Chemically induced lipid phase separation in model membranes containing charged lipids: a spin label study.

The lipid distribution in binary mixed membranes containing charged and uncharged lipids and the effect of Ca2+ and polylysine on the lipid organization was studied by the spin label technique. Dipalmitoyl phosphatidic acid was the charged, and spin labelled dipalmitoyl lecithin was the uncharged (zwitterionic) component. The ESR spectra were analyzed in terms of the spin exchange frequency, Wex. By measuring Wex as a function of the molar percentage of labelled lecithin a distinction between a random and a heterogeneous lipid distribution could be made. It is established that mixed lecithin-phosphatidic acid membranes exhibit lipid segregation (or a miscibility gap) in the fluid state. Comparative experiments with bilayer and monolayer membranes strongly suggest a lateral lipid segregation. At low lecithin concentration, aggregates containing between 25% and 40% lecithin are formed in the fluid phosphatidic acid membrane. This phase separation in membranes containing charged lipids is understandable on the basis of the Gouy-Chapman theory of electric double layers. In dipalmitoyl lecithin and in dimyristoyl phosphatidylethanolamine membranes the labelled lecithin is randomly distributed above the phase transition and has a coefficient of lateral diffusion of D = 2.8-10(-8) cm2/s at 59 degrees C. Addition of Ca2+ dramatically increases the extent of phase separation in lecithin-phosphatidic acid membranes. This chemically (and isothermally) induced phase separation is caused by the formation of crystalline patches of the Ca2+-bound phosphatidic acid. Lecithin is squeezed out from these patches of rigid lipid. The observed dependence of Wex on the Ca2+ concentration could be interpreted quantitatively on the basis of a two-cluster model. At low lecithin and Ca2+ concentration clusters containing about 30 mol % lecithin are formed. At high lecithin or Ca2+ concentrations a second type of precipitation containing 100% lecithin starts to form in addition. A one-to-one binding of divalent ions and phosphatidic acid at pH 9 was assumed. Such a one-to-one binding at pH 9 was established for the case of Mn2+ using ESR spectroscopy. Polylysine leads to the same strong increase in the lecithin segregation as Ca2+. The transition of the phosphatidic acid bound by the polypeptide is shifted from Tt = 47.5 degrees to Tt = 62 degrees C. This finding suggests the possibility of cooperative conformational changes in the lipid matrix and in the surface proteins in biological membranes.     

Protein surface-distribution and protein-protein interactions in the binding of peripheral proteins to charged lipid membranes.

The binding of native cytochrome c to negatively charged lipid dispersions of dioleoyl phosphatidylglycerol has been studied over a wide range of ionic strengths. Not only is the strength of protein binding found to decrease rapidly with increasing ionic strength, but also the binding curves reach an apparent saturation level that decreases rapidly with increasing ionic strength. Analysis of the binding isotherms with a general statistical thermodynamic model that takes into account not only the free energy of the electrostatic double layer, but also the free energy of the surface distribution of the protein, demonstrates that the apparent saturation effects could arise from a competition between the out-of-plane binding reaction and the lateral in-plane interactions between proteins at the surface. It is found that association with nonlocalized sites results in binding isotherms that display the apparent saturation effect to a much more pronounced extent than does the Langmuir adsorption isotherm for binding to localized sites. With the model for nonlocalized sites, the binding isotherms of native cytochrome c can be described adequately by taking into account only the entropy of the surface distribution of the protein, without appreciable enthalpic interactions between the bound proteins. The binding of cytochrome c to dioleoyl phosphatidylglycerol dispersions at a temperature at which the bound protein is denatured on the lipid surface, but is nondenatured when free in solution, has also been studied. The binding curves for the surface-denatured protein differ from those for the native protein in that the apparent saturation at high ionic strength is less pronounced. This indicates the tendency of the denatured protein to aggregate on the lipid surface, and can be described by the binding isotherms for nonlocalized sites only if attractive interactions between the surface-bound proteins are included in addition to the distributional entropic terms. Additionally, it is found that the binding capacity for the native protein is increased at low ionic strength to a value that is greater than that for complete surface coverage, and that corresponds more closely to neutralization of the effective charge (determined from the ionic strength dependence), rather than of the total net charge, on the protein. Electron spin resonance experiments with spin-labeled lipids indicate that this different mode of binding arises from a penetration or disturbance of the bilayer surface by the protein that may alleviate the effects of in-plane interactions under conditions of strong binding.     

Anion binding to neutral and positively charged lipid membranes

Aqueous anion binding to bilayer membranes consisting of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) was investigated by using deuterium and phosphorus-31 nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Only those anions that exhibit chaotropic properties showed significant binding to POPC membranes. A detailed investigation of thiocyanate binding to neutral POPC and to positively charged mixed POPC/dihexadecyldimethylammonium bromide (DHDMAB) (8:2 mol/mol) membranes revealed changes in the 2H NMR quadrupole splittings from POPC specifically deuteriated at either the alpha-segment or the beta-segment of the choline head group which were consistent with a progressive accumulation of excess negative charge at the membrane surface with increasing SCN- concentration. Both the 2H and 31P NMR spectra indicated the presence of fluid lipids in a bilayer configuration up to at least 1.0 M NaSCN with no indication of any phase separation of lipid domains. Calibration of the relationship between the change in the 2H NMR quadrupole splitting and the amount of SCN- binding provided thiocyanate binding isotherms. At a given SCN- concentration the positively charged membranes bound levels of SCN- 3 times that of the neutral membranes. The binding isotherms were analyzed by considering both the electrostatic and the chemical equilibrium contributions to SCN- binding. Electrostatic considerations were accounted for by using the Gouy-Chapman theory. For 100% POPC membranes as well as for mixed POPC/DHDMAB (8:2 mol/mol) membranes the thiocyanate binding up to concentrations of 100 mM was characterized by a partition equilibrium with an association constant of K approximately 1.4 +/- 0.3 M-1.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Unconjugated bilirubin exhibits spontaneous diffusion through model lipid bilayers and native hepatocyte membranes

The liver is responsible for the clearance and metabolism of unconjugated bilirubin, the hydrophobic end-product of heme catabolism. Although several putative bilirubin transporters have been described, it has been alternatively proposed that bilirubin enters the hepatocyte by passive diffusion through the plasma membrane. In order to elucidate the mechanism of bilirubin uptake, we measured the rate of bilirubin transmembrane diffusion (flip-flop) using stopped-flow fluorescence techniques. Unconjugated bilirubin rapidly diffuses through model phosphatidylcholine vesicles, with a first-order rate constant of 5.3 s-1 (t(1)/(2) = 130 ms). The flip-flop rate is independent of membrane cholesterol content, phospholipid acyl saturation, and lipid packing, consistent with thermodynamic analyses demonstrating minimal steric constraint to bilirubin transmembrane diffusion. The coincident decrease in pH of the entrapped vesicle volume supports a mechanism whereby the bilirubin molecule crosses the lipid bilayer as the uncharged diacid. Transport of bilirubin by native rat hepatocyte membranes exhibits kinetics comparable with that in model vesicles, suggesting that unconjugated bilirubin crosses cellular membranes by passive diffusion through the hydrophobic lipid core. In contrast, there is no demonstrable flip-flop of bilirubin diglucuronide or bilirubin ditaurate in phospholipid vesicles, yet these compounds rapidly traverse isolated rat hepatocyte membranes, confirming the presence of a facilitated uptake system(s) for hydrophilic bilirubin conjugates.     

Chemically induced lipid phase separation in model membranes containing charged lipids: A spin label study

The lipid distribution in binary mixed membranes containing charged and uncharged lipids and the effect of Ca²⁺ and polylysine on the lipid organization was studied by the spin label technique. Dipalmitoyl phosphatidic acid was the charged, and spin labelled dipalmitoyl lecithin was the uncharged (zwitterionic) component. The ESR spectra were analyzed in terms of the spin exchange frequency, W_ex. By measuring W_ex as a function of the molar percentage of labelled lecithin a distinction between a random and a heterogeneous lipid distribution could be made. It is established that mixed lecithinphosphatidic acid membranes exhibit lipid segregation (or a miscibility gap) in the fluid state. Comparative experiments with bilayer and monolayer membranes strongly suggest a lateral lipid segregation. At low lecithin concentration, aggregates containing between 25% and 40% lecithin are formed in the fluid phosphatidic acid membrane. This phase separation in membranes containing charged lipids is understandable on the basis of the Gouy-Chapman theory of electric double layers.In dipalmitoyl lecithin and in dimyristoyl phosphatidylethanolamine membranes the labelled lecithin is randomly distributed above the phase transition and has a coefficient of lateral diffusion of D = 2.8·10^?8 cm²/s at 59°C.Addition of Ca²⁺ dramatically increases the extent of phase separation in lecithin-phosphatidic acid membranes. This chemically (and isothermally) induced phase separation is caused by the formation of crystalline patches of the Ca²⁺-bound phosphatidic acid. Lecithin is squeezed out from these patches of rigid lipid. The observed dependence of W_ex on the Ca²⁺ concentration could be interpreted quantitatively on the basis of a two-cluster model. At low lecithin and Ca²⁺ concentration clusters containing about 30 mol% lecithin are formed. At high lecithin or Ca²⁺ concentrations a second type of precipitation containing 100% lecithin starts to form in addition. A one-to-one binding of divalent ions and phosphatidic acid at pH 9 was assumed. Such a one-to-one binding at pH 9 was established for the case of Mn²⁺ using ESR spectroscopy.Polylysine leads to the same strong increase in the lecithin segregation as Ca²⁺. The transition of the phosphatidic acid bound by the polypeptide is shifted from T_t = 47.5° to T_t = 62°C. This finding suggests the possibility of cooperative conformational changes in the lipid matrix and in the surface proteins in biological membranes.     

Flexible charged macromolecules on mixed fluid lipid membranes: theory and Monte Carlo simulations

Fluid membranes containing charged lipids enhance binding of oppositely charged proteins by mobilizing these lipids into the interaction zone, overcoming the concomitant entropic losses due to lipid segregation and lower conformational freedom upon macromolecule adsorption. We study this energetic-entropic interplay using Monte Carlo simulations and theory. Our model system consists of a flexible cationic polyelectrolyte, interacting, via Debye-Hückel and short-ranged repulsive potentials, with membranes containing neutral lipids, 1% tetravalent, and 10% (or 1%) monovalent anionic lipids. Adsorption onto a fluid membrane is invariably stronger than to an equally charged frozen or uniform membrane. Although monovalent lipids may suffice for binding rigid macromolecules, polyvalent counter-lipids (e.g., phosphatidylinositol 4,5 bisphosphate), whose entropy loss upon localization is negligible, are crucial for binding flexible macromolecules, which lose conformational entropy upon adsorption. Extending Rosenbluth's Monte Carlo scheme we directly simulate polymer adsorption on fluid membranes. Yet, we argue that similar information could be derived from a biased superposition of quenched membrane simulations. Using a simple cell model we account for surface concentration effects, and show that the average adsorption probabilities on annealed and quenched membranes coincide at vanishing surface concentrations. We discuss the relevance of our model to the electrostatic-switch mechanism of, e.g., the myristoylated alanine-rich C kinase substrate protein.     

Protein diffusion and macromolecular crowding in thylakoid membranes

The photosynthetic light reactions of green plants are mediated by chlorophyll-binding protein complexes located in the thylakoid membranes within the chloroplasts. Thylakoid membranes have a complex structure, with lateral segregation of protein complexes into distinct membrane regions known as the grana and the stroma lamellae. It has long been clear that some protein complexes can diffuse between the grana and the stroma lamellae, and that this movement is important for processes including membrane biogenesis, regulation of light harvesting, and turnover and repair of the photosynthetic complexes. In the grana membranes, diffusion may be problematic because the protein complexes are very densely packed (approximately 75% area occupation) and semicrystalline protein arrays are often observed. To date, direct measurements of protein diffusion in green plant thylakoids have been lacking. We have developed a form of fluorescence recovery after photobleaching that allows direct measurement of the diffusion of chlorophyll-protein complexes in isolated grana membranes from Spinacia oleracea. We show that about 75% of fluorophores are immobile within our measuring period of a few minutes. We suggest that this immobility is due to a protein network covering a whole grana disc. However, the remaining fraction is surprisingly mobile (diffusion coefficient 4.6 +/- 0.4 x 10(-11) cm(2) s(-1)), which suggests that it is associated with mobile proteins that exchange between the grana and stroma lamellae within a few seconds. Manipulation of the protein-lipid ratio and the ionic strength of the buffer reveals the roles of macromolecular crowding and protein-protein interactions in restricting the mobility of grana proteins.     

Interaction of charged lipid vesicles with planar bilayer lipid membranes: Detection by antibiotic membrane probes

A technique has been developed for monitoring the interaction of charged phospholipid vesicles with planar bilayer lipid membranes (BLM) by use of the antibiotics Valinomycin, Nonactin, and Monazomycin as surface-charge probes. Anionic phosphatidylserine vesicles, when added to one aqueous compartment of a BLM, are shown to impart negative surface charge to zwitterionic phosphatidylocholine and phosphatidylethanolamine bilayers. The surface charge is distributed asymmertically, mainly on the vesicular side of the BLM, and is not removed by exchange of the vesicular aqueous solution. Possible mechanisms for the vesicle-BLM interactions are discussed.     

Tunable 2D diffusion of DNA nanostructures on lipid membranes

DNA nanotechnology facilitates the synthesis of biomimetic models for studying biological systems. This work uses lipid bilayers as platforms for two-dimensional single-particle tracking of the dynamics of DNA nanostructures. Three different DNA origami structures adhere to the membrane through hybridization with cholesterol-modified strands. Their two-dimensional diffusion coefficient is modulated by changing the concentration of monovalent and divalent salts and the number of anchors. In addition, the diffusion coefficient is tuned by targeting cholesterol-modified anchor strands with strand-displacement reactions. We demonstrate a responsive system with changing diffusivity by selectively displacing membrane-bound anchor strands. We also show the programmed release of origami structures from the lipid membranes.     

Impact of a model synovial fluid on supported lipid membranes

The interaction of a model synovial fluid, here a solution of 3mg/mL hyaluronic acid (HA) in heavy water (D(2)O), with an oligolamellar stack of lipid (DMPC) membranes on silicon support has been studied by neutron reflectometry and infrared spectroscopy on the molecular scale at non-physiological and physiological conditions. The system under investigation represents a simple model for lipid-coated mammalian joints and other artificial implant surfaces. When exposed to pure D(2)O at 21°C, i.e. below the main phase transition of the system, the lipid membranes show a lamellar spacing of 65?. Heating to 26°C results in detachment of all lipid bilayers except for the innermost lipid lamella directly adsorbed to the surface of the silicon support. On the contrary, when incubated in the solution of HA in D(2)O the oligolamellar lipid system starts swelling. In addition, heating to 39°C does not result in loss of the lipid membranes into the liquid phase. The interfacial lipid coating adopts a new stable lamellar state with an increase in d-spacing by 380% to 247? measured after 43 days of incubation with the model synovial fluid. Potential consequences for joint lubrication and protective wear functionality are considered.     

Protein kinases: evolution of dynamic regulatory proteins

Eukayotic protein kinases evolved as a family of highly dynamic molecules with strictly organized internal architecture. A single hydrophobic F-helix serves as a central scaffold for assembly of the entire molecule. Two non-consecutive hydrophobic structures termed "spines" anchor all the elements important for catalysis to the F-helix. They make firm, but flexible, connections within the molecule, providing a high level of internal dynamics of the protein kinase. During the course of evolution, protein kinases developed a universal regulatory mechanism associated with a large activation segment that can be dynamically folded and unfolded in the course of cell functioning. Protein kinases thus represent a unique, highly dynamic, and precisely regulated set of switches that control most biological events in eukaryotic cells.     

Distribution of charge on photoreceptor disc membranes and implications for charged lipid asymmetry.

A novel spin labeling technique is used to determine both the inner and outer surface potentials of isolated rod outer segment disc membranes and of reconstituted membranes containing rhodopsin with defined lipid compositions. It is shown that these potentials can be accounted for in a consistent manner by the accepted model of rhodopsin, the known lipid composition, and the Gouy-Chapman theory, provided the charged lipid is asymmetric in the membrane, with approximately 75% on the external surface.     

Statistical mechanics of lipid membranes. Protein correlation functions and lipid ordering

An expression is derived for the lipid-mediated intermolecular interaction between protein molecules embedded in a lipid bilayer. It is assumed that protein particles are accommodated by the bilayer, but they distort the lipids in some manner from their equilibrium protein-free configuration. We treat this situation by expanding the free energy density in the plane of the membrane as a Taylor series in some arbitrary parameter and its gradient. Minimization of the total membrane energy for a given particle configuration yields the interparticle interaction energy for that configuration. A test of the model is provided by measurement of the protein-protein pair distribution function from freeze-fracture micrographs of partially aggregated membranes. The measured functions can be simulated by adjustment of two parameters (a) a lipid correlation length that characterizes the distance over which a distortion of the bilayers is transmitted laterally through the bilayer, and (b) a term quantifying the energy of the protein-lipid interaction at the protein-lipid boundary. Correlation lengths obtained by fitting the calculated particle distribution functions to the data are found to be several nanometers. Protein-lipid interaction energies are of the order of a few kT.     

The evolution of slow dispersal rates: a reaction diffusion model

 We consider n phenotypes of a species in a continuous but heterogeneous environment. It is assumed that the phenotypes differ only in their diffusion rates. With haploid genetics and a small rate of mutation, it is shown that the only nontrivial equilibrium is a population dominated by the slowest diffusing phenotype. We also prove that if there are only two possible phenotypes, then this equilibrium is a global attractor and conjecture that this is true in general. Numerical simulations supporting this conjecture and suggesting that this is a robust phenomenon are also discussed. Received: 29 January 1997 / Revised version: 23 September 1997     

Effect of cytochrome c on the phase behavior of charged multicomponent lipid membranes

We studied the effect of submicromolar concentrations of cytochrome c (cyt c) on the phase behavior of ternary lipid membranes composed of charged dioleoylphosphatidylglycerol, egg sphingomyelin and cholesterol. The protein was found to induce micron-sized domains in membranes belonging to the single-fluid-phase region of the protein-free ternary mixture and, as a result, to expand the region of coexistence of liquid ordered (L_o) and liquid disordered (L_d) phases. Direct observations on individual vesicles revealed that protein adsorption increases the area of L_d domains. Measurements using a fluorescent analog of cyt c showed that the protein preferentially adsorbs onto domains belonging to the L_d phase. The adsorption was quantitatively characterized in terms of partitioning ratios between the L_d and the L_o phases. The protein was also found to induce vesicle leakage even at relatively low concentrations. In eukaryotic cells under normal physiological conditions, cyt c is localized within the intermembrane space of mitochondria. During cell apoptotis, cyt c is released into the cytosol and its adsorption to intracellular membranes may strongly perturb the lipid distribution within these membranes as suggested by our results.     

Effect of polymyxin B on the conductivity of negatively charged bilayer lipid membranes

Effect of polymyxin B on the planar bilayer lipid membranes (BLM) formed from synthetic phosphatidic acid has been studied. The addition of cholesterol to phospholipid in molar ratio 1 : 2 was followed by an increase of BLM conductance from 2 x 10(-8) to 3 x 10(-7) Ohm-1 cm-2. It was suggested that the observed increase of conductance was due to the fluidity of the membrane matrix in the presence of cholesterol. It was shown that 10(-6)--10(-5) M polymyxin slightly affected the conductance of BLM from phosphatidic acid. It was found that polymyxin increased conductance of negatively charged BLM modified by palmitic acid from 10(-8) to 10(-6) Ohm-1 cm-2.     

Domain formation induced by the adsorption of charged proteins on mixed lipid membranes

Peripheral proteins can trigger the formation of domains in mixed fluid-like lipid membranes. We analyze the mechanism underlying this process for proteins that bind electrostatically onto a flat two-component membrane, composed of charged and neutral lipid species. Of particular interest are membranes in which the hydrocarbon lipid tails tend to segregate owing to nonideal chain mixing, but the (protein-free) lipid membrane is nevertheless stable due to the electrostatic repulsion between the charged lipid headgroups. The adsorption of charged, say basic, proteins onto a membrane containing anionic lipids induces local lipid demixing, whereby charged lipids migrate toward (or away from) the adsorption site, so as to minimize the electrostatic binding free energy. Apart from reducing lipid headgroup repulsion, this process creates a gradient in lipid composition around the adsorption zone, and hence a line energy whose magnitude depends on the protein's size and charge and the extent of lipid chain nonideality. Above a certain critical lipid nonideality, the line energy is large enough to induce domain formation, i.e., protein aggregation and, concomitantly, macroscopic lipid phase separation. We quantitatively analyze the thermodynamic stability of the dressed membrane based on nonlinear Poisson-Boltzmann theory, accounting for both the microscopic characteristics of the proteins and lipid composition modulations at and around the adsorption zone. Spinodal surfaces and critical points of the dressed membranes are calculated for several different model proteins of spherical and disk-like shapes. Among the models studied we find the most substantial protein-induced membrane destabilization for disk-like proteins whose charges are concentrated in the membrane-facing surface. If additional charges reside on the side faces of the proteins, direct protein-protein repulsion diminishes considerably the propensity for domain formation. Generally, a highly charged flat face of a macroion appears most efficient in inducing large compositional gradients, hence a large and unfavorable line energy and consequently lateral macroion aggregation and, concomitantly, macroscopic lipid phase separation.