Differential expression of thyroid hormone receptor isoforms dictates the dominant negative activity of mutant Beta receptor

Mutations in the thyroid hormone receptor beta gene (TRbeta) cause resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH). Genetic analyses indicate that phenotypic manifestation of RTH is due to the dominant negative action of mutant TRbeta. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying the dominant negative action of mutants and how the same mutation results in marked variability of resistance in different tissues in vivo are not clear. Here we used a knock-in mouse (TRbetaPV mouse) that faithfully reproduces human RTH to address these questions. We demonstrated directly that TRbeta1 protein was approximately 3-fold higher than TRalpha1 in the liver of TRbeta(+/+) mice but was not detectable in the heart of wild-type and TRbetaPV mice. The abundance of PV in the liver of TRbeta(PV/PV) was more than TRbeta(PV/+) mice but not detectable in the heart. TRalpha1 in the liver was approximately 6-fold higher than that in the heart of wild-type and TRbetaPV mice. Using TR isoforms and PV-specific antibodies in gel shift assays, we found that in vivo, PV competed not only with TR isoforms for binding to thyroid hormone response elements (TRE) but also competed with TR for the retinoid X receptors in binding to TRE. These competitions led to the inhibition of the thyroid hormone (T(3))-positive regulated genes in the liver. In the heart, however, PV was significantly lower and thus could not effectively compete with TRalpha1 for binding to TRE, resulting in activation of the T(3)-target genes by higher levels of circulating thyroid hormones. These results indicate that in vivo, differential expression of TR isoforms in tissues dictates the dominant negative activity of mutant beta receptor, thereby resulting in variable phenotypic expression in RTH.     

Cell type-dependent modulation of the dominant negative action of human mutant thyroid hormone beta 1 receptors.

BACKGROUND: Mutations in the ligand-binding domain of the thyroid hormone receptor beta (TR beta) gene cause the syndrome of resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH). The clinical phenotype results from the antagonism of the normal TR alpha and the non-mutated TR beta alleles by the TR beta 1 mutants, via a dominant negative effect. There is, however, marked heterogeneity of organ resistance within and among kindreds with RTH. This study examines the potential role of cell type in modulating the dominant negative potency of human TR beta 1 (h-TR beta 1) mutants. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Transient transfections were performed in HeLa and NIH3T3 cells, using a wild type (WT) and three naturally occurring mutant h-TR beta 1 constructs, and three natural thyroid hormone response elements (TREs). Immunocytochemistry was performed to detect levels of TR beta 1 expression in these two cell types. In order to determine how TR beta 1 interacts with other cellular partners, gel-shift analyses using HeLa and NIH3T3 nuclear extracts were performed. RESULTS: Transfection studies using WT h-TR beta 1 in HeLa and NIH3T3 cells, showed that the 3,3',5-triiodothyronine (T3)-induced transactivation of the different TREs varied between cell types. Unlike the non-T3-binding h-TR beta 1 mutant, PV, mutants ED and OK displayed the expected T3-induced dose responsiveness in these two cell types. For each TRE examined, the magnitude of the dominant negative effect varied between the cell types. The levels of receptor expression in HeLa and NIH3T3 cells were identical, as determined by immunocytochemistry. Gel-shift analyses showed differences in the formation of hetero- and homodimers depending on both the cell type and TRE motif. CONCLUSIONS: The cell type in which a mutant receptor operates affects the relative amounts of hetero- and homodimers. Together with the nature of the mutation and the TRE-motif, this could modulate the dominant negative action of mutant receptors in different tissues, which, in turn, could contribute to the variable phenotypic characteristics of RTH.     

Marked potentiation of the dominant negative action of a mutant thyroid hormone receptor beta in mice by the ablation of one wild-type beta allele

Mutations in the thyroid hormone receptor (TR) beta gene result in resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH), characterized by reduced sensitivity of tissues to thyroid hormone. To understand which physiological TR pathways are affected by mutant receptors, we crossed mice with a dominantly negative TRbeta mutation (TRbetaPV) with mice carrying a TRbeta null mutation (TRbeta(-/-)) to determine the consequences of the TRbetaPV mutation in the absence of wild-type TRbeta. TRbeta(PV/-) mice are distinct from TRbeta(+/-) mice that did not show abnormalities in thyroid function tests. TRbeta(PV/-) mice are also distinct from TRbeta(PV/+) and TRbeta(-/-) mice in that the latter shows mild dysfunction in the pituitary-thyroid axis, whereas the former exhibit very severe abnormalities, including extensive papillary hyperplasia of the thyroid epithelium, indistinguishable from that observed in TRbeta(PV/PV) mice. Similar to TRbeta(PV/PV) mice, TRbeta(PV/-) mice exhibited impairment in weight gain. Moreover, the abnormal regulation patterns of T3-target genes in the tissues of TRbeta(PV/-) and TRbeta(PV/PV) mice were strikingly similar. Using TR isoforms and PV-specific antibodies in gel shift assays, we found that in vivo, PV competed with TRalpha1 for binding to thyroid hormone response elements in TRbeta(PV/-) mice as effectively as in TRbeta(PV/PV) mice. Thus, the actions of mutant TRbeta are markedly potentiated by the ablation of the second TRbeta allele, suggesting that interference with wild-type TRalpha1-mediated gene regulation by mutant TRbeta leads to severe RTH.     

Compensatory role of thyroid hormone receptor (TR) alpha 1 in resistance to thyroid hormone: study in mice with a targeted mutation in the TR beta gene and deficient in TR alpha 1

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is caused by mutations of the thyroid hormone receptor beta (TR beta) gene. Almost all RTH patients are heterozygous with an autosomal dominant pattern of inheritance. That most are clinically euthyroid suggests a compensatory role of the TR alpha1 isoform in maintaining the normal functions of thyroid hormone (T3) in these patients. To understand the role of TR alpha1 in the manifestation of RTH, we compared the phenotypes of mice with a targeted dominantly negative mutant TR beta (TR betaPV) with or without TR alpha1. TR betaPV mice faithfully recapitulate RTH in humans in that these mice demonstrate abnormalities in the pituitary-thyroid axis and impairment in growth. Here we show that the dysregulation of the pituitary-thyroid axis was worsened by the lack of TR alpha1 in TR betaPV mice, and severe impairment of postnatal growth was manifested in TR betaPV mice deficient in TR alpha1. Furthermore, abnormal expression patterns of T3-target genes in TR betaPV mice were altered by the lack of TR alpha1. These results demonstrate that the lack of TR alpha1 exacerbates the manifestation of RTH in TR betaPV mice. Therefore, TR alpha1 could play a compensatory role in mediating the functions of T3 in heterozygous patients with RTH. This compensatory role may be especially crucial for postnatal growth.     

Differential recruitment of nuclear coregulators directs the isoform-dependent action of mutant thyroid hormone receptors

Studies using mice deficient in thyroid hormone receptors (TR) indicate that the two TR isoforms, TRα1 and TRβ1, in addition to mediating overlapping biological activities of the thyroid hormone, T3, also mediate distinct functions. Mice harboring an identical dominant negative mutation (denoted PV) at the C terminus of TRα1 (Thra1(PV) mice) or β1 (Thrb(PV) mice) also exhibit distinct phenotypes. These knockin mutant mice provide an opportunity to understand the molecular basis of isoform-dependent functions in vivo. Here we tested the hypothesis that the distinct functions of TR mutant isoforms are directed by a subset of nuclear regulatory proteins. Tandem-affinity chromatography of HeLa nuclear extracts showed that distinct 33 nuclear proteins including nuclear receptor corepressor (NCoR1) and six other proteins preferentially associated with TRα1PV or TRβ1PV, respectively. These results indicate that recruitment of nuclear regulatory proteins by TR mutants is subtype dependent. The involvement of NCoR1 in mediating the distinct liver phenotype of Thra1(PV) and Thrb(PV) mice was further explored. NCoR1 preferentially interacted with TRα1PV rather than with TRβ1PV. NCoR1 was recruited more avidly to the thyroid hormone response element-bound TRα1PV than to TRβ1PV in the promoter of the CCAAT/enhancer-binding protein α gene to repress its expression in the liver of Thra1(PV) mice, but not in Thrb(PV) mice. This preferential recruitment of NCoR1 by mutant isoforms could contribute, at least in part, to the distinct liver lipid phenotype of these mutant mice. The present study highlights a novel mechanism by which TR isoforms direct their selective functions via preferential recruitment of a subset of nuclear coregulatory proteins.     

Serum copper as a novel biomarker for resistance to thyroid hormone

Thyroid hormone action is mediated by the thyroid hormone receptors TRα1 and TRβ. Defects in TRβ lead to RTH (resistance to thyroid hormone) β, a syndrome characterized by high levels of thyroid hormone and non-suppressed TSH (thyroid-stimulating hormone). However, a correct diagnosis of RTHβ patients is difficult as the clinical picture varies. A biochemical serum marker indicative of defects in TRβ signalling is needed and could simplify the diagnosis of RTHβ, in particular the differentiation to TSH-secreting pituitary adenomas, which present with clinically similar symptoms. In the present paper we show that serum copper levels are regulated by thyroid hormone, which stimulates the synthesis and the export of the hepatic copper-transport protein ceruloplasmin into the serum. This is accompanied by a concerted reduction in the mRNA levels of other copper-containing proteins such as metallothioneins 1 and 2 or superoxide dismutase 1. The induction of serum copper is abolished in genetically hyperthyroid mice lacking TRβ and human RTHβ patients, demonstrating an important role of TRβ for this process. Together with a previously reported TRα1 specific regulation of serum selenium, we show that the ratio of serum copper and selenium, which is largely independent of thyroid hormone levels, volume changes or sample degradation, can constitute a valuable novel biomarker for RTHβ. Moreover, it could also provide a suitable large-scale screening parameter to identify RTHα patients, which have not been identified to date.     

Resistance to thyroid hormone mediated by defective thyroid hormone receptor alpha

Background

Thyroid hormone acts via receptor subtypes (TRα1, TRβ1, TRβ2) with differing tissue distributions, encoded by distinct genes (THRA, THRB). THRB mutations cause a disorder with central (hypothalamic–pituitary) resistance to thyroid hormone action with markedly elevated thyroid hormone and normal TSH levels.

Scope of review

This review describes the clinical features, genetic and molecular pathogenesis of a homologous human disorder mediated by defective THRA. Clinical features include growth retardation, skeletal dysplasia and constipation associated with low-normal T4 and high-normal T3 levels and a low T4/T3 ratio, together with subnormal reverse T3 levels. Heterozygous TRa1 mutations in affected individuals generate defective mutant receptors which inhibit wild-type receptor action in a dominant negative manner.

Major conclusions

Mutations in human TRα1 mediate RTH with features of hypothyroidism in particular tissues (e.g. skeleton, gastrointestinal tract), but are not associated with a markedly dysregulated pituitary–thyroid axis.

General significance

Human THRA mutations could be more common but may have eluded discovery due to the absence of overt thyroid dysfunction. Nevertheless, in the appropriate clinical context, a thyroid biochemical signature (low T4/T3 ratio, subnormal reverse T3 levels), may enable future identification of cases.This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Thyroid hormone signalling.     

Advanced bone formation in mice with a dominant-negative mutation in the thyroid hormone receptor β gene due to activation of Wnt/β-catenin protein signaling

Thyroid hormone (T(3)) acts in chondrocytes and bone-forming osteoblasts to control bone development and maintenance, but the signaling pathways mediating these effects are poorly understood. Thrb(PV/PV) mice have a severely impaired pituitary-thyroid axis and elevated thyroid hormone levels due to a dominant-negative mutant T(3) receptor (TRβ(PV)) that cannot bind T(3) and interferes with the actions of wild-type TR. Thrb(PV/PV) mice have accelerated skeletal development due to unknown mechanisms. We performed microarray studies in primary osteoblasts from wild-type mice and Thrb(PV/PV) mice. Activation of the canonical Wnt signaling in Thrb(PV/PV) mice was confirmed by in situ hybridization analysis of Wnt target gene expression in bone during postnatal growth. By contrast, T(3) treatment inhibited Wnt signaling in osteoblastic cells, suggesting that T(3) inhibits the Wnt pathway by facilitating proteasomal degradation of β-catenin and preventing its accumulation in the nucleus. Activation of the Wnt pathway in Thrb(PV/PV) mice, however, results from a gain of function for TRβ(PV) that stabilizes β-catenin despite the presence of increased thyroid hormone levels. These studies demonstrate novel interactions between T(3) and Wnt signaling pathways in the regulation of skeletal development and bone formation.     

A thyrotoxic skeletal phenotype of advanced bone formation in mice with resistance to thyroid hormone

Thyroid hormone (T3) regulates bone turnover and mineralization in adults and is essential for skeletal development during childhood. Hyperthyroidism is an established risk factor for osteoporosis. Nevertheless, T3 actions in bone remain poorly understood. Patients with resistance to thyroid hormone, due to mutations of the T3-receptor beta (TRbeta) gene, display variable phenotypic abnormalities, particularly in the skeleton. To investigate the actions of T3 during bone development, we characterized the skeleton in TRbetaPV mutant mice. TRbetaPV mice harbor a targeted resistance to thyroid hormone mutation in TRbeta and recapitulate the human condition. A severe phenotype, which includes shortened body length, was evident in homozygous TRbetaPV/PV animals. Accelerated growth in utero was associated with advanced endochondral and intramembranous ossification. Advanced bone formation resulted in postnatal growth retardation, premature quiescence of the growth plates, and shortened bone length, together with increased bone mineralization and craniosynostosis. In situ hybridization demonstrated increased expression of fibroblast growth factor receptor-1, a T3-regulated gene in bone, in TRbetaPV/PV perichondrium, growth plate chondrocytes, and osteoblasts. Thus, the skeleton in TRbetaPV/PV mice is thyrotoxic and displays phenotypic features typical of juvenile hyperthyroidism.     

Contrasting skeletal phenotypes in mice with an identical mutation targeted to thyroid hormone receptor alpha1 or beta

Thyroid hormone (T(3)) regulates bone turnover and mineralization in adults and is essential for skeletal development. Surprisingly, we identified a phenotype of skeletal thyrotoxicosis in T(3) receptor beta(PV) (TRbeta(PV)) mice in which a targeted frameshift mutation in TRbeta results in resistance to thyroid hormone. To characterize mechanisms underlying thyroid hormone action in bone, we analyzed skeletal development in TRalpha1(PV) mice in which the same PV mutation was targeted to TRalpha1. In contrast to TRbeta(PV) mice, TRalpha1(PV) mutants exhibited skeletal hypothyroidism with delayed endochondral and intramembranous ossification, severe postnatal growth retardation, diminished trabecular bone mineralization, reduced cortical bone deposition, and delayed closure of the skull sutures. Skeletal hypothyroidism in TRalpha1(PV) mutants was accompanied by impaired GH receptor and IGF-I receptor expression and signaling in the growth plate, whereas GH receptor and IGF-I receptor expression and signaling were increased in TRbeta(PV) mice. These data indicate that GH receptor and IGF-I receptor are physiological targets for T(3) action in bone in vivo. The divergent phenotypes observed in TRalpha1(PV) and TRbeta(PV) mice arise because the pituitary gland is a TRbeta-responsive tissue, whereas bone is TRalpha responsive. These studies provide a new understanding of the complex relationship between central and peripheral thyroid status.     

Contrasting developmental and tissue-specific expression of alpha and beta thyroid hormone receptor genes.

Thyroid hormones and their receptors (TRs) have critical functions in development. Here we show that a chicken TR beta cDNA clone encodes a receptor with a novel, short N-terminal domain. In vitro-expressed TR beta protein bound thyroid hormone with similar affinity as the chicken TR alpha. Comparison of expression of TR alpha and TR beta mRNAs throughout chicken development until 3 weeks post-hatching revealed ubiquitous expression of TR alpha mRNAs (in 14 different tissues) with some variations in levels, from early embryonic stages. In contast, expression of TR beta mRNA was restricted, occurring notably in brain, eye, lung, yolk sac and kidney, and was subject to striking developmental control, especially in brain where levels increased 30-fold upon hatching. Levels also sharply increased in late embryonic lung, but were relatively high earlier in embryonic eye and yolk sac. RNase protection analyses detected no obvious mRNAs for alpha and beta TRs with variant C-termini as demonstrated previously for the rat TR alpha gene. The data suggest a general role for TR alpha and specific developmental functions for TR beta, and that thyroid-dependent development involves temporal and tissue-specific expression of the TR beta gene.     

An unliganded thyroid hormone beta receptor activates the cyclin D1/cyclin-dependent kinase/retinoblastoma/E2F pathway and induces pituitary tumorigenesis

Thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH)-secreting tumors (TSH-omas) are pituitary tumors that constitutively secrete TSH. The molecular genetics underlying this abnormality are not known. We discovered that a knock-in mouse harboring a mutated thyroid hormone receptor (TR) beta (PV; TRbeta(PV/PV) mouse) spontaneously developed TSH-omas. TRbeta(PV/PV) mice lost the negative feedback regulation with highly elevated TSH levels associated with increased thyroid hormone levels (3,3',5-triiodo-l-thyronine [T3]). Remarkably, we found that mice deficient in all TRs (TRalpha1(-/-) TRbeta(-/-)) had similarly increased T3 and TSH levels, but no discernible TSH-omas, indicating that the dysregulation of the pituitary-thyroid axis alone is not sufficient to induce TSH-omas. Comparison of gene expression profiles by cDNA microarrays identified overexpression of cyclin D1 mRNA in TRbeta(PV/PV) but not in TRalpha1(-/-) TRbeta(-/-) mice. Overexpression of cyclin D1 protein led to activation of the cyclin D1/cyclin-dependent kinase/retinoblastoma protein/E2F pathway only in TRbeta(PV/PV) mice. The liganded TRbeta repressed cyclin D1 expression via tethering to the cyclin D1 promoter through binding to the cyclic AMP response element-binding protein. That repression effect was lost in mutant PV, thereby resulting in constitutive activation of cyclin D1 in TRbeta(PV/PV) mice. The present study revealed a novel molecular mechanism by which an unliganded TRbeta mutant acts to contribute to pituitary tumorigenesis in vivo and provided mechanistic insights into the understanding of pathogenesis of TSH-omas in patients.