Correlation between initial chromatid damage and survival of various cell lines exposed to heavy charged particles

The biophysical characteristics of heavy ions make them a rational source of radiation for use in radiotherapy of malignant tumours. Prior to radiotherapy treatment, a therapeutic regimen must be precisely defined, and during this stage information on individual patient radiosensitivity would be of very great medical value. There are various methods to predict radiosensitivity, but some shortfalls are difficult to avoid. The present study investigated the induction of chromatid breaks in five different cell lines, including one normal liver cell line (L02), exposed to carbon ions accelerated by the heavy ion research facility in Lanzhou (HIRFL), using chemically induced premature chromosome condensation (PCC). Previous studies have reported the number of chromatid breaks to be linearly related to the radiation dose, but the relationship between cell survival and chromatid breaks is not clear. The major result of the present study is that cellular radiosensitivity, as measured by D₀, is linearly correlated with the frequency of chromatid breaks per Gy in these five cell lines. We propose that PCC may be applied to predict radiosensitivity of tumour cells exposed to heavy ions.     

A correlation between radiation sensitivity and initial chromatid breaks in cancer cell lines revealed by Calyculin A-induced premature condensation

Three human malignancy cell lines were irradiated with ⁶⁰Co γ-rays. Initial chromatid breaks were measured by using the chemically induced premature chromosome condensation technique. Survival curves of cells exposed to gamma rays was linear-quadratic while the efficiency of Calyculin A in inducing PCC of G₂ PCC was about five times more than G₁ PCC. A dose-dependent increase in radiation-induced chromatid/isochromatid breaks was observed in G₁ and G₂ phase PCC and a nearly positive linear correlation was found between cell survival and chromatin breaks. This study implies that low LET radiation-induced chromatid/isochromatid breaks can potentially be used to predict the radiosensitivity of tumor cells either in in vitro experimentation or in in vivo clinical radiotherapy.     

Progress towards understanding the nature of chromatid breakage

The wide range of sensitivities of stimulated T-cells from different individuals to radiation-induced chromatid breakage indicates the involvement of several low penetrance genes that appear to link elevated chromatid breakage to cancer susceptibility. The mechanisms of chromatid breakage are not yet fully understood. However, evidence is accumulating that suggests chromatid breaks are not simply expanded DNA double-strand breaks (DSB). Three models of chromatid breakage are considered. The classical breakage-first and the Revell "exchange" models do not accord with current evidence. Therefore a derivative of Revell's model has been proposed whereby both spontaneous and radiation-induced chromatid breaks result from DSB signaling and rearrangement processes from within large looped chromatin domains. Examples of such rearrangements can be observed by harlequin staining whereby an exchange of strands occurs immediately adjacent to the break site. However, these interchromatid rearrangements comprise less than 20% of the total breaks. The rest are thought to result from intrachromatid rearrangements, including a very small proportion involving complete excision of a looped domain. Work is in progress with the aim of revealing these rearrangements, which may involve the formation of inversions adjacent to the break sites. It is postulated that the disappearance of chromatid breaks with time results from the completion of such rearrangements, rather than from the rejoining of DSB. Elevated frequencies of chromatid breaks occur in irradiated cells with defects in both nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ) and homologous recombination (HR) pathways, however there is little evidence of a correlation between reduced DSB rejoining and disappearance of chromatid breaks. Moreover, at least one treatment which abrogates the disappearance of chromatid breaks with time leaves DSB rejoining unaffected. The I-SceI DSB system holds considerable promise for the elucidation of these mechanisms, although the break frequency is relatively low in the cell lines so far derived. Techniques to study and improve such systems are under way in different cell lines. Clearly, much remains to be done to clarify the mechanisms involved in chromatid breakage, but the experimental models are becoming available with which we can begin to answer some of the key questions.     

Molecular mechanisms involved in the production of cromosomal aberrations II. Utilization of neurospora endonuclease for the study of aberration production by X-rays in G1 and G2 stages of the cell cycle

Chinese hamster ovary cells (CHO) were X-irradiated in G₁ and G₂ stages of the cell cycle and subsequently Neurospora endonuclease (NE) (E.C.3.1.4), an enzyme which is specific in cleaving single-stranded DNA, was introduced into the cells, after making the cells permeable by treatment with inactivated Sendai virus. With this treatment all classes of X-ray-induced chromatid aberrations increased in G₂ cells, whereas in G₁ cells an increase in cromosome type of aberrations was found, associated with a profound induction of chromatid type of aberrations as well. Duration of the availability of single-strand gaps for the action of NE has been studied in G₂ cells following X-irradiation and the influence of different parts of the G₂ stage on the type and frequencies of chromatid aberrations was discerned. While the increase in chromosome type of aberrations by NE in X-irradiated G₁ cells has been interpreted as due to the conversion of DNA single-strand breaks or gaps to double-strand breaks by NE, the induction of chromatid aberrations in G₁ has been assumed to be due to conversion of some of the damaged bases strand breaks by NE. Biochemical evidence is presented for the conversion by NE of DNA single-strand breaks induced by X-rays into double-strand breaks using neutral sucrose gradient centrifugation.     

Sedimentation of DNA of Dictyostelium discoideum lysed on alkaline sucrose gradients: role of single-strand breaks in gamma ray lethality of sensitive and resistant strains

The nuclear and mitochondrial DNA of the amoebae of the cellular slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum have been labeled with [methyl-³H]thymidine by allowing them to grow on Escherichia coli 15T^? containing this label in its DNA. Neutral CsCl gradients were used to identify the labeled molecules. Alkaline sucrose sedimentation profiles of cells lysed directly on the gradients revealed two high molecular weight species, one of about 90 S (single-strand mol wt = 1.4 × 10⁸) identified by alkaline CsCl rebanding as nuclear DNA, and another of 43 S (single-strand mol wt = 2.3 × 10⁷), identified as mitochondrial DNA. These alkaline sucrose gradients were used to study the production of single-strand breaks and their rejoining in DNA of a gamma ray-resistant strain (NC-4; 10% survival dose for cell proliferation, D₁₀ = 300 krad) and in two radiation-sensitive daughter mutants (γs-18, D₁₀ = 75 krad; γs-13, D₁₀ = 4 krad). With ⁶⁰Co gamma rays, breaks were produced in nuclear and mitochondrial DNA at an efficiency of one break per 33 eV in all three strains. At doses up to about 100 krad, these single-strand breaks were closed equally well during post-irradiation incubation of NC-4, γs-18 and γs-13, even though their survivals were widely different, indicating no apparent correlation between parental strand rejoining and survival in the sensitive strains. At higher doses, post-irradiation treatment with 1 mg caffeine/ml sensitized NC-4 and retarded strand-rejoining, suggesting that lethality in this resistant strain may be related to strand breaks. It is concluded that single-strand rejoining is a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for radiation survival in this organism. The nature of the apparently unrepaired lesions leading to lethality in the sensitive strains is not known.     

Repression of mutagenesis by Rad51D-mediated homologous recombination

Homologous recombinational repair (HRR) restores chromatid breaks arising during DNA replication and prevents chromosomal rearrangements that can occur from the misrepair of such breaks. In vertebrates, five Rad51 paralogs are identified that contribute in a nonessential but critical manner to HRR proficiency. We constructed and characterized a knockout of the paralog Rad51D in widely studied CHO cells. The rad51d mutant (clone 51D1) displays sensitivity to a diverse spectrum of induced DNA damage including gamma-rays, ultraviolet (UV)-C radiation, and methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), indicating the broad relevance of HRR to genotoxicity. Spontaneous chromatid breaks/gaps and isochromatid breaks are elevated 3- to 12-fold, but the chromosome number distribution remains unchanged. Most importantly, 51D1 cells exhibit a 12-fold-increased rate of hprt mutation, as well as 4- to 10-fold increased rates of gene amplification at the dhfr and CAD loci, respectively. Xrcc3 irs1SF cells from the same parental CHO line show similarly elevated mutagenesis at these three loci. Collectively, these results confirm the a priori expectation that HRR acts in an error-free manner to repress three classes of genetic alterations (chromosomal aberrations, loss of gene function and increased gene expression), all of which are associated with carcinogenesis.     

Radiation-induced chromatid aberrations in the bone marrow and lymph nodes of the rat during the first 24 h after irradiation

Wistar rats of both sexes were exposed to 100 R of X-rays. Chromatid-type aberrations in metaphase figures of bone marrow and lymph node cells were scored after 2, 4, 6, 8 and 24 h and 3, 5, 7, 9 and 24 h, respectively.The shape of the curve for chromatid plus isochromatid breaks in bone marrow cells versus time is exponential. It is suggested that this shape is mainly a consequence of the continuous entrance into mitosis of cells irradiated while in S phase, in addition to those that were irradiated in G₂. For lymph nodes the frequency of chromatid plus isochromatid deletions increased up to the 5th h, then began to fall off in a manner similar to that for the bone marrow. The difference in the shape of the two curves is the consequence of the different dependence on time for chromatid and isochromatid breaks in each tissue. While the frequency of chromatid breaks fell steeply with time both for the bone marrow and for lymph nodes, the frequency of isochromatid breaks remained nearly constant for bone marrow, whereas it rose to a peak at the 5th h for the lymph nodes.These differences are tentatively explained by a shift in the phases of the cell cycle sampled owing to the greater mitotic delay of G₂ cells in lymph nodes, with the suggestion that in the late S phase the frequency of isochromatid breaks is lower than in all other phases of the cell cycle.     

Induction of chromatid breaks by carbon K-shell ultrasoft X rays

Chromatid breaks have previously been shown to be induced in G2-phase cells after exposure to ionizing radiation (X and gamma rays) as a linear function of dose, consistent with a single-event mechanism. DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) are thought to be the initiating lesion, and experiments with a genetically engineered cell line containing a single DSB site also indicate that a single DSB is sufficient to induce a chromatid break. Although the precise mechanism of conversion of an isolated DSB into a chromatid break is not yet understood, it is known that a proportion of chromatid breaks result from rearrangements between sister chromatids. Here we report further evidence for the single-event hypothesis for the formation of chromatid breaks. The evidence derives from experiments in which chromatid breaks have been induced by exposure of Chinese hamster cells to ultrasoft carbon K-shell X rays. Since the energy of carbon K-shell X rays is not sufficient for the secondary electrons to span more than one DNA double helix, we conclude that single traversals, and hence single (complex) DSBs, are responsible for the formation of chromatid breaks. We find that, as for 60Co gamma rays, around 10% of the carbon K-shell X-ray-induced chromatid breaks have associated color switches at breakpoints, indicating that they arise through sister chromatid rearrangements.     

The Fanconi anemia pathway limits the severity of mutagenesis

Fanconi anemia (FA) is a developmental and cancer predisposition disorder in which key, yet unknown, physiological events promoting chromosome stability are compromised. FA cells exhibit excess metaphase chromatid breaks and are universally hypersensitive to DNA interstrand crosslinking agents. Published mutagenesis data from single-gene mutation assays show both increased and decreased mutation frequencies in FA cells. In this review we discuss the data from the literature and from our isogenic fancg knockout hamster CHO cells, and interpret these data within the framework of a molecular model that accommodates these seemingly divergent observations. In FA cells, reduced rates of recovery of viable X-linked hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (hprt) mutants are characteristically observed for diverse mutagenic agents, but also in untreated cultures, indicating the relevance of the FA pathway for processing assorted DNA lesions. We ascribe these reductions to: (1) impaired mutagenic translesion synthesis within hprt during DNA replication and (2) lethality of mutant cells following replication fork breakage on the X chromosome, caused by unrepaired double-strand breaks or large deletions/translocations encompassing essential genes flanking hprt. These findings, along with studies showing increased spontaneous mutability of FA cells at two autosomal loci, support a model in which FA proteins promote both translesion synthesis at replication-blocking lesions and repair of broken replication forks by homologous recombination and DNA end joining. The essence of this model is that the FANC protein pathway serves to restrict the severity of mutational outcome by favoring base substitutions and small deletions over larger deletions and chromosomal rearrangements.     

Telomerase-dependent and -independent chromosome healing in mouse embryonic stem cells

Telomeres play an important role in protecting the ends of chromosomes and preventing chromosome fusion. We have previously demonstrated that double-strand breaks near telomeres in mammalian cells result in either the addition of a new telomere at the site of the break, termed chromosome healing, or sister chromatid fusion that initiates chromosome instability. In the present study, we have investigated the role of telomerase in chromosome healing and the importance of chromosome healing in preventing chromosome instability. In embryonic stem cell lines that are wild type for the catalytic subunit of telomerase (TERT), chromosome healing at I-SceI-induced double-strand breaks near telomeres accounted for 22 of 35 rearrangements, with the new telomeres added directly at the site of the break in all but one instance. In contrast, in two TERT-knockout embryonic stem cell lines, chromosome healing accounted for only 1 of 62 rearrangements, with a 23 bp insertion at the site of the sole chromosome-healing event. However, in a third TERT-knockout embryonic stem cell line, 10PTKO-A, chromosome healing was a common event that accounted for 20 of 34 rearrangements. Although this chromosome healing also occurred at the I-SceI site, differences in the microhomology at the site of telomere addition demonstrated that the mechanism was distinct from that in wild-type embryonic stem cell lines. In addition, the newly added telomeres in 10PTKO-A shortened with time in culture, eventually resulting in either telomere elongation through a telomerase-independent mechanism or loss of the subtelomeric plasmid sequences entirely. The combined results demonstrate that chromosome healing can occur through both telomerase-dependent and -independent mechanisms, and that although both mechanisms can prevent degradation and sister chromatid fusion, neither mechanism is efficient enough to prevent sister chromatid fusion from occurring in many cells experiencing double-strand breaks near telomeres.     

Proliferative potential after DNA damage and non-homologous end joining are affected by loss of securin

The faithful repair of DNA damage, especially chromosomal double-strand breaks (DSBs), is crucial for genomic integrity. We have previously shown that securin interacts with the Ku70/80 heterodimer of the DSB non-homologous DNA end-joining (NHEJ) repair machinery. Here we demonstrate that securin deficiency compromises cell survival and proliferation, but only after genotoxic stress. Securin(-/-) cells show a significant increase in gross chromosomal rearrangements and chromatid breaks after DNA damage, and also reveal an altered pattern of end resection in an NHEJ assay in comparison with securin(+/+) cells. These data suggest that securin has a key role in the maintenance of genomic stability after DNA damage, thereby providing a previously unknown mechanism for regulating tumour progression.     

Chromosome breakage and rejoining of sister chromatids in Bloom's syndrome

The occurrence of chromosome breaks and reunion of sister chromatids in lymphocytes of two patients with Bloom's syndrome has been compared with those found in X-rayed and control cells. The distribution of breaks in BS is non-random both between and within chromosomes, the centric regions of certain chromosomes being preferentially involved. The following working hypotheses are put forward: When chromosome breaks in human lymphocytes occur in G₀— G₁, practically no sister chromatid reunion (SCR) takes place, whereas ends created by an S—G₂ break show a considerable tendency to SCR. We propose further that chromosome aberrations in BS mainly result from breaks in S—G₂, including possible U-type rejoining of sister chromatid exchanges. Fragments extra to an intact chromosome complement result from a chromatid break or an asymmetrical chromatid translocation in a previous mitosis.     

Synthesis and cellular bioactivities of novel isoxazole derivatives incorporating an arylpiperazine moiety as anticancer agents

In our endeavour towards the development of effective anticancer therapeutics, a novel series of isoxazole-piperazine hybrids were synthesized and evaluated for their cytotoxic activities against human liver (Huh7 and Mahlavu) and breast (MCF-7) cancer cell lines. Within series, compounds 5l-o showed the most potent cytotoxicity on all cell lines with IC₅₀ values in the range of 0.3–3.7?μM. To explore the mechanistic aspects fundamental to the observed activity, further biological studies with 5m and 5o in liver cancer cells were carried out. We have demonstrated that 5m and 5o induce oxidative stress in PTEN adequate Huh7 and PTEN deficient Mahlavu human liver cancer cells leading to apoptosis and cell cycle arrest at different phases. Further analysis of the proteins involved in apoptosis and cell cycle revealed that 5m and 5o caused an inhibition of cell survival pathway through Akt hyperphosphorylation and apoptosis and cell cycle arrest through p53 protein activation.     

The effects of incorporated tritium and bromodeoxyuridine on the frequency of sister chromatid exchanges

Cells in third mitosis treated during the first cell cycle with ³H-TdR and during the next two cycles with BrdU (without ³H-TdR) show a typical pattern of chromosome differentiation which allows identification of sister chromatid exchanges occurring during the first (SCE₁, second (SCE₂) and third cycles (SCE₃). Chromosomes labeled only with ³H-TdR had the most SCEs; those labeled only with BrdU, the second highest number; and those labeled with ³H-TdR plus BrdU, the fewest. Since BrdU and ³H-TdR are well known inducers of SCEs, the relatively low frequency of exchanges produced by the combined action of these two compounds is paradoxical. — It is assumed that SCEs are generated by the abnormal recombination of double-strand DNA breaks occurring at the junctions between completely and partially duplicated replicon clusters. Thus, agents that induce absolute blocks to DNA fork displacement will favor the appearance of SCEs because double-strand breaks have more time to occur at junctions. Conversely, agents that inhibit the initiation of replication will decrease the probability of SCEs. Ionizing radiation delays the onset of cluster replication. Therefore, in ³H-TdR plus BrdU-substituted chromosomes the radiation from tritium may inhibit the appearance of BrdU-induced SCEs. Since the inhibition does not exist in chromosomes substituted only with BrdU, the frequency of SCEs in these elements is higher than in double-substituted chromosomes. During the first cell cycle the onset of cluster replication is normal. However, the incorporation of ³H-TdR in the replication fork may enhance the appearance of double-strand breaks, thus inducing a high frequency of SCEs.     

The concentration jump method

Lipophilic cationic fluorescent dyes (D) specifically stain the mitochondria of living cells. A perfusion chamber for cell cultures is described, which can be used to determine the kinetics of vital staining of the mitochondria of single selected cells in situ. In these experiments styrylpyridinium dyes and cultures of HeLa cells were used. The dyes differ strongly in their lipophilic properties; R _m values and the partition coefficients P _o/w between n-octanol (o) and water (w) were determined in order to characterize their lipophilicity. In the thermostat-regulated chamber the concentration of the dye C _D can be increased from C _D=0 to C _D>0 within a few seconds (concentration jump). Thus, the time t=0 for the beginning of the vital staining and the dye concentration in the cell medium during the staining experiment, C _D=const., are unambiguously defined. The concentration of the dye, C _b, which is bound to the mitochondria (b), is proportional to the intensity of the fluorescence I _b. On the other hand, the free dye molecules (f) in the aqueous medium exhibit practically no fluorescence, I _fI _b. The intensity of the fluorescence I=I _b was measured as a function of time t; the measured values were corrected for photobleaching. The fluorescence intensity I(t) at first increases linearly with t and reaches a saturation value for t . In the linear range of I(t) the flow J _o=(dI/dt)_o of the dye into the cell depends strongly on the dye concentration and increases linearly with C _D. The concentration range C _D=10^–9–10^–5 M at 37° C was investigated. From the linear correlation between J _o and C _D it follows that the kinetics of the vital staining of mitochondria is controlled by diffusion. At t=0 the flow of the xenobiotic agent through the cell membrane determines the rate of staining. The slope dJ _o/dC _D of the plot J _o vs C _D describes the efficiency of dye accumulation at the mitochondria and strongly increases with increasing lipophilicity of the dye molecules. Thus lipophilic dyes pass through the cell membrane more easily than less lipophilic molecules.     

Chromatid damage induced by fluorescent light during G2 phase in normal and Gardner syndrome fibroblasts. Interpretation in terms of deficient DNA repair

Skin fibroblasts from Gardner syndrome (GS) compared with those from normal donors showed a significantly higher incidence of chromatid gaps and breaks following exposure to low-intensity, cool-white fluorescent light during G2 phase of the cell cycle. Considerable evidence supports the concept that chromatid gaps and breaks seen directly after exposure to DNA-damaging agents represent unrepaired DNA single- and double-strand breaks respectively. The changes in incidence of chromatid aberrations with time after light exposure are consistent with the sequence of events known to follow DNA damage and repair. Initially, the incidence of light-induced chromatid gaps was equivalent in GS and normal fibroblasts. In the normal cells, the chromatid gaps disappeared by 1 h post-exposure, presumably as a result of efficient repair of DNA single-strand breaks. In contrast, the incidence of gaps increased in GS cells by 0.5 h followed by a decrease at 1 h and concomitant increase in chromatid breaks. It appears from these findings that the increased incidence of chromatid damage in GS fibroblasts results from deficient repair of DNA single-strand breaks which arise from incomplete nucleotide excision of DNA damage during G2 phase.     

Enhancement of chromosome aberrations by the combination of DNA substitution with halogenated deoxyuridine and streptonigrin treatments

We treated CHO cells with streptonigrin (SN) alone, in combination with BrdUrd or IdUrd substitution, and with or without the addition of caffeine. The cells assessed for chromosome damage by SN were in the G₂ period and the magnitude of the damage was expressed as monosubstituted chromatid breaks, bisubstituted chromatid breaks and boundary regions breaks (boundary regions indicate the point of exchange of mono- and bisubstituted chromatids). We found that the combination of BrdUrd or IdUrd substitution with SN treatments produced a remarkable increase in the frequency of breaks over the frequencies observed with the halogenated compound only. The effect was more evident with IdUrd than with BrdUrd, and more dramatic in bisubstituted than in monosubstituted chromatids. The frequency of boundary breaks in cells treated with BrdUrd plus SN was similar to the frequency of breaks in monosubstituted chromatids treated similarly. Conversely, the damage in boundary regions was almost similar to that in bisubstituted chromatids in cells challenged with IdUrd plus SN. The addition of caffeine to BrdUrd-substituted chromosomes gave rise to a marked enhancement of breakages with a gradient of chromatid damage that was: bisubstituted > monosubstituted > boundary regions. A further increase of chromatin breaks maintaining the gradient indicated above was obtained when the cells were treated with BrdUrd plus SN plus caffeine. We propose that BrdUrd and IdUrd substitution alone or in combination with caffeine treatments and with SN in its capacity to bind DNA, give rise to different chromatin structures capable of modulating the DNA damage induced along the chromatin fibril by the active oxygen species liberated by SN-DNA complexes.     

Dose rate effects of low-LET ionizing radiation on fish cells

Radiobiological responses of a highly clonogenic fish cell line, eelB, to low-LET ionizing radiation and effects of dose rates were studied. In acute exposure to 0.1–12 Gy of gamma rays, eelB’s cell survival curve displayed a linear–quadratic (LQ) relationship. In the LQ model, α, β, and α/β ratio were 0.0024, 0.037, and 0.065, respectively; for the first time that these values were reported for fish cells. In the multi-target model, n, D _o, and D _q values were determined to be 4.42, 2.16, and 3.21 Gy, respectively, and were the smallest among fish cell lines being examined to date. The mitochondrial potential response to gamma radiation in eelB cells was at least biphasic: mitochondria hyperpolarized 2 h and then depolarized 5 h post-irradiation. Upon receiving gamma rays with a total dose of 5 Gy, dose rates (ranging between 83 and 1366 mGy/min) had different effects on the clonogenic survival but not the mitochondrial potential. The clonogenic survival was significantly higher at the lowest dose rate of 83 mGy/min than at the other higher dose rates. Upon continuous irradiation with beta particles from tritium at 0.5, 5, 50, and 500 mGy/day for 7 days, mitochondria significantly depolarized at the three higher dose rates. Clearly, dose rates had differential effects on the clonogenic survival of and mitochondrial membrane potential in fish cells.     

Appendix: A model of plaque formation

Equations describing plaque formation in soft agar have been based on certain simplifying assumptions, for which data are presented. The derived equations permit one to calculate (i) average plaque size as a function of the initial density of indicator cells (D_o), (ii) the number of cells lysed per plaque as a function of D_o, and (iii) the cumulative number of cells lysed at various stages of plaque development. The calculated values agree well with those determined experimentally.