The Pseudomonas syringae Type III Effector HopF2 Suppresses Arabidopsis Stomatal Immunity

Pseudomonas syringae subverts plant immune signalling through injection of type III secreted effectors (T3SE) into host cells. The T3SE HopF2 can disable Arabidopsis immunity through Its ADP-ribosyltransferase activity. Proteomic analysis of HopF2 interacting proteins identified a protein complex containing ATPases required for regulating stomatal aperture, suggesting HopF2 may manipulate stomatal immunity. Here we report HopF2 can inhibit stomatal immunity independent of its ADP-ribosyltransferase activity. Transgenic expression of HopF2 in Arabidopsis inhibits stomatal closing in response to P. syringae and increases the virulence of surface inoculated P. syringae. Further, transgenic expression of HopF2 inhibits flg22 induced reactive oxygen species production. Intriguingly, ADP-ribosyltransferase activity is dispensable for inhibiting stomatal immunity and flg22 induced reactive oxygen species. Together, this implies HopF2 may be a bifunctional T3SE with ADP-ribosyltransferase activity required for inhibiting apoplastic immunity and an independent function required to inhibit stomatal immunity.     

Relatedness of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato, Pseudomonas syringae pv. maculicola and Pseudomonas syringae pv. antirrhini

The relationships among strains of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato, Ps. syr. antirrhini, Ps. syr. maculicola, Ps. syr. apii and a strain isolated from squash were examined by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) patterns, nutritional characteristics, host of origin and host ranges. All strains tested except for Ps. syr. maculicola 4326 isolated from radish ( Raphanus sativus L.) constitute a closely related group. No polymorphism was seen among strains probed with the 5.7 and 2.3 kb Eco RI fragments which lie adjacent to the hrp cluster of Ps. syr. tomato and the 8.6 kb Eco RI insert of pBG2, a plasmid carrying the β-glucosidase gene(s). All strains tested had overlapping host ranges. In contrast to this, comparison of strains by RFLP patterns of sequences homologous to the 4.5 kb Hind III fragment of pRut2 and nutritional properties distinguished four groups. Group 1, consisting of strains of pathovars maculicola, tomato and apii , had similar RFLP patterns and used homoserine but not sorbitol as carbon sources. Group 2, consisting of strains of pathovars maculicola and tomato , differed from Group 1 in RFLP patterns and did not use either homoserine or sorbitol. Group 3 was similar to Group 2 in RFLP patterns but utilized homoserine and sorbitol. This group included strains of the pathovars tomato and antirrhini , and a strain isolated from squash. Group 4, a single strain of Ps. syr. maculicola isolated from radish, had unique RFLP patterns and resembled Group 3 nutritionally. The evolutionary relationships of these strains are discussed.     

Immunomodulation by the Pseudomonas syringae HopZ Type III Effector Family in Arabidopsis

Pseudomonas syringae employs a type III secretion system to inject 20–30 different type III effector (T3SE) proteins into plant host cells. A major role of T3SEs is to suppress plant immune responses and promote bacterial infection. The YopJ/HopZ acetyltransferases are a superfamily of T3SEs found in both plant and animal pathogenic bacteria. In P. syringae, this superfamily includes the evolutionarily diverse HopZ1, HopZ2 and HopZ3 alleles. To investigate the roles of the HopZ family in immunomodulation, we generated dexamethasone-inducible T3SE transgenic lines of Arabidopsis for HopZ family members and characterized them for immune suppression phenotypes. We show that all of the HopZ family members can actively suppress various facets of Arabidopsis immunity in a catalytic residue-dependent manner. HopZ family members can differentially suppress the activation of mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase cascades or the production of reactive oxygen species, whereas all members can promote the growth of non-virulent P. syringae. Localization studies show that four of the HopZ family members containing predicted myristoylation sites are localized to the vicinity of the plasma membrane while HopZ3 which lacks the myristoylation site is at least partially nuclear localized, suggesting diversification of immunosuppressive mechanisms. Overall, we demonstrate that despite significant evolutionary diversification, all HopZ family members can suppress immunity in Arabidopsis.     

Systemic Induction of Salicylic Acid Accumulation in Cucumber after Inoculation with Pseudomonas syringae pv syringae

Inoculation of one true leaf of cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) plants with Pseudomonas syringae pathovar syringae results in the systemic appearance of salicylic acid in the phloem exudates from petioles above, below, and at the site of inoculation. Analysis of phloem exudates from the petioles of leaves 1 and 2 demonstrated that the earliest increases in salicylic acid occurred 8 hours after inoculation of leaf 1 in leaf 1 and 12 hours after inoculation of leaf 1 in leaf 2. Detaching leaf 1 at intervals after inoculation demonstrated that leaf 1 must remain attached for only 4 hours after inoculation to result in the systemic accumulation of salicylic acid. Because the levels of salicylic acid in phloem exudates from leaf 1 did not increase to detectable levels until at least 8 hours after inoculation with P. s. pathovar syringae, the induction of increased levels of salicylic acid throughout the plant are presumably the result of another chemical signal generated from leaf 1 within 4 hours after inoculation. Injection of salicylic acid into tissues at concentrations found in the exudates induced resistance to disease and increased peroxidase activity. Our results support a role for salicylic acid as an endogenous inducer of resistance, but our data also suggest that salicylic acid is not the primary systemic signal of induced resistance in cucumber.     

Allele-Specific Virulence Attenuation of the Pseudomonas syringae HopZ1a Type III Effector via the Arabidopsis ZAR1 Resistance Protein

Plant resistance (R) proteins provide a robust surveillance system to defend against potential pathogens. Despite their importance in plant innate immunity, relatively few of the ∼170 R proteins in Arabidopsis have well-characterized resistance specificity. In order to identify the R protein responsible for recognition of the Pseudomonas syringae type III secreted effector (T3SE) HopZ1a, we assembled an Arabidopsis R gene T–DNA Insertion Collection (ARTIC) from publicly available Arabidopsis thaliana insertion lines and screened it for plants lacking HopZ1a-induced immunity. This reverse genetic screen revealed that the Arabidopsis R protein HOPZ-ACTIVATED RESISTANCE 1 (ZAR1; At3g50950) is required for recognition of HopZ1a in Arabidopsis. ZAR1 belongs to the coiled-coil (CC) class of nucleotide binding site and leucine-rich repeat (NBS–LRR) containing R proteins; however, the ZAR1 CC domain phylogenetically clusters in a clade distinct from other related Arabidopsis R proteins. ZAR1–mediated immunity is independent of several genes required by other R protein signaling pathways, including NDR1 and RAR1, suggesting that ZAR1 possesses distinct signaling requirements. The closely-related T3SE protein, HopZ1b, is still recognized by zar1 Arabidopsis plants indicating that Arabidopsis has evolved at least two independent R proteins to recognize the HopZ T3SE family. Also, in Arabidopsis zar1 plants HopZ1a promotes P. syringae growth indicative of an ancestral virulence function for this T3SE prior to the evolution of recognition by the host resistance protein ZAR1. Our results demonstrate that the Arabidopsis resistance protein ZAR1 confers allele-specific recognition and virulence attenuation of the Pseudomonas syringae T3SE protein HopZ1a.     

Crystal structure of uroporphyrinogen III synthase from Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000

Uroporphyrinogen III synthase (U3S) is one of the key enzymes in the biosynthesis of tetrapyrrole compounds. It catalyzes the cyclization of the linear hydroxymethylbilane (HMB) to uroporphyrinogen III (uro’gen III). We have determined the crystal structure of U3S from Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 (psU3S) at 2.5 Å resolution by the single wavelength anomalous dispersion (SAD) method. Each psU3S molecule consists of two domains interlinked by a two-stranded antiparallel β-sheet. The conformation of psU3S is different from its homologous proteins because of the flexibility of the linker between the two domains, which might be related to this enzyme’s catalytic properties. Based on mutation and activity analysis, a key residue, Arg219, was found to be important for the catalytic activity of psU3S. Mutation of Arg219 to Ala caused a decrease in enzymatic activity to about 25% that of the wild type enzyme. Our results provide the structural basis and biochemical evidence to further elucidate the catalytic mechanism of U3S.     

Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato hijacks the Arabidopsis abscisic acid signalling pathway to cause disease

We have found that a major target for effectors secreted by Pseudomonas syringae is the abscisic acid (ABA) signalling pathway. Microarray data identified a prominent group of effector-induced genes that were associated with ABA biosynthesis and also responses to this plant hormone. Genes upregulated by effector delivery share a 42% overlap with ABA-responsive genes and are also components of networks induced by osmotic stress and drought. Strongly induced were NCED3, encoding a key enzyme of ABA biosynthesis, and the abscisic acid insensitive 1 (ABI1) clade of genes encoding protein phosphatases type 2C (PP2Cs) involved in the regulation of ABA signalling. Modification of PP2C expression resulting in ABA insensitivity or hypersensitivity led to restriction or enhanced multiplication of bacteria, respectively. Levels of ABA increased rapidly during bacterial colonisation. Exogenous ABA application enhanced susceptibility, whereas colonisation was reduced in an ABA biosynthetic mutant. Expression of the bacterial effector AvrPtoB in planta modified host ABA signalling. Our data suggest that a major virulence strategy is effector-mediated manipulation of plant hormone homeostasis, which leads to the suppression of defence responses.     

Fatty Acid Composition of Pseudomonas syringae pv. savastanoi

Over 85% of total cellular fatty acids of 30 strains of P. syringae pv. savastanoi, grown for one day at 28 °C on King's medium B (KB) agar, were 12:0 (5.0%), 16:0 (27.5%), 16:1 (36.7%) and 18:1 (16.8%). Three hydroxy-substituted fatty acids comprised 7.2% of the total and 22 other minor components, each occurring at concentrations of less than 1%, comprised an additional 4%. Three percent were unidentified components. Cells grown for 3 and 6 days on KB agar contained lower concentrations of the unsaturated 16:1 (30.4 and 21.1%, respectively), and higher concentrations of branched-chain and cyclopropane fatty acids than one-day old cells. No consistent differences in fatty acid composition could be detected between virulent and avirulent strains, nor between pv. savastanoi and other pathovars of P. syringae. However, when cells were grown on a chemically-defined medium for 6 days, concentrations of 16:0 and a tentatively-identified 17-carbon hydroxy fatty acid were higher, and those of 12:0 and 16:1 were lower in strains from Fraxinus than from Olea. P. fluorescens (7 strains) and P. viridiflava (6 strains) could be differentiated from each other but not from P. syringae.     

Response of tomato genotypes to bacterial speck (Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato)

Two genotypes of tomato A 100 and Ontario 7710 which were inoculated separately with four strains of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato differed significantly in disease severity (susceptibility) to bacterial speck. At both concentrations of inoculum of each strain used (10⁷ and 10⁸ cfu/ml) A 100 appeared to be highly susceptible whereas Ontario 7710 showed very low or no susceptibility. The significant differences in virulence between strains and in response of tomato plants in three replicate experiments were found. Generally, concentration of inoculum 10⁷ cfu/ml was too low to induce consistent level of disease severity. The obtained results indicate the importance of consistent and favorable conditions for disease development in screening of tomato resistance to bacterial speck.     

The Arabidopsis Lectin Receptor Kinase LecRK-V.5 Represses Stomatal Immunity Induced by Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000

Stomata play an important role in plant innate immunity by limiting pathogen entry into leaves but molecular mechanisms regulating stomatal closure upon pathogen perception are not well understood. Here we show that the Arabidopsis thaliana L-type lectin receptor kinase-V.5 (LecRK-V.5) negatively regulates stomatal immunity. Loss of LecRK-V.5 function increased resistance to surface inoculation with virulent bacteria Pseudomonas syringae pv tomato DC3000. Levels of resistance were not affected after infiltration-inoculation, suggesting that LecRK-V.5 functions at an early defense stage. By contrast, lines overexpressing LecRK-V.5 were more susceptible to Pst DC3000. Enhanced resistance in lecrk-V.5 mutants was correlated with constitutive stomatal closure, while increased susceptibility phenotypes in overexpression lines were associated with early stomatal reopening. Lines overexpressing LecRK-V.5 also demonstrated a defective stomatal closure after pathogen-associated molecular pattern (PAMP) treatments. LecRK-V.5 is rapidly expressed in stomatal guard cells after bacterial inoculation or treatment with the bacterial PAMP flagellin. In addition, lecrk-V.5 mutants guard cells exhibited constitutive accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and inhibition of ROS production opened stomata of lecrk-V.5. LecRK-V.5 is also shown to interfere with abscisic acid-mediated stomatal closure signaling upstream of ROS production. These results provide genetic evidences that LecRK-V.5 negatively regulates stomatal immunity upstream of ROS biosynthesis. Our data reveal that plants have evolved mechanisms to reverse bacteria-mediated stomatal closure to prevent long-term effect on CO₂ uptake and photosynthesis.     

Analysis of the Role of the Type III Effector Inventory of Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola 1448a in Interaction with the Plant

In Pseudomonas syringae, the type III secretion system (T3SS) is essential for disease in compatible hosts and for eliciting the hypersensitive response in incompatible hosts. P. syringae pathovars secrete a variable number of type III effectors that form their secretomes. The secretome of Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola 1448a (Pph1448a) currently includes 22 experimentally validated effectors, one HrpL-regulated candidate for which translocation results have been inconsistent, two translocated candidates for which in planta expression has not been established, one bioinformatically identified candidate, and six candidates that have been experimentally discarded. We analyzed the translocation and/or expression of these and other candidates to complete the Pph1448a effector inventory, bringing this inventory to 27 bona fide effectors, including a new one that does not belong to any of the previously described effector families. We developed a simple process for rapidly making single and double knockout mutants and apply it to the generation of an effector mutant collection that includes single knockouts for the majority of the Pph1448a effector inventory. We also generated two double mutant strains containing effectors with potentially redundant functions and analyzed the virulence of the single and double mutant strains as well as strains expressing each of the effectors from a plasmid. We demonstrate that AvrB4-1 and AvrB4-2, as well as HopW1-1 and HopW1-2, are fully redundant and contribute to virulence in bean plants, thus validating this approach for dissecting the contribution of the Pph1448a type III effector inventory to virulence. We also analyzed the effect that the expression of these four effectors from Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 (PtoDC3000) has during its interaction with Arabidopsis thaliana, establishing that AvrB4-1, but not the others, determines a restriction of bacterial growth that takes place mostly independently of the salicylic acid (SA)-signaling pathway.Type III secretion systems (T3SS) are complex and specialized machineries that inject effector proteins directly into the host cell cytosol (2). In Pseudomonas syringae, T3SS-mediated secretion is essential for disease in compatible hosts and for eliciting the hypersensitive response (HR) in incompatible hosts (1). P. syringae pathovars secrete a variable number of type III effectors that form their so-called secretomes and are expressed within the plant under the control of the alternative sigma factor HrpL (47). Understanding how the T3SS determines pathogenicity requires the functional characterization of the complete type III effector inventory. However, this characterization has been partially hindered by the fact that mutation of individual effectors, usually the most straightforward approach, rarely causes virulence attenuation (14). Thus, reports showing the contribution of the type III effector to virulence in P. syringae pathovars have resorted to ectopic expression in homolog-lacking related strains (40), plasmid-cured derivatives (21), double mutants (6, 28), or polymutants (3, 26). In relation to this, we have previously established the use of the competitive index (CI) in mixed infections (13, 42) as a more sensitive virulence assay for P. syringae pathovars than traditional assays (31). Using CIs, we demonstrated for the first time the individual contribution of AvrPto, an otherwise thoroughly characterized type III effector from Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato (9, 17, 18, 27, 36, 39, 40, 46), to pathogen growth within its natural host (31). Therefore, analysis of effector mutants by use of the CI may provide the means to establish the quantitative contribution of the members of P. syringae T3SS secretomes to virulence. In addition, genetic analysis of the effects of combinations of effector mutations on virulence has already proven a useful approach to establishing the contribution of the members of the P. syringae pv. tomato DC3000 secretome to virulence by revealing a functional overlap (6, 26, 28). Thus, generation of knockouts in all individual effector genes of a given secretome, achieved in such a manner as to allow for easy combination of these strains into double or multiple mutant strains, is a desirable task, albeit a cumbersome one, considering the size of most secretomes.The secretome of the fully sequenced wild-type (wt) representative of the Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola 1448a strain (Pph1448a) has previously been analyzed, using a differential fluorescence induction screen (7) and bioinformatics (44), to identify effector genes. Our laboratory contributed to establishing this secretome through the development and application of a very sensitive assay for T3SS-mediated translocation based on CI assays (30). This assay represents an improvement over the sensitivity of the commonly used AvrRpt2 reporter assay. When fused to a T3SS-secreted protein, AvrRpt2^81-255 is translocated inside the host cell, eliciting a hypersensitive response (HR), dependent on the resistance protein RPS2 (32). By using CIs to measure the bacterial growth reduction associated with the AvrRpt2-RPS-mediated defense response, we detected translocation for two out of four Pph1448a effector candidates previously discarded by other assays, HopAJ1 and HopAK1 (30), and demonstrated translocation for two out of five previously untested candidates, HopAH2 and A0129. However, although in planta expression has been shown to take place in an HrpL-dependent manner for HopAJ1 and HopAK1 (7), it has not been established for HopAH2 and A0129. Effector nomenclature guidelines recommend that the abbreviation for the pathovars as well as the name of the strain should be included within the effector name (29). For simplicity, we include this indication only when effectors from other pathovars are mentioned. In summary, to date, 22 effectors in Pph1448a have been experimentally validated (7, 30, 44), one HrpL-regulated candidate has given inconsistent translocation results (AvrE1) (7), two translocated candidates have not been analyzed for expression in planta (HopAH2 and A0129) (30), one bioinformatically identified candidate has not been experimentally tested (AvrB4-2) (23), and six additional candidates have been proposed but experimentally ruled out (PSPPH3757, HopAN1, HopAJ2, HopW1-2, HopV1, and HopJ1) (7, 30).In this work, we analyzed the translocation and/or expression of these and other candidate effectors to close the type III effector inventory of Pph1448a. Our results indicate that the Pph1448a complete type III secretome is formed by 27 validated effectors, including a new one, HopAY1, which does not belong to any of the previously described effector families. The work includes the development of a simplified process for quick generation of single and double knockout mutants and its application to constructing a collection of single mutants for almost all members of the Pph1448a type III secretome. Additionally, we generated two double mutant strains containing effectors with potentially redundant functions and analyzed the virulence of the four single and two double mutant strains as well as the double mutants expressing each of the effectors from a plasmid. We demonstrate that AvrB4-1 and AvrB4-2, as well as HopW1-1 and HopW1-2, are fully redundant and contribute to the virulence of Pph1448a. The tools and approach used in this work set the groundwork for dissecting the contribution of the entire Pph1448a type III secretome to virulence.     

Molecular characterization of avirulence gene D from Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato

Avirulence gene D, cloned from Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato, caused P. s. pv. glycinea to elicit a hypersensitive defense response on certain cultivars of soybean. Nucleotide sequence data for a 5.6-kb HindIII fragment containing avrD disclosed five long open-reading frames (ORFs) occurring in tandem. The phenotype conferred by avrD was expressed in P. s. pv. glycinea solely by the first of these ORFs (933 bases) that encoded a protein of 34,115 daltons. Neither a signal peptide sequence nor significant regions of hydrophobicity were present that would indicate secretion of the protein or its membrane association. Hybridization analyses revealed that some but not all P. syringae pathovars contained DNA homologous to avrD. This included weak hybridization to all tested races of P. s. pv. glycinea, although none of them express the phenotype conferred by avrD. The avrD gene occurred on an indigenous 75-kb plasmid in several P. s. pv. tomato isolates.     

The HopPtoF locus of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 encodes a type III chaperone and a cognate effector

Type III secretion systems are highly conserved among gram-negative plant and animal pathogenic bacteria. Through the type III secretion system, bacteria inject a number of virulence proteins into the host cells. Analysis of the whole genome sequence of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 strain identified a locus, named HopPtoF, that is homologous to the avirulence gene locus avrPphF in P. syringae pv. phaseolicola. The HopPtoF locus harbors two genes, ShcF(Pto) and HopF(Pto), that are preceded by a single hrp box promoter. We present evidence here to show that ShcF(Pto) and HopF(Pto) encode a type III chaperone and a cognate effector, respectively. ShcF(Pto) interacts with and stabilizes the HopF(Pto) protein in the bacterial cell. Translation of HopF(Pto) starts at a rare initiation codon ATA that limits the synthesis of the HopF(Pto) protein to a low level in bacterial cells.     

Genetics of resistance to bacterial speck of tomato caused by Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato

Two tomato cultivars, Ontario 7710 and Rehovot 13, and their F₁, F₂, F₃ and backcross progenies were screened for resistance to bacterial speck (Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato) of tomato. The results support the hypothesis that the resistance factors contained in the two parents are non-allelic and controlled by two different genes.     

Molecular cloning of copper resistance genes from Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato.

A cosmid library of copper-resistant (Cur) Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato PT23 plasmid DNA was constructed and mobilized into the copper-sensitive recipient P. syringae pv. syringae PS61. One resultant cosmid clone, pCOP1 (46 kilobases), conferred copper resistance. The PT23 Cur gene(s) was located on pCOP1 by subcloning PstI restriction endonuclease fragments of pCOP1 in the broad-host-range vector pRK404. A subclone containing a 4.4-kilobase PstI fragment conferred Cur on PS61. The Cur gene(s) was further located by insertional inactivation with Tn5. A subcloned fragment internal to the Cur determinant on pCOP2 was probed to plasmid and chromosomal DNA of four copper-resistant and three copper-sensitive strains of P. syringae pv. tomato. The probe hybridized to plasmids in resistant strains, but showed no detectable homology to copper-sensitive strains.