High Resolution Structural Studies of Cro Repressor Protein and Implications for DNA Recognition

Abstract

Cro repressor is a small dimeric protein that binds to specific sites on the DNA of bacteriophage λ. The structure of Cro has been determined and suggests that the protein binds to its sequence-specific sites with a pair of two-fold related α-helices of the protein located within successive major grooves of the DNA.

From the known three-dimensional structure of the repressor, model building and energy refinement have been used to develop a detailed model for the presumed complex between Cro and DNA. Recognition of specific DNA binding sites appears to occur via multiple hydrogen bonds between amino acid side chains of the protein and base pair atoms exposed within the major groove of DNA. The Cro:DNA model is consistent with the calculated electrostatic potential energy surface of the protein.

From a series of amino acid sequence and gene sequence comparisons, it appears that a number of other DNA-binding proteins have an α-helical DNA-binding region similar to that seen in Cro. The apparent sequence homology includes not only DNA-binding proteins from different bacteriophages, but also gene-regulatory proteins from bacteria and yeast. It has also been found that the conformations of part of the presumed DNA-binding regions of Cro repressor, λ repressor and CAP gene activator proteins are strikingly similar. Taken together, these results strongly suggest that a two-helical structural unit occurs in the DNA-binding region of many proteins that regulate gene expression. However, the results to date do not suggest that there is a simple one-to-one recognition code between amino acids and bases.

Crystals have been obtained of complexes of Cro with six-base-pair and nine-basepair DNA oligomers, and X-ray analysis of these co-crystals is in progress.     

Prediction of 3-D Structure of the Cro Protein from Phage 434

Abstract

A comparative model building process has been utilized to predict (he three-dimensional structure of the bacteriophage 434 Cro protein, Amino acid sequence similarities between the 434 Cro protein and other bacteriophage repressor and Cro proteins have been used, in conjunction with secondary structure prediction and the known structures of other base sequence specific DNA binding proteins, to derive the model. From this model the interactions between the 434 Cro protein and its operator DNA have been deduced. These proposed interactions are consistent with the known properties of the bacteriophage 434 Cro protein.     

Prediction of 3-D structure of the Cro protein from phage 434

A comparative model building process has been utilized to predict the three-dimensional structure of the bacteriophage 434 Cro protein. Amino acid sequence similarities between the 434 Cro protein and other bacteriophage repressor and Cro proteins have been used, in conjunction with secondary structure prediction and the known structures of other base sequence specific DNA binding proteins, to derive the model. From this model the interactions between the 434 Cro protein and its operator DNA have been deduced. These proposed interactions are consistent with the known properties of the bacteriophage 434 Cro protein.     

How lambda repressor and lambda Cro distinguish between OR1 and OR3

Although lambda repressor and lambda Cro bind to the same six operators on the phage chromosome, the fine specificities of the two proteins differ: repressor binds more tightly to OR1 than to OR3, and vice versa for Cro. In this paper, we change base pairs in the operators and amino acids in the proteins to analyze the basis for these preferences. We find that these preferences are determined by residues 5 and 6 of the recognition helices of the two proteins and by the amino-terminal arm, in the case of repressor. We also find that the most important base pairs in the operator which enable repressor and Cro to discriminate between OR1 and OR3 are position 3 (for Cro) and positions 5 and 8 (for repressor). These and previous results show how repressor and Cro recognize and distinguish between two related operator sequences.     

Combinatorial redesign of the DNA binding specificity of a prokaryotic helix-turn-helix repressor

Redesign of the bacteriophage 434 Cro repressor was accomplished by using an in vivo genetic screening system to identify new variants that specifically bound previously unrecognized DNA sequences. Site-directed, combinatorial mutagenesis of the 434 Cro helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif generated libraries of new variants which were screened for binding to new target sequences. Multiple mutations of 434 Cro that functionally converted wild-type (wt) 434 Cro DNA binding-sequence specificity to that of a lambda bacteriophage-specific repressor were identified. The libraries contained variations within the HTH sequence at only three positions. In vivo and in vitro analysis of several of the identified 434 Cro variants showed that the relatively few changes in the recognition helix of the HTH motif of 434 Cro resulted in specific and tight binding of the target DNA sequences. For the best 434 Cro variant identified, an apparent K(d) for lambda O(R)3 of 1 nM was observed. In competition experiments, this Cro variant was observed to be highly selective. We conclude that functional 434 Cro repressor variants with new DNA binding specificities can be generated from wt 434 Cro by mutating just the recognition helix. Important characteristics of the screening system responsible for the successful identifications are discussed. Application of the techniques presented here may allow the identification of DNA binding protein variants that functionally affect DNA regulatory sequences important in disease and industrial and biotechnological processes.     

Changes in the Functional Activity of Phi11 Cro Protein is Mediated by Various Ions

Phi11, a temperate bacteriophage of Staphylococcus aureus, has been found to harbor a cro repressor gene which facilitates Phi11 to adopt the lytic mode of development. The Cro protein has been found to bind very specifically to a 15-bp operator DNA, located in the Phi11 cI–cro intergenic region [1]. To investigate the effects exerted by different ions upon the interaction between Cro and its cognate operator DNA, we have employed gel shift assays as well as circular dichroism spectral analysis. In this communication, we have shown that NH₄ ⁺ and acetate^? ions better facilitated the binding of Cro with its cognate operator as compared to Na⁺, K⁺ and Li⁺. Interestingly, Mg²⁺, carbonate^2? and Citrate^3? have an inhibitory effect upon the binding. The effect of the said ions upon the structure of Cro was also investigated by circular dichroism and it was found that other than Citrate^3? ions, none of the other ions destabilised the protein. On the other hand, Mg²⁺ and carbonate^2? ions maintained the structure of the protein but severely hampered its functional activity. Citrate^3? ions severely unfolded Cro and also inhibited its function. Considering all the data, NH₄ ⁺ and acetate^? ions appeared to be more suitable in maintaining the biological activity of Cro.     

A comparative study of dynamic structures between phage 434 Cro and repressor proteins by normal mode analysis

Two DNA binding proteins, Cro and the amino-terminal domain of the repressor of bacteriophage 434 (434 Cro and 434 repressor) that regulate gene expression and contain a helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif responsible for their site-specific DNA recognition adopt very similar three-dimensional structures when compared to each other. To reveal structural differences between these two similar proteins, their dynamic structures, as examined by normal mode analysis, are compared in this paper. Two kinds of structural data, one for the monomer and the other for a complex with DNA, for each protein, are used in the analyses. From a comparison between the monomers it is found that the interactions of Ala-24 in 434 Cro or Val-24 in 434 repressor, both located in the HTH motif, with residues 44, 47, 48, and 51 located in the domain facing the motif, and the interactions between residues 17, 18, 28, and 32, located in the HTH motif, cause significant differences in the correlative motions of these residues. From the comparison between the monomer and the complex with DNA for each protein, it was found that the first helix in the HTH motif is distorted in the complex form. While the residues in the HTH motif in 434 Cro have relatively larger positive correlation coefficients of motions with other residues within the HTH motif, such correlations are not large in the HTH motif of 434 repressor. It is suggestive to their specificity because the 434 repressor is less specific than 434 Cro. Although a structural comparison of proteins has been performed mainly from a static or geometrical point of view, this study demonstrates that the comparison from a dynamic point of view, using the normal mode analysis, is useful and convenient to explore a difference that is difficult to find only from a geometrical point of view, especially for proteins very similar in structure. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Bending of synthetic bacteriophage 434 operators by bacteriophage 434 proteins.

The extent of DNA bending induced by 434 repressor, its amino terminal DNA binding domain (R1-69), and 434 Cro was studied by gel shift assay. The results show that 434 repressor and R1-69 bend DNA to the same extent. 434 Cro-induced DNA bends are similar to those seen with the 434 repressor proteins. On approximately 265 base pair fragments, the cyclic AMP receptor protein of Escherichia coli (CRP) produces larger mobility shifts than does 434 repressor. This indicates that the 434 proteins bend DNA to a much smaller extent than does CRP. The effects of central operator sequence on intrinsic and 434 protein-induced DNA bending was also examined by gel shift assay. Two 434 operators having different central sequences and affinities for 434 proteins display no static bending. The amount of gel shift induced by 434 repressor on these operators is identical, showing that the 434 repressor bends operators with different central sequences to the same extent. Hence, mutations in the central region of the operator do not influence the bent structure of the unbound or bound operator.     

Many gene-regulatory proteins appear to have a similar α-helical fold that binds DNA and evolved from a common precursor

Summary Amino acid and DNA sequence comparisons suggest that many sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins have in common and homologous region of about 22 amino acids. This region corresponds to two consecutive α-helices that occur in bot Cro and cI repressor proteins of bacteriophage λ and in catabolite gene activator protein ofEscherichia coli and are presumed to interact with DNA. The results obtained here suggest that this α-helical DNA-binding fold occurs in many proteins that regulate gene expression. It also appears that this DNA-binding unit evolved from a common evolutionary precursor.     

Determinants of bacteriophage 933W repressor DNA binding specificity

We reported previously that 933W repressor apparently does not cooperatively bind to adjacent sites on DNA and that the relative affinities of 933W repressor for its operators differ significantly from that of any other lambdoid bacteriophage. These findings indicate that the operational details of the lysis-lysogeny switch of bacteriophage 933W are unique among lambdoid bacteriophages. Since the functioning of the lysis-lysogeny switch in 933W bacteriophage uniquely and solely depends on the order of preference of 933W repressor for its operators, we examined the details of how 933W repressor recognizes its DNA sites. To identify the specificity determinants, we first created a molecular model of the 933W repressor-DNA complex and tested the predicted protein-DNA interactions. These results of these studies provide a picture of how 933W repressor recognizes its DNA sites. We also show that, opposite of what is normally observed for lambdoid phages, 933W operator sequences have evolved in such a way that the presence of the most commonly found base sequences at particular operator positions serves to decrease, rather than increase, the affinity of the protein for the site. This finding cautions against assuming that a consensus sequence derived from sequence analysis defines the optimal, highest affinity DNA binding site for a protein.     

Immunity repressor of bacteriophage P2: Identification and DNA-binding activity

The product of gene C of the temperate bacteriophage P2, the immunity repressor, can be detected as a unique band eluting from phosphocellulose columns at 0.12 m-potassium phosphate when differentially labelled with a radioactive amino acid: the band is absent when phages that either have lost gene C through deletion or carry a suppressor-sensitive mutation in the gene are used. The repressor in its monomeric form is about 11,000 in molecular weight. At near physiological salt concentrations, the form predominantly recovered is the dimer.In filter-binding assays, the partially purified repressor binds wild-type P2 DNA strongly. It does not bind DNA of P2 vir94, a deletion that removes all the genetic elements involved in the regulation of lysogeny; it also does not bind, or binds inefficiently, DNA of P2 vir3, a mutation in the operator that controls the early replicative functions of P2. At the concentrations employed, the dimer is the active form in binding.The P2 repressor clearly differs in several features from the well-studied immunity repressor of bacteriophage lambda.     

A code governing specific binding of regulatory proteins to DNA and structure of stereospecific sites of regulatory proteins]

A model is proposed for the structure of stereospecific sites in regulatory proteins. On its basis a possible code is suggested that governs the binding of regulatory proteins at specific control sites on DNA. Stereospecific sites of regulatory proteins are assumed to contain pairs of antiparallel polypeptide chain segments which form a right-hand twisted antiparallel beta-sheet, with single-stranded regions at the ends of the beta-structure. The model predicts that binding reaction between a regulatory protein and double-helical DNA is a cooperative phenomenon and is accompanied by significant structural alteration at the stereospecific site of the protein. Half of hydrogen bonds normally existing in beta-structure are broken upon complex formation with DNA and a new set of hydrogen bonds is formed between polypeptide amide groups and DNA base pairs. In a stereospecific site, one chain (t-chain) is attached through hydrogen bonds to the carbonyl oxygens of pyramides and N3 adenines lying in one DNA strand, while the second polypeptide chain (g chain) is hydrogen bonded to the 2-amino groups of guanine residues lying in the opposite DNA strand. The amide groups serve as specific reaction sites being hydrogen bond acceptors in g-chain and hydrogen bond donors in t-chain. The single-stranded portions of t- and g-chains lying in neighbouring subunits of regulatory protein interact with each other forming deformed beta-sheets. The recognition of regulatory sequences by proteins is based on the structural complementarity between stereospecific sites of regulatory proteins and base pairs sequences at the control sites. An essential feature of these sequences is the asymmetrical distribution of guanine residues between the two DNA strands. The code predicts that there are six fundamental amino acid residues (serine, threonine, asparagine, histidine, glutamine and cysteine) whose sequence in stereospecific site determines the base pair sequence to which a given regulatory protein would bind preferentially. The code states a correspondence between four amino acid residues at the stereospecific site of regulatory protein with the two residues being in t- and g-segments, respectively, and AT(GC) base pair at the control site. It is thus possible to determine which amino acid residues in the repressor and which base pairs in the operator DNA are involved in specific interactions with each other, as exemplified by lac repressor binding to lac operator.     

Crystal structure of the P2 C-repressor: a binder of non-palindromic direct DNA repeats

As opposed to the vast majority of prokaryotic repressors, the immunity repressor of temperate Escherichia coli phage P2 (C) recognizes non-palindromic direct repeats of DNA rather than inverted repeats. We have determined the crystal structure of P2 C at 1.8 Å. This constitutes the first structure solved from the family of C proteins from P2-like bacteriophages. The structure reveals that the P2 C protein forms a symmetric dimer oriented to bind the major groove of two consecutive turns of the DNA. Surprisingly, P2 C has great similarities to binders of palindromic sequences. Nevertheless, the two identical DNA-binding helixes of the symmetric P2 C dimer have to bind different DNA sequences. Helix 3 is identified as the DNA-recognition motif in P2 C by alanine scanning and the importance for the individual residues in DNA recognition is defined. A truncation mutant shows that the disordered C-terminus is dispensable for repressor function. The short distance between the DNA-binding helices together with a possible interaction between two P2 C dimers are proposed to be responsible for extensive bending of the DNA. The structure provides insight into the mechanisms behind the mutants of P2 C causing dimer disruption, temperature sensitivity and insensitivity to the P4 antirepressor.     

Secondary structure switching in Cro protein evolution

We report the solution structure of the Cro protein from bacteriophage P22. Comparisons of its sequence and structure to those of lambda Cro strongly suggest an alpha-to-beta secondary structure switching event during Cro evolution. The folds of P22 Cro and lambda Cro share a three alpha helix fragment comprising the N-terminal half of the domain. However, P22 Cro's C terminus folds as two helices, while lambda Cro's folds as a beta hairpin. The all-alpha fold found for P22 Cro appears to be ancestral, since it also occurs in cI proteins, which are anciently duplicated paralogues of Cro. PSI-BLAST and transitive homology analyses strongly suggest that the sequences of P22 Cro and lambda Cro are globally homologous despite encoding different folds. The alpha+beta fold of lambda Cro therefore likely evolved from its all-alpha ancestor by homologous secondary structure switching, rather than by nonhomologous replacement of both sequence and structure.