Leakage and slow allostery limit performance of single drug-sensing aptazyme molecules based on the hammerhead ribozyme

Engineered “aptazymes” fuse in vitro selected aptamers with ribozymes to create allosteric enzymes as biosensing components and artificial gene regulatory switches through ligand-induced conformational rearrangement and activation. By contrast, activating ligand is employed as an enzymatic cofactor in the only known natural aptazyme, the glmS ribozyme, which is devoid of any detectable conformational rearrangements. To better understand this difference in biosensing strategy, we monitored by single molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and 2-aminopurine (AP) fluorescence the global conformational dynamics and local base (un)stacking, respectively, of a prototypical drug-sensing aptazyme, built from a theophylline aptamer and the hammerhead ribozyme. Single molecule FRET reveals that a catalytically active state with distal Stems I and III of the hammerhead ribozyme is accessed both in the theophylline-bound and, if less frequently, in the ligand-free state. The resultant residual activity (leakage) in the absence of theophylline contributes to a limited dynamic range of the aptazyme. In addition, site-specific AP labeling shows that rapid local theophylline binding to the aptamer domain leads to only slow allosteric signal transduction into the ribozyme core. Our findings allow us to rationalize the suboptimal biosensing performance of the engineered compared to the natural aptazyme and to suggest improvement strategies. Our single molecule FRET approach also monitors in real time the previously elusive equilibrium docking dynamics of the hammerhead ribozyme between several inactive conformations and the active, long-lived, Y-shaped conformer.     

Detection of small organic analytes by fluorescing molecular switches

A sensor system was developed for the determination of theophylline concentrations based on a theophylline-dependent allosteric ribozyme (Soukup, G. A.; Breaker, R. R. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 1999, 96, 3584) in combination with an RNA substrate which is double-labeled with a fluorophore and a quencher dye. In the presence of theophylline, a hammerhead ribozyme domain is switched into an active conformation by the action of a theophylline-binding aptamer domain. Upon substrate cleavage, the quencher is removed from the vicinity of the fluorophore, causing an increased fluorescence signal. Real-time analysis of the cleavage reactions both under single and multiple turnover conditions revealed a dependence on the cleavage rate within a range from 0.01 to 2mM theophylline. The structurally similar molecule caffeine, however, had no detectable influence on the fluorescence signal.     

Altering molecular recognition of RNA aptamers by allosteric selection

In a continuing effort to explore structural and functional dynamics in RNA catalysis, we have created a series of allosteric hammerhead ribozymes that are activated by theophylline. Representative ribozymes exhibit greater than 3000-fold activation upon effector-binding and cleave with maximum rate constants that are equivalent to the unmodified hammerhead ribozyme. In addition, we have evolved a variant allosteric ribozyme that exhibits an effector specificity change from theophylline to 3-methylxanthine. Molecular discrimination between the two effectors appears to be mediated by subtle conformational differences that originate from displacement of the phosphodiester backbone near the effector binding pocket. These findings reveal the importance of abstruse aspects of molecular recognition by nucleic acids that are likely to be unapproachable by current methods of rational design.     

Design of allosteric hammerhead ribozymes activated by ligand-induced structure stabilization.

BACKGROUND: Ribozymes can function as allosteric enzymes that undergo a conformational change upon ligand binding to a site other than the active site. Although allosteric ribozymes are not known to exist in nature, nucleic acids appear to be well suited to display such advanced forms of kinetic control. Current research explores the mechanisms of allosteric ribozymes as well as the strategies and methods that can be used to create new controllable enzymes. RESULTS: In this study, we exploit the modular nature of certain functional RNAs to engineer allosteric ribozymes that are activated by flavin mononucleotide (FMN) or theophylline. By joining an FMN- or theophylline-binding domain to a hammerhead ribozyme by different stem II elements, we have identified a minimal connective bridge comprised of a G.U wobble pair that is responsive to ligand binding. Binding of FMN or theophylline to its allosteric site induces a conformational change in the RNA that stabilizes the wobble pair and ultimately favors the active form of the catalytic core. These ligand-sensitive ribozymes exhibit rate enhancements of more than 100-fold in the presence of FMN and of approximately 40-fold in the presence of theophylline. CONCLUSIONS: An adaptive strategy for modular rational design has proven to be an effective approach to the engineering of novel allosteric ribozymes. This strategy was used to create allosteric ribozymes that function by a mechanism involving ligand-induced structure stabilization. Conceivably, similar engineering strategies and allosteric mechanisms could be used to create a variety of novel allosteric ribozymes that function with other effector molecules.     

Cooperative binding of effectors by an allosteric ribozyme

An allosteric ribozyme that requires two different effectors to induce catalysis was created using modular rational design. This ribozyme construct comprises five conjoined RNA modules that operate in concert as an obligate FMN- and theophylline-dependent molecular switch. When both effectors are present, this 'binary' RNA switch self-cleaves with a rate enhancement of approximately 300-fold over the rate observed in the absence of effectors. Kinetic and structural studies implicate a switching mechanism wherein FMN binding induces formation of the active ribozyme conformation. However, the binding site for FMN is rendered inactive unless theophylline first binds to its corresponding site and reorganizes the RNA structure. This example of cooperative binding between allosteric effectors reveals a level of structural and functional complexity for RNA that is similar to that observed with allosteric proteins.     

Rapid kinetic characterization of hammerhead ribozymes by real-time monitoring of fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)

In established methods for analyzing ribozyme kinetics, radiolabeled RNA substrates are primarily used. Each data point requires the cumbersome sampling, gel electrophoretic separation, and quantitation of reaction products, apart from the continuous loss of substrate by radioactive decay. We have used stable, double fluorescent end-labeled RNA substrates. Fluorescence of one fluorophore is quenched by intramolecular energy transfer (FRET). Upon substrate cleavage, both dyes become separated in two RNA products and fluorescence is restored. This can be followed in real time and ribozyme reactions can be analyzed under multiple (substrate excess) and under single (ribozyme excess) turnover conditions. A detailed comparison of unlabeled, single, and double fluorescent-labeled RNAs revealed moderate kinetic differences. Results with two systems, hammerhead ribozymes in I/II (small ribozyme, large substrate) and in I/III format (large ribozyme, small substrate), are reported.     

Generating new ligand-binding RNAs by affinity maturation and disintegration of allosteric ribozymes

Allosteric ribozymes are engineered RNAs that operate as molecular switches whose rates of catalytic activity are modulated by the binding of specific effector molecules. New RNA molecular switches can be created by using "allosteric selection," a molecular engineering process that combines modular rational design and in vitro evolution strategies. In this report, we describe the characterization of 3',5'-cyclic nucleotide monophosphate (cNMP)-dependent hammerhead ribozymes that were created using allosteric selection (Koizumi et al., Nat Struct Biol, 1999, 6:1062-1071). Artificial phylogeny data generated by random mutagenesis and reselection of existing cGMP-, cCMP-, and cAMP-dependent ribozymes indicate that each is comprised of distinct effector-binding and catalytic domains. In addition, patterns of nucleotide covariation and direct mutational analysis both support distinct secondary-structure organizations for the effector-binding domains. Guided by these structural models, we were able to disintegrate each allosteric ribozyme into separate ligand-binding and catalytic modules. Examinations of the independent effector-binding domains reveal that each retains its corresponding cNMP-binding function. These results validate the use of allosteric selection and modular engineering as a means of simultaneously generating new nucleic acid structures that selectively bind ligands. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the binding affinity of an allosteric ribozyme can be improved through random mutagenesis and allosteric selection under conditions that favor tighter binding. This "affinity maturation" effect is expected to be a valuable attribute of allosteric selection as future endeavors seek to apply engineered allosteric ribozymes as biosensor components and as controllable genetic switches.     

Coupling between substrate binding and allosteric regulation in ribozyme catalysis

The contribution of substrate binding to allosteric regulation in the ribozyme catalysis has been investigated using allosteric ribozymes consisting of the hammerhead ribozyme and a flavin mononucleotide (FMN) aptamer. Kinetic parameters were measured for various lengths of the substrates with a wide range of binding energy. The maximum cleavage rate of each ribozyme was retained with the long substrates. However, the cleavage rates largely decreased by the truncation of the substrates according to loss in the free energy of substrate binding. The high sensitivity to the substrate lengths is attributed to the increase in the energetic requirement for the catalytic core folding, which is caused by the incorporation of the aptamer region. One role of FMN binding is assisting the promotion of the core folding through the stabilization of the aptamer domain. The allosteric effect is significantly expressed only when the substrate binding energy is insufficient for the core folding of the ribozyme-substrate complex. This type of allosteric interaction dominates the substrate dependency of another type of regulation. These results demonstrate that an adequate correlation between the type of regulation and the substrate binding is responsible for the effective allosteric interaction in the kinetic process.     

Computational selection of nucleic acid biosensors via a slip structure model

Aptamers have been shown to undergo ligand-dependent conformational changes, and can be joined to ribozymes to create allosteric ribozymes (aptazymes). An anti-flavin (FMN) aptamer joined to the hammerhead ribozyme yielded an aptazyme that underwent small, FMN-dependent displacements in the helix that joined the aptamer and ribozyme. This 'slip structure' model in which alternative sets of base-pairs are formed in the absence and presence of ligand proved amenable to energetic and computational modeling. Initial successes in modeling the activities of known aptazymes led to the in silico selection of new ligand-dependent aptazymes from virtual pools that contained millions of members. Those aptazymes that were predicted to best fit the slip structure model were synthesized and assayed, and the best-designed aptazyme was activated 60-fold by FMN. The slip structure model proved to be generalizable, and could be applied with equal facility to computationally generate aptazymes that proved to be experimentally activated by other ligands (theophylline) or that contained other catalytic cores (hairpin ribozyme). Moreover, the slip structure model could be applied to the prediction of a ligand-dependent aptamer beacon biosensor in which the addition of the protein vascular endothelial growth factor (VegF) led to a 10-fold increase in fluorescent signal.     

Reaction pathway of the trans-acting hepatitis delta virus ribozyme: a conformational change accompanies catalysis.

The hepatitis delta virus (HDV), an infectious human pathogen and satellite of hepatitis B virus, leads to intensified disease symptoms, including progression to liver cirrhosis. Both the circular RNA genome of HDV and its complementary antigenome contain the same cis-cleaving catalytic RNA motif that plays a crucial role in virus replication. Previously, the high-resolution crystal structure of the product form of a cis-acting genomic HDV ribozyme has been determined, while a trans-acting version of the ribozyme was used to dissect the cleavage reaction pathway. Using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) on a synthetic trans-cleaving form of the ribozyme, we are able to directly observe substrate binding (at a rate constant k(on) of 7.8 x 10(6) M(-1) min(-1) at pH 7.5, 11 mM MgCl(2), and 25 degrees C) and dissociation (at 0.34 min(-1)). Steady-state and time-resolved FRET experiments in solution and in nondenaturing gels reveal that the substrate (precursor) complex is slightly more compact (by approximately 3 A) than the free ribozyme, yet becomes significantly extended (by approximately 15 A) upon cleavage and product complex formation. We also find that trans cleavage is characterized by a high transition-state entropy (-26 eu). We propose that the significant global conformational change that we observe between the precursor and product structures occurs on the reaction trajectory into a constrained product complex-like transition state. Our observations may present the structural basis of the recently described utilization of intrinsic substrate binding energy to the overall catalytic rate enhancement by the trans-acting HDV ribozyme.     

Mechanism for allosteric inhibition of an ATP-sensitive ribozyme.

We report the structural basis for the modulation of an ATP-sensitive ribozyme that was engineered by modular rational design. This allosteric ribozyme is composed of two independently functioning domains, one a receptor for ATP and the other a self-cleaving ribozyme. When fused in the appropriate fashion, the conjoined aptamer-ribozyme construct functions as an allosteric ribozyme that is inhibited in the presence of ATP. The aptamer domain remains conformationally heterogeneous in the absence of ATP, but folds into a distinct structure upon ligand binding. This ATP-induced conformational change causes a reduction in catalytic activity of the adjacent ribozyme domain due to steric interference between the aptamer and ribozyme tertiary structures. This mechanism for structural and functional modulation of nucleic acids is one of several possible mechanisms by which the function of ribozymes could be specifically controlled by small effector molecules.     

A general strategy for effector-mediated control of RNA-cleaving ribozymes and DNA enzymes

A novel and general approach is described for generating versions of RNA-cleaving ribozymes (RNA enzymes) and DNAzymes (DNA enzymes), whose catalytic activity can be controlled by the binding of activator molecules. Variants of the RNA-cleaving 10-23 DNAzyme and 8-17 DNAzyme were created, whose catalysis was activated by up to approximately 35-fold by the binding of the effector adenosine. The design of such variants was possible even though the tertiary folding of the two DNAzymes is not known. Variants of the hammerhead ribozyme were constructed, to respond to the effectors ATP and flavin mononucleotide. Whereas in conventional allosteric ribozymes, effector-binding modulates the chemical step of catalysis, here, effectors exercise their effect upon the substrate-binding step, by stabilizing the enzyme-substrate complex. Because such an approach for controlling the activity of DNAzymes/ribozymes requires no prior knowledge of the enzyme's secondary or tertiary folding, this regulatory strategy should be generally applicable to any RNA-cleaving ribozyme or DNAzyme, natural or in vitro selected, provided substrate-recognition is achieved by Watson-Crick base-pairing.     

Allosteric ribozymes sensitive to the second messengers cAMP and cGMP.

We have engineered allosteric ribozymes by combining modular rational design with combinatorial strategies. This new procedure was used to create allosteric ribozymes that are activated by specific nucleoside 3',5'-cyclic monophosphates (cNMPs). A random-sequence domain was attached to stem II of hammerhead ribozymes via a communication module that serves as an interface between ribozyme and the effector binding site. Subjecting this initial random pool to in vitro selection methods produced populations that respond, or cleave, only in the presence of specific effector molecules. From generation 18, 20 and 23, cGMP, cCMP and cAMP-specific responsive ribozymes, respectively, were isolated and characterized. These methods show great promise for engineering allosteric ribozymes and for creating new ligand-specific aptamers.     

Intracellular ribozyme-catalyzed trans-cleavage of RNA monitored by fluorescence resonance energy transfer

Small catalytic RNAs like the hairpin ribozyme are proving to be useful intracellular tools; however, most attempts to demonstrate trans-cleavage of RNA by ribozymes in cells have been frustrated by rapid cellular degradation of the cleavage products. Here, we describe a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) assay that directly monitors cleavage of target RNA in tissue-culture cells. An oligoribonucleotide substrate was modified to inhibit cellular ribonuclease degradation without interfering with ribozyme cleavage, and donor (fluorescein) and acceptor (tetramethylrhodamine) fluorophores were introduced at positions flanking the cleavage site. In simple buffers, the intact substrate produces a strong FRET signal that is lost upon cleavage, resulting in a red-to-green shift in dominant fluorescence emission. Hairpin ribozyme and fluorescent substrate were microinjected into murine fibroblasts under conditions in which substrate cleavage can occur only inside the cell. A strong FRET signal was observed by fluorescence microscopy when substrate was injected, but rapid decay of the FRET signal occurred when an active, cognate ribozyme was introduced with the substrate. No acceleration in cleavage rates was observed in control experiments utilizing a noncleavable substrate, inactive ribozyme, or an active ribozyme with altered substrate specificity. Subsequently, the fluorescent substrates were injected into clonal cell lines that expressed cognate or noncognate ribozymes. A decrease in FRET signal was observed only when substrate was microinjected into cells expressing its cognate ribozyme. These results demonstrate trans-cleavage of RNA within mammalian cells, and provide an experimental basis for quantitative analysis of ribozyme activity and specificity within the cell.     

Dynamic polymorphism of Ras observed by single molecule FRET is the basis for molecular recognition

Ras regulates signal transduction pathway function by dynamically interacting with various effectors. To understand the basis for Ras function, its conformational dynamics were measured in the absence and presence of effectors using single molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between probes located on the Switch II region and GTP. The time trajectories of FRET efficiency from GTP-bound Ras showed that this conformation spontaneously varies among multiple states. Among them, a low FRET state was identified as an inactive state. The transition involving the inactive conformational state occurred in the time range of seconds. In contrast, fluctuation occurring most probably between multiple active high FRET conformational states lasted approximately 30 ms but converged to a specific conformational state upon binding to an effector. Thus, Ras conformation spontaneously fluctuates to readily interact with various effectors.     

Structural flexibility and the thermodynamics of helix exchange constrain attenuation and allosteric activation of hammerhead ribozyme TRAPs

Perturbations of precleavage equilibria in RNA-cleaving ribozymes can be exploited to control cleavage kinetics. In the targeted ribozyme-attenuated probes (TRAP) design, antisense and attenuator sequences are appended onto the catalytic core of a ribozyme or deoxyribozyme. The attenuator anneals to conserved bases in the catalytic core to form an inactive conformation, which is activated upon binding of a sense strand oligonucleotide to the antisense module. In this work, the apparent Michaelis-Menton constant (K'm) for the binding of the RNA substrate to the ribozyme is shown to be within a factor of 2 for a number of constructs whose observed cleavage rates varied by several 100-fold. These observations rule out models of allosteric regulation based on modulation of substrate binding affinity, instead favoring a model in which regulation arises from equilibration between the active and inactive conformations of the TRAP. Free energies of formation for isolated helices that are exchanged during this reequilibration were determined from the concentration dependence of optical melt data. These values established that the thermodynamic stabilities of sense-antisense duplexes and of the attenuator-core duplexes correlate with observed rates of cleavage. Notably reduced cleavage rates are observed for TRAP ribozymes with extended antisense sequences, suggesting that tight binding of attenuator to the core is assisted by a long antisense portion. A construct with a 25-nucleotide antisense showed greater than 730-fold activation upon annealing with a 20-nucleotide DNA sense strand oligo, representing the greatest activation observed to date for the TRAP design.     

Nuclear magnetic resonance studies of the hammerhead ribozyme domain. Secondary structure formation and magnesium ion dependence

Proton nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) experiments were used to probe base-pair formation in several hammerhead RNA enzyme (ribozyme) domains. The hammerhead domains consist of a 34 nucleotide ribozyme bound to a complementary 13 nucleotide non-cleavable DNA substrate. Three hammerhead domains were studied that differ in the sequence and stability of one of the helices involved in recognition of the substrate by the ribozyme. The n.m.r. data show a 1:1 stoichiometry for the ribozyme-substrate complexes. The imino proton resonances in the hammerhead complexes were assigned by two-dimensional nuclear Overhauser effect experiments. These data confirm the presence of two of the three helical regions in the hammerhead domain, predicted from phylogenetic data; and are also consistent with the formation of the third helix. Since a divalent cation is required for efficient catalytic activity of the hammerhead domain, the magnesium ion dependence of the n.m.r. spectra was studied for two of the hammerhead complexes. One of the complexes showed very large spectral changes upon addition of magnesium ions. However, the complex that has the most C.G base-pairs in one of the recognition helices shows essentially no spectral (and therefore presumably structural) changes upon addition of magnesium. These data are consistent with a model where the magnesium binding site already exists in the magnesium-free complex, suggesting that the magnesium ion serves primarily a catalytic, and not a structural, role under the conditions used here.     

Photocrosslinking detects a compact, active structure of the hammerhead ribozyme

The hammerhead ribozyme has been intensively studied for approximately 15 years, but its cleavage mechanism is not yet understood. Crystal structures reveal a Y-shaped molecule in which the cleavage site is not ideally aligned for an S(N)2 reaction and no RNA functional groups are positioned appropriately to perform the roles of acid and base or other functions in the catalysis. If the ribozyme folds to a more compact structure in the transition state, it probably does so only transiently. We have used photocrosslinking as a tool to trap hammerhead ribozyme-substrate complexes in various stages of folding. Results suggest that the two substrate residues flanking the cleavage site approach and stack upon two guanosines (G8 and G12) in domain 2, moving 10-15 A closer to domain 2 than they appear in the crystal structure. Most crosslinks obtained with the nucleotide analogues positioned in the ribozyme core are catalytically inactive; however, one cobalt(III) hexaammine-dependent crosslink of an unmodified ribozyme retains catalytic activity and confirms the close stacking of cleavage site residue C17 with nucleotide G8 in domain 2. These findings suggest that residues involved in the chemistry of hammerhead catalysis are likely located in that region containing G8 and G12.     

Efficient ligation of the Schistosoma hammerhead ribozyme

The hammerhead ribozyme from Schistosoma mansoni is the best characterized of the natural hammerhead ribozymes. Biophysical, biochemical, and structural studies have shown that the formation of the loop-loop tertiary interaction between stems I and II alters the global folding, cleavage kinetics, and conformation of the catalytic core of this hammerhead, leading to a ribozyme that is readily cleaved under physiological conditions. This study investigates the ligation kinetics and the internal equilibrium between cleavage and ligation for the Schistosoma hammerhead. Single turnover kinetic studies on a construct where the ribozyme cleaves and ligates substrate(s) in trans showed up to 23% ligation when starting from fully cleaved products. This was achieved by an approximately 2000-fold increase in the rate of ligation compared to a minimal hammerhead without the loop-loop tertiary interaction, yielding an internal equilibrium that ranges from 2 to 3 at physiological Mg2+ ion concentrations (0.1-1 mM). Thus, the natural Schistosoma hammerhead ribozyme is almost as efficient at ligation as it is at cleavage. The results here are consistent with a model where formation of the loop-loop tertiary interaction leads to a higher population of catalytically active molecules and where formation of this tertiary interaction has a much larger effect on the ligation than the cleavage activity of the Schistosoma hammerhead ribozyme.