The signature of seeds in resurrection plants: a molecular and physiological comparison of desiccation tolerance in seeds and vegetative tissues

Desiccation-tolerance in vegetative tissues of angiosperms hasa polyphyletic origin and could be due to 1) appropriation ofthe seed-specific program of gene expression that protects orthodoxseeds against desiccation, and/or 2) a sustainable version ofthe abiotic stress response. We tested these hypotheses by comparingmolecular and physiological data from the development of orthodoxseeds, the response of desiccation-sensitive plants to abioticstress, and the response of desiccation-tolerant plants to extremewater loss. Analysis of publicly-available gene expression dataof 35 LEA proteins and 68 anti-oxidant enzymes in the desiccation-sensitiveArabidopsis thaliana identified 13 LEAs and 4 anti-oxidantsexclusively expressed in seeds. Two (a LEA6 and 1-cys-peroxiredoxin)are not expressed in vegetative tissues in A. thaliana, buthave orthologues that are specifically activated in desiccatingleaves of Xerophyta humilis. A comparison of antioxidant enzymeactivity in two desiccation-sensitive species of Eragrostiswith the desiccation-tolerant E. nindensis showed equivalentresponses upon initial dehydration, but activity was retainedat low water content in E. nindensis only. We propose that theseantioxidants are housekeeping enzymes and that they are protectedfrom damage in the desiccation-tolerant species. Sucrose isconsidered an important protectant against desiccation in orthodoxseeds, and we show that sucrose accumulates in drying leavesof E. nindensis, but not in the desiccation-sensitive Eragrostisspecies. The activation of "seed-specific" desiccation protectionmechanisms (sucrose accumulation and expression of LEA6 and1-cys-peroxiredoxin genes) in the vegetative tissues of desiccation-tolerantplants points towards acquisition of desiccation tolerance fromseeds.     

Desiccation Tolerance Studied in the Resurrection Plant Craterostigma plantagineum

This review will focus on the acquisition of desiccation tolerancein the resurrection plant Craterostigma plantagineum. Molecularaspects of desiccation tolerance in this plant will be comparedwith the response of non-tolerant plants to dehydration. Uniquefeatures of C. plantagineum are described like the CDT-1 (Craterostigmadesiccation tolerance gene-1) gene and the carbohydrate metabolism.Abundant proteins which are associated with the desiccationtolerance phenomenon are the late embryogenesis abundant (=LEA)proteins. These proteins are very hydrophilic and occur in severalother species which have acquired desiccation tolerance.     

Freeze-substitution of dehydrated plant tissues: Artefacts of aqueous fixation revisited

Summary This investigation assessed the extent of rehydration of dehydrated plant tissues during aqueous fixation in comparison with the fine structure revealed by freeze-substitution. Radicles from desiccation-tolerant pea (Pisum sativum L.), desiccation-sensitive jackfruit seeds (Artocarpus heterophyllus Lamk.), and leaves of the resurrection plantEragrostis nindensis Ficalho & Hiern. were selected for their developmentally diverse characteristics. Following freeze-substitution, electron microscopy of dehydrated cells revealed variable wall infolding. Plasmalemmas had a trilaminar appearance and were continuous and closely appressed to cell walls, while the cytoplasm was compacted but ordered. Following aqueous fixation, separation of the plasmalemma and the cell wall, membrane vesiculation and distortion of cellular substructure were evident in all material studied. The sectional area enclosed by the cell wall in cortical cells of dehydrated pea and jackfruit radicles and mesophyll ofE. nindensis increased after aqueous fixation by 55, 20, and 30%, respectively. Separation of the plasmalemma and the cell wall was attributed to the characteristics of aqueous fixatives, which limited the expansion of the plasmalemma and cellular contents but not that of the cell wall. It is proposed that severed plasmodesmatal connections, plasmalemma discontinuities, and membrane vesiculation that frequently accompany separation of walls and protoplasm are artefacts of aqueous fixation and should not be interpreted as evidence of desiccation damage or membrane recycling. Evidence suggests that, unlike aqueous fixation, freeze-substitution facilitates reliable preservation of tissues in the dehydrated state and is therefore essential for ultrastructural studies of desiccation.Abbreviations LM light microscopy - TEM transmission electron microscopy - CF conventional (aqueous) fixation - FS freeze-substitution - ER endoplasmic reticulum     

The effect of dehydration and rehydration on the nitrogen content of various fractions from resurrection plants

Nitrogen contents were determined in 20 species of “resurrection plants”,i.e. plants with leaves which are able to revive from an air-dry state (viz. Boea hygroscopica, Borya nitida, Cheilanthes sieberi, Coleochloa pallidior, C. setifera, Craterostigma plantagineum, Myrothamnus flabellifolia, Oropetium capense, Pellaea calomelanos, P. falcata, P, viridis, Polypodium polypodioides, Ramondia pyrenaica, Selaginella lepidophylla, Sporobolus stapfianus, Talbotia elegans,Tripogon loliiformis, Xerophyta retinervis, X. villosa, X. viscosa), and in three desiccation sensitive species (Eragrostis tenuifolia, Selaginella kraussiana andSporobolus pyramidalis). In a preponderance of resurrection plants insoluble nitrogen content fell during dehydration of intact plants and soluble non-protein N rose. Both changes were particularly marked in species which lose chlorophyll and thylakoid structure during drying. These trends were usually only partially reversed after 24 h rehydration. Recovery of¹⁴C-leucine incorporation in rehydrating leaves was slow. Leaves of desiccation sensitive vascular plants tended on the average to lose soluble protein rather than insoluble N during drying, and tended to have higher soluble non-protein N contents than tolerant plants. However, similarity in the changes in N-contents inXerophyta villosa leaves killed by airdrying compared to leaves surviving air-drying, opposes the view that death was due to excessive loss of protein.     

Molecular characterization of two alanine-rich Lea genes abundantly expressed in the resurrection plant C. plantagineum in response to osmotic stress and ABA

Expression of many genes is induced during dehydration in vegetative tissues of the desiccation tolerant resurrection plantCraterostigma plantagineum. The most abundant group of desiccation-related gene products belong to the LEA (= Late Embryogenesis Abundant) proteins. Here we describe structures and expression patterns of members of group 3 and group 4Lea genes fromC. plantagineum. The most intriguing observation is the strong conservation of repeat motifs inLea genes found across divers plant species includingC. plantagineum and non-desiccation tolerant plants. This conservation of structural elements leads to speculations about evolution of desiccation tolerance in the resurrection plant.     

Dessication-induced Changes in the Protein Complement of Soluble Extracts from Leaves of Resurrection Plants and Related Desiccation-sensitive Species

Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis studies were conducted onthe soluble proteins of angiosperm plants whose leaf protoplasmcan revive from complete dehydration (Xerophyta viscosa, Talbotiaelegans, Sporobolus stapfianus, Myrothamnus flabellifolia, Boryanitida) and of desiccation sensitive plants (Sporobolus pyramidalis,Eragrostis tenuifolia, Selaginella kraussiana). Changes in thesoluble protein composition were found in all species afterdehydration, and were extensive in most species, both resurrectionand non-resurrection. Both groups showed loss of protein bands,but there was no consistent pattern of compositional changewithin either type of plant. Net hydrolysis of high molecularweight protein could be deduced, and the possibility of disulphide-mediatedaggregation arose in some species. Induction of tolerance todesiccation in Borya nitida appeared to be associated with retentionor restoration of the control pattern of protein bands in contrastto loss of very low and very high mol. wt protein (loss wasextreme in desiccation-killed leaves). There was evidence of a disproportionately great synthesis ofvery low mol. wt protein during the midphase of rehydrationin X. viscosa. These results point to the possibility of an important roleof protein synthesis for survival of dehydration. Resurrection plants, desiccation-sensitive plants, protein complement, polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis     

Bayesian reconstruction of ancestral expression of the LEA gene families reveals propagule-derived desiccation tolerance in resurrection plants

Desiccation tolerance is a complex trait that is broadly but infrequently present throughout the evolutionary tree of life. Desiccation tolerance has played a significant role in land plant evolution, in both the vegetative and reproductive life history stages. In the land plants, the late embryogenesis abundant (LEA) gene families are involved in both abiotic stress tolerance and the development of reproductive propagules. They are also a major component of vegetative desiccation tolerance. Phylogenies were estimated for four families of LEA genes from Arabidopsis, Physcomitrella, and the desiccation tolerant plants Tortula ruralis, Craterostigma plantagineum, and Xerophyta humilis. Microarray expression data from Arabidopsis and a subset of the Physcomitrella LEAs were used to estimate ancestral expression patterns in the LEA families and to evaluate alternative hypotheses for the origins of vegetative desiccation tolerance in the flowering plants. The results contradict the idea that vegetative desiccation tolerance in the resurrection angiosperms Craterostigma and Xerophyta arose through the co-option of genes exclusively related to stress tolerance, and support the propagule-derived origin of vegetative desiccation tolerance in the resurrection plants.     

Differences in Rehydration of Three Desiccation-tolerant Angiosperm Species

The rehydration characteristics of the desiccation-tolerantplantsCraterostigma wilmsii andMyrothamnus flabellifolia (homoiochlorophyllous)andXerophyta viscosa (poikilochlorophyllous) were studied todetermine differences among them. A desiccation-sensitive plant(Pisum sativum) was used as a control. Recovery of water content,quantum efficiency (F_V/F_M), photosynthetic pigments and chloroplastultrastructure as well as damage to the plasmamembrane werestudied. P. sativum did not recover after desiccation and considerabledamage occurred during rehydration. The desiccation-tolerantplants appeared to differ in their responses to dehydrationand rehydration. The small herbaceousC. wilmsii generally showedlittle damage in the dry state and recovered faster than theother tolerant species.M. flabellifolia took longer to recoverthanC. wilmsii probably due to the presence of a woody stemin which dehydration-induced xylem embolisms slowed the rateof recovery. The poikilochlorophyllous speciesX. viscosa tookthe longest to recover because it took longer to reconstitutethe chloroplasts and the photosynthetic pigments. Quantum efficiencyrecovered in all species before water content and chlorophyllcontent recovered to control levels. The significance of thesedifferent responses to desiccation and recovery from desiccationis discussed. Desiccation-tolerant; F_V/F_M; homoiochlorophyllous; poikilochlorophyllous; chlorophyll; chloroplast; ultrastructure; Craterostigma wilmsii ; Myrothamnus flabellifolia ; Xerophyta viscosa ;Pisum sativum     

Protocols for nuclei isolation and nuclear protein extraction from the resurrection plant Xerophyta viscosa for proteomic studies

The plant nucleus is an important subcellular organelle but the isolation of pure and enriched nuclei from plants and subsequent extraction of nuclear proteins for proteomic studies is challenging. Here, we present protocols for nuclei isolation and nuclear protein extraction from the resurrection plant, Xerophyta viscosa, and show optimization and modification of the most critical steps.     

The use of aeroponics to investigate antioxidant activity in the roots of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Xerophyta viscosa</Emphasis>

In order to ultimately understand the whole plant mechanism of attaining desiccation tolerance, we undertook to investigate the root tissues of the resurrection plant Xerophyta viscosa, as previous work has only been conducted on the leaf tissues of resurrection plants. An aeroponic plant growth system was designed and optimised to observe the root’s response to desiccation without the restrictions of a soil medium, allowing easy access to roots. Successful culture of both X.viscosa and the control, Zea mays, was achieved and dehydration stress was implemented through reduction of nutrient solution spraying of the roots. After drying to the air dry state (achieved after 7 days for roots and 10 days for shoots), rehydration was achieved by resumption of root spraying. X.viscosa plants survived desiccation and recovered but Z. mays did not. The activity of the antioxidant enzymes superoxide dismutase, catalase, ascorbate peroxidase and glutathione reductase and quantities of ascorbate and glutathione were determined during root desiccation. There was an initial decline in activity in all enzymes upon drying to 80% RWC, but activity thereafter remained constant, at rates indicative of potential metabolic activity, to the air-dry state. This data suggests that these enzymes are not denatured by desiccation of the root tissue. Ascorbate and glutathione content remained constant at concentrations of 70 and 100 μM, respectively during drying. Thus root tissues appear to retain antioxidant potential during drying, for use in recovery upon rehydration, as has been reported for leaf tissues of this and other resurrection plants.     

Constitutive expression of small heat shock proteins in vegetative tissues of the resurrection plant Craterostigma plantagineum

Using antibodies raised against two sunflower small heat shock proteins (sHSPs), we have detected immunologically related proteins in unstressed vegetative tissues from the resurrection plant Craterostigma plantagineum. In whole plants, further accumulation of these polypeptides was induced by heat-shock or water-stress. In desiccation-intolerant Craterostigma callus tissue, we failed to detect sHSP-related polypeptides, but their expression, and the concurrent acquisition of desiccation tolerance was induced by exogenous abscisic acid (ABA) treatment. In untressed plants, the cross-reacting polypeptides were abundant in the roots and lower part of the shoots, where they showed homogeneous tissue-distributions. This constitutive expression is novel for vegetative tissues of higher plants, and resembles the expression patterns of sHSPs in desiccation-tolerant zygotic embryos and germinating seeds.J.A. and C.A. contributed equally to this work and are both considered to be first author     

Dynamics of Endogenous Phytohormones during Desiccation and Recovery of the Resurrection Plant Species Haberlea rhodopensis

Drought is one of the most significant threats to world agriculture and hampers the supply of food and energy. The mechanisms of drought responses can be studied using resurrection plants that are able to survive extreme dehydration. As plant hormones function in an intensive cross-talk, playing important regulatory roles in the perception and response to unfavorable environments, the dynamics of phytohormones was followed in the resurrection plant Haberlea rhodopensis Friv. during desiccation and subsequent recovery. Analysis of both leaves and roots revealed that jasmonic acid, along with and even earlier than abscisic acid, serves as a signal triggering the response of the resurrection plants to desiccation. The steady high levels of salicylic acid could be considered an integral part of the specific set of parameters that prime H. rhodopensis desiccation tolerance. The dynamic changes of cytokinins and auxins suggest that these hormones actively participate in the dehydration response and development of desiccation tolerance in the resurrection plants. Our data contribute to the elucidation of a global complex picture of the resurrection plant’s ability to withstand desiccation, which might be successfully utilized in crop improvement.