Down-regulation of Transforming Growth Factor-β Receptors: Cooperativity between the Types I, II, and III Receptors and Modulation at the Cell Surface

The types I, II, and III receptors (RI, RII, RIII) for transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) become down-regulated in response to ligand, presumably via their internalization from the cell surface. This report examines the down-regulation of full-length RI, RII, and RIII in cells endogenously or transiently expressing these receptors. Down-regulation occurred rapidly (within 2 h after TGF-β1 treatment at 37°C) and showed a dose response, between 10 and 200 pM TGF-β1, in cells expressing RI, RII, and RIII (Mv1lu and A549 cells). A comparison between Mv1Lu and mutant cell derivatives R-1B (lacking RI) or DR-26 (lacking RII) indicated that all three receptors were necessary for efficient down-regulation. Down-regulation experiments, utilizing TGF-β-treated 293 cells transiently expressing different combinations of these receptors indicated that neither RII or RIII were down-regulated when expressed alone and that RI was required for maximal down-regulation of RII. RII and RIII were partially down-regulated when these receptors were coexpressed in the absence of RI (in R-1B and 293 cells). Surprisingly, TGF-β receptors were partially down-regulated in Mv1Lu, A549, and 293 cells treated with TGF-β1 at 4°C. Microscopic examination of 293 cells coexpressing RI fused to green fluorescent protein (RI–GFP) and RII indicated that, after treatment with TGF-β1 at 4°C, RI–GFP formed aggregates at the cell surface at this temperature. RI–GFP was not detected at the surface of these cells after TGF-β1 treatment at 37°C. Our results suggest a two phase mechanism for TGF-β1 receptor down-regulation involving receptor modulation (aggregation) at the cell surface and internalization.     

Transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta 1 internalization: modulation by ligand interaction with TGF-beta receptors types I and II and a mechanism that is distinct from clathrin-mediated endocytosis

Transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) internalization was studied by monitoring the uptake of (125)I-TGF-beta1 in Mv1Lu cells, which endogenously express TGF-beta receptors types I (RI), II (RII), and III (RIII), and 293 cells transfected with RI and RII. At 37 degrees C internalization occurred rapidly, within 10 min of ligand addition. Internalization was optimal in 293 cells expressing both RI and RII. Internalization was prevented by phenylarsine oxide, a nonspecific inhibitor of receptor internalization, but was not affected by reagents that interfere with clathrin-mediated endocytosis such as monodansylcadaverine, K44A dynamin, and inhibitors of endosomal acidification. Electron microscopic examination of Mv1Lu cells treated with (125)I- TGF-beta1 at 37 degrees C indicated that internalization occurred via a noncoated vesicular mechanism. Internalization was prevented by prebinding cells with TGF-beta1 at 4 degrees C for 2 h prior to switching the cells to 37 degrees C. This was attributed to a loss of receptor binding, as indicated by a rapid decrease in the amount of TGF-beta1 bound to the cell surface at 37 degrees C and by a reduction in the labeling intensities of RI and RII in (125)I-TGF-beta1-cross-linking experiments. Mv1Lu or 293 (RI+RII) cells, prebound with TGF-beta1 at 4 degrees C and subsequently stripped of ligand by an acid wash, nevertheless initiated a signaling response upon transfer to 37 degrees C, suggesting that prebinding promotes formation of stable RI.RII complexes that can signal independently of ligand.     

Predominant intracellular localization of the type I transforming growth factor-beta receptor and increased nuclear accumulation after growth arrest

Transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) signaling requires the functional interaction of two distinct receptors, type I (RI) and type II (RII), at the cell surface. Exposure of cells to TGF-beta results in receptor internalization and down-regulation (Zwaagstra et al., 1999, Exp. Cell Res. 252, 352362); however, little is known about the subsequent fate of RI or RII. In this study the cellular distribution of RI was examined in cells before and after treatment with ligand. RI was localized by immunocytochemistry and confocal microscopy using two polyclonal antisera directed against two different epitopes, one in the C-terminal region and one in the N-terminal region of the cytoplasmic domain. The majority of RI molecules in untreated MvlLu and A549 cells were found to be intracellular. Treatment of MvlLu and A549 cells with 100 pM TGF-beta1 for 24 h at 37 degrees C caused a redistribution of surface RI on MvlLu cells, as evidenced by surface RI aggregation. Unexpectedly, this TGF-beta1 treatment also caused redistribution and accumulation of intracellular RI in and around the nucleus for both MvlLu and A549 cells. Nuclear accumulation of RI was also promoted independently of ligand receptor activation by treatment of MvlLu cells with olomoucine, an agent that results in growth arrest. The capacity of RI to localize in the nucleus was confirmed by microscopic examination of 293 cells transiently expressing RI fused to green fluorescent protein (RI-GFP). Olomoucine treatment of these cells resulted in the movement of RI-GFP into the nucleus. Our results indicate that growth arrest alters intracellular transport/routing of RI and may indicate that RI functions not only at the cell surface but inside the cell as well.     

Equilibrium model for insulin-induced receptor down-regulation. Regulation of insulin receptors in differentiated BC3H-1 myocytes

The mechanism of insulin-induced down-regulation of surface membrane insulin receptors was studied in the muscle cell line BC3H-1. Down-regulation for the differentiated myocytes is dose- and time-dependent with a half-maximum response at 0.5 nM insulin and a maximum decrease of 50% in the number of surface insulin receptors following exposure to 20 nM insulin for 18 h at 37 degrees C, as confirmed by Scatchard analysis. These receptors were fully recoverable upon lysis of the down-regulated myocyte with Triton X-100, demonstrating that down-regulation is mediated solely by insulin-induced receptor internalization without detectable receptor degradation. Phospholipase C treatment of intact down-regulated cells and Triton X-100 treatment after subcellular fractionation showed that no cryptic or masked receptors were detectable within the plasma membrane. Insulin-induced receptor internalization was dependent upon cellular energy production, protein synthesis, and endocytosis, but was insensitive to agents which primarily affect lysosomal, cytoskeletal, or transglutaminase activities. The magnitude of insulin-induced down-regulation and the kinetics of down-regulation and recovery of cell surface receptors indicate that the surface and internal receptor pools are in dynamic equilibrium with each other. The kinetic data are accommodated by separate internalization rate constants for the unoccupied (0.01 h-1) and occupied (0.11 h-1) surface receptors and a single recycling rate constant (0.11 h-1) for the internalized receptors. This model also explains the previous apparently paradoxical finding in several other systems that down-regulation is more sensitive to hormone than hormone-receptor binding under physiologic conditions. Down-regulation in BC3H-1 myocytes, therefore, appears to be mediated solely by an insulin-induced increase in the receptor internalization rate constant and a consequent shift in the dynamic equilibrium between the surface and internalized receptor pools, resulting in a 50% decrease in the number of cell surface receptors. In other systems where the internalized hormone receptor is a substrate for rapid degradation, the essential role of this shift in mediating the down-regulation process may be obscured.     

Analysis of the contribution of receptor subdomains to the cooperative binding and internalization of transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) type I and type II receptors

The mechanistic basis underlying the striking cooperativity observed for the assembly of TGF-β family ligand/receptor complexes is not well understood. We report here an investigation in which we used a novel ligand sequestration assay, in combination with immunofluorescent light microscopy and flow cytometry analyses, to examine and quantify cooperative assembly of TGF-β ligand/receptor complexes on the cell surface, as well as ligand/receptor complex internalization. We analyzed the roles played by the ecto/transmembrane (ecto/TM) domains and endodomains of RI and RII TGF-β receptors in these processes by transfecting 293 or HeLa cells with different combinations of receptor mutants. We found that the ecto/TM domains of RII and RI cooperated together to promote the formation of cell surface receptor/ligand complexes. Furthermore, in agreement with the recently determined structure of the TGF-β3/RII ectodomain/RI ectodomain complex [J. Groppe, C.S. Hinck, P. Samavarchi-Tehrani, C. Zubieta, J.P. Schuermann, A.B. Taylor, P.M. Schwarz, J.L. Wrana, A.P. Hinck, Cooperative assembly of TGF-beta superfamily signaling complexes is mediated by two disparate mechanisms and distinct modes of receptor binding, Mol. Cell 29 (2008) 157–168], we observed that the N-terminus of the RII ectodomain was required for full assembly. With respect to endodomains, we found that the RI endodomain enhanced cooperative complex assembly at the cell surface, whereas both the RI and RII endodomains enhanced internalization. Finally, we observed that ligand/receptor internalization, but not complex assembly at the cell surface, was partly raft-dependent. In light of these results, currently proposed mechanisms of cooperative ligand/receptor assembly are discussed.     

Differential expression of transforming growth factor-beta receptors in a rabbit zone II flexor tendon wound healing model

Flexor tendon repair in zone II is complicated by adhesions that impair normal postoperative gliding. Transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) is a family of growth factors that has been implicated in scar formation. The TGF-beta family of proteins binds to three distinct classes of membrane receptors, termed RI, RII, and RIII. In this study, we analyzed the temporal and spatial distribution of TGF-beta receptor isoforms (RI, RII, and RIII) in a rabbit zone II flexor tendon wound healing model.Twenty-eight adult New Zealand White rabbit forepaws underwent isolation of the middle digit flexor digitorum profundus tendon in zone II. The tendons underwent transection in zone II and immediate repair. The tendons were harvested at increasing time points: 1, 3, 7, 14, 28, and 56 days postoperatively (n = 4 at each time point). The control flexor tendons were harvested without transection and repair (n = 4). Immunohistochemical analysis was used to detect the expression patterns for TGF-beta receptors RI, RII, and RIII.Immunohistochemical staining of the transected and repaired tendons demonstrated up-regulation of TGF-beta RI, RII, and RIII protein levels. TGF-beta receptor production in the experimental group (transection and repair) was concentrated in the epitenon and along the repair site. Furthermore, the TGF-beta receptor expression levels peaked at day 14 and decreased by day 56 postoperatively. In contrast, minimal receptor expression was observed in the untransected and unrepaired control tendons.These data provide evidence that (1) TGF-beta receptors are up-regulated after injury and repair; (2) peak levels of TGF-beta receptor expression occurred at day 14 and decreased by day 56 after wounding and repair; and (3) both the tendon sheath and epitenon have the highest receptor expression, and both may play critical roles in flexor tendon wound healing. Understanding the up-regulation of TGF-beta isoforms and the up-regulation of their corresponding receptors during flexor tendon wound healing provides new targets for biomolecular modulation of postoperative scar formation.     

Endocytosis of the type III transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) receptor through the clathrin-independent/lipid raft pathway regulates TGF-beta signaling and receptor down-regulation

Transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) signals through three highly conserved cell surface receptors, the type III TGF-beta receptor (T beta RIII), the type II TGF-beta receptor (T beta RII), and the type I TGF-beta receptor (T beta RI) to regulate diverse cellular processes including cell proliferation, differentiation, migration, and apoptosis. Although T beta RI and T beta RII undergo ligand-independent endocytosis by both clathrin-mediated endocytosis, resulting in enhanced signaling, and clathrin-independent endocytosis, resulting in receptor degradation, the mechanism and function of T beta RIII endocytosis is poorly understood. T beta RIII is a heparan sulfate proteoglycan with a short cytoplasmic tail that functions as a TGF-beta superfamily co-receptor, contributing to TGF-beta signaling through mechanisms yet to be fully defined. We have reported previously that T beta RIII endocytosis, mediated by a novel interaction with beta arrestin-2, results in decreased TGF-beta signaling. Here we demonstrate that T beta RIII undergoes endocytosis in a ligand and glycosaminoglycan modification-independent and cytoplasmic domain-dependent manner, with the interaction of Thr-841 in the cytoplasmic domain of T beta RIII with beta-arrestin2 enhancing T beta RIII endocytosis. T beta RIII undergoes both clathrin-mediated and clathrin-independent endocytosis. Importantly, inhibition of the clathrin-independent, lipid raft pathway, but not of the clathrin-dependent pathway, results in decreased TGF-beta1 induced Smad2 and p38 phosphorylation, supporting a specific role for clathrin-independent endocytosis of T beta RIII in regulating both Smad-dependent and Smad-independent TGF-beta signaling.     

Enhancement of the antagonistic potency of transforming growth factor-beta receptor extracellular domains by coiled coil-induced homo- and heterodimerization

Transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) plays a causal role in several human pathologies including fibrotic diseases and metastasis. TGF-beta signaling is mediated through its interaction with three types of cell surface receptors, RI, RII, and RIII. The soluble ectodomains of RII and RIII bind to TGF-beta, making them attractive candidates to sequester TGF-beta and inhibit its activity. To optimize the activity of the ectodomains, we studied the effect of artificially dimerizing them upon their kinetics of binding to TGF-beta using an optical biosensor and studied their antagonistic potencies using an in vitro signaling assay. We fused the RII ectodomain and the membrane-proximal ligand-binding domain of the RIII ectodomain to de novo designed heterodimerizing coil strands and demonstrated that the coil strands within the fusion proteins were capable of promoting the dimerization of the coil-tagged ectodomains. Our results indicate that coiled coil-induced dimerization of the ectodomains stabilized their interaction with TGF-beta as compared with the monomeric ectodomains. Also, in contrast to the monomeric ectodomains, which did not block signaling, the coiled coil-induced dimers were characterized by antagonistic potencies in the low nanomolar range.     

Role of the rate of internalization of the agonist-receptor complex on the agonist-induced down-regulation of the lutropin/choriogonadotropin receptor.

The extent of agonist-induced down-regulation of the LH/CG receptor (LHR) in human kidney 293 cells transfected with the rat LHR (rLHR) is much lower than in two Leydig tumor cell lines (MA-10 and R2C) that express the rodent LHR endogenously. This difference can not be attributed to differences in the recycling of internalized receptors, or in the replenishment of new receptors at the cell surface. It can be correlated, however, with the half-life of internalization of the bound agonist, which is approximately 60 min in Leydig tumor cells and about 100 min in transfected 293 cells. To determine whether the rate of internalization of the bound agonist affects down-regulation, we compared these two parameters in 293 cells expressing four rLHR mutants that enhance internalization and three mutants that impair internalization. We show that all four mutations of the rLHR that enhanced internalization enhanced down-regulation, while only one of the three mutations that impaired internalization impaired down-regulation. In addition, cotransfections of 293 cells with the rLHR-wt and three constructs that enhanced internalization (G protein-coupled receptor kinase 2, beta-arrestin, and arrestin-3) increased down-regulation, while a related construct (visual arrestin) that had no effect on internalization also had no effect on down-regulation. We conclude that the rate of internalization of the agonist-LHR complex is the main determinant of the extent of down-regulation of the LHR.     

Responsiveness to transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) restored by genetic complementation between cells defective in TGF-beta receptors I and II.

Selection of mutant Mv1Lu mink lung epithelial cells resistant to growth inhibition by transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) has led to the isolation of cell clones with distinct alterations in type I and II TGF-beta receptors. Certain mutant clones present a decreased number or complete loss of detectable type I receptor. Other clones show a loss and/or altered electrophoretic mobility of the type II receptor, with concomitant loss of the type I receptor. Using somatic cell hybridization analysis we demonstrate the recessive nature of these mutants with respect to the wild-type phenotype and define various mutant complementation groups. Among these, hybrids between cells that express only type II receptor (R mutants) and cells that express neither receptor type (DRa mutants) rescue wild-type expression of type I receptors. Moreover, these hybrids regain full responsiveness to TGF-beta 1, as measured by inhibition of DNA synthesis as well as stimulation of fibronectin and plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 production. These results provide evidence for an interaction between TGF-beta receptor components I and II and show that, in Mv1Lu cells, expression of both receptor types is required for mediation of biological responses to TGF-beta 1.     

Morphology of the surface of normal and virus transformed cells in vitro]

The cell surface morphology of two cell lines--from the mink lung (Mv1Lu) and from the Kirsten sarcoma virus transformed derivate (Ki-Mv1Lu)--was studied by scanning electron microscopy. Marked differences are seen in cell morphology of these two lines at high cell densities. Mv1Lu cells at high densities had uniform flat polygonal shape with microvilli at their surface. A marked diversity in cell morphology was characteristic of Ki-Mv1Lu cells at comparable cell densities: variation in shape, in thickness degrees, and in the expression of cell surface ultrastructure (microvilli, blebs, filopodia). No dependence of Ki-Mv1Lu cell morphology from cell densities was observed. At low cell densities of Mv1Lu cells, cells with the morphology differing from the typical pattern of confluent Mv1Lu cells were seen. Morphological diversity of these cells was comparable with that of Ki-Mv1Lu cells. Nothing has been found in cell surface morphology that could be absolutely specific for transformed cells only.     

The mannose 6-phosphate/insulin-like growth factor-II receptor is a substrate of type V transforming growth factor-beta receptor.

The type V transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) receptor (TbetaR-V) is a ligand-stimulated acidotropic Ser-specific protein kinase that recognizes a motif of SXE/S(P)/D. This motif is present in the cytoplasmic domain of the mannose 6-phosphate/insulin-like growth factor-II (Man-6-P/IGF-II) receptor. We have explored the possibility that the Man-6-P/IGF-II receptor is a substrate of TbetaR-V. Purified bovine Man-6-P/IGF-II receptor was phosphorylated by purified bovine TbetaR-V in the presence of [gamma-32P]ATP and MnCl2 with an apparent Km of 130 nM. TGF-beta stimulated the phosphorylation of the Man-6-P/IGF-II receptor at 0 degrees C in mouse L cells overexpressing the Man-6-P/IGF-II receptor and in wild-type mink lung epithelial (Mv1Lu cells) metabolically labeled with [32P]orthophosphate. The in vitro and in vivo phosphorylation of the Man-6-P/IGF-II receptor occurred at the putative phosphorylation sites as revealed by phosphopeptide mapping and amino acid sequence analysis. TGF-beta stimulated Man-6-P/IGF-II receptor-mediated uptake (approximately 2-fold after 12 h treatment) of exogenous beta-glucuronidase in Mv1Lu cells and type II TGF-beta receptor (TbetaR-II)-defective mutant cells (DR26 cells) but not in type I TGF-beta receptor (TbetaR-I)-defective mutant cells (R-1B cells) and human colorectal carcinoma cells (RII-37 cells) expressing TbetaR-I and TbetaR-II but lacking TbetaR-V. These results suggest the Man-6-P/IGF-II receptor serves as an in vitro and in vivo substrate of TbetaR-V and that both TbetaR-V and TbetaR-I may play a role in mediating the TGF-beta-stimulated uptake of exogenous beta-glucuronidase.     

ALK1 regulates the internalization of endoglin and the type III TGF-β receptor

Complex formation and endocytosis of transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β) receptors play important roles in signaling. However, their interdependence remained unexplored. Here, we demonstrate that ALK1, a TGF-β type I receptor prevalent in endothelial cells, forms stable complexes at the cell surface with endoglin and with type III TGF-β receptors (TβRIII). We show that ALK1 undergoes clathrin-mediated endocytosis (CME) faster than ALK5, type II TGF-β receptor (TβRII), endoglin, or TβRIII. These complexes regulate the endocytosis of the TGF-β receptors, with a major effect mediated by ALK1. Thus, ALK1 enhances the endocytosis of TβRIII and endoglin, while ALK5 and TβRII mildly enhance endoglin, but not TβRIII, internalization. Conversely, the slowly endocytosed endoglin has no effect on the endocytosis of either ALK1, ALK5, or TβRII, while TβRIII has a differential effect, slowing the internalization of ALK5 and TβRII, but not ALK1. Such effects may be relevant to signaling, as BMP9-mediated Smad1/5/8 phosphorylation is inhibited by CME blockade in endothelial cells. We propose a model that links TGF-β receptor oligomerization and endocytosis, based on which endocytosis signals are exposed/functional in specific receptor complexes. This has broad implications for signaling, implying that complex formation among various receptors regulates their surface levels and signaling intensities.     

SPARC inhibits epithelial cell proliferation in part through stimulation of the transforming growth factor-beta-signaling system

Secreted protein, acidic and rich in cysteine (SPARC) is a multifunctional secreted protein that regulates cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions, leading to alterations in cell adhesion, motility, and proliferation. Although SPARC is expressed in epithelial cells, its ability to regulate epithelial cell growth remains largely unknown. We show herein that SPARC strongly inhibited DNA synthesis in transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta-sensitive Mv1Lu cells, whereas moderately inhibiting that in TGF-beta-insensitive Mv1Lu cells (i.e., R1B cells). Overexpression of dominant-negative Smad3 in Mv1Lu cells, which abrogated growth arrest by TGF-beta, also attenuated growth arrest stimulated by SPARC. Moreover, the extracellular calcium-binding domain of SPARC (i.e., SPARC-EC) was sufficient to inhibit Mv1Lu cell proliferation but not that of R1B cells. Similar to TGF-beta and thrombospondin-1, treatment of Mv1Lu cells with SPARC or SPARC-EC stimulated Smad2 phosphorylation and Smad2/3 nuclear translocation: the latter response to all agonists was abrogated in R1B cells or by pretreatment of Mv1Lu cells with neutralizing TGF-beta antibodies. SPARC also stimulated Smad2 phosphorylation in MB114 endothelial cells but had no effect on bone morphogenetic protein-regulated Smad1 phosphorylation in either Mv1Lu or MB114 cells. Finally, SPARC and SPARC-EC stimulated TGF-beta-responsive reporter gene expression through a TGF-beta receptor- and Smad2/3-dependent pathway in Mv1Lu cells. Collectively, our findings identify a novel mechanism whereby SPARC inhibits epithelial cell proliferation by selectively commandeering the TGF-beta signaling system, doing so through coupling of SPARC-EC to a TGF-beta receptor- and Smad2/3-dependent pathway.     

Apoptosis of mink lung epithelial cells by co-treatment of low-dose staurosporine and transforming growth factor-beta1 depends on the enhanced TGF-beta signaling and requires the decreased phosphorylation of PKB/Akt

We demonstrate how co-treatment of low-dose staurosporine (STS) and TGF-beta1, which alone have little effect on cell death, markedly induces apoptosis in Mv1Lu mink lung epithelial cells, but not in its clonal variant R1B cells lacking functional TGF-beta signaling. This process was associated with mitochondria-dependent apoptosis and the enhanced TGF-beta/Smad signaling in Mv1Lu cells. When R1B cells were infected with adenovirus carrying wild-type ALK5, a functional TGF-beta type I receptor gene, the apoptotic cell death was significantly restored in these cells following co-treatment of low-dose STS and TGF-beta1. Treatment of Mv1Lu cells with both low-dose STS and TGF-beta1 decreased the activity of phospho-Akt, which is involved in cell survival signal. In addition, pre-treatments of PI3 kinase inhibitors, LY294002 and wortmannin, further increased the apoptosis of MvlLu cells induced by co-treatment of low-dose STS and TGF-beta1. And overexpression of constitutively active Akt (myr-Akt) using adenoviral expression system inhibited the apoptotic cell death of Mv1Lu cells by about 50% upon co-treatment of low-dose STS and TGF-beta1. These results suggest that co-treatment of low-dose STS and TGF-beta1 induces apoptosis of mink lung epithelial cells by enhancing TGF-beta signaling and in part suppressing cytoprotective signaling.     

The antiproliferative effect of type beta transforming growth factor occurs at a level distal from receptors for growth-activating factors

Transforming growth factor-beta (TGF beta) from human platelets blocks the ability of Mv1Lu mink lung epithelial cells to grow in response to serum mitogens, epidermal growth factor (EGF), or insulin. The phenotypic response of Mv1Lu cells to TGF beta is characterized by a flat, very enlarged cell morphology and a markedly increased production and accumulation of extracellular matrix fibronectin. The ability of TGF beta to alter the ligand binding or signal transducing activity of mitogen receptors in Mv1Lu cells has been examined. In contrast to NRK-49F rat fibroblasts, Mv1Lu cells do not respond to TGF beta with a decrease in the affinity or a change in the number of cell surface receptors for EGF. Soluble extracts from Mv1Lu cells contain a protein kinase activity which selectively phosphorylates ribosomal protein S6; this S6 kinase activity is elevated severalfold minutes after exposure of cells to mitogens. This kinase activity has been used as the parameter to measure the signaling ability of EGF receptors and insulin receptors in cells treated with TGF beta. We find that TGF beta does not alter the basal level of S6 kinase activity or its elevation by EGF or insulin. In TGF beta-treated cells rendered insensitive to the growth-promoting action of EGF, the parameters of elevation of S6 kinase activity by EGF are similar to those of control, growth-competent cells. The results suggest that TGF beta inhibits cell proliferation by acting at a level distal from the receptors for growth-activating factors.