An experimental study of mechanism and specificity of peptide nucleic acid (PNA) binding to duplex DNA

We investigated the mechanism and kinetic specificity of binding of peptide nucleic acid clamps (bis-PNAs) to double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). Kinetic specificity is defined as a ratio of initial rates of PNA binding to matched and mismatched targets on dsDNA. Bis-PNAs consist of two homopyrimidine PNA oligomers connected by a flexible linker. While complexing with dsDNA, they are known to form P-loops, which consist of a [PNA]2-DNA triplex and the displaced DNA strand. We report here a very strong pH-dependence, within the neutral pH range, of binding rates and kinetic specificity for a bis-PNA consisting of only C and T bases. The specificity of binding reaches a very sharp and high maximum at pH 6.9. In contrast, if all the cytosine bases in one of the two PNA oligomers within the bis-PNA are replaced by pseudoisocytosine bases (J bases), which do not require protonation to form triplexes, a weak dependence on pH of the rates and specificity of the P-loop formation is observed. A theoretical analysis of the data suggests that for (C+T)-containing bis-PNA the first, intermediate step of PNA binding to dsDNA occurs via Hoogsteen pairing between the duplex target and one oligomer of bis-PNA. After that, the strand invasion occurs via Watson-Crick pairing between the second bis-PNA oligomer and the homopurine strand of the target DNA, thus resulting in the ultimate formation of the P-loop. The data for the (C/J+T)-containing bis-PNA show that its high affinity to dsDNA at neutral pH does not seriously compromise the kinetic specificity of binding. These findings support the earlier expectation that (C/J+T)-containing PNA constructions may be advantageous for use in vivo.     

Structural isomers of bis-PNA bound to a target in duplex DNA

Upon binding of a decamer bis-PNA (H-Lys-TTCCTCTCTT-(eg1)(3)-TTCTCTCCTT-LysNH(2)) to a complementary target in a double-stranded DNA fragment, three distinct complexes were detected by gel mobility shift analysis. Using in situ chemical probing techniques (KMnO(4) and DMS) it was found that all three complexes represent bona fide sequence-specific PNA binding to the designated target, but the complexes were structurally different. One complex that preferentially formed at higher PNA concentrations contains two bis-PNA molecules per DNA target, whereas the other two complexes are genuine triplex invasion clamped structures. However, these two latter complexes differ by the path relative to the DNA target of the flexible ethylene-glycol linker connecting the two PNA oligomers that comprise a bis-PNA. We distinguish between one in which the linker wraps around the non-target DNA strand, thus making this strand part of the triplex invasion complex and another complex that encompass the target strand only. The implications of these results are discussed in terms of DNA targeting by synthetic ligands.     

Short pyrimidine stretches containing mixed base PNAs are versatile tools to induce translation elongation arrest and truncated protein synthesis

Recently, we showed that antisense peptide nucleic acids (PNA) containing a short pyrimidine stretch (C(4)TC(3)) invade Ha-ras mRNA hairpin structures to form highly stable duplex and triplex complexes that contribute to the arrest of translation elongation. The antisense PNA targeted to codon 74 of Ha-ras was designed to bind in antiparallel configuration (the N-terminal of the PNA faces the 3'-end of target mRNA), as PNA/RNA duplexes are most stable in this configuration. In order to show that different sequences in the coding region could be targeted successfully with antisense PNAs, we extended our study to three other purine-rich targets. We show that the tridecamer PNA (targeted to codon 149) containing a CTC(3)T pyrimidine stretch forms with the complementary oligoribonucleotide (ORN) a stable (PNA)(2)/ORN triplex at neutral pH (T(m) = 50 degrees C) and arrests Ha-ras mRNA translation elongation. Interestingly, the thermal stability of triplexes formed with PNAs designed to bind to the complementary ORN in a parallel orientation (the N-terminal of the PNA faces the 5'-end of target) was higher than that formed with antiparallel oriented PNAs (T(m) = 58 degrees C). Because parallel and antiparallel PNAs form stable triplexes with target sequence, they act as translation elongation blockers. These duplex-forming and partly triplex-forming PNAs targeted to Ha-ras mRNA also arrested translation elongation at specific polypurine sites contained in the mRNA coding for HIV-integrase protein. Furthermore, the tridecamer PNA containing the C(3)TC(4) motif was more active than a bis-PNA in which the Hoogsteen recognizing strand was linked to the Watson-Crick recognizing strand by a flexible linker. Pyrimidine-rich, short PNAs that form very stable duplexes with target Ha-ras mRNA inhibit translation by a mechanism that does not involve ribosome elongation arrest, whereas PNAs forming duplex and triplex structures arrest ribosome elongation. The remarkable efficacy of the tridecamer PNAs in arresting translation elongation of HIV-1 integrase mRNA is explained by their ability to form stable triplexes at neutral pH with short purine sequences.     

Efficient pH-independent sequence-specific DNA binding by pseudoisocytosine-containing bis-PNA.

The synthesis and DNA binding properties of bis-PNA (peptide nucleic acid) are reported. Two PNA segments each of seven nucleobases in length were connected in a continuous synthesis via a flexible linker composed of three 8-amino-3,6-dioxaoctanoic acid units. The sequence of the first strand was TCTCTTT (C- to N-terminal), while the second strand was TTTCTCT or TTTJTJT, where J is pseudoisocytosine. These bis-PNAs form triple-stranded complexes of somewhat higher thermal stability than monomeric PNA with complementary oligonucleotides and the thermal melting transition shows very little hysteresis. When the J base is placed in the strand parallel to the DNA complement ('Hoogsteen strand'), the DNA binding was pH independent. The bis-PNAs were also superior to monomeric PNAs for targeting double-stranded DNA by strand invasion.     

Unwinding of unnatural substrates by a DNA helicase

Helicases separate double-stranded DNA into single-stranded DNA intermediates that are required during replication and recombination. These enzymes are believed to transduce free energy available from ATPase activity to unwind the duplex and translocate along the nucleic acid lattice. The nature of enzyme-substrate interactions between helicases and duplex DNA substrates has not been well-defined. Most helicases require a single-stranded DNA overhang adjacent to duplex DNA in order to initiate unwinding. The strand containing the overhang is referred to as the loading strand whereas the complementary strand is referred to as the displaced strand. We have investigated the interactions between a DNA helicase and the DNA substrate by replacing the displaced strand with a nucleic acid mimic, peptide nucleic acid (PNA). PNA is capable of forming duplex structures with DNA according to Watson-Crick base pairing rules, but contains a N-(2-aminoethyl)glycine backbone in place of the deoxyribose phosphates. The PNA-DNA hybrids had higher melting temperatures than their DNA-DNA counterparts. Dda helicase, from bacteriophage T4, was able to unwind the DNA-PNA substrates at similar rates as DNA-DNA substrates. The results indicate that the rate-limiting step for unwinding is relatively insensitive to the chemical nature of the displaced strand and the thermal stability of oligonucleotide substrates.     

Peptide nucleic acid-DNA duplexes containing the universal base 3-nitropyrrole

A peptide nucleic acid (PNA) monomer containing the universal base 3-nitropyrrole was synthesized by coupling 1-carboxymethyl-3-nitropyrrole to ethyl N-[2-(tert-butoxycarbonylamino)ethyl]glycinate. The PNA sequence H-TGTACGTXACAACTA-NH2 (X = 3-nitropyrrole and C) and DNA sequence 5'-TGTACGTXACAACTA-3' were synthesized and thermal melting studies with the complementary DNA sequence 5'-TAGTTGTYACGTACA-3' (Y = A,C, G, T) compared. The T(m) data show that 3-nitropyrrole pairs indiscriminately with all four natural nucleobases as a constituent of either DNA or PNA. However, 3-nitropyrrole-containing PNA-DNA (average T(m) value = 51.1 degrees C) is significantly more thermally stable than 3-nitropyrrole-containing DNA-DNA (average T(m) value = 39.6 degrees C). From circular dichroism measurements, it is apparent that 3-nitropyrrole in the PNA strand causes a significant change in duplex structure.     

Quinoxaline antibiotics enhance peptide nucleic acid binding to double-stranded DNA

The effects of a wide range of DNA binding drugs on peptide nucleic acid (PNA) binding to double-stranded DNA by strand displacement have been investigated using a gel retardation assay. The bis-PNA [H-(Lys)-TTJTTJTTTT-(eg)(3)-TTTTCTTCTT-Lys-NH(2)] was used together with a 248 bp DNA fragment containing an appropriate target for the PNA. Most of the ligands that were studied, including DNA minor groove binders as well as intercalators and bis-intercalators, either have no effect or strongly inhibit PNA binding to DNA. By contrast, quinoxaline antibiotics facilitate PNA-DNA complex formation. The "PNA-helper" effect of echinomycin was studied in more detail using time and temperature dependence experiments to elucidate the mechanism. PNA binding to DNA follows pseudo-first-order kinetics, but the initial rate of binding is accelerated more than 10-fold in the presence of 10 microM echinomycin. The activation energy for PNA binding to dsDNA is lowered 2-fold by the antibiotic (45 vs 90 kJ/mol in the control). The reasons why quinoxalines promote the binding of PNA to DNA are not entirely clear but may well include distortions (opening) of the double helix that facilitate PNA invasion. This study establishes that the efficacy of DNA-targeted PNA antigene molecules could potentially be enhanced by judiciously adding certain DNA-interactive ligands.     

Structural diversity of target-specific homopyrimidine peptide nucleic acid-dsDNA complexes

Sequence-selective recognition of double-stranded (ds) DNA by homopyrimidine peptide nucleic acid (PNA) oligomers can occur by major groove triplex binding or by helix invasion via triplex P-loop formation. We have compared the binding of a decamer, a dodecamer and a pentadecamer thymine–cytosine homopyrimidine PNA oligomer to a sequence complementary homopurine target in duplex DNA using gel-shift and chemical probing analyses. We find that all three PNAs form stable triplex invasion complexes, and also conventional triplexes with the dsDNA target. Triplexes form with much faster kinetics than invasion complexes and prevail at lower PNA concentrations and at shorter incubation times. Furthermore, increasing the ionic strength strongly favour triplex formation over invasion as the latter is severely inhibited by cations. Whereas a single triplex invasion complex is formed with the decameric PNA, two structurally different target-specific invasion complexes were characterized for the dodecameric PNA and more than five for the pentadecameric PNA. Finally, it is shown that isolated triplex complexes can be converted to specific invasion complexes without dissociation of the Hoogsteen base-paired triplex PNA. These result demonstrate a clear example of a ‘triplex first’ mechanism for PNA helix invasion.     

Sequence-specific recognition, photocrosslinking and cleavage of the DNA double helix by an oligo-[alpha]-thymidylate covalently linked to an azidoproflavine derivative.

A 3-azidoproflavine derivative was covalently linked to the 5'-end of an octathymidylate synthesized with the [alpha]-anomers of the nucleoside. Two target nucleic acids were used for this substituted oligo-[alpha]-thymidylate: a 27-mer single-stranded DNA fragment containing an octadeoxyadenylate sequence and a 27-mer duplex containing eight contiguous A.T base pairs with all adenines on the same strand. Upon visible light irradiation the octa-[alpha]-thymidylate was photocrosslinked to the single-stranded 27-mer. Chain breaks were induced at the crosslinked sites upon piperidine treatment. From the location of the cleavage sites on the 27-mer sequence it was concluded that a triple helix was formed by the azidoproflavine-substituted oligo-[alpha]-thymidylate with its complementary oligodeoxyadenylate sequence. When the 27-mer duplex was used as a substrate cleavage sites were observed on both strands after piperidine treatment of the irradiated sample. They were located at well defined positions which indicated that the octathymidylate was bound to the (dA)8.(dT)8 sequence in parallel orientation with respect to the (dA)8-containing strand. Specific binding of the [alpha]-octathymidylate involved local triple strand formation with the duplex (dA)8.(dT)8 sequence. This result shows that it is possible to synthesize sequence-specific molecules which specifically bind oligopurine-oligopyrimidine sequences in double-stranded DNA via recognition of the major groove hydrogen bonding sites of the purines.     

Kinetic sequence discrimination of cationic bis-PNAs upon targeting of double-stranded DNA.

Strand displacement binding kinetics of cationic pseudoisocytosine-containing linked homopyrimidine peptide nucleic acids (bis-PNAs) to fully matched and singly mismatched decapurine targets in double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) are reported. PNA-dsDNA complex formation was monitored by gel mobility shift assay and pseudo-first order kinetics of binding was obeyed in all cases studied. The kinetic specificity of PNA binding to dsDNA, defined as the ratio of the initial rates of binding to matched and mismatched targets, increases with increasing ionic strength, whereas the apparent rate constant for bis-PNA-dsDNA complex formation decreases exponentially. Surprisingly, at very low ionic strength two equally charged bis-PNAs which have the same sequence of nucleobases but different linkers and consequently different locations of three positive charges differ in their specificity of binding by one order of magnitude. Under appropriate experimental conditions the kinetic specificity for bis-PNA targeting of dsDNA is as high as 300. Thus multiply charged cationic bis-PNAs containing pseudoisocytosines (J bases) in the Hoogsteen strand combined with enhanced binding affinity also exhibit very high sequence specificity, thereby making such reagents extremely efficient for sequence-specific targeting of duplex DNA.     

Effect of temperature and ionic strength on the dissociation kinetics and lifetime of PNA-DNA triplexes

Dissociation kinetics of triplexes formed by molecules of peptide nucleic acid (PNA) and DNA have been studied. The complexes consisted of oligomeric PNA containing 10 thymine bases and the dA(10) target incorporated in single-stranded (ssDNA) or double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). Their dissociation was followed by means of the gel mobility shift assay at various temperatures and sodium ion concentrations. In all experiments, the dissociation kinetics of triplexes were exponential; the effective lifetime of a triplex, tau, depended on temperature in accordance with the Arrhenius law. The tau values for T(10) PNA complexes with ss- and dsDNA were equal within the accuracy of experiments. The activation energy, U, value for T(10) PNA-DNA complexes did not change when the NaCl concentration was increased from 50 to 200 or 600 mM. Conversely, the tau values decreased with the increase in NaCl concentration. The equal lifetimes of the T(10) PNA-DNA triplexes containing ss- and dsDNA suggest that the loop formed in dsDNA does not noticeably affect the triplex structure. The decrease in the triplex lifetime tau with an increase in ionic strength was accounted for by the fact that the PNA backbone is neutral. The lack of relationship between the activation energy of dissociation and salt concentration suggests that the dissociation enthalpy does not depend on the ionic strength. Thus, the effect of ionic strength on the lifetime is entropic by its nature. Contrary to this, for complexes of ssDNA with bis-PNA 1743, which also consists of 10 thymine bases but contains 2 additional positive charges inside the sequence in 1 of the PNA arms, an increase of the dissociation enthalpy at low salt concentration was observed. We suggest that this effect is a result of a direct electrostatic interaction of the positive charges of the PNA with the DNA backbone. Finally, our results allow an estimate of the lifetime of a 10-mer triplex invasion complex in dsDNA at 37 degrees C in excess of several hundred days.     

Initiation of adenovirus DNA replication. II. Structural requirements using synthetic oligonucleotide adenovirus templates

Adenovirus (Ad) virions contain a 55-kDa terminal protein covalently linked to both 5'-ends of the linear duplex DNA genome. The origin of DNA replication is contained within the terminal 50 base pair of the inverted terminal repeats. In the accompanying paper (Kenny, M. K., Balogh, L. A., and Hurwitz, J. (1988) J. Biol. Chem. 263, 9801-9808), it was demonstrated that synthetic oligonucleotide templates which contain the Ad origin, but lack the 55-kDa terminal protein, can serve as templates for the initiation of Ad DNA replication. Partially duplex oligonucleotides that lacked up to 14 nucleotides from the 5'-end of the nontemplate (displaced) strand supported initiation as much as 20-fold more efficiently than fully duplex oligonucleotides. The removal of 18 nucleotides or more from the 5'-end of the displaced strand resulted in a sharp decrease in the ability of the DNA templates to support initiation. The poor template efficiency of certain DNAs could be explained by their inability to bind nuclear factor I. The initiation efficiency observed with other DNAs correlated with their ability to bind the preterminal protein-Ad DNA polymerase complex. At low concentrations of the Ad DNA-binding protein, protein-primed initiation was also observed on single-stranded DNAs. The single-stranded template strand of the Ad origin was at least 5-20-fold better at supporting initiation than other single-stranded DNAs. These findings suggest a model in which the 3'-end of the template strand is rendered single-stranded as a prerequisite for initiation of Ad DNA replication.     

Inducing the replacement of PNA in DNA.PNA duplexes by DNA

The uncharged DNA-analogue peptide nucleic acid (PNA) can invade into dsDNA by displacing the non-complementary DNA strand. The formed strand displacement complexes can create a sterical hindrance to block access of enzymes such as nucleases and polymerases. Due to the high stability of DNA.PNA duplexes it is usually not possible to displace the PNA strand by ssDNA or ssRNA. We herein report that the polycationic, comb-type copolymer alphaPLL-g-Dex can induce such a replacement of PNA in DNA.PNA duplexes by ssDNA. The influence of the copolymer on strand exchange highly depends on the nature of the oligonucleotides. Acceleration has only been observed when both the starting duplex and the single-stranded exchanger strand were negatively charged. The presented approach should allow the withdrawal of PNA induced sterical hindrance of DNA by rehybridisation with ssDNA.     

Specific oligonucleotide invasion into an end of a DNA duplex

A new phenomenon was described: a double-stranded DNA fragment interacted with a single-stranded oligonucleotide complementary to the terminal region of one strand of the duplex to yield a complex with oligonucleotide invasion. Generation of Holliday junctions by homologous linear DNA fragments was less efficient in the presence of single-stranded oligonucleotides complementary to duplex ends. The effect depended on the oligonucleotide concentration, size, and complementarity to a duplex strand. Sequence-specific complexes with single strand invasion were detected in mixtures containing radiolabeled oligonucleotides and duplexes. A single-stranded oligonucleotide invaded a duplex even when its concentration was far lower than the duplex concentration. Complexes with single strand invasion were analyzed by chemical cleavage of noncanonical base pairs. Analysis showed that an oligonucleotide interacts with the complementary region of one strand of the duplex, gradually displacing the other strand. The extent of oligonucleotide invasion into the duplex considerably varied. Oligonucleotide invasion into duplexes became more efficient with increasing oligonucleotide size.     

Recognition of double-stranded RNA by guanidine-modified peptide nucleic acids

Double-helical RNA has become an attractive target for molecular recognition because many noncoding RNAs play important roles in the control of gene expression. Recently, we discovered that short peptide nucleic acids (PNA) bind strongly and sequence selectively to a homopurine tract of double-helical RNA via formation of a triple helix. Herein, we tested if the molecular recognition of RNA could be enhanced by α-guanidine modification of PNA. Our study was motivated by the discovery of Ly and co-workers that the guanidine modification greatly enhances the cellular delivery of PNA. Isothermal titration calorimetry showed that the guanidine-modified PNA (GPNA) had reduced affinity and sequence selectivity for triple-helical recognition of RNA. The data suggested that in contrast to unmodified PNA, which formed a 1:1 PNA-RNA triple helix, GPNA preferred a 2:1 GPNA-RNA triplex invasion complex. Nevertheless, promising results were obtained for recognition of biologically relevant double-helical RNA. Consistent with enhanced strand invasion ability, GPNA derived from d-arginine recognized the transactivation response element of HIV-1 with high affinity and sequence selectivity, presumably via Watson-Crick duplex formation. On the other hand, strong and sequence selective triple helices were formed by unmodified and nucelobase-modified PNA and the purine-rich strand of the bacterial A-site. These results suggest that appropriate chemical modifications of PNA may enhance molecular recognition of complex noncoding RNAs.