Toward genomic identification of β-barrel membrane proteins: Composition and architecture of known structures

The amino acid composition and architecture of all beta-barrel membrane proteins of known three-dimensional structure have been examined to generate information that will be useful in identifying beta-barrels in genome databases. The database consists of 15 nonredundant structures, including several novel, recent structures. Known structures include monomeric, dimeric, and trimeric beta-barrels with between 8 and 22 membrane-spanning beta-strands each. For this analysis the membrane-interacting surfaces of the beta-barrels were identified with an experimentally derived, whole-residue hydrophobicity scale, and then the barrels were aligned normal to the bilayer and the position of the bilayer midplane was determined for each protein from the hydrophobicity profile. The abundance of each amino acid, relative to the genomic abundance, was calculated for the barrel exterior and interior. The architecture and diversity of known beta-barrels was also examined. For example, the distribution of rise-per-residue values perpendicular to the bilayer plane was found to be 2.7 +/- 0.25 A per residue, or about 10 +/- 1 residues across the membrane. Also, as noted by other authors, nearly every known membrane-spanning beta-barrel strand was found to have a short loop of seven residues or less connecting it to at least one adjacent strand. Using this information we have begun to generate rapid screening algorithms for the identification of beta-barrel membrane proteins in genomic databases. Application of one algorithm to the genomes of Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa confirms its ability to identify beta-barrels, and reveals dozens of unidentified open reading frames that potentially code for beta-barrel outer membrane proteins.     

Estimating the twist of beta-strands embedded within a regular parallel beta-barrel structure

The parallel beta-barrel is a recurrent structural motif found in a large variety of different enzymes belonging to the family of alpha/beta-proteins. It has been shown previously that the hyperboloid can be considered as a scaffold describing the parallel beta-barrel structure. To assess restraints on beta-strand twist imposed by a given scaffold geometry, the notion of scaffold twist, Ts, is introduced. From Ts, the beta-strand twist (Tw beta) expected for a given scaffold geometry can be derived and it is verified that this computed twist can be used to identify beta-barrels characterized by good hydrogen bonding. It is noted that Tw beta is only slightly affected for beta-barrels differing in the number (N) of beta-strands, suggesting that restraints on main-chain conformation of beta-strands are not likely to account for the N = 8 invariability observed in natural parallel beta-barrels thereby strengthening previous work rationalizing this constancy.     

Conformational and geometrical properties of idealized beta-barrels in proteins

An equation for calculating the distances between the atoms involved in forming an idealized hydrogen bond in a parallel or antiparallel beta-barrel has been derived by adjusting the corresponding data given by Pauling and Corey for a beta-sheet. Based on these distances, a geometrical optimization method was developed, by which one can generate various idealized beta-barrels: parallel or antiparallel, tilted or non-tilted, right-tilted or left-tilted. For each type of idealized beta-barrel thus obtained, the corresponding conformation and characteristic geometric parameters as well as their relationship are analyzed and discussed. Since the strand in a tilted beta-barrel traces a curve rather than a straight line on a cylinder-like surface, a regular chain in which the dihedral angles of each residue are the same cannot form a tilted beta-barrel but only a non-tilted beta-barrel. As observed, the strands of a right-tilted beta-barrel possess a very strong right-handed twist. The radii of the idealized tilted parallel and antiparallel beta-barrels are greater than those of the corresponding non-tilted ones by approximately 1 A and approximately 1.5 A, respectively. Consequently, there is relatively more room for a tilted beta-barrel to accommodate the internal side-chains, suggesting that a conformational change from a non-tilted beta-barrel to a tilted one would ease the repulsion among the crowded internal side-chains so as to make the structure more stable. The values of root-mean-square fits indicate that the idealized right-tilted beta-barrels coincide quite well with the observed beta-barrels in both parallel and antiparallel cases.     

Topological diversity of artificial beta-barrels in water

Rigid-rod beta-barrels are composed of interdigitating, short, amphiphilic peptide strands flanked by stabilizing rigid-rod "staves". We here report studies on the topological diversity of these recently devised artificial beta-barrels with regard to their length. For this purpose, homologous p-octiphenyl, p-sexiphenyl, and p-quarterphenyl rods were equipped with complementary tripeptide strands based on the sequences Lys-Leu-Lys and Glu-Leu-Glu. The stability of rigid-rod beta-barrels of different length was determined by denaturation with guanidinium chloride. Free energies of delta GH2O = -5.2 kcalmol-1, delta GH2O = -2.9 kcalmol-1, and delta GH2O < -0.3 kcalmol-1 found for homologous p-octiphenyl, p-sexiphenyl, and p-quarterphenyl beta-barrels demonstrated strong dependence of beta-barrel stability on beta-barrel length. These results revealed a very qualitative minimal (approximately 23 A) and an "ideal" beta-barrel length (approximately 34 A), synergistic formation (alpha = 1.4) and remarkable stability for "ideal" p-octiphenyl beta-barrels exceeding that of several proteins and most synthetic models. Rigid-rod beta-barrels with p-oligophenyl "staves" longer than approximately 34 A will be very difficult to make and study because of rapidly decreasing rod solubilities. However, a strategy to bypass this apparent upper limitation of beta-barrel length is introduced: supramolecular matching of mismatched rods yielded elongated beta-barrels (61 A) of acceptable stability (delta GH2O = 2.2 - 3.1 kcalmol-1).     

Tilt, twist, and coiling in beta-barrel membrane proteins: relation to infrared dichroism

The x-ray coordinates of beta-barrel transmembrane proteins from the porins superfamily and relatives are used to calculate the mean tilt of the beta-strands and their mean local twist and coiling angles. The 13 proteins examined correspond to beta-barrels with 8 to 22 strands, and shear numbers ranging from 8 to 24. The results are compared with predictions from the model of Murzin, Lesk, and Chothia for symmetrical regular barrels. Good agreement is found for the mean strand tilt, but the twist angles are smaller than those for open beta-sheets and beta-barrels with shorter strands. The model is reparameterised to account for the reduced twist characteristic of long-stranded transmembrane beta-barrels. This produces predictions of both twist and coiling angles that are in agreement with the mean values obtained from the x-ray structures. With the optimized parameters, the model can then be used to determine twist and coiling angles of transmembrane beta-barrels from measurements of the amide band infrared dichroism in oriented membranes. Satisfactory agreement is obtained for OmpF. The strand tilt obtained from the x-ray coordinates, or from the reparameterised model, can be combined with infrared dichroism measurements to obtain information on the orientation of the beta-barrel assembly in the membrane.     

A comprehensive analysis of the Greek key motifs in protein beta-barrels and beta-sandwiches

The Greek key motifs are the topological signature of many beta-barrels and a majority of beta-sandwich structures. An updated survey of these structures integrates many early observations and newly emerging patterns and provides a better understanding of the unique role of Greek keys in protein structures. A stereotypical Greek key beta-barrel accommodates five or six strands and can have 12 possible topologies. All except one six-stranded topologies have been observed, and only one five-stranded topologies have been seen in actual structures. Of the representative beta-barrel structures analyzed here, half have left-handed Greek keys. This result challenges the empirical claim of the handedness regularity of Greek keys in beta-barrels. One of the five-stranded topologies that has not been observed in beta-barrels comprises two overlapping Greek keys. The two three-dimensional forms of this topology constitute a structural unit that is present in a vast majority of known beta-sandwich structures. Using this unit as the root, we have built a new taxonomy tree for the beta-sandwich folds and deduced a set of rules that appear to constrain how other beta-strands adjoin the unit to form a larger double-layered structure. These rules, though derived from a larger data set, are essentially the same as those drawn from earlier studies, suggesting that they may reflect the true topological constraints in the design of beta-sandwich structures. Finally, a novel variant of the Greek key motif (defined here as the twisted Greek key) has emerged which introduces loop crossings into the folded structures. Proteins 2000;40:409-419.     

The structure of bacterial outer membrane proteins

Integral membrane proteins come in two types, alpha-helical and beta-barrel proteins. In both types, all hydrogen bonding donors and acceptors of the polypeptide backbone are completely compensated and buried while nonpolar side chains point to the membrane. The alpha-helical type is more abundant and occurs in cytoplasmic (or inner) membranes, whereas the beta-barrels are known from outer membranes of bacteria. The beta-barrel construction is described by the number of strands and the shear number, which is a measure for the inclination angle of the beta-strands against the barrel axis. The common right-handed beta-twist requires shear numbers slightly larger than the number of strands. Membrane protein beta-barrels contain between 8 and 22 beta-strands and have a simple topology that is probably enforced by the folding process. The smallest barrels form inverse micelles and work as enzymes or they bind to other macromolecules. The medium-range barrels form more or less specific pores for nutrient uptake, whereas the largest barrels occur in active Fe(2+) transporters. The beta-barrels are suitable objects for channel engineering, because the structures are simple and because many of these proteins can be produced into inclusion bodies and recovered therefrom in the exact native conformation.     

Transbilayer pores formed by beta-barrels: molecular modeling of pore structures and properties.

Transmembrane beta-barrels, first observed in bacterial porins, are possible models for a number of membrane channels. Restrained molecular dynamics simulations based on idealized C alpha beta templates have been used to generate models of such beta-barrels. Model beta-barrels have been analyzed in terms of their conformational, energetic, and pore properties. Model beta-barrels formed by N = 4, 8, 12 and 16 anti-parallel Ala10 strands have been developed. For each N, beta-barrels with shear numbers S = N to 2N have been modeled. In all beta-barrel models the constituent beta-strands adopt a pronounced right-handed twist. Interstrand interactions are of approximately equal stability for all models with N > or = 8, whereas such interactions are weaker for the N = 4 beta-barrels. In N = 4 beta-barrels the pore is too narrow (minimum radius approximately 0.6 A) to allow ion permeation. For N > or = 8, the pore radius depends on both N and S; for a given value of N an increase in S from N to 2N is predicted to result in an approximately threefold increase in pore conductance. Calculated maximal conductances for the beta-barrel models are compared with experimental values for porins and for K+ channels.     

Energetics of the structure and chain tilting of antiparallel beta-barrels in proteins

The preferred structural pattern of antiparallel beta-barrels in proteins, described as the right-handed tilting of the peptide strands with respect to the axis of the barrel, is accounted for in terms of intra- and interchain interaction energies. It is related to the preference of beta-sheets for right-handed twisting. Conformational energy computations have been carried out on three eight-stranded antiparallel beta-barrels composed of six-residue strands, in which L-Val and Gly alternate, and having a right-handed, a left-handed, or no tilt. After energy minimization, the relative energies of these structures were 0.0, 8.6, and 46.1 kcal/mol, respectively; i.e., the right-tilted beta-barrel is favored energetically, in agreement with anti-parallel beta-barrels observed in proteins. Tilting of the barrel is favored, relative to the nontilted structure, by both intra- and interstrand interactions, because tilting allows better packing of the bulky side chains. On the other hand, the energy difference between the left- and right-tilted barrels arises essentially from intrachain interactions. This is a consequence of the preference of beta-sheets for a right-handed twist. Space limitations inside the barrel are satisfied if there is an alternation of bulky residues and residues with small or no side chain (preferably Gly) in neighboring positions on adjacent strands. Such a pattern is seen frequently in antiparallel beta-barrels of globular proteins. The computations indicate that a structure with Val...Gly pairs can be accommodated in a beta-barrel with no distortion.     

Comparison of the hemocyanin beta-barrel with other Greek key beta-barrels: possible importance of the "beta-zipper" in protein structure and folding.

The Greek key beta-barrel topology is a folding motif observed in many proteins of widespread evolutionary origin. The arthropodan hemocyanins also have such a Greek key beta-barrel, which forms the core of the third domain of this protein. The hemocyanin beta-barrel was found to be structurally very similar to the beta-barrels of the immunoglobulin domains, Cu,Zn-superoxide dismutase and the chromophore carrying antitumor proteins. The structural similarity within this group of protein families is not accompanied by an evolutionary or functional relationship. It is therefore possible to study structure-sequence relations without bias from nonstructural constraints. The present study reports a conserved pattern of features in these Greek key beta-barrels that is strongly suggestive of a folding nucleation site. This proposed nucleation site, which we call a "beta-zipper," shows a pattern of well-conserved, large hydrophobic residues on two sequential beta-strands joined by a short loop. Each beta-zipper strand is near the center of one of the beta-sheets, so that the two strands face each other from opposite sides of the barrel and interact through their hydrophobic side chains, rather than forming a hydrogen-bonded beta-hairpin. Other protein families with Greek key beta-barrels that do not as strongly resemble the immunoglobulin fold--such as the azurins, plastocyanins, crystallins, and prealbumins--also contain the beta-zipper pattern, which might therefore be a universal feature of Greek key beta-barrel proteins.     

The design of idealized alpha/beta-barrels: analysis of beta-sheet closure requirements

The 8-fold parallel alpha/beta-barrel topology is encountered in proteins that display an impressive variety of functions, suggesting that this topology may be a rather nonspecific and stable folding motif. Consequently, this motif can be considered as an interesting framework to design novel proteins. It has been shown that the shape of the beta-sheet portion of the barrel can be approximated by a hyperboloid. This geometric object may therefore be used as a scaffold to construct an idealized eight-stranded beta-barrel. To facilitate the de novo design of such structures, a collection of modeling tools has been developed allowing secondary structure elements to be mapped onto the scaffold surface and rotation and translation operations to be performed about user defined axes while evaluating their contribution to the conformational energy of the system. These tools have been applied in a systematic study assessing the phi, psi requirements to design symmetric eight stranded beta barrels with optimal hydrogen bonding between adjacent beta-strands. It is observed that: (a) the beta-sheet structure can be closed without introducing irregular stagger between beta-strands and (b) the region of phi, psi dihedral angle space compatible with the formation of regular symmetric eight stranded beta-barrels coincides with the phi, psi region corresponding to average beta-strands in known protein structures, suggesting that barrel closure does not impose gross constraints on beta-strand geometry.     

Chaperones: inserting beta barrels into membranes

How beta-barrel proteins are inserted into cellular membranes is poorly understood. New work has identified a sorting and assembly machinery that chaperones beta-barrels into the mitochondrial outer membrane and is evolutionarily conserved from bacteria to man.     

Origami in the outer membrane: the transmembrane arrangement of mitochondrial porins.

Voltage-dependent anion-selective channels (VDAC), also known as mitochondrial porins, are key regulators of metabolite flow across the mitochondrial outer membrane. Porins from a wide variety of organisms share remarkably similar electrophysiological properties, in spite of considerable sequence dissimilarity, indicating that they share a common structure. Based on primary sequence considerations, analogy with bacterial porins, and circular dichroism analysis, it is agreed that VDAC spans the outer membrane as a beta-barrel. However, the residues that form the antiparallel beta-strands comprising this barrel remain unknown. Various predictive methods, largely based on the known structures of bacterial beta-barrels, have been applied to the primary sequences of VDAC. Refinement and confirmation of these predictions have developed through numerous investigations of wild-type and variant porins, both in mitochondria and in artificial membranes. These experiments have involved VDAC from several sources, precluding the generation of a unified model. Herein, using the Neurospora VDAC sequence as a template, the published structural information and predictions have been reassessed to delineate a model that satisfies most of the available data.     

Gene duplication of the eight-stranded beta-barrel OmpX produces a functional pore: a scenario for the evolution of transmembrane beta-barrels

The repeating unit of outer membrane beta-barrels from Gram-negative bacteria is the beta-hairpin, and representatives of this protein family always have an even strand number between eight and 22. Two dominant structural forms have eight and 16 strands, respectively, suggesting gene duplication as a possible mechanism for their evolution. We duplicated the sequence of OmpX, an eight-stranded beta-barrel protein of known structure, and obtained a beta-barrel, designated Omp2X, which can fold in vitro and in vivo. Using single-channel conductance measurements and PEG exclusion assays, we found that Omp2X has a pore size similar to that of OmpC, a natural 16-stranded barrel. Fusions of the homologous proteins OmpX, OmpA and OmpW were able to fold in vitro in all combinations tested, revealing that the general propensity to form a beta-barrel is sufficient to evolve larger barrels by simple genetic events.     

Folding kinetics of the outer membrane proteins OmpA and FomA into phospholipid bilayers

The folding mechanism of outer membrane proteins (OMPs) of Gram-negative bacteria into lipid bilayers has been studied using OmpA of E. coli and FomA of F. nucleatum as examples. Both, OmpA and FomA are soluble in unfolded form in urea and insert and fold into phospholipid bilayers upon strong dilution of the denaturant urea. OmpA is a structural protein and forms a small ion channel, composed of an 8-stranded transmembrane beta-barrel domain. FomA is a voltage-dependent porin, predicted to form a 14 stranded beta-barrel. Both OMPs fold into a range of model membranes of very different phospholipid compositions. Three membrane-bound folding intermediates of OmpA were discovered in folding studies with dioleoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers that demonstrated a highly synchronized mechanism of secondary and tertiary structure formation of beta-barrel membrane proteins. A study on FomA folding into lipid bilayers indicated the presence of parallel folding pathways for OMPs with larger transmembrane beta-barrels.     

Protein secretion and outer membrane assembly in Alphaproteobacteria

The assembly of beta-barrel proteins into membranes is a fundamental process that is essential in Gram-negative bacteria, mitochondria and plastids. Our understanding of the mechanism of beta-barrel assembly is progressing from studies carried out in Escherichia coli and Neisseria meningitidis. Comparative sequence analysis suggests that while many components mediating beta-barrel protein assembly are conserved in all groups of bacteria with outer membranes, some components are notably absent. The Alphaproteobacteria in particular seem prone to gene loss and show the presence or absence of specific components mediating the assembly of beta-barrels: some components of the pathway appear to be missing from whole groups of bacteria (e.g. Skp, YfgL and NlpB), other proteins are conserved but are missing characteristic domains (e.g. SurA). This comparative analysis is also revealing important structural signatures that are vague unless multiple members from a protein family are considered as a group (e.g. tetratricopeptide repeat (TPR) motifs in YfiO, beta-propeller signatures in YfgL). Given that the process of the beta-barrel assembly is conserved, analysis of outer membrane biogenesis in Alphaproteobacteria, the bacterial group that gave rise to mitochondria, also promises insight into the assembly of beta-barrel proteins in eukaryotes.     

Outer surface modification of synthetic multifunctional pores

The characteristics of pores formed by p-octiphenyl beta-barrels with LWV triads at the outer surface are reported in comparison with the conventional rigid-rod beta-barrels with all-L outer surface. Maintained multifunctionality of tetrameric pores with external LWV triads (inversion of ion selectivity, molecular recognition and transformation) is implicative for intact barrel interior. Increased pore activity supports dominance of high bilayer affinity for W over low affinity for V. Transmembrane p-octiphenyl orientation (from fluorescence depth quenching) supports barrel-stave (rather than toroidal) pores and dominance of transmembrane preference of rigid rods over interfacial preference of W. Destabilization of beta-barrel pores in membranes (from short single-channel lifetimes) and in the media (from 4th-power dependence on monomer concentration) by LWV triads supports dominance of low beta-propensity for W over high beta-propensity for V. The relation between the stability of supramolecular (pre)pores and dependence of activity on monomer concentration is discussed in a more general context.     

Asymmetric amino acid compositions of transmembrane beta-strands

In contrast to water-soluble proteins, membrane proteins reside in a heterogeneous environment, and their surfaces must interact with both polar and apolar membrane regions. As a consequence, the composition of membrane proteins' residues varies substantially between the membrane core and the interfacial regions. The amino acid compositions of helical membrane proteins are also known to be different on the cytoplasmic and extracellular sides of the membrane. Here we report that in the 16 transmembrane beta-barrel structures, the amino acid compositions of lipid-facing residues are different near the N and C termini of the individual strands. Polar amino acids are more prevalent near the C termini than near the N termini, and hydrophobic amino acids show the opposite trend. We suggest that this difference arises because it is easier for polar atoms to escape from the apolar regions of the bilayer at the C terminus of a beta-strand. This new characteristic of beta-barrel membrane proteins enhances our understanding of how a sequence encodes a membrane protein structure and should prove useful in identifying and predicting the structures of trans-membrane beta-barrels.     

FhuA barrel-cork hybrids are active transporters and receptors

The crystal structure of Escherichia coli FhuA reveals a beta-barrel domain that is closed by a globular cork domain. It has been assumed that the proton motive force of the cytoplasmic membrane through the interaction of the TonB protein with the TonB box of the cork opens the FhuA channel. Yet, deletion of the cork results in an FhuA derivative, FhuADelta5-160, that still displays TonB-dependent substrate transport and phage receptor activity. To investigate this unexpected finding further, we constructed FhuADelta5-160 derivatives of FhuA proteins from Salmonella paratyphi B, Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium, and Pantoea agglomerans. The FhuADelta5-160 proteins inserted correctly into the outer membrane, and with the exception of the P. agglomerans protein, transported ferrichrome and albomycin. FhuA hybrids consisting of the beta-barrel of one strain and the cork of another strain were active and showed higher TonB-dependent ferrichrome transport rates than the corkless derivatives. Exceptions were the E. coli beta-barrel/Salmonella serovar Typhimurium cork hybrid protein and the Salmonella serovar Typhimurium beta-barrel/P. agglomerans cork hybrid protein, both of which were less active than the beta-barrels alone. Each of the FhuA mutant proteins displayed activity for each of their ligands, except for phage T5, only when coupled to TonB. The hybrid FhuA proteins displayed a similar activity with the E. coli TonB protein as with their cognate TonB proteins. Sensitivity to phages T1, T5, and phi80, rifamycin CGP 4832, and colicin M was determined by the beta-barrel, whereas sensitivity to phage ES18 and microcin J25 required both the beta-barrel and cork domains. These results demonstrate that the beta-barrel domain of FhuA confers activity and specificity and responds to TonB and that the cork domains of various FhuA proteins can be interchanged and contribute to the activities of the FhuA hybrids.     

Structure of the Haemophilus influenzae HMW1B translocator protein: evidence for a twin pore

Secretion of the Haemophilus influenzae HMW1 adhesin occurs via the two-partner secretion pathway and requires the HMW1B outer membrane translocator. HMW1B has been subjected to extensive biochemical studies to date. However, direct examination of the structure of HMW1B has been lacking, leaving fundamental questions about the oligomeric state, the membrane-embedded beta-barrel domain, the approximate size of the beta-barrel pore, and the mechanism of translocator activity. In the current study, examination of purified HMW1B by size exclusion chromatography and negative staining electron microscopy revealed that the predominant species was a dimer. In the presence of lipid, purified HMW1B formed two-dimensional crystalline sheets. Examination of these crystals by cryo-electron microscopy allowed determination of a projection structure of HMW1B to 10 A resolution. The native HMW1B structure is a dimer of beta-barrels, with each beta-barrel measuring 40 A by 50 A in the two orthogonal directions and appearing largely occluded, leaving only a narrow pore. These observations suggest that HMW1B undergoes a large conformational change during translocation of the 125-kDa HMW1 adhesin.