Microbial Complexes Occurring on the Apogeotropic Roots and in the Rhizosphere of Cycad Plants

The microbial complexes of soil, the rhizosphere, and the rhizoplane of the apogeotropic (coralloid) roots of cycad plants were comparatively studied. The aseptically prepared homogenates of the surface-sterilized coralloid roots did not contain bacterial microsymbiont, indicating that in the root tissues the symbiosis is a two-component one (plant–cyanobacteria). At the same time, associated bacteria belonging to different taxonomic groups were detected in increasing amounts in the cycad rhizoplane, rhizosphere, and the surrounding soil. The bacterial communities found in the cycad rhizoplane and the surrounding soil were dominated by bacteria from the genus Bacillus. The saprotrophic bacteria and fungi colonizing the cycad rhizosphere and rhizoplane were dominated by microorganisms capable of degrading the plant cell walls. The local degradation of the cell wall was actually observed on the micrographs of the thin sections of cycad roots in the form of channels through which symbiotic cyanobacterial filaments can penetrate into the cortical parenchyma.     

Cyanobacterial–Bacterial Complexes in Plant Syncyanoses

The morphology and ultrastructure of associative microsymbiont complexes (AMC) isolated from the ferns Azolla pinnata and Azolla sp. and the apogeotropic roots of the cycad Cycas revoluta were studied. The composition of the AMC obtained includes the cyanobionts (symbiotic cyanobacteria) and satellite bacteria (SB). It was found that two types of cyanobacteria that substantially differ in their morphological organization are likely present as cyanobionts in the coralloids of C. revoluta. The isolated cyanobiont strains exhibited the morphological traits and regularities of development typical of the genus Nostoc; they were characterized by the ability of their cells to divide in mutually perpendicular planes. When isolating AMC from different morphological zones of C. revoluta apogeotropic roots, SB growth was revealed only around the pieces corresponding to the coralloid apical zone. No AMC components were revealed around the segments of the basal growth zone. Pure cyanobiont cultures were obtained from the AMC of C. revoluta coralloids. The AMC isolated from the ferns A. pinnata and Azolla sp. are characterized by obligate mutual dependence of the partners (the cyanobiont and SB).     

Comparison of DNA restriction fragment length polymorphisms of Nostoc strains in and from cycads

DNA was prepared from cyanobacteria freshly isolated from coralloid roots of natural populations of five cycad species: Ceratozamia mexicana mexicana (Mexico), C. mexicana robusta (Mexico), Dioon spinulosum (Mexico), Zamia furfuraceae (Mexico) and Z. skinneri (Costa Rica). Using the Southern blot technique and cloned Anabaena PCC 7120 nifK and glnA genes as probes, restriction fragment length polymorphisms of these cyanobacterial symbionts were compared. The five cyanobacterial preparations showed differences in the sizes of their DNA fragments hybridizing with both probes, indicating that different cyanobacterial species and/or strains were in the symbiotic associations. On the other hand, a similar comparison of cyanobacteria freshly collected from a single Encephalartos altensteinii coralloid root and from three independently subcultured isolates from the same coralloid root revealed that these were likely to be one and the same organism. Moreover, the complexity of restriction patterns shows that a mixture of Nostoc strains can associate with a single cycad species although a single cyanobacterial strain can predominate in the root of a single cycad plant. Thus, a wide range of Nostoc strains appear to associate with the coralloid roots of cycads.Non-standard abbreviations bp base pairs - kbp kilobase pairs - RFLP's restriction fragment length polymorphisms     

Microbial complexes from apogeotropic roots and from rhizosphere of cycad plants

The microbial complexes of soil, the rhizosphere, and the rhizoplane of the apogeotropic (coralloid) roots of cycad plants were comparatively studied. The aseptically prepared homogenates of the surface-sterilized coralloid roots did not contain bacterial microsymbiont, indicating that it was absent in the root tissues. At the same time, associated bacteria belonging to different taxonomic groups were detected in increasing amounts in the cycad rhizoplane, rhizosphere, and the surrounding soil. The bacterial communities found in the cycad rhizoplane and the surrounding soil were dominated by bacteria from the genus Bacillus. The saprotrophic bacteria and fungi colonizing the cycad rhizosphere and rhizoplane were dominated by microorganisms capable of degrading the plant cell walls. The local degradation of the cell wall was actually observed on the micrographs of the thin sections of cycad roots in the form of channels, through which symbiotic cyanobacterial filaments can penetrate into the cortical parenchyma.     

Comparative analysis of cyanobacteria in the rhizosphere and as endosymbionts of cycads in drought-affected soils

Does the diversity of cyanobacteria in the cycad rhizosphere relate to the cyanobiont species found in the coralloid roots of these ancient plants? The aim of this study was to identify the diversity of soil cyanobacteria occurring in the immediate vicinity of 22 colonized coralloid roots belonging to members of the cycad genera: Macrozamia, Lepidozamia, Bowenia and Cycas. The majority of coralloid roots were sampled at depths >?10?cm below the soil surface. A total of 32 cyanobacterial isolates were cultured and their 16S rRNA gene partially sequenced. Phylogenetic analysis revealed nine operational taxonomic units of soil cyanobacteria comprising 30 Nostoc spp., a Tolypothrix sp. and a Leptolyngbya sp. Microscopy indicated that all isolates were unialgal and confirmed their genus identity. Rhizospheric diversity was compared to existing data on cyanobionts isolated at the same time from the cycad coralloid root. The same isolate was present in both the cycad coralloid root and rhizosphere at only six sites. Phylogenetic evidence indicates that most rhizosphere isolates were distinct from root cyanobionts. This weak relationship between the soil cyanobacteria and cycad cyanobionts might indicate that changes in the soil community composition are due to environmental factors.     

Symbiosis in cycads: the origin and development of coralloid roots in Macrozamia communis (Cycadaceae)

Coralloid roots of Macrozamia have more apparent developmental stages than those of many other cycad genera, providing an ideal study vehicle for obtaining a better understanding of the growth and development of symbiotic cycad coralloid roots. In M. communis L. Johnson, the process begins with initiation of young apogeotropic, papillose roots called “precoralloids” and involves phases of maturation, cyanobacterial invasion, coralloid formation, senescence, and regeneration. Active precoralloid apices continue to produce papillose tissue, but during precoralloid maturation, the prominent papillose sheath is gradually replaced by a thin, dermal layer with scattered lenticels. Cyanobacterial invasion has been observed at different stages of precoralloid maturation and stimulates further, irreversible development of precoralloids into coralloids. Newly invaded precoralloids in the process of transition may be readily identified by their distinctive apical lenticels. Coralloid development involves transformation of the original, apogeotropic precoralloid tissue as well as production of new coralloid tissue by apical meristems. Although continuous, these two coralloid regions may be recognized by their external morphology. New coralloid growth involves cessation of papillose sheath production, change in gravitropic response, proliferation of lenticels, and early differentiation of a conspicuous cyanobacterial zone. Three mechanisms enabling continuity of the coralloid root system are: 1) production of new precoralloids and coralloids from bases of existing roots of the same kind; 2) initiation of atypical roots from within the internal tissues of degenerating coralloids; and 3) development of internal secondary periderm during decortication of aging coralloid tissue.     

Features of cyanobacterial-bacterial complexes of microsymbionts of plant syncyanoses

The morphology and ultrastructure of associative microsymbiont complexes (AMC) isolated from the ferns Azolla pinnata and Azolla sp. and the apogeotropic roots of the cycad Cycas revoluta were studied. The composition of the AMC obtained includes the cyanobionts (symbiotic cyanobacteria) and satellite bacteria (SB). It was found that two types of cyanobacteria that substantially differ in their morphological organization are likely present as cyanobionts in the coralloids of C. revoluta. The isolated cyanobiont strains exhibited the morphological traits and regularities of development typical of the genus Nostoc; they were characterized by the ability of their cells to divide in mutually perpendicular planes. When isolating AMC from different morphological zones of C. revoluta apogeotropic roots, SB growth was revealed only around the pieces corresponding to the coralloid apical zone. No AMC components were revealed around the segments of the basal growth zone. Pure cyanobiont cultures were obtained from the AMC of C. revoluta coralloids. The AMC isolated from the ferns A. pinnata and Azolla sp. are characterized by obligate mutual dependence of the partners (the cyanobiont and SB).     

Highly diverse endophytes in roots of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cycas bifida</Emphasis> (Cycadaceae), an ancient but endangered gymnosperm

As an ancient seed plant, cycads are one of the few gymnosperms that develop a root symbiosis with cyanobacteria, which has allowed cycads to cope with harsh geologic and climatic conditions during the evolutionary process. However, the endophytic microbes in cycad roots remain poorly identified. In this study, using next-generation sequencing techniques, we investigated the microbial diversity and composition of both the coralloid and regular roots of Cycas bifida (Dyer) K.D. Hill. Highly diverse endophytic communities were observed in both the coralloid and regular roots. Of the associated bacteria, the top five families were the Nostocaceae, Sinobacteraceae, Bradyrhizobiaceae, Bacillaceae, and Hyphomicrobiaceae. The Nectriaceae, Trichocomaceae, and Incertae sedis were the predominant fungal families in all root samples. A significant difference in the endophytic bacterial community was detected between coralloid roots and regular roots, but no difference was observed between the fungal communities in the two root types. Cyanobacteria were more dominant in coralloid roots than in regular roots. The divergence of cycad root structures and the modified physiological processes may have contributed to the abundance of cyanobionts in coralloid roots. Consequently, the colonization of cyanobacteria inhibits the assemblage of other endophytes. Our results contribute to an understanding of the species diversity and composition of the cycad-endophyte microbiome and provide an abbreviated list of potential ecological roles of the core microbes present.     

Infection of Plants and Plant Tissue Cultures with Cyanobacteria–Bacteria Complexes

The infection of tobacco, nightshade, rice plants, and their tissue cultures with the cyanobacteria–bacteria associative microsymbiont complexes (AMC) isolated from natural syncyanoses (the ferns Azolla pinnataand Azollasp. and the cycad Encephalartos ferox) was studied. The inoculation of the intact plants or their cuttings with AMC led to the colonization of the plant roots, stems, and leaves by cyanobacteria and their bacterial symbionts (referred to as satellite bacteria, SB). The sites of the long-term contact of plant organs with cyanobacteria were characterized by the formation of copious slime. On the roots of infected plants, one could observe the callus growth of cortical parenchyma cells and the formation of pseudonodules, in which SB cells gradually accumulated. In mixed cultures of plant callus tissues and the AMC isolated from the fernsA. pinnataand Azollasp., the callus tissue specifically influenced the growth of the AMC components, causing (depending on the plant species and strain) either their balanced growth, or their cyclic growth, or the predominant growth of one of the AMC components (either cyanobacteria or satellite bacteria). This phenomenon is proposed to be used for the dissociation of stable multicomponent natural symbiotic complexes and the selection of their particular components.     

Glutamine synthetase: activity and localization in cyanobacteria of the cycadsCycas revoluta andZamia skinneri

Nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria inhabit the zone between the inner and outer cortex of cycad coralloid roots. In the growing tip of such roots the cyanobacterial heterocyst frequency, nitrogenase activity (C₂H₂-reduction) and glutamine synthetase activity (both transferase and biosynthetic) were comparable to those found in freeliving cyanobacteria. The relative level of glutamine synthetase protein and its pattern of cellular/subcellular localization in heterocysts and vegetative cells were also similar to those of free-living cyanobacteria. However, there was a progressive decline in nitrogenase activity along the coralloid root with maximum reduction occurring in the regions farthest from the growing tip. A similar but less pronounced pattern was observed for glutamine synthetase activity. Distribution of glutamine synthetase protein in cyanobacteria in the first 2–3 mm of the root tip indicated a slight decrease in the heterocysts and vegetative cells. However, the overall level of cyanobacterial glutamine synthetase protein did not change because of a drastic increase in the numbers of heterocysts, which contain a proportionally higher level of glutamine synthetase than the vegetative cells.Abbreviation GS glutamine synthetase     

Atypical Cell Forms Overproducing Extracellular Substances in Populations of Cycad Cyanobionts

The ultrastructure of the cyanobionts of the greenhouse-grown cycads Cycas circinalis, Ceratozamia mexicana, and Encephalartos villosus was studied. The cyanobiont microcolonies grown in the intercellular space of the cyanobacterial zone of cortical parenchyma in the cycad coralloid roots contained two specific forms of vegetative cells with a reduced cell wall, namely, protoplasts and spheroplasts. The protoplasts and spheroplasts exhibited ultrastructural properties indicating the overproduction of two extracellular substances, one of which resembled the mucilage polysaccharides and the other was protein-like. The substances were likely to be synthesized intracellularly and then be excreted with the aid of surface vesicles or by ruptures in the cytoplasmic membrane to form, respectively, a mucilagious extracellular matrix and an additional electron-opaque envelope around the cell. At the late developmental stages, the excretion of these substances was accompanied by degradative changes in the cells, leading eventually to cell death. The physiological role of these specific cell forms and the factors that induce their development and death in the cell populations of cyanobionts are discussed.     

Pathways of assimilation and transfer of fixed nitrogen in coralloid roots of cycad-Nostoc symbioses

Freshly detached coralloid roots of several cycad species were found to bleed spontaneously from xylem, permitting identification of products of nitrogen transfer from symbiotic organ to host. Structural features relevant to the export of fixed N were described for Macrozamia riedlei (Fisch. ex Gaud.) Gardn. the principal species studied. Citrulline (Cit), glutamine (Gln) and glutamic acid (Glu), the latter usually in a lesser amount, were the principal translocated solutes in Macrozamia (5 spp.), Encephalartos (4 spp.) and Lepidozamia (1 sp.), while Gln and a smaller amount of Glu, but no Cit were present in xylem sap of Bowenia (1 sp.),and Cycas (2 spp.). Time-course studies of ¹⁵N enrichment of the different tissue zones and the xylem sap of ¹⁵N₂-pulse-fed coralloid roots of M. riedlei showed earlier ¹⁵N incorporation into Gln than into Cit, and a subsequent net decline in the ¹⁵N of Gln of the coralloid-root tissues, whereas Cit labeling continued to increase in inner cortex and stele and in the xylem sap. Hydrolysis of the ¹⁵N-labeled Cit and Gln consistently demonstrated much more intense labeling of the respective carbamyl and amide groups than of the other N-atoms. Coralloid roots of M. riedlei pulse-fed ¹⁴CO₂ in darkness showed ¹⁴C labeling of aspartic acid (Asp) and Cit in all tissue zones and of Cit of xylem bleeding sap. Lateral roots and uninfected apogeotropic roots of M. riedlei and M. moorei also incorporated ¹⁴CO₂ into Cit. The ¹⁴C of Cit was restricted to the carbamyl-C. Comparable ¹⁵N₂ and CO₂-feeding studies on corallid roots of Cycas revoluta showed Gln to be the dominant product of N₂ fixation, with Asp and alanine as other major ¹⁴C-labeled amino compounds, but a total absence of Cit in labeled or unlabeled form.Abbreviations Ala alanine - Asp aspartic acid - Cit citrulline - Gln glutamine - Glu glutamic acid - Orn ornithine     

Characteristics of infection of plants and their cultured tissue with cyanobacterial-bacterial symbiotic associations]

The infection of tobacco, nightshade, rice plants, and their tissue cultures with the cyanobacteria-bacteria symbiotic associations (CBSA) isolated from natural syncyanoses (the ferns Azolla pinnata and Azolla sp. and the cycad Encephalartos ferox) was studied. The inoculation of the intact plants or their cuttings with CBSA led to the colonization of the plant roots, stems, and leaves by cyanobacteria and their bacterial symbionts (referred to as satellite bacteria, SB). The sites of the long-term contact of plant organs with cyanobacteria were characterized by the formation of copious slime. On the roots of infected plants, one could observe the callus growth of cortical parenchyma cells and the formation of pseudonodules, in which SB cells gradually accumulated. In mixed cultures of plant callus tissues and the CBSA isolated from the ferns A. pinnata and Azolla sp., the callus tissue specifically influenced the growth of the CBSA components, causing (depending on the plant species and strain) either their balanced growth, or their cyclic growth, or the predominant growth of one of the CBSA components (either cyanobacteria or satellite bacteria). This phenomenon is proposed to be used for the dissociation of stable multicomponent natural symbiotic complexes and the selection of their particular components.     

Comparative host tissue Réactions of Musa acuminate (AAA group) cvs Poyo and Gros Michel roots to three banana-parasitic nématodes

In a comparative histopathological investigation, Poyo and Gros Michel cul-tivars of Musa acuminata (AAA triploid) were inoculated with Radopholus similis, Helicotylenchus multicinctus or Hoplolaimus pararobustus and were grown in a greenhouse under tropical conditions. R. similis infected all the cortical parenchyma layers of the roots, reaching the vascular cylinder, but it stayed more superficial in Gros Michel roots. Red-brown cytoplasmic globules appeared in the cortical parenchyma cells of Gros Michel only. H. multicinctus infected much of the outer cortical parenchyma in roots of both cultivars with a few phenolic cells occurring around the superficial lesions. H. pararobustus penetrated only the immediate sub-epidermal tissues in both cultivars. The differences observed between nématodes and cultivars reflect specific host-nematode interactions on bananas.     

Nodulation in Light- and Dark-grown Macrozamia communis L. Johnson Seedlings in Sterile Culture

The ability of aseptically cultured Macrozamia communis seedlingsto form apogeotropic root nodules in light and darkness wasexamined. In darkness, apogeotropic root nodules developed atthe junction of the primary-root and the cotyledonary node.More acropetally formed lateral-roots were not nodular and weretypical ageotropic or plagiotropic secondary-roots. When thesecultures were exposed to light, all of the roots became typical,apogeotropic cycad root nodules. Light stimulated dichotomousbranching of nodules previously formed in the dark. Nodulesexposed to light were more papillose than those maintained indarkness. Light also inhibited primary and secondary-root elongation. Macrozamia communis, cycad apogeotropism, dichotomous branching, light induction, root nodulation sterile culture     

N(2)-Fixation by Freshly Isolated Nostoc from Coralloid Roots of the Cycad Macrozamia riedlei (Fisch. ex Gaud.) Gardn

Nitrogenase (EC 1.7.99.2) activity (acetylene reduction) and nitrogen fixation (¹⁵N₂ fixation) were measured in cyanobacteria freshly isolated from the coralloid roots of Macrozamia riedlei (Fisch. ex Gaud.) Gardn. Light and gas phase oxygen concentration had marked interactive effects on activity, with higher (up to 100-fold) rates of acetylene reduction and ¹⁵N₂ fixation in light. The relationship between ethylene formation and N₂-fixation varied in the freshly isolated cyanobacteria from 4 to 7 nanomoles of C₂H₄ per nanomole ¹⁵N₂. Intact coralloid roots, incubated in darkness and ambient air, showed a value of 4.3. Maximum rates of nitrogenase activity occurred at about 0.6% O₂ in light, while in darkness there was a broad optimum around 5 to 8% O₂. Inhibition of nitrogenase, in light, by pO₂ above 0.6% was irreversible. Measurements of light-dependent O₂ evolution and ¹⁴CO₂ fixation indicated negligible photosynthetic electron transport involving photosystem II and, on the basis of inhibitor studies, the stimulatory effect of light was attributed to cyclic photophos-phorylation. Nitrogenase activity of free-living culture of an isolate from Macrozamia (Nostoc PCC 73102) was only slightly inhibited by O₂ levels above 6% O₂ and the inhibition was reversible. These cells showed rates of light-dependent O₂ evolution and ¹⁴CO₂ fixation which were 100- to 200-fold higher than those by the freshly isolated symbiont. Furthermore, nitrogenase activity was dependent on both photosynthetic electron transport and photophosphorylation. These data indicate that cyanobacteria within cycad coralloid roots are differentiated specifically for symbiotic functioning in a microaerobic environment. Specializations include a high heterocyst frequency, enhanced permeability to O₂, and a direct dependence on the cycad for substrates to support nitrogenase activity.     

Atypical cell forms overproducing extracellular substances in population of cycad cyanobionts

The ultrastructure of the cyanobionts of the greenhouse-grown cycads Cycas circinalis, Ceratozamia mexicana, and Encephalartos villosus was studied. The cyanobiont microcolonies grown in the intercellular space of the cyanobacterial zone of cortical parenchyma in the cycad coralloid roots contained two specific forms of vegetative cells with a reduced cell wall, namely, protoplasts and spheroplasts. The protoplasts and spheroplasts exhibited ultrastructural changes indicating the overproduction of two extracellular substances, one of which resembled the mucilage polysaccharides and the other was proteinous. The substances were likely to be synthesized intracellularly and then be excreted with the aid of surface vesicles or by channels in the cytoplasmic membrane to form, respectively, a slimy extracellular matrix and an additional electron-opaque envelope around the cell. At the late developmental stages, the excretion of these substances was accompanied by degradative changes in the cells, leading eventually to cell death. The physiological role of these specific cell forms and the factors that induce their development and death in the cell populations of cyanobionts are discussed.     

Exploring cycad foliage as an archive of the isotopic composition of atmospheric nitrogen

Molecular nitrogen (N₂) constitutes the majority of Earth's modern atmosphere, contributing ~0.79 bar of partial pressure (pN₂). However, fluctuations in pN₂ may have occurred on 10⁷–10⁹ year timescales in Earth's past, perhaps altering the isotopic composition of atmospheric nitrogen. Here, we explore an archive that may record the isotopic composition of atmospheric N₂ in deep time: the foliage of cycads. Cycads are ancient gymnosperms that host symbiotic N₂‐fixing cyanobacteria in modified root structures known as coralloid roots. All extant species of cycads are known to host symbionts, suggesting that this N₂‐fixing capacity is perhaps ancestral, reaching back to the early history of cycads in the late Paleozoic. Therefore, if the process of microbial N₂ fixation records the δ¹⁵N value of atmospheric N₂ in cycad foliage, the fossil record of cycads may provide an archive of atmospheric δ¹⁵N values. To explore this potential proxy, we conducted a survey of wild cycads growing in a range of modern environments to determine whether cycad foliage reliably records the isotopic composition of atmospheric N₂. We find that neither biological nor environmental factors significantly influence the δ¹⁵N values of cycad foliage, suggesting that they provide a reasonably robust record of the δ¹⁵N of atmospheric N₂. Application of this proxy to the record of carbonaceous cycad fossils may not only help to constrain changes in atmospheric nitrogen isotope ratios since the late Paleozoic, but also could shed light on the antiquity of the N₂‐fixing symbiosis between cycads and cyanobacteria.     

DEVELOPMENTAL ANATOMY OF CORALLOID ROOTS IN CYCADS

Coralloid roots of cycads were found to originate endogenously from the pericycle of apogeotropic secondary roots or adventitious roots that have become exposed or nearly exposed to the soil surface. All mature coralloid roots are susceptible to infection by algal endophytes, which seem to enter from the soil through a break in the dermal layers. In the coralloid roots the algae inhabit intercellular spaces in a definite zone that arises from the protoderm, and in which the cells elongate radially following algal infection. The zone is completely surrounded by a persistent rootcap which is interpreted by most authors as a secondary cortex. The secondary cortex was shown to be derived from the rootcap in this investigation.     

A light and electron microscopic study of the blue-green algae living either in the coralloid roots of « Macrozamia communis » or isolated in culture

Abstract

The present work is a study of the blue-green algae living in the coralloid roots of Macrozamia communis and isolated from Macrozamia communis in culture.

The light and electron microscopic study pointed out the distribution of these microorganisms in the cortical area of coralloids and did not reveal any cells invaded by bacteria. On the basis of their aspect the blue-green algae living either in the coralloid roots or in culture were classified as belonging to the genus Nosloc, with some features of Nosloc commune.

Inside the coralloids the cells of the blue-green algae were surrounded by abundant mucilage and contain granulations. In culture the blue-green algae were on the contrary very poor in mucilage and rich in polyphosphate granules. Numerous phycobilosomes were ranged along the outside of the thylakoid membranes in alternate arrangement to the granules of the neighbouring lamellae.