Synaptonemal complex analysis of X-7 translocations in male mice

The synaptonemal complexes of surface-spread spermatocytes of mice heterozygous for one of two reciprocal translations (R3 and R5) between the X and chromosome 7 have been examined by light and electron microscopy (EM). The break points of R3 were determined to be at 70% of chromosome 7, as measured from the centromere, and at 22% of the X. Translocation quadrivalents were formed almost exclusively. The break points of R5 were at 21% of chromosome 7 as measured from the centromere, and at 83% of the X. There was little indication that the break in the X interfered with sex-chromosome synapsis between the 7X and Y. Univalent Y's were not observed in R3, and only seldom observed (8–14%) in R5. However, in contrast to R3, R5 formed quadrivalents relatively rarely (20% in the EM study of 100 nuclei), and heteromorphic bivalents of 7X-Y and X7-7 quite frequently (72%). Possible causes of this high bivalent frequency are discussed. Light-microscope (LM) analysis alone was found to be inadequate for interpreting synaptic configurations (quadrivalents vs. bivalents) in R5. The LM analysis was further complicated by the occurrence of nonhomologous synapsis in the heteromorphic bivalents of R5, a phenomenon easily recognized and interpreted in the EM portion of the study.     

Nonhomologous synapsis of the sex chromosomes in the heteromorphic bivalents of two X-7 translocations in male mice: R5 and R6

Electron microscopy of pachytene nuclei of mice heterozygous for either of two reciprocal X-7 translocations (R5 or R6) revealed a high frequency of heteromorphic bivalents involving the translocated chromosomes. In both translocations the break was in the proximal third of the 7 and the distal third of the X, but the R5 breaks were closer to the 7 centromere and X telomere than the R6 breaks. In both translocations the 7 frequently synapsed nonhomologously with the X7. In R5 the part of the X to which the 7 synapsed may include a region that synapses with the Y in normal mice. However, in R6 the 7 synapsed with a portion of the X that never synapses with the Y (Synapsis was clearl in the differentiated region). In both translocations the Y synapsed maximally with the X portion of the 7X in those nuclei in which there was nonhomologous synapsis of the 7 with the X7. The Y occasionally synapsed nonhomologously with the 7 portion of the 7X. The behavior of the bivalents suggests that the autosomal portions of the 7X and X7 may alter the behavior of the sex-chromosome portions. Both the nonhomologous synapsis of the Y with the 7X and the timing of events during pachytene have led us to question the homology between the X and Y in this species.     

A new type of nonhomologous synapsis in T(X;4)1R1 translocation male mice

The synaptonemal complexes of T(X;4)1R1 (abbreviated R1) translocation heterozygotes have been examined by electron microscopy and compared with those of two X-7 translocations: R5 and R6. The X chromosome breakpoint of R1 is estimated to lie between 78 and 82% from the proximal end of the X, in the same general region as the R5 and R6 breakpoints. The position of the autosomal breakpoint of R1, like that of R6, is about 30% from the proximal end of the respective autosome. R1 is also similar to R6 in that there is extensive nonhomologous synapsis both in quadrivalents and heteromorphic bivalents. We have recently found that the location of breakpoints with respect to the position of the G-bands appears to be related to the synaptic behavior seen in translocation heterozygotes. If both breaks of a reciprocal translocation lie in G-light bands, as was the case with R5, synapsis is confined to homology. However, if one break lies in or immediately adjacent to a G-dark band, there is nonhomologous synapsis, as occurs with R1 and R6. Comparison of the synaptic behavior of R1 with R5 and R6 leads to the conclusion that this G-band-related nonhomologous synapsis is of a different type than the "synaptic adjustment" phenomenon that has been described by Moses (1977a). This G-band-related nonhomologous synapsis is not substage-specific, but competes with homologous synapsis during zygotene-early pachytene.     

Axial shortening during pachynema unrelated to nonhomologous synapsis

The pachytene behavior of chromosomes participating in quadrivalent formation in male mice heterozygous for T(X;4)7Rl or T(X;4)8Rl was analyzed in electron micrographs of microspread spermatocytes. In each population of nuclei from the translocation heterozygotes, the longest 4X axes were approximately the proportional length expected from the respective contributions of the 4 and the X estimated from breakpoint positions in mitotic chromosomes. However, the 4X axis of these translocation quadrivalents undergoes extensive shortening. In both R7 and R8 the shortest 4X axis observed in the population of nuclei was approximately the length of the normal 4 axis. This equalization of axial lengths suggests that there may be an interchromosomal interaction between synapsed chromosomes. In R8, axial shortening of the 4X occurs as pachynema progresses. In both translocations, shortening is accompanied by twisting of the 4X around the 4. Both axial shortening and twists are characteristics exhibited by chromosomal axes of unequal length as part of the meiotic phenomenon described as "synaptic adjustment" (Moses, 1977). Synaptic adjustment involves, in addition, nonhomologous synapsis, which is delayed until the latter part of pachynema. However, axial shortening in R7 and R8 is not accompanied by nonhomologous synapsis. In R7, nonhomologous synapsis does not occur; in R8, it is confined to quadrivalents in which the 4X axis is near its maximum length (i.e., early). This behavior suggests that axial shortening and nonhomologous synapsis during the progression of pachynema (previously considered collectively under the term "synaptic adjustment") are not necessarily coupled events.     

Sex chromosome configurations in pachytene spermatocytes of an XYY mouse

Karyotypic investigation of a phenotypically normal but sterile male mouse showed the presence of an XYY sex chromosome constitution. The synaptic behaviour of the three sex chromosomes was examined in 65 pachytene cells. The sex chromosomes formed a variety of synaptic configurations: an XYY trivalent (40%); an XY bivalent and Y univalent (38.5%); an X univalent and YY bivalent (13.8%); or X, Y, Y univalence (7.7%). There was considerable variation in the extent of synapsis and some of the associations clearly involved nonhomologous pairing. These observations have been compared with previously published information on chromosome configurations at metaphase I from other XYY males.     

Two new X-autosome Robertsonian translocations in the mouse

The influence of X-autosome Robertsonian (Rb) translocation hemizygosity on meiotic chromosome behaviour was investigated in male mice. Two male fertile translocations [Rb(X.2)2Ad and Rb(X.9)6H] and a male sterile translocation [Rb(X.12)7H] were used. In males of all three Rb translocation types, the acrocentric homologue of the autosome involved in the rearrangement regularly failed at pachytene to pair completely with its partner in the Rb metacentric. The centric end of the acrocentric autosome was found regularly to associate either with the proximal end of the Y chromosome or with the ends of nonhomologous autosomal bivalents; the proportions of cells with such configurations varied between pachytene substages and genotypes. Various other categories of synaptic anomaly, such as nonhomologous synapsis, foldback pairing and interlocks, affected the sex chromosome multivalent in a substantial proportion of cells. In one of the Rb(X.12)7H males screened, an unusual, highly aneuploid spermatocyte that contained trivalent and bivalent configurations was found. Rb translocation hemizygosity did not appear to increase to a significant extent the incidence of X-Y pairing failure at pachytene, although the incidence was elevated at metaphase I in Rb(X.12)7H animals. Overall, a comparison of the frequencies and types of chromosome pairing anomalies did not suggest that these were important factors in the aetiology of infertility in males carrying the Rb(X.12)7H translocation.     

Immunocytogenetics. III. Analysis of trivalent and multivalent configurations in mouse pachytene spermatocytes by human autoantibodies to synaptonemal complexes and kinetochores

Mice heterozygous for one or more Robertsonian (Rb) translocation chromosomes have been used to analyze synaptonemal complex (SC) configurations and kinetochore arrangements in trivalents and multivalents. Rb heterozygosity without arm homologies leads to the formation of heteromorphic trivalents in meiosis I; alternating homology of the chromosome arms produces ringlike or chainlike multivalents. Immunofluorescence double-labeling with human antibodies to SCs and kinetochores was performed on surface-spread pachytene spermatocytes. Both Rb bivalents and Rb trivalents clearly showed that metacentrics possess only one centromere. In heteromorphic trivalent SCs, the nonhomologous kinetochores of the two acrocentrics were closely paired in a cis-configuration and juxtaposed opposite the kinetochore of the metacentric; the latter appeared to be an integral part of the longitudinal SC axis. Meiotic multivalents of interpopulation hybrids included up to 36 chromosome arms. In multivalent SCs, the kinetochores always lay together, with the SC arms arranged away from the central centromere cluster. The paracentromeric regions of the Rb chromosomes appeared to remain unsynapsed on both sides of the centromeres. The SC arms were often linked by end-to-end associations. Following desynapsis of the multivalent SC, the kinetochores of the Rb metacentrics showed a highly nonrandom topologic distribution within the nucleus, reminiscent of their arrangement during synapsis.     

Redundant segments inZea mays detected by translocations of monoploid origin

Twenty-two independently occurring spontaneous reciprocal translocations were isolated from monoploid X diploid crosses in maize and their breakpoints were determined. As 12 of the translocations involved the same two chromosomes and had breakpoints at approximately the same positions (6L. 2–3, 7L. 2–3) and two other translocations appeared to be identical with breakpoints at 2L. 9, 6L. 4, 14 of the 22 translocations probably arose by crossing over within duplicate segments of nonhomologous chromosomes. Thus, at least part of the bivalents seen at diakinesis and chromatid bridges seen at anaphase I in monoploid plants appear to be generated by recombination between redundant chromosome segments. The other eight translocations each occurred once. Because our evidence indicates that recombination between nonhomologous illegitimately synapsed chromosome segments does not occur in maize, these were probably also produced by recombination between redundant segments. If one assumes that their breakpoints also mark regions of interchromosomal redundancy, other conclusions can be reached: A) corn does not contain detectable homoeologous chromosomes, thus it is precently a true diploid, and B) as exchanges giving rise to translocations did not occur in the centromeres or proximal heterochromatin, these regions either do not possess redundancy or are rarely involved in chiasma formation. Furthermore, the duplicated segments in the genome giving rise to translocations in haploid microsporocytes probably have the same serial order with respect to the centromere.This work was partially supported by U.S. Atomic Energy Commission Contract AT(11-1)-2121.     

Meiotic chromosome pairing in fetal oocytes of trisomy 21 human females

The influence of trisomy on meiotic chromosome association and synapsis was studied in oocytes of two trisomy 21 fetuses. The patterns of association of the three chromosomes 21 were determined by analysis of late zygotene to early diplotene fetal oocytes after immunofluorescent staining of synaptonemal complexes. The identity of chromosome 21 was confirmed using FISH with either a whole chromosome 21 paint or an alpha-satellite DNA repeat probe. In both fetuses, a wide variety of configurations was present at pachytene. The most common configurations were a trivalent (35.5% and 51.6% of analyzable cells) and a bivalent plus univalent (62.9% and 45.2%). These different frequencies between the fetuses were not significant. Trivalents showed either triple synapsis or double synapsis with pairing-partner switches. The extent of triple synapsis varied from a short segment, either terminal or interstitial, to the whole chromosome length. Through use of immunofluorescent staining of the centromeres, we identified novel types of abnormal chromosome behavior in trisomy 21 fetal oocytes. Thus, we found that 6/41 trivalents had one of the chromosomes associated "out of register," i.e., in a nonhomologous fashion, with its two homologs. Likewise, we found three cells with bivalent plus univalent configurations, in which the univalent showed self-synapsis. The presence of three copies of chromosome 21 therefore results not only in the formation of complex and highly variable synaptic associations but also causes a significant increase in the occurrence of nonhomologous synapsis in human fetal oocytes.     

Chromosomes and DNA of Mus

Using C-banded preparations of Mus dunni it is possible to study the behavior of constitutive heterochromatin in early stages of meiotic prophase. The X and the Y chromosomes, both of which contain a large amount of heterochromatin, lie apart in leptotene but move toward each other during zygotene. They then form the sex vesicle at late zygotene. In autosomes zygotene pairing appears to start from the telomeric ends. The centromere of the Y chromosome associates end-to-end with the terminal end of the long arm of the X chromosome. The autosomal heterochromatic short arms show forked morphology in certain bivalents at pachytene, suggesting probable incomplete synapsis.     

A re-examination of the case for homology between the X and Y chromosomes of mouse and man

Summary Evidence is presented from the literature which suggests that in mouse and man, (1) synapsis between the X and Y is nonhomologous, (2) crossing over does not regularly occur between the X and Y, but is prevented by precocious desynapsis, and (3) normal disjunction of the X and Y is assured by an achiasmatic end association.     

Cytogenetics of collared lemmings (Dicrostonyx groenlandicus). II. Meiotic behavior of B chromosomes suggests a Y-chromosome origin of supernumerary chromosomes

The patterns of synapsis and chiasma formation of the B chromosomes of male collared lemmings (Dicrostonyx groenlandicus) were analyzed by light and electron microscopy and compared to expectations for various hypotheses for the intragenomic origin of supernumerary chromosomes. Pachytene analysis revealed a variety of synaptic configurations including B-chromosome univalents, bivalents and trivalents. In approximately one-half of the pachytene nuclei examined, B chromosomes were in synaptic associations with the normally unpaired portion of the Y chromosome. The B-chromosome configurations at pachynema, including those involving the Y chromosome, were maintained into diakinesis and metaphase I. The meiotic behavior of the B chromosomes was inconsistent with their derivation from centric-fusion products, isochromosome formation, small-autosome polysomy, or the X chromosome. However, the frequent synapsis and apparent recombination between B chromosomes and the Y chromosome implicate this sex chromosome as a possible source of the B chromosomes in collared lemmings.     

小麦-冰草附加系Ⅱ-21-2的细胞遗传学与分子标记分析

在本研究室获得的一套小麦-冰草附加系材料中,附加了冰草(1.4)重组P染色体的附加系Ⅱ-21-2出现了较高频率的多价体。对小麦-冰草附加系Ⅱ-21-2的10个不同株系花粉母细胞减数分裂进行观察与统计,结果表明,不同株系均存在低频率的单价体,染色体异常联会主要表现为出现六价体和四价体,其中株系1-7-3出现六价体频率较高,出现六价体的花粉母细胞为41%,而株系1-7-7有13%的花粉母细胞出现四价体。小麦SSR标记分析表明,不同株系存在小麦基因组或P基因组的多态性。小麦-冰草附加系Ⅱ-21-2染色体异常联会可能与附加的P染色体有关,而其分子水平的多态性和重组可能对于遗传改良具有潜在的意义。     

Correlation between meiotic behavior and breakpoints with respect to G-bands in two X-4 mouse translocations: T(X;4)7R1 and T(X;4)8R1

The meiotic synaptic behavior of male mice heterozygous for one of two X-4 translocations was examined to test a recently advanced hypothesis (Ashley, 1988) suggesting that it is possible to predict the synaptic behavior (nonhomologous vs. homologous) and recombinational parameters (suppression vs. nonsuppression of crossing-over) of a chromosome aberration from mitotic G-band breakpoint data. The hypothesis was based on prior observations of synaptic behavior in a series of X-autosome translocations in mice. The breakpoints of the translocation T(X;4)7R1 are both in G-light bands. As predicted by the hypothesis, synapsis was restricted to homology. In contrast, one breakpoint of the translocation T(X;4)8R1 lies in a "stippled" band of the standard diagrams of Nesbitt and Francke (1981). As predicted (Ashley, 1988), "stippled" bands are shown here to synapse nonhomologously, i.e., they behave as "G-dark." The linkage data, as they relate to the synaptic data and the predictions of the hypothesis, are also discussed.     

A 45,X male with Y-specific DNA translocated onto chromosome 15.

A 20-year-old male patient with chromosomal constitution 45,X, testes and normal external genitalia was examined. Neither mosaicism nor a structurally aberrant Y chromosome was observed when routine cytogenetic analysis was performed on both lymphocytes and skin fibroblasts. Y chromosome-specific single-copy and repeated DNA sequences were detected in the patient's genome by means of 11 different recombinant-DNA probes of known regional assignment on the human Y chromosome. Data indicated that the short arm, the centromere, and part of the long-arm euchromatin of the Y chromosome have been retained and that the patient lacks deletion intervals 6 and 7 of Yq. High-resolution analysis of prometaphase chromosomes revealed additional euchromatic material on the short arm of one of the patient's chromosomes 15. After in situ hybridization with the Y chromosome-specific probe pDP105, a significant grain accumulation was observed distal to 15p11.2, suggesting a Y/15 chromosomal translocation. We conclude that some 45,X males originate from Y-chromosome/autosome translocations following a break in the proximal long arm of the Y chromosome.     

Persistence of two Y chromosomes through meiotic prophase and metaphase I in an XYY man

Summary Studies of spermatogenesis in an XYY male, presenting at a subfertility clinic, confirm the tendency for the germ cells to lose the second Y chromosome but for some XYY cells to reach metaphase I (MI). Light microscope studies of MI revealed the presence of YY bivalents and EM studies of microspread, silver-stained pachytene stages showed 30% of the cells to have two Y chromosomes; 13 out of 16 of these showing a YY synaptonemal complex. Strikingly, the Y axes show only partial synapsis; in no case was synapsis of the long arm heterochromatic regions apparent.     

The quantitative analysis of chromosome pairing and chiasma formation based on the relative frequencies of M I configurations

In autotetraploids, chromosome pairing may be in the form of quadrivalents or bivalent pairs. Whether or not the quadrivalents are maintained until first meiotic metaphase depends on the formation of chiasmata. The relative frequencies of M I configurations thus contain information both on pairing and on chiasma formation. With distal chiasma localisation six configurations can be recognised and their relative frequencies determined: ring quadrivalents, chain quadrivalents, trivalents (with univalent), ring bivalents, open (rod) bivalents, univalent pairs. These represent five degrees of freedom permitting five parameters to be estimated: the frequency (f) of quadrivalent pairing; the frequencies of chiasmate association of the two ends (arms in metacentrics), a′, b′, after quadrivalent pairing, and a, b after bivalent pairing. — The appropriate formulae have been derived and applied to observations on Tradescantia virginiana (4n=24) which has pronounced distal chiasma localisation. Slight modifications make the model applicable to autotetraploids with interstitial in addition to distal chiasmata. In T. virginiana, chromosome pairing appeared to be random between homologues (65.8% quadrivalent pairing; 55.4% observed at M I). After quadrivalent pairing chiasmate association is frequent in the “average long” arm (95.0%) and much less so in the other arm (60.5%). This is attributed to partner exchange. After bivalent pairing chiasma frequencies are still different for the two arms (93.8% and 83.5% association respectively) but much less pronounced. Various complications are discussed.     

Identification and analysis of DYAD: a gene required for meiotic chromosome organisation and female meiotic progression in Arabidopsis

The dyad mutant of Arabidopsis was previously identified as being defective in female meiosis. We report here the analysis of the DYAD gene. In ovules and anthers DYAD RNA is detected specifically in female and male meiocytes respectively, in premeiotic interphase/meiotic prophase. Analysis of chromosome spreads in female meiocytes showed that in the mutant, chromosomes did not undergo synapsis and formed ten univalents instead of five bivalents. Unlike mutations in AtDMC1 and AtSPO11 which also affect bivalent formation as the univalent chromosomes segregate randomly, the dyad univalents formed an ordered metaphase plate and underwent an equational division. This suggests a requirement for DYAD for chromosome synapsis and centromere configuration in female meiosis. The dyad mutant showed increased and persistent expression of a meiosis-specific marker, pAtDMC1::GUS during female meiosis, indicative of defective meiotic progression. The sequence of the putative protein encoded by DYAD did not reveal strong similarity to other proteins. DYAD is therefore likely to encode a novel protein required for meiotic chromosome organisation and female meiotic progression.     

The maize desynaptic1 mutation disrupts meiotic chromosome synapsis

In most eukaryotes, homologous chromosomes undergo synapsis during the first meiotic prophase. A consequence of mutations that interfere with the fidelity or completeness of synapsis can be failure in the formation or maintenance of bivalents, resulting in univalent formation at diakinesis and production of unbalanced spores or gametes. Such mutations, termed desynaptic mutations, can result in complete or partial sterility. We have examined the effect of the maize desynaptic1-9101 mutation on synapsis, using the nuclear spread technique and electron microscopy to examine microsporocytes ranging from early pachytene until the diplotene stage of prophase I. Throughout the pachytene stage, there was an average of about 10 sites of lateral element divergence (indicating nonhomologous synapsis), and during middle and late pachytene, an average of two and three sites of foldback (intrachromosomal) synapsis, per mutant nucleus, respectively. By the diplotene stage, the number of sites of lateral element divergence had decreased to seven, and there was an average of one foldback synapsis site per nucleus. Lateral element divergence and foldback synapsis were not found in spread pachytene nuclei from normal plants. These results imply that the normal expression of the dsy1 gene is essential for the restriction of chromosome synapsis to homologues. The abundance of nonhomologous synapsis and the persistence of extended stretches of unsynapsed axial elements throughout the pachytene stage of dsy1–9101 meiocytes suggests that this mutation disrupts both the fidelity of homology search and the forward course of the synaptic process. This mutation may identify a maize mismatch repair gene. Dev. Genet. 21:146–159, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.