Karl ernst von Baer's 'Uber Entwickelungsgeschichte der Thiere II' and its unpublished drawings

In 1828 Karl Ernst von Baer (1792-1876) published his seminal Uber Entwickelungsgeschichte der Thiere. Beobachtung und Reflexion. In the preface he announced that a second volume with one copper plate would be finished 'in a few weeks'. However, it took nine years until the unfinished second volume was released, with four copperplates. In his 'Autobiography', von Baer did not clarify the reasons why he did not finish his research program of comparative embryology. The paper attempts to elucidate them, furnished by archival documents and von Baer's unpublished embryological drawings. Our sketch of a few figures will show that (1) von Baer searched for 'analogies' (homologies) as a unifying principle and (2) explained the mechanisms of embryogenesis by physiological reasoning (electromagnetism). The main objective is to show that technical problems in illustrating and conceptual difficulties impeded von Baer's ambitious research program.     

A new model of developmental constraints as applied to the Drosophila system

Von Baer's laws of development observe that an embryo, in the course of its ontogeny, progresses through a series of forms which diverge increasingly from the embryonic forms of related species, and in an evolutionary interpretation, from those of its phylogenetic ancestors. This observation on the relation of phylogeny to ontogeny is explained by Wimsatt's (1986) "Developmental Lock" model of complex generative systems, which proposes that evolution is constrained to alter developmental programs in a manner that usually modifies or adds new complexity to pre-existent developmental functions at positions relatively "downstream" in the causal structure. If the Developmental Lock model is correct, (1) evolution should have resulted in hierarchically ordered developmental programs, and (2) the most important developmental functions in the hierarchy should be ancient. Wimsatt also suggests that developmental functions be analyzed according to a degree property called "generative entrenchment", which replaces the temporal analysis in the traditional formulation of von Baer's laws. Herein, a substantial body of data on Drosophila ontogeny is analyzed according to generative entrenchment, in order to try the effectiveness of this form of analysis, and also to empirically test these two main predictions of the Developmental Lock model. The novel analytic approach proves to be fruitful, both in generating experimental hypotheses and in ordering existing data. Moreover, data concerning the developmental functions discussed here indicate that the order of the Drosophila developmental program conforms to the predictions of Wimsatt's model with few deviations. Explanations of the anomalies are offered, along with proposals for experiments to test some of those explanations.     

Karl Ernst Ritter von Baer

The discoverer of the egg‐cell: Karl Ernst von Baer Being a versatile scientist of great influence, the Baltic aristocrat Karl Ernst von Baer (1792–1876) became the originator of comparative ontogeny. During his time as professor at Königsberg University von Baer, who formerly studied medicine, developed a deep interest in processes of recapitulation during embryonic growth and discovered the spinal cord and the mammalian egg‐cell. After retirement he became one of the most prominent opponents of Charles Darwin. Von Baer established several scientific laws, societies and journals.     

In search of the vertebrate phylotypic stage: a molecular examination of the developmental hourglass model and von Baer's third law

In 1828, Karl von Baer proposed a set of four evolutionary "laws" pertaining to embryological development. According to von Baer's third law, young embryos from different species are relatively undifferentiated and resemble one another but as development proceeds, distinguishing features of the species begin to appear and embryos of different species progressively diverge from one another. An expansion of this law, called "the hourglass model," has been proposed independently by Denis Duboule and Rudolf Raff in the 1990s. According to the hourglass model, ontogeny is characterized by a starting point at which different taxa differ markedly from one another, followed by a stage of reduced intertaxonomic variability (the phylotypic stage), and ending in a von-Baer-like progressive divergence among the taxa. A possible "translation" of the hourglass model into molecular terminology would suggest that orthologs expressed in stages described by the tapered part of the hourglass should resemble one another more than orthologs expressed in the expansive parts that precede or succeed the phylotypic stage. We tested this hypothesis using 1,585 mouse genes expressed during 26 embryonic stages, and their human orthologs. Evolutionary divergence was estimated at different embryonic stages by calculating pairwise distances between corresponding orthologous proteins from mouse and human. Two independent datasets were used. One dataset contained genes that are expressed solely in a single developmental stage; the second was made of genes expressed at different developmental stages. In the second dataset the genes were classified according to their earliest stage of expression. We fitted second order polynomials to the two datasets. The two polynomials displayed minima as expected from the hourglass model. The molecular results suggest, albeit weakly, that a phylotypic stage (or period) indeed exists. Its temporal location, sometimes between the first-somites stage and the formation of the posterior neuropore, was in approximate agreement with the morphologically defined phylotypic stage. The molecular evidence for the later parts of the hourglass model, i.e., for von Baer's third law, was stronger than that for the earlier parts.     

The action of stabilizing selection on the perfection of new characters in evolution

In birds, fusion of the carpal elements to a carpometacarpus during morphogenesis takes place during the evolutionary process at different rates, i.e. heterochronically, in different groups (developmental radiations), like the elements of the nasal apparatus in Sauropsida. This is because new characters spread and are pushed back at different rates from the terminal to the initial levels of morphogenesis. The shift is most likely automatic, in that it does not require further mutation, but it is set in motion by selection. Selection does not take effect only when an adequate character (which at first is very imperfect) is accepted; it also causes the character to grow, pushes it back towards the threshold of morphogenesis and thereby increases its perfection and its fitness. The path along which the shift takes place is determined by the morphogenetic route of recapitulation of the ancestral structure and since this movement is caused by protracted stabilizing selection, we can describe it as orthoselective movement. This means that recapitulation is flexible. At the same time, cellular and epigenetic interactions with surrounding structures are reciprocally influenced. The shift continues until adequate adaptation and perfection have been achieved. Stabilizing selection then ceases to act. The shift shows the evolutionary trend or further developmental possibilities. Its chief role is probably in the development of specializations.     

Test of Von Baer's law of the conservation of early development

One of the oldest and most pervasive ideas in comparative embryology is the perceived evolutionary conservation of early ontogeny relative to late ontogeny. Karl Von Baer first noted the similarity of early ontogeny across taxa, and Ernst Haeckel and Charles Darwin gave evolutionary interpretation to this phenomenon. In spite of a resurgence of interest in comparative embryology and the development of mechanistic explanations for Von Baer's law, the pattern itself has been largely untested. Here, I use statistical phylogenetic approaches to show that Von Baer's law is an unnecessarily complex explanation of the patterns of ontogenetic timing in several clades of vertebrates. Von Baer's law suggests a positive correlation between ontogenetic time and amount of evolutionary change. I compare ranked position in ontogeny to frequency of evolutionary change in rank for developmental events and find that these measures are not correlated, thus failing to support Von Baer's model. An alternative model that postulates that small changes in ontogenetic rank are evolutionarily easier than large changes is tentatively supported.     

Richard Owen, Morphology and Evolution

Richard Owen has been condemned by Darwinians as an anti-evolutionist and an essentialist. In recent years he has been the object of a revisionist analysis intended to uncover evolutionary elements in his scientific enterprise. In this paper I will examine Owen's evolutionary hypothesis and its connections with von Baer's idea of divergent development. To give appropriate importance to Owen's evolutionism is the first condition to develop an up-to-date understanding of his scientific enterprise, that is to disentagle Owen's contribution to the modernization of typology and morphology. I will argue that Owen's Platonic essentialism is rhetorical and incongruous. On the contrary, an interpretation of the archetype based on Aristotle's biological works makes possible a new conception of type, based on a homeostatic mechanism of stability. The renewal of morphology hinges on homological correspondences and a homeostatic process is also the origin of serial and special homology. I will argue that special homology shows an evolutionary orientation insofar as it is a typically inter-specific character while serial homology is determined through an elementary usage of the categories of developmental morphology. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Haeckel's ABC of evolution and development

One of the central, unresolved controversies in biology concerns the distribution of primitive versus advanced characters at different stages of vertebrate development. This controversy has major implications for evolutionary developmental biology and phylogenetics. Ernst Haeckel addressed the issue with his Biogenetic Law, and his embryo drawings functioned as supporting data. We re-examine Haeckel's work and its significance for modern efforts to develop a rigorous comparative framework for developmental studies. Haeckel's comparative embryology was evolutionary but non-quantitative. It was based on developmental sequences, and treated heterochrony as a sequence change. It is not always clear whether he believed in recapitulation of single characters or entire stages. The Biogenetic Law is supported by several recent studies -- if applied to single characters only. Haeckel's important but overlooked alphabetical analogy of evolution and development is an advance on von Baer. Haeckel recognized the evolutionary diversity in early embryonic stages, in line with modern thinking. He did not necessarily advocate the strict form of recapitulation and terminal addition commonly attributed to him. Haeckel's much-criticized embryo drawings are important as phylogenetic hypotheses, teaching aids, and evidence for evolution. While some criticisms of the drawings are legitimate, others are more tendentious. In opposition to Haeckel and his embryo drawings, Wilhelm His made major advances towards developing a quantitative comparative embryology based on morphometrics. Unfortunately His's work in this area is largely forgotten. Despite his obvious flaws, Haeckel can be seen as the father of a sequence-based phylogenetic embryology.     

Hox-controlled reorganisation of intrasegmental patterning cues underlies Drosophila posterior spiracle organogenesis

Hox proteins provide axial positional information and control segment morphology in development and evolution. Yet how they specify morphological traits that confer segment identity and how axial positional information interferes with intrasegmental patterning cues during organogenesis remain poorly understood. We have investigated the control of Drosophila posterior spiracle morphogenesis, a segment-specific structure that forms under Abdominal-B (AbdB) Hox control in the eighth abdominal segment (A8). We show that the Hedgehog (Hh), Wingless (Wg) and Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor (Egfr) pathways provide specific inputs for posterior spiracle morphogenesis and act in a genetic network made of multiple and rapidly evolving Hox/signalling interplays. A major function of AbdB during posterior spiracle organogenesis is to reset A8 intrasegmental patterning cues, first by reshaping wg and rhomboid expression patterns, then by reallocating the Hh signal and later by initiating de novo expression of the posterior compartment gene engrailed in anterior compartment cells. These changes in expression patterns confer axial specificity to otherwise reiteratively used segmental patterning cues, linking intrasegmental polarity and acquisition of segment identity.     

August Rauber (1841-1917): from the primitive streak to Cellularmechanik

In the early 19th century Karl Ernst von Baer initiated a new research program searching for the mechanisms by which an egg transforms itself into an embryo. August Rauber (1841-1917) took up this challenge. He considered the phylogenetic principle as the right tool to explain the similitude of embryogenetic processes. In extending Baer's approach, he combined comparative embryology and histology in his studies of avian and mammalian embryos. His earlier work demonstrated that the two-layered chick embryo is a modified gastrula and not a "disc" as Wilhelm His had claimed. From the 1880s onwards, he concentrated on the issue of how the development of germ layers is related to tissue differentiation. To address this, he studied the blastopore, epiblast, primitive streak, teratology and the relative importance of nucleus and cytoplasm in heredity. This paper reconstructs some of Rauber's work and concludes that his observations and reflections constituted a new approach combining embryology and histology with "phylogenetic" reasoning.     

Normal epithelial branching morphogenesis in the absence of collagen I

Interstitial collagens are thought to mediate epithelial-mesenchymal interactions during organogenesis. We have used the collagen I-deficient mouse mutant Mov13 to directly investigate the role of this major representative of the interstitial collagens in epithelial branching morphogenesis. Since homozygous embryos die at midgestation, we have studied the development of organ rudiments from Mov13 homozygous (i.e., collagen I-deficient), heterozygous, and wild-type embryos in culture. Development of all explants, including lung, kidney, salivary glands, pancreas, and skin, was normal by light and electron microscopic criteria and was independent of the genotype of the donor embryo. Metabolic labeling and immune staining verified the complete absence of collagen I in homozygous explants while revealing substantial production of collagens III and V in explants of all three genotypes. These results indicate either that collagen I has no role in the morphogenesis of these organs, or that its function is shared, or can be substituted for, by other fibrillar collagens.     

多胺对宁夏枸杞愈伤组织器官发生和体细胞胚发生的影响

利用已建立的宁夏枸杞（Lycium barbarumL.)愈伤组织器官发生和体细胞胚发生体系,对多胺在其离体形态发生中的作用进行研究。通过检测内源多胺含量发现,在所研究的三种多胺中,Put是器官发生途径的主要多胺,而在体细胞胚发生途径Spd含量占优势。Put含量变化在两条途径中相似：在愈伤组织分化的早期迅速积累不仅又下降,随着芽原基和球形胚的形成含量又进一步上升。器官发生中Spd最高含量仅在培养的第一天后,Spd含量才开始上升,到第十天时达到最高值。三种外源多胺的添加均有有效地促进两种离体分化途径的形态建成：Spd(100 μmol/L）能显著增加不定芽数,而体细胞胚发生中Spd(100μmol/L）而Put（100μmol/L）的单独处理能最好地促进体细胞胚形成和进一步发育成苗;尽管Spm在离体形态发生中含量较低,但添加外源Spm也促进了不定芽形成和体细胞胚形成然后成苗。多胺生物合成抑制剂CHA处理阻碍不定芽形成和和体细胞胚的进一步发育;但是MGBG对器官发生途径中的形态建成没有影响,即降低体细胞胚的发生频率及再生苗数。添加Spd(50μmol/L)能部分逆转CHA、MGBG的抑制效应。以上结果表明,多胺对宁夏枸杞器官发生和体细胞胚发生途径的离体形态建成有一定影响。     

Does population ecology have general laws?

There is a widespread opinion among ecologists that ecology lacks general laws. In this paper the author argues that this opinion is mistaken. Taking the case of population dynamics, the author points out that there are several very general law-like propositions that provide the theoretical basis for most population dynamics models that were developed to address specific issues. Some of these foundational principles, like the law of exponential growth, are logically very similar to certain law of physics (Newton's law of intertia, for example, is almost a direct analogue of exponential growth). The author discusses two other principles (population self-limitation and resource-consumer oscillations), as well as the more elementary postulates that underlie them. None of the "laws" that the author proposes for population ecology are new. Collectively ecologists have been using these general principles in guiding development of their models and experiments since the days of Lotka, Volterra, and Gause.     

Patterning parameters associated with the branching of the ureteric bud regulated by epithelial-mesenchymal interactions

The mechanisms by which the branching of epithelial tissue occurs and is regulated to generate different organ structures are not well understood. In this work, image analyses of the organ rudiments demonstrate specific epithelial branching patterns for the early lung and kidney; the lung type typically generating several side branches, whereas kidney branching was mainly dichotomous. Parameters such as the number of epithelial tips, the angle of the first branch, the position index of the first branch (PIFB) in a module, and the percentage of epithelial module type (PMT) were analysed. The branching patterns in the cultured lung and kidney, and in homotypic tissue recombinants recapitulated their early in vivo branching patterns. The parameters were applied to heterotypic tissue recombinants between lung mesenchyme and ureteric bud, and tip number, PIFB and PMT values qualified the change in ureter morphogenesis and the reprogramming of the ureteric bud with lung mesenchyme. All the values for the heterotypic recombinant between ureteric bud and lung mesenchyme were significantly different from those for kidney samples but similar to those of the lung samples. Hence, lung mesenchyme can instruct the ureteric bud to undergo aspects of early lung-type epithelial morphogenesis. Different areas of the lung mesenchyme, except the tracheal region, were sufficient to promote ureteric bud growth and branching. In conclusion, our findings provide morphogenetic parameters for monitoring epithelial development in early embryonic lung and kidney and demonstrate the use of heterotypic tissue recombinants as a model for studying tissue-specific epithelial branching during organogenesis.     

Regulation of ureteric bud branching morphogenesis by sulfated proteoglycans in the developing kidney

Glycosaminoglycans in the form of heparan sulfate proteoglycans (HSPG) and chondroitin sulfate proteoglycans (CSPG) are required for normal kidney organogenesis. The specific roles of HSPGs and CSPGs on ureteric bud (UB) branching morphogenesis are unclear, and past reports have obtained differing results. Here we employ in vitro systems, including isolated UB culture, to clarify the roles of HSPGs and CSPGs on this process. Microarray analysis revealed that many proteoglycan core proteins change during kidney development (syndecan-1,2,4, glypican-1,2,3, versican, decorin, biglycan). Moreover, syndecan-1, syndecan-4, glypican-3, and versican are differentially expressed during isolated UB culture, while decorin is dynamically regulated in cultured isolated metanephric mesenchyme (MM). Biochemical analysis indicated that while both heparan sulfate (HS) and chondroitin sulfate (CS) are present, CS accounts for approximately 75% of the glycosaminoglycans (GAG) in the embryonic kidney. Selective perturbation of HS in whole kidney rudiments and in the isolated UB resulted in a significant reduction in the number of UB branch tips, while CS perturbation has much less impressive effects on branching morphogenesis. Disruption of endogenous HS sulfation with chlorate resulted in diminished FGF2 binding and proliferation, which markedly altered kidney area but did not have a statistically significant effect on patterning of the ureteric tree. Furthermore, perturbation of GAGs did not have a detectable effect on FGFR2 expression or epithelial marker localization, suggesting the expression of these molecules is largely independent of HS function. Taken together, the data suggests that nonselective perturbation of HSPG function results in a general proliferation defect; selective perturbation of specific core proteins and/or GAG microstructure may result in branching pattern defects. Despite CS being the major GAG synthesized in the whole developing kidney, it appears to play a lesser role in UB branching; however, CS is likely to be integral to other developmental processes during nephrogenesis, possibly involving the MM. A model is presented of how, together with growth factors, heterogeneity of proteoglycan core proteins and glycosaminoglycan sulfation act as a switching mechanism to regulate different stages of the branching process. In this model, specific growth factor-HSPG combinations play key roles in the transitioning between stages and their maintenance.     

In vitro control of organogenesis and body patterning by activin during early amphibian development

In the process of amphibian development, an embryonic body plan is established through cell division, sequential gene expression, morphogenesis and cell differentiation. The mechanism of body patterning is complex and includes multiple induction events. Activin, a TGF-beta family protein, can induce several kinds of mesodermal and endodermal tissues in animal cap explants in a dose-dependent manner. In a recent study of the role of activin in organogenesis, we succeeded in raising a beating heart by treating animal caps with a high concentration of activin. Activin also participates in kidney organogenesis in combination with retinoic acid. An embryonic kidney induced by activin and retinoic acid in vitro can function in vivo when it is transplanted into a larva in which pronephros rudiments have already been removed. Further, the activin-treated animal caps clearly show organizer actions that are closely related to body patterning along the anteroposterior axis. These experiments will help to serve as a model system for understanding organogenesis and body patterning at the cellular and molecular levels.     

Relationship between vasculogenesis, angiogenesis and haemopoiesis during avian ontogeny

Quail-chick intracoelomic grafts of organ rudiments were used to study the origin of endothelia and haemopoietic cells during avian organogenesis in conjunction with the monoclonal antibody QH1 which recognizes the quail haemangioblastic lineage. Results differed according to the germ-layer constitution of the grafted rudiments. In the case of the limb buds, endothelial cells from the host invaded the graft through an angiogenic process. Haemopoietic progenitors from the host also colonized the grafted bone marrow. In contrast, rudiments of internal organs provided their own contingent of endothelial precursors, a process termed vasculogenesis. Nevertheless, haemopoietic cells in these organs were all derived from the host. In the lung, this extrinsic cell population appeared regularly scattered around the parabronchi and had a macrophage-like phenotype. In the pancreas, the granulocytes which differentiate as dense aggregates located in the wall of the largest vessels were extrinsic. Similarly in the spleen, a mesodermal primordium that develops in close association with the pancreatic endoderm, endothelial cells were intrinsic and haemopoietic cells host-derived. This study demonstrates that, in ontogeny, vascularization obeys different rules depending on which germ layer the mesoderm is associated with: in mesodermal/ectodermal rudiments angiogenesis is the rule; in mesodermal/endodermal rudiments, vasculogenesis occurs. However, in these internal organs undergoing vasculogenesis, endothelial and haemopoietic cells have separate origins. We put forward the hypothesis that the endoderm induces the emergence of endothelial cells in the associated mesoderm. Formation of blood stem cells may also involve interactions between endoderm and mesoderm, but in this case the responding capacity of the mesoderm appears restricted to the paraaortic region.     

Sucrose stimulates branching morphogenesis of embryonic mouse lung in vitro: a problem of osmotic balance between lumen fluid and culture medium

In organ cultures of lung rudiments from 11-day mouse embryos, it was found that addition of sucrose to the culture medium stimulated branching morphogenesis and reduced lumen distension. Two possible roles of sucrose were postulated: one as a nutrient and another as a generator of osmotic pressure inducing osmosis of water from the lumen fluid to the culture medium across a simple columnar epithelial cell layer. To assess which was the case, branching morphogenesis was investigated in lung rudiments cultured in medium in which osmotic pressure was increased by the addition of lactose or NaCl rather than sucrose: similar acceleration of branching was observed in both. In another experiment, lumen fluid of cultured lung rudiments was mechanically drained each day, and significantly stimulated branching morphogenesis was observed even when sucrose was not added to the culture medium. Heparin is known to induce abnormal lumen distension and inhibits branching morphogenesis. Heparin-induced abnormal morphogenesis was prevented either by the addition of sucrose to the culture medium or by the mechanical drainage of lumen fluid. These results suggest that lumen distension caused by the accumulation of lumen fluid disrupts lung branching morphogenesis in vitro, even when the mechanism of branching morphogenesis is intact.     

Xylose-linked proteoglycan synthesis does not have a primary role in the control of secretory cell differentiation in salivary glands

Xylose-linked proteoglycans, particularly chondroitin sulfate proteoglycan, have been shown to play a significant role in the regulation of salivary gland morphogenesis. The purpose of this study was to determine if xylose-linked proteoglycans are involved in the regulation of differentiation of salivary gland secretory cells. Embryonic rat submandibular salivary gland rudiments were cultured for 120 hr in the presence or absence of 0.75 to 1.0 mM p-nitrophenyl-beta-D-xylopyranoside (beta-D-xyloside), an inhibitor of xylose-linked proteoglycan assembly. beta-D-Xyloside has been shown to block submandibular gland morphogenesis (Thompson and Spooner, 1982). In the present study glandular morphogenesis was blocked in 93.3% of the rudiments cultured in the presence of beta-D-xyloside. However, secretory cell differentiation was observed in 71.4% of those rudiments in which morphogenesis had been inhibited. Biochemical evaluation confirmed that xylose-linked proteoglycan assembly had been inhibited by xyloside. These results indicate that while xylose-linked proteoglycans play a significant role in the control of salivary gland morphogenesis these molecules are not primary regulators for secretory cell differentiation within developing salivary glands.