The role of loop 5 in acetylcholine receptor channel gating

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor channel (AChR) gating is an organized sequence of molecular motions that couples a change in the affinity for ligands at the two transmitter binding sites with a change in the ionic conductance of the pore. Loop 5 (L5) is a nine-residue segment (mouse alpha-subunit 92-100) that links the beta4 and beta5 strands of the extracellular domain and that (in the alpha-subunit) contains binding segment A. Based on the structure of the acetylcholine binding protein, we speculate that in AChRs L5 projects from the transmitter binding site toward the membrane along a subunit interface. We used single-channel kinetics to quantify the effects of mutations to alphaD97 and other L5 residues with respect to agonist binding (to both open and closed AChRs), channel gating (for both unliganded and fully-liganded AChRs), and desensitization. Most alphaD97 mutations increase gating (up to 168-fold) but have little or no effect on ligand binding or desensitization. Rate-equilibrium free energy relationship analysis indicates that alphaD97 moves early in the gating reaction, in synchrony with the movement of the transmitter binding site (Phi = 0.93, which implies an open-like character at the transition state). alphaD97 mutations in the two alpha-subunits have unequal energetic consequences for gating, but their contributions are independent. We conclude that the key, underlying functional consequence of alphaD97 perturbations is to increase the unliganded gating equilibrium constant. L5 emerges as an important and early link in the AChR gating reaction which, in the absence of agonist, serves to increase the relative stability of the closed conformation of the protein.     

Initial coupling of binding to gating mediated by conserved residues in the muscle nicotinic receptor

We examined functional consequences of intrasubunit contacts in the nicotinic receptor alpha subunit using single channel kinetic analysis, site-directed mutagenesis, and structural modeling. At the periphery of the ACh binding site, our structural model shows that side chains of the conserved residues alphaK145, alphaD200, and alphaY190 converge to form putative electrostatic interactions. Structurally conservative mutations of each residue profoundly impair gating of the receptor channel, primarily by slowing the rate of channel opening. The combined mutations alphaD200N and alphaK145Q impair channel gating to the same extent as either single mutation, while alphaK145E counteracts the impaired gating due to alphaD200K, further suggesting electrostatic interaction between these residues. Interpreted in light of the crystal structure of acetylcholine binding protein (AChBP) with bound carbamylcholine (CCh), the results suggest in the absence of ACh, alphaK145 and alphaD200 form a salt bridge associated with the closed state of the channel. When ACh binds, alphaY190 moves toward the center of the binding cleft to stabilize the agonist, and its aromatic hydroxyl group approaches alphaK145, which in turn loosens its contact with alphaD200. The positional changes of alphaK145 and alphaD200 are proposed to initiate the cascade of perturbations that opens the receptor channel: the first perturbation is of beta-strand 7, which harbors alphaK145 and is part of the signature Cys-loop, and the second is of beta-strand 10, which harbors alphaD200 and connects to the M1 domain. Thus, interplay between these three conserved residues relays the initial conformational change from the ACh binding site toward the ion channel.     

Acetylcholine receptor gating at extracellular transmembrane domain interface: the cys-loop and M2-M3 linker

Acetylcholine receptor channel gating is a propagated conformational cascade that links changes in structure and function at the transmitter binding sites in the extracellular domain (ECD) with those at a "gate" in the transmembrane domain (TMD). We used Phi-value analysis to probe the relative timing of the gating motions of alpha-subunit residues located near the ECD-TMD interface. Mutation of four of the seven amino acids in the M2-M3 linker (which connects the pore-lining M2 helix with the M3 helix), including three of the four residues in the core of the linker, changed the diliganded gating equilibrium constant (K(eq)) by up to 10,000-fold (P272 > I274 > A270 > G275). The average Phi-value for the whole linker was approximately 0.64. One interpretation of this result is that the gating motions of the M2-M3 linker are approximately synchronous with those of much of M2 (approximately 0.64), but occur after those of the transmitter binding site region (approximately 0.93) and loops 2 and 7 (approximately 0.77). We also examined mutants of six cys-loop residues (V132, T133, H134, F135, P136, and F137). Mutation of V132, H134, and F135 changed K(eq) by 2800-, 10-, and 18-fold, respectively, and with an average Phi-value of 0.74, similar to those of other cys-loop residues. Even though V132 and I274 are close, the energetic coupling between I and V mutants of these positions was small (< or =0.51 kcal mol(-1)). The M2-M3 linker appears to be the key moving part that couples gating motions at the base of the ECD with those in TMD. These interactions are distributed along an approximately 16-A border and involve about a dozen residues.     

Conformational dynamics of the alphaM3 transmembrane helix during acetylcholine receptor channel gating

Muscle acetylcholine receptors are synaptic ion channels that "gate" between closed- and open-channel conformations. We used Phi-value analysis to probe the transition state of the diliganded gating reaction with regard to residues in the M3, membrane-spanning helix of the muscle acetylcholine receptor alpha-subunit. Phi (a fraction between 1 and 0) parameterizes the extent to which a mutation changes the opening versus the closing rate constant and, for a linear reaction mechanism, the higher the Phi-value, the "earlier" the gating motion. In the upper half of alphaM3 the gating motions of all five tested residues were temporally correlated (Phi approximately 0.30) and serve to link structural changes occurring at the middle of the M2, pore-lining helix with those occurring at the interface of the extracellular and transmembrane domains. alphaM3 belongs to a complex and diverse set of synchronously moving parts that change structure relatively late in the channel-opening process. The propagation of the gating Brownian conformational cascade has a complex spatial distribution in the transmembrane domain.     

Gating dynamics of the acetylcholine receptor extracellular domain

We used single-channel recording and model-based kinetic analyses to quantify the effects of mutations in the extracellular domain (ECD) of the alpha-subunit of mouse muscle-type acetylcholine receptors (AChRs). The crystal structure of an acetylcholine binding protein (AChBP) suggests that the ECD is comprised of a beta-sandwich core that is surrounded by loops. Here we focus on loops 2 and 7, which lie at the interface of the AChR extracellular and transmembrane domains. Side chain substitutions in these loops primarily affect channel gating by either decreasing or increasing the gating equilibrium constant. Many of the mutations to the beta-core prevent the expression of functional AChRs, but of the mutants that did express almost all had wild-type behavior. Rate-equilibrium free energy relationship analyses reveal the presence of two contiguous, distinct synchronously-gating domains in the alpha-subunit ECD that move sequentially during the AChR gating reaction. The transmitter-binding site/loop 5 domain moves first (Phi = 0.93) and is followed by the loop 2/loop 7 domain (Phi = 0.80). These movements precede that of the extracellular linker (Phi = 0.69). We hypothesize that AChR gating occurs as the stepwise movements of such domains that link the low-to-high affinity conformational change in the TBS with the low-to-high conductance conformational change in the pore.     

Structural examination of phi-value analysis in protein folding

Protein folding intermediates and transition states are commonly characterized using a protein engineering procedure (Phi-value analysis) based on several assumptions, including (1) intermediates and transition states have native-like conformations and (2) single mutations from larger hydrophobic residues to smaller ones do not perturb their structures. Although Phi-value analysis has been widely used, these assumptions have not been tested to date because of the lack of high-resolution structures of intermediates and transition states. We recently have determined the structure of a folding intermediate for a four-helix bundle protein (Rd-apocytochrome b(562)) using NMR. The intermediate has the N-terminal helix unfolded. The other three helices fold in a native-like topology with extensive non-native hydrophobic interactions. Here, we have determined the Phi values for 14 hydrophobic core residues, including those with significant non-native interactions. All of the Phi values are in the normal range from 0 to 1, indicating that these non-native interactions cannot be identified by the common Phi-value analysis, and therefore, the first assumption is not valid for this intermediate. We also determined the structure of a mutant (F65A) of the intermediate and found that the structure of the intermediate is not perturbed by the mutation, supporting the second assumption. Together, these results suggest that Phi-value analysis may be valid for characterizing the energetics of the interactions between the mutated residue and others, but not for determining the detailed structures of intermediates and transition states because non-native interactions may exist and may not be identifiable by the common Phi-value analysis.     

Mapping heat exchange in an allosteric protein

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) are synaptic ion channels that spontaneously isomerize (i.e., gate) between resting and active conformations. We used single-molecule electrophysiology to measure the temperature dependencies of mouse neuromuscular AChR gating rate and equilibrium constants. From these we estimated free energy, enthalpy, and entropy changes caused by mutations of amino acids located between the transmitter binding sites and the middle of the membrane domain. The range of equilibrium enthalpy change (13.4 kcal/mol) was larger than for free energy change (5.5 kcal/mol at 25°C). For two residues, the slope of the rate-equilibrium free energy relationship (Φ) was approximately constant with temperature. Mutant cycle analysis showed that both free energies and enthalpies are additive for energetically independent mutations. We hypothesize that changes in energy associated with changes in structure mainly occur close to the site of the mutation, and, hence, that it is possible to make a residue-by-residue map of heat exchange in the AChR gating isomerization. The structural correlates of enthalpy changes are discussed for 12 different mutations in the protein.     

Gating at the mouth of the acetylcholine receptor channel: energetic consequences of mutations in the alphaM2-cap

Gating of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors from a C(losed) to an O(pen) conformation is the initial event in the postsynaptic signaling cascade at the vertebrate nerve-muscle junction. Studies of receptor structure and function show that many residues in this large, five-subunit membrane protein contribute to the energy difference between C and O. Of special interest are amino acids located at the two transmitter binding sites and in the narrow region of the channel, where C<-->O gating motions generate a low<-->high change in the affinity for agonists and in the ionic conductance, respectively. We have measured the energy changes and relative timing of gating movements for residues that lie between these two locations, in the C-terminus of the pore-lining M2 helix of the alpha subunit ('alphaM2-cap'). This region contains a binding site for non-competitive inhibitors and a charged ring that influences the conductance of the open pore. alphaM2-cap mutations have large effects on gating but much smaller effects on agonist binding, channel conductance, channel block and desensitization. Three alphaM2-cap residues (alphaI260, alphaP265 and alphaS268) appear to move at the outset of channel-opening, about at the same time as those at the transmitter binding site. The results suggest that the alphaM2-cap changes its secondary structure to link gating motions in the extracellular domain with those in the channel that regulate ionic conductance.     

Acetylcholine receptor gating at extracellular transmembrane domain interface: the "pre-M1" linker

Charged residues in the beta10-M1 linker region ("pre-M1") are important in the expression and function of neuromuscular acetylcholine receptors (AChRs). The perturbation of a salt bridge between pre-M1 residue R209 and loop 2 residue E45 has been proposed as being a principle event in the AChR gating conformational "wave." We examined the effects of mutations to all five residues in pre-M1 (positions M207-P211) plus E45 in loop 2 in the mouse alpha(1)-subunit. M207, Q208, and P211 mutants caused small (approximately threefold) changes in the gating equilibrium constant (K(eq)), but the changes for R209, L210, and E45 were larger. Of 19 different side chain substitutions at R209 on the wild-type background, only Q, K, and H generated functional channels, with the largest change in K(eq) (67-fold) from R209Q. Various R209 mutants were functional on different E45 backgrounds: H, Q, and K (E45A), H, A, N, and Q (E45R), and K, A, and N (E45L). Phi values for R209 (on the E45A background), L210, and E45 were 0.74, 0.35, and 0.80, respectively. Phi values for R209 on the wt and three other backgrounds could not be estimated because of scatter. The average coupling energy between 209/45 side chains (six different pairs) was only -0.33 kcal/mol (for both alpha subunits, combined). Pre-M1 residues are important for expression of functional channels and participate in gating, but the relatively modest changes in closed- vs. open-state energy caused mutations, the weak coupling energy between these residues and the functional activity of several unmatched-charge pairs are not consistent with the perturbation of a salt bridge between R209 and E45 playing the principle role in gating.     

Linking the Acetylcholine Receptor-Channel Agonist-Binding Sites with the Gate

The gating isomerization of neuromuscular acetylcholine receptors links the rearrangements of atoms at two transmitter-binding sites with those at a distant gate region in the pore. To explore the mechanism of this reversible process, we estimated the gating rate and equilibrium constants for receptors with point mutations of α-subunit residues located between the binding sites and the membrane domain (N95, A96, Y127, and I49). The maximum energy change caused by a side-chain substitution at αA96 was huge (∼8.6 kcal/mol, the largest value measured so far for any α-subunit amino acid). A Φ-value analysis suggests that αA96 experiences its change in energy (structure) approximately synchronously with residues αY127 and αI49, but after the agonist molecule and other residues in loop A. Double mutant-cycle experiments show that the energy changes at αA96 are strongly coupled with those of αY127 and αI49. We identify a column of mutation-sensitive residues in the α-subunit that may be a pathway for energy transfer through the extracellular domain in the gating isomerization.     

The intrinsic energy of the gating isomerization of a neuromuscular acetylcholine receptor channel

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) channels at neuromuscular synapses rarely open in the absence of agonists, but many different mutations increase the unliganded gating equilibrium constant (E0) to generate AChRs that are active constitutively. We measured E0 for two different sets of mutant combinations and by extrapolation estimated E0 for wild-type AChRs. The estimates were 7.6 and 7.8×10(-7) in adult-type mouse AChRs (-100 mV at 23°C). The values are in excellent agreement with one obtained previously by using a completely different method (6.5×10(-7), from monoliganded gating). E0 decreases with depolarization to the same extent as does the diliganded gating equilibrium constant, e-fold with ～60 mV. We estimate that at -100 mV the intrinsic energy of the unliganded gating isomerization is +8.4 kcal/mol (35 kJ/mol), and that in the absence of a membrane potential, the intrinsic chemical energy of this global conformational change is +9.4 kcal/mol (39 kJ/mol). Na+ and K+ in the extracellular solution have no measureable effect on E0, which suggests that unliganded gating occurs with only water occupying the transmitter binding sites. The results are discussed with regard to the energy changes in receptor activation and the competitive antagonism of ions in agonist binding.     

Activation kinetics of recombinant mouse nicotinic acetylcholine receptors: mutations of alpha-subunit tyrosine 190 affect both binding and gating.

Affinity labeling and mutagenesis studies have demonstrated that the conserved tyrosine Y190 of the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) alpha-subunit is a key determinant of the agonist binding site. Here we describe the binding and gating kinetics of embryonic mouse AChRs with mutations at Y190. In Y190F the dissociation constant for ACh binding to closed channels was reduced approximately 35-fold at the first binding site and only approximately 2-fold at the second site. At both binding sites the association and dissociation rate constants were decreased by the mutation. Compared with wildtype AChRs, doubly-liganded alpha Y190F receptors open 400 times more slowly but close only 2 times more rapidly. Considering the overall activation reaction (vacant-closed to fully occupied-open), there is an increase of approximately 6.4 kcal/mol caused by the Y-to-F mutation, of which at least 2.1 and 0.3 kcal/mol comes from altered agonist binding to the first and second binding sites, respectively. The closing rate constant of alpha Y190F receptors was the same with ACh, carbamoylcholine, or tetramethylammonium as the agonist. This rate constant was approximately 3 times faster in ACh-activated S, W, and T mutants. The equilibrium dissociation constant for channel block by ACh was approximately 2-fold lower in alpha Y190F receptors compared with in wildtype receptors, suggesting that there are changes in the pore region of the receptor as a consequence of the mutation. The activation reaction is discussed with regard to energy provided by agonist-receptor binding contacts, and by the intrinsic folding energy of the receptor.     

Second transmembrane domains of ENaC subunits contribute to ion permeation and selectivity

Epithelial sodium channels (ENaC) are composed of three structurally related subunits (alpha, beta, and gamma). Each subunit has two transmembrane domains termed M1 and M2, and residues conferring cation selectivity have been shown to reside in a pore region immediately preceding the M2 domains of the three subunits. Negatively charged residues are interspersed within the M2 domains, and substitution of individual acidic residues within human alpha-ENaC with arginine essentially eliminated channel activity in oocytes, suggesting that these residues have a role in ion permeation. We examined the roles of M2 residues in contributing to the permeation pore by individually mutating residues within the M2 domain of mouse alphaENaC to cysteine and systematically characterizing functional properties of mutant channels expressed in Xenopus oocytes by two-electrode voltage clamp. The introduction of cysteine residues at selected sites, including negatively charged residues (alphaGlu(595), alphaGlu(598), and alphaAsp(602)) led to a significant reduction of expressed amiloride-sensitive Na(+) currents. Two mutations (alphaE595C and alphaD602C) resulted in K(+)-permeable channels whereas multiple mutations altered Li(+)/Na(+) current ratios. Channels containing alphaD602K or alphaD602A also conducted K(+) whereas more conservative mutations (alphaD602E and alphaD602N) retained wild type selectivity. Cysteine substitution at the site equivalent to alphaAsp(602) within beta mENaC (betaD544C) did not alter either Li(+)/Na(+) or K(+)/Na(+) current ratios, although mutation of the equivalent site within gamma mENaC (gammaD562C) significantly increased the Li(+)/Na(+) current ratio. Mutants containing introduced cysteine residues at alphaGlu(595), alphaGlu(598), alphaAsp(602), or alphaThr(607) did not respond to externally applied sulfhydryl reagent with significant changes in macroscopic currents. Our results suggest that some residues within the M2 domain of alphaENaC contribute to the channel's conduction pore and that, in addition to the pore region, selected sites within M2 (alphaGlu(595) and alphaAsp(602)) may have a role in conferring ion selectivity.     

Mapping the structural requirements for nicotinic acetylcholine receptor activation by using tethered alkyltrimethylammonium agonists and antagonists

A molecule as simple in structure as tetramethylammonium gates the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) with high efficacy. To compare the structure of the nAChR transmitter binding site in the open channel state with that of the ACh binding protein, we determined the efficacy of nAChR gating by -S(CH(2))(n)N(CH(3))(3)(+) (n = 1-4) tethered to substituted cysteines at positions in the alpha subunits or gamma and delta subunits predicted to contribute to the ACh binding sites in mutant Torpedo nAChRs expressed in Xenopus oocytes. For tethered thiocholine [-S(CH(2))(2)N(CH(3))(3)(+)], we previously reported that within alpha195-201 gating was observed only at alphaY198C while at alphaY93C it acted as an antagonist. We now show that within alpha191-194, thiocholine activates when tethered at alphaCys192 or alphaCys193. Thiocholine also activates when tethered at alphaY190C or alphaW149C in nAChRs containing a beta subunit mutation (betaL257S) that destabilizes the closed channel, but not from gammaW55C/deltaW57C, where longer adducts can activate. When tethered at positions in binding site segment E, thiocholine activates only from gammaL119C/deltaL121C, where the shorter -S(CH(2))(1)N(CH3)(3)(+) acts as an antagonist. Longer adducts tethered at gammaL109C/deltaL111C or gammaL119C/deltaL121C also activate, but less efficiently. The length requirements for efficient gating by tethered agonists agree closely with predictions based upon the structure of the agonist site in a nAChR homology model derived from the ACh binding protein structure, which suggests that this structure is an excellent model of the nAChR agonist binding site in the open channel conformation. The inability of thiocholine to activate from alphaY93C, which is not predicted by the model, is discussed in terms of the structure of the nAChR in the closed state.     

Role of the minor energetic determinants of chicken egg white lysozyme (HEWL) to the stability of the HEWL.antibody scFv-10 complex

Seven of the 13 non-glycine contact amino acids in the hen (chicken) egg white lysozyme (HEWL) epitope for antibody Fab-10 each contribute < or =0.3 kcal/mol to the change in free energy (DeltaDeltaG(D)) from wild type (WT) when replaced by alanine (nullspots), and three others each give (0.7 < DeltaDeltaG(D) < or = 1. 0) kcal/mol (warm spots) (Rajpal et al. Protein Sci 1998;7:1868-1874). The low DeltaDeltaG(D) values introduced by alanine mutations present an opportunity to explore accurately their cumulative effects, as the sum of the combined DeltaDeltaG(D) values is not so large as to destabilize the complex beyond the range of accurate measurement. Substitution of six of the seven null spot residues by alanine leads to a cumulative DeltaDeltaG(D) = 2.25 +/- 0.04 kcal/mol, whereas the sum of the six individual changes is only -0.36 +/- 0.32 kcal/mol. The triple warm spot mutation generates a DeltaDeltaG(D) = 5.11 +/- 0.06 kcal/mol versus DeltaDeltaG(D) = 2.52 +/- 0.22 kcal/mol for the sum of the three individuals. The non-additivity in the individual DeltaDeltaG(D) values for the alanine mutations may indicate that these residues provide a conformationally stabilizing effect on the hot spot residues, each of which exhibits DeltaDeltaG(D) > 4.0 kcal/mol on alanine substitution.     

Residues at the outer mouth of Kir1.1 determine K-dependent gating

Three residues (E132, F127, and R128) at the outer mouth of Kir1.1b directly affected inward rectifier gating by external K, independent of pH gating. Each of the individual mutations E132Q, F127V, F127D, and R128Y changed the normal K dependence of macroscopic conductance from hyperbolic (Km = 6 ± 2 mM) to linear, up to 500 mM, without changing the hyperbolic K dependence of single-channel conductance. This suggests that E132, F127, and R128 are responsible for maximal Kir1.1b activation by external K. In addition, these same residues were also essential for recovery of Kir1.1b activity after complete removal of external K by 18-Crown-6 polyether. In contrast, charge-altering mutations at neighboring residues (E92A, E104A, D97V, or Q133E) near the outer mouth of the channel did not affect Kir1.1b recovery after chelation of external K. The collective role of E132, R128, and F127 in preventing Kir1.1b inactivation by either cytoplasmic acidification or external K removal implies that pH inactivation and the external K sensor share a common mechanism, whereby E132, R128, and F127 stabilize the Kir1.1b selectivity filter gate in an open conformation, allowing rapid recovery of channel activity after a period of external K depletion.     

Regional specificity of human ether-a'-go-go-related gene channel activation and inactivation gating

Slow activation and rapid C-type inactivation produce inward rectification of the current-voltage relationship for human ether-a'-go-go-related gene (hERG) channels. To characterize the voltage sensor movement associated with hERG activation and inactivation, we performed an Ala scan of the 32 amino acids (Gly(514)-Tyr(545)) that comprise the S4 domain and the flanking S3-S4 and S4-S5 linkers. Gating and ionic currents of wild-type and mutant channels were measured using cut-open oocyte Vaseline gap and two microelectrode voltage clamp techniques to determine the voltage dependence of charge movement, activation, and inactivation. Mapping the position of the charge-perturbing mutations (defined as |DeltaDeltaG| > 1.0 kcal/mol) on a three-dimensional S4 homology model revealed a spiral pattern. As expected, mutation of these residues also altered activation. However, mutation of residues in the S3-S4 and S4-S5 linkers and the C-terminal end of S4 perturbed activation (|DeltaDeltaG| > 1.0 kcal/mol) without altering charge movement, suggesting that the native residues in these regions couple S4 movement to the opening of the activation gate or stabilize the open or closed state of the channel. Finally, mutation of a distinct set of residues impacted inactivation and mapped to a single face of the S4 helix that was devoid of activation-perturbing residues. These results define regions on the S4 voltage sensor that contribute differentially to hERG activation and inactivation gating.     

Double mutant cycle analysis identified a critical leucine residue in the IIS4S5 linker for the activation of the Ca(V)2.3 calcium channel

Mutations in distal S6 were shown to significantly alter the stability of the open state of Ca(V)2.3 (Raybaud, A., Baspinar, E. E., Dionne, F., Dodier, Y., Sauvé, R., and Parent, L. (2007) J. Biol. Chem. 282, 27944-27952). By analogy with K(V) channels, we tested the hypothesis that channel activation involves electromechanical coupling between S6 and the S4S5 linker in Ca(V)2.3. Among the 11 positions tested in the S4S5 linker of domain II, mutations of the leucine residue at position 596 were found to destabilize significantly the closed state with a -50 mV shift in the activation potential and a -20 mV shift in its charge-voltage relationship as compared with Ca(V)2.3 wt. A double mutant cycle analysis was performed by introducing pairs of glycine residues between S4S5 and S6 of Domain II. Strong coupling energies (ΔΔG(interact) > 2 kcal mol(-1)) were measured for the activation gating of 12 of 39 pairs of mutants. Leu-596 (IIS4S5) was strongly coupled with distal residues in IIS6 from Leu-699 to Asp-704. In particular, the double mutant L596G/I701G showed strong cooperativity with a ΔΔG(interact) ≈6 kcal mol(-1) suggesting that both positions contribute to the activation gating of the channel. Altogether, our results highlight the role of a leucine residue in S4S5 and provide the first series of evidence that the IIS4S5 and IIS6 regions are energetically coupled during the activation of a voltage-gated Ca(V) channel.