Recombinant collagen studies link the severe conformational changes induced by osteogenesis imperfecta mutations to the disruption of a set of interchain salt bridges

The clinical severity of Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI), also known as the brittle bone disease, relates to the extent of conformational changes in the collagen triple helix induced by Gly substitution mutations. The lingering question is why Gly substitutions at different locations of collagen cause different disruptions of the triple helix. Here, we describe markedly different conformational changes of the triple helix induced by two Gly substitution mutations placed only 12 residues apart. The effects of the Gly substitutions were characterized using a recombinant collagen fragment modeling the 63-residue segment of the alpha1 chain of type I collagen containing no Hyp (residues 877-939) obtained from Escherichia coli. Two Gly --> Ser substitutions at Gly-901 and Gly-913 associated with, respectively, mild and severe OI variants were introduced by site-directed mutagenesis. Biophysical characterization and limited protease digestion experiments revealed that while the substitution at Gly-901 causes relatively minor destabilization of the triple helix, the substitution at Gly-913 induces large scale unfolding of an unstable region C-terminal to the mutation site. This extensive unfolding is caused by the intrinsic low stability of the C-terminal region of the helix and the mutation induced disruption of a set of salt bridges, which functions to lock this unstable region into the triple helical conformation. The extensive conformational changes associated with the loss of the salt bridges highlight the long range impact of the local interactions of triple helix and suggest a new mechanism by which OI mutations cause severe conformational damages in collagen.     

Folding and conformational consequences of glycine to alanine replacements at different positions in a collagen model peptide

The collagen model peptide T1-892 includes a C-terminal nucleation domain, (Gly-Pro-Hyp)(4), and an N-terminal (Gly-X-Y)(6) sequence taken from type I collagen. In osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) and other collagen diseases, single base mutations often convert one Gly to a larger residue, and T1-892 homologues modeling such mutations were synthesized with Gly to Ala substitutions in either the (Gly-Pro-Hyp)(4) domain, Gly25Ala, or the (Gly-X-Y)(6) domain, Gly10Ala. CD and NMR studies show the Gly10Ala peptide forms a normal triple-helix at the C-terminal end and propagates from the C- to the N-terminus until the Gly --> Ala substitution is encountered. At this point, triple-helix folding is terminated and cannot be reinitiated, leaving a nonhelical N-terminus. A decreased thermal stability is observed as a result of the shorter length of the triple-helix. In contrast, introduction of the Gly to Ala replacement at position 25, in the nucleation domain, shifts the monomer/trimer equilibrium toward the monomer form. The increased monomer and lower trimer populations are reflected in the dramatic decrease in triple-helix content and stability. Unlike the Ala replacement at position 10, the Ala substitution in the (Gly-Pro-Hyp)(4) region can still be incorporated into a triple-helix, but at a greatly decreased rate of folding, since the original efficient nucleation site is no longer operative. The specific consequences of Gly to Ala replacements in two distinctive sequences in this triple-helical peptide may help clarify the variability in OI clinical severity resulting from mutations at different sites along type I collagen chains.     

Osteogenesis Imperfecta Model Peptides: Incorporation of Residues Replacing Gly within a Triple Helix Achieved by Renucleation and Local Flexibility

Missense mutations, which replace one Gly with a larger residue in the repeating sequence of the type I collagen triple helix, lead to the hereditary bone disorder osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). Previous studies suggest that these mutations may interfere with triple-helix folding. NMR was used to investigate triple-helix formation in a series of model peptides where the residue replacing Gly, as well as the local sequence environment, was varied. NMR measurement of translational diffusion coefficients allowed the identification of partially folded species. When Gly was replaced by Ala, the Ala residue was incorporated into a fully folded triple helix, whereas replacement of Gly by Ser or Arg resulted in the presence of some partially folded species, suggesting a folding barrier. Increasing the triple-helix stability of the sequence N-terminal to a Gly-to-Ser replacement allowed complete triple-helix folding, whereas with the substitution of Arg, with its large side chain, the peptide achieved full folding only after flexible residues were introduced N-terminal to the mutation site. These studies shed light on the factors important for accommodation of Gly mutations within the triple helix and may relate to the varying severity of OI.     

Stability junction at a common mutation site in the collagenous domain of the mannose binding lectin

Missense mutations in the collagen triple-helix that replace one of the required Gly residues in the (Gly-Xaa-Yaa)(n)() repeating sequence have been implicated in various disorders. Although most hereditary collagen disorders are rare, a common occurrence of a Gly replacement mutation is found in the collagenous domain of mannose binding lectin (MBL). A Gly --> Asp mutation at position 54 in MBL is found at a frequency as high as 30% in certain populations and leads to increased susceptibility to infections. The structural and energetic consequences of this mutation are investigated by comparing a triple-helical peptide containing the N-terminal Gly-X-Y units of MBL with the homologous peptide containing the Gly to Asp replacement. The mutation leads to a loss of triple-helix content but only a small decrease in the stability of the triple-helix (DeltaT(m) approximately 2 degrees C) and no change in the calorimetric enthalpy. NMR studies on specifically labeled residues indicate the portion of the peptide C-terminal to residue 54 is in a highly ordered triple-helix in both peptides, while residues N-terminal to the mutation site have a weak triple-helical signal in the parent peptide and are completely disordered in the mutant peptide. These results suggest that the N-terminal triplet residues are contributing little to the stability of this peptide, a hypothesis confirmed by the stability and enthalpy of shorter peptides containing only the region C-terminal to the mutation site. The Gly to Asp replacement at position 54 in MBL occurs at the boundary of a highly stable triple-helix region and a very unstable sequence. The junctional position of this mutation minimizes its destabilizing effect, in contrast with the significant destabilization seen for Gly replacements in peptides modeling collagen diseases.     

Free energy simulation to investigate the effect of amino acid sequence environment on the severity of osteogenesis imperfecta by glycine mutations in collagen

Molecular dynamics simulations were carried out to calculate the free energy change difference of two collagen-like peptide models for Gly --> Ser mutations causing two different osteogenesis imperfecta phenotypes. These simulations were performed to investigate the impact of local amino acid sequence environment adjacent to a mutation site on the stability of the collagen. The average free energy differences for a Gly --> Ser mutant relative to a wild type are 3.4 kcal/mol and 8.2 kcal/mol for a nonlethal site and a lethal site, respectively. The free energy change differences of mutant containing two Ser residues relative to the wild type at the nonlethal and lethal mutation sites are 4.6 and 9.8 kcal/mol, respectively. Although electrostatic interactions stabilize mutants containing one or two Ser residues at both mutation sites, van der Waals interactions are of sufficient magnitude to cause a net destabilization. The presence of Gln and Arg near the mutation site, which contain large and polar side chains, provide more destabilization than amino acids containing small and nonpolar side chains.     

Type I collagen triplet duplication mutation in lethal osteogenesis imperfecta shifts register of alpha chains throughout the helix and disrupts incorporation of mutant helices into fibrils and extracellular matrix

The majority of collagen mutations causing osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) are glycine substitutions that disrupt formation of the triple helix. A rare type of collagen mutation consists of a duplication or deletion of one or two Gly-X-Y triplets. These mutations shift the register of collagen chains with respect to each other in the helix but do not interrupt the triplet sequence, yet they have severe clinical consequences. We investigated the effect of shifting the register of the collagen helix by a single Gly-X-Y triplet on collagen assembly, stability, and incorporation into fibrils and matrix. These studies utilized a triplet duplication in COL1A1 exon 44 that occurred in the cDNA and gDNA of two siblings with lethal OI. The normal allele encodes three identical Gly-Ala-Hyp triplets at aa 868-876, whereas the mutant allele encodes four. The register shift delays helix formation, causing overmodification. Differential scanning calorimetry yielded a decrease in T(m) of 2 degrees C for helices with one mutant chain and a 6 degrees C decrease in helices with two mutant chains. An in vitro binary co-processing assay of N-proteinase cleavage demonstrated that procollagen with the triplet duplication has slower N-propeptide cleavage than in normal controls or procollagen with proalpha1(I) G832S, G898S, or G997S substitutions, showing that the register shift persists through the entire helix. The register shift disrupts incorporation of mutant collagen into fibrils and matrix. Proband fibrils formed inefficiently in vitro and contained only normal helices and helices with a single mutant chain. Helices with two mutant chains and a significant portion of helices with one mutant chain did not form fibrils. In matrix deposited by proband fibroblasts, mutant chains were abundant in the immaturely cross-linked fraction but constituted a minor fraction of maturely cross-linked chains. The profound effects of shifting the collagen triplet register on chain interactions in the helix and on fibril formation correlate with the severe clinical consequences.     

Classical Ehlers-Danlos syndrome caused by a mutation in type I collagen

Classical Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS) is characterized by skin hyperelasticity, joint hypermobility, increased tendency to bruise, and abnormal scarring. Mutations in type V collagen, a regulator of type I collagen fibrillogenesis, have been shown to underlie this type of EDS. However, to date, mutations have been found in only a limited number of patients, which suggests genetic heterogeneity. In this article, we report two unrelated patients with typical features of classical EDS, including excessive skin fragility, in whom we found an identical arginine-->cysteine substitution in type I collagen, localized at position 134 of the alpha1(I) collagen chain. The arginine residue is highly conserved and localized in the X position of the Gly-X-Y triplet. As a consequence, intermolecular disulfide bridges are formed, resulting in type I collagen aggregates, which are retained in the cells. Whereas substitutions of glycine residues in type I collagen invariably result in osteogenesis imperfecta, substitutions of nonglycine residues in type I collagen have not yet been associated with a human disease. In contrast, arginine-->cysteine substitutions in type II collagen have been identified in a variety of chondrodysplasias. Our findings show that mutations in other fibrillar collagens can be causally involved in classical EDS and point to genetic heterogeneity of this disorder.     

Incorporation of type I collagen molecules that contain a mutant alpha 2(I) chain (Gly580-->Asp) into bone matrix in a lethal case of osteogenesis imperfecta.

To understand more directly the tissue defect in osteogenesis imperfecta (OI), bone matrix was analyzed from an infant with lethal OI (type II) of defined mutation (collagen alpha 2(I)Gly580-->Asp). Pepsin-solubilized alpha 1(I) and alpha 2(I) chains and derived CNBr-peptides migrated more slowly on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis compared with normal human controls. The peptide alpha 2(I)CB3,5, predicted to contain the mutation site, ran as a retarded doublet band and was purified by high performance liquid chromatography and digested with V8 protease. Two peptides with amino-terminal sequences beginning at residue 576 of the alpha 2(I) chain were isolated. One had the normal sequence. The other differed in that aspartic acid replaced glycine at residue 580 as predicted from cDNA analysis, and in having an unhydroxylated proline at residue 579. From yields on microsequencing and the relative intensities of the two forms of alpha 2(I)CB3,5 on SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, the ratio of mutant to normal alpha 2(I) chains in the infant's bone matrix was 0.7/1. Although the effects of an efficient incorporation of mutant chains on the properties of the bone matrix are unknown, it may be that in this OI case the tissue abnormalities result more from the presence of mutant protein than from an underexpression of matrix.     

Characterization of point mutations in the collagen COL1A1 and COL1A2 genes causing lethal perinatal osteogenesis imperfecta

Type I collagen mutations in a group of patients with lethal perinatal osteogenesis imperfecta were identified in fibroblast RNA by a new method which can detect, by chemical modification and cleavage, single mismatched bases in heteroduplexes formed between mRNA and normal cDNA probes. Control cDNA probes spanning the area of the pro-alpha 1(I) and pro-alpha 2(I) chains likely to contain the mutations were radioactively labeled and used to form heteroduplexes with total patient RNA. Treatment of these heteroduplexes with hydroxylamine followed by cleavage of the cDNA strand at reactive bases by piperidine identified mismatches in the pro-alpha 1(I) cDNA in four patients. In the fifth patient a mismatch was detected in the pro-alpha 2(I) cDNA. To characterize these mutations the regions containing the mismatches were amplified by the polymerase chain reaction, cloned, and sequenced. All were heterozygous single base mutations which led to the substitution of glycine residues in the helical region of the pro-alpha-chains. The substitutions were pro-alpha 1(I) Gly973 and Gly1006 to Val, Gly928 to Ala, Gly976 to Arg, and pro-alpha 2(I) Gly865 to Ser. These mutations emphasize the importance of the Gly-X-Y repeating amino acid sequence for normal collagen helix formation and function in the extracellular matrix.     

NMR Conformational and Dynamic Consequences of a Gly to Ser Substitution in an Osteogenesis Imperfecta Collagen Model Peptide

Close packing of three chains in a standard collagen triple helix requires Gly as every third residue. Missense mutations replacing one Gly by a larger residue in the tripeptide repeating sequence in type I collagen are common molecular causes of osteogenesis imperfecta. The structural and dynamic consequences of such mutations are addressed here by NMR studies on a peptide with a Gly-to-Ser substitution within an α1(I) sequence. Distances derived from nuclear Overhauser effects indicate that the three Ser residues are still packed in the center of the triple helix and that the standard 1-residue stagger is maintained. NMR dynamics using H-exchange and temperature-dependent amide chemical shifts indicate a greater disruption of hydrogen bonding and/or increased conformational flexibility C-terminal to the Ser site when compared with N terminal. This is consistent with recent suggestions relating clinical severity with an asymmetric effect of residues N- versus C-terminal to a mutation site. Dynamic studies also indicate that the relative position between a Gly in one chain and the mutation site in a neighboring staggered chain influences the disruption of the standard hydrogen-bonding pattern. The structural and dynamic alterations reported here may play a role in the etiology of osteogenesis imperfecta by affecting collagen secretion or interactions with other matrix molecules.Mutations in collagen result in a variety of connective tissue diseases (1, 2), with the clinical phenotype depending on the location and function of the collagen type. For instance, mutations in type I collagen, the major collagen in bone, lead to a bone disorder, osteogenesis imperfecta (OI),³ whereas mutations in type III collagen, which is present in high amounts in blood vessels, lead to aortic rupture in Ehlers-Danlos syndrome type IV (1, 2). All collagens have a triple helix motif composed of three polyproline II-like chains that are staggered by 1 residue and supercoiled about a common axis. The smallest residue Gly is typically present as every 3rd residue in each chain because of the tight packing of the chains, which generates the characteristic (Gly-Xaa-Yaa)_n repeating sequence. The Gly residues are all buried in the center, and the structure is stabilized by interchain N–H (Gly) … CO (Xaa) hydrogen bonds (3–5). The most common type of mutation leading to collagen disorders is a missense mutation that replaces 1 Gly in the repeating sequence by a larger residue.The best characterized collagen disease is OI, or brittle bone disease, which is distinguished by fragile bones due to mutations in type I collagen (2, 6). More than 400 Gly substitution missense mutations in the α1(I) and α2(I) chains of type I collagen have been reported to lead to OI (7). The severity of the disease varies widely from mild cases with multiple fractures to perinatal lethal cases (2, 6, 7). A single base change in a Gly codon can lead to one of 8 residues (Ser, Ala, Cys, Val, Arg, Asp, Glu, Trp) or a missense mutation. The smallest residue Ala is underrepresented in OI, suggesting that it may not always lead to pathology, whereas Ser mutations are overrepresented, corresponding to the most common substitutions observed. The 152 mutations leading to a Gly to Ser substitution account for ∼39% of all missense mutations in the α1(I) of type I collagen (7), with 115 associated with mild phenotypes and 37 associated with lethal phenotypes.The identity of the residue replacing Gly may be a determinant in the clinical severity of OI. Model peptide studies indicate that the degree of triple helix destabilization depends on the residue replacing Gly, with a ranking of the least destabilizing to the most destabilizing Ala,Ser8). There is some correlation between clinical severity of OI cases and this destabilization scale, with the strongly destabilizing residues Val, Arg, Asp, and Glu associated largely with lethal phenotypes (8). However, as cited above, a Gly to Ser mutation can lead to a mild, a severe, or a lethal OI case, with no obvious molecular explanation. Other factors suggested to contribute to clinical phenotype include the rigidity of its immediate sequence environment; its location with respect to the C terminus; its proximity to salt bridges; and its presence at an interaction site, such as the binding site for proteoglycans on collagen fibrils (7, 9). A recent study of the stability of OI collagens supported the importance of the domain location of the mutation (10), whereas a network analysis of the mutations suggested the importance of a destabilizing tripeptide sequence C-terminal to the mutation site (11).The standard triple helix conformation must undergo some structural perturbation as a result of a Gly replacement that is likely to relate to the development of the disorder. Thus it is important to define the structural consequences of a Gly substitution. It has not proved possible to obtain molecular information for the long collagen molecules themselves, but model collagen peptides have proved amenable to x-ray crystallography and NMR techniques (12, 13). The structure of a peptide containing a Gly to Ala substitution near the center of the peptide (Pro-Hyp-Gly)₁₀ has been solved by x-ray crystallography (5). This structure shows an overall straight molecule with standard triple helical structures at both ends and a localized conformational deformation at the Ala replacement site. The direct N–H (Gly) … CO (Xaa) hydrogen bond is replaced by a water-mediated hydrogen bond N–H (Ala) … H₂O … CO (Xaa).Here, NMR spectroscopy is used to define the structural and dynamic effect of a Gly to Ser replacement through the application of recently developed NMR methodology on selectively ¹³C/¹⁵N doubly labeled collagen peptides (14). This strategy includes chain assignments, measurement of NOEs, and scalar J-couplings to define the conformation of the peptide. These results combined with NMR hydrogen exchange experiments and temperature-dependent chemical shift data demonstrate the disturbed dynamic features and hydrogen bonding around the Ser substitution site. The NMR data of the Gly to Ser peptide are compared with the NMR and x-ray high resolution structure of the peptide containing a Gly to Ala substitution (5).     

Severity of osteogenesis imperfecta and structure of a collagen-like peptide modeling a lethal mutation site

We show that there are correlations between the severities of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) phenotypes and changes in the residues near the mutation site. Our results show the correlations between the severity of various forms of the inherited disease OI and alteration of residues near the site of OI causing mutations. Among our many observed correlations are particularly striking ones between the presence of nearby proline residues and lethal mutations, and the presence of nearby alanines residues and nonlethal mutations. We investigated the possibility that these correlations have a structural basis using molecular dynamics simulations of collagen-like molecules designed to mimic the site of a lethal OI mutation in collagen type I. Our significant finding is that interchain hydrogen bonding is greatly affected by variations in residue type. We found that the strength of hydrogen bond networks between backbone atoms on different chains depends on the local residue sequence and is weaker in proline-rich regions of the molecule. We also found that an alanine at a site near an OI mutation causes less structural disruption than a proline, and that residue side chains also form interchain hydrogen bonds with frequencies that are dependent on residue type. For example, arginine side chains form strong hydrogen bonds with the backbone of the subsequent peptide chain, while lysine and glutamine less frequently form similar hydrogen bonds. This decrease in the observed hydrogen bond frequency correlates with a decrease in the experimentally determined thermal stability. We contrasted general structural properties of model collagen peptides with and without the mutation to examine the effect of the single-point mutation on the surrounding residues.     

Sequence dependence of renucleation after a Gly mutation in model collagen peptides

Missense mutations in the collagen triple helix that replace one Gly residue in the (Gly-X-Y)(n) repeating pattern by a larger amino acid have been shown to delay triple helix folding. One hypothesis is that such mutations interfere with the C- to N-terminal directional propagation and that the identity of the residues immediately N-terminal to the mutation site may determine the delay time and the degree of clinical severity. Model peptides are designed to clarify the role of tripeptide sequences N-terminal to the mutation site, with respect to length, stability, and nucleation propensity, to complete triple helix folding. Two sets of peptides with different N-terminal sequences, one with the natural sequence alpha1(I) 886-900, which is just adjacent to the Gly(901) mutation, and one with a GPO(GAO)(3) sequence, which occurs at alpha1(I) 865-879, are studied by CD and NMR. Placement of the five tripeptides of the natural alpha1(I) collagen sequence N-terminal to the Gly to Ala mutation site results in a peptide that is folded only C-terminal to the mutation site. In contrast, the presence of the Hyp-rich sequence GPO(GAO)(3) N-terminal to the mutation allows complete refolding in the presence of the mutation. The completely folded peptide contains an ordered central region with unusual hydrogen bonding while maintaining standard triple helix structure at the N- and C-terminal ends. These peptide results suggest that the location and sequences of downstream regions favorable for renucleation could be the key factor in the completion of a triple helix N-terminal to a mutation.     

Structural heterogeneity of type I collagen triple helix and its role in osteogenesis imperfecta

We investigated regions of different helical stability within human type I collagen and discussed their role in intermolecular interactions and osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). By differential scanning calorimetry and circular dichroism, we measured and mapped changes in the collagen melting temperature (DeltaTm) for 41 different Gly substitutions from 47 OI patients. In contrast to peptides, we found no correlations of DeltaTm with the identity of the substituting residue. Instead, we observed regular variations in DeltaTm with the substitution location in different triple helix regions. To relate the DeltaTm map to peptide-based stability predictions, we extracted the activation energy of local helix unfolding (DeltaG) from the reported peptide data. We constructed the DeltaG map and tested it by measuring the H-D exchange rate for glycine NH residues involved in interchain hydrogen bonds. Based on the DeltaTm and DeltaG maps, we delineated regional variations in the collagen triple helix stability. Two large, flexible regions deduced from the DeltaTm map aligned with the regions important for collagen fibril assembly and ligand binding. One of these regions also aligned with a lethal region for Gly substitutions in the alpha1(I) chain.     

Collagen defects in lethal perinatal osteogenesis imperfecta.

Quantitative and qualitative abnormalities of collagen were observed in tissues and fibroblast cultures from 17 consecutive cases of lethal perinatal osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). The content of type I collagen was reduced in OI dermis and bone and the content of type III collagen was also reduced in the dermis. Normal bone contained 99.3% type I and 0.7% type V collagen whereas OI bone contained a lower proportion of type I, a greater proportion of type V and a significant amount of type III collagen. The type III and V collagens appeared to be structurally normal. In contrast, abnormal type I collagen chains, which migrated slowly on electrophoresis, were observed in all babies with OI. Cultured fibroblasts from five babies produced a mixture of normal and abnormal type I collagens; the abnormal collagen was not secreted in two cases and was slowly secreted in the others. Fibroblasts from 12 babies produced only abnormal type I collagens and they were also secreted slowly. The slower electrophoretic migration of the abnormal chains was due to enzymic overmodification of the lysine residues. The distribution of the cyanogen bromide peptides containing the overmodified residues was used to localize the underlying structural abnormalities to three regions of the type I procollagen chains. These regions included the carboxy-propeptide of the pro alpha 1(I)-chain, the helical alpha 1(I) CB7 peptide and the helical alpha 1(I) CB8 and CB3 peptides. In one baby a basic charge mutation was observed in the alpha 1(I) CB7 peptide and in another baby a basic charge mutation was observed in the alpha 1(I) CB8 peptide. The primary defects in lethal perinatal OI appear to reside in the type I collagen chains. Type III and V collagens did not appear to compensate for the deficiency of type I collagen in the tissues.     

Clinical variability of osteogenesis imperfecta reflecting molecular heterogeneity: cysteine substitutions in the alpha 1(I) collagen chain producing lethal and mild forms

We have examined the collagenous proteins extracted from skin and produced by skin fibroblast cultures from the members of a family with mild dominant osteogenesis imperfecta (OI type I). The two affected patients, mother and son, produce two populations of alpha 1(I) chains of type I collagen, one chain being normal, the other containing a cysteine within the triple-helical domain. Both forms can be incorporated into triple-helical molecules with an alpha 2(I) chain. When two mutant alpha (I) chains are incorporated into the same molecule, a disulfide bonded dimer is produced. We have characterized these chains by sodium dodecyl sulfate-gel electrophoresis and CNBr-peptide mapping and by measuring a number of biosynthetic and physical variables. The cysteine was localized to the COOH-terminal peptide alpha (I) CB6. Molecules containing the mutant chains are stable, have a normal denaturation temperature, are secreted normally, and have normal levels of post-translational modification of lysyl residues and intracellular degradation. We have compared and contrasted these observations with those made in a patient with lethal osteogenesis imperfecta in which there was a cysteine substitution in alpha 1(I) CB6 (Steinmann, B., Rao, V. H., Vogel, A., Bruckner, P., Gitzelmann, R., and Byers, P. H. (1984) J. Biol. Chem 259, 11129-11138) and have concluded that the mutation in the present family occurs in the X or Y position of a Gly-X-Y repeating unit of collagen and not in the glycine position shown for the previous patient (Cohn, D. H., Byers, P. H., Steinmann, B, and Gelinas, R. E. (1986) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A., in press.     

Covalent structure of collagen: amino acid sequence of alpha 2-CB5 of chick skin collagen containing the animal collagenase cleavage site.

The amino acid sequence of the 112 residues from the amino terminus of alpha 2-CB5 from chick skin collagen was determined by automated sequential degradation of intact alpha 2-CB5 and several chymotryptic and tryptic peptides. This segment of the peptide includes the site of the action of animal collagenases. As compared to the sequence around the alpha 1 cleavage site, the alpha 2 sequence is notable for the remarkable constancy of the residues to the amino side and the relative abundance of hydrophobic residues to the carboxyl side of the cleavage site, suggesting that these features are important in the recognition by the enzyme. The sequence of this region of the alpha 2 chain is consistent with the Gly-X-Y triplet structure and the preference of certain residues for either the X or Y position in distribution. However, three of the six residues of leucine were found in the Y position rather than the X position. Leucine residues were found only once in the Y position in the alpha 1 (I) chain. This preference does not appear to hold in the alpha 2 chain.     

Two novelCOL1A1 mutations in patients with osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) affect the stability of the collagen type I triple-helix

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a bone dysplasia caused by mutations in theCOL1A1 andCOL1A2 genes. Although the condition has been intensely studied for over 25 years and recently over 800 novel mutations have been published, the relation between the location of mutations and clinical manifestation is poorly understood. Here we report missense mutations inCOL1A1 of several OI patients. Two novel mutations were found in the D1 period. One caused a substitution of glycine 200 by valine at the N-terminus of D1 in OI type I/IV, lowering collagen stability by 50% at 34°C. The other one was a substitution of valine 349 by phenylalanine at the C-terminus of D1 in OI type I, lowering collagen stability at 37.5°C. Two other mutations, reported before, changed amino residues in D4. One was a lethal substitution changing glycine 866 to serine in genetically identical twins with OI type II. That mutated amino acid was near the border of D3 and D4. The second mutation changed glycine 1040 to serine located at the border of D4 and D0.4, in a proband manifesting OI type III, and lowered collagen stability at 39°C (2°C lower than normal). Our results confirm the hypothesis on a critical role of the D1 and D4 regions in stabilization of the collagen triple-helix. The defect in D1 seemed to produce a milder clinical type of OI, whereas the defect in the C-terminal end of collagen type caused the more severe or lethal types of OI.     

Computed free energy differences between point mutations in a collagen-like peptide

We studied the results of mutating alanine --> glycine at three positions of a collagen-like peptide in an effort to develop a computational method for predicting the energetic and structural effects of a single point genetic mutation in collagen, which is associated with the clinical diagnosis of Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI). The differences in free energy of denaturation were calculated between the collagen-like peptides [(POG)(4)(POA)(POG)(4)](3) and [(POG)(10)](3) (POG: proline-hydroxyproline-glycine).* Our computational results, which suggest significant destabilization of the collagen-like triple-helix upon the glycine --> alanine mutations, correlate very well with the experimental free energies of denaturation. The robustness of our collagen-like peptide model is shown by its reproduction of experimental results with both different simulation paths and different lengths of the model peptide. The individual free energy for each alanine --> glycine mutation (and the reverse free energy, glycine --> alanine mutation) in the collagen-like peptide has been calculated. We find that the first alanine introduced into the triple helix causes a very large destabilization of the helix, but the last alanine introduced into the same position of an adjacent chain causes a very small change in the peptide stability. Thus, our results demonstrate that each mutation does not contribute equally to the free energy. We find that the sum of the calculated individual residues' free energy can accurately model the experimental free energy for the whole peptide.