Implications of high RNA virus mutation rates: lethal mutagenesis and the antiviral drug ribavirin

The antiviral drug ribavirin exhibits strong antiviral activity against a broad range of RNA viruses. This drug is currently used clinically to treat hepatitis C virus infections, respiratory syncytial virus infections, and Lassa fever virus infections. Although ribavirin was discovered in 1972, its mechanism of action has remained unclear until recently. Using poliovirus as an RNA virus model, it was shown that ribavirin is a virus mutagen, and it was proposed that the primary mechanism of action of ribavirin is via lethal mutagenesis of the RNA virus genomes. This represents a novel antiviral mechanism of action and provides a model for the development of new antiviral strategies. In this review we discuss the genetic explanations, evolutionary implications, and drug development opportunities associated with RNA virus mutagenesis.     

The broad-spectrum antiviral ribonucleoside ribavirin is an RNA virus mutagen

The ribonucleoside analog ribavirin (1-beta-D-ribofuranosyl-1,2, 4-triazole-3-carboxamide) shows antiviral activity against a variety of RNA viruses and is used in combination with interferon-alpha to treat hepatitis C virus infection. Here we show in vitro use of ribavirin triphosphate by a model viral RNA polymerase, poliovirus 3Dpol. Ribavirin incorporation is mutagenic, as it templates incorporation of cytidine and uridine with equal efficiency. Ribavirin reduces infectious poliovirus production to as little as 0. 00001% in cell culture. The antiviral activity of ribavirin correlates directly with its mutagenic activity. These data indicate that ribavirin forces the virus into 'error catastrophe'. Thus, mutagenic ribonucleosides may represent an important class of anti-RNA virus agents.     

Ribavirin can be mutagenic for arenaviruses

Arenaviruses include several important human pathogens, and there are very limited options of preventive or therapeutic interventions to combat these viruses. An off-label use of the purine nucleoside analogue ribavirin (1-β-d-ribofuranosyl-1-H-1,2,4-triazole-3-carboxamide) is the only antiviral treatment currently available for arenavirus infections. However, the ribavirin antiviral mechanism action against arenaviruses remains unknown. Here we document that ribavirin is mutagenic for the prototypic arenavirus lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) in cell culture. The mutagenic activity of ribavirin on LCMV was observed under single- and multiple-passage regimes and could not be accounted for by a decrease of the intracellular GTP pool promoted by ribavirin-mediated inhibition of inosine monophosphate dehydrogenase (IMPDH). Our findings suggest that the antiviral activity of ribavirin on arenaviruses might be exerted, at least partially, by lethal mutagenesis. Implications for antiarenavirus therapy are discussed.     

Ribavirin induces error-prone replication of GB virus B in primary tamarin hepatocytes

GB virus B (GBV-B) is the closest relative of hepatitis C virus (HCV) and is an attractive surrogate model for HCV antiviral studies. GBV-B induces an acute, resolving hepatitis in tamarins. Utilizing primary cultures of tamarin hepatocytes, we have previously developed a tissue culture system that exhibits high levels of GBV-B replication. In this report, we have extended the utility of this system for testing antiviral compounds. Treatment with human interferon provided only a marginal antiviral effect, while poly(I-C) yielded >3 and 4 log units of reduction of cell-associated and secreted viral RNA, respectively. Interestingly, treatment of GBV-B-infected hepatocytes with ribavirin resulted in an approximately 4-log decrease in viral RNA levels. Guanosine blocked the antiviral effect of ribavirin, suggesting that inhibition of IMP dehydrogenase (IMPDH) and reduction of intracellular GTP levels were essential for the antiviral effect. However, mycophenolic acid, another IMPDH inhibitor, had no antiviral effect. Virions harvested from ribavirin-treated cultures exhibited a dramatically reduced specific infectivity. These data suggest that incorporation of ribavirin triphosphate induces error-prone replication with concomitant reduction in infectivity and that reduction of GTP pools may be required for incorporation of ribavirin triphosphate. In contrast to the in vitro studies, no significant reduction in viremia was observed in vivo following treatment of tamarins with ribavirin during acute infection with GBV-B. These findings are consistent with the observation that ribavirin monotherapy for HCV infection decreases liver disease without a significant reduction in viremia. Our data suggest that nucleoside analogues that induce error-prone replication could be an attractive approach for the treatment of HCV infection if administered at sufficient levels to result in efficient incorporation by the viral polymerase.     

奥司他韦、利巴韦林和盐酸金刚乙胺对甲型H1N1流感病毒的抑制作用

目的细胞水平测试奥司他韦、利巴韦林和盐酸金刚乙胺对甲型流感H1N1病毒的抑制或杀伤作用。方法通过在MDCK细胞系和甲型H1N1病毒株间建立药物剂量-效应关系确定导致细胞死亡的效力与抑制病毒复制的效力的比值（治疗指数）,测试药物的抗病毒效果。结果奥司他韦、利巴韦林和盐酸金刚乙胺对MDCK细胞的半数中毒浓度分别为（1134.7±186.8）μg/mL、（742.0±76.9）μg/mL、（94.6±1.9）μg/mL,对甲型H1N1病毒的治疗指数（TI）分别为71.19、24.9和3.12。结论奥司他韦对甲型H1N1病毒抑制作用最强,利巴韦林其次,盐酸金刚乙胺对甲型H1N1病毒抑制效果较弱。     

Combination of N-methylisatin-β-thiosemicarbazone derivative (SCH16) with ribavirin and mycophenolic acid potentiates the antiviral activity of SCH16 against Japanese encephalitis virus in vitro

Aim: To investigate the drug to drug interaction of N-methylisatin-β-thiosemicarbazone (MIBT) derivative (SCH16) with ribavirin, mycophenolic acid and pentoxifylline against Japanese encephalitis virus in vitro. Our earlier studies have reported significant antiviral activity of these compounds against Japanese encephalitis virus in vitro and in vivo. Methods and Results: An in vitro drug to drug combination analysis was carried out to investigate whether or not the direct antiviral effect shown by the individual MIBT derivative could be effectively increased when lower concentrations of two compounds in combination were used. The results of this study showed that the combination of MIBT derivative (SCH16) with ribavirin or mycophenolic acid significantly enhanced the antiviral activity of SCH16 against JEV in vitro. In contrast, the combination of SCH16 and pentoxifylline resulted in antagonism. Conclusion: The antiviral activity showed by SCH16 was enhanced in the presence of ribavirin and mycophenolic Acid. Significance and Impact of the Study: Studying the synergistic/additive interaction of the compounds in combination would help in lowering the effective concentration so as to overcome the concern of toxicity.     

An antiviral mechanism investigated with ribavirin as an RNA virus mutagen for foot-and-mouth disease virus

To prove whether error catastrophe/lethal mutagenesis is the primary antiviral mechanism of action of ribavirin against foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV). Ribavirin passage experiments were performed and supernatants of Rp1 to Rp5 were harvested. Morphological alterations as well as the levels of viral RNAs, proteins, and infectious particles in the BHK-21 cells infected using the supernatants of Rp1 to Rp5 and control were measured by microscope, real-time RT-PCR, western-blotting and plaque assays, respectively. The mutation frequency was measured by sequencing the complete P1- and 3D-encoding region of FMDV after a single round of virus infection from ribavirin-treated or untreated FMDV-infected cells. Ribavirin treatment for FMDV caused dramatically inhibition of multiplication in cell cultures. The levels of viral RNAs, proteins, and infectious particles in the BHK-21 cells infected were more greatly reduced along with the passage from Rp1 to Rp5, moreover, nucleocapsid protein could not be detected and no recovery of infectious virus in the supernatant or detection of intracellular viral RNA was observed at the Rp5-infected cells. A high mutation rate, giving rise to an 8-and 11-fold increase in mutagenesis and resulting in some amino acid substitutions, was found in viral RNA synthesized at a single round of virus infection in the presence of ribavirin of 1000 microM and caused a 99.7% loss in viral infectivity in contrast with parallel untreated control virus. These results suggest that the antiviral molecular mechanism of ribavirin is based on the lethal mutagenesis/error catastrophe, that is, the ribavirin is not merely an antiviral reagent but also an effective mutagen.     

Modified ribavirin analogues as antiviral agents against Junín virus

In this work, several ribavirin analogues were synthesized and incorporated into a multivalent arrangement. Both were subsequently modified by the addition of polyhydroxylated residues.Their antiviral activity was tested against Junín virus, etiological agent responsible of Argentine hemorrhagic fever.Some compounds inhibited Junín virus in the range of 13.2–389.1?µM. Two modified ribavirin analogues presented an effective concentration comparable to ribavirin but with a higher selectivity index.     

Lethal mutagenesis of poliovirus mediated by a mutagenic pyrimidine analogue

Lethal mutagenesis is the mechanism of action of ribavirin against poliovirus (PV) and numerous other RNA viruses. However, there is still considerable debate regarding the mechanism of action of ribavirin against a variety of RNA viruses. Here we show by using T7 RNA polymerase-mediated production of PV genomic RNA, PV polymerase-catalyzed primer extension, and cell-free PV synthesis that a pyrimidine ribonucleoside triphosphate analogue (rPTP) with ambiguous base-pairing capacity is an efficient mutagen of the PV genome. The in vitro incorporation properties of rPTP are superior to ribavirin triphosphate. We observed a log-linear relationship between virus titer reduction and the number of rPMP molecules incorporated. A PV genome encoding a high-fidelity polymerase was more sensitive to rPMP incorporation, consistent with diminished mutational robustness of high-fidelity PV. The nucleoside (rP) did not exhibit antiviral activity in cell culture, owing to the inability of rP to be converted to rPMP by cellular nucleotide kinases. rP was also a poor substrate for herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase. The block to nucleoside phosphorylation could be bypassed by treatment with the P nucleobase, which exhibited both antiviral activity and mutagenesis, presumably a reflection of rP nucleotide formation by a nucleotide salvage pathway. These studies provide additional support for lethal mutagenesis as an antiviral strategy, suggest that rPMP prodrugs may be highly efficacious antiviral agents, and provide a new tool to determine the sensitivity of RNA virus genomes to mutagenesis as well as interrogation of the impact of mutational load on the population dynamics of these viruses.     

Lethal mutagenesis of foot-and-mouth disease virus involves shifts in sequence space

Lethal mutagenesis or virus transition into error catastrophe is an antiviral strategy that aims at extinguishing a virus by increasing the viral mutation rates during replication. The molecular basis of lethal mutagenesis is largely unknown. Previous studies showed that a critical substitution in the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) polymerase was sufficient to allow the virus to escape extinction through modulation of the transition types induced by the purine nucleoside analogue ribavirin. This substitution was not detected in mutant spectra of FMDV populations that had not replicated in the presence of ribavirin, using standard molecular cloning and nucleotide sequencing. Here we selectively amplify and analyze low-melting-temperature cDNA duplexes copied from FMDV genome populations passaged in the absence or presence of ribovirin Hypermutated genomes with high frequencies of A and U were present in both ribavirin -treated and untreated populations, but the major effect of ribavirin mutagenesis was to accelerate the occurrence of AU-rich mutant clouds during the early replication rounds of the virus. The standard FMDV quasispecies passaged in the absence of ribavirin included the salient transition-modulating, ribavirin resistance mutation, whose frequency increased in populations treated with ribavirin. Thus, even nonmutagenized FMDV quasispecies include a deep, mutationally biased portion of sequence space, in support of the view that the virus replicates close to the error threshold for maintenance of genetic information.     

PHOTOLABELING PROBES OF RIBAVIRIN AND EICAR

Ribavirin, the only small molecule available so far for treating hepatitis C virus infection, was recently used in an emergency context to treat patients with severe acute respiratory syndrome in the early stages of the disease. EICAR, one of the most potent congeners of ribavirin, has 10 to 100 times greater antiviral potency than ribavirin. The mechanisms underlying the antiviral effects of ribavirin and EICAR have not yet been definitely elucidated, but they seem to be similar. In order to study the mechanisms responsible for their antiviral effects using a photolabeling approach, we have developed photolabeling probes of ribavirin and EICAR, in which an azido group was introduced into the pseudobases of triazole and imidazole, respectively. The ribavirin photoprobes were obtained by directly coupling the azidotriazole to the protected ribose sugar, while the EICAR probe was prepared by diazotizing AICAR and subsequently substituting with NaN₃. All these probes showed a fast, clear-cut photochemical reaction, which suggests that they are promising tools for use in photolabeling studies.     

Photolabeling probes of ribavirin and EICAR

Ribavirin, the only small molecule available so far for treating hepatitis C virus infection, was recently used in an emergency context to treat patients with severe acute respiratory syndrome in the early stages of the disease. EICAR, one of the most potent congeners of ribavirin, has 10 to 100 times greater antiviral potency than ribavirin. The mechanisms underlying the antiviral effects of ribavirin and EICAR have not yet been definitely elucidated, but they seem to be similar. In order to study the mechanisms responsible for their antiviral effects using a photolabeling approach, we have developed photolabeling probes of ribavirin and EICAR, in which an azido group was introduced into the pseudobases of triazole and imidazole, respectively. The ribavirin photoprobes were obtained by directly coupling the azidotriazole to the protected ribose sugar, while the EICAR probe was prepared by diazotizing AICAR and subsequently substituting with NaN3. All these probes showed a fast, clear-cut photochemical reaction, which suggests that they are promising tools for use in photolabeling studies.     

1-beta-D-ribofuranosyl-1,2,4-triazole-3-carboxamide (ribavirin) and 5-ethynyl-1-beta-D-ribofuranosylimidazole-4-carboxamide (EICAR) markedly potentiate the inhibitory effect of 2',3'-dideoxyinosine on human immunodeficiency virus in peripheral blood lymphocytes.

Ribavirin and EICAR are two antiviral agents that share a similar antiviral activity spectrum and are targeted at inosine 5'-monophosphate (IMP) dehydrogenase. Neither ribavirin nor EICAR inhibit the replication of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) in peripheral blood lymphocyte cells (PBL) at subtoxic concentrations. However, both compounds markedly potentiate the anti-HIV activity of 2',3'-dideoxyinosine (DDI) in PBL cells without a marked increase of toxicity. Both the increased IMP levels and the decreased guanine nucleotide levels caused by ribavirin and EICAR may be responsible for their potentiating effect on the anti-HIV activity of DDI.     

The arsenolysis reaction in the biotechnological synthesis of ribavirin. The in vitro and in vivo inhibition of influenza A virus replication with a combination of ribavirin and ozeltamivir

The biotechnological method of synthesis of the antiviral drug ribavirin based on the transglycosylation reaction was improved due to the addition of catalytic amounts of sodium arsenate. This approach allows us to hydrolyze the excess natural nucleoside guanosine, a ribose donor, and, hence, made the composition of the reaction mixture less complicated, thus facilitating the process of ribavirin isolation. It was shown that in cell cultures the combination of ribavirin and oseltamivir carboxylate inhibited the replication of the influenza A virus more effectively than each of them alone. Similar results were obtained in experiments on laboratory animals (mouse Balb/c) infected with the influenza A virus H3N2/Aichi/68 strain.     

Study of antiviral activity of different drugs against bovine herpes virus and pestivirus]

In vitro antiviral activity of 11 different drugs against the viruses of infectious bovine rhionotracheitis (IBR) and bovine viral diarrhea (BVD) was studied. The ID50 of the drugs were determined in monolayers of cell cultures MDBK and KCT: 20 mcg/ml for anandin, 25 mcg/ml for polyprenole, 50 mcg/ml for bromuridin, methisazone, aciclovir, gossypole, ribavirin and liposomal ribavirin, 100 mcg/ml for eracond, and 200 mcg/ml for phosprenil and argovit. Phosprenil was the only drug that showed virucidal activity against the IBR virus. All the drugs inhibited reproduction of the IBR virus in sensitive cell culture MDBK: 100,000-fold inhibition by bromuridin, aciclovir, ribavirin and methisazone, 1000-10000-fold inhibition by liposomal ribavirin, gossypole, anandin, polyprenole and phosprenil, 100-fold inhibition by eracond and argovit. As for the BVD virus, bromuridin, phosprenil, polyprenole, methisazone, aciclovir, gossypole, argovit, ribavirin and liposomal ribavirin also showed their activity in cell culture KCT (100-10,000-fold inhibition). The other drugs were ineffective.     

Ribavirin: Biotechnological Synthesis and Effect on the Reproduction of Vaccinia Virus

The biotechnological method of synthesis of ribavirin, vidarabin, and 6-azauridine by the use of immobilized recombinant enzymatic preparations of nucleoside phosphorylase was improved. The effect of ribavirin and its combinations with the other synthesized nucleosides on the reproduction of Vaccinia virus was studied on the culture of Vero cells. The combination of ribavirin and vidarabin was shown to provide the antiviral effect at lesser concentrations than with these compounds taken separately.     

Effect of cytosine, arabinoside, iododeoxyuridine, ethyldeoxyuridine, thiocyanatodeoxyuridine, and ribavirin on tail lesion formation in mice infected with vaccinia virus.

Mice infected intravenously with vaccinia virus develop characteristic lesions over the entire tail surface. This experimental virus infection presents a highly sensitive and reliable model for evaluating the antivaccinia activity of antiviral compounds. Ara-C (1-beta-D-arabinofuranosylcytosine), ribavirin (1-beta-D-ribofuranosyl-1,2,4-triazole-3-carboxamide), IUdR (5-iodo-2'-deoxyuridine) as well as two novel analogs of IUdR, EtUdR (5-ethyl-2'-deoxyuridine), and NCSUdR (5-thiocyanato-2'-deoxyuridine), were found to inhibit the formation of vaccinia tail lesions, when administered intraperitoneally once daily for 7 days starting immediately after virus infection. The order of (decreasing) activity was: ara-C greater than IUdR greater than NCSUdR greater than ribavirin greater than EtUdR. Various drug combinations, involving IUdR + ara-C, NCSUdR + ara-C, NCSUdR + IUdR, NSCUdR + ribavirin, etc., were evaluated but none proved more efficacious than either compound administered alone.     

In vitro and in vivo activity of ribavirin against Andes virus infection

Pathogenic hantaviruses are a closely related group of rodent-borne viruses which are responsible for two distinct diseases in humans, hemorrhagic fever with renal syndrome and hantavirus pulmonary syndrome (HPS, otherwise known as hantavirus cardiopulmonary syndrome, HCPS). The antiviral effect of ribavirin against Old World hantaviruses, most notably Hantaan virus, is well documented; however, only a few studies have addressed its inhibitory effect on New World hantaviruses. In the present study, we demonstrate that ribavirin is highly active against Andes virus (ANDV), an important etiological agent of HPS, both in vitro and in vivo using a lethal hamster model of HPS. Treatment of ANDV infected Vero E6 cells with ribavirin resulted in dose-dependent reductions in viral RNA and protein as well as virus yields with a half maximal inhibitory concentration between 5 and 12.5 μg ml(-1). In hamsters, treatment with as little as 5 mg kg(-1) day(-1) was 100% effective at preventing lethal HPS disease when therapy was administered by intraperitoneal injection from day 1 through day 10 post-infection. Significant reductions were observed in ANDV RNA and antigen positive cells in lung and liver tissues. Ribavirin remained completely protective when administered by intraperitoneal injections up to three days post-infection. In addition, we show that daily oral ribavirin therapy initiated 1 day post-infection and continuing for ten days is also protective against lethal ANDV disease, even at doses of 5 mg kg(-1) day(-1). Our results suggest ribavirin treatment is beneficial for postexposure prophylaxis against HPS-causing hantaviruses and should be considered in scenarios where exposure to the virus is probable. The similarities between the results obtained in this study and those from previous clinical evaluations of ribavirin against HPS, further validate the hamster model of lethal HPS and demonstrate its usefulness in screening antiviral agents against this disease.