Myogenic cells of regenerating adult chicken muscle can fuse into myotubes after a single cell division in vivo

Autoradiographic studies were carried out on regenerating muscles of adult chickens. Three different muscles of hens were injured, and tritiated thymidine (1 microCi/g) was injected at various times after injury to label replicating muscle precursors. Detailed comparisons of grain counts over premitotic nuclei in samples removed one hour after injection of tritiated thymidine, and of postmitotic myotube nuclei in samples removed 10 days after injury (when labeled precursors had fused to form myotubes), revealed how many times some labeled precursors had divided before fusing into myotubes. DNA synthesis in muscle precursors was initiated 30 h after injury. Grain counts of myotube nuclei indicated that many muscle precursors labeled at the onset of myogenic cell proliferation had divided only once, or twice, before fusing into myotubes. The relationship of these in vivo results to the cell lineage model of myogenesis is discussed.     

A model of myogenesis in vivo,derived from detailed autoradiographic studies of regenerating skeletal muscle,challenges the concept of quantal mitosis

Summary We have recently shown that myogenesis following severe injury is prolonged compared with minor injury (McGeachie and Grounds 1987). In this previous autoradiographic study 44 mice were injected with tritiated thymidine at various times after muscle injury (0 to 120 h), and samples were taken 9d after injury to determine the percentage of labelled myotube nuclei. In the present study the same experimental data are analysed in detail to reveal how many times labelled muscle precursors divided before fusing to form myotubes.Additional mice were prepared and samples removed 1 h after injection of tritiated thymidine to determine the maximum grain counts of premitotic nuclei. When a labelled premitotic nucleus divides, each of the two daughter nuclei will contain half of the original label. The grain counts of nuclei resulting from sequential divisions of a maximally labelled premitotic nucleus, forms the basis for our detailed analysis which can reveal how many times a muscle precursor has divided after labelling.Nine days after injury the autoradiographic grain counts of labelled myotube nuclei were analysed in detail. The results describe an in vivo model of myogenesis which we use to evaluate quantitatively observations derived from tissue culture studies. The analysis shows that, at the onset of myogenesis in regenerating muscle (30 h after injury), muscle precursors divide only twice before fusing to form myotubes. This observation challenges the concept of quantal mitosis as defined by the tissue culture studies of Quinn et al. (1984, 1985).     

An autoradiographic study of satellite cell differentiation into regenerating myotubes following transplantation of muscles in young rats

Summary Satellite cells were traced autoradiographically during the regeneration of skeletal muscle in young Sprague-Dawley rats. Approximately 31% of the satellite cells in uninjured muscles appeared labelled after three injections of tritiated thymidine; none of the myonuclei were labelled in the same muscles. Four to six days after transplanting the radioactive muscles to non-radioactive littermates, regenerating myotube nuclei in the host appeared labelled. Thus, this study confirms that satellite cells in young rats can differentiate into multinucleated myotubes following muscle injury.Supported by NIH grant No. 5 S01-RR05356-13I wish to acknowledge the excellent technical assistance of Ms. Amy Erisman     

An autoradiographic study of the role of satellite cells and myonuclei during myogenesis in vitro

Satellite cells and myonuclei of neonatal rat muscles were differentially labeled with 3H-thymidine according to the procedure of Moss and Leblond (1971). Minced muscles fragments containing either labeled satellite cells or labeled myonuclei were cultured until multinucleated myotubes grew out from the explants. Reutilzation of isotope released from degenerating nuclei was competitively inhibited by using a culture medium containing excess (0.32-0.41 mM) cold thymidine. after an 8-10 day growth period, the explants were fixed and prepared for autoradiographic (ARG) examination to determine whether labeled satellite cells or myonuclei had contributed to the myonuclear population of the developing myotubes. Counts were made of the number of labeled myotubes in the explants and compared with the number of labeled satellite cells and myonuclei in samples of the original muscle tissues fixed at the time of explantation. The original muscles showed a mean satellite cell labeling index of 51.7% and gave rise to myotubes with a mean labeling incidence of 40%. In contrast, myonuclear labeling in the original muscle tissues showed no correlation with subsequent myotube labeling. Only 3.4% myotube labeling was found in explants in which over 30% of the original tissue myonuclei had been labeled. Under conditions controlled for isotope reutilization, these observations confirm results of in vivo ARG studies indicating that satellite cells are the only significant source of regenerating myoblasts in injured muscle tissue.     

A comparison of muscle precursor replication in crush-injured skeletal muscle of Swiss and BALBc mice

Summary Muscle precursor replication in Swiss mice, in which muscle regeneration is exceptionally vigorous, was compared with previous data for regeneration in BALBc mice. The tibialis anterior muscles of 23 male and 15 female inbred Swiss SJL/J mice were crush injured, and tritiated thymidine injected into mice at various times after injury to label replicating muscle precursors. Lesion samples were taken 10 days after injury, processed for autoradiography, and grain counts of myotube nuclei analysed. Muscle regeneration was more vigorous in male compared with female Swiss mice, and in both was strikingly greater than that in BALBc mice in which there was extensive fibrous connective tissue throughout the lesions. Autoradiographic analysis showed that muscle precursor replication started at 24 hours in Swiss mice, 6 hours earlier than the onset at 30 hours in BALBc mice. Muscle precursor replication appeared to be more active 96 hours after injury in female Swiss compared with male BALBc and male Swiss mice respectively, although numbers of precursor cells replicating at other times were similar. It is not known whether the slight difference in onset of muscle precursor replication can alone account for the more complete muscle regeneration seen in Swiss mice. Similar studies were carried out in 11 male and 10 female F₁ hybrid (SJL/J x BALBc) mice. Analysis of labelled myotube nuclei showed that muscle precursors did not synthesise DNA prior to 30 hours after injury, and regeneration resembled that of the parental BALBc strain.     

Reutilisation of tritiated thymidine in studies of regenerating skeletal muscle

Summary Two different aspects of tritiated thymidine (³H-Tdr) reutilisation in skeletal muscle were examined. Injection of a high dose (7 Ci/g) of ³H-Tdr into mice prior to crush injury of skeletal muscle resulted in heavy labelling (grain counts) of myotube nuclei 9 d later. In contrast, myotube nuclei were essentially unlabelled when a low dose (1 Ci/g) of ³H-Tdr was injected at similar times with respect to injury. It was concluded that labelling seen after the high dose was due to reutilisation of ³H-Tdr. (Such ³H-Tdr reutilisation can account for the results of Sloper et al. (1970) which previously supported the concept of a circulating muscle precursor cell.) When replicating muscle precursors were labelled directly with ³H-Tdr 48 h after injury, the percentages of labelled myotube nuclei and the distribution of nuclear grain counts were similar with either high or low dose.We also investigated whether the light labelling seen in regenerated myotube nuclei after 9 d, when ³H-Tdr had been injected before the onset of myogenesis (as found by McGeachie and Grounds 1987), was due to ³H-Tdr reutilisation or, alternatively, to proliferation of local cells in the wound which subsequently gave rise to muscle precursors. Labelling of myotube nuclei was compared in mice injected with ³H-Tdr either 2 h before, or 2 h after injury. In another experiment, mice were injected 12 h after injury and lesions sampled 1, 12 or 36 h later, to see whether local cells were replicating 12 h after injury, and what labelled cells subsequently entered to wound. No difference was found in myotube labelling between mice injected before or after injury, and no cells replicating locally in the wound at 12 h after injury were observed. The results clearly show that the light labelling was due to ³H-Tdr reutilisation.     

Myonuclear birthdates distinguish the origins of primary and secondary myotubes in embryonic mammalian skeletal muscles

Myotubes were isolated from enzymically disaggregated embryonic muscles and examined with light microscopy. Primary myotubes were seen as classic myotubes with chains of central nuclei within a tube of myofilaments, whereas secondary myotubes had a smaller diameter and more widely spaced nuclei. Primary myotubes could also be distinguished from secondary myotubes by their specific reaction with two monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) against adult slow myosin heavy chain (MHC). Myonuclei were birth dated with [3H]thymidine autoradiography or with 2-bromo-5'-deoxyuridine (BrdU) detected with a commercial monoclonal antibody. After a single pulse of label during the 1-2 day period when primary myotubes were forming, some primary myotubes had many myonuclei labelled, usually in adjacent groups, while in others no nuclei were labelled. If a pulse of label was administered after this time labelled myonuclei appeared in most secondary myotubes, while primary myotubes received few new nuclei. Labelled and unlabelled myonuclei were not grouped in the secondary myotubes, but were randomly interspersed. We conclude that primary myotubes form by a nearly synchronous fusion of myoblasts with similar birthdates. In contrast, secondary myotubes form in a progressive fashion, myoblasts with asynchronous birthdates fusing laterally with secondary myotubes at random positions along their length. These later-differentiating myoblasts do not fuse with primary myotubes, despite being closely apposed to their surface. Furthermore, they do not generally fuse with each other, as secondary myotube formation is initiated only in the region of the primary myotube endplate.     

Evidence for fusion of myoblasts in amphibian embryos. I. Homoplastic transplantations of somitic material labeled with tritiated thymidine

In order to obtain more direct evidence for the occurrence of myoblast fusion in the developing amphibian embryo, the following transplantations were performed in vitro. The nuclei of early embryos. Ambystoma tigrinum and A. maculatum, were labeled with tritiated thymidine. Portions of prospective somite areas from these labeled donors were grafted homoplastically and orthotopically into unlabeled hosts of the same, or nearly the same, stage. The stages employed were: neurula, early tail bud, and late tail bud. Hosts were raised until they had developed into more advanced larval forms, fixed, sectioned, and prepared for radioautographic processing according to the customary procedures. The histological preparations contained varying numbers of multinucleate myotubes of a “composite” nature: that is, individual myotubes contained labeled nuclei of the donor, side by side with unlabeled nuclei of the host. There was no doubt that the mononucleate myoblasts of the grafts had fused with those of the host species to form the mutlinucleate composite myotubes. In addition to the above determinations, the method of thymidine labeling has proven to be a satisfactory method of tracing, in the context of the intact organism, somitic cell derivatives up to the feeding larval stage. Mesenchymal cells from the grafted labeled somitic tissues were consequently found in: dermatomic, sclerotomic and intermyotomic locations; the matrix of the dorsal fin; the limb bud; the abdominal muscles.     

Cellular differences in the regeneration of murine skeletal muscle: a quantitative histological study in SJL/J and BALB/c mice

Summary Skeletal muscle regeneration in SJL/J and BALB/c mice subjected to identical crush injuries is markedly different: in SJL/J mice myotubes almost completely replace damaged myofibres, whereas BALB/c mice develop fibrotic scar tissue and few myotubes. To determine the cellular changes which contribute to these differential responses to injury, samples of crushed tibialis anterior muscles taken from SJL/J and BALB/c mice between 1 and 10 days after injury were analysed by light and electron microscopy, and by autoradiography. Longitudinal muscle sections revealed about a 2-fold greater total mononuclear cell density in SJL/J than BALB/c mice at 2 to 3 days after injury. Electron micrographs identified a similar proportion of cell types at 3 days after injury. Autoradiographic studies showed that the proportions of replicating mononuclear cells in both strains were similar: therefore greater absolute numbers of cells (including muscle precursors and macrophages) were proliferating in SJL/J muscle. Removal of necrotic muscle debris in SJL/J mice was rapid and extensive, and by 6 to 8 days multinucleated myotubes occupied a large part of the lesion. By contrast, phagocytosis was less effective in BALB/c mice, myotube formation was minimal, and fibrotic tissue conspicuous. These data indicate that the increased mononuclear cell density, more efficient removal of necrotic muscle, together with a greater capacity for myotube formation in SJL/J mice, contribute to the more successful muscle regeneration seen after injury.     

Regional injury and the terminal differentiation of satellite cells in stretched avian slow tonic muscle.

In the avian stretch model, the application of a weight overload to the humerus induces enlargement of the anterior latissimus dorsi (ALD) muscle and an increase in muscle fiber number which is accompanied by satellite cell activation. Myofiber injury may be an important stimulus to muscle fiber hyperplasia; therefore, light and electron microscopic evaluation was undertaken to determine if myofiber injury occurs in the stretch-enlarged ALD muscle of the adult quail. Autoradiographic studies were used to determine the terminal differentiation of labeled myogenic cells. A weight equal to 10% of body mass was attached to one wing of 27 adult quail and 3 birds were euthanized at 9 intervals of stretch, from 1 to 30 days. Birds were injected with tritiated thymidine at intervals ranging from 1 hr to 3 days prior to euthanization. Labeled nuclei were detected by light microscopic examination and identified by electron microscopy of a serial section. Three regions of the muscle were examined for disorganization of contractile elements, presence of cytoplasmic vacuoles, and/or phagocytic cell infiltration. The percentage of fibers exhibiting one or more of these criterion was significantly greater in the stretched ALD by Days 5 and 7 and declined at Day 10, reaching near control values by Day 14. Myofiber necrosis and phagocytic cell infiltration were only observed in the middle and distal regions of the stretched ALD muscle. Traditional signs of regeneration and repair were observed, including clusters of labeled myoblast-like cells and myotube formation within an existing basal lamina. New myotube formation with labeled central nuclei was also noted in the interstitial space, outside of basal lamina of persisting fibers. Labeled myonuclei were observed in the stretched fibers. These results demonstrate that chronic stretch produces regional injury and fiber degeneration and resultant regeneration in the ALD muscle of the adult quail. This may be an important stimulus for new fiber formation in this model.     

Sustained cell proliferation in denervated skeletal muscle of mice

Summary Cellular proliferation in skeletal muscle was measured throughout the first 4 weeks after denervation. Twenty four mice had one leg denervated, and 4 groups of 6 of these mice were injected with tritiated thymidine once daily for 7 days, either during the first, second, third or fourth week after denervation. Autoradiographic labelling of muscle and connective tissue nuclei in denervated muscles was compared with innervated muscles from the opposite innervated legs of the same mice. Labelling of connective tissue and muscle (myonuclear and satellite cell) nuclei was significantly higher in denervated muscles, compared with innervated muscles on the unoperated side. There were no significant differences among labelling of nuclei in muscles denervated for 1, 2, 3 or 4 weeks. However, connective tissue labelling after 1 week of denervation was significantly higher than at later times. This study shows that nuclei of muscle and connective tissue cells proliferate and turnover at high levels for at least one month after denervation.     

DNA synthesis and the cell cycle in cultures of normal and mutant (mdg/mdg) embryonic mouse muscle cells.

The relationship between cell fusion, DNA synthesis and the cell cycle in cultured embryonic normal and dysgenic ($\text{mdg}\text{mdg}$) mouse muscle cells has been determined by autoradiography. The experimental evidence shows that the homozygous mutant myotubes form by a process of cell fusion and that nuclei within the myotubes do not synthesize DNA or undergo mitotic or amitotic division. The duration of the total cell cycle and its component phases was statistically the same in 2-day normal and mutant ($\text{mdg}\text{mdg}$) myogenic cultures with the approximate values: T, 21.5 hr; G₁, 10.5 hr; S, 7.5 hr; and G₂, 2.5 hr. In both kinds of cultures, labeled nuclei appeared in myotubes 15–16 hr after mononucleated cells were exposed to [³H]thymidine, and the rate of incorporation of labeled nuclei into multinucleated muscle cells was comparable in control and dysgenic cultures. Thus, homozygous $\text{mdg}\text{mdg}$ muscle cells in culture are similar to control cells with respect to their mechanism of myotube formation and the coordinate regulation of DNA synthesis and the cell cycle during myogenesis.     

A KINETIC ANALYSIS OF MYOGENESIS IN VITRO

Conditions which yielded reproducible growth kinetics with extensive, relatively synchronous differentiation are described for chick muscle cultures. The effects of cell density and medium changes on the timing of cell fusion were examined. Low-density cultures which received a change of medium at 24 hr after plating show the highest rate of cell fusion, increasing from 15 to 80% fused cells in a 10 hr period. These optimal culture conditions were employed to reexamine two questions from the earlier literature on muscle culture: (a) can cells which normally would fuse at the end of one cell cycle be forced to go through another cell cycle before fusion; and (b) how soon after its final S period can a cell complete fusion? In answer to the first question, it was found that if the medium is changed, many cells which would otherwise fuse can be made to undergo another cell cycle before fusion. In the second case, radioautographs were made from cultures incubated with tritiated thymidine for various times at the beginning of the fusion period. These show labeled nuclei in myotubes as early as 3 hr after the beginning of the incubation period. This indicates that cells can fuse as early as the beginning of the G₁ period, and suggests that there is not an obligatory exit from the cell cycle or a prolonged G₁ period before cell fusion and differentiation during myogenesis.     

CELL POPULATION KINETICS OF AN OSTEOGENIC TISSUE · II

A study of the cell kinetics on the actively growing periosteal surface of the femur of rabbits aged 2 weeks has been continued. A single injection of tritiated thymidine was given and the rabbits killed from 1 hour to 4 days after injection. The grain count spectra of the different cell types, pre-osteoblast, osteoblast, and osteocyte, have been compared at different times after injection. The results showed evidence for the uptake of thymidine in nuclei which is not associated with cell division. A small percentage of osteoblasts was initially labeled at 1 hour and there was evidence that the majority of these had not divided by 3 or 4 days after injection. Some thymidine-labeled cells had also become osteocytes without division. Furthermore, it appeared that a considerable fraction of the initially labeled pre-osteoblasts did not divide. The S period for the pre-osteoblasts and osteoblasts was measured using a double-labeled thymidine technique.     

Regulation of specific developmental fates of larval- and adult-type muscles during metamorphosis of the frog Xenopus

During anuran metamorphosis, larval-type myotubes in both trunk and tail are removed by apoptosis, and only trunk muscles are replaced by newly formed adult-type myotubes. In the present study, we clarified the regulatory mechanisms for specific developmental fates of adult and larval muscles. Two distinct (adult and larval) types of myoblasts were found to exist in the trunk, but no or very few adult myoblasts were found in the tail. Each type of myoblast responded differently to metamorphic trigger, 3,3',5-triiodo-L-thyronine (T(3)) in vitro. T(3)-induced cell death was observed in larval myoblasts but not in adult myoblasts. These results suggest that the fates (life or death) of trunk and tail muscles are determined primarily by the differential distribution of adult myoblasts within the muscles. However, a transplantation study clarified that each larval and adult myoblast was not committed to fuse into particular myotube types, and they could form heterokaryon myotubes in vivo. Cell culture experiments suggested that the following two mechanisms are involved in the specification of myotube fate: (1) Heterokaryon myotubes could escape T(3)-induced death only when the proportion of adult nuclei number was higher than 70% in the myotubes. Apoptosis was not observed in any larval nuclei within the surviving heterokaryon myotubes, suggesting the conversion of larval nuclei fate. (2) Differentiation of adult myoblasts was promoted by the factor(s) released from larval myoblasts in a cell type-specific manner. Taken together, the developmental fate of myotubes is determined by the ratio of nuclei types, and the formation of adult nuclei-rich myotubes was specifically enhanced by larval myoblast factor(s).     

Image analysis of rat satellite cell proliferation in vitro

Myogenic cells were isolated from adult rat skeletal muscles and cultured in vitro. Cell proliferation was analyzed between days 1 and 14. The cell cycle phases were determined by examining Feulgen-stained cultures with a cell image processor. The nuclei were automatically analyzed by calculating 18 parameters relating to the texture and densitometry of chromatin and the shape of each nucleus. Cell cycle phases were characterized (Moustafa and Brugal, 1984). The recognition methods made it possible to analyse the nuclei of the myogenic cell populations which were either involved in each phase of the mitotic cycle, or left out of the cycle after fusion into myotubes.After 3 hr of culture 10% of the cell population was involved in the cell cycle. In the presence of foetal calf serum, this percentage increased until day 3 after plating. At that time, the DNA content of 28.2% of the cell population was higher than 3C, whereas it is 2C in G1 or G0 nuclei; image analysis showed that 42% of these cells were in S or G2 phase. From day 4, the proliferation rate gradually slowed down until day 8. After day 8, when numerous myotubes differentiated, the percentage of S and G2 phase cells had diminished to between 3 and 8%. The percentage of nuclei in G0 increased when the first myotubes differentiated around day 5. Myotube nuclei were largely in G0. When horse serum was added to the culture medium on day 4 to enhance myotube differentiation, significant cell proliferation was observed before cell fusion.These methods of analysis give the first daily pattern of myogenic cell proliferation and fusion in a cell population isolated from adult muscles.     

Neural determination of muscle fibre numbers in embryonic rat lumbrical muscles

The generation and development of muscle cells in the IVth hindlimb lumbrical muscle of the rat was studied following total or partial denervation. Denervation was carried out by injection of beta-bungarotoxin (beta-BTX), a neurotoxin which binds to and destroys peripheral nerves. Primary myotubes were generated in denervated muscles and reached their normal stable number on embryonic day 17 (E17). This number was not maintained and denervated muscles examined on E19 or E21 contained many degenerating primary myotubes. Embryos injected with beta-bungarotoxin (beta-BTX) on E12 or E13 suffered a partial loss of motoneurones, resulting in a reduced number of axons in the L4 ventral root (the IVth lumbrical muscle is supplied by axons in L4, L5 and L6 ventral roots) and reduced numbers of nerve terminals in the intrinsic muscles of the hindfoot. Twitch tension measurements showed that all myotubes in partly innervated muscles examined on E21 contracted in response to nerve stimulation. Primary myotubes were formed and maintained at normal numbers in muscles with innervation reduced throughout development, but a diminished number of secondary myotubes formed by E21. The latter was correlated with a reduction in number of mononucleate cells within the muscles. If beta-BTX was injected on E18 to denervate muscles after primary myotube formation was complete, E21 embryo muscles contained degenerating primary myotubes. After injection to denervate muscles on E19, the day secondary myotubes begin to form, E21 muscles possessed normal numbers of primary myotubes. In both cases, secondary myotube formation had stopped about 1 day after the injection and the number of mononucleate cells was greatly reduced, indicating that cessation of secondary myotube generation was most probably due to exhaustion of the supply of competent myoblasts. We conclude that nerve terminals regulate the number of secondary myotubes by stimulating mitosis in a nerve-dependent population of myoblasts and that activation of these myoblasts requires the physical presence of nerve terminals as well as activation of contraction in primary myotubes.     

Cellular insertion of primary and secondary myotubes in embryonic rat muscles

Mammalian muscles develop from two populations of myotubes; primary myotubes appear first and are few in number; secondary myotubes appear later and form most of the muscle fibres. We have made an ultrastructural study to investigate how primary and secondary myotubes in embryonic rat muscles transmit tension during the period of their development. Primary myotubes extend from end to end of the muscle from the earliest times, and attach directly to the tendon. In contrast, newly formed secondary myotubes are short cells which insert solely into the primary myotubes by a series of complex interdigitating folds along which adhering junctions occur. As the secondary myotubes lengthen and mature, their insertion is progressively transferred from the primary myotube to the tendon proper. We suggest that this variable insertion of immature secondary myotubes, combined with complex patterns of innervation and electrical coupling in developing muscle, makes it difficult to predict the overall contribution of secondary myotubes to muscle tension development. This work extends other studies showing the unique relationship between a primary myotube and its associated secondary myotubes, indicating that these may constitute a developmental compartment.     

Myotube Formation on Micro-patterned Glass: Intracellular Organization and Protein Distribution in C2C12 Skeletal Muscle Cells

Proliferation and fusion of myoblasts are needed for the generation and repair of multinucleated skeletal muscle fibers in vivo. Studies of myocyte differentiation, cell fusion, and muscle repair are limited by an appropriate in vitro muscle cell culture system. We developed a novel cell culture technique [two-dimensional muscle syncytia (2DMS) technique] that results in formation of myotubes, organized in parallel much like the arrangement in muscle tissue. This technique is based on UV lithography–produced micro-patterned glass on which conventionally cultured C2C12 myoblasts proliferate, align, and fuse to neatly arranged contractile myotubes in parallel arrays. Combining this technique with fluorescent microscopy, we observed alignment of actin filament bundles and a perinuclear distribution of glucose transporter 4 after myotube formation. Newly formed myotubes contained adjacently located MyoD-positive and MyoD-negative nuclei, suggesting fusion of MyoD-positive and MyoD-negative cells. In comparison, the closely related myogenic factor Myf5 did not exhibit this pattern of distribution. Furthermore, cytoplasmic patches of MyoD colocalized with bundles of filamentous actin near myotube nuclei. At later stages of differentiation, all nuclei in the myotubes were MyoD negative. The 2DMS system is thus a useful tool for studies on muscle alignment, differentiation, fusion, and subcellular protein localization. (J Histochem Cytochem 56:881–892, 2008)