Nonadaptive mutations occur on the F' episome during adaptive mutation conditions in Escherichia coli.

One of the most studied examples of adaptive mutation is a strain of Escherichia coli, FC40, that cannot utilize lactose (Lac-) but that readily reverts to lactose utilization (Lac+) when lactose is its sole carbon source. Adaptive reversion to Lac+ occurs at a high rate when the Lac- allele is on an F' episome and conjugal functions are expressed. It was previously shown that nonselected mutations on the chromosome did not appear in the Lac- population while episomal Lac+ mutations accumulated, but it remained possible that nonselected mutations might occur on the episome. To investigate this possibility, a second mutational target was created on the Lac- episome by mutation of a Tn1O element, which encodes tetracycline resistance (Tetr), to tetracycline sensitivity (Tets). Reversion rates to Tetr during normal growth and during lactose selection were measured. The results show that nonselected Tetr mutations do accumulate in Lac- cells when those cells are under selection to become Lac+. Thus, reversion to Lac+ in FC40 does not appear to be adaptive in the narrow sense of the word. In addition, the results suggest that during lactose selection, both Lac+ and Tetr mutations are created or preserved by the same recombination-dependent mechanism.     

Different characteristics distinguish early versus late arising adaptive mutations in Escherichia coli FC40

The Escherichia coli strain FC40 has frequently been employed to investigate the mechanism of adaptive mutations. The strain cannot utilize lactose due to a +1 frameshift mutation that reduces beta-galactosidase to about 1% of normal levels. Cells undergo a high rate of mutation from Lac- to Lac+ when cells are grown with lactose as the sole energy source. Almost all Lac+ colonies arising 3-6 days after plating result from a base pair deletion in runs of iterated base pairs within a 130-bp target region. In this study we characterized Lac+ colonies arising 3-10 days after plating. Temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) was used to detect mutations in the target region as a function of the day a colony appears. TGGE results confirmed the occurrence of mutations within the target region in 36 of 37 FC40 Lac+ colonies arising on days 3-7. However, mutations in this region were not detected in 23 of 37 Lac+ colonies arising from days 8-10. Sequencing data verified the TGGE results. Half of the Lac+ mutants arising on days 8-10 with no base pair change in the target region were unstable and exhibited a Lac- phenotype after successive growth cycles in rich medium. The results suggest that amplification of the lac operon region is a common factor in late arising colonies, and that different characteristics distinguish early and late arising Lac+ colonies.     

Genetic and molecular study of inability of the yeast Kluyveromyces lactis var drosophilarum to ferment lactose

The fermentation of lactose (Lac+) in the dairy yeast Kluyveromyces lactis var. lactis is controlled by the LAC4 (beta-galactosidase) and LAC12 (lactose permease) genes. The complementation analysis of twelve Kl. lactis var. drosophilarum natural homothallic Lac- strains of different origin was carried out using the genetic heterothallic lines of Kl. lactis var. lactis of the lac4LAC12 and LAC4lac12 genotypes. It was shown that the natural Lac- strains did not possess the LAC4LAC12 gene cluster. Southern hybridization of chromosomal DNA with LAC4 and LAC12 probes, as well as recombination analysis, showed that Kl. lactis var. drosophilarum yeasts do not have even silent copies of these genes. As distinct from this yeast, natural Lac- strains of the yeast Kl. marxianus are mutants impaired in the lactose permease gene (lac12 analogue), but possess an active beta-galactosidase gene (LAC4 analogue). The origin of the LAC4LAC12 gene cluster of the dairy yeasts Kl. lactis is discussed.     

Evidence that selected amplification of a bacterial lac frameshift allele stimulates Lac(+) reversion (adaptive mutation) with or without general hypermutability

In the genetic system of Cairns and Foster, a nongrowing population of an E. coli lac frameshift mutant appears to specifically accumulate Lac(+) revertants when starved on medium including lactose (adaptive mutation). This behavior has been attributed to stress-induced general mutagenesis in a subpopulation of starved cells (the hypermutable state model). We have suggested that, on the contrary, stress has no direct effect on mutability but favors only growth of cells that amplify their leaky mutant lac region (the amplification mutagenesis model). Selection enhances reversion primarily by increasing the mutant lac copy number within each developing clone on the selection plate. The observed general mutagenesis is attributed to a side effect of growth with an amplification-induction of SOS by DNA fragments released from a tandem array of lac copies. Here we show that the S. enterica version of the Cairns system shows SOS-dependent general mutagenesis and behaves in every way like the original E. coli system. In both systems, lac revertants are mutagenized during selection. Eliminating the 35-fold increase in mutation rate reduces revertant number only 2- to 4-fold. This discrepancy is due to continued growth of amplification cells until some clones manage to revert without mutagenesis solely by increasing their lac copy number. Reversion in the absence of mutagenesis is still dependent on RecA function, as expected if it depends on lac amplification (a recombination-dependent process). These observations support the amplification mutagenesis model.     

Increased episomal replication accounts for the high rate of adaptive mutation in recD mutants of Escherichia coli

Adaptive mutation has been studied extensively in FC40, a strain of Escherichia coli that cannot metabolize lactose (Lac-) because of a frameshift mutation affecting the lacZ gene on its episome. recD mutants of FC40, in which the exonuclease activity of RecBCD (ExoV) is abolished but its helicase activity is retained, have an increased rate of adaptive mutation. The results presented here show that, in several respects, adaptive mutation to Lac+ involves different mechanisms in recD mutant cells than in wild-type cells. About half of the apparent increase in the adaptive mutation rate of recD mutant cells is due to a RecA-dependent increase in episomal copy number and to growth of the Lac- cells on the lactose plates. The remaining increase appears to be due to continued replication of the episome, with the extra copies being degraded or passed to recD+ recipients. In addition, the increase in adaptive mutation rate in recD mutant cells is (i) dependent on activities of the single-stranded exonucleases, RecJ and ExoI, which are not required for (in fact, slightly inhibit) adaptive mutation in wild-type cells, and (ii) enhanced by RecG, which opposes adaptive mutation in wild-type cells.     

Population Dynamics of a Lac(-) Strain of Escherichia Coli during Selection for Lactose Utilization

During selection for lactose utilization, Lac(+) revertants of FC40, a Lac(-) strain of Escherichia coli, appear at a high rate. Yet, no Lac(+) revertants appear in the absence of lactose, or in its presence if the cells have another, unfulfilled requirement for growth. This study investigates more fully the population dynamics of FC40 when incubated in the absence of a carbon source or when undergoing selection for lactose utilization. In the absence of a carbon source, the viable cell numbers do not change over 6 days. When incubated in liquid lactose medium, Lac(-) cells do not undergo any measurable increase in numbers or in turbidity for at least 2 days. When FC40 is plated on lactose minimum medium in the presence of scavenger cells, the upper limit to the amount of growth of Lac(-) cells during 5 days is one doubling, and there is no evidence for turnover (i.e., a balance between growth and death). The presence of a minority population that could form microcolonies was not detected. The implications of these results, plus the fact that the appearance of Lac(+) revertants during lactose selection is nearly constant with time, are discussed in reference to several models that have been postulated to account for adaptive mutations.     

Involvement of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase II in response to oxidative damage and adaptive mutation.

DNA polymerase II (Pol II) is regulated as part of the SOS response to DNA damage in Escherichia coli. We examined the participation of Pol II in the response to oxidative damage, adaptive mutation, and recombination. Cells lacking Pol II activity (polB delta 1 mutants) exhibited 5- to 10-fold-greater sensitivity to mode 1 killing by H2O2 compared with isogenic polB+ cells. Survival decreased by about 15-fold when polB mutants containing defective superoxide dismutase genes, sodA and sodB, were compared with polB+ sodA sodB mutants. Resistance to peroxide killing was restored following P1 transduction of polB cells to polB+ or by conjugation of polB cells with an F' plasmid carrying a copy of polB+. The rate at which Lac+ mutations arose in Lac- cells subjected to selection for lactose utilization, a phenomenon known as adaptive mutation, was increased threefold in polB backgrounds and returned to wild-type rates when polB cells were transduced to polB+. Following multiple passages of polB cells or prolonged starvation, a progressive loss of sensitivity to killing by peroxide was observed, suggesting that second-site suppressor mutations may be occurring with relatively high frequencies. The presence of suppressor mutations may account for the apparent lack of a mutant phenotype in earlier studies. A well-established polB strain, a dinA Mu d(Apr lac) fusion (GW1010), exhibited wild-type (Pol II+) sensitivity to killing by peroxide, consistent with the accumulation of second-site suppressor mutations. A high titer anti-Pol II polyclonal antibody was used to screen for the presence of Pol II in other bacteria and in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Cross-reacting material was found in all gram-negative strains tested but was not detected in gram-positive strains or in S. cerevisiae. Induction of Pol II by nalidixic acid was observed in E. coli K-12, B, and C, in Shigella flexneri, and in Salmonella typhimurium.     

Plasmids, loss of lactose metabolism, and appearance of partial and full lactose-fermenting revertants in Streptococcus cremoris B1.

The unstable ability to metabolize lactose (lac) via the phosphoenolpyruvate-phosphotransferase system (PTS) was examined in Streptococcus cremoris B1. The presence of functional lactose-specific PTS enzymes was correlated with the presence of a distinct plasmid species. Characterization of deoxyribonucleic acid extracted from lactose-positive (Lac+) S. cremoris B1 revealed two plasmids having molecular weights of 9 X 10(6) and 36 X 10(6). An acriflavine (BC1)-induced, lactose-negative (Lac-) mutant possessed no plasmids and was devoid of all three lac-specific PTS enzymes. A Lac- mutant (DA2) isolated by growing at elevated temperatures only possessed the 9 X 10(6)-dalton plasmid and also lacked the lac PTS enzymes. A spontaneous Lac- mutant possessed both the 9 X 10(6)-and 36 X 10(6)-dalton plasmids. This mutant displayed FIII-lac and phospho-beta-D-galactosidase (P-beta-gal) activity but was deficient in EII-lac activity. The spontaneous Lac- strain reverted to both full and partial lactose-fermenting phenotypes having FIII-lac, EII-lac, and P-beta-gal activities. BC1 and DA2 Lac- mutants reverted only to the partial lactose-fermenting phenotype having P-beta-gal activity; EII-lac and FIII-lac activities were absent. The results indicate that the genetic determinants for EII-lac, FIII-lac, and P-beta-gal are located on the 36 X 10(6)-dalton plasmid in S. cremoris B1. Evidence for a second chromosomally associated P-beta-gal gene operating in the partial lactose-fermenting revertants is also presented.     

Two Enzymes, Both of Which Process Recombination Intermediates, Have opposite Effects on Adaptive Mutation in Escherichia Coli

Reversion of a lac(-) frameshift allele carried on an F' episome in Escherichia coli occurs at a high rate when the cells are placed under lactose selection. Unlike Lac(+) mutations that arise during nonselective growth, the production of these adaptive mutations requires the RecA-RecBCD pathway for recombination. In this report, we show that enzymes that process recombination intermediates are involved in the mutagenic process. RuvAB and RecG, E. coli's two enzymes for translocating Holliday junctions, have opposite effects: RuvAB is required for RecA-dependent adaptive mutations, whereas RecG inhibits them.     

Genetic analysis of the phase variation control of expression of type 1 fimbriae in Escherichia coli.

Expression of type 1 fimbriae in Escherichia coli exhibits phase variation, whereby individual cells can alternate between states of organelle expression (Fim+) and nonexpression (Fim-). Strains with a fimD-lac operon fusion, in which lac, rather than fimD, expression is under the control of the fimD promoter, undergo Lac+ in equilibrium Lac- phase variation, instead. After positioning a lambda prophage adjacent to the operon fusion, we were able to isolate specialized lambda phage carrying both the fimD-lac fusion and the phase variation control region. Introduction of such phage into an Fim+ strain resulted in construction of a strain with a double, independently switching phenotype (Fim+ in equilibrium Fim- and Lac+ in equilibrium Lac-), demonstrating that the region controlling phase variation is contiguous with the fimD-lac operon fusion and is cis acting. When the specialized lambda phage was propagated on a delta lac delta fim strain, phase variation occurred within the plaques, confirming that the phase variation control region is carried on the specialized transducing phage. All lysogens acquired the Lac+ in equilibrium Lac- phenotype, except for two nonswitching Lac+ recombinants, which acquired Lac+ in equilibrium Lac- phase variation only by trans complementation with fim. Phase variation of type 1 fimbriae, therefore, appears to involve both a cis-active element, which is cloned on a specialized lambda phage, and a trans-active permissive factor, which is not present on the phage, but rather must be supplied by the recipient strain in the transduction.     

Plasmids in Streptococcus lactis: evidence that lactose metabolism and proteinase activity are plasmid linked.

Populations of lactose positive (Lac+) and proteinase positive (Prt+) cells from Streptococcus lactis M18, C10, and ML3 grown at 39 degrees C gave rise to increasing proportions of Lac- Prt- clones. The deficiencies did not appear until after a number of generations at the elevated temperature, and the rate depended on the strain.Lac- Prt+ and Lac+ Prt- mutants were isolated after treatment with ethidium bromide. Plasmid deoxyribonucleic acid was isolated by cesium chloride-ethidium bromide equilibrium density gradient centrifugation from the parent cultures as well as from their Lac- Prt-, Lac- Prt+, and Lac+ Prt- mutants. Five distinct plasmid sizes of approximate molecular weights of 2,4, 8, 21, and 27 million were found in S. lactis C10, whereas the Lac- Prt- derivative lacked the 8- and 21-million-dalton plasmids, but the 8-million-dalton plasmid was present in the Lac-Att mutant. In S. lactis m18 five plasmids possessing molecular weights of about 2, 4, 10, 18 and 27 million were observed. The 10- and 18-million-dalton plasmids were not detected in the Lac- Prt- mutants, whereas the Lac- Prt+ derivative lacked only the 18-million-dalton plasmid and the Lac+ Prt- mutant lacked only the 10-million-dalton plasmid. In S. lactis ML3 five distinct plasmids, with approximate molecular weights of 2, 4, 8, 22, and 30 million, were present. The 8- and 22-million-dalton plasmids were not detected in the Lac- Prt- derivative, but the 8-million-dalton plasmid was present in the Lac- Prt+ mutant. The evidence suggests that lactose-fermenting ability and proteinase activity in these organisms are mediated through two distinct plasmids having molecular weights of 8 x 10(6) to 10 x 10(6) for proteinase activity and 18 x 10(6) to 22 x 10(6) for lactose metabolism.     

In pursuit of a molecular mechanism for adaptive gene amplification

"Adaptive" or "stationary-phase" mutation is a collection of apparent stress responses in which cells exposed to a growth-limiting environment generate genetic changes, some of which can allow resumption of rapid growth. In the well-characterized Lac system of Escherichia coli, reversions of a lac frameshift allele give rise to adaptive point mutations. Also in this system, adaptive gene amplification has been documented as a separate and parallel response that allows growth on lactose medium without acquisition of a compensatory frameshift mutation. In amplification, the DNA region containing the weakly functional lac allele becomes amplified to multiple copies, which produce sufficient enzyme activity to allow growth on the otherwise growth-limiting lactose medium. The amplifications are "adaptive" in that they occur after cells encounter the growth-limiting environment. Adaptive amplification is a reversible genetic change that allows adaptation and growth. It may be similar to chromosomal instability observed in the origins and progression of many cancers. We explore possible molecular mechanisms of adaptive amplification in the bacterial system and note parallels to chromosomal instability in other systems.     

Lactose and melibiose metabolism in Erwinia chrysanthemi.

A Lac+ mutant of Erwinia chrysanthemi was isolated from the Lac- wild type on lactose agar. beta-Galactosidase was expressed independently of lactose transport in both the mutant and the wild type, and neither strain expressed thiogalactoside transacetylase. Lactose transport and alpha-galactosidase, constitutive in the Lac+ strain, were coordinately induced in the Lac- strain by melibiose and raffinose but not by isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside or thiomethyl-beta-D-galactopyranoside. Melibiose was a strong inhibitor of both the melibiose- and the raffinose-induced lactose permeases, whereas raffinose was a strong inhibitor of only the raffinose-induced lactose permease.     

The amplification model for adaptive mutation: simulations and analysis

It has been proposed that the lac revertants arising under selective conditions in the Cairns experiment do not arise by stress-induced mutagenesis of stationary phase cells as has been previously assumed. Instead, these revertants may arise within growing clones initiated by cells with a preexisting duplication of the weakly functional lac allele used in this experiment. It is proposed that spontaneous stepwise increases in lac copy number (amplification) allow a progressive improvement in growth. Reversion is made more likely primarily by the resultant increase in the number of mutational targets--more cells with more lac copies. The gene amplification model requires no stress-induced variation in the rate or target specificity of mutation and thus does not violate neo-Darwinian theory. However, it does require that a multistep process of amplification, reversion, and amplification segregation be completed within approximately 20 generations of growth. This work examines the proposed amplification model from a theoretical point of view, formalizing it into a mathematical framework and using this to determine what would be required for the process to occur within the specified period. The analysis assumes no stress-induced change in mutation rate and describes only the growth improvement occurring during the process of amplification and subsequent elimination of excess mutant lac copies. The dynamics of the system are described using Monte Carlo simulations and numerical integration of the deterministic equations governing the system. The results imply that the amplification model can account for the behavior of the system using biologically reasonable parameter values and thus can, in principle, explain Cairnsian adaptive mutation.     

Some features of the mutability of bacteria during nonlethal selection

We describe the mutability of the Trp(-) chromosomal +1 frameshift mutation trpE7999 during nonlethal selection, finding that the appearance of Trp(+) revertants behaves similarly to that of episomal Lac(+) revertants. In addition, we show that a feature of the Lac(+) and Trp(+) mutability is the accumulation of Trp(+) and Lac(+) revertants with additional unselected mutations, most of which are not due to heritable mutators. The cells undergoing nonlethal selection apparently experience an epigenetic change resulting in a subset of bacteria with elevated mutability that often remain hypermutable for the duration of selection. The epigenetic change provoked by nonlethal selection appears to be mediated by a unique function provided by the F'128 episome.     

Adaptive Reversion of a Frameshift Mutation in Escherichia Coli

Mutation rates are generally thought not to be influenced by selective forces. This doctrine rests on the results of certain classical studies of the mutations that make bacteria resistant to phages and antibiotics. We have studied a strain of Escherichia coli which constitutively expresses a lacI-lacZ fusion containing a frameshift mutation that renders it Lac-. Reversion to Lac+ is a rare event during exponential growth but occurs in stationary cultures when lactose is the only source of energy. No revertants accumulate in the absence of lactose, or in the presence of lactose if there is another, unfulfilled requirement for growth. The mechanism for such mutation in stationary phase is not known, but it requires some function of RecA which is apparently not required for mutation during exponential growth.     

Lactose metabolism involving phospho-beta-galactosidase in Klebsiella.

Klebsiella strain RE1755A is a Lac- Gal- mutant which has lost both of its lac operons, but possesses a gene specifying beta-galactosidase III, an enzyme which hydrolyzes o-nitrophenyl-beta-D-galactopyranoside but does not hydrolyze lactose. Selective pressure was applied to isolate mutants able to utilize lactose. The lactose-utilizing mutants obtained were shown to possess an unaltered beta-galactosidase III. Lactose utilization was shown to result from a pleiotropic mutation which also (i) permits galactose utilization and (ii) prevents induction of beta-galactosidase III synthesis by lactose. Evidence is presented suggesting that a phospho-beta-galactosidase enzyme is involved in lactose metabolism.