How does fertility of the substrate affect intraspecific competition? Evidence and synthesis from self-thinning

When dense populations of even-aged plant monocultures are subject to intense competition, mortality can occur in a process known as self-thinning, in which changes in biomass are accompanied by decreases in density. On a plot of log biomass versus log density, self-thinning populations show a linear relationship called the self-thinning line. Variations in the fertility level of the substrate are known to affect self-thinning in a number of ways. Populations from substrates with different fertility levels have been observed to self-thin along the same line, or along different lines. A review of several experiments using the one species grown at different fertility levels was undertaken to look for any mechanisms that might account for the different patterns observed. It was postulated that the critical difference between whether populations followed a common or different line was the way in which competition developed in the stands as biomass accumulated. For the common-line pattern, data on the canopy volume required to support a given biomass showed that biomass packing did not differ between fertility levels, supporting the model of a common competitive mechanism operating at all fertility levels. When different lines were observed, the development of competition differed as plants increased in size and biomass accumulated at each fertility level. Over the upper range of fertility levels, biomass packing values per plant increased as fertility declined and the position of self-thinning lines followed predictions from biomass packing data. At the low end of the fertility scale, biomass packing values still decreased with fertility level, but the position of self-thinning lines was not linked to the biomass packing of individual plants: root interactions were presumed to dominate competition and the trajectory of self-thinning lines.     

Density-dependent Mortality Induced by Low Nutrient Status of the Substrate

The hypothesis that changing the fertility level of the substratewould change the self-thinning line (different slope or intercept)followed by high-density populations was tested by sowing populationsof Ocimum basilicum L. at two densities on a soil-based pottingmix adjusted to three fertility levels (F0, F1 and F2). Fertilitylevel significantly affected the slope of the thinning linesfor both shoot and root biomass. For shoot biomass, more mortalityoccurred per unit increase in biomass as fertility level declined(the slope of the thinning line became flatter). The slope ofthe log shoot biomassvs. log density relationship was -0.5 atthe F2-, zero at the F1-, and 0.94 at the F0-fertility. Forthe log root biomassvs. log density lines, slopes were zeroat the F2- and F0-fertility levels, and -0.32 at F1. Packingof shoot biomass into canopies of individual plants correlatedwell with observed exponents of self-thinning lines at the F2-and F1-fertility level. Plants at the F2-fertility level requiredmore canopy space to support a given shoot biomass than plantsat F1, indicating that shoot competition was more intense atthe F2-fertility level for a given biomass. Leaf area indexand size inequality also increased with fertility level fora given shoot biomass. Density-dependent mortality in populationsgrown at the F0-fertility level was highly unusual in havinga positive slope for the shoot biomass vs. density relationship.Shoot growth per plant was static as density declined in theF0-populations; however, root growth per plant increased. Allmeasurements of shoot growth (mass, height, canopy extension,leaf area) remained static in the F0-populations: root massand length increased in comparison. It is argued that root competitionbecame sufficiently intense to cause the density-dependent mortalityseen at the F0-fertility level, with little contribution ofshoot competition to mortality. Copyright 1999 Annals of BotanyCompany Ocimum basilicum, self-thinning, root competition, shoot competition, fertility level and competition, density-dependent mortality, allometric self-thinning.     

Effect of Localized Placement of Nutrients on Root Competition in Self-thinning Populations

The hypothesis that increased root competition can lower theslope and/or intercept of the self-thinning line traversed byplant populations was tested using localized placement of nutrientsto increase root competition. Localized placement of nutrientswill result in increased root competition, if average inter-rootdistances are reduced, and if nutrients are in limiting supply.It was predicted that high-density, nutrient-limited populationsof Ocimum basilicum L. grown with localized placement of nutrientswould self-thin along a lower biomass–density line thannon-localized controls. This was tested at two fertility levelson a soil-based potting medium in expt 1, and at one fertilitylevel on washed sand in expt 2. Localized placement of nutrients significantly reduced the elevation(intercept) of the self-thinning line for both shoot and rootbiomass in expt 2. In expt 1, at the higher-fertility level,localized placement of nutrients had no significant effect;at the lower fertility level, localization had no significanteffect on thinning lines for shoot biomass, and resulted ina zero slope of the thinning line for root biomass. Canopy-based models of self-thinning failed to account for thereduction in the thinning-line intercept observed in expt 2.In both experiments, localized placement of nutrients resultedin a higher proportion of total root length being located inthe localization zone, which would result in a reduction inthe average inter-root distance. This would intensify root competitionunder conditions of nutrient limitation. The hypothesis thatintensified root competition would lower the self-thinning lineis supported by the results of expt 2. Localized placement of nutrients; root competition; shoot competition; root–shoot allocation; self-thinning; Ocimum basilicum ; sweet basil     

Effect of Water Deficit on Self-thinning Line in Spring Wheat （Triticum aestivum L.） Populations

Monocultures of spring wheat （Triticum aestivum L.） were grown at overcrowded densities （10 000 and 3 000 plants per m^2） under well-watered and water-stressed conditions to investigate the effects of water deficits on self-thinning. The results showed that density reduction in water-stressed populations was delayed compared with that In well-watered populations. Populations grown In well-watered conditions conformed to the -3/2- power law. Compared with the well-watered condition, there was no significant decrease of the self-thinning line under water-stressed conditions In this experiment, although the rate of average shoot blomass accumulatlon decreased. This result Implied that the exponent of the -3/2-power equation Is not as sensitive as the rate of average shoot blomass accumulation to water stress. Further analysis indicated that, In each density treatment, the lines of the height versus shoot blomass relationships did not differ significantly between the two water conditions. However, the Intercepts of the height versus shoot blomass relationships were greater In the higher-density populations （10 000/m^2） than those In the lower-density populations （3 000/m^2）. These results showed that water deficit did not change plant geometry In this experiment. That Is to say, shoot competition for light remains constant at a given blomass, although root competition for water becomes more serious In water deficit conditions. Based on these results and previous reports we propose that, to affect the thinning line slope, changes In symmetric competition are not as efficient as changes In asymmetric competition.     

Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi alter plant allometry and biomass-density relationships

Background and Aims

Plant biomass–density relationships during self-thinning are determined mainly by allometry. Both allometry and biomass–density relationship have been shown to vary with abiotic conditions, but the effects of biotic interactions have not been investigated. Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) can promote plant growth and affect plant form. Here experiments were carried out to test whether AMF affect plant allometry and the self-thinning trajectory.

Methods

Two experiments were conducted on Medicago sativa L., a leguminous species known to be highly dependent on mycorrhiza. Two mycorrhizal levels were obtained by applying benomyl (low AMF) or not (high AMF). Experiment 1 investigated the effects of AMF on plant growth in the absence of competition. Experiment 2 was a factorial design with two mycorrhizal levels and two plant densities (6000 and 17 500 seeds m⁻²). Shoot biomass, root biomass and canopy radius were measured 30, 60, 90 and 120 d after sowing. The allometric relationships among these aspects of size were estimated by standardized major axis regression on log-transformed data.

Key Results

Shoot biomass in the absence of competition was lower under low AMF treatment. In self-thinning populations, the slope of the log (mean shoot biomass) vs. log density relationship was significantly steeper for the high AMF treatment (slope = –1·480) than for the low AMF treatment (–1·133). The canopy radius–biomass allometric exponents were not significantly affected by AMF level, but the root–shoot allometric exponent was higher in the low AMF treatment. With a high level of AMF, the biomass–density exponent can be predicted from the above-ground allometric model of self-thinning, while this was not the case when AMF were reduced by fungicide.

Conclusions

AMF affected the importance of below-ground relative to above-ground interactions and changed root vs. shoot allocation. This changed allometric allocation of biomass and altered the self-thinning trajectory.     

Effects of positive interactions, size symmetry of competition and abiotic stress on self-thinning in simulated plant populations

Background and Aims

Competition drives self-thinning (density-dependent mortality) in crowded plant populations. Facilitative interactions have been shown to affect many processes in plant populations and communities, but their effects on self-thinning trajectories have not been investigated.

Methods

Using an individual-based ‘zone-of-influence’ model, we studied the potential effects of the size symmetry of competition, abiotic stress and facilitation on self-thinning trajectories in plant monocultures. In the model, abiotic stress reduced the growth of all individuals and facilitation ameliorated the effects of stress on interacting individuals.

Key Results

Abiotic stress made the log biomass – log density relationship during self-thinning steeper, but this effect was reduced by positive interactions among individuals. Size-asymmetric competition also influenced the self-thinning slope.

Conclusions

Although competition drives self-thinning, its course can be affected by abiotic stress, facilitation and competitive symmetry.     

Survivorship,growth and self-thinning in Banksia ericifolia

High-density (dense) and low-density (sparse) plots were set up in naturally sown monospecific stands of Banksia ericifolia in coastal heath, 3 years after fire. This was done both in high-growth and low-growth areas. Plant mortality was recorded quarterly, and two harvests were made at 6 and 9 years to sample growth. Density-independent mortality at an exponential rate was observed in the low-growth treatments at both densities, and in the high-growth sparse treatment. Growth level affected mortality, with the half-life of populations in the high-growth sparse plots being double that of populations in the low-growth plots. Density-dependent mortality (self-thinning) was seen only in the high-growth dense plots. Seasonal effects on mortality were slight; maximum mortality was observed in the spring-summer period in plots subject to density-independent mortality, and in the winter-spring quarter in plots that had self-thinned. Yields in the high-growth plots and the low-growth dense plots were high for heath vegetation. The self-thinning populations did not exceed White's (1985) upper boundary for thinning lines of log intercept (K) = 5 on standardized axes. The data suggested a log intercept value in the range 4.8–4.9 in the high-growth stands assuming a thinning-line slope of – 1.5. Banksia ericifolia (a large shrub/small tree) has a high mean plant weight per given thinning density compared with trees, where an upper limit of log K= .4 has been suggested by White (1985). The volume of canopy space per plant in B. ericifolia is not unusual compared with other species. The amount of biomass packed into a given volume of canopy space was high in this Banksia, achieved by having leaves with a low ratio of area to weight (specific leaf area, SLA). For given values of density, leaf area index and proportion of shoot as leaf, plants with a low SLA will be several times heavier than plants with a high SLA. This achieves a high biomass to volume ratio without an erectophile canopy and may explain the high intercept seen for thinning lines of conifers.     

SPATIAL DYNAMICS OF A HIMANTHALIA ELONGATA (FUCALES, PHAEOPHYTA) POPULATION

In dense monospecific stands of plants intraspecific competition usually results in self-thinning, the concurrent increase in biomass and decrease in density over time. Self-thinning may also result in a change in the spatial pattern of individuals, but so far the spatial dynamics of marine plants has not been investigated. The brown alga Himanthalia elongata ( L.) S. F. Gray forms dense monospecific stands on many northern temperate rocky shores, and various attributes (including its simple form) facilitated the study of the spatial dynamics of this species .
The spatial pattern of settling zygotes was examined in the laboratory. In the absence of water movement, substratum heterogeneity, and a point source, zygotes usually settled in clumps rather than randomly. Within the clumps zygotes appeared to be regularly distributed at a scale similar to the size of the zygotes themselves. Furthermore, the clumps themselves seemed to be regularly distributed. On the shore, well-established stands of "button-stage" Himanthalia populations were examined during a period of extensive growth and self-thinning. Individual plants were initially highly regular in spatial pattern but became less so over time. The pattern of plants dying during self-thinning was also highly regular and probably reflected existing spatial regularity. However, using a hypothesis of mortality as a random event, I found that smaller plants had a less than average survival potential, while larger plants had a greater than average chance. A consideration of the spatial pattern of plants alive at the end of the study revealed regularity at a scale of 2–7 mm but a random spatial pattern at larger scales, which might indicate a small sphere of influence of competing individuals. The best predictor of mean nearest neighbor distances in the populations was mean plant diameter .     

植物种群自疏过程中构件生物量与密度的关系

不论是在对植物种群自疏规律还是在对能量守衡法则的研究中,个体大小(M)大多针对植物地上部分生物量,地下部分和构件生物量及其动态十分重要又多被忽视。以1年生植物荞麦为材料研究了自疏种群地下部分生物量、包括地下部分的个体总生物量以及各构件生物量与密度的关系。结果表明:平均地上生物量和个体总生物量与密度的异速关系指数(γabove-ground和γindividual)分别为-1.293和-1.253,与-4/3无显著性差异(P>0.05),为-4/3自疏法则提供了有力证据;平均根生物量-密度异速指数γroot(-1.128)与-1无显著性差异(P>0.05),与最终产量恒定法则一致;平均茎生物量-密度异速指数γstem(-1.263)接近-4/3(P>0.05),平均叶生物量-密度异速指数γleaf(-1.524)接近-3/2(P>0.05),分别符合-4/3自疏法则与-3/2自疏法则;而繁殖生物量与密度的异速关系指数γreproductive(-2.005)显著小于-3/2、-4/3或-1(P<0.001)。因此,不存在一个对植物不同构件普适的生物量-密度之间的关系。光合产物在地上和地下构件的生物量分配格局以及构件生物量与地上生物量之间特异的异速生长关系导致不同构件具有不同的自疏指数。无论对于地上生物量还是个体总生物量,荞麦种群能量均守衡,而对于地下生物量,荞麦种群能量不守衡。     

Relationship between the virtual dynamic thinning line and the self-thinning boundary line in simulated plant populations

The self-thinning rule defines a straight upper boundary line on log-log scales for all possible combinations of mean individual biomass and density in plant populations. Recently, the traditional slope of the upper boundary line, -3/2, has been challenged by -4/3 which is deduced from some new mechanical theories, like the metabolic theory. More experimental or field studies should be carried out to identify the more accurate self-thinning exponent. But it＇s hard to obtain the accurate self-thinning exponent by fitting to data points directly because of the intrinsic problem of subjectivity in data selection. The virtual dynamic thinning line is derived from the competition-density （C-D） effect as the initial density tends to be positive infinity, avoiding the data selection process. The purpose of this study was to study the relationship between the virtual dynamic thinning line and the upper boundary line in simulated plant stands. Our research showed that the upper boundary line and the virtual dynamic thinning line were both straight lines on log-log scales. The slopes were almost the same value with only a very little difference of 0.059, and the intercept of the upper boundary line was a little larger than that of the virtual dynamic thinning line. As initial size and spatial distribution patterns became more uniform, the virtual dynamic thinning line was more similar to the upper boundary line. This implies that, given appropriate parameters, the virtual dynamic thinning line may be used as the upper boundary line in simulated plant stands.     

The effects of salt stress and arbuscular mycorrhiza on plant neighbour effects and self-thinning

Abiotic and biotic factors can alter the nature and strength of plant–plant interactions and therefore self-thinning (density-dependent mortality), but few studies have looked at how such factors interact. We investigated how salt stress and arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) influence plant neighbour effects and self-thinning in experimental populations of Medicago sativa. We obtained two mycorrhizal levels by applying the fungicide benomyl (low AMF) or not (high AMF) at three salinity levels (0.05%, 0.2% and 0.5%). In experiment 1, we investigated how salinity and AMF interact to influence plant interaction intensity using a neighbour removal treatment. In experiment 2, we investigated how self-thinning dynamics vary under salinity conditions and different AMF levels at two initial plant densities (6000 and 17,500 seeds m^?2). Shoot biomass and plant density were measured 30, 60 and 90 days after sowing. Standardized major axis regression was used to estimate self-thinning parameters. In experiment 1, AMF increased competitive plant neighbour effects when there was no salinity stress, but this enhancement was not significant with increasing salinity. In experiment 2, there were effects of salinity and AMF on the self-thinning trajectory. The slope of the log (mean shoot biomass per unit area) vs. log density relationship was significantly steeper for the high AMF treatment than for the low AMF treatment without salinity, but the effect of AMF level on the self-thinning exponent was not significant under the two higher salinity levels. The effect of AMF treatments on the intercept of the self-thinning line was not significant at 0.2% salinity but was significant at 0.5% salinity, higher elevation for high AMF treatment. In self-thinning populations, AMF decreased the survival rate without salinity, but increased the survival rate at the highest salinity level. Our results support the hypothesis that salinity and AMF interact to influence plant neighbour effects and self-thinning. Under no-salinity conditions, AMF increased competition, steepened the self-thinning line and decreased survival rate, but these effects of AMF were not significant in the presence of salinity.     

Effects of self-thinning of shoots on the nutrient budgets of Zizania latifolia

This experimental study focused on the seasonal changes and mobilization of nutrients between plant parts to understand the implications of self-thinning in the ecology of Zizania latifolia (Griseb.) Turcz. ex Stapf. The observations of shoot density, above- and belowground biomass, and total nitrogen and total phosphorus concentrations were conducted from February 2002 to August 2003. The biomass of shoots that died during the period and daily uptake of nutrients were determined. The shoot density sharply increased until mid-April and thereafter decreased significantly due to self-thinning of shoots. Total nitrogen and phosphorus concentrations of rhizomes decreased initially due to translocation to new shoots; however, the nutrients of rhizomes were slightly replenished from dead shoots during self-thinning. In contrast to other species, self-thinning of Z. latifolia shoots reallocates some of the minerals contained in the dead shoots back to the rhizomes, which can be regarded as a strategy to replenish the reduced resources of the rhizomes. The initial intensive growth of shoots can be regarded as a strategy to maintain resource competition.     

Density effect, self-thinning and size distribution in Pinus densiflora Sieb. et Zucc. stands

The competition-density (C-D) effect for given times and self-thinning over time in even-aged, natural, pure stands of Pinus densiflora Sieb. et Zucc. were analyzed with the reciprocal equation of the C-D effect in self-thinning stands, and the equation describing the time-trajectory of mean stem volume and stand density. The C-D effect and self-thinning were consistently well explained by the two equations. Differences in mean stem volume and in stand density among the stands tended to merge with increasing stand age. The self-thinning line with a slope of approximately –3/2 was reached by the higher density stand prior to the medium and lower density stands. The skewness of tree height distribution showed positive values, which means that the distribution is more or less L-shaped, and in addition the skewness decreased with increasing mean tree height, which indicates that smaller trees died as the stands grew. This trend is consistent with the asymmetric (one-sided) competition hypothesis that self-thinning is driven by competition for light. The tree height distribution was analyzed using the Weibull distribution. The location parameter h _min of the Weibull distribution increased with increasing stand age, and the scale parameter a tended to increase slightly with increasing stand age. The range of the shape parameter b of the Weibull distribution corresponded to that of the skewness.     

Effects of competition on root–shoot allocation in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Plantago lanceolata</Emphasis> L.: adaptive plasticity or ontogenetic drift?

We investigated how shoot and root allocation in plants responds to increasing levels of competitive stress at different levels of soil fertility. In addition, we analyzed whether different responses were due to adaptive plasticity or should be attributed to ontogenetic drift. Plantago lanceolata plants were grown during 18 weeks at five plant densities and four nutrient supply levels in pots in the greenhouse. Thereafter root and shoot biomass was measured. There were clear negative effects of increasing plant densities on plant weights revealing strong intraspecific competition. At the lower N-treatments, the proportional allocation to root mass increased with increasing competitive stress, indicating the important role of belowground competition. At the higher N-supply rate, the relationship between competitive stress and shoot to root ratio was neutral. These responses could not be attributed to ontogenetic drift, but could only be explained by assuming adaptive plasticity. It was concluded that at lower N-supplies belowground competition dominates and leads to increased allocation to roots, while at the higher N-supply competition for soil resources and light had balanced impacts on shoot and root allocation. An alternative hypothesis explaining the observed pattern is that light competition has far less pronounced impacts on root–shoot allocation than nutrient deprival.     

AN EXPERIMENTAL EVALUATION OF DENSITY AND PLANT SIZE IN TWO LARGE BROWN SEAWEEDS

The effects of density on the growth rate and survival of individual plants as well as changes in population structure (hierarchy) and biomass accumulation (self-thinning) were experimentally evaluated in two brown macroalgae. Laminaria digitata (Hudson) Lamouroux and Fucus serratus Linnaeus populations were constructed at five (650–5156 plants·m^?2) and four densities (650–2668 plants·m^?2), respectively, and were cultivated in tanks. The relative growth rates and survivorship of individuals and the populations’ biomass and density (estimated dry mass) were periodically measured. To investigate how plant population size hierarchies influence conspecifics, single density populations of L. digitata were constructed of up to three sizes of plants in equal proportions, and these parts of the populations were compared through time with plants of the three sizes grown singly. At higher density, L. digitata plants grew more slowly, while F. serratus populations showed a similar trend that was never statistically significant. Survival of plants of both species was lower at high densities, and mortality selectively removed smaller plants. Plants of both species exhibited zero growth rates before death, when parts of the fronds were lost, but meristems (apical in F. serratus, at the base of the frond in L. digitata) were preserved until the death of the plant. All singly grown L. digitata plants survived, but survivorship was low in the fractions of small plants in mixed-size populations compared with that of the largest size plant fractions. Small L. digitata plants grew relatively faster than did large ones singly, but in mixed-size populations, small plants grew relatively slowly. Plant sizes became progressively more unequal (Gini and skewness coefficients) until self-thinning started reducing the size variability. The seaweeds followed self-thinning (density-biomass) trajectories predicted by the self-thinning “rule”, and self-thinning appeared to be seasonal- rather than species-dependent, as it occurred at a time of year when ambient light levels start to fall in the Isle of Man. Culture studies of this kind, despite their considerable potential, are a tool as yet underexploited by marine ecologists as a means of assessing intraspecific competitive interaction among seaweeds.     

The relationship between stand biomass and frond density in the clonal alga Mazzaella cornucopiae (Rhodophyta,Gigartinaceae)

The negative relationship between stand biomass and plant density observed in terrestrial plants was tested among fronds of a clonal red alga, Mazzaella cornucopiae. Stand biomass and frond density were estimated bimonthly for 1 year on 7 permanent quadrats. A positive linear correlation was found between biomass and density for the whole data set, suggesting the lack of self-thinning among fronds of this intertidal alga at natural densities. Higher frond densities could favor increased water retention among fronds, thus minimizing desiccation during low tides. In this way, stands could maintain higher production of biomass. Fronds may also be cushioned better against wave action at higher frond densities, thus decreasing the detachment of larger fronds. The temporal variation of the relationship between biomass and density was plotted separately for these 7 quadrats. Four quadrats showed positive linear correlation between both variables (the other three quadrats showed non-significant positive linear correlation). Their four slopes are statistically similar to that found for the entire data set. It is possible, then, that there is only one positive slope for the biomass-density relationship in this population. If this is true, standing biomass could be estimated from the density of fronds.     

Stand and self-thinning dynamics in natural <Emphasis Type="Italic">Abies</Emphasis> stands in northern Hokkaido,Japan

Stand dynamics and self-thinning were analyzed in relation to the dynamics of above-ground biomass in natural Abies sachalinensis stands growing on sand dunes in northern Hokkaido, Japan. This was done in order to examine wave-type regeneration in the stands. Fifty-two plots were established in almost pure Abies stands that ranged from saplings to the mature and collapsing growth stages. Above-ground biomass and tree height reached asymptotic levels prior to the collapsing phase, unlike wave-regeneration Abies stands in central Japan and North America. Stand density was high in the young growth stages, but the self-thinning rate, that is, the density decrease per biomass growth in the study stands was greater than in wave-regeneration stands in central Japan, as indicated by a large self-thinning exponent (–1.26 by reduced major axis regression). The range of tree height distribution was very narrow, and the stands vertical structure was typically single-layered. The slenderness ratio of trees was large, except in young stands. In mature and collapsing stands, advanced seedling density increased markedly. These stand and tree characteristics were considered to be correlated with the wave-type regeneration in the study stands, and it is assumed that prevailing winds affect tree mortality.     

Physiological and growth responses of Centaurea maculosa (Asteraceae) to root herbivory under varying levels of interspecific plant competition and soil nitrogen availability

Summary Centaurea maculosa seedlings were grown in pots to study the effects of root herbivory by Agapeta zoegana L. (Lep.: Cochylidae) and Cyphocleonus achates Fahr. (Col.: Curculionidae), grass competition and nitrogen shortage (each present or absent), using a full factorial design. The aims of the study were to analyse the impact of root herbivory on plant growth, resource allocation and physiological processes, and to test if these plant responses to herbivory were influenced by plant competition and nitrogen availability. The two root herbivores differed markedly in their impact on plant growth. While feeding by the moth A. zoegana in the root cortex had no effect on shoot and root mass, feeding by the weevil C. achates in the central vascular tissue greatly reduced shoot mass, but not root mass, leading to a reduced shoot/root ratio. The absence of significant effects of the two herbivores on root biomass, despite considerable consumption, indicates that compensatory root growth occurred. Competition with grass affected plant growth more than herbivory and nutrient status, resulting in reduced shoot and root growth, and number of leaves. Nitrogen shortage did not affect plant growth directly but greatly influenced the compensatory capacity of Centaurea maculosa to root herbivory. Under high nitrogen conditions, shoot biomass of plants infested by the weevil was reduced by 30% compared with uninfested plants. However, under poor nitrogen conditions a 63% reduction was observed compared with corresponding controls. Root herbivory was the most important stress factor affecting plant physiology. Besides a relative increase in biomass allocation to the roots, infested plants also showed a significant increase in nitrogen concentration in the roots and a concomitant reduction in leaf nitrogen concentration, reflecting a redirection of the nitrogen to the stronger sink. The level of fructans was greatly reduced in the roots after herbivore feeding. This is thought to be a consequence of their mobilisation to support compensatory root growth. A preliminary model linking the effects of these root herbivores to the physiological processes of C. maculosa is presented.     

Water and nitrogen addition differentially impact plant competition in a native rough fescue grassland

We examined how water and nitrogen addition and water–nitrogen interactions affect root and shoot competition intensity and competition–productivity relationships in a native rough fescue grassland in central Alberta, Canada. Water and nitrogen were added in a factorial design to plots and root exclusion tubes and netting were used to isolate root and shoot competition on two focal species (Artemisia frigida and Chenopodium leptophyllum). Both water and nitrogen were limiting to plant growth, and focal plant survival rates increased with nitrogen but not water addition. Relative allocation to root biomass increased with water addition. Competition was almost entirely belowground, with focal plants larger when released from root but not shoot competition. There were no significant relationships between productivity and root, shoot, or total competition intensity, likely because in this system shoot biomass was too low to cause strong shoot competition and root biomass was above the levels at which root competition saturates. Water addition had few effects on the intensity of root competition suggesting that root competition intensity is invariant along soil moisture gradients. Contrary to general expectation, the strength of root competition increased with nitrogen addition demonstrating that the relationship between root competition intensity and nitrogen is more complex than a simple monotonic decline as nitrogen increases. Finally, there were few interactions between nitrogen and water affecting competition. Together these results indicate that the mechanisms of competition for water and nitrogen likely differ.     

Above-ground competition does not alter biomass allocated to roots in Abutilon theophrasti

We tested whether plants allocate proportionately less biomass to roots in response to above-ground competition as predicted by optimal partitioning theory. Two population densities of Abutilon theophrasti were achieved by planting one individual per pot and varying spacing among pots so that plants in the two densities experienced the same soil volume but different degrees of canopy overlap. Density did not affect root:shoot ratio, the partitioning of biomass between fine roots and storage roots, fine root length, or root specific length. Plants growing in high density exhibited typical above-ground responses to neighbours, having higher ratios of stem to leaf biomass and greater leaf specific area than those growing in low density. Total root biomass and shoot biomass were highly correlated. However, storage root biomass was more strongly correlated with shoot biomass than was fine-root biomass. Fine-root length was correlated with above-ground biomass only for the small subcanopy plants in crowded populations. Because leaf surface area increased with biomass, the ratio between absorptive root surface area and transpirational leaf surface area declined with plant size, a relationship that could make larger plants more susceptible to drought. We conclude that A. theophrasti does not reallocate biomass from roots to shoots in response to above-ground competition even though much root biomass is apparently involved in storage and not in resource acquisition.