Sex and evolution in trypanosomes

Trypanosoma brucei is still the only kinetoplastid known to undergo genetic exchange, but it seems unreasonable to suppose that it evolved this process all by itself. The position of T. brucei on a molecular phylogenetic tree constructed from 18S ribosomal RNA gene sequences offers no clues to the likely existence of genetic exchange in trypanosome species other than the Salivaria, because this group of trypanosomes appears to have diverged from the rest a very long time ago. Antigenic variation is one characteristic shared by the Salivaria, which has been particularly well-studied in T. brucei. The large proportion of the genome devoted to variant antigen genes and related sequences in T. brucei, suggests a possible role for genetic exchange in enhancing the diversity of the repertoire. Alternatively, genetic exchange may counter potential excessive double-strand DNA damage brought about by the DNA rearrangements associated with antigenic variation. The remarkable biparental inheritance of organelle DNA (=kinetoplast DNA) in T. brucei is without precedent in other eukaryotes. The result of genetic exchange is to enhance the heterogeneity of the kinetoplast DNA minicircles.     

Genome research and evolution in trypanosomes

Trypanosoma brucei and Trypanosoma cruzi cause different human diseases. As strategies for immune evasion. T. brucei undergoes antigenic variation whereas T. cruzi becomes an intracellular organism. This fundamental difference is reflected by major differences in their genome organizations. Recent comparisons of their gene sequences indicate that these two trypanosome species are highly divergent evolutionarily.     

Avian trypanosomes as models of hemoflagellate evolution

In the 15 years since the last review on avian trypanosomes(1), there has been a steady accrual of information on the distribution and dynamics of trypanosome infections in wild bird populations. Recent immunological and biochemical studies provide evidence that several trypanosome species can parasitize an ecological guild of host species but the relative roles of avian host phylogeny and vector ecology remain unanswered. In this article, Victor Apanius reviews the habitat preferences and behavior of trypanosomes within the avian host and attempts to draw similarities in the strategy employed by the parasite for persistence in different vertebrate classes. Next, the question of host specificity is raised and recent evidence on the subject is examined with an eye toward understanding the distribution of trypanosome species in host communities.     

The surface structure of trypanosomes in relation to their molecular phylogeny

Molecular phylogenetic analysis using genes coding for ribosomal RNA and proteins suggests that trypanosomes are monophyletic. Salivarian trypanosomes showing antigenic variation of the variant surface glycoprotein (VSG) diverged from non-Salivarian trypanosomes some 200-300 million years ago. Representatives of the non-Salivarian group, the mammalian parasite, Trypanosoma cruzi, and the fresh-water fish trypanosome, T. carassii, are characterised by surfaces dominated by carbohydrate-rich mucin-like glycoproteins, which are not subject to antigenetic variation. It is suggested that this latter surface structure is typical for non-Salivarian trypanosomes as well as members of the other Kinetoplastid suborder, the Bodonina. This would imply that at some point in time in the evolution of the Salivaria the highly abundant and comparatively poorly immunogenetic mucin-like molecules must have been replaced for equally abundant but highly immunogenic VSG-like molecules. While the selective advantage for such a unique transition is difficult to imagine, the subsequent diversification of VSG genes/molecules may have been comparatively straightforward because even the most limited form of antigenic variation would have extended the duration of infection in the vertebrate and thus would have increased the chance for transfer to the vector.     

The role of population size in molecular evolution.

The results of a computer simulation study of the role of population size in population genetical models of molecular evolution are presented. If the mutation rate and strength of selection are held fixed and the population size increased, the eight models examined fall into three domains based on their rates of substitution. In the Ohta domain, the rate of substitution decreases with increasing population size; in the Kimura domain, the rate of substitution remains close to the mutation rate; in the Darwin domain, the rate of substitution increases without bound. In the Kimura and Darwin domains, the rate of substitution is much less sensitive to the population size than suggested by two-allele theories. Remarkably, the overdominance model converges to the neutral model with increasing N. The variation at a neutral locus linked to a selected locus is found to be insensitive to the population size for certain models of selection. A selected locus can actually cause the rate of substitution of deleterious alleles at a linked locus to increase with increasing population size. These unexpected results illustrate that intuition based on two-allele theory is often misleading.     

The future of molecular evolution

Antony Dean explores the past, present and future of evolutionary theory and our continuing efforts to explain biological patterns in terms of molecular processes and mechanisms.There are just two questions to be asked in evolution: how are things related, and what makes them differ? Lamarck was the first biologist—he invented the word—to address both. In his Philosophie Zoologique (1809) he suggested that the relationships among species are better described by branching trees than by a simple ladder, that new species arise gradually by descent with modification and that they adapt to changing environments through the inheritance of acquired characteristics. Much that Lamarck imagined has since been superseded. Following Wallace and Darwin, we now envision that species belong to a single highly branched tree and that natural selection is the mechanism of adaptation. Nonetheless, to Lamarck we owe the insight that pattern is produced by process and that both need mechanistic explanation.Questions of pattern, process and mechanism pervade the modern discipline of molecular evolution. The field was established when Zuckerkandl & Pauling (1965) noted that haemoglobins evolve at a roughly constant rate. Their “molecular evolutionary clock” forever changed our view of evolutionary history. Not only were seemingly intractable relationships resolved—for example, whales are allies of the hippopotamus—but also the eubacterial origins of eukaryotic organelles were firmly established and a new domain of life was discovered: the Archaea.Yet, different genes sometimes produce different trees. Golding & Gupta (1995) resolved two-dozen conflicting protein trees by suggesting that Eukarya arose following massive horizontal gene transfer between Bacteria and Archaea. Whole genome sequencing has since revealed so many conflicts that horizontal gene transfer seems characteristic of prokaryote evolution. In higher animals—where horizontal transfer is sufficiently rare that the tree metaphor remains robust—rapid and inexpensive whole genome sequencing promises to provide a wealth of data for population studies. The patterns of migration, admixture and divergence of species will be soon addressed in unprecedented detail.Sequence analyses are also used to infer processes. A constant molecular clock originally buttressed the neutral theory of molecular evolution (Kimura, 1985). The clock has since proven erratic, while the neutral theory now serves as a null hypothesis for statistical tests of ‘selection''. In truth, most tests are also sensitive to demographic changes. The promise of ultra-high throughput sequencing to provide genome-wide data should help dissect selection, which targets particular genes, from demography, which affects all the genes in a genome, although weak selection and ancient adaptations will remain undetected.In the functional synthesis (Dean & Thornton, 2007), molecular biology provides the experimental means to test evolutionary inferences decisively. For example, site-directed mutagenesis can be used to introduce putatively selected mutations into reconstructed ancestral sequences, the gene products are then expressed and purified and their functional properties determined in vitro. In microbial species, homologous recombination is used routinely to replace wild-type with engineered genes, enabling organismal phenotypes and fitnesses to be determined in vivo. The vision of Zuckerkandl & Pauling (1965) that by “furnishing probable structures of ancestral proteins, chemical paleogenetics will in the future lead to deductions concerning molecular functions as they were presumably carried out in the distant evolutionary past” is now a reality.If experimental tests of evolutionary inferences open windows on past mechanisms, directed evolution focuses on the mechanisms without attempting historical reconstruction. Today''s ‘fast-forward'' molecular breeding experiments use mutagenic PCR to generate vast libraries of variation and high throughput screens to identify rare novel mutants (Romero & Arnold, 2009; Khersonsky & Tawfik, 2010). Among numerous topics explored are: the role of intragenic recombination in furthering adaptation, the number and location of mutations in protein structures, the necessity—or lack thereof—of broadening substrate specificity before a new function is acquired, the evolution of robustness, and the alleged trade-off between stability and catalytic efficiency. Few, however, have approached the detail found in those classic studies of evolved β-galactosidase (Hall, 2003) that revealed how the free-energy profile of an enzyme-catalysed reaction evolved. Even further removed from natural systems are catalytic RNAs that, by combining phenotype and genotype within the same molecule, allow evolution to proceed in a lifeless series of chemical reactions. Recently, two RNA enzymes that catalyse each other''s synthesis were shown to undergo self-sustained exponential amplification (Lincoln & Joyce, 2009). Competition for limiting tetranucleotide resources favours mutants with higher relative fitness—faster replication—demonstrating that adaptive evolution can occur in a chemically defined abiotic genetic system.Lamarck was the first to attempt a coherent explanation of biological patterns in terms of processes and mechanisms. That his legacy can still be discerned in the vibrant field of molecular evolution would no doubt please him as much as it does us in promising extraordinary advances in our understanding of the mechanistic basis of molecular adaptation.     

The molecular evolution of development

Morphological differences between species, from simple single-character differences to large-scale variation in body plans, can be traced to changes in the timing and location of developmental events. This has led to a growing interest in understanding the genetic basis behind the evolution of developmental systems. Molecular evolutionary genetics provides one of several approaches to dissecting the evolution of developmental systems, by allowing us to reconstruct the history of developmental genetic pathways, infer the origin and diversification of developmental gene functions, and assess the relative contributions of various evolutionary forces in shaping regulatory gene evolution. BioEssays 20 :700–711, 1998. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

The molecular taxonomy and evolution of the guinea pig.

On the basis of 18 protein sequences totaling 2,413 aligned amino acid sites, it is suggested that the guinea pigs and the myomorphs (rat-like rodents) are not monophyletic. Rather, the evolutionary lineage leading to the guinea pig seems to have branched off prior to the divergence among myomorphs, lagomorphs, primates, chiropterans, artiodactyls, and carnivores. It is suggested therefore that the Caviomorpha (guinea pig-like rodents) and possibly the Hystricomorpha (porcupine-like rodents) should be elevated in taxonomic rank and conferred an ordinal status distinct from the Rodentia. This suggestion calls for a reevaluation of the morphological evolution of guinea pigs and further molecular studies on the possibility of paraphyly of the order Rodentia. If the monophyly of rodents holds, it must be concluded that the pattern of molecular evolution in many guinea pig genes has been extremely unusual and that the causes for this pattern should be sought. It is also suggested that claims of large differences in the rate of molecular evolution between guinea pigs and myomorphs may have been exaggerated in many cases as a result of an erroneous phylogenetic position for the guinea pig. The average rate of amino acid replacement in the guinea pig seems to be comparable to that in the rat and the mouse. However, the data indicate that myomorph and caviomorph genes evolve, on average, about two times faster than their human counterparts. Finally, our analysis provides evidence against the hypothesis that the gundi (an African rodent) represents the most ancient rodent lineage.     

The Cytoskeleton of trypanosomes

From the concept of cells as mere bags full of enzymes, cell biology has come a long way towards understanding the highly complex structural organization of eukaryotic cells. The cytoskeleton, ie. the complex of fibrous elements that are crucial for cell shape, motility and the structural organization of cytoplasm and cell membranes, is now recognized as vital for supporting many critical functions in eukaryotic cells. Surprisingly, this subject, which has provided scores of cell biologists with excitement and fascination, has been largely overlooked with respect to parasitic protozoa. A notable change of perception has taken place over the past few years as the cytoskeleton of parasitic protozoa has been increasingly recognized as a potential target for antiparasitic intervention. The following article by Thomas Seebeck, Andrew Hemphill and Durward Lawson highlights some recent developments in the analysis of what is presently the best-studied parasite cytoskeleton, that of the trypanosome.     

The ecotopes and evolution of triatomine bugs (triatominae) and their associated trypanosomes

Triatomine bug species such as Microtriatoma trinidadensis, Eratyrus mucronatus, Belminus herreri, Panstrongylus lignarius, and Triatoma tibiamaculata are exquisitely adapted to specialist niches. This suggests a long evolutionary history, as well as the recent dramatic spread a few eclectic, domiciliated triatomine species. Virtually all species of the genus Rhodnius are primarily associated with palms. The genus Panstrongylus is predominantly associated with burrows and tree cavities and the genus Triatoma with terrestrial rocky habitats or rodent burrows. Two major sub-divisions have been defined within the species Trypanosoma cruzi, as T. cruzi 1 (Z1) and T. cruzi 2 (Z2). The affinities of a third group (Z3) are uncertain. Host and habitat associations lead us to propose that T. cruzi 1 (Z1) has evolved in an arboreal, palm tree habitat with the triatomine tribe Rhodniini, in association with the opossum Didelphis. Similarly we propose that T. cruzi (Z2) and Z3 evolved in a terrestrial habitat in burrows and in rocky locations with the triatomine tribe Triatomini, in association with edentates, and/or possibly ground dwelling marsupials. Both sub-divisions of T. cruzi may have been contemporary in South America up to 65 million years ago. Alternatively, T. cruzi 2 (Z2) may have evolved more recently from T. cruzi 1 (Z1) by host transfers into rodents, edentates, and primates. We have constructed a molecular phylogeny of haematophagous vectors, including triatomine bugs, which suggests that faecal transmission of trypanosomes may be the ancestral route. A molecular clock phylogeny suggests that Rhodnius and Triatoma diverged before the arrival, about 40 million years ago, of bats and rodents into South America.     

The chemical kinetics of molecular evolution

This article describes a current view of the events that initiated the transition from the rich organic and inorganic chemistry of the primitive Earth to the earliest forms of life. It is a personal condensation of the basic ideas developed in the so-called G?ttingen school. Most of these will be found in the seminal paper of Eigen and the other sources cited. A detailed exposition is given by Küppers.     

The molecular evolution of signal peptides

Signal peptides direct mature peptides to their appropriate cellular location, after which they are cleaved off. Very many random alternatives can serve the same function. Of all coding sequences, therefore, signal peptides might come closest to being neutrally evolving. Here we consider this issue by examining the molecular evolution of 76 mouse-rat orthologues, each with defined signal peptides. Although they do evolve rapidly, they evolve about half as fast as neutral sequences. This indicates that a substantial proportion of mutations must be under stabilizing selection. A few putative signal sequences lack a hydrophobic core and these tend to be more slowly evolving than others, indicating even stronger stabilizing selection. However, closer scrutiny suggests that some of these represent mis-annotations in GenBank. It is also likely that some of the substitutions are not neutral. We find, for example, that the rate of protein evolution correlates with that of the mature peptide. This may be a result of compensatory evolution. We also find that signal peptides of immune genes tend to be faster evolving than the average, which suggests an association with antagonistic co-evolution. Previous reports also indicated that the signal peptide of the imprinted gene, Igf2r, is also unusually fast evolving. This, it was hypothesized, might also be indicative of antagonistic co-evolution. Comparison of Igf2r's signal peptide evolution shows that, although it is not an outlier, its rate of evolution is comparable to that of many of the faster evolving immune system signal sequences and 5/6 of the amino acid changes do not conserve hydrophobicity. This is at least suggestive that there is something unusual about Igf2r's signal sequence.     

The molecular evolution of pancreatic ribonuclease

Summary The primary structures of pancreatic ribonucleases from 26 species (18 artiodactyls, horse, whale, 5 rodents and turtle) are known. Several species contain identical ribonucleases (cow/bison; sheep/goat), other species show polymorphism (arabian camel) or the presence of two structural gene loci (guinea pig pancreas contains two ribonucleases that differ at 31 positions). 26 different sequences (including the ribonuclease from bovine seminal plasma which is paralogous to the pancreatic ribonucleases) were used to construct a most parsimonious tree. A second tree that most closely approximates current biological opinion requires 402 whereas the most parsimonious tree requires 389 nucleotide substitutions. The artiodactyl part of the most parsimonious tree conforms quite well with the biological one of this order, except for the position of the giraffe which is placed with the pronghorn. Other parts of the most parsimonious tree agree less with the biological tree, probably as a result of the occurrence of many parallel and back substitutions. Bovine seminal ribonuclease was found to be the result of a gene duplication which occurred before the divergence of the true ruminants, but after the divergence of this group from the cameloids.The evolutionary rate of ribonuclease was found to be 390, 3.0 and 11 nucleotide substitutions per 10⁹ yrs per ribonuclease gene, codon and covarion respectively. However, there is much variation in evolutionary rate in different taxa. Values ranging from about 100 (in the bovidae) to about 700 (in the rodents) nucleotide substitutions per 10⁹ yrs per gene were found.A method for counting parallel and back mutations is presented. The 389 nucleotide substitutions in the most parsimonious tree occur at 88 codon positions; 154 of them are the result of parallel and back mutations. Parallel evolution to a similar structure, including the presence of 2 sites with carbohydrate, was demonstrated in an extensive region at the surface of pig and guinea pig ribonuclease B. The presence of carbohydrate probably is important in a number of species. A correlation between the presence of heavily glycosidated ribonucleases and coecal digestion was observed. Hypothetical sequences of ancestral ungulate ribonucleases contain many recognition sites for carbohydrate attachment; this suggests that herbivores with coecal digestion might have preceded the true ruminants in mammalian evolution.     

The molecular evolution of sperm zonadhesin

Based on pioneering work of Hardy and Garbers, zonadhesin has become one of the best studied sperm ligands in boreoeutherian mammals, both from a biochemical and evolutionary perspective. Zonadhesin is a mosaic-type protein that localizes to the apical head of spermatozoa. In pig, cattle, rabbit and primates, zonadhesin precursor essentially consists of two or three MAM (meprin/A5 antigen/mu receptor tyrosine phosphatase) domains, one mucin-like domain, one incomplete and four complete D domains (homologous to vWFD). Mouse zonadhesin is distinguished from this general pattern by 20 extra partial D3 domains. While concerted evolution drives the divergence of the mucin-like domain in the ortholog comparison, MAM and D domains mainly diverge under the influence of drift and positive selection, both in the paralog and ortholog comparison. As can be seen particularly well within a putative binding region in the most C-terminal MAM domain, positive selection not only causes amino acid exchanges, but also promotes changes in the pattern of predicted posttranslational modification. Moving window and correlation analyses of sequence evolution and sexual body dimorphism further suggest that sexual selection, especially sperm competition, drives zonadhesin divergence. However, considering its zona pellucida avidity, female cryptic choice might as well contribute to zonadhesin evolution. Despite the general tendency for divergence of zonadhesin, conservation by negative selection dominates the evolution of most codon sites. In accordance, the distribution of EGF (epidermal growth factor)-like motifs, DP-doublets, single cysteines and CGLC motifs suggests a wide conservation of processing, folding and oligomerization of zonadhesin in pig, rabbit and primates.     

A molecular mechanism for eflornithine resistance in African trypanosomes

Human African trypanosomiasis, endemic to sub-Saharan Africa, is invariably fatal if untreated. Its causative agent is the protozoan parasite Trypanosoma brucei. Eflornithine is used as a first line treatment for human African trypanosomiasis, but there is a risk that resistance could thwart its use, even when used in combination therapy with nifurtimox. Eflornithine resistant trypanosomes were selected in vitro and subjected to biochemical and genetic analysis. The resistance phenotype was verified in vivo. Here we report the molecular basis of resistance. While the drug's target, ornithine decarboxylase, was unaltered in resistant cells and changes to levels of metabolites in the targeted polyamine pathway were not apparent, the accumulation of eflornithine was shown to be diminished in resistant lines. An amino acid transporter gene, TbAAT6 (Tb927.8.5450), was found to be deleted in two lines independently selected for resistance. Ablating expression of this gene in wildtype cells using RNA interference led to acquisition of resistance while expression of an ectopic copy of the gene introduced into the resistant deletion lines restored sensitivity, confirming the role of TbAAT6 in eflornithine action. Eflornithine resistance is easy to select through loss of a putative amino acid transporter, TbAAT6. The loss of this transporter will be easily identified in the field using a simple PCR test, enabling more appropriate chemotherapy to be administered.