Telencephalic sources of the afferents of the main olfactory bulb in the frog Rana temporaria

Following horseradish peroxidase iontophoretic application into the main olfactory bulb (MOB) retrograde neuronal labeling was examined in the telencephalon in the frog. Labeled neurons, the sources of the MOB afferents are found in the mitral cell layer of the contralateral MOB, pallial and some subpallial areas. Very heavy labeling is observed in the pars ventralis of the lateral pallium, and to a lesser extent in the medial pallium, pars dorsalis of the lateral pallium and in the dorsal pallium. In subpallium labeled neurons are found in the eminentia postolfactoria, the rostral part of the medial septal nucleus, and in the nucleus of the ventro-medial telencephalic wall, which is probably homologous to the nucleus of the diagonal band (Broca) of mammals. No labelled neurons were found in the caudal portion of the MOB granular layer, usually referred to as the anterior olfactory nucleus. The arrangement of the MOB centrifugal innervation in amphibians is discussed in comparison with that in mammals.     

Thoughts on the development, structure and evolution of the mammalian and avian telencephalic pallium

Various lines of evidence suggest that the development and evolution of the mammalian isocortex cannot be easily explained without an understanding of correlative changes in surrounding areas of the telencephalic pallium and subpallium. These are close neighbours in a common morphogenetic field and are postulated as sources of some cortical neuron types (and even of whole cortical areas). There is equal need to explain relevant developmental evolutionary changes in the dorsal thalamus, the major source of afferent inputs to the telencephalon (to both the pallium and subpallium). The mammalian isocortex evolved within an initially small dorsal part of the pallium of vertebrates, surrounded by other pallial parts, including some with a non-cortical, nuclear structure. Nuclear pallial elements are markedly voluminous in reptiles and birds, where they build the dorsal ventricular ridge, or hypopallium, which has been recently divided molecularly and structurally into a lateral pallium and a ventral pallium. Afferent pallial connections are often simplified as consisting of thalamic fibres that project either to focal cell aggregates in the ventral pallium (predominant in reptiles and birds) or to corticoid areas in the dorsal pallium (predominant in mammals). Karten's hypothesis, put forward in 1969, on the formation of some isocortical areas postulates an embryonic translocation into the nascent isocortex of the ventropallial thalamorecipient foci and respective downstream ventropallial target populations, as specific layer IV, layers II- III, or layers V-VI neuron populations. This view is considered critically in the light of various recent data, contrasting with the alternative possibility of a parallel, separate evolution of the different pallial parts. The new scenario reveals as well a separately evolving tiered structure of the dorsal thalamus, some of whose parts receive input from midbrain sensory centres (collothalamic nuclei), whereas other parts receive oligosynaptic 'lemniscal' connections bypassing the midbrain (lemnothalamic nuclei). An ampler look into known hodological patterns from this viewpoint suggests that ancient collothalamic pathways, which target ventropallial foci, are largely conserved in mammals, while some emergent cortical connections can be established by means of new collaterals in some of these pathways. The lemnothalamic pathways, which typically target ancestrally the dorsopallial isocortex, show parallel increments of relative size and structural diversification of both the thalamic cell populations and the cortical recipient areas. The evolving lemnothalamic pathways may interact developmentally with collothalamic corticopetal collaterals in the modality-specific invasion of the emergent new areas of isocortex.     

The corticostriatal junction: a crucial region for forebrain development and evolution

Most parts of the brain are conserved across reptiles and birds (sauropsids) and mammals. Two major qualitative differences occur in the upper part, or pallium, of the telencephalon, the most rostral part of the brain. Mammals have a six-layered neocortex and also exhibit a different morphological organization in the lateral half, or sector, of their pallium than do sauropsids. These differences of lateral pallial construction may derive from small but crucial differences in migration patterns of neuronal precursors generated at or above the corner of the lateral ventricle, the corticostriatal junction (CS). Sauropsids have a large structure, the dorsal ventricular ridge, that is proliferated from this region, and its anterior part (ADVR) receives ascending projections from the dorsal thalamus. Mammals have multiple structures in this same region-the lateral part of neocortex, amygdala, and claustrum-endopiriform formation. We propose here that, as the degree of development of structures that form the deeper tier of the pallium varies across the stages of embryology and across phylogeny, mutations may have occurred during evolution at the origin of mammals that had profound consequences for the fate of neural populations generated in the region of the CS and its neighboring pallial germinal zone.     

Comparison of the mammalian and avian telencephalon from the perspective of gene expression data.

Pallial and subpallial morphological subdivisions of the mouse and chicken telencephalon were examined from the new perspective given by gene markers expressed in these territories during development. The rationale of this approach is that common gene expression patterns may underlie similar histogenetic specification and, consequently, comparable morphological nature. The nested expression domains of the genes Dlx-2 and Nkx-2.1 are characteristic for the subpallium (lateral and medial ganglionic eminences). Similar expression of these markers in parts of the mouse septum and amygdala suggests that such parts may be considered subpallial. The genes Pax-6, Tbr-1 and Emx-1 are expressed in the pallium. Complementary areas of the septum and amygdala shared expression of these genes, suggesting these are the pallial parts of these units. Differences in the relative topography of pallial marker genes also define different regions of the pallium, which can be partially traced into the amygdala. Importantly, there is evidence of a novel "ventral pallium" subdivision, which is a molecularly distinct pallial territory intercalated between the striatum and the lateral pallium. Its derivatives in the mouse apparently belong to the claustroamygdaloid complex. Chicken genes homologous sequence-wise to these mouse developmental genes are expressed in topologically comparable patterns during development. The avian subpallium -the paleostriatum- expresses Dlx-2 and Nkx-2.1; expression extends as well into the septum and anterior and medial parts of the archistriatum. The avian pallium expresses Pax-6, Tbr-1 and Emx-1 and also contains a distinct ventral pallium, formed by the neostriatum and ventral intermediate parts of the archistriatum. The lateral pallium comprises the hyperstriatum ventrale, overlying temporo-parieto-occipital corticoid layer and piriform cortex, plus dorsal intermediate and posterior archistriatum. The dorsal pallium includes the dorsal, intercalated and accessory hyperstriatum, plus the dorsolateral corticoid area. The medial pallium contains the hippocampus and parahippocampal area. A dorsal part of the septum shares pallial molecular markers. Gene markers thus suggest common sets of molecular developmental determinants in either pallial or subpallial domains of the mouse and chicken telencephalon, extending all the way from the posterior pole (amygdala) to the septum. Ventral pallial derivatives identified as claustroamygdaloid in the mouse correlate with avian neostriatum and parts of the archistriatum.     

Localization of the sensory projection areas in the cerebral cortex of the dolphin, Tursiops truncatus

Using the evoked potential technique, studies have been made on localization of the projectional sensory areas in the cerebral cortex (visual, acoustic and somatosensory) of the porpoise T. truncatus. Distribution of these projectional areas in the porpoise is quite different as compared to that in other mammals. Visual and acoustic areas are shifted to the dorsal part of the hemisphere, all the sensory areas investigated exhibit a direct contact with each other.     

The level of metabolic activity (cytochrome oxidase) as an index of functional significance of tectofugal and thalamofugal channels of the reptilian visual system

Using histochemical determination of activity of the mitochondrial oxidative enzyme cytochrome oxidase (CO) in brain structures, metabolic activity both in turtles and in lizards has been shown to be higher in centers of the tectofugal channel (the tectal stratum griseum centrale, SGC; nucleus pretectalis ventralis, Ptv; thalamic nucleus rotundus, Rot; telencephalic visual area of the anterior dorsal ventricular ridge, Advr) than in the thalamofugal channel centers (the thalamic nucleus geniculatus lateralis pars dorsalis, GLd; cortex dorsolateralis, Cxdl; and pallial thickening, Path) of the visual system. Some interspecies differences in distribution of the CO activity in the tectal, thalamic, and telencephalic visual centers between terrestrial and pond turtles and lizards were revealed. The obtained data confirm the idea on the dominating role of the tectofugal channel over the thalamofugal channel of the visual system in information processing and organization of the day-to-day behavior of reptiles.     

Consciousness without cortex

Sensory consciousness — the awareness and ability to report subjective experiences — is a property of biological nervous systems that has evolved out of unconscious processing over hundreds of millions of years. From which brain structures and based on which mechanisms can conscious experience emerge? Based on the body of work in human and nonhuman primates, the emergence of consciousness is intimately associated with the workings of the mammalian cerebral cortex with its specific cell types and layered structure. However, recent neurophysiological recordings demonstrate a neuronal correlate of consciousness in the pallial endbrain of crows. These telencephalic integration centers in birds originate embryonically from other pallial territories, lack a layered architecture characteristic for the cerebral cortex, and exhibit independently evolved pallial cell types. This argues that the mammalian cerebral cortex is not a prerequisite for consciousness to emerge in all vertebrates. Rather, it seems that the anatomical and physiological principles of the telencephalic pallium offer this structure as a brain substrate for consciousness to evolve independently across vertebrate phylogeny.     

Projections of Olfactory Bulbs and Non-Olfactory Telencephalic Structures in Amygdaloid Complex of the Turtle <Emphasis Type="Italic">Testudo horsfieldi</Emphasis>: A Study Using Anterograde Tracer Technique

To confirm the discrete character of projections of telencephalic olfactory and non-olfactory structures to the amygdaloid complex (AC) in the terrestrial turtle Testudo horsfieldi, a study was performed by the method of anterograde axonal transport of tracers (HRP, BDA). After a massive injection of the tracers into the main and accessory olfactory bulb, a dense accumulation of labeled fibers and terminals was found in ventral part of AC in the neuropil zones of nbam (J) and ncoam and very scanty—in nmam and ncam. After a massive injection of the tracers into non-olfactory telencephalic structures including dorsal cortex, pallidal enlargement, and ADVR, a very dense terminal field was observed in the dorsal AC part and a less dense one, with predominance of labeled fibers, in its ventral part. Local administration of the tracers separately into the dorsolateral (visual area) and the ventromedial (auditory-somatic area) parts of the ADVR allowed revealing discrete projections, respectively, to the laterocentral and mediocentral areas of the dorsal AC part with a relative overlapping in the central AC area. In all experiments, retrogradely labeled neurons in AC were also observed in zones of the corresponding bulbar and rostrotelencephalic projections. Thus, it has been shown that in the turtle AC there exist not only separation of direct olfactory and non-olfactory projections, but also discrete projections of different sensory areas of ADVR. Reciprocity of these connections is also confirmed. Organization of afferent olfactory and non-olfactory telencephalic connections in AC is similar in reptiles and in mammals.     

Proliferation, neurogenesis and regeneration in the non-mammalian vertebrate brain

Post-embryonic neurogenesis is a fundamental feature of the vertebrate brain. However, the level of adult neurogenesis decreases significantly with phylogeny. In the first part of this review, a comparative analysis of adult neurogenesis and its putative roles in vertebrates are discussed. Adult neurogenesis in mammals is restricted to two telencephalic constitutively active zones. On the contrary, non-mammalian vertebrates display a considerable amount of adult neurogenesis in many brain regions. The phylogenetic differences in adult neurogenesis are poorly understood. However, a common feature of vertebrates (fish, amphibians and reptiles) that display a widespread adult neurogenesis is the substantial post-embryonic brain growth in contrast to birds and mammals. It is probable that the adult neurogenesis in fish, frogs and reptiles is related to the coordinated growth of sensory systems and corresponding sensory brain regions. Likewise, neurons are substantially added to the olfactory bulb in smell-oriented mammals in contrast to more visually oriented primates and songbirds, where much fewer neurons are added to the olfactory bulb. The second part of this review focuses on the differences in brain plasticity and regeneration in vertebrates. Interestingly, several recent studies show that neurogenesis is suppressed in the adult mammalian brain. In mammals, neurogenesis can be induced in the constitutively neurogenic brain regions as well as ectopically in response to injury, disease or experimental manipulations. Furthermore, multipotent progenitor cells can be isolated and differentiated in vitro from several otherwise silent regions of the mammalian brain. This indicates that the potential to recruit or generate neurons in non-neurogenic brain areas is not completely lost in mammals. The level of adult neurogenesis in vertebrates correlates with the capacity to regenerate injury, for example fish and amphibians exhibit the most widespread adult neurogenesis and also the greatest capacity to regenerate central nervous system injuries. Studying these phenomena in non-mammalian vertebrates may greatly increase our understanding of the mechanisms underlying regeneration and adult neurogenesis. Understanding mechanisms that regulate endogenous proliferation and neurogenic permissiveness in the adult brain is of great significance in therapeutical approaches for brain injury and disease.     

Evolution of the Nasal Structure in the Lower Tetrapods

The gross structure of the nasal cavities and the distributionof the various types of epithelium lining them are describedbriefly; each living order of amphibians and reptiles possessesa characteristic and distinctive pattern. In most groups thereare two sensory areas, one lined by olfactory epithelium withnerve libers leading to the main olfactory bulb and the otherby vomeronasal epithelium with fibers to the accessory bulb.All amniotes except turtles have the vomeronasal epitheliumin a ventromedial outpocketing of the nose, the Jacobson's organ,and have one or more conchae projecting into the nasal cavityfrom the lateral wall. Although urodeles and turtles possessthe simplest nasal structure, it is not possible to show thatthey are primitive or to define a basic pattern for either amphibiansor reptiles; all the living orders are specialized and the nasalanatomy of extinct orders is unknown. Thus it is impossible,at present, to give a convincing picture of the course of nasalevolution in the lower tetrapods.     

Central Nervous System Changes Related to the Reduction of Visual Input in a Naturally Blind Fish (Astyanax hubbsi)

Tectal anatomy and physiology of the blind cave characin, Astyanaxhubbsi, have been compared with that of its sighted ancestorAstyanax mexicanus (the river fish) and with goldfish. Normaland experimental neuroanatomic methods have revealed that, withthe exception of a greatly reduced retinotectal projection,connectivity and structure of cave fish tecta are similar tothose described in sighted species. It appears that the rudimentaryretinotectal input is nonfunctional, since no tectal evokedresponses could be elicited with electrical or visual stimulationof the optic cyst, and all attempts to visually condition cavefish were unsuccessful. Attempts have also been made to record somatosensory, auditoryand lateral line activity in the tecta of the blind and sightedfish. A sparse somatic representation was found in the deeperportion of the sighted fish tecta which contrasts with a dense,well-organized one in the cave fish. No tectal responses werefound to auditory or lateral line stimuli. CNS plasticity is discussed in relation to studies of fish,amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals, in which a reductionof sensory input by any one of a number of means has resultedin alterations of structure and function.     

The temporal sequence of the mammalian neocortical neurogenetic program drives mediolateral pattern in the chick pallium

The six-layered neocortex permits complex information processing in all mammalian species. Because its homologous region (the pallium) in nonmammalian amniotes has a different architecture, the ability of neocortical progenitors to generate an orderly sequence of distinct cell types was thought to have arisen in the mammalian lineage. This study, however, shows that layer-specific neuron subtypes do exist in the chick pallium. Deep- and upper-layer neurons are not layered but are segregated in distinct mediolateral domains in vivo. Surprisingly, cultured chick neural progenitors produce multiple layer-specific neuronal subtypes in the same chronological sequence as seen in mammals. These results suggest that the temporal sequence of the neocortical neurogenetic program was already inherent in the last common ancestor of mammals and birds and that mammals use this conserved program to generate a uniformly layered neocortex, whereas birds impose spatial constraints on the sequence to pattern the pallium.     

Central Lateral Line and Auditory Pathways: A Phylogenetic Perspective

The phylogenetic origins of the lateral line electrosensory,lateral line mechanosensory, and auditory components of theoctavolateralis system are unknown but each of these sensorymodalities appears to have evolved early in vertebrate history.The octavolateralis terminal field occupies a large area ofthe dorsolateral wall of the medulla and among agnathids, cartilaginousfishes, non-teleost bony fishes and, with modifications, urodeles,consists of a dorsal electrosensory nucleus, a medial mechanosensorynucleus and a ventral octaval nuclear complex. This arrangementof medullary octavolateral nuclei, which differs from that ofnon-electroreceptive and electroreceptive teleosts, is consideredthe primitive plan and is retained in that phyletic line leadingto tetrapods. Separate and parallel pathways are known, in elasmobranchsand a few teleosts, to ascend from each medullary lateral linecenter to the midbrain and presumably from midbrain to telencephaliclevels via thalamic relays. There is no evidence, with the lossof lateral line senses among some amphibians and all amniotes,that the central neural pathways and nuclei are retained andused to process information from other sensory modalities. Theanatomy of the central auditory system of fishes is unknownbut is required for an understanding of whether auditory nucleiand pathways are retained during the fishamphibian transition,or whether new ones arise, to process information from independentlyevolved peripheral receptors.     

Corticalization of two divisions of the visual system during vertebrate evolution

Data on the evolution of the visual system in vertebrate phylogeny are described. Visual projections are demonstrated in the telencephalon of cyclostomata (lampreys). The existence of a retino-thalamo-telencephalic pathway is demonstrated in elasmobranchs (skates). Two visual pathways are present in amphibians (frogs) and reptiles (turtles): retino-thalamo-telencephalic and retino-tecto-thalamo-telencephalic, and these overlap partly at the thalamic level in the lateral geniculate nucleus and completely in the telencephalon. In turtles the earliest visual and tectal impulses relay on their way to the telencephalon in the lateral geniculate body, and later impulses relay in the nucleus rotundus. In mammals (rats) visual tecto-cortical connections are seen; judging from the latent period of potentials arising in the visual cortex in response to stimulation of the superior colliculi these connections have one synaptic relay in the thalamus. The much shorter latent periods of visual evoked potentials recorded in the tectum of the monkey than in turtles (under identical chronic experimental conditions) confirm the views of morphologists on the progressive development of the tectal division of the visual system in vertebrate phylogeny. It is concluded that corticalization of both divisions of the visual system, i.e., the existence of telencephalic representation, appears in the early stages of vertebrate evolution.     

Fate map of the avian anterior forebrain at the four-somite stage, based on the analysis of quail-chick chimeras.

To better understand the topological organization of the primordia within the anterior forebrain, we made a fate map of the rostral neural plate in the chick. Homotopic grafts at the four-somite stage were allowed to survive for up to 9 days to enable an analysis of definitive brain structures. In some cases, the topography of the grafted neuroepithelia was compared with gene expression patterns. The midpoint of the anterior neural ridge maps upon the anterior commissure in the closed neural tube, continuing concentrically into the preoptic area and optic field. Non-neural epithelium just in front of this median ridge gives rise to the adenohypophysis. Areas for the presumptive pallial commissure, septum, and prosencephalic choroidal tissue lie progressively more posteriorly along the ridge, peripheral to the telencephalic entopeduncular and striatopallidal primordia (the subpallium), and the pallium (olfactory bulb, dorsal ventricular ridge, and cortical domains). Subpallial structures lie topologically anterior to the pallial formations, and both are concentric to the septum. Within the pallium, the major cortical domains (Wulst and caudolateral, parahippocampal, and hippocampal cortices) appear posterior to the dorsal ventricular ridge. The amygdaloid region appears concentrically across both the subpallial and pallial regions. This fate map shows that the arrangement of the prospective primordia in the neural plate is basically a flattened representation of topological relationships present in the mature brain, though marked phenomena of differential growth and selective tangential migration of some cell populations complicate the histogenetic constitution of the mature telencephalon.     

Development and evolution of the pallium

The neocortex is the most representative and elaborated structure of the mammalian brain and is related to the achievement of complex cognitive capabilities, which are disturbed following malformation or lesion. Searching for the evolutionary origin of this structure continues to be one of the most important and challenging questions in comparative neurobiology. However, this is extremely difficult because of the highly divergent evolution of the pallium in different vertebrates, which has obscured the comparison. Herein, we review developmental neurobiology data for trying to understand the genetic factors that define and underlie the parcellation of homologous pallial subdivisions in different vertebrates. According to these data, the pallium in all tetrapods parcellates during development into four major histogenetic subdivisions, which are homologous as fields across species. The neocortex derives from the dorsal pallium and, as such, is only comparable to the sauropsidian dorsal pallium (avian hyperpallium and lizard/turtle dorsal cortex). We also tried to identify developmental changes in phylogeny that may be responsible of pallial divergent evolution. In particular, we point out to evolutionary differences regarding the cortical hem (an important signaling center for pallial patterning, that also is a source of Cajal–Retzius cells, which are involved in cortical lamination), which may be behind the distinct organization of the pallium in mammals and non-mammals. In addition, we mention recent data suggesting a correlation between the appearance and elaboration of the subventricular zone (a new germinative cell layer of the developing neocortex), and the evolution of novel cell layers (the supragranular layers) and interneuron subtypes. Finally, we comment on epigenetic factors that modulate the developmental programs, leading to changes in the formation of functional areas in the pallium (within some constraints).     

Cytoarchitectonic study of the brain of a perciform species, the sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax). I. The telencephalon

A cytoarchitectonic analysis of the telencephalon of the sea bass Dicentrarchus labrax, based on cresyl violet-stained serial transverse sections, is presented. Rostrally, the brain of the sea bass is occupied by sessile olfactory bulbs coupled to telencephalic hemispheres. The olfactory bulbs comprise an olfactory nerve fiber layer, a glomerular layer, an external cellular layer, a secondary olfactory fiber layer, and an internal cellular layer. Large terminal nerve ganglion cells are evident in the caudomedial olfactory bulbs. We recognized 22 distinct telencephalic nuclei which were classified in two main areas, the ventral telencephalon and the dorsal telencephalon. The ventral telencephalon displays four periventricular cell masses: the dorsal, ventral, supracommissural, and postcommissural nuclei; and four migrated populations: the lateral, central, intermediate, and entopeduncular nuclei. In addition, a periventricular cell population resembling the lateral septal organ reported in birds is observed in the ventral telencephalon of the sea bass. The dorsal telencephalon contains 13 nuclei, which can be organized into five major zones: the medial part, dorsal part, lateral part and its ventral, dorsal, and posterior divisions, the central part, and posterior part. Based on histological criteria, two cell masses are recognized in the ventral division of the lateral part of the dorsal telencephalon. The nucleus taenia is found in the caudal area of the dorsal telencephalon, close to the ventral area. This study represents a useful tool for the precise localization of the neuroendocrine territories and for the tracing of the neuronal systems participating in the regulation of reproduction and metabolism in this species.     

Non-laminar cerebral cortex in teleost fishes?

A large skull is disadvantageous to animals that move quickly in three-dimensional space, such as fishes and birds in water or air. A cerebral neocortex with a six-layered sheet has not evolved, most likely due to the limited cranial space. Instead of the laminar cortex, telencephalic nuclear masses seem to have evolved as the pallium in teleost fishes. We consider that the nuclear masses contain rather simple neural circuits sharing a skeleton of simple circuits in the mammalian cortex, which have been elaborated by additional circuits in mammals. Such basic similarities at the connectional level shared by nuclear and cortical pallium might underlie similar or equivalent functions.     

Organization of histamine-containing neurons in the brain of the crested newt,Triturus carnifex

The distribution of immunoreactivity for histamine was studied in the brain of the urodele Triturus carnifex using the indirect immunofluorescence method. Histamine-immunoreactive cell bodies were localized in the caudal hypothalamus within the dorsolateral walls of the infundibular recesses. These immunoreactive cell bodies were pear-shaped, bipolar and frequently of the cerebrospinal-fluid-contacting type. Histaminergic nerve fibers were detected in almost all parts of the brain. Dense innervation was seen in the telencephalic medial pallium and ventral striatum, the neuropil of the preoptic area, the septum, the paraventricular organ, the posterior commissure, the caudal hypothalamus, the ventral and lateral mesencephalic tegmentum. Medium density innervation was observed in the lateral mesencephalic tegmentum and optic tectum. Poor innervation was present in the telencephalic dorsal pallium and in the central gray of the medulla oblongata. Few fibers occurred in the olfactory bulbs and in the telencephalic lateral pallium. Double immunofluorescence staining, using an antibody against tyrosine hydroxylase, showed that histamine-immunostained somata and those containing tyrosine-hydroxylase-like immunoreactivity were co-distributed in the tuberal hypothalamus. No co-occurrence of histamine-like and tyrosine hydroxylase-like immunostaining was seen in the same neuron. The pattern of histamine-immunoreactive neurons in the newt was similar to that described in other vertebrates. Our observations, carried out on the apparently simplified brain of the newt confirm that the basic histaminergic system is well conserved throughout vertebrates.