Effect of DNA repair on the cytotoxicity and mutagenicity of polycyclic hydrocarbon derivatives in normal and xeroderma pigmentosum human fibroblasts

The cytotoxicity of the “K-region” epoxides as well as several other reactive metabolites or chemical derivatives of polycyclic hydrocarbons was compared in normally-repairing human diploid skin fibroblasts and in fibroblasts from a classical xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) patient (XP2BE) whose cells have been shown to carry out excision repair of damage induced in DNA by ultraviolet (UV) radiation at a rate approx. 20% that of normal cells. Each compound tested exhibited a 2- to 3-fold greater cytotoxicity in this XP strain than in the normal strain. To determine whether this difference in survival reflected a difference in the capacity of the strains to repair DNA damage caused by such hydrocarbon derivatives, we compared the cytotoxic effect of several “K-region” epoxides in two additional XP strains, each with a different capacity for repair of UV damage. The ration of the slopes of the survival curves for each of the XP strains to that of the normal strain, following exposure to each epoxide, was very similar to that which we had previously determined for their respective UV curves, suggesting that human cells repair damage induced in DNA by exposure to hydrocarbon derivatives with the same system used for UV-induced lesions.To determine whether the deficiency in rate of excision repair in this classical XP strain (XP2BE) causes such cells to be abnormally susceptible to mutations induced by “K-region” epoxides of polycyclic hydrocarbons, we compared them with normal cells for the frequency of induced mutations to 8-azaguanine resistance. The XP cells were two to three times more susceptible to mutations induced by the “K-region” epoxide of benzo(a)pyrene (BP), 7,12-dimethylbenz(a)anthracene (DMBA), and dibenz(a,h)anthracene (DBA). Evidence also was obtained that cells from an XP variant patient are abnormally susceptible to mutations induced by hydrocarbon epoxides and, as is the case following exposure to UV, are abnormally slow in converting low molecular weight DNA, synthesized from a template following exposure to hydrocarbon epoxides, into large-size DNA.     

Radioresistant DNA synthesis: an intrinsic feature of ataxia telangiectasia

DNA synthesis in 6 ataxia langiectasia (AT) cell strains was much more resistant to X-irradiation than was DNA synthesis in normal human diploid cells. 3 of the cell strains tested have been classified as proficient in repair replication. These data, along with those reported elsewhere, strongly suggest that radioresistant DNA synthesis is an intrinsic feature of this disease.The radioresistance of DNA synthesis in AT cells is primarily due to a reduced inhibition of replicon initiation compared to that occuring in normal cells, but DNA chain elongation is also more radioresistant in AT cells. The small inhibition of DNA synthesis that does occur in AT cells at doses up to 2000 rad is almost exclusively due to inhibition of replicon initiation and not to inhibition of chain elongation, as would be expected from results with normal human cells or from previous studies with established cell lines.     

Repair of bleomycin-damaged DNA by human fibroblasts

The ability of human fibroblasts to repair bleomycin-damaged DNA was examined in vivo. Repair of the specific lesions caused by bleomycin (BLM) was investigated in normal cell strains as well as those isolated from patients with apparent DNA repair defects. The diseases ataxia telangiectasia (AT), Bloom syndrome (BS), Cockayne syndrome (CS), Fanconi anemia (FA), and xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) were those selected for study. The method used for studying the repair of DNA after BLM exposure was alkaline sucrose gradient centrifugation. After exposure to BLM, a fall in the molecular weight of DNA was observed, and after drug removal the DNA reformed rapidly to high molecular weight. The fall in molecular weight upon exposure to BLM was observed in all cells examined with the exception of some XP strains. Prelabeled cells from some XP complementation groups were found to have a higher percentage of low molecular weight DNA on alkaline gradients than did normal cells. This prelabeled low molecular weight DNA disappeared upon exposure to BLM.     

Deoxyribonucleic Acid Repair in a Highly Radiation-Resistant Strain of Salmonella typhimurium

Deoxyribonucleic acid repair was studied in gamma-irradiated wild-type Salmonella typhimurium and in a radiation-resistant derivative 20 times more resistant than wild type. After exposure to 20 or 50 krad, the wild-type strain (DB21) degraded 30 to 50% of its prelabeled DNA into acid-soluble fragments, whereas the radioresistant strain degraded less than 15% after 4 h of incubation. Post-irradiation synthesis of DNA in the wild-type strain DB21 was reduced after a dose of 20 krad and totally inhibited after exposure to 200 krad. With radiation-resistant strain, D21R6008, on the other hand, DNA synthesis was delayed after a dose of 200 krad but not inhibited. Doses of 20 and 200 krad produced a similar number of single-strand breaks in the DNA of both strains as determined by zone sedimentation analysis in alkaline sucrose gradients. The radiation-resistant strain D21R6008, on the other hand, DNA synthesis was strand breaks in its DNA and repairs these damages more rapidly than wild-type Salmonella.     

DNA-repair synthesis in ataxia telangiectasia lymphoblastoid cells

The ability of a number of Epstein-Barr virus-transformed lymphoblastoid cells from ataxia telangiectasia (AT) patients to repair γ-radiation damage to DNA was determined. All of these AT cells were previously shown to be hypersensitive to γ-irradiation. Two methods were used to determine DNA-repair synthesis: isopycnic gradient analysis and a method employing hydroxyurea to inhibit semiconservative DNA synthesis. Control, AT heterozygote and AT homozygote cells were demonstrateed to have similar capacities for repair of radiation damage to DNA. In addition at high radiation doses (10–40 krad) the extent of inhibition of DNA synthesis was similar in the different cell types.     

Reduced inhibition of replicon initiation and chain elongation by neocarzinostatin in skin fibroblasts from patients with ataxia telangiectasia

Cells from patients with the genetic disease ataxia telangiectasia are hypersensitive to the DNA-breaking agents X-rays, bleomycin and neocarzinostatin, and show reduced inhibition of DNA synthesis after treatment with these agents, as compared to normal cells. The rate of replicon initiation and chain elongation was measured shortly after brief exposure of two normal and two ataxia telangiectasia fibroblast strains to low doses (0.10-0.30 microgram/ml) of neocarzinostatin, by means of alkaline sucrose gradient analysis. Neocarzinostatin was found to inhibit both initiation and elongation, and both components of DNA synthesis were more resistant to this inhibition in the A-T strains.     

A further definition of characteristics of DNA-excision repair in xeroderma pigmentosum complementation group A strains

The location in the genome of excision repair following exposure to UV (254 nm) of two XP complementation group A strains, XP12BE and XP8LO, that differ considerably in their excision-repair rates, have been determined. Capacity for repair in XP8LO has also been determined. Sites repaired in DNA in a 24-h post-UV period were located relative to the remaining pyrimidine dimers using the M. luteus UV-endonuclease to nick partially repaired DNA and sedimentation in alkaline sucrose to size the resulting DNA. Repair in group A occurs randomly throughout the genome in a manner similar to that observed for normal cells but in contrast to domain-limited repair in group C strains. This observation defines a further similarity of the excision repair detected in group A compared to normal cells that is in addition to the previously reported related characteristics of the respective excision rate curves. A reduced repair capacity in XP8LO relative to normal cells was detected. This strain, which repairs DNA at an initial rate identical to that of normal strains when irradiated with doses of 5 J/m2 or less, repairs DNA at a slower than normal but constant rate at higher doses. This leads to the suggestion that XP8LO is defective in the number of repair enzyme complexes compared to normal cells.     

Effects of inhibitors on repair of DNA in normal human and xeroderma pigmentosum cells after exposure to x-rays and ultraviolet irradiation

Experiments were carried out to obtain direct evidence for the hypothesis that in human cells the repair of UV-damaged DNA is initiated by an incision step, and that this step is defective in cells from patients having Xeroderma pigmentosum (XP). The alkaline sucrose gradient centrifugation technique was used to detect breaks in the DNA.A decreased sedimentation velocity of the DNA was found after exposure of normal and XP cells to high doses of UV (5000 erg/mm²). Breaks were induced in the DNA by the UV irradiation without the action of an enzyme. After exposure of both types of cell to UV doses of 100–500 erg/mm², breaks that might occur by enzymic incision were not observed, possibly because of immediate rejoining.After single-strand breaks had been induced by X-rays, rejoining did not occur at temperatures lower than 22°. Rejoining was inhibited by KCN, 2,4-dinitrophenol, EDTA, iodoacetate and crystal violet. Actinomycin D, acriflavine and phleomycin, also tested as potential inhibitors of the repair process, induced breaks or conformational changes in the DNA of unirradiated normal and XP cells.Application to UV-exposed cells of conditions that inhibit the rejoining of breaks did not cause accumulation of breaks in the DNA. The results suggest a coordinated and sequential performance of the steps in the repair of each UV lesion by repair enzymes which may act as a complex.     

Reduced inhibition of replicon initiation and chain elongation by neocarzinostatin in skin fibroblasts from patients with ataxia telangiectasia

Cells from patients with the genetic disease ataxia telangiectasia are hypersensitive to the DNA-breaking agents X-rays, bleomycin and neocarzinostatin, and show reduced inhibition of DNA synthesis after treatment with these agents, as compared to normal cells. The rate of replicon initiation and chain elongation was measured shortly after brief exposure of two normal and two ataxia telangiectasia fibroblast strains to low doses (0.10–0.30 μg/ml) of neocarzinostatin, by means of alkaline sucrose gradient analysis. Neocarzinostatin was found to inhibit both initiation and elongation, and both components of DNA synthesis were more resistant to this inhibition in the A-T strains.     

UV-induced DNA repair synthesis in cells of patients with different forms of xeroderma pigmentosum and of heterozygotes

UV-induced DNA repair synthesis, as measured by autoradiography as well as by isopycnic centrifugation methods, was studied in a large number of cell strains from patients with the classic form of xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) or the De Sanctis-Cacchione syndrome (DSC) and several of their heterozygous parents. On the basis of the kinetics of repair synthesis in the cultured skin fibroblasts we have recognized four distinct groups of XP patients: (1) classic XP patients with low residual repair capacities, (2) classic XP patients with intermediate, but dose-dependent, levels of repair synthesis relative to the normal level, (3) patients, diagnosed as having classic XP, with a normal or only slightly reduced repair capacity and (4) DSC patients with a complete deficiency of repair synthesis. Complementation studies reported elsewhere have shown that different mutations are responsible for the detect in at least three of these groups. Cell strains of each of the four XP types were able to rejoin single-strand DNA breaks induced by X-rays. Most of the cell strains derived from heterozygotes showed normal repair activities. However, in the parents some of the of DSC-patients a significant reduction of the level of repair synthesis was found.     

Effect of ionizing radiation on DNA synthesis in ataxia telangiectasia cells.

The effect of ionizing radiation on DNA synthesis in control and ataxia telangiectasia (AT) lymphoblastoid cell lines was determined. A dose dependent decrease in DNA synthesis was observed in control cells, and the rate and extent of thi decrease in synthesis increased with time after irradiation. No decrease in DNA synthesis was obtained in AT cells, immediately following irradiation, at doses up to 400 rads. At longer times postirradiation, inhibition of synthesis increased but the extent of inhibition was less in AT cell than controls at all doses used. An immediate depression of DNA synthesis was evident in control cells after a radiation dose of 200 rads reaching a maximum at 90 min postirradiation. Little or no decrease in DNA synthesis was evident in AT cells up to 60 min after the same radiation dose, but a decrease occurred between 60 and 90 min after irradiation. The rate of recovery of DNA synthesis to normal levels was more rapid in AT cells than in controls.     

Hypersensitivity of ataxia telangiectasia skin fibroblasts to DNA alkylating agents

3 ataxia telangiectasia (AT) fibroblast cell strains, AT4BI, AT5BI and AT2BE (CRL1343) were studied for their colony-forming ability after treatment with various concentrations of 4 different DNA alkylating agents. The results were compared to the response of fibroblast strains from 3 normal individuals. None of the AT strains were abnormally sensitive to N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine. 1 strain (AT5BI) was significantly more sensitive to treatment with methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) based on a survival curve D0 value of 0.29 mM vs. the normal average D0 of 0.38 mM (P less than 0.02) and a D10 value of 0.85 mM vs. the normal average D10 of 1.2 mM (P less than 0.025). Strain AT4BI was also significantly more sensitive to MMS treatment when D10 values were compared (0.73 mM, P less than 0.01). All 3 AT cell strains were significantly more sensitive to treatment with ethyl methanesulfonate when D10 values were the criterion of sensitivity, AT4BI 16 mM, AT5BI 13 mM and AT2BE 15 mM vs. the normal human fibroblast average D10 value of 28 mM (P less than 0.01 for all 3 AT strains). 2 of the 3 AT cell strains (AT4BI and AT2BE) were abnormally sensitive to treatment with 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide; the D0 values were 0.045 microM and 0.05 microM, respectively, vs. the normal average D0 value of 0.11 microM (P less than 0.01 for both AT strains). The corresponding D10 values were 0.08 microM and 0.11 microM, respectively, vs. the normal average D10 value of 0.27 microM (P less than 0.01 for AT4BI and P less than 0.025 for AT2BE). These results indicate that there is a heterogeneity in the response of AT fibroblast cell strains to treatment with DNA alkylating agents, except possibly in the case of ethylating compounds.     

Complementation analysis of xeroderma pigmentosum variants

DNA repair after UV exposure was studied in multinucleate cells, obtained after fusion of excision-defective and variant xeroderma pigmentosum fibroblasts. Optimal fusion conditions were determined, facilitating the measurement of DNA replication in heterokaryons. In unirradiated multikaryons, entry into the S phase was depressed, when compared with unfused cells. The extent of the depression of S phase entry was dependent on the fusion conditions. In heterokaryons obtained after fusion of XP variant (6 different strains) with excision-defective XP (three cell strains from complementation groups A, C and D) both unscheduled DNA synthesis and postreplication repair after UV irradiation were restored to normal levels. In contrast, complementation was not observed after pairwise fusion of the XP variant cell strains. These results suggest that the XP variants comprise a single complementation group, different from complementation groups A, C and D.     

Spontaneous and induced sister chromatid exchanges in the blood lymphocytes of healthy persons and of xeroderma pigmentosum patients exposed to the inhibitors of DNA repair and replication caffeine, 3-methoxybenzamide and novobiocin

The frequency of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs), both spontaneous and induced by UV-light, X-rays, mitomycin C and ethylmetansulphonate (EMS), has been investigated in cultured human peripheral blood lymphocytes. Besides, frequency of spontaneous and induced SCEs was studied under the action of the inhibitors of topoisomerase II, polymerase poly(ADP-ribose), and DNA repair, i. e. novobiocin, 3-metoxybenzamide, and caffeine, respectively. It is shown that the base-line SCEs in lymphocytes of the patient with xeroderma pigmentosum II (XP2LE) is dramatically higher compared to that in normal and pigmented xerodermoid cells (XP3LE). The above inhibitors of DNA synthesis and repair enhance the rate of spontaneous SCEs in normal, XP2LE and XP3LE cells. UV-, X-ray and chemical mutagens induced an increased frequency of SCEs in these cells. Simultaneous treatment with mutagenes and inhibitors of DNA synthesis and DNA repair enhanced the rate of SCEs in lymphocytes of healthy donors and in the XP3LE patient. The frequency of the XP2LE cells. Novobiocin, 3-MBA and caffeine significantly decreased the frequency of SCEs in mitomycin C- and EMS-treated XP2LE lymphocyte, which nevertheless was much higher than that in normal cells treated with the same agents.     

DNA semi-conservative synthesis in normal and Fanconi anemia fibroblasts following treatment with 8-methoxypsoralen and near ultraviolet light or with X-rays

Summary The effect of treatment with 8-methoxypsoralen (8-MOP) plus near-UV radiation (UVA) or with X-rays on the rate of DNA semi-conservative synthesis of fibroblasts from 10 Fanconi anemia (FA), two heterozygous, and three normal cell lines was studied. Following treatments with either X-rays or low doses of 8-MOP plus UVA leading to a majority of monoadducts over cross-links per genome, the FA and hetcrozygous cell lines were indistinguishable from normals: the transient inhibition of semi-conservative DNA synthesis was followed by the recovery of a nomral rate of synthesis. In contrast treatment with higher (but not saturating) doses of 8-MOP plus UVA allowed us to distinguish two classes among the FA cell lines. One class demonstrated a pattern of recovery similar to that of heterozygous and normal cell lines. This indicates that in such cell lines, the predominant lesion in this condition, the cross-links, do not arrest DNA synthesis and are likely to be normally repaired. Another class of FA cell lines did not show a recovery of a normal rate of DNA synthesis even after prolonged post-treatment incubation and although the proportion of cells in S phase was similar to that of the strains of the first category. This indicates that in such cell lines the repair of cross-links is inhibited at some step which is not necessarily the incision one.     

An apparent correlation between the inhibition of induced ornithine decarboxylase activity by γ radiation and the capacity for DNA repair synthesis in normal and ataxia telangiectasia human fibroblasts: No correlation with cell survival

Summary Exposure of normal human fibroblasts (F107) in stationary phase to radiation inhibited the appearance of induced ornithine decarboxylase (ODC) activity. Skin fibroblasts derived from two ataxia telangiectasia (AT) patients (F184 and F182) displayed a similar response. The level of DNA repair synthesis was also similar in the three cell strains. Fibroblasts from another apparently normal donor (F196) were very sensitive to inhibition of induced ODC activity by radiation and were also deficient in radiation-induced DNA repair synthesis. However, the two strains derived from normal donors displayed the same degree of cellular sensitivity towards X-rays, whereas the two AT strains showed the typical hypersensitivity to the cytotoxic effect of X-irradiation. The results suggest a possible correlation between the inhibition of induced ODC activity by radiation and the extent of DNA repair synthesis at high radiation doses, but there is no correlation between these two parameters and cellular survival at low radiation doses.     

Various Levels of DNA Repair Synthesis in Xeroderma Pigmentosum Cells exposed to the Carcinogens N-Hydroxy and N-Acetoxy-2-acetyl-aminofluorene

IN assessing environmental health hazards, the question has arisen of whether “safe”, “tolerable” or “permissible” levels of carcinogens, mutagens or teratogens can be derived by extrapolation of bioassays using rodents exposed for various periods to very high concentrations of chemicals or using cultured mammalian cell lines. Variations in susceptibility are only rarely taken into account, if at all and doses which seem to be harmless to the average person may be harmful to susceptible people. The reduced capacity to repair ultraviolet-induced DNA lesions in xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) cells may exemplify a mechanism leading to an elevated neoplastic transformation rate in man^1–4. The question arises as to whether cells with deficient repair synthesis respond to chemical carcinogens in the same manner as cells with adequate repair systems. We report here the levels of DNA repair synthesis in XP cells of five patients exposed to the carcinogenic^5,6 and mutagenic⁷ compounds N-acetoxy or N-hydroxy-2-acetyl-aminofluorene, which are ultimate and proximate carcinogenic forms of 2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF). We were particularly interested in comparing the different levels of DNA repair synthesis following ultraviolet irradiation with those following treatment with chemical carcinogens.     

Nuclear and Mitochondrial DNA Synthesis in Gamma Ray-Resistant and -Sensitive Slime Mold Amebas

Uptake of [methyl-³H]thymidine label from Escherichia coli 15T^- into the DNA of Dictyostelium discoideum has been measured in control and [⁶⁰Co]-gamma-irradiated cells of the resistant strain NC-4 (D₁₀, colony-forming survival = 300 krad) and two sensitive daughter strains, γs-18 (D₁₀ = 75 krad) and γs-13 (D₁₀ = 4 krad). Nuclear (n) and mitochondrial (m) DNA were resolved by isopycnic CsCl gradients. The uptake of label into n-DNA during the immediate postirradiation period was selectively inhibited by irradiation, compared with uptake into m-DNA. For all three strains, the gamma ray dose to reduce the uptake into n-DNA to 37% of the control during the first hour after irradiation was 3 krad, whereas for uptake into m-DNA it was 75 krad. After the initial dose- and strain-dependent lag, uptake into n-DNA resumed. γs-18 showed longer lags in n-DNA synthesis and cell division than did NC-4. γs-13 resumed n-DNA synthesis and cell division after slightly shorter lags than for NC-4. The early postlag uptake into n-DNA in this strain was almost at the control rate and was accompanied by division until the cell number had nearly doubled. The rate of label uptake then declined, division stopped, and gradual cell lysis ensued. The postdelay response of γs-13 was almost independent of dose in the range of 10-100 krad. The response of γs-18 in these and earlier experiments is consistent with the view-point that it is sensitive because of a decreased rate of repair of DNA damage. However, the basis for the sensitivity of γs-13 seems to be more complex. This strain undergoes a premature but short-lived burst of n-DNA synthesis and division for what appears to be about one round of replication. Replication then ceases, even at very low doses, leading to greatly reduced probability of survival.     

Normal inhibition of DNA synthesis following gamma-irradiation of radiosensitive cell lines from patients with Down's syndrome and Alzheimer's disease

Inhibition of DNA synthesis was studied in gamma-irradiated lymphoblastoid cells from patients with Alzheimer's disease and Down's syndrome. A normal biphasic pattern of inhibition was observed over a dose range of 0-4 krad of gamma-rays in all of the cell lines. 3 out of 4 Down's and all the Alzheimer's cell lines were shown to be hypersensitive to ionizing radiation based on induced chromosomal aberrations. Increased G2 phase delay, comparable to that occurring in ataxia-telangiectasia cells, was observed for some of the cell lines, after exposure to gamma-rays. Contrary to other data in the literature these results demonstrate that radioresistant DNA synthesis is not an intrinsic feature of all disorders characterized by radiosensitivity.     

Survival of apurinic SV40 DNA in the d-complementation group of xeroderma pigmentosum.

The survival of depurinated Form I SV40 DNA was studied in normal human fibroblasts and in D-complementation Xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) fibroblasts. Survival was measured with an infective center assay. Heat-acid and methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) were used as depurinating agents. After 3 hrs of depurination by heat--acid treatment, infectivity in normal cells was less than 15% of the controls compared to more than 50% for the XP D cell strains. Similar results were obtained with MMS-treated DNA. These results are contrary to expectation since apurinic endonuclease activity, which is presumed to be involved in the repair of apurinic sites, is much lower in XP D cell strains than in normal cell strains. Our results indicate that another mechanism for the repair of apurinic sites could exist.