Aromatase

Aromatase catalyzes the conversion of androgens to estrogens through a series of monooxygenations to achieve the 19-desmolation and aromatization of the neutral steroid ring-A structure. We have separated two forms of aromatase, a major (P2a) and a minor (P3) form, from human term placenta through solubilization and chromatography. Partially purified aromatase in each form was immunoaffinity chromatographed to give a single band (SDS-PAGE) cytochrome P-450 of 55 kDa, utilizing a mouse monoclonal anti-human placental aromatase cytochrome P-450 IgGi (MAb3-2C2) which is capable of suppressing placental aromatase activity. The purified cytochrome P-450 showed specific aromatase activity of 25-30 nmol/min per mg with Km of 20-30 nM for androstenedione on reconstitution with NADPH-cyt P-450 reductase and dilauroyl L-alpha-phosphatidylcholine. This one step represents a higher than 100-fold purification with maintenance of the same Km. The stability analysis showed a half-life of more than 5 yr for solubilized aromatase and 2 months for the aromatase cytochrome P-450 on storage at -90 degrees C. Contrary to the recent claim that estrogen biosynthesis by reconstituted human placental cytochrome P-450 is by trans-diaxial 1 alpha,2 beta-hydrogen elimination, all of our partially purified forms and reconstituted aromatase synthesized estrogens by cis-1 beta, 2 beta-hydrogen elimination. Use of purified aromatase and [19-3H3, 4-14C]androstenedione led us to discover a metabolic switching by aromatase to 2 beta-hydroxylation of androgen. Results of the MAb3-2C2 suppression of aromatase activity in different species and tissues including human, baboons, horses, cows, pigs and rats indicated the presence of various isozymes of aromatase.     

Aromatase inhibitors--socio-economical issues

Novel, third-generation aromatase inhibitors are currently implemented for treatment of postmenopausal breast cancer in the metastatic and adjuvant setting and, potentially, for breast cancer prevention. Introduction of novel therapeutic strategies to large patient groups may add significant costs to health care budgets, forcing institutions to focus entirely on costs or the cost-utility of implementing such novel strategies. Breast cancer is the most frequent cancer in the female population in western societies, and its incidence is currently increasing in other parts of the world as well. Due to the proven efficacy and limited side effects of endocrine therapy in the adjuvant setting, the indications for use have been successively broadened. Currently, the majority of postmenopausal women treated for an estrogen-receptor positive breast cancer will be offered adjuvant endocrine therapy; thus, a general change of practice may cause significant implications to healthcare costs. This may relate to direct drug costs as well as indirect costs related to prevention of side effects, like additional use of bisphosphonates to prevent enhanced bone loss. The aim of this paper is to overview these considerations and put them into perspective by simple illustrations taken from current cost estimates.     

Aromatase inhibitors--socioeconomical issues

With costs of health care in general and for cancer therapy in particular escalating due to implementation of novel compounds, there is an increasing focus on therapy costs in most countries. A common way of assessing therapeutic utility versus cost is by assessing cost per additional life year gained or cost per additional quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained with a novel therapy. While endocrine therapy in general is associated with low costs, the fact that aromatase inhibitors are administered over several years to each patient in the adjuvant setting, together with the substantial number of postmenopausal breast cancer patients that are candidates for adjuvant treatment with aromatase inhibitors, advocates critical examination of cost–utilities related to implementation of such therapy in the adjuvant setting. While cost–utility estimates for treatment with aromatase inhibitors in the adjuvant setting look favorable, the estimates are sensitive to variations with respect to long-term benefits but also side effects. For patient groups with a low-risk of relapse but also patients with a limited life expectancy due to high age, cost–utility estimates may exceed the upper limits generally proposed for costs per quality-adjusted life year gained.     

Aromatase inhibitors and bone

The decrease in estrogen levels with the use of aromatase inhibitors results in an increase in the rate of bone remodelling. This result in an acceleration of bone loss, and probably to an increase in the risk of fractures. The risk of fracture is particularly high in the older woman and in the woman with a low bone mineral density. We have a number of proven treatments for the treatment of postmenopausal osteoporosis and it is likely that some of these, particularly bisphosphonates, could be effective at preventing bone loss with aromatase inhibitors.     

Aromatase inhibition by flavonoids

Several synthetic flavones were found to inhibit the aromatization of androstenedione to estrone catalyzed by human placental microsomes. Twenty-one compounds were tested and the IC50 of the most active were: flavone, 10 microM; 7-hydroxyflavone, 0.5 microM; 7,4'-dihydroxyflavone, 2.0 microM; flavanone, 8.0 microM; and 4'-hydroxyflavanone, 10 microM. Most of the others had IC50 values ranging from 80 to greater than 200 microM. These findings show that 4'-hydroxylation results in either no change or very little change in IC50 for flavanone, isoflavone and isoflavanone as well as other ring A hydroxylated flavones. Derivatives of flavone with a hydroxyl substituent at position 5, 6 and 7 were also screened. 7-Hydroxyflavone (11) was the most effective competitive inhibitor (IC50 = 0.5 microM) with an apparent Ki value of 0.25 microM. Compound 11 also induced a change in the absorption spectrum of the aromatase cytochrome P-450 which is indicative of substrate displacement. The relative binding affinities of the flavonoid analogs were determined and only ring A adn ring B dihydroxylated analogs were found to bind to the estrogen receptor.     

Aromatase and its inhibitors

Inhibitors of aromatase (estrogen synthetase) have been developed as treatment for postmenopausal breast cancer. Both steroidal substrate analogs, type I inhibitors, which inactivate the enzyme and non-steroidal competitive reversible, type II inhibitors, are now available. 4-hydroxyandrostenedione (4-OHA), the first selective aromatase inhibitor, has been shown to reduce serum estrogen concentrations and cause complete and partial responses in approximately 25% of patients with hormone responsive disease who have relapsed from previous endocrine treatment. Letrozole (CGS 20, 269) and anastrozole (ZN 1033) have been recently approved for treatment. Both suppress serum estrogen levels to the limit of assay detection. Letrozole has been shown to be significantly superior to megace in overall response rates and time to treatment failure, whereas anastrozole was found to improve survival in comparison to megace. Both were better tolerated than the latter. The potential of aromatase within the breast as a significant source of estrogen mediating tumor proliferation and which might determine the outcome of inhibitor treatment was explored. Using immunocytochemistry and in situ hybridization, aromatase and mRNA_arom was detected mainly in the epithelial cells of the terminal ductal lobular units (TDLU) of the normal breast and also in breast tumor epithelial cells as well as some stromal cells. Increase in proliferation, measured by increased thymidine incorporation into DNA and by PCNA immunostaining in response to testosterone was observed in histocultures of breast cancer samples. This effect could be inhibited by 4-OHA and implies that intratumoral aromatase has functional significance. An intratumoral aromatase model in the ovariectomized nude mouse was developed which simulated the hormone responsive postmenopausal breast cancer patient. This model also allows evaluation of the efficacy of aromatase inhibitors and antiestrogens in tumors of estrogen receptor positive, human breast carcinoma cells transfected with the human aromatase gene. Thus, the cells synthesized estrogen which stimulated tumor formation. Both aromatase inhibitors and antiestrogens were effective in suppressing tumor growth in this model. However, letrozole was more effective than tamoxifen. When the aromatase inhibitors were combined with tamoxifen, tumor growth was suppressed to about the same extent as with the aromatase inhibitors alone. Thus, there was no additive or synergistic effects of combining tamoxifen with aromatase inhibitors. This suggests that sequential treatment with these agents is likely to be more beneficial to the patient in terms of longer response to treatment.     

Aromatase inhibitors and arthralgia

In several large adjuvant clinical trials it has been demonstrated that substitution (eventually addition) of aromatase inhibitors (AIs) provides an improved outcome of endocrine-sensitive breast cancer over tamoxifen alone. Nevertheless, arthralgia induced by the AIs is one of the most frequent side effects in hormonal therapy. It is characterized by tenosynovial changes and is more frequent in patients in clinical practice than previously appreciated in adjuvant clinical trials. AI-related arthralgia may be related to estrogen deprivation, but estrogen replacement is not an option for these women. Therefore standard painkillers, NSAIDs (COX2 inhibitors), week opioids and other interventions (vitamin D, calcium, bisphosphonates, exercise, acupuncture, complementary and alternative approaches, eventually switch to another endocrine drug) are used for managing this treatment-related side effect, and improve adherence and quality of life among breast cancer survivors.     

Aromatase inhibitors and hormone-dependent cancers

Aromatase (estrogen synthetase) occurs in a variety of tissues. Using immunocytochemistry, we have recently located this enzyme in cellular compartments of several types of human tissue. Furthermore, we found the mRNA was located in the same structures where tested. As both gonadal and peripherally formed estrogen contribute to growth of hormone sensitive cancers, we have developed aromatase inhibitors to block synthesis of this hormone. We have determined that 4-hydroxyandrostenedione (4-OHA) selectively inhibits aromatase activity in ovarian and peripheral tissues and reduces plasma estrogen levels in rat and non-human primate species. 4-OHA was also found to inhibit gonadotropin levels and reduce estrogen and progesterone receptor levels in treated animals. The mechanism of these effects appear to be associated with the weak androgenic activity of the compound. These effects together with aromatase inhibition may result in a synergistic response reducing estrogen production and action. In postmenopausal women, estrogens are mainly of peripheral origin. When postmenopausal breast cancer patients were administered either daily oral or parenteral weekly treatment with 4-OHA at doses that did not affect their gonadotropin levels, plasma estrogen concentrations were significantly reduced. Complete or partial response to treatment occurred in 34% of 100 patients with advanced breast cancer, while the disease was stabilized in 12%. These results indicate that 4-OHA is of benefit in postmenopausal patients with advanced disease who have relapsed from prior hormonal therapies, and that steroidal inhibitors may be of value in premenopausal patients.     

Aromatase activity in uterine leiomyomata

Of the 24 samples of leiomyoma tissues examined 14 were shown to have aromatase activity in vitro. In contrast only 1 of 12 samples of myometrium had any demonstrable activity. Measurements of tissue oestrogen levels showed no correlation with the amount of aromatase activity although oestradiol levels were consistently higher in the tumour tissues compared with the normal myometrium.     

Aromatase inhibitors: future directions

Estrogen and its cognate estrogen receptor are key players in the etiology and progression of breast cancer. Aromatase inhibitors, suppressing tumor and plasma estrogen levels by blocking testosterone conversion to estrogen, have been proven to provide the most effective endocrine therapy for postmenopausal breast cancer patients. Aromatase inhibitors are now the first choice endocrine therapy in the metastatic setting for postmenopausal women. These endocrine agents also seem likely to soon become the standard adjuvant therapy, either alone or in sequence with tamoxifen, though their long-term toxicity and the optimum duration of therapy still remain to be defined. Advanced experimental studies and some clinical observations reveal the importance of blocking both the genomic and non-genomic activities of the estrogen receptor, as well as its crosstalk with growth factor and other cellular signaling, for greatest effectiveness of endocrine therapy. Consequently, these studies provide a mechanistic explanation for the superb performance of aromatase inhibitors, and also suggest how inhibiting selected growth factor receptors might delay or prevent the onset of resistance to aromatase inhibitors and other endocrine therapies.     

Aromatase in human lung carcinoma

Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer mortality in both women and men worldwide but gender differences exist in their clinical and biological manifestations. In particular, among life time non-smoker, female are far more likely to develop lung carcinoma than male. Recent studies demonstrated that estrogens are synthesized in situ in both male and female lung cancers through aromatase, suggesting that sex steroid may contribute to the pathogenesis and development of lung carcinoma. In addition, human lung carcinomas have been recently demonstrated to be frequently associated with expression of estrogen receptors in both male and female patients and a lower expression of aromatase was reported to be associated with better prognosis. Preclinical studies further demonstrated that aromatase inhibitor (AI) suppressed the lung tumor growth both in vitro and in vivo. These findings all suggest a potential role of intratumoral aromatase in biological behavior of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), the most common form of human lung malignancy. Therefore, AIs may become viable therapeutic options for disease management in NSCLC patients but further studies are definitely required to obtain a better understanding of the potential roles of intratumoral aromatase expression as a predictive biomarker for clinical outcome in these NSCLC patients.     

Aromatase and its inhibitors--an overview

Estrogen synthesis by aromatase occurs in a number of tissues throughout the body. Strategies which reduce production of estrogen offer useful means of treating hormone-dependent breast cancer. Initially, several steroidal compounds were determined to be selective inhibitors of aromatase. The most potent of these, 4-hydroxyandrostenedione (4-OHA) inhibits aromatase competitively but also causes inactivation of the enzyme. A number of other steroidal inhibitors appear to act by this mechanism also. In contrast, the newer imidazole compounds are reversible, competitive inhibitors. In vivo studies demonstrated that 4-OHA inhibited aromatase activity in ovarian and peripheral tissues and reduced plasma estrogen levels in rat and non-human primate species. In rats with mammary tumors, reduction in ovarian estrogen production was correlated with tumor regression. 4-OHA was also found to inhibit gonadotropin levels in animals in a dose-dependent manner. The mechanism of this effect appears to be associated with the weak androgenic activity of the compound. Together with aromatase inhibition, this action may contribute to reducing the growth stimulating effects of estrogen. A series of studies have now been completed in postmenopausal breast cancer patients treated with 4-OHA either 500 mg/2 weeks or weekly, or 250 mg/2 weeks. These doses did not affect gonadotropin levels. Plasma estrogen concentrations were significantly reduced. Complete or partial tumor regression occurred in 26% of the patients and the disease was stabilized in 25% of the patients. The results suggest that 4-OHA is of benefit to postmenopausal patients who have relapsed from prior hormonal therapies. Several of the steroidal inhibitors are now entering clinical trials as well as non-steroidal compounds which are more potent and selective than aminoglutethimide. Aromatase inhibitors should provide several useful additions to the treatment of breast cancer.     

Aromatase in the human testis

Low levels of testicular estrogen synthesis have been reported in a number of species, but the cellular localization has not been unequivocally established. To study aromatase in the human testis, we have combined immunocytochemistry with direct measurement of enzyme activity in the testicular 6μm cryosections. Thus, the functionality of the immunoreaction and its sensitivity can be assessed in quantitative terms. Testes were obtained from immediate autopsy from men aged 18–53 years, from surgery from two patients with prostatic cancer (67 and 74 years) and from two normal children aged 8 months and 3 years at autopsy. Benign testicular sex cord tumors were also examined from two unrelated patients aged 5 and 8 years with gynecomastia and diagnosed with Peutz-Jeghers syndrome. Our results consistently showed low to moderate staining intensity of immunoreactive aromatase in comparison to that of normal human placental cryosections. Immunoreactive aromatase was only present in the interstitial Leydig cells and absent from the Sertoli cells of all normal adult testes showing spermatogenesis. Aromatase activity correlated well with the intensity of the immunostain. However, there was no obvious relationship between the level of aromatase activity and increasing age. Generally higher levels were present in testes of young men (18–22 years). No immunostain in any cell type was detected in one 33-year-old patient with testicular cancer. In the testes of the two normal prepubertal boys, no immunostaining was observed. However, intensely stained Sertoli cells as well as high aromatase activity were observed in the testicular tumors of the patients with Peutz-Jeghers syndrome. Our results suggest that Leydig cells are the source of aromatase in normal men but that Sertoli cells may express this enzyme under abnormal conditions. The combined methods for measuring enzyme activity and immunoreactive aromatase are suitable for application to tissues expressing low levels of aromatase.     

Aromatase inhibitors in post-menopausal endometriosis

Background

Serum anti-Mullerian hormone (AMH) is currently considered the best marker of ovarian reserve and of ovarian responsiveness to gonadotropins in in-vitro fertilization (IVF). AMH assay, however, is not available in all IVF Units and is quite expensive, a reason that limits its use in developing countries. The aim of this study is to assess whether the "ovarian sensitivity index" precisely reflects AMH so that this index may be used as a surrogate for AMH in prediction of ovarian response during an IVF cycle.

Methods

AMH serum levels were measured in 61 patients undergoing IVF with a "long" stimulation protocol including the GnRH agonist buserelin and recombinant follicle-stimulating hormone (rFSH). Patients were divided into four subgroups according to the percentile of serum AMH and their ovarian stimulation was prospectively followed. Ovarian sensitivity index (OSI) was calculated dividing the total administered FSH dose by the number of retrieved oocytes.

Results

AMH and OSI show a highly significant negative correlation (r = -0.67; p = 0.0001) that is stronger than the one between AMH and the total number of retrieved oocytes and than the one between AMH and the total FSH dose.

Conclusions

OSI reflects quite satisfactory the AMH level and may be proposed as a surrogate of AMH assay in predicting ovarian responsiveness to FSH in IVF. Being very easy to calculate and costless, its use could be proposed where AMH measurement is not available or in developing countries where limiting costs is of primary importance.     

Aromatase inhibitors in ovarian stimulation

The selective estrogen receptor modulator, clomiphene citrate (CC), has been the principal drug used for induction of ovulation in women with polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS). CC is associated with adverse side effects and low pregnancy rates attributed to long-lasting estrogen receptor depletion. Anastrozole and letrozole are potent, non-steroidal, reversible aromatase inhibitors, developed for postmenopausal breast cancer therapy. We hypothesized that aromatase inhibitors could mimic the action of CC in reducing estrogen negative feedback on follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) secretion, without depleting estrogen receptors. In a series of preliminary studies, we reported the success of aromatase inhibition in inducing ovulation in anovulatory women with PCOS. Moreover, we showed that concomitant use of aromatase inhibitors resulted in a significant reduction of the FSH dose needed for controlled ovarian hyperstimulation. We suggest that aromatase inhibitors act through an increase in endogenous gonadotropin secretion as well as through increased intraovarian androgen levels that may increase ovarian FSH receptors. Recently, we demonstrated the safety of aromatase inhibitors in pregnancy outcome studies examining spontaneous pregnancy loss, multiple pregnancy rates and congenital anomalies compared to a control group of infertility patients treated with CC.     

Aromatase inhibitors in gynecologic cancers

The female genital tract is hormonally responsive, and consequently some tumors, which arise within in it, may be treated at least in part, with hormonal manipulation. The range of responses in clinical trials and case reports will be reviewed. Many of these diseases are too rare for clinical trial testing, and in some cases evidence is anecdotal at best. Recurrences of ovarian cancer have been treated with tamoxifen and megesterol acetate with variable response rates from 0 to 56%. The favorable toxicity profile of aromatase inhibitors led to trials of these agents for the treatment of relapsed epithelial ovarian cancer. These agents have proved tolerable with minor response rates but a significant disease stabilization rate, which may be prolonged in a minority of cases. It is unclear if these responses may be predicted by estrogen receptor expression or aromatase expression. Anastrazole has also been tried in combination with an EGFR receptor-inhibitor, again showing minor responses but possibly an increase in TTT in some patients. Granulosa cell tumors of the ovary are rare, hormonally sensitive tumors, with reported responses to a variety of hormonal manipulations, including aromatase inhibition. In addition, combined endocrine blockade, including aromatase inhibition, has been tried with reports of success. Endometrial cancers, particularly type I lesions, are often treated with hormonal manipulation, most commonly with progestins, but also with antiestrogens such as tamoxifen. A trial of aromatase inhibition in the treatment of recurrent endometrial cancer showed minimal responses. Endometrial stromal sarcoma, an uncommon uterine malignancy, has shown response to hormonal treatments, with multiple case reports of efficacy of aromatase inhibition. Despite the rarity of some of these tumor types, rare tumor study groups, such as within the Gynecologic Oncology Group, should make an effort to prospectively define the utility of these treatments.     

Aromatase inhibitors and xenograft studies

Aromatase inhibitors (AIs) have become the front-line choice for treatment of ER+ breast cancer. Nevertheless, although patients are responsive initially, they may acquire resistance and become unresponsive to further treatment. In addition, approximately 25% of breast cancers do not express the estrogen receptor (ERα) and consequently, are innately resistant to endocrine therapy. We have investigated the mechanisms associated with this lack of treatment response using xenograft models. We found that in cells and tumors that acquired resistance to the AI letrozole therapy, expression of the ER was reduced whereas growth factor signally was enhanced, including a marked increase in HER2 expression. Treatment with trastuzumab (HER2 antibody) resulted in a significant down-regulation of HER2 and p-MAPK as well as restoration of ERα expression. Thus, when trastuzumab was added to letrozole treatment at the time of tumor progression, there was significantly prolonged tumor suppression compared to trastuzumab or letrozole alone. This suggests that inhibition of both HER2 and ERα signaling pathways are required for overcoming resistance and restoring treatment sensitivity. ER negative tumors are innately resistant to endocrine therapy. Repression of the ERα has been found to be due to epigenetic modifications such as increased methylation and histone deacetylation. We found that entinostat (ENT), a histone deacetylase inhibitor (HDACi), activated not only expression of ERα but also aromatase in MDA-MB-231 ER-negative breast cancer cells, resulting in their ability to respond to estrogen and letrozole. Treatment with ENT in combination with letrozole significantly reduced tumor growth rate in xenografts compared to control tumors (p < 0.001). ENT plus letrozole treatment also prevented the colonization and growth of MDA-MB-231 cells in the lung with a significant reduction (p < 0.03) in both visible and microscopic foci. These results provide a strong indication for possible use of AIs in combination with HDAC inhibitors for the treatment of ER-negative breast cancer.     

Epitope Characterization of an Aromatase Monoclonal Antibody Suitable for the Assessment of Intratumoral Aromatase Activity

Immunohistochemistry is one of the most suitable methods for the detection of intratumoral aromatase in order to identify patients who may respond to aromatase inhibitor therapy in hormone-dependent breast cancer. Previous studies showed statistically significant correlation between results of immnuohistochemistry and biochemical analysis in carcinoma components stained by aromatase monoclonal antibody 677. In this study, determination of the antigenic peptides recognized by aromatase antibodies through epitope mapping, combined with the new knowledge on aromatase-reductase interaction, provide insights for understanding various immunostaining patterns using different aromatase antibodies. Our studies on aromatase-reductase interaction also provided critical information on how aromatase and reductase interact with each other on the endoplasmic reticulum membrane, and identified key residues, including K108 of aromatase, that are involved in the interaction with reductase. Through epitope mapping and taking into consideration the interference with aromatase immunohistochemical staining by NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase, we demonstrated that monoclonal antibody 677 is a suitable antibody for an assessment of intratumoral aromatase activity in breast cancer patients for making clinical management decisions. These results also provide valuable information to identify new aromatase antibodies for immunohistochemical diagnosis of hormone-dependent breast cancer in future.