The RNA origin of transfer RNA aminoacylation and beyond

Aminoacylation of tRNA is an essential event in the translation system. Although in the modern system protein enzymes play the sole role in tRNA aminoacylation, in the primitive translation system RNA molecules could have catalysed aminoacylation onto tRNA or tRNA-like molecules. Even though such RNA enzymes so far are not identified from known organisms, in vitro selection has generated such RNA catalysts from a pool of random RNA sequences. Among them, a set of RNA sequences, referred to as flexizymes (Fxs), discovered in our laboratory are able to charge amino acids onto tRNAs. Significantly, Fxs allow us to charge a wide variety of amino acids, including those that are non-proteinogenic, onto tRNAs bearing any desired anticodons, and thus enable us to reprogramme the genetic code at our will. This article summarizes the evolutionary history of Fxs and also the most recent advances in manipulating a translation system by integration with Fxs.     

On the conformation of serine-specific transfer RNA. Studies by small-angle X-ray scattering and ultraviolet absorption of the molecule in solution.

The scattered X-ray intensities from dilute solutions of tRNASer (yeast) in 0.1 M Soerensen buffer at pH 7.0 were measured at 25 degrees C. The radius of gyration, molecular weight and volume were determined. A model equivalent in scattering is given. The change of the conformation of tRNASer by heating was followed by small-angle X-ray measurements and ultraviolet absorption in a temperature range 20-70 degrees C. The molecule begins to unfold at about 40 degrees C and 70 degrees C has a random coil conformation. Addition of magnesium stabilizes the tRNASer molecule. The reversibility of the melting process was also studied by both methods. An interesting effect was found by ultraviolet absorption: by heating the tRNASer solutions to 55 degrees C and 60 degrees C and subsequently slowly cooling, the melting curves lie at higher absorption values than the corresponding cooling curves. The small-angle data and optical properties of tRNASer are compared with those of tRNAPhe which has already been thoroughly investigated.     

The non-monophyletic origin of the tRNA molecule

The hypothesis that the tRNA molecule may have originated from the assembly of two similar RNA hairpin structures is utilised to understand the evolutionary period in which this molecule originated. Consistent with the exon theory of genes is the observation that the introns in tRNA genes are found almost exclusively in the anticodon loop and "stitched together" the two halves of the molecule, which originally may have been simply two hairpin structures and which can still be observed in the three-dimensional structure of tRNAs. This theory therefore considers these hairpin structures as minigenes on which complex protein synthesis may have been achieved. This in turn leads to the belief that the organisation of the genetic code may have been determined by use of the hairpin structures but not the complete tRNA molecule. In view of this, it can be conjectured that tRNA molecules might have been assembled only after the establishment of the main phyletic lines. If this is all true, then the origin of the tRNA molecule might have been non-monophyletic, i.e. a tRNA specific for a certain amino acid might have been assembled in different phyletic lines with a second and different hairpin structure. This leads to the belief that tRNAs specific for different amino acids but belonging to the same phyletic line might have been more similar to one another than to tRNAs specific for the same amino acid but belonging to different phyletic lines. This prediction seems to be supported by phylogenetic analysis making major use of the bootstrap technique performed on the tRNA sequences and by analysis already existing in the literature which supports the non-monophyletic origin of the tRNA molecule. The main conclusion of this paper is that if the tRNA molecule was assembled in the main phyletic lines this would imply a still rapidly evolving translation apparatus which, in turn, seems to imply that the last universal common ancestor was a progenote.     

Photobinding of 8-methoxypsoralen to transfer RNA and 5-fluorouracil-enriched transfer RNA.

The photobinding of [3H]8MOP to tRNA upon irradiation at 365 nm in the absence of O2 was determined by gel filtration. The maximum photobinding was found to be ca. 4 mol of 8MOP er mol of tRNA and 5FU-tRNA, with an overall quantum yield of 2.3 X 10(-3). The photobinding kinetics for 8MOP-tRNA showed an apparent induction period or sigmoidal kinetic curve, indicating a specific initial photobinding site on tRNA which was identified as 4-thiouridine at position 8 from the 5'-end of Escherichia coli tRNA. Photobinding of 8MOP to 5FU-tRNA proceeded without an apparent induction period. 8MOP-tRNA and 8MOP-5FU-tRNA adducts were characterized by absorption, fluorescence, and CD spectroscopy. A modified procedure was also developed to analyze the nucleoside composition in modified 8MOP-tRNA and 8MOP-5FU-tRNA. The results showed that 8MOP photochemically added mainly to pyrimidine bases. The photobinding of 8MOP changed the conformation (secondary in particular) of tRNA and inhibited aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase activity.     

Aminoacylation of rat liver transfer RNA with L-penicillamine. On the specificity of the aminoacylation reaction.

L-]14C]Penicillamine is bound to RNA from rat liver in an in vitro reaction catalyzed by rat liver aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. Addition of certain naturally occuring amino acids results in a significant decrease of L-penicillamine binding. The most potent inhibitor of this binding is L-valine, followed by L-isoleucine and L-threonine. Amino acids without structural relationship to L-penicillamine in the non-functional part of the molecule, such as L-phenylalanine, are ineffective. Studies on the competition of L-penicillamine and L-isoleucine, respectively, with L-valine demonstrate the high specificity of the aminoacylation reaction. They show that the change of L-penicillamine binding to tRNA Val is considerably lower than that of L-valine.     

Isolation of the transfer RNA genes of bacteriophage T4 and transfer RNA synthesis in vitro.

Non-glucosylated T4 DNA was restricted with the endonuclease EcoRI and the mixture of DNA fragments separated by gel electrophoresis and transcribed with purified Escherichia coli RNA polymerase. Three purified fragments were shown to act as templates for tRNA synthesis. A smaller fragment, shown to be hybridizable to 32P-labeled T4 tRNA was not transcribable. It was concluded that the promoter for T4 tRNA synthesis had been separated from the structural genes in the smaller fragment by EcoRI and that the distal portion of the tRNA gene cluster lacks internal promoters which display in vitro activity. Preparations of non-glucosylated T4 DNA were never fully restricted with EcoRI and when the larger purified fragments carrying the tRNA were restricted with excess enzyme only a slight cleavage to yield the smaller fragments was obtained. The property of the DNA-limiting complete restriction is not know.     

Interaction of RNA with transformed glucocorticoid receptor. II. Identification of the RNA as transfer RNA

An endogenous RNA (designated as PIVB RNA), which is capable of associating with the 4 S glucocorticoid receptor (GR) to generate the 6 S form, has been purified from AtT-20 cells (Ali, M., and Vedeckis, W. V. (1987) J. Biol. Chem., 262, 6771-6777). We describe here the physiochemical properties, GR-RNA interaction characteristics, and the chemical identification of PIVB RNA. 32P-Labeled PIVB RNA was similar to transfer RNA (tRNA) in its sedimentation coefficient (4 S) on sucrose gradients, electrophoretic mobility on formaldehyde-agarose gels, and receptor binding characteristics. The amino acid acceptor activity of PIVB RNA displayed a typical tRNA-dependent saturation curve and was 2-3-fold higher than that of homologous rabbit liver tRNA when tested using rabbit liver aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase. The purified [3H] aminoacyl-PIVB complex was also capable of binding to the 4 S GR to generate the 6 S form. The analysis of PIVB RNA on an acrylamide-urea sequencing gel revealed that it contained a major tRNA of 76 nucleotides and other minor tRNA species of 74 and 78 nucleotides. The identity of the tRNA present in the PIVB RNA was indirectly deduced by analyzing the 3H-amino acids, liberated from the [3H]aminoacyl-PIVB RNA (tRNA) complex, and subsequent analysis on an amino acid analyzer. PIVB RNA mainly contained tRNAArg (51.8%), tRNALys (17.1%), and tRNAHis (9.2%) which together accounted for 78% of the total PIVB tRNA. The remaining 22% of tRNA was contributed by threonine, valine, aspartic acid, alanine, and phenylalanine tRNAs. The GR displayed no species specificity, and tRNA samples from mouse, cow, rabbit, yeast, and Escherichia coli can bind to the mouse 4 S GR to generate the 6 S form. However, PIVB RNA did not affect the sedimentation profiles of albumin, chymotrypsinogen, and histone, indicating that PIVB RNA does not bind to all proteins. Thus, there may exist some specificity both at the level of protein (GR) and the selection of RNA (tRNA). The GR binding to PIVB RNA occurred at low (nM) receptor concentration, and PIVB RNA showed limited capacity to shift 4 S GR to the 6 S form. 22.4 X 10(-11) mol of PIVB RNA can completely shift 4.8 X 10(-13) mol of 4 S GR to 6 S. That is, PIVB RNA has to be in a 500-600-fold excess over the amounts of GR to observe a stable 6 S GR X RNA complex on sucrose gradients. These results conclusively demonstrate that the transformed GR specifically binds to endogenous tRNA.     

Purification of a hybrid molecule composed of tyrosine transfer RNA and its complementary DNA sequence

The transducing bacteriophage φ80psu_III⁺ carries one structural Escherichia coli gene specifying tyrosine tRNA.The r strand of bacteriophage φ80psu_III⁺ was hybridized with E. coli transfer RNA and the hybrid digested with Neurospora crassa endonuclease. The analysis of the products of enzymic digestion demonstrated the release of a cistron-hybrid composed of tyrosine tRNA and its complementary DNA sequence. The cistron-hybrid was purified from unhybridized DNA by cesium sulphate density-gradient centrifugation and gel filtration.The ratio between tyrosine tRNA and its complementary DNA sequence in the final product was 1:1 as demonstrated by radioisotopic analysis. This purification represents a 30,000-fold enrichment of the E. coli genome for a specific DNA sequence.     

The origin of the tRNA molecule: implications for the origin of protein synthesis

A model for tRNA molecule origin is discussed. The model postulates that this molecule originated simply by direct duplication (and subsequent evolution) of a gene coding for an RNA hairpin structure, which can thus be hypothesized as the evolutionary precursor of the tRNA molecule. The main properties are defined for these hairpin structures and it is suggested that these structures might have housed, near their 3' end, anticodons that were transferred to the loop of the tRNA anticodon during duplication of the hairpin structures. Moreover, the main characteristics are given for the evolutionary intermediary formed by direct duplication of the hairpin structure, i.e. the double hairpin. The evolutionary stages envisaged by this model for tRNA origin seem to naturally imply some evolutionary transitions through which the origin of protein synthesis passed. Finally, some strong historical evidence is provided to corroborate the model.     

Role of the origin of transfer in termination of strand transfer during bacterial conjugation.

Conjugal transfer of the broad-host-range plasmid R1162 is initiated and terminated at the nic site within the 38-bp origin of transfer (oriT). Termination involves ligation of the transferred single strand by the plasmid-encoded MobA protein. Several different assays were used to identify the oriT DNA required for termination. For plasmids containing two oriTs, with transfer initiated at one and terminated at the other, the inverted repeat within oriT is important for termination. Deletion of the outer arm reduces the termination frequency; those terminations that do occur probably depend upon nicking at this oriT prior to transfer. The locations of second-site suppressor mutations indicate that base pairing between the arms of the inverted repeat is important for termination. In vitro, the inverted repeat is not required for specific cleavage of single-stranded DNA at nic, but competition experiments indicate that oriTs with the inverted repeat are preferentially cleaved. We propose that the function of the oriT inverted repeat is to trap the plasmid-encoded MobA protein at the end of a round of strand transfer, thus ensuring that the protein is available for the ligation step.     

Binding of ampholine to transfer RNA.

The melting temperature of isoaccepting tRNAfMet is affected by Ampholine. The plot of Tm versus the logarithm of Ampholine concentration shows clearly an increasing effect of Ampholine when the pH changes from 7.4 to 4.2. This result is interpreted as binding of Ampholine to the nucleic acid. The effects of Ampholine have been compared with those of soidum, magnesium and tetraethylene pentamine. Ampholine carrier ampholytes at pH 4.2 bind to tRNA with the same affinity as magnesium; at higher pH values they are less active. An hypothesis for the mechanism of action of Ampholine on nucleic acids during isoelectric focusing is proposed.     

On the origin of eukaryotic cytoskeleton.

The origin of eukaryote-specific cytoskeletal proteins is an issue which is closely related to the origin of the domain Eukarya. As nearly all of these proteins are not found in prokaryotes, the prokaryotic origin of eukaryotic cytoskeletal network suggested by most models is questionable. Eukaryotic cytoskeletal proteins might descend from subpopulations of pre-cells co-existing with Bacteria and Archaea prior to the origin of eukaryotes. The pre-karyote (the host for a-proteobacterial ancestors of mitochondria) might have already possessed eukaryotic-like cytoskeleton. A possible role for viruses in the origin of eukaryotic cytoskeletal proteins is discussed. Viruses parasitizing on pre-cells and/or on the pre-karyote might have themselves used several eukaryotic-like cytoskeletal proteins for segregation and packing of their genomes.