Breaking free from the crystal lattice: Structural biology in solution to study protein degraders

Structural biology offers a versatile arsenal of techniques and methods to investigate the structure and conformational dynamics of proteins and their assemblies. The growing field of targeted protein degradation centres on the premise of developing small molecules, termed degraders, to induce proximity between an E3 ligase and a protein of interest to be signalled for degradation. This new drug modality brings with it new opportunities and challenges to structural biologists. Here we discuss how several structural biology techniques, including nuclear magnetic resonance, cryo-electron microscopy, structural mass spectrometry and small angle scattering, have been explored to complement X-ray crystallography in studying degraders and their ternary complexes. Together the studies covered in this review make a case for the invaluable perspectives that integrative structural biology techniques in solution can bring to understanding ternary complexes and designing degraders.     

Modeling the CRL4A ligase complex to predict target protein ubiquitination induced by cereblon-recruiting PROTACs

PROteolysis TArgeting Chimeras (PROTACs) are hetero-bifunctional small molecules that can simultaneously recruit target proteins and E3 ligases to form a ternary complex, promoting target protein ubiquitination and degradation via the Ubiquitin-Proteasome System (UPS). PROTACs have gained increasing attention in recent years due to certain advantages over traditional therapeutic modalities and enabling targeting of previously “undruggable” proteins. To better understand the mechanism of PROTAC-induced Target Protein Degradation (TPD), several computational approaches have recently been developed to study and predict ternary complex formation. However, mounting evidence suggests that ubiquitination can also be a rate-limiting step in PROTAC-induced TPD. Here, we propose a structure-based computational approach to predict target protein ubiquitination induced by cereblon (CRBN)-based PROTACs by leveraging available structural information of the CRL4A ligase complex (CRBN/DDB1/CUL4A/Rbx1/NEDD8/E2/Ub). We generated ternary complex ensembles with Rosetta, modeled multiple CRL4A ligase complex conformations, and predicted ubiquitination efficiency by separating the ternary ensemble into productive and unproductive complexes based on the proximity of the ubiquitin to accessible lysines on the target protein. We validated our CRL4A ligase complex models with published ternary complex structures and additionally employed our modeling workflow to predict ubiquitination efficiencies and sites of a series of cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) after treatment with TL12–186, a pan-kinase PROTAC. Our predictions are consistent with CDK ubiquitination and site-directed mutagenesis of specific CDK lysine residues as measured using a NanoBRET ubiquitination assay in HEK293 cells. This work structurally links PROTAC-induced ternary formation and ubiquitination, representing an important step toward prediction of target “degradability.”     

Polyglutamine- and Temperature-Dependent Conformational Rigidity in Mutant Huntingtin Revealed by Immunoassays and Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy

Background

In Huntington''s disease, expansion of a CAG triplet repeat occurs in exon 1 of the huntingtin gene (HTT), resulting in a protein bearing>35 polyglutamine residues whose N-terminal fragments display a high propensity to misfold and aggregate. Recent data demonstrate that polyglutamine expansion results in conformational changes in the huntingtin protein (HTT), which likely influence its biological and biophysical properties. Developing assays to characterize and measure these conformational changes in isolated proteins and biological samples would advance the testing of novel therapeutic approaches aimed at correcting mutant HTT misfolding. Time-resolved Förster energy transfer (TR-FRET)-based assays represent high-throughput, homogeneous, sensitive immunoassays widely employed for the quantification of proteins of interest. TR-FRET is extremely sensitive to small distances and can therefore provide conformational information based on detection of exposure and relative position of epitopes present on the target protein as recognized by selective antibodies. We have previously reported TR-FRET assays to quantify HTT proteins based on the use of antibodies specific for different amino-terminal HTT epitopes. Here, we investigate the possibility of interrogating HTT protein conformation using these assays.

Methodology/Principal Findings

By performing TR-FRET measurements on the same samples (purified recombinant proteins or lysates from cells expressing HTT fragments or full length protein) at different temperatures, we have discovered a temperature-dependent, reversible, polyglutamine-dependent conformational change of wild type and expanded mutant HTT proteins. Circular dichroism spectroscopy confirms the temperature and polyglutamine-dependent change in HTT structure, revealing an effect of polyglutamine length and of temperature on the alpha-helical content of the protein.

Conclusions/Significance

The temperature- and polyglutamine-dependent effects observed with TR-FRET on HTT proteins represent a simple, scalable, quantitative and sensitive assay to identify genetic and pharmacological modulators of mutant HTT conformation, and potentially to assess the relevance of conformational changes during onset and progression of Huntington''s disease.     

AlphaLISA技术的发展及应用

AlphaLISA技术是一种基于微珠的化学发光的新型均相检测技术,与传统的ELISA技术相比具有更高的敏感性、精确性、均一性、背景低、广泛的动态检测范围,而且无需洗涤及样本需求量极少等特点.该技术可用于多种组织、细胞来源的生物分子的检测,如细胞因子、抗原抗体的检测、蛋白相互作用及蛋白质与核酸相互作用的检测以及药物分析等研究.随着AlphaLISA技术的发展,该技术已在医学及分子生物学领域得到了广泛的应用.     

Development of the first small molecule histone deacetylase 6 (HDAC6) degraders

Histone deacetylases (HDACs) decrease the acetylation level of histones and other non-histone proteins. Over expression of HDACs have been observed in cancers and other diseases. Targeted protein degradation by “hijacking” the natural ubiquitin-proteasome-system (UPS) recently emerged as a novel technology to “knock-out” endogenous disease-causing proteins. We applied this strategy to the development of the first small molecule degraders for zinc-dependent HDACs by conjugating non-selective HDAC inhibitors with E3 ubiquitin ligase ligands. Through cell-based assays, we discovered novel bifunctional molecules (dHDAC6) that could selectively degrade HDAC6. Further mechanistic studies indicated that HDAC6 was selectively removed by the UPS.     

A Protein L -Based Immunodiagnostic Approach Utilizing Time-Resolved F?rster Resonance Energy Transfer

Chelated lanthanides such as europium (Eu) have uniquely long fluorescence emission half-lives permitting their use in time-resolved fluorescence (TRF) assays. In Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) a donor fluorophore transfers its emission energy to an acceptor fluorophore if in sufficiently close proximity. The use of time-resolved (TR) FRET minimizes the autofluorescence of molecules present in biological samples. In this report, we describe a homogenous immunoassay prototype utilizing TR-FRET for detection of antibodies in solution. The assay is based on labeled protein L, a bacterial protein that binds to immunoglobulin (Ig) light chain, and labeled antigen, which upon association with the same Ig molecule produce a TR-FRET active complex. We show that the approach is functional and can be utilized for both mono- and polyvalent antigens. We also compare the assay performance to that of another homogenous TR-FRET immunoassay reported earlier. This novel assay may have wide utility in infectious disease point-of-care diagnostics.     

TR-FRET-based high-throughput screening assay for identification of UBC13 inhibitors

UBC13 is a noncanonical ubiquitin conjugating enzyme (E2) that has been implicated in a variety of cellular signaling processes due to its ability to catalyze formation of lysine 63-linked polyubiquitin chains on various substrates. In particular, UBC13 is required for signaling by a variety of receptors important in immune regulation, making it a candidate target for inflammatory diseases. UBC13 is also critical for double-strand DNA repair and thus a potential radiosensitizer and chemosensitizer target for oncology. The authors developed a high-throughput screening (HTS) assay for UBC13 based on the method of time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET). The TR-FRET assay combines fluorochrome (Fl)-conjugated ubiquitin (fluorescence acceptor) with terbium (Tb)-conjugated ubiquitin (fluorescence donor), such that the assembly of mixed chains of Fl- and Tb-ubiquitin creates a robust TR-FRET signal. The authors defined conditions for optimized performance of the TR-FRET assay in both 384- and 1536-well formats. Chemical library screens (total 456 865 compounds) were conducted in high-throughput mode using various compound collections, affording superb Z' scores (typically >0.7) and thus validating the performance of the assays. Altogether, the HTS assays described here are suitable for large-scale, automated screening of chemical libraries in search of compounds with inhibitory activity against UBC13.     

Development of a homogeneous AlphaLISA ubiquitination assay using ubiquitin binding matrices as universal components for the detection of ubiquitinated proteins

The Ubiquitin Proteasome Pathway (UPP) has become a target rich pathway for therapeutic intervention as its role in pathogenic disease is better understood. In particular many E3 ligases within this pathway have been implicated in cancer, inflammation and metabolic diseases. It has been of great interest to develop biochemical assays to identify inhibitors of catalytic E3 ubiquitination activity as a means of abrogating the disease mechanism. Here we describe a homogeneous biochemical assay that utilizes native ubiquitin and Tandem-repeated Ubiquitin-Binding Entities (TUBEs) as a detection technology for ubiquitination activity. We developed a TUBEs based proximity AlphaLisa? assay for Mdm2, which is an E3 ligase that negatively regulates p53 tumor suppressor protein. We further demonstrate that this assay strategy or design can also be applied to the development of assays to detect autoubiquitination of other E3 ligases that are also of interest for therapeutic intervention. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Ubiquitin Drug Discovery and Diagnostics.     

Targeted protein degradation: Emerging concepts and protein state-specific targeting principles

Targeted protein degraders are heterobifunctional small molecules that link a target ligand or bait to an E3-ligase binder via a chemical spacer. Upon entering the cell, these ligands trigger the formation of a ternary complex between the target protein, degrader and E3-ligase, which leads to target polyubiquitination and proteasomal degradation. In recent years, TPD has expanded rapidly as a field, becoming the modality of choice in drug discovery and chemical probe development. This has been driven by the unique pharmacology of these molecules, which allows for fast and reversible knockdown of the target protein. Recent studies have demonstrated that degraders with specificity for a defined subpopulation of a protein-of-interest can be developed, giving rise to the emerging concept of protein state-specific targeting. In this article, we review advances towards developing degraders that differentiate between target protein subpopulations based on their; activation state, oligomerization state, cellular localization state, and cell type.     

Binding characterization of the interleukin-13 signaling complex and development of a ternary time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay

Interleukin-13 (IL-13) is a critical mediator of pulmonary pathology associated with asthma. Drugs that block the biological function of IL-13 may be an effective treatment for asthma. IL-13 signals by forming a ternary complex with IL-13Rα1 and IL-4R. Genetic variants of IL-13 and of its receptor components have been linked to asthma. One in particular, IL-13R110Q, is associated with increased IgE levels and asthma. We characterized the interactions of the binary complexes composed of IL-13 or IL-13R110Q with IL-13Rα1 and the ternary complexes composed of IL-13 or IL-13R110Q and IL-13Rα1 with IL-4R using surface plasmon resonance and time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET). By both biophysical methods, we found no differences between IL-13 and IL-13R110Q binding in either the binary or the ternary complex. IL-4R bound to the IL-13/IL-13Rα1 complex with slow on and off rates, resulting in a relatively weak affinity of about 100 nM. We developed a TR-FRET assay targeting the interaction between the IL-4R and the binary complex. Two antibodies with known binding epitopes to IL-13 that block binding to either IL-13Rα1 or IL-4R inhibited the TR-FRET signal formed by the ternary complex. This assay will be useful to identify and characterize inhibitory molecules of IL-13 function.     

An efficient system to detect protein ubiquitination by agroinfiltration in Nicotiana benthamiana

The ubiquitination proteasome pathway has been demonstrated to regulate all plant developmental and signaling processes. E3 ligase/substrate‐specific interactions and ubiquitination play important roles in this pathway. However, due to technical limitations only a few instances of E3 ligase–substrate binding and protein ubiquitination in plants have been directly evidenced. An efficient in vivo and in vitro ubiquitination assay was developed for analysis of protein ubiquitination reactions by agroinfiltration expression of both substrates and E3 ligases in Nicotiana benthamiana. Using a detailed analysis of the well‐known E3 ligase COP1 and its substrate HY5, we demonstrated that this assay allows for fast and reliable detection of the specific interaction between the substrate and the E3 ligase, as well as the effects of MG132 and substrate ubiquitination and degradation. We were able to differentiate between the original and ubiquitinated forms of the substrate in vivo with antibodies to ubiquitin or to the target protein. We also demonstrated that the substrate and E3 ligase proteins expressed by agroinfiltration can be applied to analyze ubiquitination in in vivo or in vitro reactions. In addition, we optimized the conditions for different types of substrate and E3 ligase expression by supplementation with the gene‐silencing suppressor p19 and by time‐courses of sample collection. Finally, by testing different protein extraction buffers, we found that different types of buffer should be used for different ubiquitination analyses. This method should be adaptable to other protein modification studies.     

Analysis of ubiquitin E3 ligase activity using selective polyubiquitin binding proteins

The ubiquitin proteasome pathway controls the cellular degradation of ~80-90% of the proteome in a highly regulated manner. In this pathway, E3 ligases are responsible for the conjugation of ubiquitin to protein substrates which can lead to their destruction by the 26S proteasome. Aberrant E3 ligases have been implicated in several diseases and are widely recognized as attractive targets for drug discovery. As researchers continue to characterize E3 ligases, additional associations with various disease states are being exposed. The availability of assays that allow rapid analysis of E3 ligase activity is paramount to both biochemical studies and drug discovery efforts aimed at E3 ligases. To address this need, we have developed a homogenous assay for monitoring ubiquitin chain formation using Tandem Ubiquitin Binding Entities (TUBEs). TUBEs bind selectively to polyubiquitin chains versus mono-ubiquitin thus enabling the detection of polyubiquitin chains in the presence of mono-ubiquitin. This assay reports on the proximity between the protein substrate and TUBEs as a result of polyubiquitin chain formation by an E3 ligase. This homogenous assay is a step forward in streamlining an approach for characterizing and quantitating E3 ligase activity in a rapid and cost effective manner. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Ubiquitin Drug Discovery and Diagnostics.     

Binary and ternary complexes of FLNa-Ig21 with cytosolic tails of αMß2 integrin reveal dual role of filamin mediated regulation

BackgroundCytoskeletal protein filamin A is critical for the outside-in signaling of integrins. Although molecular mechanisms of filamin-integrin interactions are not fully understood. Mostly, the membrane distal (MD) part of the cytosolic tail (CT) of β subunit of integrin is known to interact with filamin A domain 21 (FLNa-Ig2). However, binary and ternary complexes of full-length CTs of leucocyte specific ß2 integrins with FLNa-Ig21 are yet to be elucidated.MethodsBinding interactions of the CTs of integrin αMß2 with FLNa-Ig21 are extensively investigated by NMR, ITC, cell-based functional assays and computational docking.ResultsThe αM CT demonstrates interactions with FLNa-Ig21 forming a binary complex. Filamin/αM interface is mediated by sidechain-sidechain interactions among non-polar and aromatic residues involving MP helix of αM and the canonical CD face of FLNa-Ig21. Functional assays delineated an interfacial residue Y1137 of αM CT is critical for in-cell binding to FLNa-Ig2. In addition, full-length ß2 CT occupies two distinct binding sites in complex with FLNa-Ig21. A ternary complex of FLNa-Ig21 with CTs has been characterized. In the ternary complex, αM CT moves away to a distal site of FLNa-Ig21 with fewer interactions.ConclusionOur findings demonstrate a plausible dual role of filamin in integrin regulation. The molecular interactions of the ternary complex are critical for the resting state of integrins whereas stable FLNa-Ig21/αM CT binary complex perhaps be required for the activated state.General significanceFilamin binding to both α and β CTs of other integrins could be essential in regulating bidirectional signaling mechanisms.     

Assessing compound binding to the Eg5 motor domain using a thermal shift assay

Eg5 is a kinesin whose inhibition leads to cycle arrest during mitosis, making it a potential therapeutic target in cancers. Circular dichroism and isothermal titration calorimetry of our pyrrolotriazine-4-one series of inhibitors with Eg5 motor domain revealed enhanced binding in the presence of adenosine 5′-diphosphate (ADP). Using this information, we studied the interaction of this series with ADP-Eg5 complexes using a thermal shift assay. We measured up to a 7 °C increase in the thermal melting (T_m) of Eg5 for an inhibitor that produced IC₅₀ values of 60 and 130 nM in microtubule-dependent adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) and cell-based cytotoxicity assays, respectively. In general, the inhibitor potency of the pyrrolotriazine-4-one series in in vitro biological assays correlated with the magnitude of the thermal stability enhancement of ADP-Eg5. The thermal shift assay also confirmed direct binding of Eg5 inhibitors identified in a high-throughput screen and demonstrated that the thermal shift assay is applicable to a range of chemotypes and can be useful in evaluating both potent (nM) and relatively weakly binding (μM) leads. Overall, the thermal shift assay was found to be an excellent biophysical method for evaluating direct binding of a large number of compounds to Eg5, and it complemented the catalytic assay screens by providing an alternative determination of inhibitor potency.     

The rise of covalent proteolysis targeting chimeras

Targeted protein degradation offers several advantages over direct inhibition of protein activity and is gaining increasing interest in chemical biology and drug discovery. Proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) in particular are enjoying widespread application. However, PROTACs, which recruit an E3 ligase for degradation of a target protein, still suffer from certain challenges. These include a limited selection for E3 ligases on the one hand and the requirement for potent target binding on the other hand. Both issues restrict the target scope available for PROTACs. Degraders that covalently engage the target protein or the E3 ligase can potentially expand the pool of both targets and E3 ligases. Moreover, they may offer additional advantages by improving the kinetics of ternary complex formation or by endowing additional selectivity to the degrader. Here, we review the recent progress in the emerging field of covalent PROTACs.     

Interaction of an anticancer benzopyrane derivative with DNA: Biophysical,biochemical, and molecular modeling studies

BackgroundSIMR1281 is a potent anticancer lead candidate with multi- target activity against several proteins; however, its mechanism of action at the molecular level is not fully understood. Revealing the mechanism and the origin of multitarget activity is important for the rational identification and optimization of multitarget drugs.MethodsWe have used a variety of biophysical (circular dichroism, isothermal titration calorimetry, viscosity, and UV DNA melting), biochemical (topoisomerase I & II assays) and computational (molecular docking and MD simulations) methods to study the interaction of SIMR1281 with duplex DNA structures.ResultsThe biophysical results revealed that SIMR1281 binds to dsDNA via an intercalation-binding mode with an average binding constant of 3.1 × 10⁶ M⁻¹. This binding mode was confirmed by the topoisomerases' inhibition assays and molecular modeling simulations, which showed the intercalation of the benzopyrane moiety between DNA base pairs, while the remaining moieties (thiazole and phenyl rings) sit in the minor groove and interact with the flanking base pairs adjacent to the intercalation site.ConclusionsThe DNA binding characteristics of SIMR1281, which can disrupt/inhibit DNA function as confirmed by the topoisomerases' inhibition assays, indicate that the observed multi-target activity might originate from ligand intervention at nucleic acids level rather than due to direct interactions with multiple biological targets at the protein level.General significanceThe findings of this study could be helpful to guide future optimization of benzopyrane-based ligands for therapeutic purposes.