Effects of Dose on the Induction of Dominant-Lethal Mutations and Heritable Translocations with Ethyl Methanesulfonate in Male Mice

Genetic damage by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) in male mice was measured at doses ranging from 50 to 300 mg/kg with dominant-lethal mutations and reciprocal translocations as endpoints. No appreciable increase in dominant-lethal mutations was detected following a dose of 100 mg/kg. Dominant lethals induced by EMS were convincingly detected only after a dose of 150 mg/kg, but in the translocation experiment an increase in the genetic effect was detectable at the 50 mg/kg dose. It is likely that dominant lethals had also been induced at the 50 and 100 mg/kg doses, but were not detected due to the relative insensitivity of the dominant..lethal procedure. Thus, for detection of low levels of EMS-induced chromosome breakage, translocations are a much more reliable endpoint than are dominant-lethal mutations. A procedure for large-scale screening of induced translocations is described.—The dominant-lethal dose-response curve, plotted on the basis of living embryos as a percentage of the control value, is clearly not linear as it is markedly concave downward. Similarly, the translocation dose-response curve showed a more rapid increase in the number of translocations with dose than would be expected on the basis of dose-square kinetics. It is clear for both of these endpoints that the effectiveness of EMS in inducing chromosome breakage is proportionately much lower at low doses.     

Chemical induction of presumed dominant-lethal mutations in postcopulation germ cells and zygotes of mice. II. Sensitivity of different postcopulation-precleavage stages to three alkylating chemicals.

The relative sensitivities of various postcopulation-precleabage and pronuclear stages to dominant-lethal effects of isopropyl methanesulfonate (IMS), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), and triethylenemelamine (TEM) were investigated. The pattern of sensitivity differed with the chemical. IMS was most effective when pronuclear formation was already completed and the majority of the zygotes were presumably undergoing DNA synthesis. EMS, on the other hand, induced its most pronounced effects when eggs in the course of second meiotic division and zygotes in early pronuclear stages were treated. The greatest effect of TEM was observed when zygotes were treated at the early pronuclear stage. EMS and TEM, in contrast to IMS, are similar to radiations in that zygotes undergoing DNA synthesis are more resistant to them than are the early pronuclear stages. In the case of IMS, effects induced in the most sensitive postcopulation-precleavage stage were 6 to 9 times greater than in the most sensitive precopulatory dictyate oocytes or male germ cells. On the other hand, in the case of EMS and TEM, the most sensitive precopulatory male germ cells, but not the dictyate oocytes, were more sensitive than the most sensitive postcopulation stages.     

Activity of germ-cell mutagens and nonmutagens in the rat spermatocyte UDS assay

The ability of 13 chemicals of known germ-cell mutagenicity to induce unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) in rat spermatocytes was examined. At selected times following i.p. injection of test compounds, spermatocytes were isolated from Fischer 344 rats by enzymatic digestion of the seminiferous tubules and cultured for 24 h in the presence of [3H]thymidine. 7 compounds, methyl methanesulfonate, triethylenemelamine, cyclophosphamide, methylnitrosourea, ethylnitrosourea, procarbazine, and dibromochloropropane produced positive UDS responses in spermatocytes. These chemicals are also positive for specific locus mutations, heritable translocations, or dominant lethal mutations when administered to male rodents. Mitomycin C, which produces DNA interstrand crosslinks and induces heritable mutations and translocations in male germ cells, failed to stimulate UDS in rat spermatocytes. Germ-cell nonmutagens N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, dimethylnitrosamine, 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide, and ethylene dibromide were negative in the rat spermatocyte UDS assay. Correlation of these results with those of other assays for heritable mutations in germ cells indicates that the in vivo/in vitro spermatocyte DNA repair assay is useful in predicting the mutagenic potential of chemicals in male germ cells.     

Heritable translocation test on random-bred mice after prolonged triethylenemelamine treatment.

Heritable translocation and dominant lethal tests were conducted with random-bred Swiss albino male mice. The animals were provided drinking water containing triethylenemelamine (TEM) for 4 weeks, and were then mated for 3 successive weeks for analysis of dominant lethality and production of F1 progeny. Potential translocation carriers among F1 males were selected after two breedings and confirmed by cytogenetic analysis. Translocation heterozygotes were obtained in offspring of the TEM-treated groups, but not in the control groups. In F1 males produced from the first week of mating, the frequencies of translocations were 0, 1.78 6.2 and 10.0% for the control group and groups receiving TEM at 0.0125, 0.025 and 0.050 mg/kg/day, respectively, and in those produced from the third week of mating, the values were 0 and 2.1%, respectively, for the control group and the group receiving TEM at 0.050 mg/kg/day. F1 males from the second week of mating were not studied for the induction of heritable translocations. TEM-induced dominant lethality and heritable translocations were most prominent in the first week of mating after 4 weeks of treatment. In addition, heritable translocations appeared to be a more sensitive endpoint than dominant lethal mutations for the measurement of mutagenic effects of TEM.     

Recombinational repair of alkylation lesions in phage T4

Summary Treatment of bacteriophage T4 by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS)¹ caused more than a doubling in recombination between two rII markers. The functions of genes 47, 46, 32, 30, uvsX and y are known to be required for genetic recombination, and mutants defective in these genes were found to be more sensitive to inactivation by EMS than wild-type phage. This suggests that a recombinational pathway involving the products of these genes may be employed in repairing EMS induced lethal lesions. Genes 45 and denV are apparently not involved in recombination, and mutants defective in these genes were not EMS-sensitive. Gene 47, 46 and y mutants which were defective in the repair of EMS induced lethal lesions had no detectable deficiency in their ability to undergo EMS-induced mutation. This implies that recombinational repair of EMS lesions does not contribute substantially to EMS mutatenesis. The results obtained here with EMS are in general similar to the results reported in the preceding paper with MNNG, suggesting that the lesions caused by both of these monofunctional alkylating agents may be eliminated by similar recombinational repair processes.     

Heritable translocation study in male mice with trimethyl phosphate

Dominant lethal and heritable translocation studies were performed in male mice receiving a single intraperitoneal injection of trimethyl phosphate (TMP). The germ cell stage investigated was the spermatid. Methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) was used as a positive control in the latter study. A dominant lethal assay gave marked dose-dependent increases in early fetal deaths. Heritable translocations were detected at 1000 or 1500 mg of TMP/kg in F1 male progeny when screening for semi-sterility and cytogenetically analyzing the meiotic or mitotic chromosomes. Translocation induction was higher at the higher TMP dose (14.3%) than at the lower dose (5.3%) and the yield from the higher dose was similar to that induced by 50 mg of MMS/kg (11.0%). Most of the translocation carriers were semi-sterile or sterile. The data confirm conclusions from other dominant lethal studies showing TMP to be capable of causing chromosomal damage in mouse spermatids and show that certain types of damage result in heritable translocations.     

Induction of specific-locus mutations in male mice by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS)

Using a sequential mating procedure, the induction of specific-locus mutations by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) was reinvestigated in male mice. Doses of 175 mg/kg b.w. and 250 mg/kg b.w. of EMS induce gene mutations in the mating intervals 5-8 and 9-12 days post treatment. However, only the frequency of dominant lethal mutations increases with the dose, not the frequency of specific-locus mutations. This observation implies that with a higher dose of EMS a larger fraction of mutagenized spermatozoa and spermatids are selectively eliminated, leading to underestimation of the specific-locus mutation yield at high doses. EMS does not induce specific-locus mutations in spermatogonia.     

Delayed Formation of Chromosome Aberrations in Mouse Pachytene Spermatocytes Treated with Triethylenemelamine (Tem)

Induction of chromosome aberrations in pachytene spermatocytes of mice by 2 mg/kg TEM was compared with induction by 400 R X rays. These doses induced comparably high dominant lethal effects in pachytene spermatocytes of mice. Cytological analysis at diakinesis–metaphase I stage showed that whereas 76.4% of the cells treated with X rays at pachytene stage had aberrations, the frequencies observed in two TEM experiments were only 0.8 and 2.2%. On the other hand, 5% of the progeny from TEM-treated pachytene spermatocytes were found to be translocation heterozygotes. This is the first report on the recovery of heritable translocations from treated spermatocytes of mice. The aberration frequencies observed for TEM in diakinesis–metaphase I were much too low to account for all the lethal mutations and heritable translocations. Thus, the formation of the bulk of aberrations induced by TEM in pachytene spermatocytes was delayed—a marked contrast to the more immediate formation of X-ray-induced aberrations. It is postulated that the formation of the bulk of TEM-induced aberrations in pachytene spermatocytes and in certain postmeiotic stages occurs sometime during spermiogenesis, and not through the operation of postfertilization pronuclear DNA synthesis.     

Nuclear and extranuclear mutations in yeast induced by ethyl methanesulfonate

When zero-point mutations were induced in the yeastSaccharomyces cerevisiae using ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) no differences were found in the frequency of auxotrophic mutants formed by a short and a prolonged treatment of the agent at equal survival level. The expression of a part of the mutations induced by a prolonged EMS treatment was delayed by one or two division cycles. The total frequency of auxotrophs due to both the zero point and delayed mutations, however, is still considerably lower than the frequency of auxotrophs induced by a prolonged treatment of EMS in some bacterial species. Both the prolonged and short EMS treatment induces in yeast also extranuclear respiration-deficient (RD) mutants at a relatively high frequency; in wild strains at equal survival level the prolonged treatment produces a higher number of RD mutants than the short one. In strain which is more susceptible to the lethal EMS effect than wild strain the number of RD mutants produced by the agent is much higher than in the wild strain. The results support the assumption of the different DNA arrangement in yeast nuclei and mitochondria and indicate the possible effect of repair mechanisms during the induction of mutations causing the respiration deficiency.     

Mutations Affecting Functions of the Drosophila Gene Glued

Glued mutations in Drosophila comprise an essential complementation group with complex developmental effects. The original Glued mutation (Gl) has dominant nonlethal effects in heterozygous flies, principally on the morphogenesis of the visual system. Gl also has a recessive lethal effect early in development. Mutations that reverse the dominant visual effects of Gl (GlR mutations) were induced by gamma-radiation or by insertions of the transposable P element. The GlR(G) mutations induced by gamma-radiation do not reverse the lethal effect of Gl; these appear to be null mutations, some of which (and possibly all) delete segments of the Glued region. The GlR(P) mutations induced by insertion of the P element also reverse concomitantly a recessive lethal effect of Gl, suggesting that both the recessive and dominant effects are controlled by the same gene. The reversal of a lethal effect of Gl by the P element is remarkable, since it indicates that an essential gene function can be restored by insertion of unrelated DNA. Another class of lethal Glued mutations was induced in the normal Gl+ strain by ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS). The EMS mutations belong to the same essential complementation group as Gl, but do not have the strong dominant effects of Gl on the visual system. The GlR(P) mutations provide a molecular marker for the Glued gene, which was used to map the gene to the 70C2 band of chromosome 3L by in situ hybridization of a P element probe to polytene chromosomes from the GlR(P) strains and also to isolate clones of Glued genomic DNA for molecular studies of the normal gene and the various Glued mutations.     

Micronuclei in mouse bone-marrow cells. A simple in vivo model for the evaluation of drug-induced chromosomal aberrations

For studying, in vivo, chromosomal damage in bone-marrow cells of CD mice the following compounds were used: Trenimon®; Endoxanm® (cyclophosphamide); triethylenemelamine (TEM); methyl methanesulfonate (MMS); ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS); mitomycin C; colchicine; N-methyl-N′-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) and caffeine. In a first set of experiments the compounds were given twice intraperitoneally with an interval of 24 h. In a second set, effects on bone marrow were studied after 2 i.v. or p.o. administrations of TEM or EMS. All compounds except MNNG and caffeine produced bone-marrow depression and micronuclei, depending on the dose. For the active compounds an interesting difference was revealed by a comparison of the lowest effective dose (as measured by micronuclei formation) with the lethal dose. Trenimon, TEM, cyclophosphamide and MMS (some of which are used in human chemotherapy in similar mg/kg doses) were active on mouse bone-marrow at very low doses compared with their lethal doses. On the other hand, colchicine, mitomycin C and EMS exhibited an effect only at doses very close to, or within, the toxic range. Different routes of administration of either TEM or EMS produced similar effects.The results indicate that the test is especially suitable for initial large-scale screening of suspected chromosomal mutagens and spindle poisons. In addition, the use of the relationship between doses required to induce micronuclei and lethal doses in mice provides a practical measure of the relative potencies of such compounds.     

EMS-induced mutations in Anopheles quadrimaculatus (Say), species A

Three new mutants were induced in a laboratory strain of Anopheles quadrimaculatus (Say), species A, by feeding adult males ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS). Rose eye (ro) is a recessive X-linked trait. Short antenna (Sa) and melanotic (Mel) are dominant autosomal traits that are lethal in the homozygous condition. Linkage crosses and X-autosome translocations were used to assign short antenna to the right arm of chromosome 3 about 45 map units proximal to stripe (st+), and melanotic was located on chromosome 2 near the centromere.     

Mutagenic action of alkylating agents on prophage lambda

The lethal and mutagenic effects of 7 alkylating agents: N-nitroso-N-methylurea (NMU), N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG), methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), nitrogen mustard (HN2), mitomycin C (MC), bifunctional acridine mustard (AM)--and of cyanate (KNCO) on heat inducible lambda cI857 prophage were studied. After treatment of lysogenic cells with mutagens, prophage was heat-induced either immediately or after 90 min incubation in nutrient broth and c mutants forming clear plaques at 32 degrees C were scored. NMU (0.02 M) when immediately induced with heat, induces c mutants very efficiently (maximal yield 10%) not only in the wild-type cells but also in repair-deficient mutants recA13, lexA102, uvrA6 umuC36, recF143, xthA9, polA1, uvrD3 and uvrD502. These data show that NMU-induced mutations are fixed as replication errors due to mispairing modified bases. After delayed heat induction, the prophage survival enhances and the frequency of c mutations declines considerably in host cells of all repair genotypes tested. Carbamoylation is not involved in the mutagenic action of NMU, because KNCO (0.02 M) has a very slight lethal effect and does not induce mutations. MNNG (100 micrograms/ml) and EMS (0.1 M) also induce mutations by replicative mechanism, because maximal yield of c mutations does not depend on RecA+ and is about 15 and 2%, respectively. MMS is a mutagen of the repair type, since its mutagenic action is suppressed by recA mutation of the host. NH2 only inactivates prophage, but does not induce mutations. MC (50 micrograms/ml) and AM (150 micrograms/ml) induce mutations rather inefficiently (the maximal yield 0.1 and 0.3%, respectively) both in recA+ and recA- hosts. The mutagenic action of these agents is probably due to intercalation.     

O-alkylation in DNA does not correlate with the formation of chromosome breakage events in D. melanogaster

Postmeiotic cell stages of repair-proficient ring-X (RX) males were treated with methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), diethylnitrosamine (DEN) or ethylnitrosourea (ENU) and then mated to either repair-defective (mei-9L1) or to repair-competent females (mei-9+). Absence of the mei-9+ function resulted in a hypermutability effect to all alkylating agents (AAs) when they were assayed for their ability to induce chromosomal aberrations (chromosome loss; CL), irrespective of marked differences in distribution of DNA adducts brought about by these AAs. This picture is different from that described previously for the induction of point mutations (Vogel et al., 1985a). There, evidence was presented indicating that reduction in DNA excision repair does not affect point mutation induction (recessive lethals) by those AAs most efficient in ring-oxygen alkylation such as ENU, DEN, N-ethyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (ENNG), and isopropyl methanesulfonate (iPMS): the order of hypermutability of AAs with mei-9L relative to mei-9+ was MMS greater than MNU greater than DMN = EMS greater than iPMS = ENU = DEN = ENNG. When the percentage of lethal mutations induced in mei-9L1 females were plotted against those determined for mei-9+ females, straight lines of following slopes were obtained: MMS = 7.6, MNU = 5.4, DMN = 2.4, EMS = 2.4, and iPMS = ENU = DEN = ENNG = 1. Those findings, together with the recent observation that AAs do not split into two groups when assayed for their ability to cause CL, point to the involvement of different DNA alkylation products in ENU- and DEN-induced chromosome loss vs. that of point mutations. It is concluded that with ENU and DEN chromosomal loss results from N-alkylation products whereas point mutations (SLRL) are the consequence of interactions with oxygen-sites in DNA. Thus, as a consequence of a very dominating role of O-ethylguanine (and possibly O4-alkylation of thymine), N-alkylation in DNA does not contribute measurably to mutation induction in the case of ENU-type mutagens while O-alkylation, very clearly, does not show a positive correlation with the formation of chromosome breakage events in Drosophila. Conversely, it appeared that with MMS-type mutagens (MMS; dimethyl sulfate, DMS; trimethyl phosphate, TMP), alkylation products such as 7-methylguanine and 3-methyladenine, if unrepaired or misrepaired, are potentially mutagenic lesions causing both mutations and chromosomal aberrations.     

Effects of Dose on the Induction of Dominant-Lethal Mutations with Triethylenemelamine in Male Mice

Dose effects of triethylenemelamine (TEM) in the induction of dominant-lethal mutations were studied at the early spermatozoon, midspermatid and spermatocyte stages. The pattern of effects on spermatocytes, unlike midspermatids and early spermatozoa, indicated possible cytotoxic damage, so for the determination of TEM dose-response curves in the induction of genetic damage only the data for midspermatids and early spermatozoa were used. The TEM dose-effect curves for those two stages differ markedly from ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) dose-effect curves. Beginning with the lowest doses at which significant effects are observed, there is a considerably more rapid increase in dominant-lethal effects with dose of EMS than TEM. Another marked difference between the two compounds is in the ratio of the genetically effective dose (as measured by dominant-lethal mutations) to the lethal dose. The ratio is 1:100 for TEM and only 1:3.5 for EMS; thus, TEM is mutagenic far below its toxic level. Obviously, these results have important implications not only for our understanding of the nature of chemical induction and recovery of chromosomal aberrations but also for the practical problems of evaluating the mutagenic effects of chemicals.     

The Zuker collection: a resource for the analysis of autosomal gene function in Drosophila melanogaster

The majority of genes of multicellular organisms encode proteins with functions that are not required for viability but contribute to important physiological functions such as behavior and reproduction. It is estimated that 75% of the genes of Drosophila melanogaster are nonessential. Here we report on a strategy used to establish a large collection of stocks that is suitable for the recovery of mutations in such genes. From approximately 72,000 F(3) cultures segregating for autosomes heavily treated with ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), approximately 12,000 lines in which the treated second or third chromosome survived in homozygous condition were selected. The dose of EMS induced an estimated rate of 1.2-1.5 x 10(-3) mutations/gene and predicts five to six nonessential gene mutations per chromosome and seven to nine alleles per locus in the samples of 6000 second chromosomes and 6000 third chromosomes. Due to mosaic mutations induced in the initial exposure to the mutagen, many of the lines are segregating or are now fixed for lethal mutations on the mutagenized chromosome. The features of this collection, known as the Zuker collection, make it a valuable resource for forward and reverse genetic screens for mutations affecting a wide array of biological functions.     

Different modifications by vanillin in cytotoxicity and genetic changes induced by EMS and H2O2 in cultured Chinese hamster cells.

The modifying effects of vanillin on the cytotoxicity and 6-thioguanine (6TG)-resistant mutations induced by two different types of chemical mutagens, ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), were examined using cultured Chinese hamster V79 cells. The effects of vanillin on H2O2-induced chromosome aberrations were also examined. Vanillin had a dose-dependent enhancing effect on EMS-induced cytotoxicity and 6TG-resistant mutations, when cells were simultaneously treated with vanillin. The post-treatment with vanillin during the mutation expression time of cells after treatment with EMS also showed an enhancement of the frequency of mutations induced by EMS. However, vanillin suppressed the cytotoxicity induced by H2O2 when cells were post-treated with vanillin after H2O2 treatment. Vanillin showed no change in the absence of activity of H2O2 to induce mutations. Post-treatment with vanillin also suppressed the chromosome aberrations induced by H2O2. The differential effects of vanillin were probably due to the quality of mutagen-induced DNA lesions and vanillin might influence at least two different kinds of cellular repair functions. The mechanisms by which vanillin enhances or suppresses chemical-induced cytotoxicity, mutations and chromosome aberrations are discussed.     

Comparative study of the clastogenic efficiency of ethyl methanesulfonate and diethyl sulfate in Drosophila melanogaster mature sperm

Chromosome loss and translocation tests were carried out in Drosophila melanogaster sperm, stored in untreated females for up to 24 days, to compare the clastogenicity of ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) and diethyl sulfate (DES). The sex-linked recessive lethal test was used as a "biological dosimeter" and the following results were obtained: The yield of 2-3 translocations induced by both mutagens increased steadily with storage, being significantly higher after EMS than after DES treatment. The frequencies of partial losses induced by EMS and DES were similar and increased with storage. With up to 11 days' storage, the frequency of complete loss induced by DES was higher than that induced by EMS and remained unchanged when storage was extended to 24 days. Complete loss induced by EMS increased significantly with further storage (12-24 days). With DES, complete (but not partial) loss was detected with a dose at which EMS failed to modify the control values. These data suggest that the lower recovery of II-III translocations after treatment with DES does not result from a low breaking capacity but from a diminished or delayed rejoining of the induced breaks. This could be due to a physiological impairment of the treated cells by the high toxicity of DES or to an actual lower rejoinability of the broken ends. The differential recovery of complete and partial losses after DES treatment further suggests that the mechanisms leading to the fixation of both types of damage are somehow different, and that processes intervening in the recovery of partial losses are less affected, or not at all, by the proposed reduced rejoining of chromosome breaks.     

Unscheduled DNA synthesis in spermatogenic cells of mice treated in vivo with the indirect alkylating agents cyclophosphamide and mitomen

Cyclophosphamide (CPA) and mitomen (DMO) are chemical mutagens that require metabolic activation to produce their biological effect. We have used an in vivo UDS assay in various meiotic and postmeiotic germ-cell stages of male mice to study DNA repair after treatment with these chemicals. EMS, a compound requiring no metabolic activation, was also used for comparative purposes.CPA and DMO induced UDS in meiotic through early-to-midspermatid stages, but no UDS was detected in late spermatids and mature sperm. While EMS produced a maximum UDS response in the germ cells immediately after treatment, CPA and DMO did not produce a maximum response until ～0.5 to 1 h after injection. This delay is attributed to the time required for CPA and DMO to be enzymatically vonverted active alkylating metabolites.Unlike the results found with EMS, mutation frequencies (dominant lethals, translocations, specific-locus mutations) following CPA treatment are not noticeably reduced in germ-cell stages in which UDS occurred. In the case of DMO, mutations are induced only in mature spermatozoa, and these germ-cell stages represent only a fraction of those in which no UDS is detected. The results with CPA and DMO thus still leave unclear the relationship between DNA repair and the differential spermatogenic response of mice to genetic damage.     

Mutagenic and error-free DNA repair in Streptomyces

Summary Two mutants of Streptomyces fradiae defective in DNA repair have been characterized for their responses to the mutagenic and lethal effects of several chemical mutagens and ultraviolet (UV) light. S. fradiae JS2 (mcr-2) was more sensitive than wild type to agents which produce bulky lesions resulting in large distortions of the double helix [i.e. UV-light, 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide (NQO), and mitomycin C (MC)] but not to agents which produce small lesions [i.e. hydroxylamine (HA), methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) and N-methyl-N-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG)]. JS2 expressed a much higher frequency of mutagenesis induced by UV-light at low doses and thus appeared to be defective in an error-free excision repair pathway for bulky lesions analogous to the uvr ABC pathway of Escherichia coli. S. fradiae JS4 (mcr-4) was defective in repair of damage by most agents which produce small or bulky lesions (i.e., HA, NQO, MMS, MNNG, MC, and UV, but not EMS). JS4 was slightly hypermutable by EMS and MMS but showed reduced mutagenesis by NQO and HA. This unusual phenotype suggests that the mcr-4 ⁺ protein plays some role in error-prone repair in S. fradiae.