The enumeration of thermotrophic types amongst the Enterobacteriaceae colonizing perishable foods

A total of 41 pure cultures of Enterobacteriaceae, comprising 32 thermotrophic and nine psychrotrophic strains, pathogens or marker organisms, were examined for numbers of colony forming units obtained at 37° and 42°5°C (thermotrophs) and 30°C (psychrotrophs), when surface-plated on a rich infusion agar and violet red bile agar. In addition 42 food and water samples, collected in a rural area of the Philippines, were examined by surface inoculating violet red bile AIPC (agar immersion plating and contact; 'dip') slides and incubating at 37° and 42°5°C. At 42°5°C there was almost total recovery of the thermotrophic Enterobacteriaceae, whereas the psychrotrophic strains were completely suppressed. At 37°C the psychrotrophs were only slightly inhibited. The Philippine foods, predominantly cooked meals, milk and drinking water, appeared to be significantly colonized by thermotrophic Enterobacteriaceae. It is concluded that incubation at 42°5°C satisfactorily selects enteropathogenic and other enteric Enterobacteriaceae while suppressing the psychrotrophic types which are mainly of vegetable origin. It is emphasized that, regardless of the temperature used, a resuscitation procedure for Enterobacteriaceae populations that have incurred sublethal injury in food has to precede counts on or in the usual selective media.     

The enumeration of thermotrophic types amongst the Enterobacteriaceae colonizing perishable foods

A total of 41 pure cultures of Enterobacteriaceae, comprising 32 thermotrophic and nine psychrotrophic strains, pathogens or marker organisms, were examined for numbers of colony forming units obtained at 37 degrees and 42.5 degrees C (thermotrophs) and 30 degrees C (psychrotrophs), when surface-plated on a rich infusion agar and violet red bile agar. In addition 42 food and water samples, collected in a rural area of the Philippines, were examined by surface inoculating violet red bile AIPC (agar immersion plating and contact; 'dip') slides and incubating at 37 degrees and 42.5 degrees C. At 42.5 degrees C there was almost total recovery of the thermotrophic Enterobacteriaceae, whereas the psychrotrophic strains were completely suppressed. At 37 degrees C the psychrotrophs were only slightly inhibited. The Philippine foods, predominantly cooked meals, milk and drinking water, appeared to be significantly colonized by thermotrophic Enterobacteriaceae. It is concluded that incubation at 42.5 degrees C satisfactorily selects enteropathogenic and other enteric Enterobacteriaceae while suppressing the psychrotrophic types which are mainly of vegetable origin. It is emphasized that, regardless of the temperature used, a resuscitation procedure for Enterobacteriaceae populations that have incurred sublethal injury in food has to precede counts on or in the usual selective media.     

Incidence and Spoilage Potential of Isolates from Vacuum-packaged Meat of High pH Value

Meat of high pH value (6·6) showing dark-cutting characteristics was vacuum-packaged and stored for up to 8 weeks at 0–2°C. 'Off'-odours were detected on opening the packages after 6 weeks of storage. Total counts at this stage were ca. 10⁷/cm² of which lactobacilli were the major component, with ca. 10⁶/cm² Gram negative organisms. Psychrotrophic Enterobacteriaceae represented a major proportion of the microflora only after the full 8 weeks of storage and were not detected previously. Aerobic storage of steaks cut from the vacuum packaged meat stored for 8 weeks resulted in a predominantly Gram negative spoilage flora.
Inoculation studies on meat of normal pH value (5·4) and appearance using representative isolates from the vacuum-packaged meat microflora indicated that most of the test organisms were capable of causing spoilage under aerobic conditions but few under vacuum-packaging when incubated at 4°C. On meat of higher pH value (6·15) many of the Gram negative isolates did not grow as well, whereas the Gram positive isolates grew better than on meat of normal pH value when held under aerobic conditions. Under vacuum-packaging all but one isolate grew as well or better on meat of high pH value than on normal meat at 4°C and objectionable odours were more marked.     

Changes in the Microbiology of Vacuum-packaged Beef

The development of the microbial flora on meat stored in vacuum-bags at 0–2° for up to 9 weeks was studied. Although the proportion of lactic acid bacteria increased relative to the aerobic spoilage organisms, the numbers of the latter continued to increase throughout storage. The initial contamination of the meat before vacuum-packaging was important; meat with a very low initial number had lower numbers of bacteria throughout storage for up to 9 weeks and steaks cut from such meat which had been stored always had 1–2 days' additional aerobic shelf life at 4°. Spoilage of these steaks was due either to slime formation and off-odour associated with high counts of presumptive Pseudomonas spp., or by discoloration and souring (lactic acid bacteria). Extract release volume and pH measurements performed on the vacuum-packaged primal joints were only of value in determining the onset of aerobic spoilage when large numbers of Gram negative organisms were present, whereas the titrimetric method of spoilage evaluation of the vacuum-packaged meat showed a correlation with spoilage due to lactic organisms.     

Conditions affecting growth and enterotoxin production by Staphylococcus aureus on temperature-abused chicken meat

Growth of Staphylococcus aureus at 15°C, with and without addition of representative spoilage bacteria, was studied in cooked, whole chicken meat and chicken broth. In the absence of competitors, the organism grew better in broth culture than on whole meat, but multiplied more slowly in broth when other organisms were present, even from twice the previous level of inoculum. The presence of competitors had no marked effect on the growth of Staph. aureus on whole meat. Enterotoxin A was not produced at 15°C on either whole meat or in broth, and occurred at 20°C only in pure culture. At 30° and 37°C, toxin was produced whether or not competitors were present. Toxin production by Staph. aureus appeared to be influenced more by growth temperature than by bacterial competition.     

The Development of the Anaerobic Spoilage Flora of Meat Stored at Chill Temperatures

In meat juice medium under anaerobic conditions, spoilage bacteria utilized the following substrates: Microbacterium thermosphactum , glucose; Enterobacter , glucose and glucose-6-phosphate; Lactobacillus , glucose and arginine. On meat stored anaerobically. Lactobacillus grew faster than the other species at all temperatures between 2° and 15 °C. Enterobacter had a greater affinity for glucose than M. thermosphactum. As a result, high numbers of Enterobacter inhibited growth of M. thermosphactum under the glucose limiting conditions at the meat surface. High numbers of Lactobacillus inhibited growth of both competing species, apparently by producing an inhibitory substance.     

Microbiological quality and safety of zoo food

Two types of commercial products for feeding zoo animals (a frozen meat product, referred to as zoo food, and a dry product, referred to as dry food) were microbiologically examined for spoilage organisms (aerobic, psychrotrophic, coliform, Escherichia coli, mold, and yeasts) and pathogens (Salmonella spp., Listeria monocytogenes, and Campylobacter jejuni). Levels of microorganisms in frozen ground zoo food were compared with those in frozen ground beef and frozen ground turkey meat. The level of microbial contaminants in frozen ground zoo meat was found to be similar to that in frozen ground beef and higher than that in frozen ground turkey meat. Sixty percent of the frozen zoo meat samples were Salmonella positive, and all of the samples were L. monocytogenes positive. Dry zoo food was documented to have microbial levels lower than those in frozen zoo meat; the pathogen levels were less than 1/25 g of food. Defrosting zoo meat at 10, 25, and 37 degrees C for 24 h showed that 10 degrees C is the best temperature for defrosting frozen ground zoo meat loaves (length, 9 in. [22.8 cm]; radius, 2 in. [5.1 cm]) without affecting the microbiological quality or safety of the product.     

Microbiological quality and safety of zoo food.

Two types of commercial products for feeding zoo animals (a frozen meat product, referred to as zoo food, and a dry product, referred to as dry food) were microbiologically examined for spoilage organisms (aerobic, psychrotrophic, coliform, Escherichia coli, mold, and yeasts) and pathogens (Salmonella spp., Listeria monocytogenes, and Campylobacter jejuni). Levels of microorganisms in frozen ground zoo food were compared with those in frozen ground beef and frozen ground turkey meat. The level of microbial contaminants in frozen ground zoo meat was found to be similar to that in frozen ground beef and higher than that in frozen ground turkey meat. Sixty percent of the frozen zoo meat samples were Salmonella positive, and all of the samples were L. monocytogenes positive. Dry zoo food was documented to have microbial levels lower than those in frozen zoo meat; the pathogen levels were less than 1/25 g of food. Defrosting zoo meat at 10, 25, and 37 degrees C for 24 h showed that 10 degrees C is the best temperature for defrosting frozen ground zoo meat loaves (length, 9 in. [22.8 cm]; radius, 2 in. [5.1 cm]) without affecting the microbiological quality or safety of the product.     

Observations on the Microbiology of Cooked Chicken Carcasses

S ummary . The residual microbial flora and the flora developing during storage at 1–3° and at 16°, of chicken carcasses cooked in a circulating moist air oven operated at 85°, have been studied. All parts of the carcasses reached and maintained 85° for at least 50 min, and the residual flora consisted largely of spore forming bacteria. The predominant residual species were Bacillus subtilis and Clostridium bifermentans. Non-sporing bacteria were not detected after cooking nor after storage at 1–3° for up to 7 days. Storage at 16° for 3 days markedly increased the number of non-sporing organisms although off-odours typical of spoilage were not apparent until at least 10 days. Staphylococcus aureus and Salmonella spp. were not detected after cooking and storage and Cl. welchii was rarely isolated. It is concluded that poultry cooked by this method present a minimal risk of food-borne infection or intoxication by these organisms if contamination after cooking is avoided, the carcasses are cooled rapidly to c , 3° and stored at this temperature or frozen.     

Isolation of proteolytic psychrotrophic yeasts from fresh raw seafoods

A total of 103 cultures of yeasts were isolated from seven kinds of fresh raw seafoods. The isolates comprised six genera, Candida, Cryptococcus, Debaryomyces, Rhodotorula, Sterigmatomyces and Trichosporon , and included 21 different species. All the isolates were psychrotrophic yeasts. Proteolytic activities of 50 psychrotrophic strains were studied by use of skim milk within the temperature range of 0–42°C. All the strains showed various degrees of proteolysis. In particular, Candida lipolytica. Trichosporon pullulans and Candida scottii were active species at low temperatures. Sensory spoilage due to the proteolytic yeasts were observed in mackerel homogenates stored at 10°C. C. lipolytica -inoculated homogenates caused spoilage with ammoniacal odours after 1 week of storage. Values of total volatile basic nitrogen at 10°C were highest with C. lipolytica among 35 strains tested, followed by Tr. pullans. Trichosporon cutaneum, C. scottii, Rhodotorula glutinis and Cryptococcus luteolus. Proteolytic psychrotrophic yeasts were widely distributed in raw seafoods.     

Growth at sub-zero temperatures of black spot fungi from meat

Glycerol can prevent both freezing and desiccation of micro-organisms growing at sub-zero temperatures. On media containing glycerol, at concentrations readily tolerated by the organisms at ambient temperatures, three species of fungi isolated from black spot spoilt meat failed to grow at temperatures much below -5°C. This would, therefore, seem to be the minimum possible growth temperature of these organisms. Although the fungi could grow on frozen media, their rates of growth were such that, on frozen meat, several months would be required for colonies to become barely visible. It therefore seems that significant black spot spoilage will only develop on frozen meat if it is held at temperatures within 2–3° below the freezing point for prolonged periods, or if the meat surface reaches higher temperatures with surface drying inhibiting bacterial growth. There has been little study during the last 50 years of mould spoilage of meat, although it is still of importance in the international trade in frozen meats. Because moulds grow relatively slowly, they only spoil meat if the storage conditions prevent bacterial growth, but there are few firm data on the time and temperature requirements for visible mould growth to develop in the absence of bacterial spoilage. Such data are necessary if the causes of particular outbreaks of fungal spoilage are to be assessed correctly.     

Effects of gaseous environment and temperature on the storage behaviour of Listeria monocytogenes on chicken breast meat

Portions of skinless chicken breast meat (pH 5·8) were inoculated with a strain of Listeria monocytogenes and stored at 1, 6 or 15°C in (1) aerobic conditions; (2) 30% CO₂+ air; (3) 30% CO₂+ N₂; and (4) 100% CO₂. When samples were held at 1°C the organism failed to grow under any of the test conditions, despite marked differences between treatments in spoilage rate and ultimate microflora. At 6°C counts of L. monocytogenes increased ca 10-fold in aerobic conditions before spoilage of the meat, but only when the inoculum culture was incubated at 1°C rather than 37°C. In CO₂ atmospheres growth of L. monocytogenes was inhibited on meat held at 6°C, especially under 100% CO₂. By contrast, storage at 15°C led to spoilage of the meat within 2 d, in all gaseous environments, and listeria levels increased up to 100-fold. Differences in the behaviour of L. monocytogenes on poultry and red meats are discussed.     

The effect of variation of thermal processing on the microbial spoilage of chub-packed luncheon meat

Process pasteurization values for reference temperature 70°C (P₇₀) were calculated from the temperature profiles of 250 g luncheon meat chubs cooked under experimental conditions. A simple equation relating Process P₇₀-value and the time and temperature of cooking was derived. With minimal cooking (P₇₀= 40) the surviving microflora (10³/g) was dominated by species of Lactobacillus, Brochothrix and Micrococcus. These organisms were destroyed by more intensive cooking (P₇₀= 105), leaving a flora (10²/g) composed of Bacillus and Micrococcus species. The spoilage that developed after 14 d storage at 25°C reflected the severity of the heat treatment received by each chub: with P₇₀ between 40 and 90, a Streptococcus spoilage sequence occurred; with P₇₀ between 105 and 120, a Bacillus/Streptococcus spoilage sequence occurred; with P₇₀ of 135 and above, a Bacillus spoilage sequence occurred. Cooking to a P₇₀= 75 was adequate to reduce the surviving microflora to the 10²/g level associated with current good manufacturing practice.     

Culturable psychrotrophic bacterial communities in raw milk and their proteolytic and lipolytic traits

During cold storage after milk collection, psychrotrophic bacterial populations dominate the microflora, and their extracellular enzymes, mainly proteases and lipases, contribute to the spoilage of dairy products. The diversity, dynamics, and enzymatic traits of culturable psychrotrophs in raw milk from four farms were investigated over a 10-month period. About 20% of the isolates were found to be novel species, indicating that there is still much to be learned about culturable psychrotrophs in raw milk. The psychrotrophic isolates were identified and classified in seven classes. Three classes were predominant, with high species richness (18 to 21 species per class) in different seasons of the year: Gammaproteobacteria in spring and winter, Bacilli in summer, and Actinobacteria in autumn. The four minor classes were Alphaproteobacteria, Betaproteobacteria, Flavobacteria, and Sphingobacteria. The dominant classes were found in all four dairies, although every dairy had its own unique "bacterial profile." Most but not all bacterial isolates had either lipolytic or both lipolytic and proteolytic activities. Only a few isolates showed proteolytic activity alone. The dominant genera, Pseudomonas and Acinetobacter (Gammaproteobacteria), showed mainly lipolytic activity, Microbacterium (Actinobacteria) was highly lipolytic and proteolytic, and the lactic acid bacteria (Lactococcus and Leuconostoc) displayed very minor enzymatic ability. Hence, the composition of psychrotrophic bacterial flora in raw milk has an important role in the determination of milk quality. Monitoring the dominant psychrotrophic species responsible for the production of heat-stable proteolytic and lipolytic enzymes offers a sensitive and efficient tool for maintaining better milk quality in the milk industry.     

Efficiency of different enrichment and isolation procedures for the detection of Salmonella serotypes in edible offal

Rapid detection systems for Salmonella in foodstuffs are currently being developed. However, existing standards still call for application of traditional methods employing pre-enrichment followed by selective enrichment and isolation. The efficacy of various methods was tested using 264 chicken and lamb organ meats. Pre-enrichment was carried out in Tryptone Soy Broth (TSB) and enrichment in Tetrathionate Brilliant Green Broth (TTB) at 37°C, Selenite Broth with Brilliant Green and Sulphapyridine at 37°C and 43°C, and Rappaport-Vassiliadis Broth (RV 10) at 42°C. The isolation media were Brilliant Green Agar (BGA), Deoxycholate Citrate Agar, Hektoen Enteric Agar (HEA) and Salmonella-Shigella Agar.
Enrichment in RV/42°C followed by isolation on BGA as recommended by ISO standard no. 6579 and enrichment in TTB/37°C followed by isolation in HEA, no longer recommended by that standard, produced the best results. Low percentages of positive samples and difficulties in detecting Salmonella are the result of interference by competing organisms (Enterobacteriaceae) and the number of salmonellas present after enrichment.
A total of 528 samples (TSB, eggs, lamb liver and chicken liver) were inoculated with Salm. enteritidis, Salm. kapemba and Salm. virchow , and the preceding experiment was repeated. All the TSB and egg samples tested positive, but the percentage of positive samples from the lamb and chicken liver was only 81–92%. Recovery of the salmonellas did not depend upon the method employed or the serotype inoculated but instead on interference by competing flora and the numbers of Salmonella present in the samples.     

A note on Aeromonas spp. from chickens as possible food-borne pathogens

The possible role of Aeromonas spp. as potential food-borne psychrotrophic pathogens was investigated by examining organisms isolated from processed raw chicken for their biochemical characteristics, ability to produce exotoxins and to grow at chill temperatures. These strains, in particular A. sobria , with identical characteristics to human diarrhoea-associated aeromonads were readily found. Chicken, and human and environmental (water) strains characterized in a previous study, were investigated for their ability to grow at refrigeration temperatures (5 ± 2°C) and, for selected strains, the theoretical minimum temperature for growth ( T _min) was determined from the growth pattern in a temperature gradient incubator. All enterotoxigenic chicken strains tested were typical mesophiles, with an optimal growth temperature of ˜37°C and T _min values ˜4.5°C. They were rapidly outgrown by a psychrotrophic Pseudomonas sp. typical of spoilage biota found on food. Enterotoxin was not produced below 15°C by any of the toxigenic food strains tested. The Aeromonas strains isolated from chickens in this study seem unlikely therefore to be a significant health risk, provided the chickens are properly stored and cooked. This would appear to be substantiated by the lack of reports of food-associated outbreaks of illness from these sources.     

The microbiological quality of hot water-washed broccoli florets and cut green beans

AIMS: To determine the effect of hot water washing on the microbiological quality of cut broccoli florets and trimmed green beans. METHODS AND RESULTS: Broccoli florets and trimmed beans were washed for 90 s in tap water at either 20 degrees C or 52 degrees C and stored at 7 and 10 degrees C. The numbers of naturally occurring aerobic mesophilic organisms, Pseudomonas spp., Enterobacteriaceae, yeast and moulds and lactobacilli or lactic acid bacteria were enumerated at intervals for up to 2 weeks. The ability of Listeria monocytogenes, Bacillus cereus and Escherichia coli O157:H7 inoculated onto the tissue post heat treatment to survive or grow was also measured to mimic the effect of postprocess contamination. Using a hot wash treatment improved the initial appearance of the vegetables and resulted in a small, but significant, reduction in populations of all groups of endogenous flora measured. The number of yeast and moulds on the vegetables washed at 52 degrees C remained below the levels observed on the 20 degrees C washed vegetables throughout the observation period, but Pseudomonas spp., lactobacilli and Enterobacteriaceae were better able to grow on the hot-washed vegetables such that the counts at the end of storage were greater on hot-washed than ambient-washed vegetables. All three of the pathogens tested were better able to grow on hot-washed broccoli and beans than on equivalent product washed at 20 degrees C. CONCLUSIONS: Hot water washing can be used to control enzymic browning or yeast and moulds growth but it can also allow more rapid and extensive growth by pathogens and spoilage organisms. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Reduced protection against growth by pathogens means that the hot wash treatment of vegetables should be used with caution and requires careful assessment of risk.     

Storage of poultry meat under modified atmospheres or vacuum packs: possible role of microbial metabolites as indicator of spoilage

The effect of carbon dioxide (100%), nitrogen (100%), carbon dioxide/oxygen (20% : 80%) or vacuum pack at 3 and 10°C was studied on the microbial flora, in skinless poultry breast fillets or thigh meat. Lactic acid bacteria and Brochothrix thermosphacta were the predominant organisms in samples stored in vacuum packs, carbon dioxide and nitrogen. Pseudomonads grew only in oxygen/carbon dioxide packaging systems. The concentration of lactate diminished in both thigh and breast meat during storage at 3 and 10°C. This decrease was more pronounced in thigh meat stored under 20% : 80% carbon dioxide/oxygen. Acetate increased to varying degrees in all samples regardless of the storage conditions.     

A substrate-mediated assay of bacterial proton efflux/influx to predict the degree of spoilage of beef mince stored at chill temperatures

A method was developed to predict spoilage of minced meat at chill temperatures, based on the difference in proton efflux from and influx into bacterial cells. This difference depends on the number of organisms present, the available glucose in the meat sample and the ability of the organisms to metabolize amino acids. The proton efflux/influx of a meat filtrate containing bacteria was measured at 25°C with a pH/ion meter in the presence of peptone with or without glucose. There was a noticeable rate of change of mV h_-1 of the meat filtrate prior to the organoleptic detection of spoilage which may be used semi-predictively to determine the remaining shelf-life of meat at different storage temperatures. The method could be investigated further, encompassing type and relative numbers of organisms, incubation temperature, meat type and composition (i.e. available glucose) to produce a spoilage prediction model. The method does not require sophisticated equipment, only a standard pH/ion meter, is cheap, needing only peptone and glucose, is relatively simple, and takes less than 2 h to perform.