Magainin 2 Revisited: A Test of the Quantitative Model for the All-or-None Permeabilization of Phospholipid Vesicles

The all-or-none kinetic model that we recently proposed for the antimicrobial peptide cecropin A is tested here for magainin 2. In mixtures of phosphatidylcholine (PC)/phosphatidylglycerol (PG) 50:50 and 70:30, release of contents from lipid vesicles occurs in an all-or-none fashion and the differences between PC/PG 50:50 and 70:30 can be ascribed mainly to differences in binding, which was determined independently and is ∼20 times greater to PC/PG 50:50 than to 70:30. Only one variable parameter, β, corresponding to the ratio of the rates of pore opening to pore closing, is used to fit dye release kinetics from these two mixtures, for several peptide/lipid ratios ranging from 1:25 to 1:200. However, unlike for cecropin A where it stays almost constant, β increases five times as the PG content of the vesicles increases from 30 to 50%. Thus, magainin 2 is more sensitive to anionic lipid content than cecropin A. But overall, magainin follows the same all-or-none kinetic model as cecropin A in these lipid mixtures, with slightly different parameter values. When the PG content is reduced to 20 mol %, dye release becomes very low; the mechanism appears to change, and is consistent with a graded kinetic model. We suggest that the peptide may be inducing formation of PG domains. In either mechanism, no peptide oligomerization occurs and magainin catalyzes dye release in proportion to its concentration on the membrane in a peptide state that we call a pore. We envision this structure as a chaotic or stochastic type of pore, involving both lipids and peptides, not a well-defined, peptide-lined channel.     

Interactions between human defensins and lipid bilayers: evidence for formation of multimeric pores.

Defensins comprise a family of broad-spectrum antimicrobial peptides that are stored in the cytoplasmic granules of mammalian neutrophils and Paneth cells of the small intestine. Neutrophil defensins are known to permeabilize cell membranes of susceptible microorganisms, but the mechanism of permeabilization is uncertain. We report here the results of an investigation of the mechanism by which HNP-2, one of 4 human neutrophil defensins, permeabilizes large unilamellar vesicles formed from the anionic lipid palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylglycerol (POPG). As observed by others, we find that HNP-2 (net charge = +3) cannot bind to vesicles formed from neutral lipids. The binding of HNP-2 to vesicles containing varying amounts of POPG and neutral (zwitterionic) palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylcholine (POPC) demonstrates that binding is initiated through electrostatic interactions. Because vesicle aggregation and fusion can confound studies of the interaction of HNP-2 with vesicles, those processes were explored systematically by varying the concentrations of vesicles and HNP-2, and the POPG:POPC ratio. Vesicles (300 microM POPG) readily aggregated at HNP-2 concentrations above 1 microM, but no mixing of vesicle contents could be detected for concentrations as high as 2 microM despite the fact that intervesicular lipid mixing could be demonstrated. This indicates that if fusion of vesicles occurs, it is hemi-fusion, in which only the outer monolayers mix at bilayer contact sites. Under conditions of limited aggregation and intervesicular lipid mixing, the fractional leakage of small solutes is a sigmoidal function of peptide concentration. For 300 microM POPG vesicles, 50% of entrapped solute is released by 0.7 microM HNP-2. We introduce a simple method for determining whether leakage from vesicles is graded or all-or-none. We show by means of this fluorescence "requenching" method that native HNP-2 induces vesicle leakage in an all-or-none manner, whereas reduced HNP-2 induces partial, or graded, leakage of vesicle contents. At HNP-2 concentrations that release 100% of small (approximately 400 Da) markers, a fluorescent dextran of 4,400 Da is partially retained in the vesicles, and a 18,900-Da dextran is mostly retained. These results suggest that HNP-2 can form pores that have a maximum diameter of approximately 25 A. A speculative multimeric model of the pore is presented based on these results and on the crystal structure of a human defensin.     

Fluctuations and the Rate-Limiting Step of Peptide-Induced Membrane Leakage

Peptide-induced vesicle leakage is a common experimental test for the membrane-perturbing activity of antimicrobial peptides. The leakage kinetics is usually very slow, requiring minutes to hours for complete release of vesicle contents, and exhibits a biphasic behavior. We report here that, in the case of the peptaibol trichogin GA IV, all processes involved in peptide-membrane interaction, such as peptide-membrane association, peptide aggregation, and peptide translocation, take place on a timescale much shorter than the leakage kinetics. On the basis of these findings, we propose a stochastic model in which the leakage kinetics is determined by the discrete nature of a vesicle suspension: peptides are continuously exchanging among vesicles, producing significant fluctuations over time in the number of peptide molecules bound to each vesicle, and in the formation of pores. According to this model, the fast initial leakage is caused by vesicles that contain at least one pore after the peptides are randomly distributed among the liposomes, whereas the slower release is associated with the time needed to occasionally reach in an intact vesicle the critical number of bound peptides necessary for pore formation. Fluctuations due to peptide exchange among vesicles therefore represent the rate-limiting step of such a slow mechanism.     

Mechanism of the cell-penetrating peptide transportan 10 permeation of lipid bilayers

The mechanism of the interaction between the cell-penetrating peptide transportan 10 (tp10) and phospholipid membranes was investigated. Tp10 induces graded release of the contents of phospholipid vesicles. The kinetics of peptide association with vesicles and peptide-induced dye efflux from the vesicle lumen were examined experimentally by stopped-flow fluorescence. The experimental kinetics were analyzed by directly fitting to the data the numerical solution of mathematical kinetic models. A very good global fit was obtained using a model in which tp10 binds to the membrane surface and perturbs it because of the mass imbalance thus created across the bilayer. The perturbed bilayer state allows peptide monomers to insert transiently into its hydrophobic core and cross the membrane, until the peptide mass imbalance is dissipated. In that transient state tp10 "catalyzes" dye efflux from the vesicle lumen. These conclusions are consistent with recent reports that used molecular dynamics simulations to study the interactions between peptide antimicrobials and phospholipid bilayers. A thermodynamic analysis of tp10 binding and insertion in the bilayer using water-membrane transfer hydrophobicity scales is entirely consistent with the model proposed. A small bilayer perturbation is both necessary and sufficient to achieve very good agreement with the model, indicating that the role of the lipids must be included to understand the mechanism of cell-penetrating and antimicrobial peptides.     

Kinetics of dye efflux and lipid flip-flop induced by delta-lysin in phosphatidylcholine vesicles and the mechanism of graded release by amphipathic, alpha-helical peptides

Delta-lysin is a 26-residue, amphipathic, alpha-helical peptide of bacterial origin. Its specificity is to some extent complementary to that of antimicrobial peptides. Therefore, understanding its mechanism is important for the more general goal of understanding the interaction of amphipathic peptides with membranes. In this article, we show that delta-lysin induces graded efflux of the contents of phosphatidylcholine vesicles. In view of this finding, carboxyfluorescein efflux kinetics were re-examined. In addition, peptide-induced lipid flip-flop was directly measured using fluorescence energy transfer between two lipid fluorophores initially placed on opposite leaflets of the bilayer. Carboxyfluorescein efflux and lipid flip-flop occur with essentially identical rate constants. On the basis of a detailed, quantitative analysis of the kinetics of peptide-vesicle interactions, we conclude that the peptide translocates across the bilayer as a small, transient aggregate, most likely a trimer. Dye efflux and lipid flip-flop occur concomitantly with the transient peptide-induced perturbation of the membrane. The experimental data are interpreted by comparing the predictions of the available models for the mechanism of action of amphipathic alpha-helical peptides. We demonstrate how the combination of the quantitative kinetic analysis, graded efflux, and reversibility of the peptide-vesicle interaction can be used to reject several models for this particular peptide. Two models are compatible with the data, the toroidal pore model and the sinking raft model. On the basis of the small aggregate size, a trimer, the latter appears to be more plausible. Some significant modifications are introduced in the sinking raft model to take into account the new finding of graded dye release. Furthermore, we present an explanation for the phenomenon of graded release in general, which, contrary to all-or-none efflux, has not been well-understood.     

Reversible surface aggregation in pore formation by pardaxin.

The mechanism of leakage induced by surface active peptides is not yet fully understood. To gain insight into the molecular events underlying this process, the leakage induced by the peptide pardaxin from phosphatidylcholine/ phosphatidylserine/cholesterol large unilamellar vesicles was studied by monitoring the rate and extent of dye release and by theoretical modeling. The leakage occurred by an all-or-none mechanism: vesicles either leaked or retained all of their contents. We further developed a mathematical model that includes the assumption that certain peptides become incorporated into the vesicle bilayer and aggregate to form a pore. The current experimental results can be explained by the model only if the surface aggregation of the peptide is reversible. Considering this reversibility, the model can explain the final extents of calcein leakage for lipid/peptide ratios of > 2000:1 to 25:1 by assuming that only a fraction of the bound peptide forms pores consisting of M = 6 +/- 3 peptides. Interestingly, less leakage occurred at 43 degrees C, than at 30 degrees C, although peptide partitioning into the bilayer was enhanced upon elevation of the temperature. We deduced that the increased leakage at 30 degrees C was due to an increase in the extent of reversible surface aggregation at the lower temperature. Experiments employing fluorescein-labeled pardaxin demonstrated reversible aggregation of the peptide in suspension and within the membrane, and exchange of the peptide between liposomes. In summary, our experimental and theoretical results support reversible surface aggregation as the mechanism of pore formation by pardaxin.     

Mechanisms of leakage

Abstract

Two mechanisms of leakage from liposomes are discussed, (i) Cations such as Ca²⁺ induce graded release whose rate depends mainly on vesicle collisions and is associated in the case of several acidic phospholipids with fusion events. A certain degree of leakage also occurs in between collisions. Consequently, the leakage per fusion is reduced at larger lipid and Ca concentrations, (n) Certain peptides induce leakage by pore formation, which shows selectivity to the size of the entrapped molecules and occurs by an all or none mechanism; vesicles either leak or retain all of their contents. A model for final extents and kinetics of leakage due to pore forming peptides is described. This model assumes that pore forming peptides become incorporated into the vesicle bilayer and aggregate to form a pore. Recent developments in the model enable considerations of a reversible or irreversible surface aggregation of peptides. Results of final extents and kinetics of leakage induced by pore forming peptides can be well explained and predicted by this formalism. Studies demonstrate that Ca can play a dual role in affecting leakage. A case is presented where Ca ⁺ inhibits and can even arrest pore formation by a peptide, while promoting vesicle fusion. Conversely, formation of pore structures by a peptide can inhibit vesicle fusion.     

Consequences of nonlytic membrane perturbation to the translocation of the cell penetrating peptide pep-1 in lipidic vesicles

The action of the cell penetrating pep-1 at the molecular level is not clearly understood. The ability of the peptide to induce (1) vesicle aggregation, (2) lipidic fusion, (3) anionic lipid segregation, (4) pore or other lytic structure formation, (5) asymmetric lipidic flip-flop, and (6) peptide translocation across the bilayers in large unilamellar vesicles was studied using photophysical methodologies mainly related to fluorescence spectroscopy. Neflometry and turbidimetry techniques show that clustering of vesicles occurs in the presence of the peptide in a concentration- and anionic lipid content-dependent manner. Results from Forst?r resonance energy transfer-based methodologies prove lipidic fusion and anionic lipid segregation, but no evidence for pores or other lytic structures was found. Asymmetric lipid flip-flop was not detected either. A specific method related to the quenching of the rhodamine-labeled lipids by pep-1 was developed to study the eventual translocation of the peptide. Translocation does not occur in symmetrical neutral and negatively charged vesicles, except when a valinomycin-induced transmembrane potential exists. Our work strongly suggests that the main driving force for peptide translocation is charge asymmetry between the outer and inner leaflet of biological membranes and reveals that pep-1 is able to perturb membranes without being cytotoxic. This nonlytic perturbation is probably mandatory for translocation to occur.     

The Mechanism of a Nuclear Pore Assembly: A Molecular Biophysics View

The basic problem of nuclear pore assembly is the big perinuclear space that must be overcome for nuclear membrane fusion and pore creation. Our investigations of ternary complexes: DNA–PC liposomes–Mg²⁺, and modern conceptions of nuclear pore structure allowed us to introduce a new mechanism of nuclear pore assembly. DNA-induced fusion of liposomes (membrane vesicles) with a single-lipid bilayer or two closely located nuclear membranes is considered. After such fusion on the lipid bilayer surface, traces of a complex of ssDNA with lipids were revealed. At fusion of two identical small liposomes (membrane vesicles) <100 nm in diameter, a “big” liposome (vesicle) with ssDNA on the vesicle equator is formed. ssDNA occurrence on liposome surface gives a biphasic character to the fusion kinetics. The “big” membrane vesicle surrounded by ssDNA is the base of nuclear pore assembly. Its contact with the nuclear envelope leads to fast fusion of half of the vesicles with one nuclear membrane; then ensues a fusion delay when ssDNA reaches the membrane. The next step is to turn inside out the second vesicle half and its fusion to other nuclear membrane. A hole is formed between the two membranes, and nucleoporins begin pore complex assembly around the ssDNA. The surface tension of vesicles and nuclear membranes along with the kinetic energy of a liquid inside a vesicle play the main roles in this process. Special cases of nuclear pore formation are considered: pore formation on both nuclear envelope sides, the difference of pores formed in various cell-cycle phases and linear nuclear pore clusters.     

Transmembrane pore formation by the carboxyl terminus of Bax protein

Bax is a cytosolic protein that responds to various apoptotic signals by binding to the outer mitochondrial membrane, resulting in membrane permeabilization, release of cytochrome c, and caspase-mediated cell death. Currently discussed mechanisms of membrane perforation include formation of hetero-oligomeric complexes of Bax with other pro-apoptotic proteins such as Bak, or membrane insertion of multiple hydrophobic helices of Bax, or formation of lipidic pores physically aided by mitochondrial membrane-inserted proteins. There is compelling evidence provided by our and other groups indicating that the C-terminal “helix 9” of Bax mediates membrane binding and pore formation, yet the mechanism of pore forming capability of Bax C-terminus remains unclear. Here we show that a 20-amino acid peptide corresponding to Bax C-terminus (VTIFVAGVLTASLTIWKKMG) and two mutants where the two lysines are replaced with glutamate or leucine have potent membrane pore forming activities in zwitterionic and anionic phospholipid membranes. Analysis of the kinetics of calcein release from lipid vesicles allows determination of rate constants of pore formation, peptide–peptide affinities within the membrane, the oligomeric state of transmembrane pores, and the importance of the lysine residues. These data provide insight into the molecular details of membrane pore formation by a Bax-derived peptide and open new opportunities for design of peptide-based cytotoxic agents.     

Pore formation and translocation of melittin.

Melittin, a bee venom, is a basic amphiphilic peptide, which mainly acts on the lipid matrix of membranes, lysing various cells. To elucidate the molecular mechanism, we investigated its interactions with phospholipid vesicles. The peptide formed a pore with a short lifetime in the membrane, as revealed by the release of an anionic fluorescent dye, calcein, from the liposomes. Our new double-labeling method clarified that the pore size increased with the peptide-to-lipid ratio. Upon the disintegration of the pore, a fraction of the peptides translocated across the bilayer. The pore formation was coupled with the translocation, which was proved by three fluorescence experiments recently developed by our laboratory. A novel model for the melittin pore formation was discussed in comparison with other pore-forming peptides.     

Melittin-induced leakage from phosphatidylcholine vesicles is modulated by cholesterol: a property used for membrane targeting

Melittin, an amphiphathic peptide, affects the permeability of vesicles. This can be demonstrated using the dye release technique. Calcein, a fluorescent marker, is trapped in large unilamellar 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (POPC) vesicles and melittin-induced leakage of the dye can be monitored directly by increasing fluorescence intensity. First, we characterized the effect of increasing cholesterol content in the membrane on melittin-induced leakage and our results reveal that cholesterol inhibits the lytic activity of the peptide. Using intrinsic fluorescence of the single tryptophan of melittin and ²H-NMR of headgroup deuterated phosphatidylcholine, we demonstrated that the affinity of melittin for phosphatidylcholine vesicles is reduced in the presence of cholesterol; this is associated with the tighter lipid packing of the cholesterol-containing bilayer. This reduced binding is responsible for the reduced melittin-induced leakage from cholesterol-containing membranes. The pathway of release was determined to be an all-or-none mechanism. Finally, we investigated the possibility of achieving specific membrane targeting with melittin, when vesicles of different lipid composition are simultaneously present. Melittin incubated together with vesicles made of pure POPC and POPC containing 30(mol)% cholesterol can empty nearly all the cholesterol-free vesicles while the cholesterol-containing vesicles remain almost intact. Owing to the preferential interaction of melittin with the pure POPC vesicles, we were able to achieve controlled release of encapsulated material from a specific vesicle population. Received: 8 May 1996 / Accepted: 12 September 1996     

Pardaxin Permeabilizes Vesicles More Efficiently by Pore Formation than by Disruption

Pardaxin is a 33-amino-acid neurotoxin from the Red Sea Moses sole Pardachirus marmoratus, whose mode of action shows remarkable sensitivity to lipid chain length and charge, although the effect of pH is unclear. Here we combine optical spectroscopy and dye release experiments with laser scanning confocal microscopy and natural abundance ¹³C solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance to provide a more complete picture of how pardaxin interacts with lipids. The kinetics and efficiency of release of entrapped calcein is highly sensitive to pH. In vesicles containing zwitterionic lipids (PC), release occurs most rapidly at low pH, whereas in vesicles containing 20% anionic lipid (PG), release occurs most rapidly at high pH. Pardaxin forms stable or transient pores in PC vesicles that allow release of contents without loss of vesicle integrity, whereas the inclusion of PG promotes total vesicle collapse. In agreement with this, solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance reveals that pardaxin takes up a trans-membrane orientation in 14-O-PC/6-O-PC bicelles, whereas the inclusion of 14-0-PG restricts it to contacts with lipid headgroups, promoting membrane lysis. Pore formation in zwitterionic vesicles is more efficient than lysis of anionic vesicles, suggesting that electrostatic interactions may trap pardaxin in several suboptimal interconverting conformations on the membrane surface.     

Lysylated phospholipids stabilize models of bacterial lipid bilayers and protect against antimicrobial peptides

Aminoacylated phosphatidylglycerols are common lipids in bacterial cytoplasmic membranes. Their presence in Staphylococcus aureus has been linked to increased resistance to a number of antibacterial agents, including antimicrobial peptides. Most commonly, the phosphatidylglycerol headgroup is esterified to lysine, which converts anionic phosphatidylglycerol into a cationic lipid with a considerably increased headgroup size. In the present work, we investigated the interactions of two well-studied antimicrobial peptides, cecropin A and mastoparan X, with lipid vesicles composed of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (POPC) and 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylglycerol (POPG), containing varying fractions of an aminoacylated phosphatidylethanolamine, a stable analog of the corresponding phosphatidylglycerol-derivative. To differentiate between the effects of headgroup size and charge on peptide–lipid interactions, we synthesized two different derivatives. In one, the headgroup was modified by the addition of lysine, and in the other, by glutamine. The modification by glutamine results in a phospholipid with a headgroup size comparable to that of the lysylated version. However, whereas lysyl-phosphatidylethanolamine (Lys-PE) is cationic, glutaminyl-phosphatidylethanolamine (Gln-PE) is zwitterionic. We found that binding of mastoparan X and cecropin A was not significantly altered if the content of aminoacylated phosphatidylethanolamines did not exceed 20 mol.%, which is the concentration found in bacterial membranes. However, a lysyl-phosphatidylethanolamine content of 20 mol% significantly inhibits dye release from lipid vesicles, to a degree that depends on the peptide. In the case of mastoparan X, dye release is essentially abolished at 20 mol.% lysyl-phosphatidylethanolamine, whereas cecropin A is less sensitive to the presence of lysyl-phosphatidylethanolamine. These observations are understood through the complex interplay between peptide binding and membrane stabilization as a function of the aminoacylated lipid content. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Interfacially Active Peptides and Proteins. Guest Editors: William C. Wimley and Kalina Hristova.     

Crumpled structure of the custom hydrophobic lytic peptide cecropin B3.

The solution structure of a custom lytic peptide, cecropin B3 (CB3), having two identical hydrophobic segments on both the N- and C-termini, was investigated by two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy. The need to determine the structure of this peptide is rooted in its specific ability to lyse lipid layers that have a high content of anionic lipid. The lytic activities of CB3 on cell membranes including cancer cells and bacteria is found to be less than cecropin B1. The results show that CB3 has four discrete segments forming alpha helical structures. The crumpled structure of CB3 provides evidence for the lysis of the lipid layer being via a pathway that differs from pore formation. The results in this study provide strong clues towards a rational design for a potent antimicrobial and antitumor peptide.     

Interaction of wheat alpha-thionin with large unilamellar vesicles.

The interaction of the wheat antibacterial peptide alpha-thionin with large unilamellar vesicles has been investigated by means of fluorescence spectroscopy. Binding of the peptide to the vesicles is followed by the release of vesicle contents, vesicle aggregation, and lipid mixing. Vesicle fusion, i.e., mixing of the aqueous contents, was not observed. Peptide binding is governed by electrostatic interactions and shows no cooperativity. The amphipatic nature of wheat alpha-thionin seems to destabilize the membrane bilayer and trigger the aggregation of the vesicles and lipid mixing. The presence of distearoylphosphatidylethanolamine-poly(ethylene glycol 2000) (PEG-PE) within the membrane provides a steric barrier that inhibits vesicle aggregation and lipid mixing but does not prevent leakage. Vesicle leakage through discrete membrane channels is unlikely, because the release of encapsulated large fluorescent dextrans is very similar to that of 8-aminonaphthalene-1,3,6,trisulfonic acid (ANTS). A minimum number of 700 peptide molecules must bind to each vesicle to produce complete leakage, which suggests a mechanism in which the overall destabilization of the membrane is due to the formation of transient pores rather than discrete channels.     

Aggregation and hemi-fusion of anionic vesicles induced by the antimicrobial peptide cryptdin-4

We show that cryptdin-4 (Crp4), an antimicrobial peptide found in mice, induces the aggregation and hemi-fusion of charged phospholipid vesicles constructed of the anionic lipid POPG and the zwitterionic lipid POPC. Hemi-fusion is confirmed with positive total lipid-mixing assay results, negative inner monolayer lipid-mixing assay results, and negative results from contents-mixing assays. Aggregation, as quantified by absorbance and dynamic light scattering, is self-limiting, creating finite-sized vesicle assemblies. The rate limiting step in the formation process is the mixing of juxtaposed membrane leaflets, which is regulated by bound peptide concentration as well as vesicle radius (with larger vesicles less prone to hemi-fusion). Bound peptide concentration is readily controlled by total peptide concentration and the fraction of anionic lipid in the vesicles. As little as 1% PEGylated lipid significantly reduces aggregate size by providing a steric barrier for membrane apposition. Finally, as stable hemi-fusion is a rare occurrence, we compare properties of Crp4 to those of many peptides known to induce complete fusion and lend insight into conditions necessary for this unusual type of membrane merger.     

Aggregation and hemi-fusion of anionic vesicles induced by the antimicrobial peptide cryptdin-4

We show that cryptdin-4 (Crp4), an antimicrobial peptide found in mice, induces the aggregation and hemi-fusion of charged phospholipid vesicles constructed of the anionic lipid POPG and the zwitterionic lipid POPC. Hemi-fusion is confirmed with positive total lipid-mixing assay results, negative inner monolayer lipid-mixing assay results, and negative results from contents-mixing assays. Aggregation, as quantified by absorbance and dynamic light scattering, is self-limiting, creating finite-sized vesicle assemblies. The rate limiting step in the formation process is the mixing of juxtaposed membrane leaflets, which is regulated by bound peptide concentration as well as vesicle radius (with larger vesicles less prone to hemi-fusion). Bound peptide concentration is readily controlled by total peptide concentration and the fraction of anionic lipid in the vesicles. As little as 1% PEGylated lipid significantly reduces aggregate size by providing a steric barrier for membrane apposition. Finally, as stable hemi-fusion is a rare occurrence, we compare properties of Crp4 to those of many peptides known to induce complete fusion and lend insight into conditions necessary for this unusual type of membrane merger.