Challenges and frustrations in the separation and analysis of chiral agrochemicals

The development of chiral HPLC methods and isolation techniques within Zeneca Agrochemicals (formerly ICI Agrochemicals) is reviewed. The use of low temperature to improve chiral separations has been successfully applied to production analysis, but although useful for some compounds it is regrettably not a universal panacea for all poor separations. The need to isolate small quantities of individual enantiomers from new compounds for research evaluation has led us to devise a more universal and cheap chiral stationary phase (CSP) for Preparative-LC. Joint academic research produced a CSP based on tartaric acid which was made commercially available and it was gratifying to find it was the only phase able to resolve a novel insecticide. However, as new CSPs emerged almost every month, our attention turned to using a universal chiral detector for analysis, rather than via separation of individual enantiomers. Diode laser-based polarimeters offered the opportunity of cheap, sensitive chiroptical detectors for HPLC and the ability to move away from chiral columns in both research and production analysis. Jointly sponsored research with a university has successfully explored the versatility of chiroptical detectors in agrochemical and food analysis. Comparison of chiral SFC with chiral HPLC and an extensive evaluation of established and research agrochemicals on a wide range of commercial CSPs have led to a revised method development strategy. Current work with high load displacement chiral chromatography will be described as a potential means of isolating pure enantiomers from racemates. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Role of the weak interactions in enantiorecognition of racemic dihydropyrimidinones by novel brush-type chiral stationary phases

The chiral discrimination ability of two recently prepared chiral stationary phases (CSP 1 and CSP 2), based on a leucine derived chiral selector, was tested for the enantiomers of dihydropyrimidone (DHPM) derivatives and compared with the commercially available Hyun-leucine CSP 3 and classical Pirkle-leucine CSP 4. By combining all of these CSPs, the enantiomers of all DHPM derivatives used in this study can be properly resolved. Particularly good enantioresolutions were achieved for thioureide derivatives, such as Monastrol. The results presented show that sulfur-aromatic interactions are meritorious for these very good separations.     

Liquid chromatographic resolution of 3-amino-1,4-benzodiazepin-2-one derivatives on various Pirkle-type chiral stationary phases

The two enantiomers of N-acyl amide and N-ureide derivatives of 3-amino-5-phenyl-1,4-benzodiazepin-2-ones, which have been known to show anti-respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) activity, were resolved on seven different Pirkle-type chiral stationary phases (CSPs) with the use of 10% isopropyl alcohol in hexane as a mobile phase. Among the seven Pirkle-type CSPs, the one based on (S)-leucine derivative named as N-Phe-L-Leu was found to be most successful, the separation factors (α) and the resolutions (R(S) ) for seven analytes being in the range of 1.78-4.21 and 5.94-15.08, respectively. By resolving N-benzyloxycarbonyl derivatives of 3-amino-5-phenyl(or 5-methyl)-1,4-benzodiazepin-2-ones on Pirkle-type CSPs, the phenyl ring at the 5-position and the N?H hydrogen at the 1-position of analytes were found to play an important role in the chiral recognition.     

Enantioseparation and molecular modeling study of chiral amines as three naphthaldimine derivatives using amylose or cellulose trisphenylcarbamate chiral stationary phases

This study describes the enantioseparation of three chiral amines as naphthaldimine derivatives, using normal phase HPLC with amylose and cellulose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) chiral stationary phases (CSPs). Three chiral amines were derivatized using three structurally similar naphthaldehyde derivatizing agents, and the enantioselectivity of the CSPs toward the derivatives was examined. The degree of enantioseparation and resolution was affected by the amylose or cellulose-derived CSPs and aromatic moieties as well as a kind of chiral amine. Especially, efficient enantiomer separation was observed for 2-hydroxynapthaldimine derivatives on cellulose-derived CSPs. Molecular docking studies of three naphthaldimine derivatives of leucinol on cellulose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) were performed to estimate the binding energies and conformations of the CSP–analyte complexes. The obtained binding energies were in good agreement with the experimentally determined enantioseparation and elution order.     

Enantiomeric separation of prothioconazole and prothioconazole‐desthio on chiral stationary phases

Prothioconazole is a type of broad‐spectrum triazole thione fungicide developed by the Bayer Company. Prothioconazole‐desthio is the main metabolite of prothioconazole in the environment. In our study, enantiomeric separation of prothioconazole and prothioconazole‐desthio was performed on various chiral stationary phases (CSPs) by high‐performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). It was found that polysaccharide CSPs showed better ability than brushing CSPs in enantiomeric separation. The successful chiral separation of prothioconazole could be achieved on self‐made Chiralcel OD, commercialized Chiralcel OJ‐H and Lux Cellulose‐1. Chiralpak IA, Chiralpak IB, Chiralpak IC, Chiralcel OD, Chiralpak AY‐H, Chiralpak AZ‐H, and Lux Cellulose‐1 realized the baseline separation of prothioconazole‐desthio enantiomers. Simultaneous enantiomeric separation of prothioconazole and prothioconazole‐desthio was performed on Lux Cellulose‐1 using acetonitrile (ACN) and water as mobile phase. In most cases, low temperature favored the separation of two compounds. The influence of the mobile phase ratio or type was deeply discussed. We obtained larger Rs and longer analysis time with a smaller proportion of isopropanol (IPA) or ethanol and more water content at the same temperature. The ratio of ACN and water had influences on the outflow orders of prothioconazole‐desthio enantiomers. This work provides a new approach for chiral separation of prothioconazole and prothioconazole‐desthio with a discussion of chiral separation mechanism on different CSPs.     

A chiral stationary phase which affords unusually high levels of enantioselectivity

A chiral stationary phase (CSP) derived from N-(1-naphthyl) leucine has been prepared. This CSP is conceptually similar to the CSP derived from N-(2-naphthyl)alanine and was expected to separate the enantiomers of the same clientele of analytes as does the latter. The magnitudes of the separation factors observed on the two CSPs may differ markedly for a given analyte, the new CSP often affording much greater enantioselectivity.     

Direct HPLC enantioseparation of chiral aptazepine derivatives on coated and immobilized polysaccharide-based chiral stationary phases

The direct HPLC enantioseparation of Mianserin and a series of aptazepine derivatives is accomplished on polysaccharide-based chiral stationary phases (CSPs). The resolutions are performed on the coated-type Chiralcel OD and Chiralpak AD CSPs and on the first commercially available immobilized-type Chiralpak IA CSP, in normal-phase and polar-organic modes. The complete separation of enantiomers of all racemates investigated was successfully achieved under at least one of CSP/eluent combinations employed. Pure alcohols such ethanol or 2-propanol, with a fixed percentage of DEA added, serve as valuable alternatives to the more common n-hexane-based normal-phase eluents in resolution of Mianserin on the AD CSP. In order to study the chiroptical properties of aptazepine derivatives, chromatographic resolutions are carried out at semipreparative scale using Chiralpak AD and Chiralpak IA as CSPs. Nonconventional dichloromethane-based eluents have permitted to expand the chiral resolving ability of the immobilized Chiralpak IA CSP and to perform mg-scale enantioseparations with an analytical-size column. Assignment of the absolute configuration of the separated enantiomers is empirically established by comparing their chiroptical data with those of structurally related Mianserin.     

Chiral separation based on immobilized intact and fragmented cellobiohydrolase II (CBH II): A comparison with cellobiohydrolase I (CBH I)

Intact and fragmented cellobiohydrolase II (CBH II) were immobilized to silica and used as chiral stationary phases (CSPs) for liquid chromatographic separations of enantiomers. Both acidic and basic chiral compounds could be resolved into their enantiomers on these phases. The enantioselectivities obtained on intact CBH II and its core were almost equivalent. Comparisons were also made with CBH I silica. It was found that the new materials show quite different chiral and chromatographic properties. The enzymatic activity of the CBH II in free solution was influenced by alprenolol and mexiletine, both separated on the corresponding CSP. It indicates that the sites for catalysis and for chiral recognition overlap. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Enantioseparation of α‐Hydroxyallylphosphonates and Phosphonoallylic Carbonate Derivatives on Chiral Stationary Phases Using Sequential UV,Polarimetric, and Refractive Index Detection

Chromatographic separation of the enantiomers of parent compounds dimethyl α‐hydroxyallyl phosphonate 1a and 1‐(dimethoxyphosphoryl) allyl methyl carbonate 1b was demonstrated by high‐performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) using Chiralpak AS‐H and ad ‐H chiral stationary phases (CSP), respectively, using a combination of UV, polarimetric, and refractive index detectors. A comparison was made of the separation efficiency and elution order of enantiomeric α‐hydroxyallyl phosphonates and their carbonate derivatives on commercially available polysaccharide AS, ad , OD, IC‐3, and Whelk‐O 1 CSPs. In general, the α‐hydroxyallyl phosphonates were resolved on the AS‐H CSP, whereas the carbonate derivatives 1b and 2b were preferentially resolved on the ad ‐H CSP. The impact of aryl substitution on the resolution of analytes 1d , 1e , 1f and 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 was evaluated. Thermodynamic parameters determined for enantioselective adsorption hydroxyphosphonates 1a and 4 on the AS‐H CSP and carbonate 1b on the ad ‐H CSP demonstrated enthalpic control for separation of the enantiomers. Chirality 28:656–662, 2016. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Comparative HPLC Enantioseparation of Thirty‐Six Aromatic Compounds on Four Columns of the Lux® Series: Impact of Substituents,Shapes and Electronic Properties

With the aim to define a combined computational/chromatographic empirical approach useful for the high‐performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) method development of new chiral compounds, 36 racemic aromatic compounds with different chemical structures were used as test probes on four polysaccharide‐based chiral stationary phases (CSPs) of the Lux series, namely Lux Cellulose‐1, Lux Cellulose‐2, Lux Cellulose‐4, and Lux Amylose‐2, using classical n‐hexane/2‐propanol mixtures as mobile phase. Electrostatic potential surfaces (EPSs) determined using Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations were used to derive size, shape, and electronic properties of each analyte. Then a comparative HPLC screening was carried out in order to evaluate the impact of substituents, shapes, and electronic properties of the analytes on the chromatographic behavior as the column changes. The four CSPs showed good complementary recognition ability. The elution sequence was determined in 30 cases out of 36. The success rate to afford baseline separations (R_s ≥ 1.5) was estimated: 29 compounds out of 36 showed baseline enantioseparation on at least one of the four selected CSPs. The combined computational‐chromatographic screening furnished useful collective structure‐chromatographic behavior relationships and a map of the chiral discrimination abilities of the considered CSPs towards the analytes. On this basis, the chromatographic behavior of new analytes on a set of polysaccharide‐based CSPs can be mapped through the qualitative correlation of chromatographic parameters (k, α, R_s) to computed molecular properties of the analytes. Chirality 25:709–718, 2013. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Synthesis of poly(phenylacetylene)s containing chiral phenylethyl carbamate residues as coated-type CSPs with high solvent tolerability

Two novel helical poly(phenylacetylene) derivatives containing chiral phenylethyl carbamate residues in the end of each side chain ( PPA-S and PPA-R ) were synthesized by polymerization of the corresponding phenylacetylene monomers using Rh(nbd)BPh₄ as a catalyst in DMF. The enantioseparation properties of the polymers were evaluated as coated-type chiral stationary phases (CSPs) for high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Under the same chromatographic conditions, PPA-S and PPA-R showed different enantioseparation properties, indicating that the different interactions between the analytes and the polymers, which result from the different chiral phenylethyl carbamate groups in the end of each side chains. Racemates 1 , 7 , and 8 could be better resolved on PPA-S , while racemate 6 was separated on PPA-R more efficiently. In addition, the coated-type CSPs showed good solvent tolerability and could work without any damage by introducing the polar solvents, such as CHCl₃ and THF, in eluent. Moreover, some racemates could be better resolved on these coated-type CSPs with the addition of THF to the eluent.     

Chiral recognition of binaphthyl derivatives: a chiral recognition model on the basis of chromatography, spectroscopy, and molecular mechanistic calculations for the enantioseparation of 1,1'-binaphthyl derivatives on cholic acid-bonded stationary phases.

In an effort to elucidate the mechanism of chiral discrimination of cholic acid-based stationary phases, the enantiomeric recognition ability of six chiral stationary phases (CSPs), prepared from differently substituted cholic acid derivatives, was evaluated in normal phase high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with a series of 1,1'-binaphthyl compounds. The influence of structural variations of analytes on retention and enantioselectivity was investigated. Particularly high values of enantioselectivity were observed for the binaphthol enantiomers on a CSP prepared from the allyl 7 alpha,12 alpha-dihydroxy-3 alpha-phenylcarbamoyloxy-5 beta-cholan-24-oate. The complexes of this chiral selector with both enantiomers of binaphthol were studied as models for the interactions responsible for the enantioseparation with the cholic acid-based stationary phases. The 1:1 stoichiometry of the complex in solution was determined by UV titration. The chiral selector dissolved in chloroform exhibited a chiral discrimination for the binaphthol in (1)H and (13)C nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopies. Some aromatic proton and carbon resonances of binaphthol were clearly separated into a pair of peaks due to enantiomers in the presence of the chiral selector. Moreover, on the basis of molecular mechanics calculation, a chiral discrimination model was proposed which nicely explains the relevant chromatographic behavior of the 1,1'-binaphthyl derivatives.     

Evaluation of π-acid chiral stationary phases deriving from tyrosine and related amino acids for the chromatographic resolution of racemates: Specific requirements for enantiorecognition ability

Chromatographic applications of three novel chiral stationary phases (CSPs) deriving from (S)-(N)-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)tyrosine are reported, under liquid chromatographic (LC) and subscritical fluid chromatographic (SubFC) conditions. Two grafting modes of the chiral moiety have been experimented starting either from γ-mercaptopropyl-silanized (type 1) or γ-aminopropyl-silanized (type 2) silica gels. For type 2 CSPs an evaluation of the stability of the amide linkage was achieved by means of SubFC; the relative contriution of ionic and covalent bindings to the ciral recognitio aility was then outlined. The chromatographic properties of these CSPs were compared with those of the corresponding CSPs deriving from phenylglycine, p-hydroxyphenylglycine, and phenylalanine for the resolution of some tertiary phosphine oxide, naphthoyl amide, and α-methylene γ-lactam enantiomers. Some simple requirements regarding the solute and CSP structures for chiral recognition ability can be inferred from these results. In addition, the resolutio of π-acid α-N-(3,5-dinitrobenzoyl)amino esters was investigated on these π-acid CSPs. An example of preparative scale chromatography is also presented.     

Dynamic HPLC of stereolabile iron(II) complexes on chiral stationary phases

A series of chiral tris-(1,10)-phenanthroline iron(II) complexes have been resolved by HPLC on chiral stationary phases based on either cellulose tris-(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate) or teicoplanin. At sub ambient temperatures, baseline separation of the enantiomers was observed for five different iron(II) complexes featuring substituted phenanthroline ligands. Dynamic HPLC profiles were observed near or above room temperature, indicating on-column Delta/Lambda enantiomerization. Rate constants for the Delta/Lambda interconversion in free solution and during chromatography were obtained by thermal racemization experiments and by computer simulation of the HPLC dynamic plots, respectively.     

Enantiomers of a nonylphenol isomer: absolute configurations and estrogenic potencies

Enantiomers of 4-(1,1,2-trimethylhexyl)phenol, a chiral isomer of the endocrine disrupting chemical nonylphenol, have been resolved and isolated by preparative chiral HPLC. The absolute configurations of the enantiomers were then determined by an X-ray crystallographic study of the (-)-camphanoyl derivative of the first eluted enantiomer NP(35)E1. The first enantiomer (NP(35)E1) and the second enantiomer (NP(35)E2) eluted were found to have the S and R absolute configurations, respectively. The estrogenic potencies of the S and R enantiomers were tested by the E-screen assay. A slight difference was observed in the relative proliferative effect between the S enantiomer and R enantiomer in the E-screen assay.     

Enantiorecognition of triiodothyronine and thyroxine enantiomers using different chiral selectors by HPLC and micro-HPLC

This paper deals with the chiral separation of triiodothyronine (T₃) and thyroxine (T₄) by HPLC and micro-HPLC. The separation of T₃ and T₄ is of great pharmaceutical and clinical interest, since the enantiomers exhibit different pharmacological activities. The HPLC measurements were performed on a chiral stationary ligand-exchange phase using l-4-hydroxyproline bonded via 3-glycidoxypropyltrimethoxysilane to silica gel as a selector. Also a chiral teicoplanin (Chirobiotic ™®) phase was used.

In micro-HPLC the chiral separation behaviour of l-4-hydroxyproline, and of the macrocyclic antibiotics teicoplanin and teicoplanin aglycone was investigated for the enantioseparation of T₃ and T₄. l-4-Hydroxyproline was bonded to 3 μm and the glycopeptide antibiotics were bonded to 3.5 μm silica gel and separations were accomplished by microbore HPLC columns (10 cm × 1 mm I.D.). With both techniques and all chiral selectors investigated T₃ and T₄ were baseline resolved. micro-HPLC was found to be superior to analytical HPLC with respect to low consumption of packing material, mobile phase and analyte.     

Use of a new pirkle-type chiral stationary phase in analytical and preparative subcritical fluid chromatography of pharmaceutical compounds

Good results have been obtained with use of the new bonded chiral stationary phase Whelk-O 1 in analytical and preparative subcritical fluid chromatography. A wide variety of enantiomeric pairs of compounds with different functional groups that are of pharmaceutical and biological interest have been resolved. This Pirkle-concept CSP appears to be more rugged than cellulosic phases (e.g., Chiralcel) with regards to solvents and pressure. In comparing the usefulness of the column for SFC versus HPLC chiral analysis, we have observed a clear superiority of SFC in terms of higher speed and efficiency of analysis, and faster method development. This is consistent with our experience with Chiralcel CSPs. With the Whelk-O 1 we have shown that the effects of temperature and modifier on SFC separations are similar to what has been reported for most other CSPs. We also observed a unique selectivity advantage of SFC for verapamil. We had good success with using a 1-in. diameter column packed with Whelk-O 1 to perform preparative SFC separations of a number of enantiomeric mixtures. The advantages of preparative SFC over preparative HPLC will be discussed. The feasibility of preparative SFC is dependent on how well we meet the practical challenges such as sample introduction issues, special hardware requirements due to the high pressure, and fraction collection issues. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Evaluation of dalbavancin as chiral selector for HPLC and comparison with teicoplanin‐based chiral stationary phases

Dalbavancin is a new compound of the macrocyclic glycopeptide family. It was covalently linked to 5 μm silica particles using two different binding chemistries. Approximately 250 racemates including (a) heterocyclic compounds, (b) chiral acids, (c) chiral amines, (d) chiral alcohols, (e) chiral sulfoxides and sulfilimines, (f) amino acids and amino acid derivatives, and (g) other chiral compounds were tested on the two new chiral stationary phases (CSPs) using three different mobile phases. As dalbavancin is structurally related to teicoplanin, the same set of chiral compounds was screened on two commercially available teicoplanin CSPs for comparison. The dalbavancin CSPs were able to separate some enantiomers that were not separated by the teicoplanin CSPs and also showed improved separations for many racemates. However, there were other compounds only separated or better separated on teicoplanin CSPs. Therefore, the dalbavancin CSPs are complementary to the teicoplanin CSPs. Chirality, 2010. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Enantiomeric separation of imidazolinone herbicides using chiral high-performance liquid chromatography

Chiral high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) is one of the most powerful tools to prepare enantiopure standards of chiral compounds. In this study, the enantiomeric separation of imidazolinone herbicides, i.e., imazethapyr, imazapyr, and imazaquin, was investigated using chiral HPLC. The enantioselectivity of Chiralpak AS, Chiralpak AD, Chiralcel OD, and Chiralcel OJ columns for the three analytes was compared under similar chromatographic conditions. Chiralcel OJ column showed the best chiral resolving capacity among the test columns. The resolved enantiomers were distinguished by their signs of circular dichroism detected at 275 nm and their structures confirmed with LC-mass spectrometric analysis. Factors affecting the chiral separation of imidazolinones on Chiralcel OJ column were characterized. Ethanol acted as a better polar modifier than the other alcohols including 2-propanol, 1-butanol, and 1-pentanol. Although the acidic modifier in the mobile phase did not influence chiral recognition, it was necessary for reducing the retention time of enantiomers and suppressing their peak tailing. Thermodynamic evaluation suggests that enantiomeric separation of imidazolinones on Chiralcel OJ column is an enthalpy-driven process from 10 to 40 degrees C. This study also shows that small amounts of pure enantiomers of imidazolinones may be obtained by using the analytical chiral HPLC approach.     

Comparative HPLC enantioseparation of ferrocenylalcohols on two cellulose-based chiral stationary phases

The direct HPLC enantiomeric separation of several ferrocenylalcohols on the commercially available Chiralcel OD and Chiralcel OJ columns has been evaluated in normal-phase mode. Almost all the compounds were resolved on one or both chiral stationary phases (CSPs) with separation factor (alpha) ranging from 1.06 to 2.88 while the resolution (R(s)) varied from 0.63 to 12.70 In the separation of the alpha-ferrocenylalcohols 1a-e and the phenyl analogues 2a-e, which were all resolved except 1c, a similar trend in the retention behavior for the two series of alcohols was evidenced and the selectivity was roughly complementary on the two investigated CSP. For three ferrocenylacohols, chosen as model compounds, the influence of the mobile phase composition and temperature on the enantioseparation were investigated and additional information on the chiral recognition mechanism were deduced from the chromatographic behavior of their acetylderivatives.