Immobilized-biomembrane affinity chromatography for binding studies of membrane proteins

Analyses of specific interactions between solutes and a membrane protein can serve to characterize the protein. Frontal affinity chromatography of an interactant on a column containing the membrane protein immobilized in a lipid environment is a simple and robust approach for series of experiments with particular protein molecules. Regression analysis of the retention volumes at a series of interactant concentrations shows the affinity of the protein for the interactant and the amount of active binding sites. The higher the affinity, the fewer sites are required to give sufficient retention. Competition experiments provide the affinities of even weakly binding solutes and the non-specific retention of the primary interactant. Hummel and Dreyer size-exclusion chromatography allows complementary analyses of non-immobilized membrane materials. Analyses of the human facilitative glucose transporter GLUT1 by use of the inhibitor cytochalasin B (radioactively labeled) and the competitive substrate D-glucose (non-labeled) showed that GLUT1 interconverted between two states, exhibiting one or two cytochalasin B-binding sites per two GLUTI monomers, dependent on the membrane composition and environment. Similar analyses of a nucleoside transporter, a photosynthetic reaction center, nicotinic acetylcholine receptors and a P-glycoprotein, alternative techniques, and immobilized-liposome chromatographic approaches are presented briefly.     

Histidine ligand affinity chromatography

The sorbents with immobilized histidine as a pseudo affinity ligand with a wide specificity is described. The possibilities and relevant chemistries to use both particulate and flat or hollow fiber membranes as support matrices are discussed. The usefulness of such adsorbents for the purification of a wide variety of proteins, with relevant interaction mechanism are described. Practical protocols of sample quality, capacity and scaled up and scaled down operations are discussed. Possibilities of pyrogen removal from high value blood proteins and their simultaneous recovery in the pure form, using histidine immobilized sorbents are described.     

Muscarinic receptor-detergent complexes with different biochemical properties: selective solubilization, lectin affinity chromatography and ligand binding studies

Muscarinic receptors were solubilized by nonionic, zwitterionic and ionic detergents from porcine striatum. A mixture of digitonin and gitonin (3:2) was found to be most suitable in respect to receptor yield and stability. The solubilization of muscarinic receptors by this detergent appears to be dependent on the existence of free detergent micelles. Consequently, the receptor solubilization was studied at different protein-to-detergent ratios. Based on these experiments, a double extraction procedure was developed in which the receptor is solubilized subsequent to the solubilization of other membrane proteins. After elimination of the detergent excess, the binding of the receptor-detergent complex to six immobilized lectins was studied. In accordance with previous reports, we found a considerable portion of the digitonin/gitonin solubilized receptors (one step extraction procedure) specifically bound to wheat germ agglutinin via sialic acid residues. Muscarinic receptors solubilized by a double extraction procedure (either from porcine striatum or rat brain) did not bind to the lectin. This is not owing to selective extraction or partial denaturation, and indicates that considerable portions of the glycan residues are not covalently bound to the receptor polypeptide. A GTP-insensitive heterogenous agonist binding was found only at the non-wheat germ agglutinin binding receptors. The data analysis was performed by the affinity spectra method.     

Quantitative studies of ion-exchange and affinity elution chromatography of enzymes

Quantitative studies on the binding of a variety of enzymes to CM-cellulose have been carried out, and the magnitude of the affinity elution effect in the presence of substrates of the enzymes has been determined. In most cases the weakening of binding in the presence of substrate corresponded closely to the amount expected as a result of the overall charge change, but in a few examples the effect was greater. Some calculations have been made demonstrating the range of strengths of interactions between enzyme and adsorbent, and the energy involved per charge on the protein molecule.     

Quantitative affinity chromatography.

The objective of this review is to summarize developments in the use of quantitative affinity chromatography to determine equilibrium constants for solute interactions of biological interest. Affinity chromatography is an extremely versatile method for characterizing interactions between dissimilar reactants because the biospecificity incorporated into the design of the affinity matrix ensures applicability of the method regardless of the relative sizes of the two reacting solutes. Adoption of different experimental strategies, such as column chromatography, simple partition equilibrium experiments, solid-phase immunoassay, and biosensor technology, has led to a situation whereby affinity chromatography affords a means of characterizing interactions governed by an extremely broad range of binding affinities--relatively weak interactions (binding constants below 10(3) M(-1)) through to interactions with binding constants in excess of 10(9) M(-1). In addition to its important role in solute separation and purification, affinity chromatography thus also possesses considerable potential for investigating the functional roles of the reactants thereby purified.     

Quantitative affinity chromatography of alpha-chymotrypsin

Affinity chromatography on a column of 4-phenylbutylamine, immobilized on succinylated polyacrylic hydrazide agarose, has been employed to study binding of ligands to α-chymotrypsin. In contrast to earlier studies of competitive elution phenomena, where an added soluble ligand interferes with enzyme binding to an affinity matrix, benzyloxycarbonyl derivatives of aromatic acids have been shown to facilitate binding of chymotrypsin to this matrix. This behavior has been analyzed in terms of an expanded binding scheme for affinity chromatography including the formation of a ternary complex (α-chymotrypsin · benzyloxycarbonyl-amino acid · 4-phenylbutylamine · matrix) where the soluble ligand and immobilized ligand bind to different sites. Equations to describe the phenonema have been derived and utilized to quantitate equilibrium constants for dissociation of the binary and ternary complexes. Benzyloxycarbonyl-Ala-Ala was found to promote earlier elution of the enzyme from its affinity matrix. Other ligands known to bind to the active site do not alter the binding to the 4-phenylbutylamine affinity matrix. These results illustrate the conclusion that binding of a small molecule can alter affinity retention in positive, negative, or neutral modes. This suggests that affinity chromatography could be “fine-tuned” by appropriate selection of cosolutes and illustrates the value of relatively weakly binding affinity matrices in enzyme studies.     

DNA affinity binding studies using a fluorescent dye displacement technique: the dichotomy of the binding site

We have observed a number of discrepancies and contradictions in the use of a fluorescent intercalator displacement assay in surveying the binding affinities of dinuclear polypyridyl ruthenium(II) complexes with DNA. By a modification of the assay using the fluorescent minor-groove binder 4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole, rather than intercalating dyes (ethidium bromide or thiazole orange), results were obtained for all complexes studied which were consistent with relative affinities and stereoselectivities observed with other techniques, including NMR, affinity chromatography and equilibrium dialysis. It is believed that the difference in binding mode between the minor groove-binding Ru(II) complexes and the intercalating fluorescent dyes they are displacing may contribute to these discrepancies. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Specific adsorbents for affinity chromatography of benzodiazepine binding proteins

The use of affinity chromatography as means of isolating/purifying proteins which have an affinity for benzodiazepine is described. Three such drugs are employed: chlorazepate, clonazepam and delorazepam. The results presented in this paper indicate that the proposed technique only works for chlorazepate and delorazepam. In fact these benzodiazepine-Sepharose derivatives are able to retain specifically proteins from human serum and rat kidney, lung, skeletal muscle and brain.     

Protein-peptide interaction studies demonstrate the versatility of calmodulin target protein binding

Calmodulin (CaM) is a prototypical Ca2+-sensor protein that can control many important biological functions by binding to hundreds of target proteins. To gain insight into the versatility of CaM-target recognition, we have analyzed the complex structures for many types of CaM-binding peptides and some target proteins. In particular, some recently reported novel complex structures reveal that the versatile target binding of CaM is accommodated by its flexible domain arrangement and the malleability of its interfaces.     

Crystal packing modifies ligand binding affinity: the case of aldose reductase

The relationship between the structures of protein-ligand complexes existing in the crystal and in solution, essential in the case of fragment-based screening by X-ray crystallography (FBS-X), has been often an object of controversy. To address this question, simultaneous co-crystallization and soaking of two inhibitors with different ratios, Fidarestat (FID; K(d) = 6.5 nM) and IDD594 (594; K(d) = 61 nM), which bind to h-aldose reductase (AR), have been performed. The subatomic resolution of the crystal structures allows the differentiation of both inhibitors, even when the structures are almost superposed. We have determined the occupation ratio in solution by mass spectrometry (MS) Occ(FID)/Occ(594) = 2.7 and by X-ray crystallography Occ(FID)/Occ(594) = 0.6. The occupancies in the crystal and in solution differ 4.6 times, implying that ligand binding potency is influenced by crystal contacts. A structural analysis shows that the Loop A (residues 122-130), which is exposed to the solvent, is flexible in solution, and is involved in packing contacts within the crystal. Furthermore, inhibitor 594 contacts the base of Loop A, stabilizing it, while inhibitor FID does not. This is shown by the difference in B-factors of the Loop A between the AR-594 and AR-FID complexes. A stable loop diminishes the entropic energy barrier to binding, favoring 594 versus FID. Therefore, the effect of the crystal environment should be taken into consideration in the X-ray diffraction analysis of ligand binding to proteins. This conclusion highlights the need for additional methodologies in the case of FBS-X to validate this powerful screening technique, which is widely used.     

Co-operative binding interactions in affinity chromatography: Theoretical considerations

A theoretical relationship has been developed to allow the effect of free ligand concentration on the capacity of an affinity Chromatography matrix to be determined where the protein adsorbed shows co-operative binding. Computer simulations using literature values for association constants show that under optimal conditions resin capacity can be increased significantly in the presence of a small but finite concentration of free ligand. The model also allows prediction of the soluble ligand concentration required for biospecific elution. The results obtained suggest the possibility of a new elution technique, "reverse biospecific elution," that reduces the amount of free ligand required to effect elution.     

High-performance affinity chromatography: a powerful tool for studying serum protein binding

High-performance affinity chromatography (HPAC) is a method in which a biologically-related ligand is used as a stationary phase in an HPLC system. This approach is a powerful means for selectively isolating or quantitating agents in complex samples, but it can also be employed to study the interactions of biological systems. In recent years there have been numerous reports in which HPAC has been used to examine the interactions of drugs, hormones and other substances with serum proteins. This review discusses how HPAC has been used in such work. Particular attention is given to the techniques of zonal elution and frontal analysis. Various applications are provided for these techniques, along with a list of factors that need to be considered in their optimization and use. New approaches based on band-broadening studies and rapid immunoextraction are also discussed.     

Immobilized cytochrome c--an effective ligand for affinity chromatography of electron transport proteins

Preparations of horse heart cytochrome c have been obtained immobilized on Sepharose derivatives via lysine epsilon-amino groups, carboxyl groups of aspartic and glutamic acid residues, methionine and histidine residues as well as imidazole groups additionally introduced by means of chemical modification of free carboxyl groups by histamine. Dissociation constants have been determined for complexes of adrenodoxin, hepatoredoxin, cytochrome b5 heme-containing fragment and myoglobin with preparations of cytochrome c immobilized via lysine residues (adsorbent I) or additionally introduced imidazole groups (adsorbent II). The latter is found to possess a 2-3 times greater affinity for adrenodoxin and hepatoredoxin than the former. The affinity of the proteins studied for the adsorbent II constitutes the following sequence: adrenodoxin greater than or equal to hepatoredoxin greater than cytochrome b5 heme-containing fragment greater than myoglobin. The adsorbent II is shown to be effective when used for purification of hepatoredoxin, adrenodoxin, cytochrome b5 and isolation of cytochrome b5 heme-containing fragment.     

The insulin receptor. Structural basis for high affinity ligand binding

Treatment of the soluble insulin receptor from human placenta with 1.25 mM dithiothreitol and 75 mM Tris at pH 8.5 results in complete reduction of interhalf disulfide bonds (class 1 disulfides) and dissociation of the tetrameric receptor into the dimeric alpha beta form. The alpha beta receptor halves exhibit a reduced affinity for insulin binding (B?ni-Schnetzler, M., Rubin, J. B., and Pilch, P. F. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 15281-15287). Kinetic experiments reveal that reduction of class 1 disulfides is a faster process than the loss of affinity for ligand, indicating that events subsequent to reduction of interhalf disulfides are responsible for the affinity change. We show that a third class of alpha subunit intrachain disulfides is more susceptible to reduction at pH 7.6 than at pH 8.5 and appears to form part of the ligand binding domain. Reduction of the intrachain disulfide bonds in this part of the alpha subunit leads to a loss of insulin binding. Modification of this putative binding domain by dithiothreitol can be minimized if reduction is carried out at pH 8.5. When the insulin receptor in placental membranes is reduced at pH 8.5, the receptor's affinity for insulin is not changed when binding is measured in the membrane. However, the Kd for insulin binding is reduced 10-fold when alpha beta receptor halves are subsequently solubilized. Scatchard analysis of insulin binding to reduced or intact receptors in the membrane and in soluble form together with sucrose density gradient analysis of soluble receptors suggests that alpha beta receptor halves remain associated in the membrane after reduction, but they are dissociated upon solubilization. We interpret these results to mean that the association of two ligand binding domains, 2 alpha beta receptor halves, is required for the formation of an insulin receptor with high affinity for ligand.     

Distinct affinity and effector residues in the binding site for a regulatory ligand

A hypothesis concerning two distinct classes of amino acid residues in some regulatory binding sites is proposed. The affinity residues are those that are unable to transduce the ligand information signal but are responsible for overcoming the barrier for the attachment of a ligand to its binding site while the effector residues transfer the binding signal to the other functional part of the protein, which then undergoes a non-equilibrium energetic cycle induced by interaction with the ligand.As an example, the purine nucleotide inhibition of H⁺ transport through the uncoupling protein of brown adipose tissue mitochondria is discussed; there is a concentration range in which the nucleotide is bound but does not inhibit H⁺ transport. This is interpreted in terms of inaccessibility of the effector residues inducing H⁺ transport inhibition below a certain threshold concentration.     

Quantitative structure-retention relationships in affinity high-performance liquid chromatography

In this report the affinity high-performance liquid chromatography data, which were determined on silica-based human serum albumin, alpha1-acid glycoprotein, keratin, collagen, melanin, amylose tris(3,5-dimethylphenylcarbamate), and basic fatty acid binding protein columns, are discussed. Using a quantitative structure-retention relationship (QSRR) approach the affinity data were interpreted in terms of structural requirements of specific binding sites on biomacromolecules. The unique chromatographic properties of immobilized artificial membrane and cholesterol stationary phases were also analyzed from the point of view of mimicking biological processes. It has been demonstrated that chemometric processing of appropriately designed sets of chromatographic data derived in systems comprising biomolecules provides information of relevance for molecular pharmacology and rational drug design.     

Immobilization of DNA for affinity chromatography and drug-binding studies.

A method is described in which double-stranded DNA is alkylated with 4-bis-(2-chloroethyl)amino-L-phenylalanine and the product immobilized on an insoluble support via the primary amino group of the phenylalanine moiety. The DNA is hence irreversibly bound to the matrix by both strands at a limited number of points.     

Manipulation of ligand binding affinity by exploitation of conformational coupling

Traditional approaches for increasing the affinity of a protein for its ligand focus on constructing improved surface complementarity in the complex by altering the protein binding site to better fit the ligand. Here we present a novel strategy that leaves the binding site intact, while residues that allosterically affect binding are mutated. This method takes advantage of conformationally distinct states, each with different ligand-binding affinities, and manipulates the equilibria between these conformations. We demonstrate this approach in the Escherichia coli maltose binding protein by introducing mutations, located at some distance from the ligand binding pocket, that sterically affect the equilibrium between an open, apo-state and a closed, ligand-bound state. A family of 20 variants was generated with affinities ranging from an approximately 100-fold improvement (7.4 nM) to an approximately two-fold weakening (1.8 mM) relative to the wild type protein (800 nM).     

The affinity of human RANK binding to its ligand RANKL

Receptor activator of nuclear factor-kappa B (RANK) and its ligand, RANKL play critical roles in bone re-modeling, immune function, vascular disease and mammary gland development. To study the interaction of RANK and RANKL, we have expressed both extracellular domain of RANK and ectodomain of RANKL using Escherichia coli expression system. RANK was expressed as an inclusion body first which properly refolded later, while RANKL was initially produced as a GST fusion protein, after which the GST was removed by enzyme digestion. Soluble RANK existed as a monomer while RANKL was seen as a trimer in solution, demonstrated by gel filtration chromatography and cross-linking experiment. The recombinant RANK and RANKL could bind to each other and the binding affinity of RANKL for RANK was measured with surface plasmon resonance technology and K_D value is about 1.09 × 10⁻¹⁰ M.