Delayed transmission selects for increased survival of vesicular stomatitis virus

Life-history theory predicts that traits for survival and reproduction cannot be simultaneously maximized in evolving populations. For this reason, in obligate parasites such as infectious viruses, selection for improved between-host survival during transmission may lead to evolution of decreased within-host reproduction. We tested this idea using experimental evolution of RNA virus populations, passaged under differing transmission times in the laboratory. A single ancestral genotype of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), a negative-sense RNA Rhabdovirus, was used to found multiple virus lineages evolved in either ordinary 24-h cell-culture passage, or in delayed passages of 48 h. After 30 passages (120 generations of viral evolution), we observed that delayed transmission selected for improved extracellular survival, which traded-off with lowered viral fecundity (slower exponential population growth and smaller mean plaque size). To further examine the confirmed evolutionary trade-off, we obtained consensus whole-genome sequences of evolved virus populations, to infer phenotype–genotype associations. Results implied that increased virus survival did not occur via convergence; rather, improved virion stability was gained via independent mutations in various VSV structural proteins. Our study suggests that RNA viruses can evolve different molecular solutions for enhanced survival despite their limited genetic architecture, but suffer generalized reproductive trade-offs that limit overall fitness gains.     

Mutation analyses of molecularly cloned satellite tobacco mosaic virus during serial passage in plants: evidence for hotspots of genetic change.

The high level of genetic diversity and rapid evolution of viral RNA genomes are well documented, but few studies have characterized the rate and nature of ongoing genetic change over time under controlled experimental conditions, especially in plant hosts. The RNA genome of satellite tobacco mosaic virus (STMV) was used as an effective model for such studies because of advantageous features of its genome structure and because the extant genetic heterogeneity of STMV has been characterized previously. In the present study, the process of genetic change over time was studied by monitoring multiple serial passage lines of STMV populations for changes in their consensus sequences. A total of 42 passage lines were initiated by inoculation of tobacco plants with a helper tobamovirus and one of four STMV RNA inocula that were transcribed from full-length infectious STMV clones or extracted from purified STMV type strain virions. Ten serial passages were carried out for each line and the consensus genotypes of progeny STMV populations were assessed for genetic change by RNase protection analyses of the entire 1,059-nt STMV genome. Three different types of genetic change were observed, including the fixation of novel mutations in 9 of 42 lines, mutation at the major heterogeneity site near nt 751 in 5 of the 19 lines inoculated with a single genotype, and selection of a single major genotype in 6 of the 23 lines inoculated with mixed genotypes. Sequence analyses showed that the majority of mutations were single base substitutions. The distribution of mutation sites included three clusters in which mutations occurred at or very near the same site, suggesting hot spots of genetic change in the STMV genome. The diversity of genetic changes in sibling lines is clear evidence for the important role of chance and random sampling events in the process of genetic diversification of STMV virus populations.     

Lack of evolutionary stasis during alternating replication of an arbovirus in insect and mammalian cells

The evolution of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) in a constant environment, consisting of either mammalian or insect cells, has been compared to the evolution of the same viral population in changing environments consisting in alternating passages in mammalian and insect cells. Fitness increases were observed in all cases. An initial fitness loss of VSV passaged in insect cells was noted when fitness was measured in BHK-21 cells, but this effect could be attributed to a difference of temperature during VSV replication at 37 degrees C in BHK-21 cells. Sequencing of nucleotides 1-4717 at the 3' end of the VSV genome (N, P, M and G genes) showed that at passage 80 the number of mutations accumulated during alternated passages (seven mutations) is similar or larger than that observed in populations evolving in a constant environment (two to four mutations). Our results indicate that insect and mammalian cells can constitute similar environments for viral replication. Thus, the slow rates of evolution observed in natural populations of arboviruses are not necessarily due to the need for the virus to compromise between adaptation to both arthropod and vertebrate cell types.     

Heterogeneous RNA of the Prague strain of Rous sarcoma virus caused by undiluted passages.

The size of genomic RNA in PR-RSV A passaged in chick embryo fibroblasts (CEF) or quail embryo fibroblasts (QEF) was determined by gel electrophoresis. The results showed that 3 undiluted passages resulted in heterogeneity of RNA. The heterogeneity of the smaller incomplete RNAs in the virus stock was decreased by diluted passage or cloning, but RNA of the b subunit size and a subunit RNA of complete genome size were relatively stable. These heterogeneous RNAs were characterized by hybridization analysis. The RNAs from 4 peaks hybridized with both cDNAtotal and cDNAsrc to appreciable extents, indicating that they were derived from viral RNA and that at least some of them contained the src sequence. This finding and the failure to isolate a td mutant from the undiluted-passaged virus stock or from some subclones that had a and b subunits of RNA indicate that the td virus was only a minor constituent of the incomplete virus population caused by undiluted passages. Some viruses with incomplete RNA in the virus stock could produce foci with the aid of td B77 or RAV-60. The emergence of rd viruses by undiluted passages was indicated.     

Initial Fitness Recovery of HIV-1 Is Associated with Quasispecies Heterogeneity and Can Occur without Modifications in the Consensus Sequence

Background

Fitness recovery of HIV-1 “in vitro” was studied using viral clones that had their fitness decreased as a result of plaque-to-plaque passages.

Principal Findings

After ten large population passages, the viral populations showed an average increase of fitness, although with wide variations among clones. While 5 clones showed significant fitness increases, 3 clones showed increases that were only marginally significant (p<0.1), and 4 clones did not show any change. Fitness recovery was not accompanied by an increase in p24 production, but was associated with an increase in viral titer. Few mutations (an average of 2 mutations per genome) were detected in the consensus nucleotide sequence of the entire genome in all viral populations. Five of the populations did not fix any mutation, and three of them displayed marginally significant fitness increases, illustrating that fitness recovery can occur without detectable alterations of the consensus genomic sequence. The investigation of other possible viral factors associated with the initial steps of fitness recovery, showed that viral quasispecies heterogeneity increased between the initial clones and the passaged populations. A direct statistical correlation between viral heterogeneity and viral fitness was obtained.

Conclusions

Thus, the initial fitness recovery of debilitated HIV-1 clones was mediated by an increase in quasispecies heterogeneity. This observation, together with the invariance of the consensus sequence despite fitness increases demonstrates the relevance of quasispecies heterogeneity in the evolution of HIV-1 in cell culture.     

Molecular epizootiology and evolution of vesicular stomatitis virus New Jersey.

Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) has been shown previously to be capable of undergoing rapid mutational change during sequential experimental infections in various tissue culture cell systems (J. Holland, K. Spindler, F. Horodyski, E. Grabau, S. Nichol, and S. Vandepol, Science 215:1577-1585, 1982). The present study was undertaken to determine the degree of genetic diversity and evolution of the virus under natural infection conditions and to gain insight into the epizootiology of the disease. Between 1982 and 1985, numerous outbreaks of VSV of the New Jersey serotype were reported throughout regions of the United States and Mexico. A T1 RNase fingerprint analysis was performed on the RNA genomes of 43 virus isolates from areas of epizootic and enzootic virus activity. This indicates that virus populations were genetically relatively homogeneous within successive U.S. virus epizootics. The data included virus isolates from different epizootic stages, geographical locations, host animals, and host lesion sites. In contrast, only distant genome RNA T1 fingerprint similarities were observed among viruses of the different U.S. epizootics. However, Mexican viruses isolated before or concurrent with U.S. epizootics had very similar RNA genome fingerprints, suggesting that Mexico may have been the possible origin of virus initiating recent U.S. VSV New Jersey outbreaks. Comparison of T1 fingerprints of viruses with enzootic disease areas revealed a greater extent of virus genetic diversity in these areas relative to that observed in epizootic areas. The evolutionary significance of these findings and their relationship to experimental data on VSV evolution are discussed.     

Effect of passage in culture on a clone of BALB/c 3T3 cells transformed by simian virus 40.

Most simian virus 40 (SV40)-transformed BALB/c 3T3 clones employed for biochemical studies have been used without regard to passage level. To determine whether virus-induced properties are stable as a function of passage, we have extensively characterized one transformed clone, FNE, which was isolated after SV40 infection BALB/c 3T3 cells in factor-free medium. From the initial testing at passage 5 and for at least 50 subsequent subcultures, the cells stably maintained many transformed growth properties, including high saturation density, morphology, colony formation on contact-inhibited monolayers, tumorigenicity, and synthesis of viral-specific RNA. However, other properties varied as a function of passage. There was a slight decrease in viral genome equivalents per cell from 1.1 copy/cell at passage 5 to 0.7 copies at passage 40. Initially, the cells were negative for all type C virus; however, cells carried at low density for 13 to 20 passages (65 to 100 generations) began to release an endogenous type C virus that then persisted in the culture. Spontaneous release of type C virus did not occur in control BALB/c 3T3 cells carried under identical culture conditions for 90 passages. When the cultures were releasing type C viruses they stained uniformly and brightly positive for SV40 tumor (T) antigen by immunofluorescence, whereas T antigen staining was variable at early passage. These experiments suggest that subtle but perhaps important differences in viral gene expression can occur as a function of passage; they also demonstrate the importance of evaluating the interactions between SV40 and endogenous type C viruses.     

Mutagenesis-induced, large fitness variations with an invariant arenavirus consensus genomic nucleotide sequence

Enhanced mutagenesis may result in RNA virus extinction, but the molecular events underlying this process are not well understood. Here we show that 5-fluorouracil (FU)-induced mutagenesis of the arenavirus lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) resulted in preextinction populations whose consensus genomic nucleotide sequence remained unaltered. Furthermore, fitness recovery passages in the absence of FU, or alternate virus passages in the presence and absence of FU, led to profound differences in the capacity of LCMV to produce progeny, without modification of the consensus genomic sequence. Molecular genetic analysis failed to produce evidence of hypermutated LCMV genomes. The results suggest that low-level mutagenesis to enrich the viral population with defector, interfering genomes harboring limited numbers of mutations may mediate the loss of infectivity that accompanies viral extinction.     

Evolutionary dynamics of viral attenuation

The genetic trajectory leading to viral attenuation was studied in a canine parvovirus (CPV) strain grown on dog kidney cells for 115 transfers. Consensus sequences of viral populations at passages 0, 3, 30, 50, 80, and 115 were obtained from PCR products covering 86% of the genome; clones from each of the 80th and 115th passages were also sequenced, covering 69% of the genome. Sixteen changes were fixed in the 115th-passage virus sample. Levels of polymorphism were strikingly different over time, in part because of a plaque-cloning step at passage 112 that reduced variation: passage 80 had 19 variants common among the clones, but passage 115 had only a single common variant. Several mutations increased in the culture at the same time, with most reaching fixation only after the 80th passage. The pattern of evolution was consistent with recombination and not with separate selective sweeps of individual mutations. Thirteen of the changes observed were identical to or at the same positions as changes observed in other isolates of CPV or feline panleukopenia virus.     

Genetic and phenotypic variation of foot-and-mouth disease virus during serial passages in a natural host

Foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV), like other RNA viruses, exhibits high mutation rates during replication that have been suggested to be of adaptive value. However, even though genetic variation in RNA viruses and, more specifically, FMDV has been extensively examined during virus replication in a wide variety of in vitro cell cultures, very little is known regarding the generation and effects of genetic variability of virus replication in the natural host under experimental conditions and no genetic data are available regarding the effects of serial passage in natural hosts. Here, we present the results of 20 serial contact transmissions of the highly pathogenic, pig-adapted O Taiwan 97 (O Tw97) isolate of FMDV in swine. We examined the virus genomic consensus sequences for a total of 37 full-length viral genomes recovered from 20 in vivo passages. The characteristics and distributions of changes in the sequences during the series of pig infections were analyzed in comparison to the O Tw97 genomes recovered from serially infected BHK-21 cell cultures. Unexpectedly, a significant reduction of virulence upon pig passages was observed, and finally, interruption of the viral transmission chain occurred after the14th pig passage (T14). Virus was, however, isolated from the tonsils and nasal swabs of the asymptomatic T15 pigs at 26 days postcontact, consistent with a natural establishment of the carrier state previously described only for ruminants. Surprisingly, the region encoding the capsid protein VP1 (1D) did not show amino acid changes during in vivo passages. These data demonstrate that contact transmission of FMDV O Tw97 in pigs mimics the fitness loss induced by the bottleneck effect, which was previously observed by others during plaque-to-plaque FMDV passage in vitro, suggesting that unknown mechanisms of virulence recovery might be necessary during the evolution and perpetuation of FMDV in nature.     

Evolution of pseudorabies virions containing genomes with an invertible long component after repeated passage in chicken embryo fibroblasts.

The genome of pseudorabies virus consists of two components, short (S) and long (L). Only the S component is bracketed by inverted repeats, and only the S component inverts itself relative to the L component, giving rise to two isomeric forms of the genome. An attenuated vaccine strain of pseudorabies virus (Norden), however, has a genome which is found in four isomeric forms (B. Lomniczi, M. L. Blankenship, and T. Ben-Porat, J. Virol. 49:970-979, 1984). To determine the basis for the atypical structure of the genome of the Norden strain, we examined more than 40 field isolates of pseudorabies virus; all contained genomes in which the L component was fixed in only one orientation relative to the S component. Several independently generated vaccine strains which have been passaged extensively in chicken embryos and chicken embryo fibroblast (CEF) cell cultures were also analyzed; they possessed an invertible L component. Furthermore, emergence of pseudorabies virus variants with an invertible L component was observed after passage of the virus in CEF, but not in rabbit kidney or pig kidney, cells. The invertibility of the L component was associated consistently with a translocation of sequences from the left end of the genome to a position next to the inverted repeat sequence of the S component. Three observations indicate that genomes with an invertible L component (and the translocation) have a selective growth advantage over standard pseudorabies virus when grown in CEF. The proportion of virions with such genomes does not increase linearly as would be expected if the translocation events occurred repeatedly, most genomes eventually experiencing the translocation. Instead, after a lag, the proportion of such virions in the population increases relatively rapidly. The genome structures that are generated upon independent passage in CEF of each virion population were relatively homogeneous. Some heterogeneity was observed at relatively early stages of the emergence of the genomes carrying the translocation; at later stages, virions with genomes with a specific size translocation predominated in the virus population. Parallel passages in CEF of the same pseudorabies virus strain resulted in the emergence of populations of virions with genomes with different size translocations. However, in each of the passaged populations of virions the majority of virions had genomes with the same size translocation. The most likely interpretation of these results is that virions with genomes carrying the translocations that emerge upon passage of the virus in CEF have a selective advantage when grown in these cells.     

Genetic bottlenecks and population passages cause profound fitness differences in RNA viruses.

Repeated clone-to-clone (genetic bottleneck) passages of an RNA phage and vesicular stomatitis virus have been shown previously to result in loss of fitness due to Muller's ratchet. We now demonstrate that Muller's ratchet also operates when genetic bottleneck passages are carried out at 37 rather than 32 degrees C. Thus, these fitness losses do not depend on growth of temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants at lowered temperatures. We also demonstrate that during repeated genetic bottleneck passages, accumulation of deleterious mutations does occur in a stepwise (ratchet-like) manner as originally proposed by Muller. One selected clone which had undergone significant loss of fitness after only 20 genetic bottleneck passages was passaged again in clone-to-clone series. Additional large losses of fitness were observed in five of nine independent bottleneck series; the relative fitnesses of the other four series remained close to the starting fitness. In sharp contrast, when the same selected clone was transferred 20 more times as large populations (10(5) to 10(6) PFU transferred at each passage), significant increases in fitness were observed in all eight passage series. Finally, we selected several clones which had undergone extreme losses of fitness during 20 bottleneck passages. When these low-fitness clones were passaged many times as large virus populations, they always regained very high relative fitness. We conclude that transfer of large populations of RNA viruses regularly selects those genomes within the quasispecies population which have the highest relative fitness, whereas bottleneck transfers have a high probability of leading to loss of fitness by random isolation of genomes carrying debilitating mutations. Both phenomena arise from, and underscore, the extreme mutability and variability of RNA viruses.     

Factors involved in the generation and replication of rhabdovirus defective T particles.

Previous indications that cloned B virions might be genetically predisposed to generate a particular defective T particle are shown to be inaccurate. T particle generation was found to be a much more random process than was previously believed. We show that the previously observed generation of particular sizes of T particles by B virion pools is due to the random generation of T particles during preparation of first-passage pools of cloned B virions, and these breed true during the additional passages needed to produce visible quantities of T particles. It is also shown that different host cell lines selectively amplify different T particles, suggesting a strong role of host cell factors in T particle replication. Surprisingly, our line of HeLa cells did not generate or replicate detectable T particles of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) Indiana after either serial undiluted passage or direct addition of T particles, even though the added T particles strongly interfered with B virion replication. In contrast to VSV, rabies virus generates large amounts of T particles during the first passage of cloned B virions, and every rabies-infected baby hamster kidney-21 cell culture evolves into a persistent carrier state. We find that T particle RNA is biologically inactive although T particle nucleocapsid ribonucleoprotein replicates and interferes in cells coinfected with B virions. Efforts to study the mechanism of T particle generation by in vitro attempts to generate T particles or modify their size (using sheared ribonucleoprotein or chemical or UV mutagenesis) were unsuccessful. The kinetics of UV and nitrous acid inactivation of T particles indicate a smaller target size relative to B virions, even after correcting for lengths of RNA molecules. The intercalating dye proflavine does not photosensitize VSV B virions or T particles when present during replication, indicating that there is little or no RNA base pairing in the helical nucleocapsids of either.     

Nucleotide sequence heterogeneity of the RNA from a natural population of foot-and-mouth-disease virus

The genomic RNA from isolates of foot-and-mouth-disease virus (FMDV) of serological types O or C obtained during epizootic outbreaks have been analysed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of the T1 RNase-generated oligonucleotides (T1 fingerprinting). Among virus isolates that are closely related serologically, 4-12 oligonucleotide changes were detected constitute the genome, the variations affect 0.7%-2.2% positions in FMDV RNA. Higher nucleotide-sequence divergence exists between the genomic RNAs from serologically unrelated viruses, while a 100-fold lower RNA sequence heterogeneity has been detected by analysis of individual clones derived from one viral isolate. Oligonucleotide mapping indicates that the variant oligonucleotides are scattered throughout the FMDV genome. We suggest that extensive genetic variability at many RNA sites is the basis for the antigenic diversity of FMDV.