The compositional patterns of the avian genomes and their evolutionary implications

The compositional distributions of large (main-band) DNA fragments from eight birds belonging to eight different orders (including both paleognathous and neognathous species) are very broad and extremely close to each other. These findings, which are paralleled by the compositional similarity of homologous coding sequences and their codon positions, support the idea that birds are a monophyletic group.The compositional distribution of third-codon positions of genes from chicken, the only avian species for which a relatively large number of coding sequences is known, is very broad and bimodal, the minor GC-richer peak reaching 100% GC. The very high compositional heterogeneity of avian genomes is accompanied (as in the case of mammalian genomes) by a very high speciation rate compared to cold-blooded vertebrates which are characterized by genomes that are much less heterogeneous. The higher GC levels attained by avian compared to mammalian genomes might be correlated with the higher body temperature (41–43°C) of birds compared to mammals (37°C).A comparison of GC levels of coding sequences and codon positions from man and chicken revealed very close average GC levels and standard deviations. Homologous coding sequences and codon positions from man and chicken showed a surprisingly high degree of compositional similarity which was, however, higher for GC-poor than for GC-rich sequences. This indicates that GC-poor isochores of warm-blooded vertebrates reflect the composition of the isochores of the genome of the common reptilian ancestor of mammals and birds, which underwent only a small compositional change at the transition from cold- to warm-blooded vertebrates. In contrast, the GC-rich isochores of birds and mammals are the result of large compositional changes at the same evolutionary transition, where were in part different in the two classes of warm-blooded vertebrates.Correspondence to: G. Bernaadi     

Statistical analysis of vertebrate sequences reveals that long genes are scarce in GC-rich isochores

We compared the exon/intron organization of vertebrate genes belonging to different isochore classes, as predicted by their GC content at third codon position. Two main features have emerged from the analysis of sequences published in GenBank: (1) genes coding for long proteins (i.e., 500 aa) are almost two times more frequent in GC-poor than in GC-rich isochores; (2) intervening sequences (=sum of introns) are on average three times longer in GC-poor than in GC-rich isochores. These patterns are observed among human, mouse, rat, cow, and even chicken genes and are therefore likely to be common to all warm-blooded vertebrates. Analysis of Xenopus sequences suggests that the same patterns exist in cold-blooded vertebrates. It could be argued that such results do not reflect the reality because sequence databases are not representative of entire genomes. However, analysis of biases in GenBank revealed that the observed discrepancies between GC-rich and GC-poor isochores are not artifactual, and are probably largely underestimated. We investigated the distribution of microsatellites and interspersed repeats in introns of human and mouse genes from different isochores. This analysis confirmed previous studies showing that Ll repeats are almost absent from GC-rich isochores. Microsatellites and SINES (Alu, B1, B2) are found at roughly equal frequencies in introns from all isochore classes. Globally, the presence of repeated sequences does not account for the increased intron length in GC-poor isochores. The relationships between gene structure and global genome organization and evolution are discussed.     

Different hydrophobicities of orthologous proteins from Xenopus and human

A compositional transition was previously detected by comparing orthologous coding sequences from cold- and warm-blooded vertebrates (see Bernardi, G., Hughes, S., Mouchiroud, D., 1997. The major compositional transitions in the vertebrate genome. J. Mol. Evol. 44, S44-S51 for a review). The transition is characterized by higher GC levels (GC is the molar ratio of guanine+cytosine in DNA) and, especially, by higher GC3 levels (GC3 is the GC level of third codon positions) in coding sequences from warm-blooded vertebrates. This transition essentially affects GC-rich genes, although the nucleotide substitution rate is of the same order of magnitude in both GC-poor and GC-rich genes. In order to understand the evolutionary basis of the changes, we have compared the hydrophobicity of orthologous proteins from Xenopus and human. Although the differences are small in proteins encoded by coding sequences ranging from 0 to 65% in GC3, they are large in the proteins encoded by sequences characterized by GC3 values higher than 65%. The latter proteins are more hydrophobic in human than in Xenopus.     

Compositional bimodality and evolution of retroviral genomes.

The compositional distributions of genomes, genes (and their third codon positions) and long terminal repeats from retroviruses of warm-blooded vertebrates are characterized by a striking bimodality which is accompanied by a remarkable compositional homogeneity within each retroviral genome. A first, major class of retroviral genomes is GC-rich, whereas a second, minor class is GC-poor. Representative expressed viral genomes from the two classes integrate in GC-rich and GC-poor isochores, respectively, of host genomes. The first class comprises all oncoviruses (except B-types and some D-types), the second, lentiviruses, spumaviruses, as well as B-type and some D-type oncoviruses (e.g., mouse mammary tumor virus and simian retroviruses type D, respectively). The compositional bimodal distribution of retroviral genomes and the accompanying compositional homogeneity within each retroviral genome appear to be the result of the compositional evolution of retroviral genomes in their integrated form.     

Compositional properties of nuclear genes from cold-blooded vertebrates

Summary We have investigated the compositional properties of coding sequences from cold-blooded vertebrates and we have compared them with those from warm-blooded vertebrates. Moreover, we have studied the compositional correlations of coding sequences with the genomes in which they are contained, as well as the compositional correlations among the codon positions of the genes analyzed.The distribution of GC levels of the third codon positions of genes from cold-blooded vertebrates are distinctly different from those of warm-blooded vertebrates in that they do not reach the high values attained by the latter. Moreover, coding sequences from cold-blooded vertebrates are either equal, or, in most cases, lower in GC (not only in third, but also in first and second codon positions) than homologous coding sequences from warm-blooded vertebrates; higher values are exceptional. These results at the gene level are in agreement with the compositional differences between cold-blooded and warm-blooded vertebrates previously found at the whole genome (DNA) level (Bernardi and Bernardi 1990a,b).Two linear correlations were found: one between the GC levels of coding sequences (or of their third codon positions) and the GC levels of the genomes of cold-blooded vertebrates containing them; and another between the GC levels of third and first+ second codon positions of genes from cold-blooded vertebrates. The first correlation applies to the genomes (or genome compartments) of all vertebrates and the second to the genes of all living organisms. These correlations are tantamount to a genomic code.     

The compositional transition between the genomes of cold- and warm-blooded vertebrates: codon frequencies in orthologous genes

The genomes of the ancestors of mammals and birds underwent a compositional change in which the gene-richest regions increased their GC levels. Here we investigated this compositional transition by analyzing the levels of G and C in third codon positions, as well as the codon frequencies of orthologous genes from human, chicken and Xenopus. The results may be summed up as follows: (i) GC-poor genes, that did not undergo the compositional transition, showed only minor differences in orthologous sets from Xenopus, human and chicken; this is remarkable in view of the very many nucleotide substitutions that occurred over the long evolutionary times separating these species; (ii) GC-rich genes, that underwent the compositional transition, showed large differences between Xenopus and warm-blooded vertebrates, but not between chicken and human. In other words, the independent changes that occurred in avian and mammalian genes, on the average, were the same.     

Directional fixation of mutations in vertebrate evolution

Summary We have made pairwise comparisons between the coding sequences of 21 genes from coldblooded vertebrates and 41 homologous sequences from warm-blooded vertebrates. In the case of 12 genes, GC levels were higher, especially in third codon positions, in warm-blooded vertebrates compared to cold-blooded vertebrates. Six genes showed no remarkable difference in GC level and three showed a lower level. In the first case, higher GC levels appear to be due to a directional fixation of mutations, presumably under the influence of body temperature (see Bernardi and Bernardi 1986b). These GC-richer genes of warm-blooded vertebrates were located, in all cases studied, in isochores higher in GC than those comprising the homologous genes of cold-blooded vertebrates. In the third case, increases appear to be due to a limited formation of GC-rich isochores which took place in some cold-blooded vertebrates after the divergence of warm-blooded vertebrates. The directional changes in the GC content of coding sequences and the evolutionary conservation of both increased and unchanged GC levels are in keeping with the existence of compositional constraints on the genome.     

The length of chromatin loops in meiotic prophase I of warm-blooded vertebrates depends on the DNA compositional organization

In meiotic prophase I, chromatin fibrils attached to the lateral elements of the synaptonemal complexes (SC) form loops. SCAR DNA (synaptonemal complex associated regions of DNA) is a family of genomic DNA tightly associated with the SC and located at the chromatin loop basements. Using the hybridization technique, it was demonstrated that localization of SCAR DNA was evolutionarily conserved in the isochore compositional fractions of the three examined genomes of warm-blooded vertebrates—human, chicken, and golden hamster. The introduction of the concept of the comparative loops (CL) of DNA that form of chromatin attach to SC in the isochore compositional fractions provided the calculation of their length. An inverse proportional relationship between the length of CL DNA and the GC level in the isochore compartments of the studied warm-blooded vertebrate genomes was revealed. An exception was the GCpoorest L1 isochore family. For different compositional isochores of the human and chicken genomes, the number of genes in the CL DNA was evaluated. A model of the formation of GC-rich isochores in vertebrate genomes, according to which there was not only an increase in the GC level but also the elimination of functionally insignificant noncoding DNA regions, as well as joining of isochores decreasing in size, was suggested.     

A relationship between GC content and coding-sequence length

Since base composition of translational stop codons (TAG, TAA, and TGA) is biased toward a low G+C content, a differential density for these termination signals is expected in random DNA sequences of different base compositions. The expected length of reading frames (DNA segments of sense codons flanked by in-phase stop codons) in random sequences is thus a function of GC content. The analysis of DNA sequences from several genome databases stratified according to GC content reveals that the longest coding sequences—exons in vertebrates and genes in prokaryotes—are GC-rich, while the shortest ones are GC-poor. Exon lengthening in GC-rich vertebrate regions does not result, however, in longer vertebrate proteins, perhaps because of the lower number of exons in the genes located in these regions. The effects on coding-sequence lengths constitute a new evolutionary meaning for compositional variations in DNA GC content. Correspondence to: J. L. Oliver     

Gene-rich and gene-poor chromosomal regions have different locations in the interphase nuclei of cold-blooded vertebrates

In situ hybridizations of single-copy GC-rich, gene-rich and GC-poor, gene-poor chicken DNA allowed us to localize the gene-rich and the gene-poor chromosomal regions in interphase nuclei of cold-blooded vertebrates. Our results showed that the gene-rich regions from amphibians (Rana esculenta) and reptiles (Podarcis sicula) occupy the more internal part of the nuclei, whereas the gene-poor regions occupy the periphery. This finding is similar to that previously reported in warm-blooded vertebrates, in spite of the lower GC levels of the gene-rich regions of cold-blooded vertebrates. This suggests that this similarity extends to chromatin structure, which is more open in the gene-rich regions of both mammals and birds and more compact in the gene-poor regions. In turn, this may explain why the compositional transition undergone by the genome at the emergence of homeothermy did not involve the entire ancestral genome but only a small part of it, and why it involved both coding and noncoding sequences. Indeed, the GC level increased only in that part of the genome that needed a thermodynamic stabilization, namely in the more open gene-rich chromatin of the nuclear interior, whereas the gene-poor chromatin of the periphery was stabilized by its own compact structure.     

Evolution of base composition in the insulin and insulin-like growth factor genes

The genomes of homeothermic (warm-blooded) vertebrates are mosaic interspersions of homogeneously GC-rich and GC-poor regions (isochores). Evolution of genome compartmentalization and GC-rich isochores is hypothesized to reflect either selective advantages of an elevated GC content or chromosome location and mutational pressure associated with the timing of DNA replication in germ cells. To address the present controversy regarding the origins and maintenance of isochores in homeothermic vertebrates, newly obtained as well as published nucleotide sequences of the insulin and insulin-like growth factor (IGF) genes, members of a well-characterized gene family believed to have evolved by repeated duplication and divergence, were utilized to examine the evolution of base composition in nonconstrained (flanking) and weakly constrained (introns and fourfold degenerate sites) regions. A phylogeny derived from amino acid sequences supports a common evolutionary history for the insulin/IGF family genes. In cold- blooded vertebrates, insulin and the IGFs were similar in base composition. In contrast, insulin and IGF-II demonstrate dramatic increases in GC richness in mammals, but no such trend occurred in IGF- I. Base composition of the coding portions of the insulin and IGF genes across vertebrates correlated (r = 0.90) with that of the introns and flanking regions. The GC content of homologous introns differed dramatically between insulin/IGF-II and IGF-I genes in mammals but was similar to the GC level of noncoding regions in neighboring genes. Our findings suggest that the base composition of introns and flanking regions is determined by chromosomal location and the mutational pressure of the isochore in which the sequences are embedded. An elevated GC content at codon third positions in the insulin and the IGF genes may reflect selective constraints on the usage of synonymous codons.      

CpG islands: features and distribution in the genomes of vertebrates

We have investigated the distribution of unmethylated CpG islands in vertebrate genomes fractionated according to their base composition. Genomes from warm-blooded vertebrates (man, mouse and chicken) are characterized by abundant CpG islands, whose frequency increases in DNA fractions of increasing % of guanine + cytosine; % G + C (GC), in parallel with the distribution of genes and CpG doublets. Small, yet significant, differences in the distribution of CpG islands were found in the three genomes. In contrast, genomes from cold-blooded vertebrates (two reptiles, one amphibian, and two fishes) were characterized by an extreme scarcity or absence of CpG islands (detected in these experiments as HpaII tiny fragments or HTF). CpG islands associated with homologous genes from cold- and warm-blooded vertebrates were then compared by analyzing CpG frequencies, GC levels, HpaII sites, rare-cutter sites and G/C boxes (GGGGCGGGGC and closely related motifs) in sequences available in gene banks. Small, yet significant, differences were again detected among the CpG islands associated with homologous genes from warm-blooded vertebrates, in that CpG islands associated with mouse or rat genes often showed low CpG and/or GC levels, as well as low numbers of HpaII sites, rare-cutter sites and G/C boxes, compared to homologous human genes; more rarely, CpG islands were just absent. As far as cold-blooded vertebrates were concerned, a number of genes showed CpG islands, which exhibited a much lower frequency of CpG doublets than that found in CpG islands of warm-blooded vertebrates, but still approached the statistically expected frequency; none of the other features of CpG islands associated with genes from warm-blooded vertebrates were present. Other genes did not show any associated CpG islands, unlike their homologues from warm-blooded vertebrates.     

The major shifts of human duplicated genes

Since many gene duplications in the human genome are ancient duplications going back to the origin of vertebrates, the question may be asked about the fate of such duplicated genes at the compositional genome transitions that occurred between cold- and warm-blooded vertebrates. Indeed, at that transition, about half of the (GC-poor) genes of cold-blooded vertebrates (the genes of the gene-dense "ancestral genome core") underwent a GC enrichment to become the genes of the "genome core" of warm-blooded vertebrates. Since the compositional distribution of the human duplicated genes investigated (1111 pairs) mimics the general distribution of human genes (about 50% GC(3)-poor and 50% GC(3)-rich genes, the border being at 60% GC(3)), we considered two possibilities, namely that the compositional transition affected either (i) about half of the copies on a random basis, or (ii) preferentially only one copy of the duplicated genes. The two possibilities could be distinguished if each copy is put into one of two subsets according to its GC(3) level. Indeed, in the first case, the two distributions would be similar, whereas in the second case, the two distributions would be different, one copy having maintained the ancestral GC-poor composition, and one copy having undergone the compositional change. Using this approach, we could show that, by far and large, one copy of the duplicated genes preferentially underwent the GC enrichment. This result implies that this copy, which had possibly acquired a different function and/or regulation, was preferentially translocated into the gene-dense compartment of the genome, the "ancestral genome core", namely the "gene space" which underwent the compositional transition at the emergence of warm-blooded vertebrates.     

Isochores and the evolutionary genomics of vertebrates

The nuclear genomes of vertebrates are mosaics of isochores, very long stretches (>300kb) of DNA that are homogeneous in base composition and are compositionally correlated with the coding sequences that they embed. Isochores can be partitioned in a small number of families that cover a range of GC levels (GC is the molar ratio of guanine+cytosine in DNA), which is narrow in cold-blooded vertebrates, but broad in warm-blooded vertebrates. This difference is essentially due to the fact that the GC-richest 10-15% of the genomes of the ancestors of mammals and birds underwent two independent compositional transitions characterized by strong increases in GC levels. The similarity of isochore patterns across mammalian orders, on the one hand, and across avian orders, on the other, indicates that these higher GC levels were then maintained, at least since the appearance of ancestors of warm-blooded vertebrates. After a brief review of our current knowledge on the organization of the vertebrate genome, evidence will be presented here in favor of the idea that the generation and maintenance of the GC-richest isochores in the genomes of warm-blooded vertebrates were due to natural selection.     

A compositional map of human chromosome 21.

GC-poor and GC-rich isochores, the long (greater than 300 kb) compositionally homogeneous DNA segments that form the genome of warm-blooded vertebrates, are located in G- and R-bands respectively of metaphase chromosomes. The precise correspondence between GC-rich isochores and R-band structure is still, however, an open problem, because GC-rich isochores are compositionally heterogeneous and only represent one-third of the genome, with the GC-richest family (which is by far the highest in gene concentration) corresponding to less than 5% of the genome. In order to clarify this issue and, more generally, to correlate DNA composition and chromosomal structure in an unequivocal way, we have developed a new approach, compositional mapping. This consists of assessing the base composition over 0.2-0.3 Mb (megabase) regions surrounding landmarks that were previously localized on the physical map. Compositional mapping was applied here to the long arm of human chromosome 21, using 53 probes that had already been used in physical mapping. The results obtained provide a direct demonstration that the DNA stretches of G-bands essentially correspond to GC-poor isochores, and that R-band DNA is characterized by a compositional heterogeneity that is much more striking than expected, in that it comprises isochores covering the full spectrum of GC levels. GC-poor isochores of R-bands may, however, correspond to 'thin' G-bands, as visualized at high resolution, leaving GC-rich and very GC-rich isochores as the real components of (high-resolution) R-band DNA.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The compositional distribution of coding sequences and DNA molecules in humans and murids

Summary The compositional distributions of coding sequences and DNA molecules (in the 50-100-kb range) are remarkably narrower in murids (rat and mouse) compared to humans (as well as to all other mammals explored so far). In murids, both distributions begin at higher and end at lower GC values. A comparison of homologous coding sequences from murids and humans revealed that their different compositional distributions are due to differences in GC levels in all three codon positions, particularly of genes located at both ends of the distribution. In turn, these differences are responsible for differences in both codon usage and amino acids. When GC levels at first+second codon positions and third codon positions, respectively, of murid genes are plotted against corresponding GC levels of homologous human genes, linear relationships (with very high correlation coefficients and slopes of about 0.78 and 0.60, respectively) are found. This indicates a conservation of the order of GC levels in homologous genes from humans and murids. (The same comparison for mouse and rat genes indicates a conservation of GC levels of homologous genes.) A similar linear relationship was observed when plotting GC levels of corresponding DNA fractions (as obtained by density gradient centrifugation in the presence of a sequence-specific ligand) from mouse and human. These findings indicate that orderly compositional changes affecting not only coding sequences but also noncoding sequences took place since the divergence of murids. Such directional fixations of mutations point to the existence of selective pressures affecting the genome as a whole.     

Comparative Genomic Study Reveals a Transition from TA Richness in Invertebrates to GC Richness in Vertebrates at CpG Flanking Sites： An Indication for Context-Dependent Mutagenicity of Methylated CpG Sites

Vertebrate genomes are characterized with CpG deficiency, particularly for GCpoor regions. The GC content-related CpG deficiency is probably caused by context-dependent deamination of methylated CpG sites. This hypothesis was examined in this study by comparing nucleotide frequencies at CpG flanking positions among invertebrate and vertebrate genomes. The finding is a transition of nucleotide preference of 5＇ T to 5＇ A at the invertebrate-vertebrate boundary, indicating that a large number of CpG sites with 5＇ Ts were depleted because of global DNA methylation developed in vertebrates. At genome level, we investigated CpG observed/expected （obs/exp） values in 500 bp fragments, and found that higher CpG obs/exp value is shown in GC-poor regions of invertebrate genomes （except sea urchin） but in GC-rich sequences of vertebrate genomes. We next compared GC content at CpG flanking positions with genomic average, showing that the GC content is lower than the average in invertebrate genomes, but higher than that in vertebrate genomes. These results indicate that although 5＇ T and 5＇ A are different in inducing deamination of methylated CpG sites, GC content is even more important in affecting the deamination rate. In all the tests, the results of sea urchin are similar to vertebrates perhaps due to its fractional DNA methylation. CpG deficiency is therefore suggested to be mainly a result of high mutation rates of methylated CpG sites in GC-poor regions.