Normal telomere lengths of spermatozoa in somatic cell-cloned bulls

Interesting questions have been raised regarding cloned animals, including whether cloning restores cellular senescence undergone by donor cells, and how long cloned animals will be able to live. In this study, focusing our attention on the fact that telomere lengths of spermatozoa are longer than those of any somatic cells and that telomere length is maintained throughout aging in humans, we compared the telomere lengths of spermatozoa in normal and two somatic cell-cloned cattle. The telomere lengths of the spermatozoa in the normal cattle (22.42+/-0.32 kb) were maintained throughout aging as in humans. In the cloned cattle, telomere lengths of the spermatozoa (25.8 and 20.9 kb) were the same as or longer than those found in normal cattle. Considering that telomere lengths of the donor cells, which had been derived from the muscle tissue of an old bull, were reported to be 20.1 kb, the results suggested that the telomere lengths of the germ cell line had extended from nucleus transfer to spermatogenesis. Moreover, we produced offspring (nine calves) from a somatic cell-cloned bull and measured the telomere lengths of their leukocytes. In all of the offspring, the telomere lengths of leukocytes were normal, too. These results indicate the possibility that somatic cloned bulls could be used as breeding sires.     

The analysis of telomere length and telomerase activity in cloned pigs and cows

Inefficiency in the production of cloned animals is most likely due to epigenetic reprogramming errors after somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT). In order to investigate whether nuclear reprogramming restores cellular age of donor cells after SCNT, we measured telomere length and telomerase activity in cloned pigs and cattle. In normal pigs and cattle, the mean telomere length was decreased with biological aging. In cloned or transgenic cloned piglets, the mean telomere length was elongated compared to nuclear donor fetal fibroblasts and age-matched normal piglets. In cloned cattle, no increases in mean telomere length were observed compared to nuclear donor adult fibroblasts. In terms of telomerase activity, significant activity was observed in nuclear donor cells and normal tissues from adult or new-born pigs and cattle, with relatively higher activity in the porcine tissues compared to the bovine tissues. Cloned calves and piglets showed the same level of telomerase activity as their respective donor cells. In addition, no difference in telomerase activity was observed between normal and transgenic cloned piglets. However, increased telomerase activity was observed in porcine SCNT blastocysts compared to nuclear donor cells and in vitro fertilization (IVF)-derived blastocysts, suggesting that the elongation of telomere lengths observed in cloned piglets could be due to the presence of higher telomerase activity in SCNT blastocysts. In conclusion, gathering from the comparative studies with cattle, we were able to demonstrate that telomere length in cloned piglets was rebuilt or elongated with the use of cultured donor fetal fibroblasts.     

Telomere lengths in cloned transgenic pigs

Studies of cloned cattle and mice have resulted in controversies regarding the restoration of eroded telomere length of donor cells by the nuclear transfer process. Little is known about telomere lengths in pigs from either natural reproduction or nuclear transfer. In this study, we measured the telomere lengths in six major porcine organs from animals of different ages, and found that their lengths remained consistent throughout different tissues during fetal stages, and then shortened, in a tissue- specific manner, after birth. Telomeres of skin samples from six cloned transgenic pigs at 4 mo of age did not differ significantly from those of age-matched controls. Two cloned pigs that died shortly after birth had skin telomere lengths equivalent to those of late-stage fetuses.     

Nuclear transfer in cattle using colostrum-derived mammary gland epithelial cells and ear-derived fibroblast cells

To assess the developmental potential of nuclear transfer embryos in cattle using mammary gland epithelial (MGE) cells derived from the colostrum, we compared the effectiveness of cloning using those cells and fibroblast cells derived from the ear. The fusion rate of the enucleated oocytes with fibroblast cells (75 +/- 4%) was significantly higher than that with MGE cells (56 +/- 7%, P<0.05). There were no significant differences in the cleavage rate (85 +/- 3% vs. 91+/- 2%) or in the developmental rate to the blastocyst stage (35 +/- 6% vs. 35 +/- 5%) using MGE cells vs. fibroblast cells as donor nuclei (P>0.05). After transfer of blastocysts derived from nuclear transfer embryos produced using MGE cells and fibroblast cells, 13% (4/31) and 16% (6/37) of recipient heifers were pregnant on Day 42 as assessed by ultrasonography, respectively. Two of the 4 and 4 of the 6 recipients of embryos with MGE cell- and fibroblast cell-derived nuclei, respectively, aborted within 150 days of pregnancy. Four live female calves were obtained from MGE cells or fibroblast cells. However, one died from internal hemorrhage of the arteria umbilicalis. The other three calves were normal and healthy. There were no differences in the pregnancy rate or calving rate when using MGE cells vs. fibroblast cells. Microsatellite DNA analyses confirmed that the cloned calves were genetically identical to the donor cows and different from the recipient heifers. We conclude that colostrum-derived MGE cells have the developmental potential to term by nuclear transfer, and the efficiency of development of those cloned embryos was the same as that of embryos obtained using fibroblast cells as donor nuclei, although there was a significant difference in the fusion rate. This method using MGE cells derived from colostrum, which is obtained easily and safely from live adult cows, is more advantageous for cloning with somatic cells.     

曲古抑菌素A对克隆猪端粒长度的影响

端粒是染色体末端结构, 在细胞分裂时随着DNA复制而缩短, 体细胞核移植能不同程度地延长端粒长度, 但有些克隆动物端粒的长度在体细胞核移植过程中不能有效恢复, 因而这些克隆动物就会表现出早衰现象。文章发现克隆东北民猪以及eGFP、Mx和PGC1α转基因克隆猪的端粒长度与核供体成体成纤维细胞相比显著缩短(P<0.05), 表明体细胞核移植的重编程过程没能延长细胞的“寿命”。曲古抑菌素A(Trichostatin A, TSA)是一种去乙酰化酶抑制剂, 有研究表明其能提高某些物种的体细胞核重编程效率。为了使端粒长度有效恢复, 文章利用40 nmol/L TSA处理1细胞期猪克隆胚胎24 h, 结果发现, 与对照组相比, TSA处理能显著地提高克隆胚胎体外发育的囊胚率(16.35% vs. 2 7.09%, 21.60% vs. 34.90%, P<0.05), 而且囊胚期端粒长度也得到显著延长(P<0.05)。克隆胚胎移植受体后得到了TSA处理组与非处理组的克隆猪, 虽然TSA处理并没有提高克隆效率(1.3% vs. 1.7%, TSA vs. control), 但端粒长度与对照组和供体细胞相比均显著延长(P<0.05)。猪体细胞核移植不能有效恢复端粒长度, 但是TSA处理能有效延长克隆猪端粒长度。     

Cloning cattle

Over the past six years, hundreds of apparently normal calves have been cloned worldwide from bovine somatic donor cells. However, these surviving animals represent less than 5% of all cloned embryos transferred into recipient cows. Most of the remaining 95% die at various stages of development from a predictable pattern of placental and fetal abnormalities, collectively referred to as the "cloning-syndrome." The low efficiency seriously limits commercial applicability and ethical acceptance of somatic cloning and enforces the development of improved cloning methods. In this paper, we describe our current standard operating procedure (SOP) for cattle cloning using zona-free nuclear transfer. Following this SOP, the output of viable and healthy calves at weaning is about 9% of embryos transferred. Better standardization of cloning protocols across and within research groups is needed to separate technical from biological factors underlying low cloning efficiency.     

Production and health assessment of second-generation cloned Holstein cows derived by somatic cell nuclear transfer

In this study we evaluated cloning efficiency of second-generation (G2) cloned Holstein cows derived from ear fibroblasts of a first-generation (G1) cloned cow, and assessed their health status in terms of physical, growth and reproductive parameters. Compared with G1 cloning, G2 cloning showed a slight decrease on blastocyst rate of reconstructed embryos (30.2±5.8% vs. 28.5±7.2%, p>0.05), while the quality of its blastocysts reduced significantly (Grade 1 and Grade 2, 21.1±4.1% vs. 17.1±5.7%, p<0.05). After embryo transfer (ET), both pregnancy rate to term and calving rate of G2 cloning were approximately half of G1 cloning (5.8% vs. 10.7%; 3.9% vs. 8.6%, p>0.05). Six G2 cloned cows were delivered, and three of them survived. G2 cloned calves displayed symptoms of being overweight at birth and tachycardia in the first week after birth. During the first 12 months, the growth of G2 cloned calves was similar to control calves derived from artificial insemination (AI). Furthermore, the interindividual variation of growth within the G2 clonal family was smaller except at birth and at two months of age. Interestingly, although G2 cloned cows reached puberty 45 days later in comparison with control cows derived from AI, they were all pregnant by AI, and gave birth to healthy calves. This suggests that their reproductive performance was not affected by late puberty. In summary, our results showed that although cloning efficiency of G2 was lower than that of G1, the surviving G2 clones appeared physically healthy and were fertile.     

Ontogeny of cloned cattle to lactation

Central to the success of large animal cloning is the production of healthy animals that can provide products for human health, food, and other animal agriculture applications. We report development of cloned cattle derived from 34 genetically unique, nonembryonic cell lines using nuclear transfer performed between 1 January 1998 and 29 February 2000. Nearly 25% (535/2170) of the recipients receiving reconstructed embryos initiated pregnancy. Overall, 19.8% (106/535) of the initiated pregnancies resulted in live births, while 77% (82/106) of these cattle clones remain healthy and productive today. Although a wide variation in birth weight of clone calves was observed, their growth rates, reproductive performance, and lactation characteristics are similar to that found in noncloned dairy cattle. Our data represent the most comprehensive information on cattle derived from nuclear transfer procedures and indicate that this emerging reproductive technology offers unique opportunities to meet critical needs in both human health care and agriculture.     

Growth and fertility of bulls cloned from the somatic cells of an aged and infertile bull

In the present study, somatic cell cloning technology was used to produce eight newborn calves from an aged, infertile bull. Average birth weight of these calves was significantly higher than that of calves produced using AI. Four of the cloned calves died during the peripartum period; the remaining four (Clones A-D) survived and were used in this study. Two of the surviving calves (Clones C and D) were castrated; growth rates of the intact and castrated clones were similar to those of intact and castrated bulls, respectively, that had been derived by AI. Both uncastrated bulls (Clones A and B) began to produce normal semen at approximately 12 months of age. Semen produced by these clones, and their nuclear donor, was subsequently used for IVF; the proportion of IVM-IVF oocytes developing to the blastocyst stage was 23.4% (50/214), 28.4% (52/183) and 30.9% (63/204), respectively. Conception rates for AI were 54.5% (12/22) and 62.7% (64/102) for semen derived from Clone A and from the nuclear donor, respectively. The length of pregnancy and birth weight of the calves derived from semen collected from clones were similar to those of calves obtained by conventional AI using semen from their nuclear donor. Therefore, sires cloned from the somatic cells of an aged and infertile bull had normal fertility.     

Cloned calves produced by nuclear transfer from cultured cumulus cells

Short-term cultured cumulus cell lines (1-5BCC) derived from 5 individual cows were used in nuclear transfer (NT) and 1188 enucleated bovine oocytes matured in vitro were used as nuclear recipients. A total of 931 (78.4%) cloned embryos were reconstructed, of which 763 (82%) cleaved, 627 (67.3%) developed to 8-cell stage, and 275 (29.5%) reached blastocyst stage. The average cell number of blastocysts was 124±24.5 (n=20). In this study, the effects of donor cell sources, serum starvation of donor cells, time interval from fusion to activation (IFA) were also tested on cloning efficiency. These results showed that blastocyst rates of embryos reconstructed from 5 different individuals cells were significantly different among them (14.1%, 45.2%, 27.3%, 34.3%, vs 1.5%, P<0.05); that serum starvation of donor cells had no effect on blastocyst development rate of NT embryos (47.1% vs 44.4%, P>0.05); and that blastocyst rate (20.3%) of the group with fusion/activation interval of 2-3 h, was significantly lower     

Comparison of liver mitochondrial proteins derived from newborn cloned calves and from cloned adult cattle by two-dimensional differential gel electrophoresis

Aberrant reprogramming of donor somatic cell nuclei may result in many severe problems in animal cloning. The inability to establish functional interactions between donor nucleus and recipient mitochondria is also likely responsible for such a developmental deficiency. However, detailed knowledge of protein expression during somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) in cattle is lacking. In the present study, variations in mitochondrial protein levels between SCNT‐derived and control cattle, and from calves derived by artificial insemination were investigated. Mitochondrial fractions were prepared from frozen liver samples and subjected to two‐dimensional (2‐D) fluorescence differential gel electrophoresis (DIGE) using CyDye? dyes. Protein expression changes were confirmed with a volume ratio greater than 2.0 (P < 0.05). 2D‐DIGE analysis revealed differential expression of three proteins for SCNT cattle (n = 4) and seven proteins for SCNT calves (n = 6) compared to controls (P < 0.05). Different protein patterning was observed among SCNT animals even if animals were generated from the same donor cell source. No differences were detected in two of the SCNT cattle. Moreover, there was no novel protein identified in any of the SCNT cattle or calves. In conclusion, variation in mitochondrial protein expression concentrations was observed in non‐viable, neonatal SCNT calves and among SCNT individuals. This result implicates mitochondrial‐related gene expression in early developmental loss of SCNT embryos. Comparative proteomic analysis represents an important tool for further studies on SCNT animals. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 78:263–273, 2011. © 2011 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Production of cloned calves by combination treatment of both donor cells and early cloned embryos with 5-aza-2/-deoxycytidine and trichostatin A

We previously reported that treatment of both donor cells and early cloned embryos with a combination of 0.01 μM 5-aza-2^/-Deoxycytidine (5-aza-dC) and 0.05 μM trichostatin A (TSA) significantly improved development of cloned bovine embryos in vitro. In the present study, we investigated the effect of this combination treatment on the in vivo development potency and postnatal survivability of cloned calves. Blastocysts (77 and 82 blastocysts derived from untreated (control) and treated groups, respectively) were individually transferred to recipient cows. Relative to the control group, the combination treatment of both donor cells and early embryos with 5-aza-dC and TSA dramatically increased the cleavage rate (49.2 vs 63.6%, P < 0.05) at 24 h of culture, and blastocyst development rate on Days 6 and 7 of culture (18.8 vs 33.9% and 27.1 vs 38.5% respectively, P < 0.05). Although pregnancy rate did not differ 40 d after transfer, it was lower in the treated than control group 90 d after transfer (7.8 vs 29.3%, P < 0.05). In the control group, there were three calves born to 77 recipients (only two survived beyond 60 d), whereas in the treated group, 17 calves were born to 82 recipients, and 11 survived beyond 60 d. In conclusion, a combination treatment of donor cells and early cloned embryos with 5-aza-dC and TSA significantly enhanced development of somatic cell cloned bovine embryos in vivo; cloning efficiency (number of surviving calves at 60 d of birth/number of recipient cows) was increased from 2.6 to 13.4%.     

Birth of large calves that developed from in vitro-derived bovine embryos

High birth weights were observed in calves that developed from bovine embryos produced by in vitro maturation (IVM) and in vitro fertilization (IVF) procedures. After IVM and IVF, embryos were either co-cultured in vitro with oviductal epithelial cells or transferred into the sheep oviduct for development to the blastocyst stage. Blastocysts were transferred to the reproductive tracts of recipient heifers and cows for development to term. Birth weights and gestation periods were compared between calves that developed from in vitro-derived embryos and calves born after artificial insemination (AI) of cows in the herd from which recipient females were selected. Gestation periods were not different among the groups (P > 0.05), but calves that developed from IVM/IVF-derived embryos co-cultured in vitro were larger at birth than calves born from IVM/IVF-derived embryos that developed into blastocysts in the sheep oviduct and calves born from AI (P < 0.001). Dystocia and calf mortality were associated with large calf size at birth. These data were collected from an experiment designed for other purposes, and confounding variables and small sample size could have influenced the observed differences in birth weights. Nevertheless, the extreme birth weights of some calves suggest that abnormal prenatal growth occurs in some IVM/IVF-derived bovine embryos and that conditions for co-culture to the blastocyst stage may exacerbate the problem.     

DNA methylation status in somatic and placenta cells of cloned cats

We recently produced 11 cloned kittens by somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) using fibroblasts from a feline fetus (donor A, three kittens), an adult domestic cat (donor B, one kitten), and a deaf adult Turkish Angora cat (donor C, seven kittens). Two kittens were stillborn and three died a month after birth. The donor C-derived kittens did not share their donor's eye color or deafness. To test whether this and the low cloning success rate are due to epigenetic modifications, we compared the methylation of somatic and placental cells from the cloned cats and domestic normal cats by bisulfite mutagenesis sequencing analysis. The DNA methylation of somatic cells from the cloned kittens ranged from 78.0% to 88.9%, and did not differ significantly depending on whether they were stillborn, died early after birth, or were healthy. Donors B and C showed similar levels of methylation (77.0% and 79.1%, respectively), as did somatic cells from normal domestic and Turkish Angora cats (range, 75.7-88.0%). However, donor A showed less methylation (70.6%) than the somatic cells from the kittens derived from it (range, 82.2-88.9%). Moreover, placental cells from three donor C-derived kittens showed significantly higher DNA methylation (range, 76.7-80.5%) than placental cells from normal domestic cats (range, 64.2-74.9%). Thus, methylation of satellite regions in somatic cells may not be responsible for the stillbirth, early death, or different eye and hearing attributes of cloned cats. However, hypermethylation in the placenta of cloned cats may be responsible for low success rates in cloning cats.     

Cloned calves produced by nuclear transfer from cultured cumulus cells

Short-term cultured cumulus cell lines (1-5BCC) derived from 5 individual cows were used in nuclear transfer (NT) and 1188 enucleated bovine oocytes matured in vitro were used as nuclear recipients. A total of 931 (78.4%) cloned embryos were reconstructed, of which 763 (82%) cleaved, 627 (67.3%) developed to 8-cell stage, and 275 (29.5%) reached blastocyst stage. The average cell number of blastocysts was 124±24.5 (n=20). In this study, the effects of donor cell sources, serum starvation of donor cells, time interval from fusion to activation (IFA) were also tested on cloning efficiency. These results showed that blastocyst rates of embryos reconstructed from 5 different individuals cells were significantly different among them (14.1%, 45.2%, 27.3%, 34.3%, vs 1.5%, P<0.05); that serum starvation of donor cells had no effect on blastocyst development rate of NT embryos (47.1% vs 44.4%, P>0.05); and that blastocyst rate (20.3%) of the group with fusion/activation interval of 2–3 h, was significantly lower than that of the 3–6 h groups (31.0%), while not significantly different among 3–4 h (P < 0.05), 4–5 h, and 5–6 h groups (P≥0.05). Sixty-three thawed NT blastocysts were transferred to 31 recipient cows, of which 4 pregnancies were established and two cloned calves were given birth. These results indicate that serum starvation of cumulus cells is not a key factor for successful bovine cloning, while IFA treatment and sources of donor cells have effects on cloning efficiency.     

Endocrine characteristics of cloned calves

To examine the possible link between endocrine status and perinatal problems related to cattle cloning, plasma concentrations of cortisol, adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) and components of the insulin-like growth factor (IGF) system were compared between 13 somatic cell cloned and seven control Japanese Black calves (five produced by artificial insemination [AI] and two produced from in vitro fertilized embryos [IVP]) immediately after birth. Five cloned calves required delivery by cesarean section (C-section), while all of control calves were delivered by spontaneous vaginal delivery. The C-section delivered clones were heavier at birth, followed by vaginally delivered clones and IVP controls, and AI controls were the lightest. The neonatal mortality (death within the 1st week) of C-section delivered clones was also high (4/5) compared to that of vaginally delivered clones (1/8) or controls (0/7). Plasma concentrations of cortisol and IGF-I were lower in the clones than control calves although the plasma ACTH level was not different between the groups. A striking difference was observed in plasma IGF binding protein (IGFBP) profile in which cloned calves had a greater relative abundance of IGFBP-2 compared with controls. Observed differences suggest that insufficient prepartum rise in plasma cortisol of cloned calves failed to initiate the switch to an adult mode of the IGF system during late gestation and therefore parturition was not spontaneous. Inappropriate developmental changes in endocrine system may be partly responsible for the fetal overgrowth and perinatal complications associated with the cloning technology.     

Effects of culture systems on development of in vitro fertilized bovine ova into blastocysts

We examined the effects of co-culture with oviductal epithelial cells, cumulus cells, trophoblastic vesicles or amniotic sac cells on the development of bovine eight-cell embryos derived from in vitro maturation and fertilization into blastocysts. Frozen-thawed spermatozoa were treated with caffeine plus Ca-ionophore A23187 for capacitation and were then co-incubated for 4 h with oocytes matured in vitro. Ova resulting from this in vitro fertilization were cultured in HEPES-buffered TCM-199 + 10% fetal calf serum(FCS) for 68 h and then removed from the cumulus cell mass. The eight-cell embryos were cultured using four co-culture systems either without cells(controls) or within rabbit oviducts. The co-culture of oviductal epithelial cells, trophoblastic vesicles or amniotic sac cells significantly (P<0.05) increased development into blastocysts (39.0 to 50.7%) when compared with co-culture with cumulus cells, control or rabbit oviducts(1.9 to 29.3%). Six of 16 recipients became pregnant with frozen embryos derived from co-culture with oviductal epithelial cells(1/2), trophoblastic vesicles(2/7) or amniotic sac cells(3/7). Eight calves, including two sets of twins, were obtained.     

Proliferation of donor mitochondrial DNA in nuclear transfer calves (Bos taurus) derived from cumulus cells

In embryos derived by nuclear-transfer (NT), fusion of donor cell and recipient oocyte caused mitochondrial heteroplasmy. Previous studies from other laboratories have reported either elimination or maintenance of donor-derived mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) from somatic cells in cloned animals. Here we examined the distribution of donor mtDNA in NT embryos and calves derived from somatic cells. Donor mitochondria were clearly observed by fluorescence labeling in the cytoplasm of NT embryos immediately after fusion; however, fluorescence diminished to undetectable levels at 24 hr after nuclear transfer. By PCR-mediated single-strand conformation polymorphism (PCR-SSCP) analysis, donor mtDNAs were not detected in the NT embryos immediately after fusion (less than 3-4%). In contrast, three of nine NT calves exhibited heteroplasmy with donor cell mtDNA populations ranging from 6 to 40%. These results provide the first evidence of a significant replicative advantage of donor mtDNAs to recipient mtDNAs during the course of embryogenesis in NT calves from somatic cells.     

Telomere length status of somatic cell sheep clones and their offspring

This study was carried out to determine the telomere length status of sheep clones and their offspring, and to examine telomere dynamics and chromosomal abnormalities in culture propagated donor cells. Skin samples were collected from somatic cell nuclear transfer-derived sheep clones, and three of their progeny generated by natural mating. Samples were collected from control animals (n = 35), spanning in age from 1 month to 36 months of age. Genomic DNA was extracted from cell/tissue samples and their telomere lengths were assessed by terminal restriction fragment (TRF) analysis. Results revealed: that (a) sheep clones derived from cultured somatic cells have shortened telomere lengths compared to age-matched controls; (b) the offspring derived from natural mating between clones had normal telomere lengths compared to their age-matched counterparts; and donor cell cultures beyond 20 population doublings had significantly (P < 0.05) shortened telomeres and exhibited a higher numerical and structural chromosomal abnormalities.