Localization of vacuolar transport receptors and cargo proteins in the Golgi apparatus of developing Arabidopsis embryos

Using immunogold electron microscopy, we have investigated the relative distribution of two types of vacuolar sorting receptors (VSR) and two different types of lumenal cargo proteins, which are potential ligands for these receptors in the secretory pathway of developing Arabidopsis embryos. Interestingly, both cargo proteins are deposited in the protein storage vacuole, which is the only vacuole present during the bent-cotyledon stage of embryo development. Cruciferin and aleurain do not share the same pattern of distribution in the Golgi apparatus. Cruciferin is mainly detected in the cis and medial cisternae, especially at the rims where storage proteins aggregate into dense vesicles (DVs). Aleurain is found throughout the Golgi stack, particularly in the trans cisternae and trans Golgi network where clathrin-coated vesicles (CCVs) are formed. Nevertheless, aleurain was detected in both DV and CCV. VSR-At1, a VSR that recognizes N-terminal vacuolar sorting determinants (VSDs) of the NPIR type, localizes mainly to the trans Golgi and is hardly detectable in DV. Receptor homology-transmembrane-RING H2 domain (RMR), a VSR that recognizes C-terminal VSDs, has a distribution that is very similar to that of cruciferin and is found in DV. Our results do not support a role for VSR-At1 in storage protein sorting, instead RMR proteins because of their distribution similar to that of cruciferin in the Golgi apparatus and their presence in DV are more likely candidates. Aleurain, which has an NPIR motif and seems to be primarily sorted via VSR-At1 into CCV, also possesses putative hydrophobic sorting determinants at its C-terminus that could allow the additional incorporation of this protein into DV.     

Protein transport in plant cells: in and out of the Golgi

In plant cells, the Golgi apparatus is the key organelle for polysaccharide and glycolipid synthesis, protein glycosylation and protein sorting towards various cellular compartments. Protein import from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is a highly dynamic process, and new data suggest that transport, at least of soluble proteins, occurs via bulk flow. In this Botanical Briefing, we review the latest data on ER/Golgi inter-relations and the models for transport between the two organelles. Whether vesicles are involved in this transport event or if direct ER-Golgi connections exist are questions that are open to discussion. Whereas the majority of proteins pass through the Golgi on their way to other cell destinations, either by vesicular shuttles or through maturation of cisternae from the cis- to the trans-face, a number of membrane proteins reside in the different Golgi cisternae. Experimental evidence suggests that the length of the transmembrane domain is of crucial importance for the retention of proteins within the Golgi. In non-dividing cells, protein transport out of the Golgi is either directed towards the plasma membrane/cell wall (secretion) or to the vacuolar system. The latter comprises the lytic vacuole and protein storage vacuoles. In general, transport to either of these from the Golgi depends on different sorting signals and receptors and is mediated by clathrin-coated and dense vesicles, respectively. Being at the heart of the secretory pathway, the Golgi (transiently) accommodates regulatory proteins of secretion (e.g. SNAREs and small GTPases), of which many have been cloned in plants over the last decade. In this context, we present a list of regulatory proteins, along with structural and processing proteins, that have been located to the Golgi and the 'trans-Golgi network' by microscopy.     

Peripheral membrane proteins mediate binding of vacuolar storage proteins to membranes of the secretory pathway of developing pea cotyledons

In developing pea cotyledons, storage proteins are sorted viadense vesicles into the protein storage vacuole. Formation ofthese unique transport vesicles is characterized by aggregationof their cargo proteins. Protein sorting into dense vesiclesis pH dependent. In order to gain insight into the molecularbasis of storage protein sorting, a membrane binding assay wasdeveloped which allows for a detailed biochemical analysis ofbinding events. Employing this assay it was possible to showthat storage proteins bind in a pH-dependent manner to the membranesof the secretory pathway with a pH optimum in the range of thelumenal pH of the Golgi cisternae. Through reconstitution experiments,it was possible to demonstrate further that this recruitmentoccurs via the interaction of peripheral rather than intrinsicmembrane proteins. Results of co-immunoprecipitation experimentspoint to interactions between different storage proteins inthe secretory system. These results are discussed in terms ofthe aggregation-mediated sorting of storage proteins into maturingdense vesicles. Key words: Dense vesicles, Golgi apparatus, legumin, pea, receptor, sorting Received 22 January 2008; Revised 22 January 2008 Accepted 23 January 2008     

Transport of ricin and 2S albumin precursors to the storage vacuoles of Ricinus communis endosperm involves the Golgi and VSR-like receptors

We have studied the transport of proricin and pro2S albumin to the protein storage vacuoles of developing castor bean (Ricinus communis L.) endosperm. Immunoelectron microscopy and cell fractionation reveal that both proteins travel through the Golgi apparatus and co-localize throughout their route to the storage vacuole. En route to the PSV, the proteins co-localize in large (>200 nm) vesicles, which are likely to represent developing storage vacuoles. We further show that the sequence-specific vacuolar sorting signals of both proricin and pro2SA bind in vitro to proteins that have high sequence similarity to members of the VSR/AtELP/BP-80 vacuolar sorting receptor family, generally associated with clathrin-mediated traffic to the lytic vacuole. The implications of these findings in relation to the current model for protein sorting to storage vacuoles are discussed.     

Vacuole biogenesis and protein transport to the plant vacuole: A comparison with the yeast vacuole and the mammalian lysosome

Summary The vacuole is often termed the lytic compartment of the plant cell. The yeast cell also possesses a vacuole containing acid hydrolases. In animal cells these enzymes are localized in the lysosome. Recent research suggests that there is good reason to regard these organelles as homologous in terms of protein transport. Although sorting motifs for the recognition of vacuolar proteins within the endomembrane system differ between the three organelles, there is an underlying similarity in targeting determinants in the cytoplasmic tails of Golgi-based receptors. In all three cases these determinants appear to interact with adaptins of clathrin-coated vesicles which ferry their cargo first of all to an endosomal compartment. The situation in sorting and targeting of plant vacuolar proteins is complicated by the fact that storage and lytic vacuoles may exist together in the same cell. The origin of these two types of vacuole is also a matter of some uncertanity.Abbrevations AP assembly protein - ALP alkaline phosphatase - ARF adenosine diphosphate ribosylation factor - BiP immunoglobulin binding protein - CCV clathrin coated vesicle - CPY carboxypeptidase-Y - DPAP dipeptidyl aminopeptidase - ER endoplasmic reticulum - GApp Golgi apparatus - LAMPs lysosomal associated membrane protein(s) - LAP lysosomal acid phosphatase - LIMPs lysosomal integral membrane protein(s) - MPRs mannosyl 6-phosphate receptors - MVB multivesicular bodies - NSF N-ethylmaleimide sensitive fusion (protein) - PAT phosphinotricine acetyltransferase - PB protein body - PHA phytohemagglutinin - PM plasma membrane - PSV protein storage vacuole - SNAPs soluble NSF attachment protein(s) - SNAREs SNAP receptor(s) - TGN trans Golgi network - TIP tonoplast integral protein - VPS vacuolar protein sorting - ZIO zinc iodide/osmium     

The cargo in vacuolar storage protein transport vesicles is stratified

Developing pea seeds contain two functionally distinct vacuoles--lytic vacuoles and protein storage vacuoles (PSV). The Golgi apparatus of these cells has to discriminate between proteins destined for these vacuolar compartments. Whereas it is known that sorting into the lytic vacuole is performed via the conserved clathrin-coated vesicle pathway, sorting of proteins into the protein storage vacuole remains enigmatic. In developing pea cotyledons, the major storage proteins are sorted via 'dense vesicles'. In this report we examined the sorting of a minor protein of the protein storage vacuole, the sucrose-binding-protein homolog (SBP), along the secretory pathway employing immunoelectron microscopy on cryosectioned pea cotyledons. SBP follows the same vesicular route into the PSV as the main storage proteins legumin and vicilin, via the dense-vesicles. Furthermore, legumin and SBP are sorted together into the same dense vesicle population at the stack. Although soluble cargo proteins of the dense vesicles, they show a stratified distribution in the lumen of the dense vesicles. Whereas the legumin label is equally distributed across the lumen, the SBP label is concentrated at the membrane of the vesicle. This observation is discussed with respect to a putative receptor-mediated sorting of the proteins into the dense vesicles.     

Evidence for segregation of sphingomyelin and cholesterol during formation of COPI-coated vesicles

In higher eukaryotes, phospholipid and cholesterol synthesis occurs mainly in the endoplasmic reticulum, whereas sphingomyelin and higher glycosphingolipids are synthesized in the Golgi apparatus. Lipids like cholesterol and sphingomyelin are gradually enriched along the secretory pathway, with their highest concentration at the plasma membrane. How a cell succeeds in maintaining organelle-specific lipid compositions, despite a steady flow of incoming and outgoing transport carriers along the secretory pathway, is not yet clear. Transport and sorting along the secretory pathway of both proteins and most lipids are thought to be mediated by vesicular transport, with coat protein I (COPI) vesicles operating in the early secretory pathway. Although the protein constituents of these transport intermediates are characterized in great detail, much less is known about their lipid content. Using nano-electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry for quantitative lipid analysis of COPI-coated vesicles and their parental Golgi membranes, we find only low amounts of sphingomyelin and cholesterol in COPI-coated vesicles compared with their donor Golgi membranes, providing evidence for a significant segregation from COPI vesicles of these lipids. In addition, our data indicate a sorting of individual sphingomyelin molecular species. The possible molecular mechanisms underlying this segregation, as well as implications on COPI function, are discussed.     

Deposition of storage proteins

Plants store amino acids for longer periods in the form of specific storage proteins. These are deposited in seeds, in root and shoot tubers, in the wood and bark parenchyma of trees and in other vegetative organs. Storage proteins are protected against uncontrolled premature degradation by several mechanisms. The major one is to deposit the storage proteins into specialized membrane-bounded storage organelles, called protein bodies (PB). In the endosperm cells of maize and rice prolamins are sequestered into PBs which are derived from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Globulins, the typical storage proteins of dicotyledonous plants, and prolamins of some cereals are transported from the ER through the Golgi apparatus and then into protein storage vacuoles (PSV) which later become transformed into PBs. Sorting and targeting of storage proteins begins during their biosynthesis on membrane-bound polysomes where an N-terminal signal peptide mediates their segregation into the lumen of the ER. After cleavage of the signal peptide, the polypeptides are glycosylated and folded with the aid of chaperones. While still in the ER, disulfide bridges are formed which stabilize the structure and several polypeptides are joined to form an oligomer which has the proper conformation to be either deposited in ER-derived PB or to be further transferred to the PSV. At the trans-Golgi cisternae transport vesicles are sequestered which carry the storage proteins to the PSV. Several storage proteins are also processed after arriving in the PSVs in order to generate a conformation that is capable of final deposition. Some storage protein precursors have short N- or C-terminal targeting sequences which are detached after arrival in the PSV. Others have been shown to have internal sequence regions which could act as targeting information. In some cases positive targeting information is known to mediate sorting into the PSV whereas in other cases aggregation and membrane association seem to be major sorting mechanisms.     

The Florey Lecture, 1992. The secretion of proteins by cells.

In eukaryotic cells, protein secretion provides a complex organizational problem. Secretory proteins are first transported, in an unfolded state, across the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), and are then carried in small vesicles to the Golgi apparatus and finally to the cell membrane. The ER contains soluble proteins which catalyse the folding of newly synthesized polypeptides. These proteins are sorted from secretory proteins in the Golgi complex: they carry a sorting signal (the tetrapeptide KDEL or a related sequence) that allows them to be selectively retrieved and returned to the ER. This retrieval process also appears to be used by some bacterial toxins to aid their invasion of the cell: these toxins contain KDEL-like sequences and may, in effect, follow the secretory pathway in reverse. The membrane-bound receptor responsible for sorting luminal ER proteins has been identified in yeast by genetic means, and related receptors are found in mammalian cells. Unexpectedly, this receptor has a second role: in yeast it is required to maintain the normal size and function of the Golgi apparatus. By helping to maintain the composition of both ER and Golgi compartments, the KDEL receptor has an important role in the organization of the secretory pathway.     

Traffic Routes and Signals for the Tonoplast

Tonoplast, the membrane delimiting plant vacuoles, regulates ion, water and nutrient movement between the cytosol and the vacuolar lumen through the activity of its membrane proteins. Correct traffic of proteins from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to the tonoplast requires (i) approval by the ER quality control, (ii) motifs for exit from the ER and (iii) motifs that promote sorting to the tonoplast. Recent evidence suggests that this traffic follows different pathways that are protein‐specific and could also reflect vacuole specialization for lytic or storage function. The routes can be distinguished based on their sensitivity to drugs such as brefeldin A and C834 as well as using mutant plants that are defective in adaptor proteins of vesicle coats, or dominant‐negative mutants of Rab GTPases.     

Recycling of proteins between the endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi complex.

Several lines of investigation have shown that protein transport from the endoplasmic reticulum to the Golgi is more complex than previously imagined. Dynamic sorting of both membrane and soluble proteins is now believed to occur on the cis side of the Golgi apparatus with some proteins returning to the endoplasmic reticulum while others travel onwards.     

Low density lipoprotein receptor and cation-independent mannose 6- phosphate receptor are transported from the cell surface to the Golgi apparatus at equal rates in PC12 cells

Efficient transport of cell surface glycoproteins to the Golgi apparatus has been previously demonstrated for a limited number of proteins, and has been proposed to require selective sorting in the endocytic pathway after internalization. We have studied the endocytic fate of several glycoproteins that accumulate in different organelles in a variant clone of PC12, a regulated secretory cell line. The cation-independent mannose 6-phosphate receptor and the low density lipoprotein receptor, both rapidly internalized from the cell surface, and the synaptic vesicle membrane protein synaptophysin, were transported to the Golgi apparatus with equivalent, nonlinear kinetics. Transport to the Golgi apparatus (t1/2 = 2.5-3.0 h) was several times faster than turnover of these proteins (t1/2 greater than or equal to 20 h), indicating that transport of these proteins to the Golgi apparatus occurred on average several times for each protein. In contrast, Thy-1, a protein anchored in the membrane by a glycosylphosphoinositide group, was internalized and transported to the Golgi apparatus more slowly than the three transmembrane proteins. Since each of the transmembrane proteins studied showed the same t1/2 for transport to the Golgi apparatus, we conclude that transport of these proteins from the cell surface to the Golgi apparatus does not require sorting information specific to any one of these proteins. These results suggest that one of the functions of late endosomes is constitutive recycling of cell surface receptors through the Golgi apparatus if they fail to recycle to the cell surface directly from early endosomes, and that the late endosome recycling pathway is followed frequently by many rapidly internalized proteins.     

Vacuolar storage proteins are sorted in the cis-cisternae of the pea cotyledon Golgi apparatus

Developing pea cotyledons contain functionally different vacuoles, a protein storage vacuole and a lytic vacuole. Lumenal as well as membrane proteins of the protein storage vacuole exit the Golgi apparatus in dense vesicles rather than in clathrin-coated vesicles (CCVs). Although the sorting receptor for vacuolar hydrolases BP-80 is present in CCVs, it is not detectable in dense vesicles. To localize these different vacuolar sorting events in the Golgi, we have compared the distribution of vacuolar storage proteins and of alpha-TIP, a membrane protein of the protein storage vacuole, with the distribution of the vacuolar sorting receptor BP-80 across the Golgi stack. Analysis of immunogold labeling from cryosections and from high pressure frozen samples has revealed a steep gradient in the distribution of the storage proteins within the Golgi stack. Intense labeling for storage proteins was registered for the cis-cisternae, contrasting with very low labeling for these antigens in the trans-cisternae. The distribution of BP-80 was the reverse, showing a peak in the trans-Golgi network with very low labeling of the cis-cisternae. These results indicate a spatial separation of different vacuolar sorting events in the Golgi apparatus of developing pea cotyledons.     

The vacuolar transport of aleurain-GFP and 2S albumin-GFP fusions is mediated by the same pre-vacuolar compartments in tobacco BY-2 and Arabidopsis suspension cultured cells

Soluble proteins reach vacuoles because they contain vacuolar sorting determinants (VSDs) that are recognized by vacuolar sorting receptor (VSR) proteins. Pre-vacuolar compartments (PVCs), defined by VSRs and GFP-VSR reporters in tobacco BY-2 cells, are membrane-bound intermediate organelles that mediate protein traffic from the Golgi apparatus to the vacuole in plant cells. Multiple pathways have been demonstrated to be responsible for vacuolar transport of lytic enzymes and storage proteins to the lytic vacuole (LV) and the protein storage vacuole (PSV), respectively. However, the nature of PVCs for LV and PSV pathways remains unclear. Here, we used two fluorescent reporters, aleurain-GFP and 2S albumin-GFP, that represent traffic of lytic enzymes and storage proteins to LV and PSV, respectively, to study the PVC-mediated transport pathways via transient expression in suspension cultured cells. We demonstrated that the vacuolar transport of aleurain-GFP and 2S albumin-GFP was mediated by the same PVC populations in both tobacco BY-2 and Arabidopsis suspension cultured cells. These PVCs were defined by the seven GFP-AtVSR reporters. In wortmannin-treated cells, the vacuolated PVCs contained the mRFP-AtVSR reporter in their limiting membranes, whereas the soluble aleurain-GFP or 2S albumin-GFP remained in the lumen of the PVCs, indicating a possible in vivo relationship between receptor and cargo within PVCs.     

The riddle of the plant vacuolar sorting receptors

Proteins synthesized on membrane-bound ribosomes are sorted at the Golgi apparatus level for delivery to various cellular destinations: the plasma membrane or the extracellular space, and the lytic vacuole or lysosome. Sorting involves the assembly of vesicles, which preferentially package soluble proteins with a common destination. The selection of proteins for a particular vesicle type involves the recognition of proteins by specific receptors, such as the vacuolar sorting receptors for vacuolar targeting. Most eukaryotic organisms have one or two receptors to target proteins to the lytic vacuole. Surprisingly, plants have several members of the same family, seven in Arabidopsis thaliana. Why do plants have so many proteins to sort soluble proteins to their respective destinations? The presence of at least two types of vacuoles, lytic and storage, seems to be a partial answer. In this review we analyze the last experimental evidence supporting the presence of different subfamilies of plant vacuolar sorting receptors.     

Protein Transport in Plant Cells

The subcellular localization and secretion of proteins synthesized in the cytosol are determined by short amino acid sequences in their molecules. N-terminal transit peptides provide for protein translocation across the membranes of the ER, mitochondria, plastids, and microbodies. Later, these peptides are cleaved off by processing peptidases. C-terminal peptides direct some proteins into microbodies and vacuoles. Transport into the nucleus and insertion in the membranes are determined by the specific sequences that reside in the molecule of the mature protein. Specific receptors associated with the protein-translocating channel recognize transit peptides. Protein unfolding is required for successful protein transport through these channels. Chaperones maintain proteins in such a state. Folded proteins cross the nuclear pore complex and the membrane of microbodies. Protein transport is tightly associated with their processing. During the vesicular protein transport within the endomembrane system (ER, Golgi apparatus, plasma membrane, and vacuoles), correct protein targeting is ensured by protein sorting during vesicle loading, the assembly of corresponding protein coats, vesicle transport to the acceptor membrane, and specific membrane fusion.     

Cis-elements of protein transport to the plant vacuoles

Vacuolar proteins are synthesized and translocated into the endoplasmic reticulum and transported to the vacuoles through the secretory pathway. Three different types of vacuolar sorting signals have been identified, carried by N- or C-terminal propeptides or internal sequences. These signals are needed to target proteins to the different types of vacuoles that can coexist in a single plant cell. A conserved motif (NPIXL or NPIR) was identified within N-terminal propeptides, but can also function in a C-terminal propeptide and targets proteins in a receptor-mediated manner to a lytic vacuole. Binding to a family of putative sorting receptors for sequence-specific vacuolar sorting signals has been used as an assay to identify further peptides with other binding motifs. No motif was found in C-terminal sorting sequences, which need an accessible terminus, suggesting that they are recognized from the end by a still unknown receptor. The phosphatidylinositol kinase inhibitor wortmannin differentially affects sorting mediated by these two sorting sequences, suggesting different sorting mechanisms. Less is known about sorting mediated by internal protein sequences, which do not contain the conserved motif identified in N-terminal propeptides and by function by aggregation, leading to transport by coat-less dense vesicles to protein storage vacuoles. Even less is known about the sorting of tonoplast proteins, for which several sorting systems will also be needed.     

Insulin‐Regulated Trafficking of GLUT4 Requires Ubiquitination

A major consequence of insulin binding its receptor on fat and muscle cells is translocation of the facilitative glucose transporter GLUT4 from an intracellular store to the cell surface where it serves to clear glucose from the bloodstream. Sorting of GLUT4 into its insulin‐sensitive store requires the GGA [Golgi‐localized, γ‐ear‐containing, ADP ribosylation factor (ARF)‐binding] adaptor proteins, but the signal on GLUT4 to direct this sorting step is unknown. Here, we have identified a role for ubiquitination of GLUT4 in this process. We demonstrate that GLUT4 is ubiquitinated in 3T3‐L1 adipocytes, and that a ubiquitin‐resistant version fails to translocate to the cell surface of these cells in response to insulin. Our data support a model in which ubiquitination acts as a signal for the trafficking of GLUT4 from the endosomal/trans‐Golgi network (TGN) system into its intracellular storage compartment, from where it is mobilized to the cell surface in response to insulin.     

An investigation of the role of transmembrane domains in Golgi protein retention.

The single transmembrane domains (TMDs) of the resident glycosylation enzymes of the Golgi apparatus are involved in preventing these proteins moving beyond the Golgi. It has been proposed that either the TMDs associate, resulting in the formation of large oligomers of Golgi enzymes, or that they mediate the lateral segregation of the enzymes between lipid microdomains. Evidence for either type of interaction has been sought by examining the retention of sialyltransferase (ST), an enzyme of the mammalian trans Golgi. No evidence could be obtained for specific interactions or 'kin recognition' between ST and other proteins of the trans Golgi. Moreover, it is shown that the previously described kin recognition between enzymes of the medial Golgi involves the lumenal portions of these proteins rather than their TMDs. To investigate further the role of the ST TMD, the effects on Golgi retention of various alterations in the TMD were examined. The addition or removal of residues showed that the efficiency of retention of ST is related to TMD length. Moreover, when a type I plasma membrane protein was expressed with a synthetic TMD of 23 leucines it appeared on the cell surface, but when the TMD was shortened to 17 leucines accumulation in the Golgi was observed. These observations are more consistent with lipid-based sorting of ST TMD, but they also allow for reconciliation with the kin recognition model which appears to act on sequences outside of the TMD.     

The Golgi complex: a hub of the secretory pathway

The Golgi complex plays a central role in protein secretion by regulating cargo sorting and trafficking. As these processes are of functional importance to cell polarity, motility, growth, and division, there is considerable interest in achieving a comprehensive understanding of Golgi complex biology. However, the unique stack structure of this organelle has been a major hurdle to our understanding of how proteins are secreted through the Golgi apparatus. Herein, we summarize available relevant research to gain an understanding of protein secretion via the Golgi complex. This includes the molecular mechanisms of intra-Golgi trafficking and cargo export in the trans-Golgi network. Moreover, we review recent insights on signaling pathways regulated by the Golgi complex and their physiological significance.