Regulation of Cellular Differentiation in Filamentous Cyanobacteria in Free-Living and Plant-Associated Symbiotic Growth States

Certain filamentous nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria generate signals that direct their own multicellular development. They also respond to signals from plants that initiate or modulate differentiation, leading to the establishment of a symbiotic association. An objective of this review is to describe the mechanisms by which free-living cyanobacteria regulate their development and then to consider how plants may exploit cyanobacterial physiology to achieve stable symbioses. Cyanobacteria that are capable of forming plant symbioses can differentiate into motile filaments called hormogonia and into specialized nitrogen-fixing cells called heterocysts. Plant signals exert both positive and negative regulatory control on hormogonium differentiation. Heterocyst differentiation is a highly regulated process, resulting in a regularly spaced pattern of heterocysts in the filament. The evidence is most consistent with the pattern arising in two stages. First, nitrogen limitation triggers a nonrandomly spaced cluster of cells (perhaps at a critical stage of their cell cycle) to initiate differentiation. Interactions between an inhibitory peptide exported by the differentiating cells and an activator protein within them causes one cell within each cluster to fully differentiate, yielding a single mature heterocyst. In symbiosis with plants, heterocyst frequencies are increased 3- to 10-fold because, we propose, either differentation is initiated at an increased number of sites or resolution of differentiating clusters is incomplete. The physiology of symbiotically associated cyanobacteria raises the prospect that heterocyst differentiation proceeds independently of the nitrogen status of a cell and depends instead on signals produced by the plant partner.     

Heterocyst differentiation and pattern formation in cyanobacteria: a chorus of signals

Heterocyst differentiation in filamentous cyanobacteria provides an excellent prokaryotic model for studying multicellular behaviour and pattern formation. In Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120, for example, 5-10% of the cells along each filament are induced, when deprived of combined nitrogen, to differentiate into heterocysts. Heterocysts are specialized in the fixation of N(2) under oxic conditions and are semi-regularly spaced among vegetative cells. This developmental programme leads to spatial separation of oxygen-sensitive nitrogen fixation (by heterocysts) and oxygen-producing photosynthesis (by vegetative cells). The interdependence between these two cell types ensures filament growth under conditions of combined-nitrogen limitation. Multiple signals have recently been identified as necessary for the initiation of heterocyst differentiation, the formation of the heterocyst pattern and pattern maintenance. The Krebs cycle metabolite 2-oxoglutarate (2-OG) serves as a signal of nitrogen deprivation. Accumulation of a non-metabolizable analogue of 2-OG triggers the complex developmental process of heterocyst differentiation. Once heterocyst development has been initiated, interactions among the various components involved in heterocyst differentiation determine the developmental fate of each cell. The free calcium concentration is crucial to heterocyst differentiation. Lateral diffusion of the PatS peptide or a derivative of it from a developing cell may inhibit the differentiation of neighbouring cells. HetR, a protease showing DNA-binding activity, is crucial to heterocyst differentiation and appears to be the central processor of various early signals involved in the developmental process. How the various signalling pathways are integrated and used to control heterocyst differentiation processes is a challenging question that still remains to be elucidated.     

Effect on heterocyst differentiation of nitrogen fixation in vegetative cells of the cyanobacterium Anabaena variabilis ATCC 29413

Heterocysts are terminally differentiated cells of some filamentous cyanobacteria that fix nitrogen for the entire filament under oxic growth conditions. Anabaena variabilis ATCC 29413 is unusual in that it has two Mo-dependent nitrogenases; one, called Nif1, functions in heterocysts, while the second, Nif2, functions under anoxic conditions in vegetative cells. Both nitrogenases depended on expression of the global regulatory protein NtcA. It has long been thought that a product of nitrogen fixation in heterocysts plays a role in maintenance of the spaced pattern of heterocyst differentiation. This model assumes that each cell in a filament senses its own environment in terms of nitrogen sufficiency and responds accordingly in terms of differentiation. Expression of the Nif2 nitrogenase under anoxic conditions in vegetative cells was sufficient to support long-term growth of a nif1 mutant; however, that expression did not prevent differentiation of heterocysts and expression of the nif1 nitrogenase in either the nif1 mutant or the wild-type strain. This suggested that the nitrogen sufficiency of individual cells in the filament did not affect the signal that induces heterocyst differentiation. Perhaps there is a global mechanism by which the filament senses nitrogen sufficiency or insufficiency based on the external availability of fixed nitrogen. The filament would then respond by producing heterocyst differentiation signals that affect the entire filament. This does not preclude cell-to-cell signaling in the maintenance of heterocyst pattern but suggests that overall control of the process is not controlled by nitrogen insufficiency of individual cells.     

Effect of ammonia and sulfide on rifampicin-induced heterocyst formation inNostoc linckia

The effect of ammonia and sulfide on rifampicin-induced heterocyst differentiation was studied in the nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteriumNostoc linckia. Aerobic growth with nitrogen gas of the cyanobacterium was greatly affected by rifampicin with formation of multiple heterocysts in chains in the filaments whereas ammonia in the medium reversed the rifampicin inhibition of growth and prevented the induction of heterocysts. In a sulfide medium the suppression exerted by rifampicin on aerobic growth with nitrogen gas and heterocyst induction was found to be considerably reduced. The results suggest two interesting points,viz. that (i) rifampicin interferes with the nitrogen-fixing function of heterocysts, and (ii) it checks the synthesis of an unknown heterocyst, inhibitor and thus permits the adjacent vegetative cells to differentiate into heterocysts in chains.     

Heterocyst patterns without patterning proteins in cyanobacterial filaments

We have quantitatively modeled heterocyst differentiation after fixed nitrogen step-down in the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120 without lateral inhibition due to the patterning proteins PatS or HetN. We use cell growth and division together with fixed-nitrogen dynamics and allow heterocysts to differentiate upon the local exhaustion of available fixed nitrogen. Slow transport of fixed nitrogen along a shared periplasmic space allows for fast growing cells to differentiate ahead of their neighbors. Cell-to-cell variability in growth rate determines the initial heterocyst pattern. Early release of fixed nitrogen from committed heterocysts allows a significant fraction of vegetative cells to be retained at later times. We recover the experimental heterocyst spacing distributions and cluster size distributions of Khudyakov and Golden [Khudyakov, I.Y., Golden, J.W., 2004. Different functions of HetR, a master regulator of heterocyst differentiation in Anabaena sp PCC 7120, can be separated by mutation. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 101, 16040-16045].     

Control of heterocyst and nitrogenase synthesis in cyanobacteria.

The development of the heterocyst by filamentous nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria provides an attractive model system for studying cellular differentiation. Heterocyst synthesis is repressed by the presence of exogenous combined nitrogen. In this report, it is shown that the tryptophan analog, D,L-7-azatryptophan (Aza-T), is capable of relieving the repressive effect of exogenous NH4NO3 on heterocyst and nitrogenase synthesis. In nitrogen-fixing cultures, the presence of 20 micron Aza-T increases the heterocyst frequency twofold. The glutamate analog, L-methionine-D,L-sulfoximine (MSX), has also been shown to cause a derepression in the synthesis of heterocysts and nitrogenase. However, unlike MSX, Aza-T does not appear to exert its effects by inhibiting the activity of glutamine synthetase. Therefore, glutamine synthetase may not be the sole key to the derepression of heterocyst and nitrogenase development in the cyanobacteria. It is hoped that a study of Aza-T action may lead to the elucidation of a novel control mechanism.     

The developmental regulator PatD modulates assembly of the cell-division protein FtsZ in the cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120

FtsZ is a tubulin-like GTPase that polymerizes to initiate the process of cell division in bacteria. Heterocysts are terminally differentiated cells of filamentous cyanobacteria that have lost the capacity for cell division and in which the ftsZ gene is downregulated. However, mechanisms of FtsZ regulation during heterocyst differentiation have been scarcely investigated. The patD gene is NtcA dependent and involved in the optimization of heterocyst frequency in Anabaena sp. PCC 7120. Here, we report that the inactivation of patD caused the formation of multiple FtsZ-rings in vegetative cells, cell enlargement, and the retention of peptidoglycan synthesis activity in heterocysts, whereas its ectopic expression resulted in aberrant FtsZ polymerization and cell division. PatD interacted with FtsZ, increased FtsZ precipitation in sedimentation assays, and promoted the formation of thick straight FtsZ bundles that differ from the toroidal aggregates formed by FtsZ alone. These results suggest that in the differentiating heterocysts, PatD interferes with the assembly of FtsZ. We propose that in Anabaena FtsZ is a bifunctional protein involved in both vegetative cell division and regulation of heterocyst differentiation. In the differentiating cells PatD-FtsZ interactions appear to set an FtsZ activity that is insufficient for cell division but optimal to foster differentiation.     

Cellular differentiation in the cyanobacterium Nostoc punctiforme

Nostoc punctiforme is a phenotypically complex, filamentous, nitrogen-fixing cyanobacterium, whose vegetative cells can mature in four developmental directions. The particular developmental direction is determined by environmental signals. The vegetative cell cycle is maintained when nutrients are sufficient. Limitation for combined nitrogen induces the terminal differentiation of heterocysts, cells specialized for nitrogen fixation in an oxic environment. A number of unique regulatory events and genes have been identified and integrated into a working model of heterocyst differentiation. Phosphate limitation induces the transient differentiation of akinetes, spore-like cells resistant to cold and desiccation. A variety of environmental changes, both positive and negative for growth, induce the transient differentiation of hormogonia, motile filaments that function in dispersal. Initiation of the differentiation of heterocysts, akinetes and hormogonia are hypothesized to depart from the vegetative cell cycle, following separate and distinct events. N. punctiforme also forms nitrogen-fixing symbiotic associations; its plant partners influence the differentiation and behavior of hormogonia and heterocysts. N. punctiforme is genetically tractable and its genome sequence is nearly complete. Thus, the regulatory circuits of three cellular differentiation events and symbiotic interactions of N. punctiforme can be experimentally analyzed by functional genomics.     

A model for cell type-specific differential gene expression during heterocyst development and the constitution of aerobic nitrogen fixation ability inAnabaena sp. strain PCC 7120

When deprived of combined nitrogen, aerobically-grown filaments ofAnabaena sp. strain PCC7120 differentiate specialized cells called the heterocysts. The differentiation process is an elaborate and well orchestrated programme involving sensing of environmental and developmental signals, commitment of cells to development, gene rearrangements, intricate DNA-protein interactions, and differential expression of several genes. It culminates in a physiological division of labour between heterocysts, which become the sole sites of aerobic nitrogen fixation, and vegetative cells, that provide photosynthate to the heterocysts in return for nitrogen supplies. We propose a model, to describe the chronology of the important events and to explain how cell type-specific differential gene expression is facilitated by DNA-protein interactions leading to the development of heterocysts and constitution of nitrogen-fixing apparatus inAnabaena.     

Relationships between the ABC-Exporter HetC and Peptides that Regulate the Spatiotemporal Pattern of Heterocyst Distribution in Anabaena

In the model cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120, cells called heterocysts that are specialized in the fixation of atmospheric nitrogen differentiate from vegetative cells of the filament in the absence of combined nitrogen. Heterocysts follow a specific distribution pattern along the filament, and a number of regulators have been identified that influence the heterocyst pattern. PatS and HetN, expressed in the differentiating cells, inhibit the differentiation of neighboring cells. At least PatS appears to be processed and transferred from cell to cell. HetC is similar to ABC exporters and is required for differentiation. We present an epistasis analysis of these regulatory genes and of genes, hetP and asr2819, successively downstream from hetC, and we have studied the localization of HetC and HetP by use of GFP fusions. Inactivation of patS, but not of hetN, allowed differentiation to proceed in a hetC background, whereas inactivation of hetC in patS or patS hetN backgrounds decreased the frequency of contiguous proheterocysts. A HetC-GFP protein is localized to the heterocysts and especially near their cell poles, and a putative HetC peptidase domain was required for heterocyst differentiation but not for HetC-GFP localization. hetP is also required for heterocyst differentiation. A HetP-GFP protein localized mostly near the heterocyst poles. ORF asr2819, which we denote patC, encodes an 84-residue peptide and is induced upon nitrogen step-down. Inactivation of patC led to a late spreading of the heterocyst pattern. Whereas HetC and HetP appear to have linked functions that allow heterocyst differentiation to progress, PatC may have a role in selecting sites of differentiation, suggesting that these closely positioned genes may be functionally related.     

The mystique of irreversibility in cyanobacterial heterocyst formation: parallels to differentiation and senescence in eukaryotic cells

The formation of cyanobacterial heterocysts is unique in the prokaryotic world: it is the only irreversible collective process. This terminal differentiation resembles senescence and differentiation in the eukaryotic urkingdom. During their cell cycle eukaryotic cells at the restriction point may reversibly proceed from a vegetative phase (G1) into a quiescent state (G0), and then may irreversibly enter the way towards differentiated or senescent cells. In parallel, at commitment point 1 vegetative cells from filamentous cyanobacteria may reversibly form proheterocysts, and then may proceed irreversibly towards mature heterocysts at commitment point 2. While the signals paving the path for differentiation or senescence in eukaryotes are largely unknown, heterocyst development is clearly triggered by nitrogen starvation. The reasons for the irreversibility in both systems are poorly understood. We discuss these questions, especially in the light of recent advances in the molecular biology of cyanobacteria, with emphasis on self-stabilizing autocatalytic cycles.     

Heterocyst formation in cyanobacteria

When deprived of combined nitrogen, many filamentous cyanobacteria develop a one-dimensional pattern of specialised nitrogen-fixing cells, known as heterocysts. Recent years have seen the identification and characterisation of some of the key genes and proteins involved in heterocyst development and spacing, including the positive regulator HetR and the diffusible inhibitor PatS.     

The Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120 asr1734 gene encodes a negative regulator of heterocyst development

The novel asr1734 gene of Anabaena (Nostoc) sp. strain PCC 7120 inhibited heterocyst development when present in extra copies. Overexpression of asr1734 inhibited heterocyst development in several strains including the wild type and two strains that form multiple contiguous heterocysts (Mch phenotype): a PatS null mutant and a hetR(R223W) mutant. Overexpression of asr1734 also caused increased nblA messenger RNA levels, and increased loss of autofluorescence in vegetative cells throughout filaments after nitrogen or sulphur depletion. Unlike the wild type, an asr1734 knockout mutant formed 5% heterocysts after a nitrogen shift from ammonium to nitrate, and formed 15% heterocysts and a weak Mch phenotype after step-down to medium lacking combined nitrogen. After nitrogen step-down, the asr1734 mutant had elevated levels of ntcA messenger RNA. A green fluorescent protein reporter driven by the asr1734 promoter, P(asr1734)-gfp, was expressed specifically in differentiating proheterocysts and heterocysts after nitrogen step-down. Strains overexpressing asr1734 and containing P(hetR)-gfp or P(patS)-gfp reporters failed to show normal patterned upregulation 24 h after nitrogen step-down even though hetR expression was upregulated at 6 h. Apparent orthologues of asr1734 are found only in two other filamentous nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria, Anabaena variabilis and Nostoc punctiforme.     

Early candidacy for differentiation into heterocysts in the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120

The filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120 fixes dinitrogen facultatively. Upon depletion of combined nitrogen, about 10% of vegetative cells within the filaments differentiate terminally into nitrogen-fixing cells. The heterocyst has been studied as a model system of prokaryotic cell differentiation, with major focus on signal transduction and pattern formation. The fate of heterocyst differentiation is determined at about the eighth hour of induction (point of no return), well before conspicuous morphological or metabolic changes occur. However, little is known about how the initial heterocysts are selected after the induction by nitrogen deprivation. To address this question, we followed the fate of every cells on agar plates after nitrogen deprivation with an interval of 4 h. About 10% of heterocysts were formed without prior division after the start of nitrogen deprivation. The intensity of fluorescence of GFP in the transformants of hetR-gfp increased markedly in the future heterocysts at the fourth hour with respect to other cells. We also noted that the growing filaments consisted of clusters of four consecutive cells that we call quartets. About 75% of initial heterocysts originated from either of the two outer cells of quartets at the start of nitrogen deprivation. These results suggest that the future heterocysts are loosely selected at early times after the start of nitrogen deprivation, before the commitment. Such early candidacy could be explained by different properties of the outer and inner cells of a quartet, but the molecular nature of candidacy remains to be uncovered.     

Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120 gene devH is required for synthesis of the heterocyst glycolipid layer

In response to deprivation for fixed nitrogen, the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. strain PCC 7120 provides a microoxic intracellular environment for nitrogen fixation through the differentiation of semiregularly spaced vegetative cells into specialized cells called heterocysts. The devH gene is induced during heterocyst development and encodes a product with characteristics of a trans-acting regulatory protein. A devH mutant forms morphologically distinguishable heterocysts but is Fox(-), incapable of nitrogen fixation in the presence of oxygen. We demonstrate that rearrangements of nitrogen fixation genes take place normally in the devH mutant and that it is Fix(+), i.e., has nitrogenase activity under anoxic conditions. The Fox(-) phenotype was shown by ultrastructural studies to be associated with the absence of the glycolipid layer of the heterocyst envelope. The expression of glycolipid biosynthetic genes in the mutant is greatly reduced, and heterocyst glycolipids are undetectable.