiments supported the hypothesis. Second, we tested the hypothesis that within large-leaved plants, the clonal subtype (which invests more resources to stolons but less in flower heads than the sexual one) is more advantageous than the sexual one because it is more competitive. This hypothesis was rejected. Both subtypes coexisted in the sward. This is probably because the sexual subtype is superior for interpatch migration than the clonal one. Both subtypes differ in advantages they offer for between-patch and within-patch processes, which promotes their coexistence. Finally, field monitoring of the behavior of a large-leaved clone is described. This monitoring was conducted in a moderately grazed sward, where microenvironmental heterogeneity is extremely high in time and space.     

Saponins from Trifolium repens.

From the whole plant of white clover, Trifolium repens, five new triterpenoid saponins, designated cloversaponins I-V, were isolated together with four known saponins, beta-D-glucoronopyranosylsoyasapogenol B, soyasaponin I, soyasaponin II and azukisaponin II as their methyl esters. Their structures were determined by 2H NMR and 13C NMR spectroscopy and chemical evidence.     

Ecotypic variation of in vitro plantlet formation in white clover (Trifolium repens)

Sixteen Trifolium repens (white clover) genotypes of diverse geographic origin were tested for differences in organogenic potential of petiole and root derived explants. Significant differences were observed between ecotypes and explant types with respect to callus initiation and plantlet regenerability. The observed differences are attributed to existing genotypic variability as well as origin of explant tissue.     

Within-population variation in localized and integrated responses of Trifolium repens to biotically patchy environments

Summary Genets of Trifolium repens (white clover) were collected from three patches of old permanent pasture dominated by Agrostis capillaris, Holcus lanatus or Lolium perenne. Plants derived from the genets were grown with plants of one grass species present on one side of each T. repens, and a different grass species on the other side, in all combinations of two of the three grasses. Different modules (a node with its associated internode, leaf, and axillary bud) on the same clover plant responded independently to the microenvironment provided by their own neighbouring grasses. In contrast, all apical meristems on the plant reacted similarly, showing a unified response and integrating the effects of the different microenvironments experienced by the whole clover plant. This is consistent with what is known both physiologically about the nutrition of meristems and modules, and ecologically about the exploratory growth habit of the species. Averaged over all associated grasses, there was no significant variation in the final dry weight of the different clover genets but these differed in their growth habit response to different grasses. In response to Agrostis as a neighbour, each meristem of T. repens rapidly produced many small modules. New modules were produced more slowly and were larger when Holcus or Lolium was the neighbour. The same pattern of differences occurred among clovers sampled from different backgrounds. Either genetic differences paralleled plastic responses, or plastic changes in phenotype that developed in response to different neighbours in the field persisted in the greenhouse. Plants taken from backgrounds of different grass species showed different responses to growing with those grass species. The differences were manifest primarily in a positive leading diagonal effect of Holcus or not-Holcus. They were the result primarily of differences in the dry weight per module and the probability of development of the axillary bud into a branch. This confirms earlier results, and implicates the central importance of branching as a means of local response to the microenvironment.     

白三叶和红三叶对人工融冻胁迫的生理响应差异

采用人工模拟融冻胁迫方法,通过测定白三叶(Trifolium repens)和红三叶(T.prat-ense)在融冻胁迫中叶片细胞膜透性、MDA含量、抗氧化酶(SOD、POD、CAT)活力、渗透调节物(脯氨酸、可溶性糖和蛋白质)含量变化,以揭示未来气候变化对三叶草的影响。结果表明,经历融冻胁迫循环后抗冻力强的白三叶植株能恢复生长,而抗冻力弱的红三叶枯萎死亡。在融冻阶段,两三叶草叶片细胞膜透性增大、抗氧化酶活力增高、MDA和渗透调节物含量大幅增加;在冻融阶段,两三叶草叶片细胞膜透性降低、MDA含量下降、抗氧化酶活力降低。但在融冻胁迫循环中,白三叶叶片POD和CAT活力高于红三叶,脯氨酸含量较红三叶高5倍,但细胞膜透性低于红三叶。白三叶在-5℃抗逆生理指标达到最大值,而红三叶在-10℃。白三叶对环境温度变化反应敏感,在-5℃通过快速激活抗氧化酶系统和积累渗透调节物以抑制膜脂过氧化和维护细胞水分平衡在融冻适应上起重要作用。白三叶具有较强的抗融冻能力,是未来值得应用推广的优良园林绿化植物。     

Phosphate and Membrane Electropotentials in Trifolium repens L.

In Trifolium repens L. there were immediate transient depolarizationsof the membrane electropotential (E_vo) when KH₂PO₄ was addedto phosphate-free media, but these were of the same magnitudeas the controls (K²SO⁴ and KCI). Furthermore, the extents ofdepolarization were the same as the expected effect of the addedK⁺ calculated using the Goldman equation. There was no significantdepolarization on adding H₃PO₄ to buffered media. Consequently,there was no evidence for a depolarization caused by phosphate.This result provides evidence that the H⁺–H₂PO₄ symportin roots of T. repens operates with a stoichiometry of 1: 1. In a group of control plants ( + P plants) and a group whichwere stressed by reducing the supply of phosphate (– Pplants), the – P plants had lower values for E_vo than+P plants (– 118 mV and – 130 mV, respectively).The absence of phosphate from the measurement media also reducedE_vo (mean effect = 9 mV). A significant difference in E_vo between– P and + P plants persisted when phosphate was addedto – P plants. The electropotential difference acrossthe tonoplast (E_vo) in – P plants became more positivewith time. Key words: White clover, membrane transport, roots, tonoplast, symport     

The inheritance of cyanoglucoside content in Trifolium repens L.

A four generation backcross breeding program was undertaken. Analysis of the levels of cyanoglucoside in Acac progeny shows that the level of cyanoglucoside (linamarin and lotaustralin) is inherited and that part of the inherited variation in cyanoglucoside levels is attributable to the existence of different Ac alleles in the parent plant. In vitro microsomal cyanoglucoside biosynthetic activity was measured in a high-level and a low-level parent plant. There was no evidence for the presence of microsomes with different qualitative properties in the two plants. The Ac locus was shown to segregate independently of the S incompatibility locus.This research was supported in part by SERC Grant GRA 95550.     

Variation in growth attributes of contrasting populations of Trifolium repens

A range of growth attributes was measured in seedlings of 10 Trifolium repens populations, differing in leaf size and origin, grown in three temperature and two glasshouse environments. Growth rates of large leaf types of Mediterranean origin were higher than those of smaller leaf types at 10°C. However, the greater temperature response of the smaller leaf types resulted in higher growth rates for S.100 and S.184 than for a large leaf type from Israel at 20°C. The increase of growth rate with temperature was associated with changes in leaf area ratio and net assimilation rate between 10° and 15°C but only with changes in net assimilation rate between 15° and 20°C. Within each temperature environment, population differences in growth rate were related to differences in net assimilation rate rather than leaf expansion. At low temperature a greater proportion of dry matter was distributed to leaf tissue in large leaf types particularly those of Mediterranean origin but they showed a proportionately smaller increase in allocation to leaves with increasing temperature compared with small leaf types. In the glasshouse environments growth rates in spring were more than double those in the autumn. This difference was associated with net assimilation rates which were about five times greater in the spring environment. However, leaf area ratios in the spring were only half those in the autumn. These differences in leaf area ratio between the glasshouse environments were closely related to differences in specific leaf area but not to differences in distribution of dry matter to leaf tissue which was greater in the spring environment.     

Ovule abortion in white clover (Trifolium repens L.)

Plants of white clover ( Trifolium repens L.) cv. Olwen were grown in an open glasshouse maintained at a mean temperature of 20^oC and ovule growth and seed production measured. Differences in the rate of growth of ovules within ovaries were observed as early as 2 days after pollination. Ovules reached a maximum size after 8 days with the smallest only half the size of the largest. After 8 days, the smallest ovules became flaccid and shrivelled. Ovule position within the ovary had little effect on the frequency of seed set and although there was an apparently higher probability that central ovules produced a seed than those nearer the peduncle or style this was not statistically significant. Inflorescence position and floret position on the inflorescence had a significant effect on the number of seeds per floret and seed weight; the first formed inflorescences and the first florets to be pollinated on each inflorescence had more seeds per floret and heavier seeds and fewer florets with no seed than later pollinated florets. There were also differences between florets within the same whorl. The role of a number of factors which may influence floret site utilisation are discussed.     

Association of Rhizobium Strains with Roots of Trifolium repens

TWO TECHNIQUES WERE USED TO ASSESS THE BINDING OF RHIZOBIA TO CLOVER ROOTS: indirect counting after radiolabeling the bacteria and direct counting by using phase-contrast microscopy. Microscopic observations revealed a large variability in the number of bacteria associated with individual root hairs. This variability made unbiased counting by microscopy difficult. Systematic examination of all visible root hairs and "blind" counting of coded strains and treatments were adopted to minimize observer bias. The validity of the radiolabeling method was also examined in some detail. The reproducibility of results from this method was satisfactory. However, drawbacks of this method included its lack of sensitivity and its failure to distinguish between bacteria attached to mature root hairs, emerging root hairs, and undifferentiated epidermal cells. The method also failed to distinguish between individual bacteria and any aggregates that may be present. The ability of a number of chosen mutant strains of Rhizobium trifolii and their corresponding parent strains, as well as a number of nonhomologous strains, to bind to clover roots was assessed by using both of these methods. Our results gave no indication of specificity of R. trifolii binding to clover roots. 2-Deoxy-d-glucose did not appear to have a major inhibitory effect on the attachment of rhizobia to the host root, which suggests that lectin cross-bridging is not an obligatory step in the initiation of infection even though it may occur under some conditions. The presence or absence of the symbiotic plasmid was not correlated with bacterial adherence to the host plant root. Since host specificity functions are carried on this plasmid, our results suggest that binding of rhizobia to the legume root is not the basis of host specificity.     

Competition between cyanogenic and acyanogenic morphs of Trifolium repens

Summary To investigate the cost of the dimorphic cyanogenic system in Trifolium repens L., genotypes of the cyanogenic (T_c) and acyanogenic (T_a) morphs were grown in mixtures over a range of ratios and in pure stands at two levels of total density (low in a first experiment, high in a second experiment). The principles of the competition analysis employed were those related to the inverse linear model response. The morphs were compared using two interaction indices, the substitution rate and the relative resource total (RRT). The relative fitness of the two morphs, i.e. biomass and number of flowers per plant, suggests that the T_a morph has a competitive advantage over the T_c morph.     

The Development of Root Nodule Xylem Transfer Cells in Trifolium repens

Stereological analysis of micrographs of developing and functioningxylem transfer cells of Trifolium repens indicates that theER and dictyosomes may be involved in wall ingrowth deposition,and the ER in intracellular solute transport.     

Environment-induced Modifications to Root Longevity in Lolium perenne and Trifolium repens

Understanding how environmental factors affect the longevityof roots is essential if root mortality linked nutrient cyclingprocesses within ecosystems are to be understood, and the impactof natural and anthropogenic climate change properly evaluated.In this study the longevity of roots at two geographically andclimatically distinct sites were compared to identify the scaleof change that can occur due to environmental differences. Minirhizotrontubes were inserted into swards sown with the same variety ofLolium perenne and Trifolium repens at sites in the UK and Italy.Roots were viewed using a video camera and digitized imagesof roots generated at intervals. From these images the lifehistory of individual roots was determined and compared. Therewere few differences in patterns of longevity between differentspecies at the same site. Major differences, however, were observedbetween roots of the same species at different sites. For example,73% of Trifolium repens roots failed to survive for 21 d inItaly compared to only 29% at the UK site. Similarly, over 84%of Lolium perenne roots failed to survive for more than 21 din Italy compared to 38% in the UK. These data suggest thatenvironmental factors can have a major impact on root longevity.Copyright 2000 Annals of Botany Company Climate change, Lolium perenne L., minirhizotron, perennial ryegrass, root longevity, Trifolium repens L., white clover     

Physiological integration in the clonal perennial herb Trifolium repens L.

Summary Translocation of ¹⁴C-labelled carbohydrates between the parent stolon and branches, and among branches, of Trifolium repens plants was investigated in two glasshouse experiments to determine patterns of physiological organisation in this clonal species. Differential defoliation treatments were applied to the parent stolon and/or branches to test the sensitivity of translocation to the short-term carbon needs of defoliated sinks. Strong reciprocal exchange of carbohydrate between the parent stolon and branches was observed, with 18 41% of the ¹⁴C exported from leaves on the parent stolon moving to branches, while branches simulta-neously exported 25% (for old source branches) to 54% (for young source branches) of the ¹⁴C they assimilated to the parent plant, including translocation to other branches. Branch-to-branch translocation occurred both acropetally and basipetally. Parent-to-branch, branch-to-parent and branch-to-branch carbon fluxes all increased in response to defoliation of the sink, at the expense of carbon supply to stolon tissue or roots of the source module. Reduced export to stolon tissue of the parent axis played a major role in facilitating C reallocation from leaves on the parent stolon to defoliated branches. The observed patterns of C allocation and translocation could be adequately explained by accepted source-sink theory, and are consistent with a high degree of intra-plant physiological integration in resource supply and utilisation. This information provides mechanistic explanations for aspects of the growth dynamics and ecological interactions of T. repens in the patchy environment of a grazed pasture.     

Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi reduce effects of physiological integration in Trifolium repens

Background and Aims

One of the special properties of clonal plants is the capacity for physiological integration, which can increase plant performance through mechanisms such as resource sharing and co-ordinated phenotypic plasticity when plants grow in microsites with contrasting resource availabilities. However, many clonal plants are colonized by arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF). Since AMF are likely to reduce contrasts in effective resource levels, they could also reduce these effects of clonal integration on plasticity and performance in heterogeneous environments.

Methods

To test this hypothesis, pairs of connected and disconnected ramets of the stoloniferous herb Trifolium repens were grown. One ramet in a pair was given high light and low nutrients while the other ramet was given high nutrients and low light. The pairs were inoculated with zero, one or five species of AMF.

Key Results

Pairs of ramets grown without AMF developed division of labour and benefited from resource sharing, as indicated by effects of connection on allocation to roots, accumulation of mass, and ramet production. Inoculation with five species of AMF significantly reduced these effects of connection, both by inhibiting them in ramets given high nutrients and inducing them in ramets given high light. Inoculation with one species of AMF also reduced some effects of connection, but generally to a lesser degree.

Conclusions

The results show that AMF can significantly modify the effects of clonal integration on the plasticity and performance of clonal plants in heterogeneous environments. In particular, AMF may partly replace the effects and benefits of clonal integration in low-nutrient habitats, possibly more so where species richness of AMF is high. This provides the first test of interaction between colonization by AMF and physiological integration in a clonal plant, and a new example of how biotic and abiotic factors could interact to determine the ecological importance of clonal growth.Key words: Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi, biomass allocation, clonal plant, division of labour, environmental heterogeneity, light availability, nutrients, white clover