Features of mono- and multinucleated bone resorbing cells of the zebrafish Danio rerio and their contribution to skeletal development, remodeling, and growth.

To provide basic data about bone resorbing cells in the skeleton during the life cycle of Danio rerio, larvae, juveniles, and adults (divided into six age groups) were studied by histological procedures and by demonstration of the osteoclast marker enzyme tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP). Special attention was paid to the lower jaw, which is a standard element for fish bone studies. The presence of osteoclasts at endosteal surfaces of growing bones of all animals older than 20 days reveals that resorption is an important part of zebrafish skeletal development. The first bone-resorbing cells to form are mononucleated. They appear in 20-day-old animals concurrently in the craniofacial skeleton and vertebral column. Mononucleated osteoclasts are predominant in juveniles. Regional differences characterize the appearance of osteoclasts; at thin skeletal elements (neural arches, nasal) mononucleated osteoclasts are predominant even in adults. Multinucleated bone-resorbing cells were first observed in 40-day-old animals and are the predominant osteoclast type of adults. Both mono- and multinucleated osteoclasts contribute to allometric bone growth but multinucleated osteoclasts are also involved in lacunar bone resorption and repeated bone remodeling. Resorption of the dentary follows the pattern described above (mononucleated osteoclasts precede multinucleated cells) and includes the partial removal of Meckel's cartilage. Bone marrow spaces created by resorption are usually filled with adipose tissue. In conclusion, bone resorption is primarily subjected to the demands of growth, the appearance of mono- and multinucleated osteoclasts is site- and age-related, and bone remodeling occurs. The results are discussed in relation to findings in other teleosts and in mammals.     

A comparative view on mechanisms and functions of skeletal remodelling in teleost fish, with special emphasis on osteoclasts and their function

Resorption and remodelling of skeletal tissues is required for development and growth, mechanical adaptation, repair, and mineral homeostasis of the vertebrate skeleton. Here we review for the first time the current knowledge about resorption and remodelling of the skeleton in teleost fish, the largest and most diverse group of extant vertebrates. Teleost species are increasingly used in aquaculture and as models in biomedical skeletal research. Thus, detailed knowledge is required to establish the differences and similarities between mammalian and teleost skeletal remodelling, and between distantly related species such as zebrafish (Danio rerio) and medaka (Oryzias latipes). The cellular mechanisms of differentiation and activation of osteoclasts and the functions of teleost skeletal remodelling are described. Several characteristics, related to skeletal remodelling, distinguish teleosts from mammals. These characteristics include (a) the absence of osteocytes in most species; (b) the absence of haematopoietic bone marrow tissue; (c) the abundance of small mononucleated osteoclasts performing non‐lacunar (smooth) bone resorption, in addition to or instead of multinucleated osteoclasts; and (d) a phosphorus‐ rather than calcium‐driven mineral homeostasis (mainly affecting the postcranial dermal skeleton). Furthermore, (e) skeletal resorption is often absent from particular sites, due to sparse or lacking endochondral ossification. Based on the mode of skeletal remodelling in early ontogeny of all teleosts and in later stages of development of teleosts with acellular bone we suggest a link between acellular bone and the predominance of mononucleated osteoclasts, on the one hand, and cellular bone and multinucleated osteoclasts on the other. The evolutionary origin of skeletal remodelling is discussed and whether mononucleated osteoclasts represent an ancestral type of resorbing cells. Revealing the differentiation and activation of teleost skeletal resorbing cells, in the absence of several factors that trigger mammalian osteoclast differentiation, is a current challenge. Understanding which characters of teleost bone remodelling are derived and which characters are conserved should enhance our understanding of the process in fish and may provide insights into alternative pathways of bone remodelling in mammals.     

Osteoclast differentiation and function in aquaglyceroporin AQP9-null mice

Background information. Osteoclasts are cells specialized for bone resorption and play important roles in bone growth and calcium homoeostasis. Differentiation of osteoclasts involves fusion of bone marrow macrophage mononuclear precursors in response to extracellular signals. A dramatic increase in osteoclast cell volume occurs during osteoclast biogenesis and is believed to be mediated by AQP9 (aquaporin 9), a membrane protein that can rapidly transport water and other small neutral solutes across cell membranes. Results. In the present study we report an increase in expression of AQP9 during differentiation of a mouse macrophage cell line into osteoclasts. Bone marrow macrophages from wild‐type and AQP9‐null mice differentiate into osteoclasts that have similar morphology, contain comparable numbers of nuclei, and digest synthetic bone to the same extent. Bones from wild‐type and AQP9‐null mice contain similar numbers of osteoclasts and have comparable density and structure as measured by X‐ray absorptiometry and microcomputed tomography. Conclusions. Our results confirm that AQP9 expression rises during osteoclast biogenesis, but indicate that AQP9 is not essential for osteoclast function or differentiation under normal physiological conditions.     

Prostate cancer promotes CD11b positive cells to differentiate into osteoclasts

Bone is the preferred site of prostate cancer metastasis, contributing to the morbidity and mortality of this disease. A key step in the successful establishment of prostate cancer bone metastases is activation of osteoclasts with subsequent bone resorption causing the release of several growth factors from the bone matrix. CD11b+ cells in bone marrow are enriched for osteoclast precursors. Conditioned media from prostate cancer PC‐3 cells induces CD11b+ cells from human peripheral blood to differentiate into functional osteoclasts with subsequent bone resorption. Analysis of PC‐3 conditioned media revealed high amounts of IL‐6 and IL‐8. CD11b+ cells were cultured with M‐CSF and RANKL, IL‐6, IL‐8, and CCL2, alone or in combination. All of these conditions induced osteoclast fusion, but cells cultured with M‐CSF, IL‐6, IL‐8, and CCL2 were capable of limited bone resorption. Co‐incubation with IL‐6 and IL‐8 and the RANK inhibitor, RANK‐Fc, failed to inhibit osteoclast fusion and bone resorption, suggesting a potential RANKL‐independent mechanism of functional osteoclast formation. This study demonstrates that functional osteoclasts can be derived from CD11b+ cells derived from human PBMCs. Prostate cancer cells secrete factors, including IL‐6 and IL‐8, that play an important role in osteoclast fusion by a RANKL‐independent mechanism. J. Cell. Biochem. 106: 563–569, 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Osteoclast activation: Potent inhibition by the bisphosphonate alendronate through a nonresorptive mechanism

Alendronate, an aminobisphosphonate used in the treatment of osteoporosis, is a potent inhibitor of bone resorption. Its mechanism of action is unknown. Because it localizes to bone surfaces, we compared the sensitivity of components of the resorptive process to incubation on alendronate-coated bone surfaces. We found that bone resorption by osteoclasts isolated from neonatal rat bone was unaffected by alendronate (10^-4 M). Osteoclast production in bone marrow cultures, as assessed by the production of calcitonin-receptor positive cells, was observed even at 10^-4 M, but bone resorption in these cultures was almost completely abolished by 10^-6 M alendronate. The greater sensitivity of osteoclast activation to inhibition by alendronate that these results suggest was supported by similar inhibition of osteoblast-mediated activation of osteoclasts from neonatal rat bone. Thus, activation of osteoclasts by osteoblastic/stromal cells is apparently the most sensitive component of the pathway whereby bone resorption is affected. Moreover, the ability of alendronate to suppress osteoclastic activation does not depend on resorption-mediated release of alendronate from bone surfaces. This ability extends the range of cell types and processes that might be affected by alendronate, beyond those in the immediate vicinity of resorbing cells, to include any cell that comes into contact with alendronate-coated bone surfaces. J. Cell. Physiol. 172:79–86, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Growth requires bone resorption at particular skeletal elements in a teleost fish with acellular bone (Oreochromis niloticus, Teleostei: Cichlidae)

To date, little is known about bone resorption during skeletal development in teleostean fish with acellular bone. We report here about bone resorption with regard to growth in the tilapia Oreochromis niloticus. Nine skeletal elements obtained from growing juveniles were examined using histological and histochemical methods, and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) served as a marker for bone resorbing cells (osteoclasts), alkaline phosphatase (ALP) was used to identify osteoblasts, and alizarin staining indicated sites of bone formation. TRAP-activity was located at those skeletal elements where growth requires bone resorption, and at sites of cartilage degeneration. No TRAP-activity was found at those skeletal elements where resorption was not required for growth. The examination of the praeopercular shaft leads to a model of bone enlargement, including bone resorption by TRAP-positive cells located at the endosteal bone surface and bone formation by ALP-positive cells located at the periosteal bone surface. TRAP-positive cells were mononucleated and lacked a ruffled border. They appeared either as cell aggregates (resembling the shape of multinucleated giant cells) or as flat cells (resembling bone lining cells). Problems of osteoclast identification in bony fish are discussed.     

Optimization of the tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase detection by histochemical method

According to the new KDIGO (Kidney Disease Improving Global Outcomes) guidelines, the term of renal osteodystrophy, should be used exclusively in reference to the invasive diagnosis of bone abnormalities. Due to the low sensitivity and specificity of biochemical serum markers of bone remodelling,the performance of bone biopsies is highly stimulated in dialysis patients and after kidney transplantation. The tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRACP) is an iso-enzyme of the group of acid phosphatases, which is highly expressed by activated osteoclasts and macrophages. TRACP in osteoclasts is in intracytoplasmic vesicles that transport the products of bone matrix degradation. Being present in activated osteoclasts, the identification of this enzyme by histochemistry in undecalcified bone biopsies is an excellent method to quantify the resorption of bone. Since it is an enzymatic histochemical method for a thermolabile enzyme, the temperature at which it is performed is particularly relevant. This study aimed to determine the optimal temperature for identification of TRACP in activated osteoclasts in undecalcified bone biopsies embedded in methylmethacrylate. We selected 10 cases of undecalcified bone biopsies from hemodialysis patients with the diagnosis of secondary hyperparathyroidism. Sections of 5 μm were stained to identify TRACP at different incubation temperatures (37º, 45º, 60º, 70º and 80ºC) for 30 minutes. Activated osteoclasts stained red and trabecular bone (mineralized bone) was contrasted with toluidine blue. This approach also increased the visibility of the trabecular bone resorption areas (Howship lacunae). Unlike what is suggested in the literature and in several international protocols, we found that the best results were obtained with temperatures between 60ºC and 70ºC. For technical reasons and according to the results of the present study, we recommended that, for an incubation time of 30 minutes, the reaction should be carried out at 60ºC. As active osteoclasts are usually scarce in a bone section, the standardization of the histochemistry method is of great relevance, to optimize the identification of these cells and increase the accuracy of the histomosphometric results. Our results, allowing an increase in osteoclasts contrast, also support the use of semi-automatic histomorphometric measurements.     

Morphological evidence of reduced bone resorption in the osteosclerotic (oc) mouse

Osteopetrosis, a metabolic bone disease characterized by a generalized sclerosis of the skeleton, is inherited as an autosomal recessive in a number of mammalian species. The pathogenesis of congenital osteopetrosis is mediated by a reduction in bone resorption as a result of decreased osteoclast function. This hypothesis is based on both functional and structural evidence of reduced bone resorption in all mutations examined to date. The present study examined the histology of cartilage and bone, the ultrastructure of osteoclasts, and the morphology of mineralized bone surfaces in a lethal osteopetrotic mutation, the osteosclerotic (oc) mouse. Histologically, epiphyseal cartilage growth plates, especially the hypertrophic zone, are markedly thickened in oc mice and metaphyses contain excessive osteoid, features characteristic of rickets. Transmission electron microscopy revealed that less than one-quarter of osteoclasts in oc mice demonstrated evidence of ruffled border formation compared with three-quarters of the osteoclasts in normal littermates. In mutants, ruffled borders were less elaborate and cytoplasmic processes penetrated into bone surfaces, suggesting that bone may be removed by mechanical rather than by enzymatic means. There was little morphological evidence of cartilage degradation and broad laminae limitantes persisted in mutants. Mineralized surfaces that undergo resorption in normal mice showed no evidence of bone resorption by scanning EM in mutants. The presence of a rachitic condition, the observations of reduced bone resorption, and the possible contribution of undermineralized matrices to decreased bone resorption are characteristics of the osteosclerotic mutation which suggest that it is a unique osteopetrotic mutant in which to study both the development and regulation of skeletal metabolism.     

Tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase in mononuclear and multinuclear cells during the bone resorption of tooth eruption

Tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) has been used as a cytochemical marker for the cell mediators of bone resorption, osteoclasts and their mononuclear precursors. We have applied a cytochemical method for TRAP to study the dependence of the osteoclast-mediated bone resorption of tooth eruption on the dental follicle, a connective tissue investment of the developing tooth, by analyzing the TRAP activity of mononuclear cells in the dental follicle before and during pre-molar eruption in dogs. The percentage of TRAP-positive monocyte cells increases until mid-eruption, slightly preceding a previously demonstrated rise in numbers of osteoclasts on adjacent bone surfaces. These data suggest an ontogenetic relationship between follicular mononuclear cells and osteoclasts on adjacent alveolar bone surfaces during tooth eruption. However, because TRAP occurs in other tissues and is not an exclusive indicator of pre-osteoclasts, proof of their relationship will have to await application of more definitive techniques.     

Cellular response to ectopically implanted silk sutures and osteopetrotic bone

Summary Faulty osteoclasts, characteristic of the incisors-absent (ia) rat mutation of osteopetrosis, cause a resorptive defect which results in the persistence of immature, highly mineralized bone matrix. We implanted osteopetrotic bone subcutaneously into normal andia rats to determine ifia bone could induce functionally active and morphologically identifiable osteoclasts at the implant surface. Assays of⁴⁵Ca released from the preparations showed that normal andia recipients were capable of equivalent cell-mediated release of Ca over a 2-week implant period, indicating that theia resorptive defect was not reproduced at the subcutaneous site. Freeze-thawed osteopetrotic bone released twice as much⁴⁵Ca as normal bone. This difference was eliminated by collagenase treatment. Cellular profiles were similar in both normal andia animals regardless of the implant preparation. At 3 days after implantation, both bone and suture were surrounded by mononuclear cells. By 14 days, multinucleated cells appeared at the implant surfaces. Morphological comparison of implant-induced multinucleated cells and tibial osteoclasts indicated that bone-elicited multinucleated cells lacked the ruffled borders characteristic of normal osteoclasts or the extensive clear zones typical ofia osteoclasts, but more closely resembled suture-induced macrophage-polykaryons. We conclude that ectopically implantedia bone as compared to normal bone elicits a different functional response from structurally similar cell populations. Bone-elicited multinucleated cells could not be classified as active osteoclasts despite evidence of release of⁴⁵Ca. Release of labeled Ca was probably due to the action of mononuclear phagocytes and macrophage-polykaryons rather than to osteoclastic resorption.     

Transformations of osteoclast phenotype in ia rats cured of congenital osteopetrosis

The reduced bone resorption characteristic of osteopetrosis is accompanied in the incisors-absent (ia) rat mutation by a significant increase in osteoclasts of inactive (mutant) phenotype. Restoration of bone resorption in ia rats by transfer of spleen cells from normal littermates is preceded by a transformation of osteoclasts from mutant to normal phenotype. In this investigation the proportions of osteoclasts of normal phenotype have been determined by light microscopy in untreated ia and normal rats and in ia rats treated with various cell populations from normal rats. Significant increases in numbers of osteoclasts of normal phenotype were seen in the mutant skeleton soon after cell treatments that eventually restored bone resorption and cured the disease. No changes in osteoclast phenotype were seen after cell transfers that did not cure the disease. These data establish transformation of osteoclast phenotype as an early event in the recovery from osteopetrosis and suggest that determination of osteoclast phenotype is a reliable predictor of the success of normal cell populations to restore bone resorption in this mutation.     

Osteoclasts in bone modeling, as revealed by in vivo imaging, are essential for organogenesis in fish

Bone modeling is the central system controlling the formation of bone including bone growth and shape in early development, in which bone is continuously resorbed by osteoclasts and formed by osteoblasts. However, this system has not been well documented, because it is difficult to trace osteoclasts and osteoblasts in vivo during development. Here we showed the important role of osteoclasts in organogenesis by establishing osteoclast-specific transgenic medaka lines and by using a zebrafish osteoclast-deficient line. Using in vivo imaging of osteoclasts in the transgenic medaka carrying an enhanced GFP (EGFP) or DsRed reporter gene driven by the medaka TRAP (Tartrate-Resistant Acid Phosphatase) or Cathepsin K promoter, respectively, we examined the maturation and migration of osteoclasts. Our results showed that mononuclear or multinucleated osteoclasts in the vertebral body were specifically localized at the inside of the neural and hemal arches, but not at the vertebral centrum. Furthermore, transmission electron microscopic (TEM) analyses revealed that osteoclasts were flat-shaped multinucleated cells, suggesting that osteoclasts initially differentiate from TRAP-positive mononuclear cells residing around bone. The zebrafish panther mutant lacks a functional c-fms (receptor for macrophage colony-stimulating factor) gene crucial for osteoclast proliferation and differentiation and thus has a low number of osteoclasts. Analysis of this mutant revealed deformities in both its neural and hemal arches, which resulted in abnormal development of the neural tube and blood vessels located inside these arches. Our results provide the first demonstration that bone resorption during bone modeling is essential for proper development of neural and vascular systems associated with fish vertebrae.     

Staphylococcal protein A promotes osteoclastogenesis through MAPK signaling during bone infection

Bone infection is a common and serious complication in the orthopedics field, which often leads to excessive bone destruction and non‐union. Osteoclast is the only type of cells which have the function of bone resorption. Its over activation is closely related to excessive bone loss. Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) is a major pathogen causing bone infection, which can produce a large number of strong pathogenic substances staphylococcal protein A (SPA). However, few studies were reported about the effects of SPA on osteoclastogenesis. In our study, we observed that S. aureus activated osteoclasts and promoted bone loss in bone infection specimens. Then, we investigated the effects of SPA on RANKL‐induced osteoclastogenesis in vitro, the results revealed that SPA promoted osteoclastic differentiation and fusion, and enhanced osteoclastic bone resorption. In addition, we also showed that SPA upregulated the expression of NFATc1 and c‐FOS through the activation of MAPK signaling to promote osteoclastogenesis. Our findings might help us better understand the pathogenic role of S. aureus in bone infection and develop new therapeutic strategies for infectious bone diseases.     

Baicalin positively regulates osteoclast function by activating MAPK/Mitf signalling

Activation of osteoblasts in bone formation and osteoclasts in bone resorption is important during the bone fracture healing process. There has been a long interest in identifying and developing a natural therapy for bone fracture healing. In this study, we investigated the regulation of osteoclast differentiation by baicalin, which is a natural molecule extracted from Eucommiaulmoides (small tree native to China). It was determined that baicalin enhanced osteoclast maturation and bone resorption activity in a dose‐dependent manner. Moreover, this involves the activation of MAPK, increased Mitf nuclear translocation and up‐regulation of downstream osteoclast‐related target genes expression. The baicalin‐induced effect on osteoclast differentiation can be mimicked by specific inhibitors of p‐ERK (U0126) and the Mitf‐specific siRNA, respectively. Protein–ligand docking prediction identified that baicalin might bind to RANK, which is the upstream receptor of p‐ERK/Mitf signalling in osteoclasts. This indicated that RANK might be the binding target of baicalin. In sum, our findings revealed baicalin increased osteoclast maturation and function via p‐ERK/Mitf signalling. In addition, the results suggest that baicalin can potentially be used as a natural product for the treatment of bone fracture.     

Ultrastructure of alveolar bone during tooth eruption in the dog

Previous work from our laboratories has established that eruption of the permanent mandibular premolars in dogs is dependent upon the presence of the dental follicle and that it involves resorption of alveolar bone and the roots of the deciduous predecessor above and formation of alveolar bone below the developing crown. This study illustrates the topography of the bone surfaces of the crypt by scanning electron microscopy and the ultrastructure of the cells on alveolar bone surfaces during tooth eruption. Above the developing crown where the eruption pathway forms, the bone surface is a pitted sheet, the characteristic topographic feature of bone resorption; between the crown and the mandibular canal, the bone surface has numerous interconnecting trabeculae. Transmission electron microscopy of bone cells lining the eruption pathway area of the crypt showed numerous osteoclasts with adjacent mononuclear cells. Both cell types contained specific, membrane-bound cytoplasmic vesicles shown by the work of others to be characteristic features of osteoclasts and their precursors. Basal trabeculated bone in the crypt was covered by plump osteoblasts. These data show that the metabolic events in alveolar bone associated with tooth eruption have the appropriate cellular and bony surface correlates and that the suspected control of alveolar bone resorption by the dental follicle may be mediated by its recruiting and directing to adjacent bone surfaces the mononuclear precursors of osteoclasts.     

Role of colony-stimulating factor-1 in bone metabolism

Colony-stimulating factor-1 (CSF-1) is a cytokine required for proliferation, differentiation, activity, and survival of cells of the mononuclear phagocytic system. The growth factor is synthesized as a soluble, matrix, or membrane associated molecule. The specific functions of these forms are not clear. However, some data suggest a dependence of the development of various populations of tissue macrophages on the locally expressed and presented cytokine. Deficiency in CSF-1, as is the case in the murine mutant strain op/op, results in low numbers of macrophages and monocytes and, most striking, leads to osteopetrosis due to a virtual absence of osteoclasts. Using the op/op mutation as a model, CSF-1 was established as one of the growth factors for osteoclasts. The expression of CSF-1 receptors, encoded by the proto-oncogene c-fms, by osteoclast precursors and osteoclasts, suggested an effect of this cytokine not only during osteoclast formation but also on the mature cells. In fact, CSF-1 was shown to inhibit the resorbing activity, to stimulate migration, and to support survival of isolated osteoclasts in vitro. By these actions on cells of the osteoclast lineage, CSF-1 induces recruitment of new osteoclasts, leading to a net increase of bone resorption, and might govern the spatial distribution of resorption sites within the bone. During these processes, locally expressed and presented forms of the growth factor may play a crucial role, as will be discussed in this article. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

N-[2-(4-benzoyl-1-piperazinyl)phenyl]-2-(4-chlorophenoxy) acetamide is a novel inhibitor of resorptive bone loss in mice

The dynamic balance between bone formation and bone resorption is vital for the retention of bone mass. The abnormal activation of osteoclasts, unique cells that degrade the bone matrix, may result in many bone diseases such as osteoporosis. Osteoporosis, a bone metabolism disease, occurs when extreme osteoclast-mediated bone resorption outstrips osteoblast-related bone synthesis. Therefore, it is of great interest to identify agents that can regulate the activity of osteoclasts and prevent bone loss-induced bone diseases. In this study, we found that N-[2-(4-benzoyl-1-piperazinyl)phenyl]-2-(4-chlorophenoxy) acetamide (PPOAC-Bz) exerted a strong inhibitory effect on osteoclastogenesis. PPOAC-Bz altered the mRNA expressions of several osteoclast-specific marker genes and blocked the formation of mature osteoclasts, suppressing F-actin belt formation and bone resorption activity in vitro. In addition, PPOAC-Bz prevented OVX-induced bone loss in vivo. These findings highlighted the potential of PPOAC-Bz as a prospective drug for the treatment of osteolytic disorders.     

Immunohistochemical identification of a vacuolar proton pump (V-ATPase) in bone-resorbing cells of an advanced teleost species, Oreochromis niloticus

Poly-and monoclonal antibodies, raised against mammalian membrane-bound proton pump (V-ATPase) were applied to the bone-resorbing cells of Oreochromis niloticus to clarify if osteoclasts of an advanced teleost species display V-ATPase, a key enzyme in the process of bone resorption. All antibodies labelled cells at known sites of bone resorption, the endosteal bone surfaces surrounding the tooth anlagen. The best results were achieved with a monoclonal antibody (E11). Although the majority of labelled cells were flat and mononucleated, the occurrence of V-ATPase in these cells indicates that they function as active bone-resorbing cells. The monoclonal antibody E11 was also applied successfully to monocytes, cells that are believed to be related most closely to osteoclasts. The assignment of V-ATPase to boneresorbing cells of O. niloticus was confirmed by application of the additional osteoclast markers, tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) and tartrate-resistant ATPase (TraATPase). Co-expression of V-ATPase, TRAP and TraATPase in fish osteoclasts is demonstrated for the first time.     

Tumor necrosis factors alpha and beta induce osteoblastic cells to stimulate osteoclastic bone resorption

Antigen- or mitogen-stimulated leukocytes release bone-resorbing activity into culture supernatants in vitro. Among the agents likely to be present in such supernatants are monocyte-derived tumor necrosis factor (TNF-alpha) and lymphocyte-derived tumor necrosis factor (TNF-beta) (lymphotoxin), both of which have recently been shown to stimulate bone resorption in organ culture. To identify the mechanism of action of these agents, we compared bone resorption by isolated osteoclasts with bone resorption by osteoclasts cocultured with osteoblastic cells, and with bone resorption by osteoclasts incubated with supernatants from osteoblastic cells, in the presence and absence of recombinant TNF-alpha and TNF-beta. We found that neither TNF-alpha nor TNF-beta had any significant effect on bone resorption by isolated osteoclasts, but in the presence of osteoblasts the agents caused a twofold to threefold stimulation of bone resorption. A similar degree of stimulation was achieved by supernatants from osteoblasts incubated with TNF before addition to osteoclasts, compared with supernatants to which TNF were added after osteoblast incubation. These experiments suggest that TNF-alpha and TNF-beta stimulate bone resorption through a primary effect on osteoblastic cells, which are induced by TNF to produce a factor that stimulates osteoclastic resorption. Half-maximal stimulation of resorption occurred at 1.5 X 10(-10) M and 2.5 X 10(-10) M for TNF-alpha and TNF-beta, respectively. This degree of potency is comparable to that of parathyroid hormone, the major physiologic systemic regulator of bone resorption, and suggests that the TNF may exert a significant influence on osteoclastic bone resorption in vivo.