Effect of low oxygen and high carbon dioxide on the levels of ethylene and 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid in ripening apple fruits

The association of the level of ACC and the ethylene concentration in ripening apple fruit (Malus sylvestris Mill, var. Ben Davis) was studied. Preclimacteric apple contained small amounts of ACC and ethylene. With the onset of the climacteric and a concomitant decrease in flesh firmness, the level of ACC and ethylene concentration both increased markedly. During the postclimacteric period, ethylene concentration started to decline, but the level of ACC continued to increase. Ethylene production and loss of flesh firmness of fruits during ripening were greatly suppressed by treatments with low O₂ (O₂ 1–3%, CO₂ O%) or high CO₂ (CO₂ 20–30%, O₂ 15–20%) at the preclimacteric stage. However, after 4 weeks an accumulation of ACC was observed in treated fruits when control fruit was at the postclimacteric stage. Treatment of fruit with either low O₂ or high CO₂ at the climacteric stage resulted in a decrease of ethylene production. However, the ACC level in fruit treated with low O₂ was much higher than both control and high CO₂ treated fruit; it appears that low O₂ inhibits only the conversion of ACC to ethylene, resulting in an accumulation of ACC. Since CO₂ inhibits ethylene production but does not result in an accumulation of ACC, it appears that high CO₂ inhibits both the conversion of ACC to ethylene and the formation of ACC.     

Ethylene: Response of Fruit Dehiscence to CO(2) and Reduced Pressure

These studies were conducted to determine whether ethylene serves as a natural regulator of fruit wall dehiscence, a major visible feature of ripening in some fruits. We employed treatments to inhibit ethylene action or remove ethylene and observed their effect on fruit dehiscence. CO₂ (13%), a competitive inhibitor of ethylene action in many systems, readily delayed dehiscence of detached fruits of cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.), pecan (Carya illinoensis [Wang.] K. Koch), and okra (Hibiscus esculentus L.). The CO₂ effect was duplicated by placing fruits under reduced pressure (200 millimeters mercury), to promote the escape of ethylene from the tissue. Dehiscence of detached fruits of these species as well as attached cotton fruits was delayed. The delay of dehiscence of cotton and okra by both treatments was achieved with fruit harvested at intervals from shortly after anthesis until shortly before natural dehiscence. Pecan fruits would not dehisce until approximately 1 month before natural dehiscence, and during that time, CO₂ and reduced pressure delayed dehiscence. CO₂ and ethylene were competitive in their effects on cotton fruit dehiscence. All of the results are compatible with a hypothetical role of ethylene as a natural regulator of dehiscence, a dominant aspect of ripening of cotton, pecan, and some other fruits.     

Ozone-induced inhibition of kiwifruit ripening is amplified by 1-methylcyclopropene and reversed by exogenous ethylene

Background

Understanding the mechanisms involved in climacteric fruit ripening is key to improve fruit harvest quality and postharvest performance. Kiwifruit (Actinidia deliciosa cv. ‘Hayward’) ripening involves a series of metabolic changes regulated by ethylene. Although 1-methylcyclopropene (1-MCP, inhibitor of ethylene action) or ozone (O₃) exposure suppresses ethylene-related kiwifruit ripening, how these molecules interact during ripening is unknown.

Results

Harvested ‘Hayward’ kiwifruits were treated with 1-MCP and exposed to ethylene-free cold storage (0?°C, RH 95%) with ambient atmosphere (control) or atmosphere enriched with O₃ (0.3?μL?L^??1) for up to 6?months. Their subsequent ripening performance at 20?°C (90% RH) was characterized. Treatment with either 1-MCP or O₃ inhibited endogenous ethylene biosynthesis and delayed fruit ripening at 20?°C. 1-MCP and O₃ in combination severely inhibited kiwifruit ripening, significantly extending fruit storage potential. To characterize ethylene sensitivity of kiwifruit following 1-MCP and O₃ treatments, fruit were exposed to exogenous ethylene (100?μL?L^??1, 24?h) upon transfer to 20?°C following 4 and 6?months of cold storage. Exogenous ethylene treatment restored ethylene biosynthesis in fruit previously exposed in an O₃-enriched atmosphere. Comparative proteomics analysis showed separate kiwifruit ripening responses, unraveled common 1-MCP- and O₃-dependent metabolic pathways and identified specific proteins associated with these different ripening behaviors. Protein components that were differentially expressed following exogenous ethylene exposure after 1-MCP or O₃ treatment were identified and their protein-protein interaction networks were determined. The expression of several kiwifruit ripening related genes, such as 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid oxidase (ACO1), ethylene receptor (ETR1), lipoxygenase (LOX1), geranylgeranyl diphosphate synthase (GGP1), and expansin (EXP2), was strongly affected by O₃, 1-MCP, their combination, and exogenously applied ethylene.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that the combination of 1-MCP and O₃ functions as a robust repressive modulator of kiwifruit ripening and provide new insight into the metabolic events underlying ethylene-induced and ethylene-independent ripening outcomes.

     

Effects of Elevated CO(2) Concentrations on Glycolysis in Intact ;Bartlett' Pear Fruit

Mature intact `Bartlett' pear fruit (Pyrus communis L.) were stored under a continuous flow of air or air + 10% CO₂ for 4 days at 20°C. Fruit kept under elevated CO₂ concentrations exhibited reduced respiration (O₂ consumption) and ethylene evolution rates, and remained firmer and greener than fruit stored in air. Protein content, fructose 1,6-bisphosphate levels, and ATP:phosphofructokinase and PPi:phosphofructokinase activities declined, while levels of fructose 6-phosphate and fructose 2,6-bisphosphate increased in fruit exposed to air + 10% CO₂. These results are discussed in light of a possible inhibitory effect of CO₂ at the site of action of both phosphofructokinases in the glycolytic pathway, which could account, at least in part, for the observed reduction in respiration.     

Effect of silver ion, carbon dioxide, and oxygen on ethylene action and metabolism

The relationship between ethylene action and metabolism was investigated in the etiolated pea seedling (Pisum sativum L. cv. Alaska) by inhibiting ethylene action with Ag⁺, high CO₂, and low O₂ and then determining if ethylene metabolism was inhibited in a similar manner. Ag⁺ (100 milligrams per liter) was clearly the most potent antiethylene treatment. Ag⁺ pretreatment inhibited the growth retarding action of 0.2 microliters per liter ethylene by 48% and it also inhibited the incorporation of 0.2 microliters per liter ¹⁴C₂H₄ into pea tips by the same amount. As the ethylene concentration was increased from 0.2 to 30 microliters per liter, the effectiveness of Ag⁺ in reducing ethylene action and metabolism declined in a similar fashion. Although Ag⁺ significantly inhibited the incorporation of ¹⁴C₂H₄ into tissue metabolites, the oxidation of ¹⁴C₂H₄ to ¹⁴CO₂ was unaffected in the same tissue.     

Benefits of ethylene removal during apple storage

The potential use of an ethylene absorbent in controlled atmosphere storage of two varieties of apple has been investigated. With Golden Delicious, the rise in ethylene concentration during controlled atmosphere storage can be delayed for about 40 days but not prevented by inclusion of potassium permanganate in the storage container. But with Bramley's Seedling, potassium permanganate can delay ethylene accumulation for over 200 days. Ethylene treatment of Bramley's Seedling in a flowing stream of 5% CO₂:3% O₂:92% N₂ caused accelerated softening, accumulation of α-farnesene and earlier onset of superficial scald. Use of potassium permanganate to remove ethylene during storage in static controlled atmosphere conditions retarded all three processes in Bramley's Seedling kept in 5% CO₂:3% O₂ and in 9% CO₂:12% O₂. However, in one experiment, ethylene removal in 5% CO₂:3% O₂, led to external and internal symptoms of CO₂ damage. A subsequent investigation of the combined effects of harvest date, store temperature and ethylene removal in 5% CO₂:3% O₂ did not show any damage or accumulation of succinic acid which is known to be involved in CO₂ injury. This experiment revealed that ethylene removal could be successfully accomplished on Bramley fruit harvested up to a month after the usual date and little α-farnesene accumulated in this fruit. Nevertheless scald did develop on late picked fruit and this raises doubts about the causal role of farnesene in scald.     

Expression of ethylene response genes during persimmon fruit astringency removal

Thirteen ethylene signaling related genes were isolated and studied during ripening of non-astringent ‘Yangfeng’ and astringent ‘Mopan’ persimmon fruit. Some of these genes were characterized as ethylene responsive. Treatments, including ethylene and CO₂, had different effects on persimmon ripening, but overlapping roles in astringency removal, such as increasing the reduction in levels of soluble tannins. DkERS1, DkETR2, and DkERF8, may participate in persimmon fruit ripening and softening. The expression patterns of DkETR2, DkERF4, and DkERF5 had significant correlations with decreases in soluble tannins in ‘Mopan’ persimmon fruit, suggesting that these genes might be key components in persimmon fruit astringency removal and be the linkage between different treatments, while DkERF1 and DkERF6 may be specifically involved in CO₂ induced astringency removal. The possible roles of ethylene signaling genes in persimmon fruit astringency removal are discussed.     

Effect of diazocyclopentadiene on tomato ripening

Diazocyclopentadiene (DACP) in the presence of fluorescent light delayed ripening of tomato fruits treated at the mature green (no visible red) stage. At 25 °C, ripening was delayed 10 days if DACP [185 µl/1 (gas)] was added as a single treatment and longer if DACP was added intermittently at 5-day intervals. The addition of 1000 µl/1 ethylene following DACP and light treatment did not hasten ripening. Little ripening delay was noted for fruit + DACP held in darkness. Tomatoes covered with aluminum foil so as to exclude light but not light-activated DACP, showed ripening inhibition. Apparently, the light-activated product from DACP is stable long enough to diffuse into fruit held in darkness. After an initial inhibition, ethylene production was greatly increased in tomatoes treated with DACP. Tomatoes with or without DACP treatment were held either in air or 5% O₂/95% N₂ for 12 days then treated with ethylene. Treatment with 5% O₂ alone delayed ripening when compared to air alone, however, both groups reached 80% red color by 18 days. DACP treated fruit, whether held in air or 5% O₂, still were green after 18 days and only approached 80% red color after approximately 27 days. Thus, 5% oxygen did not appear to slow the reversal of DACP inhibition of ripening.     

Ripening tomatoes: Ethylene,oxygen, and light treatments

Tomato fruit (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. var. V. R. Moscow) harvested at the mature green stage were ripened by treatments with ethylene, oxygen, and oxygen plus ethylene. Treatments were made under dark and light conditions. Ethylene increased the ripening and respiration rates of the tomatoes. The fruit treated with ethylene had a general increase in beta carotene and lycopene when compared with untreated controls. The per cent acid was variable from year to year in the fruit treated with ethylene. The fruit ripened in ethylene had higher concentrations of citric acid than did the untreated controls. Treatments with oxygen decreased the reducing sugars and at the high concentrations used, had no effect on the rate of lycopene synthesis. Light treatments increased the per cent acid, reducing sugars, and color of the ripened fruit. The increase in color was related to an increase in both beta carotene and lycopene. Light treatment seemed to decrease the respiration rate of the fruit not treated with ethylene. Studies usingC¹⁴O₂ showed that this may be due to utilization of CO₂ evolved from respiration by the green fruit in photosynthesis.     

Products Released from Enzymically Active Cell Wall Stimulate Ethylene Production and Ripening in Preclimacteric Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) Fruit

Enzymically active cell wall from ripe tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) fruit pericarp release uronic acids through the action of wall-bound polygalacturonase. The potential involvement of products of wall hydrolysis in the induction of ethylene synthesis during tomato ripening was investigated by vacuum infiltrating preclimacteric (green) fruit with solutions containing pectin fragments enzymically released from cell wall from ripe fruit. Ripening initiation was accelerated in pectin-infiltrated fruit compared to control (buffer-infiltrated) fruit as measured by initiation of climacteric CO₂ and ethylene production and appearance of red color. The response to infiltration was maximum at a concentration of 25 micrograms pectin per fruit; higher concentrations (up to 125 micrograms per fruit) had no additional effect. When products released from isolated cell wall from ripe pericarp were separated on Bio-Gel P-2 and specific size classes infiltrated into preclimacteric fruit, ripening-promotive activity was found only in the larger (degree of polymerization >8) fragments. Products released from pectin derived from preclimacteric pericarp upon treatment with polygalacturonase from ripe pericarp did not stimulate ripening when infiltrated into preclimacteric fruit.     

Resistance of citrus fruit to mass transport of water vapor and other gases

The resistance of oranges (Citrus sinensis L. Osbeck) and grapefruit (Citrus paradisi Macf.) to ethylene, O₂, CO₂, and H₂O mass transport was investigated anatomically with scanning electron microscope and physiologically by gas exchange measurements at steady state. The resistance of untreated fruit to water vapor is far less than to ethylene, CO₂ and O₂. Waxing partially or completely plugs stomatal pores and forms an intermittent cracked layer over the surface of fruit, restricting transport of ethylene, O₂, and CO₂, but not of water; whereas individual sealing of fruit with high density polyethylene films reduces water transport by 90% without substantially inhibiting gas exchange.

Stomata of harvested citrus fruits are essentially closed. However, ethylene, O₂ and CO₂ still diffuse mainly through the residual stomatal opening where the relative transport resistance (approximately 6,000 seconds per centimeter) depends on the relative diffusivity of each gas in air. Water moves preferentially by a different pathway, probably through a liquid aqueous phase in the cuticle where water conductance is 60-fold greater. Other gases are constrained from using this pathway because their diffusivity in liquid water is 10⁴-fold less than in air.

     

Changes in colour,polygalacturonase monosaccharides and organic acids during storage of tomatoes

The appearance of polygalacturonase and red pigmentation in mature-green tomato fruit was prevented by storing the fruit in 5% O₂, 5% CO₂ and 90% N₂. However, the breakdown of starch to give monosaccharides and the change in concentration of organic acids which is normally associated with ripening still took place. On removal of the fruit to ambient conditions, polygalacturonase was synthesized and the fruit changed colour but monosaccharide and organic acid concentrations did not change.     

Growth and respiration patterns of snap bean fruits

The relationship of respiration and growth of seed, pericarp tissue and whole fruit of snap beans (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) was studied. The whole fruit exhibited an apparent climacteric type of respiration pattern. This pattern resulted from an increase in CO₂ production by the enlarging seed followed by a rapid decrease in CO₂ evolution by the pericarp tissue, and the pattern was not associated with any concomitant increase in ethylene production. Therefore, the apparent climacteric respiration pattern of a developing bean fruit is not comparable to the phenomenon that occurs in other ripening fruits.     

Antisense inhibition of the Nr gene restores normal ripening to the tomato Never-ripe mutant, consistent with the ethylene receptor-inhibition model

The hormone ethylene regulates many aspects of plant growth and development, including fruit ripening. In transgenic tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) plants, antisense inhibition of ethylene biosynthetic genes results in inhibited or delayed ripening. The dominant tomato mutant, Never-ripe (Nr), is insensitive to ethylene and fruit fail to ripen. The Nr phenotype results from mutation of the ethylene receptor encoded by the NR gene, such that it can no longer bind the hormone. NR has homology to the Arabidopsis ethylene receptors. Studies on ethylene perception in Arabidopsis have demonstrated that receptors operate by a "receptor inhibition" mode of action, in which they actively repress ethylene responses in the absence of the hormone, and are inactive when bound to ethylene. In ripening tomato fruit, expression of NR is highly regulated, increasing in expression at the onset of ripening, coincident with increased ethylene production. This expression suggests a requirement for the NR gene product during the ripening process, and implies that ethylene signaling via the tomato NR receptor might not operate by receptor inhibition. We used antisense inhibition to investigate the role of NR in ripening tomato fruit and determine its mode of action. We demonstrate restoration of normal ripening in Nr fruit by inhibition of the mutant Nr gene, indicating that this receptor is not required for normal ripening, and confirming receptor inhibition as the mode of action of the NR protein.     

Softening response of 1-methylcyclopropene-treated banana fruit to high oxygen atmospheres

Exposure to high O₂ concentrations may stimulate, have no effect or retard fruit ripening depending upon the commodity, O₂ concentration and storage time among other variables. The ethylene-binding inhibitor 1-methylcyclopropene (1-MCP) was used to investigate ethylene-mediated softening responses of Williams banana fruit exposed to elevated O₂ for various periods of time. Fruit softening was measured at 25 °C and 90% relative humidity. Exposure to high O₂ concentrations for 5 days resulted in accelerated softening. Softening of fruit treated with 1-MCP for 12 h followed by 5 days of storage in high O₂ atmospheres at 25 °C was enhanced with increasing O₂ concentration between 21 and 100%. However, overall softening was much less compared to non-1-MCP-treated fruit. Softening of 1-MCP-treated fruit was progressively enhanced with increasing holding time from 5 to 20 days. Fruit treated with 1-MCP and then held for 10 days in high O₂ atmospheres followed by exposure to ethylene for 24 h and subsequent storage for 5 days at 25 °C softened more rapidly than those held in air for 10 days. 1-MCP-treated fruit held in various high O₂ atmospheres can regain gradually the sensitivity to ethylene and finally ripen over time. Enhanced softening of fruit exposed to elevated O₂ concentrations suggests that high O₂ treatments enhance synthesis of new ethylene binding sites.     

Initiation of Ripening in Bartlett Pear with an Antiauxin alpha(p-Chlorophenoxy)isobutyric Acid

A vacuum infiltration technique was used to apply an anti-auxin, α-(p-chlorophenoxy) isobutyric acid to mature green pears (Pyrus communis var. Bartlett). Application of α-(p-chlorophenoxy) isobutyric acid, at 0.02, 0.2, and 2.0 mm progressively accelerated the onset of chlorophyll degradation, softening, and CO₂ evolution. The action of α(p-chlorophenoxy) isobutyric acid is apparently independent of ethylene, since the auxin analogue depressed ethylene evolution and could overcome ethylene deficiency in fruit ripening under hypobaric conditions.     

Ethylene-independent and ethylene-dependent biochemical changes in ripening tomatoes

Fruits of Lycopersicon esculentum Mill cv Sonatine stored in 6% CO₂, 6% O₂, and 88% N₂ for 14 weeks at 12°C, exhibited a temporal separation of certain biochemical events associated with ripening.

The specific activity of two citric acid cycle enzymes, citrate synthase and malate dehydrogenase, fell substantially during the first 2 weeks of storage when changes in organic acid concentration also occurred. During this period, lycopene, polygalacturonase, and ethylene were undetectable.

When fruit were removed from store, ethylene was evolved and polygalacturonase and invertase activity were rapidly initiated as was synthesis of lycopene.

To determine whether the changes in organic acid metabolism were affected by ethylene, fruit was kept at 22°C in either a normal atmosphere or a normal atmosphere supplemented with 27 microliters per liter of ethylene, and it was shown that in both atmospheres similar quantitative changes to those described above occurred in the citric acid cycle enzymes specific activities before any detectable increase in the specific activities of invertase and polygalacturonase. These latter changes, together with pigment changes, occurred between 2 and 3 days earlier in fruit exposed to ethylene, compared with those kept in a normal atmosphere.

     

SPINDLY interacts with EIN2 to facilitate ethylene signalling-mediated fruit ripening in tomato

The post-translational modification of proteins enables cells to respond promptly to dynamic stimuli by controlling protein functions. In higher plants, SPINDLY (SPY) and SECRET AGENT (SEC) are two prominent O-glycosylation enzymes that have both unique and overlapping roles; however, the effects of their O-glycosylation on fruit ripening and the underlying mechanisms remain largely unknown. Here we report that SlSPY affects tomato fruit ripening. Using slspy mutants and two SlSPY-OE lines, we provide biological evidence for the positive role of SlSPY in fruit ripening. We demonstrate that SlSPY regulates fruit ripening by changing the ethylene response in tomato. To further investigate the underlying mechanism, we identify a central regulator of ethylene signalling ETHYLENE INSENSITIVE 2 (EIN2) as a SlSPY interacting protein. SlSPY promotes the stability and nuclear accumulation of SlEIN2. Mass spectrometry analysis further identified that SlEIN2 has two potential sites Ser771 and Thr821 of O-glycans modifications. Further study shows that SlEIN2 is essential for SlSPY in regulating fruit ripening in tomatoes. Collectively, our findings reveal a novel regulatory function of SlSPY in fruit and provide novel insights into the role of the SlSPY-SlEIN2 module in tomato fruit ripening.