Fluorescence Fluctuation Spectroscopy of mCherry in Living Cells

The red fluorescent protein mCherry is of considerable interest for fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (FFS), because the wide separation in color between mCherry and green fluorescent protein provides excellent conditions for identifying protein interactions inside cells. This two-photon study reveals that mCherry exists in more than a single brightness state. Unbiased analysis of the data needs to account for the presence of multiple states. We introduce a two-state model that successfully describes the brightness and fluctuation amplitude of mCherry. The properties of the two states are characterized by FFS and fluorescence lifetime experiments. No interconversion between the two states was observed over the experimentally probed timescales. The effect of fluorescence resonance energy transfer between enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) and mCherry is incorporated into the two-state model to describe protein hetero-oligomerization. The model is verified by comparing the predicted and measured brightness and fluctuation amplitude of several fusion proteins that contain mCherry and EGFP. In addition, hetero-fluorescence resonance energy transfer between mCherry molecules in different states is detected, but its influence on FFS parameters is small enough to be negligible. Finally, the two-state model is applied to study protein oligomerization in living cells. We demonstrate that the model successfully describes the homodimerization of nuclear receptors. In addition, we resolved a mixture of interacting and noninteracting proteins labeled with EGFP and mCherry. These results provide the foundation for quantitative applications of mCherry in FFS studies.     

Dual-color photon counting histogram analysis of mRFP1 and EGFP in living cells

We investigate the potential of dual-color photon counting histogram (PCH) analysis to resolve fluorescent protein mixtures directly inside cells. Because of their small spectral overlap, we have chosen to look at the fluorescent proteins EGFP and mRFP1. We experimentally demonstrate that dual-color PCH quantitatively resolves a mixture of EGFP and mRFP1 in cells from a single measurement. To mimic the effect of protein association, we constructed a fusion protein of EGFP and mRFP1 (denoted EGFP-mRFP1). Fluorescence resonant energy transfer within the fusion protein alters the dual-channel brightness of the fluorophores. We describe a model for fluorescence resonant energy transfer effects on the brightness and incorporate it into dual-color PCH analysis. The model is verified using fluorescence lifetime measurements. Dual-color PCH analysis demonstrated that not all of the expressed EGFP-mRFP1 fusion proteins contained a fluorescent mRFP1 molecule. Fluorescence lifetime and emission spectra measurements confirmed this surprising result. Additional experiments show that the missing fluorescent fraction of mRFP1 is consistent with a dark state population of mRFP1. We successfully resolved this mixture of fusion proteins with a single dual-color PCH measurement. These results highlight the potential of dual-color PCH to directly detect and quantify protein mixtures in living cells.     

Fluorescence Recovery After Photobleaching (FRAP) of Fluorescence Tagged Proteins in Dendritic Spines of Cultured Hippocampal Neurons

FRAP has been used to quantify the mobility of GFP-tagged proteins. Using a strong excitation laser, the fluorescence of a GFP-tagged protein is bleached in the region of interest. The fluorescence of the region recovers when the unbleached GFP-tagged protein from outside of the region diffuses into the region of interest. The mobility of the protein is then analyzed by measuring the fluorescence recovery rate. This technique could be used to characterize protein mobility and turnover rate.In this study, we express the (enhanced green fluorescent protein) EGFP vector in cultured hippocampal neurons. Using the Zeiss 710 confocal microscope, we photobleach the fluorescence signal of the GFP protein in a single spine, and then take time lapse images to record the fluorescence recovery after photobleaching. Finally, we estimate the percentage of mobile and immobile fractions of the GFP in spines, by analyzing the imaging data using ImageJ and Graphpad softwares.This FRAP protocol shows how to perform a basic FRAP experiment as well as how to analyze the data.     

Dual-color time-integrated fluorescence cumulant analysis

We introduce dual-color time-integrated fluorescence cumulant analysis (TIFCA) to analyze fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy data. Dual-color TIFCA utilizes the bivariate cumulants of the integrated fluorescent intensity from two detection channels to extract the brightness in each channel, the occupation number, and the diffusion time of fluorophores simultaneously. Detecting the fluorescence in two detector channels introduces the possibility of differentiating fluorophores based on their fluorescence spectrum. We derive an analytical expression for the bivariate factorial cumulants of photon counts for arbitrary sampling times. The statistical accuracy of each cumulant is described by its variance, which we calculate by the moments-of-moments technique. A method that takes nonideal detector effects such as dead-time and afterpulsing into account is developed and experimentally verified. We perform dual-color TIFCA analysis on simple dye solutions and a mixture of dyes to characterize the performance and accuracy of our theory. We demonstrate the robustness of dual-color TIFCA by measuring fluorescent proteins over a wide concentration range inside cells. Finally we demonstrate the sensitivity of dual-color TIFCA by resolving EGFP/EYFP binary mixtures in living cells with a single measurement.     

Automated Analysis of Single-Molecule Photobleaching Data by Statistical Modeling of Spot Populations

The number of fluorophores within a molecule complex can be revealed by single-molecule photobleaching imaging. A widely applied strategy to analyze intensity traces over time is the quantification of photobleaching step counts. However, several factors can limit and bias the detection of photobleaching steps, including noise, high numbers of fluorophores, and the possibility that several photobleaching events occur almost simultaneously. In this study, we propose a new approach, to our knowledge, to determine the fluorophore number that correlates the intensity decay of a population of molecule complexes with the decay of the number of visible complexes. We validated our approach using single and fourfold Atto-labeled DNA strands. As an example we estimated the subunit stoichiometry of soluble CD95L using GFP fusion proteins. To assess the precision of our method we performed in silico experiments showing that the estimates are not biased for experimentally observed intensity fluctuations and that the relative precision remains constant with increasing number of fluorophores. In case of fractional fluorescent labeling, our simulations predicted that the fluorophore number estimate corresponds to the product of the true fluorophore number with the labeling fraction. Our method, denoted by spot number and intensity correlation (SONIC), is fully automated, robust to noise, and does not require the counting of photobleaching events.     

Polarized fluorescence photobleaching recovery for measuring rotational diffusion in solutions and membranes.

A variation of fluorescence photobleaching recovery (FPR) suitable for measuring the rate of rotational molecular diffusion in solution and cell membranes is presented in theory and experimental practice for epi-illumination microscopy. In this technique, a brief flash of polarized laser light creates an anisotropic distribution of unbleached fluorophores which relaxes by rotational diffusion, leading to a time-dependent postbleach fluorescence. Polarized FPR (PFPR) is applicable to any time scales from seconds to microseconds. However, at fast (microsecond) time scales, a partial recovery independent of molecular orientation tends to obscure rotational effects. The theory here presents a method for overcoming this reversible photobleaching, and includes explicit results for practical geometries, fast wobble of fluorophores, and arbitrary bleaching depth. This variation of a polarized luminescence "pump-and-probe" technique is compared with prior ones and with "pump-only" time-resolved luminescence anisotropy decay methods. The technique is experimentally verified on small latex beads with a variety of diameters, common fluorophore labels, and solvent viscosities. Preliminary measurements on a protein (acetylcholine receptor) in the membrane of nondeoxygenated cells in live culture (rat myotubes) show a difference in rotational diffusion between clustered and nonclustered receptors. In most experiments, signal averaging, high laser power, and automated sample translation must be employed to achieve adequate statistical accuracy.     

Depolarized fluorescence photobleaching recovery

The effects of the fact that the laser sources typically used in fluorescence photobleaching recovery (FPR) experiments in the most commonly employed in-line microscope imaging geometries, are highly linearly polarized, are examined in some detail. The implications of the results, in particular for the interpretation of FPR data in complex cell membrane systems in terms of laterally mobile and immobile sub-populations of the labelled molecular species of concern, are discussed. Methods of experimentally eliminating the potentially major rotational diffusion-based artifacts, different from those appropriate to three-dimensional (solution or suspension) systems which require other than in-line geometries, are delineated.Abbreviations FPR fluorescence photobleaching recovery - FRAP fluorescence recovery after photobleaching - 2- and 3-D two- and three-dimensional     

Chromophore maturation and fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy of fluorescent proteins in a cell-free expression system

Cell-free synthesis, a method for the rapid expression of proteins, is increasingly used to study interactions of complex biological systems. GFP and its variants have become indispensable for fluorescence studies in live cells and are equally attractive as reporters for cell-free systems. This work investigates the use of fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (FFS) as a tool for quantitative analysis of protein interactions in cell-free expression systems. We also explore chromophore maturation of fluorescent proteins, which is of crucial importance for fluorescence studies. A droplet sample protocol was developed that ensured sufficient oxygenation for chromophore maturation and ease of manipulation for titration studies. The kinetics of chromophore maturation of EGFP, EYFP, and mCherry were analyzed as a function of temperature. A strong increase in the rate from room temperature to 37°C was observed. We further demonstrate that all EGFP proteins fully mature in the cell-free solution and that brightness is a robust parameter specifying stoichiometry. Finally, FFS is applied to study the stoichiometry of the nuclear transport factor 2 in a cell-free system over a broad concentration range. We conclude that combining cell-free expression and FFS provides a powerful technique for quick, quantitative study of chromophore maturation and protein-protein interaction.     

Improved green and blue fluorescent proteins for expression in bacteria and mammalian cells

Fluorescent proteins have become an invaluable tool in cell biology. The green fluorescent protein variant EGFP is especially widely applied. Use of fluorescent proteins, including EGFP, however can be hindered by inefficient protein folding, resulting in protein aggregation and reduced fluorescence. This is especially profound in prokaryotic cells. Furthermore, EBFP, a blue fluorescent variant of EGFP, is rarely used because of its dim fluorescence and fast photobleaching. Thus, efforts to improve properties such as protein folding, fluorescence brightness, and photostability are important. Strongly enhanced green fluorescent (SGFP2) and strongly enhanced blue fluorescent (SBFP2) proteins were created, based on EGFP and EBFP, respectively. We used site-directed mutagenesis to introduce several mutations, which were recently shown to improve the fluorescent proteins EYFP and ECFP. SGFP2 and SBFP2 exhibit faster and more efficient protein folding and accelerated chromophore oxidation in vitro. For both strongly enhanced fluorescent proteins, the photostability was improved 2-fold and the quantum yield of SBFP2 was increased 3-fold. The improved folding efficiency reduced the extent of protein aggregation in Escherichia coli, thereby increasing the brightness of bacteria expressing SGFP2 7-fold compared to the brightness of those expressing EGFP. Bacteria expressing SBFP2 were 16-fold more fluorescent than those expressing EBFP. In mammalian cells, the improvements were less pronounced. Cells expressing SGFP2 were 1.7-fold brighter than those expressing EGFP, which was apparently due to more efficient protein expression and/or chromophore maturation. Mammalian cells expressing SBFP2 were 3.7-fold brighter than cells expressing EBFP. This increase in brightness closely resembled the increase in intrinsic brightness observed for the purified recombinant protein. The increased maturation efficiency and photostability of SGFP2 and SBFP2 facilitate detection and extend the maximum duration of fluorescence imaging.     

Quantification of fluorophore copy number from intrinsic fluctuations during fluorescence photobleaching

We present a theoretical technique for quantifying the cellular copy-number of fluorophores that relies on the random nature of the photobleaching process. Our approach does not require single-molecule sensitivity, and therefore can be used with commonly used epifluorescence microscopes. Fluctuations arising from photobleaching can be used to estimate the proportionality between fluorescence intensity and copy-number, which can then be used with subsequent intensity measurements to estimate copy-number. We calculate the statistical errors of our approach and verify them with stochastic simulations. By using fluctuations over the entire photobleaching process, we obtain significantly smaller errors than previous approaches that have used fluctuations arising from cytoplasmic proteins partitioning during cellular division. From the time-dependence of the fluctuations as photobleaching proceeds, we can discriminate between desired photobleach fluctuations and background noise or photon shot noise. Our approach does not require cellular division and the photobleaching rate sets a timescale that is adjustable with respect to cellular processes. We hope that our approach will now be applied experimentally.     

In vitro FRAP reveals the ATP-dependent nuclear mobilization of the exon junction complex protein SRm160

We present a new in vitro system for characterizing the binding and mobility of enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP)-labeled nuclear proteins by fluorescence recovery after photobleaching in digitonin-permeabilized cells. This assay reveals that SRm160, a splicing coactivator and component of the exon junction complex (EJC) involved in RNA export, has an adenosine triphosphate (ATP)-dependent mobility. Endogenous SRm160, lacking the EGFP moiety, could also be released from sites at splicing speckled domains by an ATP-dependent mechanism. A second EJC protein, RNPS1, also has an ATP-dependent mobility, but SRm300, a protein that binds to SRm160 and participates with it in RNA splicing, remains immobile after ATP supplementation. This finding suggests that SRm160-containing RNA export, but not splicing, complexes have an ATP-dependent mobility. We propose that RNA export complexes have an ATP-regulated mechanism for release from binding sites at splicing speckled domains. In vitro fluorescence recovery after photobleaching is a powerful tool for identifying cofactors required for nuclear binding and mobility.     

Brightness Analysis by Z-Scan Fluorescence Fluctuation Spectroscopy for the Study of Protein Interactions within Living Cells

Fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (FFS) quantifies interactions of fluorescently labeled proteins inside living cells by brightness analysis. Conventional FFS implicitly requires that the sample thickness exceeds the size of the observation volume. This condition is not always fulfilled when measuring cells. Cytoplasmic sections, especially, can be thinner than the axial size of the observation volume. The finite sample thickness introduces a brightness bias which, if not recognized, leads to an erroneous interpretation of the data. To avoid this artifact, we introduce z-scan FFS which consists of a fluorescence intensity z scan through the sample followed by an FFS measurement. To model the experimental z-scan data, a new PSF model had to be introduced. We use the intensity z scan together with the PSF model to determine the geometry of the sample and then extract the brightness from the FFS data. Cells expressing EGFP serve as a model system for testing the experimental approach. We demonstrate that z-scan FFS abolishes the brightness artifact and use the method to determine the oligomerization of cytoplasmic nuclear transport factor 2.     

Quantitative Brightness Analysis of Fluorescence Intensity Fluctuations in E. Coli

The brightness measured by fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy specifies the average stoichiometry of a labeled protein in a sample. Here we extended brightness analysis, which has been mainly applied in eukaryotic cells, to prokaryotic cells with E. coli serving as a model system. The small size of the E. coli cell introduces unique challenges for applying brightness analysis that are addressed in this work. Photobleaching leads to a depletion of fluorophores and a reduction of the brightness of protein complexes. In addition, the E. coli cell and the point spread function of the instrument only partially overlap, which influences intensity fluctuations. To address these challenges we developed MSQ analysis, which is based on the mean Q-value of segmented photon count data, and combined it with the analysis of axial scans through the E. coli cell. The MSQ method recovers brightness, concentration, and diffusion time of soluble proteins in E. coli. We applied MSQ to measure the brightness of EGFP in E. coli and compared it to solution measurements. We further used MSQ analysis to determine the oligomeric state of nuclear transport factor 2 labeled with EGFP expressed in E. coli cells. The results obtained demonstrate the feasibility of quantifying the stoichiometry of proteins by brightness analysis in a prokaryotic cell.     

Molecular brightness determined from a generalized form of Mandel's Q-parameter

Mandel's Q-parameter, which is determined from the first two photon count moments, provides an alternative to PCH analysis for determining the brightness of fluorophores. Here, the definition of the Q-parameter is generalized to include correlations between photon counts that are separated by a time tau. We develop and experimentally verify a theory that takes the effects of dead time, afterpulsing, and the finite sampling time on the generalized parameter Q(tau) into account. Q(0), which corresponds to the original Q-parameter, is severely affected by dead time and afterpulsing. Q(tau) for tau>0, on the other hand, is quite robust with respect to nonideal detector effects. Thus, analysis of Q(tau) provides a robust method for determining the brightness of fluorophores. We extend the theory to a mixture of species, which is characterized by an apparent brightness. The brightness of EGFP in CV-1 cells is measured as a function of protein concentration to demonstrate the feasibility of Q(tau) analysis in cells. In addition, we monitor protein association of the ligand-binding domain of retinoid X receptor in the presence and absence of 9-cis-retinoic acid by Q(tau) analysis.     

Using FCS to accurately measure protein concentration in the presence of noise and photobleaching

Quantitative cell biology requires precise and accurate concentration measurements, resolved both in space and time. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) has been held as a promising technique to perform such measurements because the fluorescence fluctuations it relies on are directly dependent on the absolute number of fluorophores in the detection volume. However, the most interesting applications are in cells, where autofluorescence and confinement result in strong background noise and important levels of photobleaching. Both noise and photobleaching introduce systematic bias in FCS concentration measurements and need to be corrected for. Here, we propose to make use of the photobleaching inevitably occurring in confined environments to perform series of FCS measurements at different fluorophore concentration, which we show allows a precise in situ measurement of both background noise and molecular brightness. Such a measurement can then be used as a calibration to transform confocal intensity images into concentration maps. The power of this approach is first illustrated with in vitro measurements using different dye solutions, then its applicability for in vivo measurements is demonstrated in Drosophila embryos for a model nuclear protein and for two morphogens, Bicoid and Capicua.     

Molecular Brightness Characterization of EGFP In Vivo by Fluorescence Fluctuation Spectroscopy

We characterize the molecular properties of autofluorescence and transiently expressed EGFP in the nucleus and in the cytoplasm of HeLa cells by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) and by photon counting histogram (PCH) analysis. PCH has been characterized and applied in vitro, but its potential for in vivo studies needs to be explored. Thus, this study mainly focuses on the characterization of PCH analysis in vivo. The strength of PCH lies in its ability to distinguish biomolecules by their molecular brightness value. Because the concept of molecular brightness is crucial for PCH analysis, we study the molecular brightness of EGFP and determine the statistical accuracy of its measurement under in vivo conditions. We started by characterizing the influence of autofluorescence on EGFP measurements. We found a molecular brightness of EGFP that is a factor of 10 higher than the brightness of the autofluorescence. Moment analysis demonstrates that the contribution of autofluorescence to fluorescence fluctuation experiments is negligible at EGFP concentrations of one protein per excitation volume. The molecular brightness of EGFP measured in the nucleus, the cytoplasm, and in vitro are identical and our study demonstrates that molecular brightness is a very stable and predictable quantity for cellular measurements. In addition to PCH, we also analyzed the autocorrelation function of EGFP. The diffusion coefficient of EGFP is a factor of 3 lower in vivo than compared to in vitro, and a simple diffusion process describes the autocorrelation function. We found that in the nucleus the fluorescence intensity is stable as a function of time, while measurements in the cytoplasm display fluorescence intensity drifts that complicate the data analysis. We introduce and discuss an analysis method that minimizes the influence of the intensity drifts on PCH analysis. This method allows us to recover the correct molecular brightness of EGFP even in the presence of drifts of the fluorescence intensity signal. We found the molecular brightness of EGFP to be a very robust parameter, and anticipate the use of PCH analysis for the study of oligomerization processes in vivo.     

Fringe pattern photobleaching, a new method for the measurement of transport coefficients of biological macromolecules.

The conventional method of studying mass transport in membranes by spot photobleaching and then following the recovery of fluorescence has disadvantages. Among them, the need for a high density of fluorescent molecules, the measurement of the beam profile, and a knowledge of the photobleaching processes are of a crucial importance. The application of a planar fringe pattern of light both for the bleaching and the monitoring of the fluorescent molecules solves these three major difficulties. Brownian diffusion coefficients and flow velocities can be measured independently and are averaged over the whole fringe pattern volume. These transport coefficients are explored over the wide range of experimentally accessible distances (from an interfringe spacing 0.5-50 micron). The quantification of the mobile and immobile components is further simplified by scanning the fringe pattern and detecting only a modulated fluorescence recovery signal. The fringe pattern photobleaching method is particularly adapted to the measurements of diffusion coefficients and flow velocity of membrane components, as well as of cytoplasmic proteins. The theoretical results and the test experiments with fluorescent bovine serum albumin are described.     

Dynamic imaging by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy identifies diverse populations of polyglutamine oligomers formed in vivo

Protein misfolding and aggregation are exacerbated by aging and diseases of protein conformation including neurodegeneration, metabolic diseases, and cancer. In the cellular environment, aggregates can exist as discrete entities, or heterogeneous complexes of diverse solubility and conformational state. In this study, we have examined the in vivo dynamics of aggregation using imaging methods including fluorescence microscopy, fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS), to monitor the diverse biophysical states of expanded polyglutamine (polyQ) proteins expressed in Caenorhabditis elegans. We show that monomers, oligomers and aggregates co-exist at different concentrations in young and aged animals expressing different polyQ-lengths. During aging, when aggregation and toxicity are exacerbated, FCS-based burst analysis and purified single molecule FCS detected a populational shift toward an increase in the frequency of brighter and larger oligomeric species. Regardless of age or polyQ-length, oligomers were maintained in a heterogeneous distribution that spans multiple orders of magnitude in brightness. We employed genetic suppressors that prevent polyQ aggregation and observed a reduction in visible immobile species with the persistence of heterogeneous oligomers, yet our analysis did not detect the appearance of any discrete oligomeric states associated with toxicity. These studies reveal that the reversible transition from monomers to immobile aggregates is not represented by discrete oligomeric states, but rather suggests that the process of aggregation involves a more complex pattern of molecular interactions of diverse intermediate species that can appear in vivo and contribute to aggregate formation and toxicity.     

The Proapoptotic Protein tBid Forms Both Superficially Bound and Membrane-Inserted Oligomers

Bid is a proapopotic activator protein of the Bcl-2 family that plays a pivotal role in controlling mitochondrial outer membrane permeabilization during apoptosis. Here, we characterized the interaction of fluorescently labeled truncated Bid (tBid) with a mitochondria-like supported lipid bilayer at the single-molecule level. The proteins observed at the membrane exhibited a very wide range of mobility. Confocal images of the membrane displayed both diffraction-limited Gaussian spots and horizontal streaks, corresponding to immobile and mobile tBid species, respectively. We observed 1), fast-diffusing proteins corresponding to a loosely, probably electrostatically bound state; 2), slowly diffusing proteins, likely corresponding to a superficially inserted state; and 3), fully immobilized proteins, suggesting a fully inserted state. The stoichiometry of these proteins was determined by normalizing their fluorescence intensity by the brightness of a tBid monomer, measured separately using fluorescence fluctuation techniques. Strikingly, the immobile species were found to be mainly tetramers and higher, whereas the mobile species had on average a significantly lower stoichiometry. Taken together, these results show that as soluble Bid progresses toward a membrane-inserted state, it undergoes an oligomerization process similar to that observed for Bax.