Empirical solvation models in the context of conformational energy searches: application to bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor.

Continuum solvation models that estimate free energies of solvation as a function of solvent accessible surface area are computationally simple enough to be useful for predicting protein conformation. The behavior of three such solvation models has been examined by applying them to the minimization of the conformational energy of bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor. The models differ only with regard to how the constants of proportionality between free energy and surface area were derived. Each model was derived by fitting to experimentally measured equilibrium solution properties. For two models, the solution property was free energy of hydration. For the third, the property was NMR coupling constants. The purpose of this study is to determine the effect of applying these solvation models to the nonequilibrium conformations of a protein arising in the course of global searches for conformational energy minima. Two approaches were used: (1) local energy minimization of an ensemble of conformations similar to the equilibrium conformation and (2) global search trajectories using Monte Carlo plus minimization starting from a single conformation similar to the equilibrium conformation. For the two models derived from free energy measurements, it was found that both the global searches and local minimizations yielded conformations more similar to the X-ray crystallographic structures than did searches or local minimizations carried out in the absence of a solvation component of the conformational energy. The model derived from NMR coupling constants behaved similarly to the other models in the context of a global search trajectory. For one of the models derived from measured free energies of hydration, it was found that minimization of an ensemble of near-equilibrium conformations yielded a new ensemble in which the conformation most similar to the X-ray determined structure PTI4 had the lowest total free energy. Despite the simplicity of the continuum solvation models, the final conformation generated in the trajectories for each of the models exhibited some of the characteristics that have been reported for conformations obtained from molecular dynamics simulations in the presence of a bath of explicit water molecules. They have smaller root mean square (rms) deviations from the experimentally determined conformation, fewer incorrect hydrogen bonds, and slightly larger radii of gyration than do conformations derived from search trajectories carried out in the absence of solvent.     

Feature space resampling for protein conformational search

De novo protein structure prediction requires location of the lowest energy state of the polypeptide chain among a vast set of possible conformations. Powerful approaches include conformational space annealing, in which search progressively focuses on the most promising regions of conformational space, and genetic algorithms, in which features of the best conformations thus far identified are recombined. We describe a new approach that combines the strengths of these two approaches. Protein conformations are projected onto a discrete feature space which includes backbone torsion angles, secondary structure, and beta pairings. For each of these there is one “native” value: the one found in the native structure. We begin with a large number of conformations generated in independent Monte Carlo structure prediction trajectories from Rosetta. Native values for each feature are predicted from the frequencies of feature value occurrences and the energy distribution in conformations containing them. A second round of structure prediction trajectories are then guided by the predicted native feature distributions. We show that native features can be predicted at much higher than background rates, and that using the predicted feature distributions improves structure prediction in a benchmark of 28 proteins. The advantages of our approach are that features from many different input structures can be combined simultaneously without producing atomic clashes or otherwise physically inviable models, and that the features being recombined have a relatively high chance of being correct. Proteins 2010. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Role of unfolded state heterogeneity and en-route ruggedness in protein folding kinetics

In order to improve our understanding of the physical bases of protein folding, there is a compelling need for better connections between experimental and computational approaches. This work addresses the role of unfolded state conformational heterogeneity and en-route intermediates, as an aid for planning and interpreting protein folding experiments. The expected kinetics were modeled for different types of energy landscapes, including multiple parallel folding routes, preferential paths dominated by one primary folding route, and distributed paths with a wide spectrum of microscopic folding rate constants. In the presence of one or more preferential routes, conformational exchange among unfolded state populations slows down the observed rates for native protein formation. We find this to be a general phenomenon, taking place even when unfolded conformations interconvert much faster than the "escape" rate constants to folding. Dramatic kinetic deceleration is expected in the presence of an increasing number of folding-incompetent unfolded conformations. This argues for the existence of parallel folding paths involving several folding-competent unfolded conformations, during the early stages of protein folding. Deviations from single-exponential behavior are observed for unfolded conformations exchanging at comparable rates or more slowly than folding events. Analysis of the effect of en-route (on-path) intermediate formation and landscape ruggedness on folding kinetics leads to the following unexpected conclusions: (1) intermediates, which often retard native state formation, may in some cases accelerate folding, and (2) rugged landscapes, usually associated with stretched exponentials, display single-exponential behavior in the presence of late high-friction paths.     

Energy landscape and dynamics of the beta-hairpin G peptide and its isomers: Topology and sequences

We have investigated free energy landscape [MM/PBSA + normal modes entropy] of permutations in the G peptide (41-56) from the protein G B1 domain by studying six isomers corresponding to moving the hydrophobic cluster along the beta-strands (toward the turn: T1, AGEWTYDDKTFTVTET; T2, GEDTWDYATFTVTKTE; T3, GEDDWTYATFTVTKTE; toward the end: E1, WTYDDAGETKTFTVT; E2, WEYTGDDATKTETFTV; E3, WTYEGDDATKTETFTV). The free energy terms include molecular mechanics energy, Poisson-Boltzmann electrostatic solvation energy, surface area solvation energy, and conformational entropy estimated by using normal mode analysis. From the wild type to T1, then T3, and finally T2, we see a progressively changing energy landscape, toward a less stable beta-hairpin structure. Moving the hydrophobic cluster outside toward the end region causes a greater change in the energy landscape. alpha-Helical instead of a beta-hairpin structure was the most stable form for the E2 isomer. However, no matter how much the sequence changes, for all variants studied, ideal "native" beta-hairpin topologies remain as minima (regardless of whether global or local) in the energy landscape. In general, we find that the energy landscape is dependent on the hydrophobic cluster topology and on the sequence. Our present study indicates that the key is the relative conformational energies of the different conformations. Changes in the sequence strongly modulate the relative stabilities of topologically similar regions in the energy landscape, rather than redefine the topology space. This finding is consistent with a population redistribution in the process of protein folding. The limited variation of topological space, compared with the number of possible sequence changes, may relate to the observation that the number of known protein folds are far less than the sequential allowance.     

Exploring the conformational space of protein side chains using dead-end elimination and the A* algorithm

We describe an algorithm which enables us to search the conformational space of the side chains of a protein to identify the global minimum energy combination of side chain conformations as well as all other conformations within a specified energy cutoff of the global energy minimum. The program is used to explore the side chain conformational energy surface of a number of proteins, to investigate how this surface varies with the energy model used to describe the interactions within the system and the rotamer library. Enumeration of the rotamer combinations enables us to directly evaluate the partition function, and thus calculate the side chain contribution to the conformational entropy of the folded protein. An investigation of these conformations and the relationships between them shows that most of the conformations near to the global energy minimum arise from changes in side chain conformations that are essentially independent; very few result from a concerted change in conformation of two or more residues. Some of the limitations of the approach are discussed. Proteins 33:227–239, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Conformational transition states of a beta-hairpin peptide between the ordered and disordered conformations in explicit water

The conformational transition states of a beta-hairpin peptide in explicit water were identified from the free energy landscapes obtained from the multicanonical ensemble, using an enhanced conformational sampling calculation. The beta-hairpin conformations were significant at 300 K in the landscape, and the typical nuclear Overhauser effect signals were reproduced, consistent with the previously reported experiment. In contrast, the disordered conformations were predominant at higher temperatures. Among the stable conformations at 300 K, there were several free energy barriers, which were not visible in the landscapes formed with the conventional parameters. We identified the transition states around the saddle points along the putative folding and unfolding paths between the beta-hairpin and the disordered conformations in the landscape. The characteristic features of these transition states are the predominant hydrophobic contacts and the several hydrogen bonds among the side-chains, as well as some of the backbone hydrogen bonds. The unfolding simulations at high temperatures, 400 K and 500 K, and their principal component analyses also provided estimates for the transition state conformations, which agreed well with those at 400 K and 500 K deduced from the current free energy landscapes at 400 K and 500 K, respectively. However, the transition states at high temperatures were much more widely distributed on the landscape than those at 300 K, and their conformations were different.     

Multiple loop conformations of peptides predicted by molecular dynamics simulations are compatible with nuclear magnetic resonance

The affinity and selectivity of protein-protein interactions can be fine-tuned by varying the size, flexibility, and amino acid composition of involved surface loops. As a model for such surface loops, we study the conformational landscape of an octapeptide, whose flexibility is chemically steered by a covalent ring closure integrating an azobenzene dye into and by a disulfide bridge additionally constraining the peptide backbone. Because the covalently integrated azobenzene dyes can be switched by light between a bent cis state and an elongated trans state, six cyclic peptide models of strongly different flexibilities are obtained. The conformational states of these peptide models are sampled by NMR and by unconstrained molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Prototypical conformations and the free-energy landscapes in the high-dimensional space spanned by the phi/psi angles at the peptide backbone are obtained by clustering techniques from the MD trajectories. Multiple open-loop conformations are shown to be predicted by MD particularly in the very flexible cases and are shown to comply with the NMR data despite the fact that such open-loop conformations are missing in the refined NMR structures.     

Statistical mechanics of protein folding by exhaustive enumeration

It is hard to construct theories for the folding of globular proteins because they are large and complicated molecules having enormous numbers of nonnative conformations and having native states that are complicated to describe. Statistical mechanical theories of protein folding are constructed around major simplifying assumptions about the energy as a function of conformation and/or simplifications of the representation of the polypeptide chain, such as one point per residue on a cubic lattice. It is not clear how the results of these theories are affected by their various simplifications. Here we take a very different simplification approach where the chain is accurately represented and the energy of each conformation is calculated by a not unreasonable empirical function. However, the set of amino acid sequences and allowed conformations is so restricted that it becomes computationally feasible to examine them all. Hence we are able to calculate melting curves for thermal denaturation as well as the detailed kinetic pathway of refolding. Such calculations are based on a novel representation of the conformations as points in an abstract 12-dimensional Euclidean conformation space. Fast folding sequences have relatively high melting temperatures, native structures with relatively low energies, small kinetic barriers between local minima, and relatively many conformations in the global energy minimum's watershed. In contrast to other folding theories, these models show no necessary relationship between fast folding and an overall funnel shape to the energy surface, or a large energy gap between the native and the lowest nonnative structure, or the depth of the native energy minimum compared to the roughness of the energy landscape. Proteins 32:425–437, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

An approach to the multiple-minima problem in protein folding by relaxing dimensionality. Tests on enkephalin

An algorithm for locating the region in conformational space containing the global energy minimum of a polypeptide is described. Distances are used as the primary variables in the minimization of an objective function that incorporates both energetic and distance-geometric terms. The latter are obtained from geometry and energy functions, rather than nuclear magnetic resonance experiments, although the algorithm can incorporate distances from nuclear magnetic resonance data if desired. The polypeptide is generated originally in a space of high dimensionality. This has two important consequences. First, all interatomic distances are initially at their energetically most favorable values; i.e. the polypeptide is initially at a global minimum-energy conformation, albeit a high-dimensional one. Second, the relaxation of dimensionality constraints in the early stages of the minimization removes many potential energy barriers that exist in three dimensions, thereby allowing a means of escaping from three-dimensional local minima. These features are used in an algorithm that produces short trajectories of three-dimensional minimum-energy conformations. A conformation in the trajectory is generated by allowing the previous conformation in the trajectory to evolve in a high-dimensional space before returning to three dimensions. The resulting three-dimensional structure is taken to be the next conformation in the trajectory, and the process is iterated. This sequence of conformations results in a limited but efficient sampling of conformational space. Results for test calculations on Met-enkephalin, a pentapeptide with the amino acid sequence H-Tyr-Gly-Gly-Phe-Met-OH, are presented. A tight cluster of conformations (in three-dimensional space) is found with ECEPP energies (Empirical Conformational Energy Program for Peptides) lower than any previously reported. This cluster of conformations defines a region in conformational space in which the global-minimum-energy conformation of enkephalin appears to lie.     

Multi‐scale characterization of the energy landscape of proteins with application to the C3D/Efb‐C complex

We present a novel multi‐level methodology to explore and characterize the low energy landscape and the thermodynamics of proteins. Traditional conformational search methods typically explore only a small portion of the conformational space of proteins and are hard to apply to large proteins due to the large amount of calculations required. In our multi‐scale approach, we first provide an initial characterization of the equilibrium state ensemble of a protein using an efficient computational conformational sampling method. We then enrich the obtained ensemble by performing short Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations on selected conformations from the ensembles as starting points. To facilitate the analysis of the results, we project the resulting conformations on a low‐dimensional landscape to efficiently focus on important interactions and examine low energy regions. This methodology provides a more extensive sampling of the low energy landscape than an MD simulation starting from a single crystal structure as it explores multiple trajectories of the protein. This enables us to obtain a broader view of the dynamics of proteins and it can help in understanding complex binding, improving docking results and more. In this work, we apply the methodology to provide an extensive characterization of the bound complexes of the C3d fragment of human Complement component C3 and one of its powerful bacterial inhibitors, the inhibitory domain of Staphylococcus aureus extra‐cellular fibrinogen‐binding domain (Efb‐C) and two of its mutants. We characterize several important interactions along the binding interface and define low free energy regions in the three complexes. Proteins 2010. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Computer simulations of cyclic enkephalin analogues

Molecular dynamics simulations and energy minimization studies of cyclic enkephalin analogues incorporating retro-inverso modifications have been carried out. The dynamic trajectories are analyzed in terms of the relative mobility of the 14-membered rings, conformational transitions among equilibrium states, and hydrogen-bonding patterns. The cyclization of the molecules reduces the motion of the ring structures substantially. Time-correlated conformational transitions resulting in the reorientation of peptide units are observed. Hydrogen bonds form principally C7 structures. Because of the incorporation of retro-inverso residues, C6 and C8 structures are also formed. Starting conformations for energy minimizations were obtained from the molecular dynamics simulations and from a systematic search of the conformational space available to the molecules. Several minimum energy backbone and side-chain conformations were found for each analogue. The effect of retro-inverso residues on hydrogen-bonding patterns and backbone conformations is discussed.     

Protein folding in the landscape perspective: Chevron plots and non-arrhenius kinetics

We use two simple models and the energy landscape perspective to study protein folding kinetics. A major challenge has been to use the landscape perspective to interpret experimental data, which requires ensemble averaging over the microscopic trajectories usually observed in such models. Here, because of the simplicity of the model, this can be achieved. The kinetics of protein folding falls into two classes: multiple-exponential and two-state (single-exponential) kinetics. Experiments show that two-state relaxation times have “chevron plot” dependences on denaturant and non-Arrhenius dependences on temperature. We find that HP and HP+ models can account for these behaviors. The HP model often gives bumpy landscapes with many kinetic traps and multiple-exponental behavior, whereas the HP+ model gives more smooth funnels and two-state behavior. Multiple-exponential kinetics often involves fast collapse into kinetic traps and slower barrier climbing out of the traps. Two-state kinetics often involves entropic barriers where conformational searching limits the folding speed. Transition states and activation barriers need not define a single conformation; they can involve a broad ensemble of the conformations searched on the way to the native state. We find that unfolding is not always a direct reversal of the folding process. Proteins 30:2–33, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Conformational states and folding pathways of peptides revealed by principal-independent component analyses

Principal component analysis is a powerful method for projecting multidimensional conformational space of peptides or proteins onto lower dimensional subspaces in which the main conformations are present, making it easier to reveal the structures of molecules from e.g. molecular dynamics simulation trajectories. However, the identification of all conformational states is still difficult if the subspaces consist of more than two dimensions. This is mainly due to the fact that the principal components are not independent with each other, and states in the subspaces cannot be visualized. In this work, we propose a simple and fast scheme that allows one to obtain all conformational states in the subspaces. The basic idea is that instead of directly identifying the states in the subspace spanned by principal components, we first transform this subspace into another subspace formed by components that are independent of one other. These independent components are obtained from the principal components by employing the independent component analysis method. Because of independence between components, all states in this new subspace are defined as all possible combinations of the states obtained from each single independent component. This makes the conformational analysis much simpler. We test the performance of the method by analyzing the conformations of the glycine tripeptide and the alanine hexapeptide. The analyses show that our method is simple and quickly reveal all conformational states in the subspaces. The folding pathways between the identified states of the alanine hexapeptide are analyzed and discussed in some detail.     

Understanding the structural characteristics of compstatin by conformational space annealing

The structural characteristics of the 13-residue compstatin molecule are investigated using the conformational space annealing (CSA) method with CHARMM force field and the GBSA continuum solvent model. In order to sample conformations in the energy range of the minimized NMR structures, we have used the stopping criterion to the CSA search when a conformation whose energy is less than -490 kcal/mol is found. With this stopping criterion, a great variety of conformations are generated around experimentally known structures. Twenty independent CSA runs starting from random states find 1000 representative conformations in the energy landscape of the compstatin, which are classified into thirty-one structural families. The majority of the conformations (94.4%) are in the coil state. Other conformers containing a 3(10)-helix, a pi-helix, a beta-hairpin, and an alpha-helix are also found.     

Exploring the Conformational Space of Chromatin Fibers and Their Stability by Numerical Dynamic Phase Diagrams

The three-dimensional structure of chromatin affects DNA accessibility and is therefore a key regulator of gene expression. However, the path of the DNA between consecutive nucleosomes, and the resulting chromatin fiber organization remain controversial. The conformational space available for the folding of the nucleosome chain has been analytically described by phase diagrams with a two-angle model, which describes the chain trajectory by a DNA entry-exit angle at the nucleosome and a torsion angle between consecutive nucleosomes. Here, a novel type of numerical phase diagrams is introduced that relates the geometric phase space to the energy associated with a given chromatin conformation. The resulting phase diagrams revealed differences in the energy landscape that reflect the probability of a given conformation to form in thermal equilibrium. Furthermore, we investigated the effects of entropy and additional degrees of freedom in the dynamic phase diagrams by performing Monte Carlo simulations of the initial chain trajectories. Using our approach, we were able to demonstrate that conformations that initially were geometrically impossible could evolve into energetically favorable states in thermal equilibrium due to DNA bending and torsion. In addition, dynamic phase diagrams were applied to identify chromatin fibers that reflect certain experimentally determined features.     

Monte Carlo minimization with thermalization for global optimization of polypeptide conformations in cartesian coordinate space.

A new minimization procedure for the global optimization in cartesian coordinate space of the conformational energy of a polypeptide chain is presented. The Metropolis Monte Carlo minimization is thereby supplemented by a thermalization process, which is initiated whenever a structure becomes trapped in an area containing closely located local minima in the conformational space. The method has been applied to the endogenous opioid pentapeptide methionine enkephalin. Five among 13 different starting conformations led to the same apparent global minimum of an in-house developed energy function, a type II' reverse turn, the central residues of which are Gly-3-Phe-4. A comparison between the ECEPP/2 global minimum conformation of methionine enkephalin and the apparent one achieved by the present method shows that minimum-energy conformations having a certain similarity can be generated by relatively different force fields.     

ARTIST: an activated method in internal coordinate space for sampling protein energy landscapes

We present the first applications of an activated method in internal coordinate space for sampling all-atom protein conformations, the activation-relaxation technique for internal coordinate space trajectories (ARTIST). This method differs from all previous internal coordinate-based studies aimed at folding or refining protein structures in that conformational changes result from identifying and crossing well-defined saddle points connecting energy minima. Our simulations of four model proteins containing between 4 and 47 amino acids indicate that this method is efficient for exploring conformational space in both sparsely and densely packed environments, and offers new perspectives for applications ranging from computer-aided drug design to supramolecular assembly.     

Toward a detailed understanding of search trajectories in fragment assembly approaches to protein structure prediction

Energy functions, fragment libraries, and search methods constitute three key components of fragment‐assembly methods for protein structure prediction, which are all crucial for their ability to generate high‐accuracy predictions. All of these components are tightly coupled; efficient searching becomes more important as the quality of fragment libraries decreases. Given these relationships, there is currently a poor understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of the sampling approaches currently used in fragment‐assembly techniques. Here, we determine how the performance of search techniques can be assessed in a meaningful manner, given the above problems. We describe a set of techniques that aim to reduce the impact of the energy function, and assess exploration in view of the search space defined by a given fragment library. We illustrate our approach using Rosetta and EdaFold, and show how certain features of these methods encourage or limit conformational exploration. We demonstrate that individual trajectories of Rosetta are susceptible to local minima in the energy landscape, and that this can be linked to non‐uniform sampling across the protein chain. We show that EdaFold's novel approach can help balance broad exploration with locating good low‐energy conformations. This occurs through two mechanisms which cannot be readily differentiated using standard performance measures: exclusion of false minima, followed by an increasingly focused search in low‐energy regions of conformational space. Measures such as ours can be helpful in characterizing new fragment‐based methods in terms of the quality of conformational exploration realized. Proteins 2016; 84:411–426. © 2016 The Authors Proteins: Structure, Function, and Bioinformatics Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

The metastable states of proteins

The intriguing process of protein folding comprises discrete steps that stabilize the protein molecules in different conformations. The metastable state of protein is represented by specific conformational characteristics, which place the protein in a local free energy minimum state of the energy landscape. The native‐to‐metastable structural transitions are governed by transient or long‐lived thermodynamic and kinetic fluctuations of the intrinsic interactions of the protein molecules. Depiction of the structural and functional properties of metastable proteins is not only required to understand the complexity of folding patterns but also to comprehend the mechanisms of anomalous aggregation of different proteins. In this article, we review the properties of metastable proteins in context of their stability and capability of undergoing atypical aggregation in physiological conditions.     

Progress in protein-protein docking: atomic resolution predictions in the CAPRI experiment using RosettaDock with an improved treatment of side-chain flexibility

RosettaDock uses real-space Monte Carlo minimization (MCM) on both rigid-body and side-chain degrees of freedom to identify the lowest free energy docked arrangement of 2 protein structures. An improved version of the method that uses gradient-based minimization for off-rotamer side-chain optimization and includes information from unbound structures was used to create predictions for Rounds 4 and 5 of CAPRI. First, large numbers of independent MCM trajectories were carried out and the lowest free energy docked configurations identified. Second, new trajectories were started from these lowest energy structures to thoroughly sample the surrounding conformation space, and the lowest energy configurations were submitted as predictions. For all cases in which there were no significant backbone conformational changes, a small number of very low-energy configurations were identified in the first, global search and subsequently found to be close to the center of the basin of attraction in the free energy landscape in the second, local search. Following the release of the experimental coordinates, it was found that the centers of these free energy minima were remarkably close to the native structures in not only the rigid-body orientation but also the detailed conformations of the side-chains. Out of 8 targets, the lowest energy models had interface root-mean-square deviations (RMSDs) less than 1.1 A from the correct structures for 6 targets, and interface RMSDs less than 0.4 A for 3 targets. The predictions were top submissions to CAPRI for Targets 11, 12, 14, 15, and 19. The close correspondence of the lowest free energy structures found in our searches to the experimental structures suggests that our free energy function is a reasonable representation of the physical chemistry, and that the real space search with full side-chain flexibility to some extent solves the protein-protein docking problem in the absence of significant backbone conformational changes. On the other hand, the approach fails when there are significant backbone conformational changes as the steric complementarity of the 2 proteins cannot be modeled without incorporating backbone flexibility, and this is the major goal of our current work.