A new mutant of bovine seminal ribonuclease with a reversed swapping propensity

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is made up of two identical subunits bridged through two disulfide bonds. In solution, it exists as a 2:1 equilibrium mixture between two forms, with (MxM) and without swapping (M=M) of the N-terminal arms. The swapping endows BS-RNase with some special biological functions, including antitumor activity, since MxM retains a dimeric structure even under reducing conditions, thus evading the cytosolic ribonuclease inhibitor. To investigate the structural basis of domain swapping in BS-RNase, we have obtained several mutants by replacing selected residues with the corresponding ones of its monomeric counterpart, bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A). We have already shown that, in contrast with all other cases of swapped proteins, the swapping propensity of BS-RNase does not depend on the specific sequence of the 16-22 hinge loop, which connects the main body to the dislocating arm. In this paper we report the design, the expression, and the structural characterization of two mutants obtained by replacing Arg80 with Ser either in BS-RNase or in the mutant already containing the 16-22 hinge sequence of RNase A. NMR and circular dichroism data indicate that, in the monomeric form of the latter mutant, Ser80 acts as a switch for the conformation of the hinge region. Accordingly, in the dimeric form of the same mutant the MxM:M=M equilibrium ratio is inverted to 1:2. Overall, these data suggest that the presence of Arg80 triggers the swapping of N-terminal ends and plays a relevant role in the stability of the swapped form of BS-RNase.     

NMR studies on structure and dynamics of the monomeric derivative of BS-RNase: new insights for 3D domain swapping

Three-dimensional domain swapping is a common phenomenon in pancreatic-like ribonucleases. In the aggregated state, these proteins acquire new biological functions, including selective cytotoxicity against tumour cells. RNase A is able to dislocate both N- and C-termini, but usually this process requires denaturing conditions. In contrast, bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase), which is a homo-dimeric protein sharing 80% of sequence identity with RNase A, occurs natively as a mixture of swapped and unswapped isoforms. The presence of two disulfides bridging the subunits, indeed, ensures a dimeric structure also to the unswapped molecule. In vitro, the two BS-RNase isoforms interconvert under physiological conditions. Since the tendency to swap is often related to the instability of the monomeric proteins, in these paper we have analysed in detail the stability in solution of the monomeric derivative of BS-RNase (mBS) by a combination of NMR studies and Molecular Dynamics Simulations. The refinement of NMR structure and relaxation data indicate a close similarity with RNase A, without any evidence of aggregation or partial opening. The high compactness of mBS structure is confirmed also by H/D exchange, urea denaturation, and TEMPOL mapping of the protein surface. The present extensive structural and dynamic investigation of (monomeric) mBS did not show any experimental evidence that could explain the known differences in swapping between BS-RNase and RNase A. Hence, we conclude that the swapping in BS-RNase must be influenced by the distinct features of the dimers, suggesting a prominent role for the interchain disulfide bridges.     

Role of the hinge peptide and the intersubunit interface in the swapping of N-termini in dimeric bovine seminal RNase.

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is the only known dimeric enzyme characterized by an equilibrium between two different 3D structures: MxM, with exchange (or swapping) of the N-terminal 1-20 residues, and M=M, without exchange. As a consequence, the hinge region 16-22 has a different tertiary structure in the two forms. In the native protein, the equilibrium ratio between MxM and M=M is about 7 : 3. Kinetic analysis of the swapping process for a recombinant sample shows that it folds mainly in the M=M form, then undergoes interconversion into the MxM form, reaching the same 7 : 3 equilibrium ratio. To investigate the role of the regions that are most affected structurally by the swapping, we expressed variant proteins by replacing two crucial residues with the corresponding ones from RNase A: Pro19, within the hinge peptide, and Leu28, located at the interface between subunits. We compared the structural properties of the monomeric forms of P19A-BS-RNase, L28Q-BS-RNase and P19A/L28Q-BS-RNase variants with those of the parent protein, and investigated the exchange kinetics of the corresponding dimers. The P19A mutation slightly increases the thermal stability of the monomer, but it does not alter the swapping tendency of the dimer. In contrast, the L28Q mutation significantly affects both the dimerization and swapping processes but not the thermal stability of the monomer. Overall, these results suggest that the structural determinants that control the exchange of N-terminal arms in BS-RNase may not be located within the hinge peptide, and point to a crucial role of the interface residues.     

Natural and chemically induced oligomeric ribonucleases: structural study by immobilized metal ion affinity electrophoresis and their functional relationship

Oligomerization can endow proteins with novel structural and catalytic properties. The native dimer of bovine seminal ribonucleases (BS-RNase) binds, melts and catalyses the hydrolysis of double-stranded ribonucleic acids 30-fold better than its pancreatic homologue, the monomeric RNase A. Chemically induced oligomers of pancreatic RNase A are also found to show an increase in enzyme activity on double-stranded poly(A).poly(U) (Libonati, M. Bertoldi, M. and Sorrentino, S. (1996) Biochem. J. 318, 287-290) and, therefore, can be considered as potential immunosuppressive and cytotoxic agents. We report here a study on the relationship between surface histidine topography in oligomeric forms of these ribonucleases and their catalytic properties. Subtle changes in structure conformation of both BS-RNase and oligomeric RNase A are shown to result in a modification of the affinity of these proteins toward the immobilized transition-metal chelate, IDA-Cu(II). Because, such conformational change has been shown to correlate with an improvement of the newly acquired biological activities upon oligomerization, we can conclude that surface histidines topography constitutes an exquisite probe for the study of protein structure/function relationship.     

Circular dichroism study of ribonuclease A mutants containing the minimal structural requirements for dimerization and swapping

Four residues Pro19, Leu28, Cys31 and Cys32 proved to be the minimal structural requirements in determining the dimeric structure and the N-terminal segment swapping of bovine seminal ribonuclease, BS-RNase. We analyzed the content of secondary and tertiary structures in RNase A, P-RNase A, PL-RNase A, MCAM-PLCC-RNase A and MCAM-BS-RNase, performing near and far-UV CD spectra. It results that the five proteins have very similar native conformations. Thermal denaturation at pH 5.0 of the proteins, studied by means of CD measurements, proved reversible and well represented by the two-state ND transition model. Thermodynamic data are discussed in the light of the structural information available for RNase A and BS-RNase.     

Thermodynamic stability of the two isoforms of bovine seminal ribonuclease

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is a dimeric protein with two identical subunits linked by two disulfide bridges, each subunit showing 80% of sequence identity with pancreatic RNase A. BS-RNase exists in two different quaternary conformations in solution: the MxM form, in which each subunit exchanges its alpha-helical N-terminal segment with its partner, and the M=M form with no exchange. By differential scanning microcalorimetry (DSC), the denaturation of the two dimeric forms of BS-RNase was found to be more complex than a simple two-state process. Monomeric derivatives of the dimeric protein follow instead a simple two-state mechanism, but are distinctly less stable than RNase A. The three-state N if I if D denaturation process of the two quaternary isoforms was interpreted by identifying in the dimers a central highly structured core, enclosing the covalently bonded subunit interface, which unfolds only after the periphery (mainly the N-terminal peptide) unfolds. Circular dichroism spectra of the two forms in the far-ultraviolet region show large differences between the secondary structure of the isoforms and that of the native BS-RNase mixture at equilibrium. This has been attributed to the presence in the equilibrium mixture of intermediate forms with displaced and disordered N-terminal alpha-helical segments.     

The multiple forms of bovine seminal ribonuclease: Structure and stability of a C-terminal swapped dimer

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) acquires an interesting anti-tumor activity associated with the swapping on the N-terminal. The first direct experimental evidence on the formation of a C-terminal swapped dimer (C-dimer) obtained from the monomeric derivative of BS-RNase, although under non-native conditions, is here reported. The X-ray model of this dimer reveals a quaternary structure different from that of the C-dimer of RNase A, due to the presence of three mutations in the hinge peptide 111–116. The mutations increase the hinge peptide flexibility and decrease the stability of the C-dimer against dissociation. The biological implications of the structural data are also discussed.     

Double Domain Swapping in Bovine Seminal RNase: Formation of Distinct N- and C-swapped Tetramers and Multimers with Increasing Biological Activities

Bovine seminal (BS) RNase, the unique natively dimeric member of the RNase super-family, represents a special case not only for its additional biological actions but also for the singular features of 3D domain swapping. The native enzyme is indeed a mixture of two isoforms: M = M, a dimer held together by two inter-subunit disulfide bonds, and MxM, 70% of the total, which, besides the two mentioned disulfides, is additionally stabilized by the swapping of its N-termini.When lyophilized from 40% acetic acid, BS-RNase oligomerizes as the super-family proto-type RNase A does. In this paper, we induced BS-RNase self-association and analyzed the multimers by size-exclusion chromatography, cross-linking, electrophoresis, mutagenesis, dynamic light scattering, molecular modelling. Finally, we evaluated their enzymatic and cytotoxic activities.Several BS-RNase domain-swapped oligomers were detected, including two tetramers, one exchanging only the N-termini, the other being either N- or C-swapped. The C-swapping event, confirmed by results on a BS-K113N mutant, has been firstly seen in BS-RNase here, and probably stabilizes also multimers larger than tetramers.Interestingly, all BS-RNase oligomers are more enzymatically active than the native dimer and, above all, they display a cytotoxic activity that definitely increases with the molecular weight of the multimers. This latter feature, to date unknown for BS-RNase, suggests again that the self-association of RNases strongly modulates their biological and potentially therapeutic properties.     

Relationships between nonhyperbolic kinetics and dimeric structure in ribonucleases

Dimers of bovine pancreatic RNase A give nonhyperbolic saturation curves for the substrate of the second, rate-limiting step of the reaction. Under the same conditions, the monomeric native enzyme shows Michaelis-Menten kinetics. Naturally dimeric bovine seminal RNase, which has been found to give nonhyperbolic saturation curves, loses this property upon monomerization. It is proposed that when RNase monomers are arranged in a quaternary structure, they assume a conformation which enables them to be modulated in their catalytic activities. A correlation is suggested between this effect and the quaternary structure proposed for both of these dimeric ribonucleases, in which composite active sites are generated by the mutual exchange of the NH2-terminal ends of the two monomers.     

Engineering the refolding pathway and the quaternary structure of seminal ribonuclease by newly introduced disulfide bridges

Seminal RNase (BS-RNase), a ribonuclease from bovine seminal vesicles, is a homodimeric enzyme with a strong cytotoxic activity selective for tumor cells. It displays the unusual structural feature of existing in solution as an equilibrium mixture of two quaternary isoforms. The major one is characterized by the swap between subunits of their N-terminal ends, whereas the minor isoform shows no swap. The tendency of the two isolated isoforms to interconvert into each other has so far made it difficult to attribute the functional properties of BS-RNase to either isoform. Herein, molecular modeling and site-directed mutagenesis were used to engineer the refolding pathway of BS-RNase and obtain a stable variant of its non-swapping isoform. The protein was engineered with two extra disulfide bridges linking the N-terminal helix of each subunit to the main body of the same subunit. Purified as an active enzyme, the BS-RNase variant was found to be very resistant to thermal denaturation. Its functional characterization revealed that the lack of swapping has a negative effect on the cytotoxic activity of BS-RNase.     

Structural and functional relationships of natural and artificial dimeric bovine ribonucleases: New scaffolds for potential antitumor drugs

Protein aggregation via 3D domain swapping is a complex mechanism which can lead to the acquisition of new biological, benign or also malignant functions, such as amyloid deposits. In this context, RNase A represents a fascinating model system, since by dislocating different polypeptide chain regions, it forms many diverse oligomers. No other protein displays such a large number of different quaternary structures. Here we report a comparative structural analysis between natural and artificial RNase A dimers and bovine seminal ribonuclease, a natively dimeric RNase with antitumor activity, with the aim to design RNase A derivatives with improved pharmacological potential.     

Evolution of oligomeric proteins. The unusual case of a dimeric ribonuclease.

The model system made up of a monomeric and a dimeric ribonuclease of the pancreatic-type superfamily has recently attracted the attention of investigators interested in the evolution of oligomeric proteins. In this system, bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) is the monomeric prototype, and bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is the dimeric counterpart. However, this evolutionary case is unusual, as BS-RNase is the only dimeric member of the whole large superfamily comprising more than 100 identified members from amphibia, aves, reptilia and mammalia. Furthermore, although the seminal-type RNase gene can be traced back to the divergence of the ruminants, it is expressed only in a single species (Bos taurus). These unusual findings are discussed, as well as previous hypotheses on the evolution of seminal RNase. Furthermore, a new 'minimalist' hypothesis is proposed, in line with basic principles of structural biology and molecular evolution.     

The role of the hinge loop in domain swapping. The special case of bovine seminal ribonuclease

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is a covalent homodimeric enzyme homologous to pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A), endowed with a number of special biological functions. It is isolated as an equilibrium mixture of swapped (MxM) and unswapped (M=M) dimers. The interchanged N termini are hinged on the main bodies through the peptide 16-22, which changes conformation in the two isomers. At variance with other proteins, domain swapping in BS-RNase involves two dimers having a similar and highly constrained quaternary association, mainly dictated by two interchain disulfide bonds. This provides the opportunity to study the intrinsic ability to swap as a function of the hinge sequence, without additional effects arising from dissociation or quaternary structure modifications. Two variants, having Pro19 or the whole sequence of the hinge replaced by the corresponding residues of RNase A, show equilibrium and kinetic parameters of the swapping similar to those of the parent protein. In comparison, the x-ray structures of MxM indicate, within a substantial constancy of the quaternary association, a greater mobility of the hinge residues. The relative insensitivity of the swapping tendency to the substitutions in the hinge region, and in particular to the replacement of Pro19 by Ala, contrasts with the results obtained for other swapped proteins and can be rationalized in terms of the unique features of the seminal enzyme. Moreover, the results indirectly lend credit to the hypothesis that the major role of Pro19 resides in directing the assembly of the non-covalent dimer, the species produced by selective reduction of the interchain disulfides and considered responsible for the special biological functions of BS-RNase.     

Binding of a substrate analog to a domain swapping protein: X-ray structure of the complex of bovine seminal ribonuclease with uridylyl(2',5')adenosine

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is a unique member of the pancreatic-like ribonuclease superfamily. The native enzyme is a mixture of two dimeric forms with distinct structural features. The most abundant form is characterized by the swapping of N-terminal fragments. In this paper, the crystal structure of the complex between the swapping dimer and uridylyl(2',5')adenosine is reported at 2.06 A resolution. The refined model has a crystallographic R-factor of 0.184 and good stereochemistry. The quality of the electron density maps enables the structure of both the inhibitor and active site residues to be unambiguously determined. The overall architecture of the active site is similar to that of RNase A. The dinucleotide adopts an extended conformation with the pyrimidine and purine base interacting with Thr45 and Asn71, respectively. Several residues (Gln11, His12, Lys41, His119, and Phe120) bind the oxygens of the phosphate group. The structural similarity of the active sites of BS-RNase and RNase A includes some specific water molecules believed to be relevant to catalytic activity. Upon binding of the dinucleotide, small but significant modifications of the tertiary and quaternary structure of the protein are observed. The ensuing correlation of these modifications with the catalytic activity of the enzyme is discussed.     

Cytotoxicity of bovine seminal ribonuclease: monomer versus dimer

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is a homologue of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A). Unlike RNase A, BS-RNase has notable toxicity for human tumor cells. Wild-type BS-RNase is a homodimer linked by two intermolecular disulfide bonds. This quaternary structure endows BS-RNase with resistance to inhibition by the cytosolic ribonuclease inhibitor protein (RI), which binds tightly to RNase A and monomeric BS-RNase. Here, we report on the creation and analysis of monomeric variants of BS-RNase that evade RI but retain full enzymatic activity. The cytotoxic activity of these monomeric variants exceeds that of the wild-type dimer by up to 30-fold, indicating that the dimeric structure of BS-RNase is not required for cytotoxicity. Dimers of these monomeric variants are more cytotoxic than wild-type BS-RNase, suggesting that the cytotoxicity of the wild-type enzyme is limited by RI inhibition following dissociation of the dimer in the reducing environment of the cytosol. Finally, the cytotoxic activity of these dimers is less than that of the constituent monomers, indicating that their quaternary structure is a liability. These data provide new insight into structure-function relationships of BS-RNase. Moreover, BS-RNase monomers described herein are more toxic to human tumor cells than is any known variant or homologue of RNase A including Onconase, an amphibian homologue in phase III clinical trials for the treatment of unresectable malignant mesothelioma.     

Chain termini cross-talk in the swapping process of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease

3D domain swapping is the process by which two or more protein molecules exchange part of their structure to form intertwined dimers or higher oligomers. Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease (RNase A) is able to swap the N-terminal α-helix (residues 1-13) and/or the C-terminal β-strand (residues 116-124), thus forming a variety of oligomers, including two different dimers. Cis-trans isomerization of the Asn113-Pro114 peptide group was observed when the protein formed the C-terminal swapped dimer. To study the effect of the substitution of Pro114 on the swapping process of RNase A, we have prepared and characterized the P114A monomeric and dimeric variants of the enzyme. In contrast with previous reports, the crystal structure and NMR data on the monomer reveals a mixed cis-trans conformation for the Asn113-Ala114 peptide group, whereas the X-ray structure of the C-terminal swapped dimer of the variant is very close to that of the corresponding dimer of RNase A. The mutation at the C-terminus affects the capability of the N-terminal α-helix to swap and the stability of both dimeric forms. The present results underscore the importance of the hydration shell in determining the cross-talk between the chain termini in the swapping process of RNase A.     

A role for the intersubunit disulfides of seminal RNase in the mechanism of its antitumor action.

The dimeric structure of seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is maintained by noncovalent interactions and by two intersubunit disulfide bridges. Another unusual feature of this enzyme is its antitumour action, consisting in a cytotoxic activity selective for malignant cells. This cytotoxic action is exerted when the protein reaches the cytosol of the affected cells, where it degrades ribosomal RNA, thus blocking protein synthesis and leading cells to death. The current model proposed for the mechanism of antitumour action of BS-RNase is based on the ability of the protein to resist the neutralizing action of the cytosolic RNase inhibitor, a resistance due to the dimeric structure of the enzyme. Monomeric RNases, and monomeric derivatives of BS-RNase, are strongly bound by the inhibitor and inactive as antitumor agents. Here we report on monomeric derivatives of BS-RNase that, although strongly inhibited by the cytosolic RNase inhibitor, are cytotoxic towards malignant cells. These monomers are produced by reductive cleavage of the intersubunit disulfides of the native, dimeric protein followed by linking the exposed sulfhydryls to small thiols through formation of mixed disulfides. We found that sulfhydryls from cell monolayers and cell membranes can attack these mixed disulfides in the monomeric derivatives, and reconstitute, through sulfhydryl-disulfide interchange reactions, the native dimeric protein, which is internalized as such, and displays its antitumour action.     

Structure-cytotoxicity relationships in bovine seminal ribonuclease: new insights from heat and chemical denaturation studies on variants

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase), a homodimeric protein displaying selective cytotoxicity towards tumor cells, is isolated as a mixture of two isoforms, a dimeric form in which the chains swap their N-termini, and an unswapped dimer. In the cytosolic reducing environment, the dimeric form in which the chains swap their N-termini is converted into a noncovalent dimer (termed NCD), in which the monomers remain intertwined through their N-terminal ends. The quaternary structure renders the reduced protein resistant to the ribonuclease inhibitor, a protein that binds most ribonucleases with very high affinity. On the other hand, upon selective reduction, the unswapped dimer is converted in two monomers, which are readily bound and inactivated by the ribonuclease inhibitor. On the basis of these considerations, it has been proposed that the cytotoxic activity of BS-RNase relies on the 3D structure and stability of its NCD derivative. Here, we report a comparison of the thermodynamic and chemical stability of the NCD form of BS-RNase with that of the monomeric derivative, together with an investigation of the thermal dissociation mechanism revealing the presence of a dimeric intermediate. In addition, we report that the replacement of of Arg80 by Ser significantly decreases the cytotoxic activity of BS-RNase and the stability of the NCD form with respect to the parent protein, but does not affect the ribonucleolytic activity or the dissociation mechanism. The data show the importance of Arg80 for the cytotoxicity of BS-RNase, and also support the hypothesis that the reduced derivative of BS-RNase is responsible for its cytotoxic activity.     

Propensity for C-terminal domain swapping correlates with increased regional flexibility in the C-terminus of RNase A

Domain swapping is a type of oligomerization in which monomeric proteins exchange a structural element, resulting in oligomers whose subunits recapitulate the native, monomeric fold. It has been implicated as a potential mechanism for protein aggregation, which provides a strong impetus to understand the structural determinants and folding mechanisms that trigger domain swapping. Bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNase A) is a well-studied protein known to domain swap under extreme conditions, such as lyophilization from acetic acid. The major domain-swapped dimer form of RNase A exchanges a β-strand at its C-terminus to form a C-terminal domain-swapped dimer. To study the mechanism by which C-terminal swapping occurs, we used a variant of RNase A containing a P114G mutation that readily domain swaps under physiological conditions. Using NMR and hydrogen-deuterium exchange, we find that the P114G variant has decreased protection from hydrogen exchange compared to the wild-type protein near the C-terminal hinge region. Our results suggest that domain swapping occurs via a local high-energy fluctuation at the C-terminus.     

Population shift vs induced fit: the case of bovine seminal ribonuclease swapping dimer

Bovine seminal ribonuclease (BS-RNase) is a unique member of the pancreatic-like ribonuclease superfamily. This enzyme exists as two conformational isomers with distinctive biological properties. The structure of the major isomer is characterized by the swapping of the N-terminal segment (MxM BS-RNase). In this article, the crystal structures of the ligand-free MxM BS-RNase and its complex with 2'-deoxycitidylyl(3',5')-2'-deoxyadenosine derived from isomorphous crystals have been refined. Interestingly, the comparison between this novel ligand-free form and the previously published sulfate-bound structure reveals significant differences. In particular, the ligand-free MxM BS-RNase is closer to the structure of MxM BS-RNase productive complexes than to the sulfate-bound form. These results reveal that MxM BS-RNase presents a remarkable flexibility, despite the structural constraints of the interchain disulfide bridges and the swapping of the N-terminal helices. These findings have important implications to the ligand binding mechanism of MxM BS-RNase. Indeed, a population shift rather than a substrate-induced conformational transition may occur in the MxM BS-RNase ligand binding process.