The DNA binding domain of estrogen receptor alpha is required for high-affinity nuclear interaction induced by estradiol

Estrogen receptor alpha (ER) is a member of the nuclear hormone receptor family, which upon binding estrogen shows increased apparent affinity for nuclear components (tight nuclear binding). The nuclear components that mediate this tight nuclear binding have been proposed to include both ER-DNA interactions and ER-protein interactions. In this paper, we demonstrate that tight nuclear binding of ER upon estrogen occupation requires ER-DNA interactions. Hormone-bound ER can be extracted from the nucleus in low-salt buffer using various polyanions, which mimic the phosphate backbone of DNA. The importance of specific ER-DNA interactions in mediating tight nuclear binding is also supported by the 380-fold lower concentration of the ERE oligonucleotide necessary to extract estrogen-occupied ER from the nucleus compared to the polyanions. We also demonstrate that estrogen-induced tight nuclear binding requires both the nuclear localization domain and the DNA binding domain of ER. Finally, enzymatic degradation of nuclear DNA allows us to recover 45% of tight nuclear-bound ER. We further demonstrate that ER-AIB1 interaction is not required for estrogen-induced tight nuclear binding. Taken together, we propose a model in which tight nuclear binding of the estrogen-occupied ER is predominantly mediated by ER-DNA interactions. The effects of estrogen binding on altering DNA binding in whole cells are proposed to occur through estrogen-induced changes in ER-chaperone protein interactions, which alter the DNA accessibility of ER but do not directly change the affinity of the ER for DNA, which is similar for both unoccupied and occupied ER.     

Interaction of the calf uterine estrogen receptor with acceptor sites in heterologous chicken target cell nuclei

Estrogen receptor (ER) from chicken liver and calf uterus were used to study the capacity and the characteristics of the receptor binding sites (acceptor sites) in chicken target cell nuclei. Binding studies were performed at a physiological salt concentration of 0.15 M KCl. Binding of liver ER to liver nuclei was temperature-dependent, showing a 9-fold increase between 0 and 28 degrees C. The maximal number of acceptor sites measured in this cell-free system (280 sites/nucleus) was considerably lower than measured in nuclei after in vivo administration of estrogen (820 sites/nucleus). Moreover incubation of nuclei with the liver ER preparation resulted in a substantial breakdown of nuclear DNA, making this ER less suitable for DNA binding studies. The temperature-activated calf uterine receptor bound to liver nuclei at 0 degrees C, at which temperature no DNA degradation was measured. To all chicken cell nuclei tested, the receptor bound with a high affinity (Kd = 0.4-1.0 nM). Nuclear binding displayed tissue specificity: oviduct greater than heart, liver greater than spleen greater than erythrocytes and was salt dependent. Calf uterine ER binding in liver nuclei ranged from 3000-6000 acceptor sites per nucleus when assayed under conditions of a constant protein or a constant DNA concentration. Nuclei isolated from estrogen-treated cockerels bound a 2-fold lower number of calf uterine ER complexes when compared to control nuclei. Incubation of nuclei with a fixed concentration of [3H]ER from liver and increasing concentrations of uterine non-radioactive-ER also resulted in a reduced binding of the liver receptor. Both types of experiments suggest that liver and uterine ER compete for a common nuclear acceptor site. Our data demonstrate that the ER from calf uterus is very useful as a probe to examine the nature of the acceptor sites in heterologous chicken target cell nuclei. The assay system functions at 0 degrees C, a temperature at which no DNA degradation occurs.     

Modulation of the estrogen receptor's affinity for DNA by estradiol

The binding constant for estrogen receptor-DNA interaction when measured in the presence and absence of estradiol revealed a distinct difference dependent upon whether the receptor was hormone-bound or hormone-free. The binding constant of estrogen receptor-DNA interaction was determined by analysis of the exponential elution profile of the estrogen receptor from DNA-Sepharose columns using Tris buffer at a constant salt concentration. The binding constant of the hormone-bound estrogen receptor for DNA in Tris buffer, pH 7.4, containing 0.2 M KCl was 10.1 +/- 0.8 X 10(6) M-1, 5-fold higher than the value for the hormone-free estrogen receptor. Analysis of the number of ionic bonds between the estrogen receptor and DNA indicates that the hormone-free receptor establishes eight salt bridges, while the hormone-bound estrogen receptor establishes 10-13. The affinity of the hormone-bound estrogen receptor for DNA in Tris buffer at pH 7.4 in 0.2 M KCl is 10-fold greater than at pH 8.0, suggesting that ionic bonding between the receptor and DNA may involve histidine residues of the receptor. The concentration-dependence of the hormone-bound receptor's affinity for DNA emphasizes the receptor's associative state as an influence on the receptor's DNA binding characteristics. Our results demonstrate that estradiol modifies the conformation of the estrogen receptor to a state having an increased affinity for DNA.     

A two-step antibody strategy for surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy detection of protein-DNA interactions in nuclear extracts

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) spectroscopy has emerged as a powerful alternative to conventional biochemistry methods for studying protein-DNA interactions that involve recombinant proteins of known identity. There are, however, limited demonstrations of SPR detection of protein-DNA bindings in crude samples, e.g., cell extracts, where the challenge is to detect and identify specific DNA binding protein(s) among other protein components in a physiological setting. We have developed a two-step antibody approach for an SPR study of estrogen receptor α (ERα)-DNA interactions, in which nuclear extracts prepared from MCF-7 breast cancer cells were used as the source of ERα protein. Following the binding of nuclear extracts to surface-immobilized estrogen response elements, rabbit anti-ERα antibody followed by a secondary antibody (goat anti-rabbit IgG) were applied to recognize the bound ERα and amplify the signals, respectively. Through a series of experiments, we have demonstrated that the magnitude of the binding signals from the secondary antibody reflects the affinity by which ERα binds to different DNA sequences. The detection sensitivity is determined by the amount of nuclear extracts and the concentration of primary antibody used. The sequence specificity of the nuclear ERα measured using the two-step antibody approach is in agreement with that measured for recombinant ERα protein (using receptor binding signals).     

Thermodynamic origins of specificity in the lac repressor-operator interaction. Adaptability in the recognition of mutant operator sites

A system has been developed for facile generation and characterization of mutant lac operator sites, free of competing pseudo operator sequences. The interaction of lac repressor with these sites has been investigated by the nitrocellulose filter binding assay. The equilibrium binding affinity for each of three single-site changes was reduced by more than three orders of magnitude relative to the wild-type operator under standard assay conditions. The free-energy changes associated with single base-pair substitutions are not additive. We propose that adaptations in the recognition surface of the repressor involving significant trade-offs between electrostatic versus non-electrostatic interactions and between enthalpic versus entropic contributions to the binding free energy occur, in order to achieve the most stable complex with a given DNA sequence.     

Ligands differentially modulate the protein interactions of the human estrogen receptors alpha and beta

The interactions of human estrogen receptor subtypes ERalpha and ERbeta with DNA and a 210 amino acid residue fragment of the coactivator protein SRC-1 bearing three nuclear receptor interaction motifs were investigated quantitatively using fluorescence anisotropy in the presence of agonist and antagonist ligands. ERalpha and ERbeta were found to bind in a similar manner to DNA, and both salt and temperature affected the affinity and/or stoichiometry of these interactions. The agonist ligands estradiol, estrone and estriol did not modify the binding of ERalpha to the fluorescein-labeled target estrogen response element. However, in the case of ERbeta, these ligands led to the formation of some higher-order protein-DNA complexes and a small decrease in affinity. The partial agonist 4-hydroxytamoxifen had little effect on either ER subtype, whereas the pure antagonist ICI 182,780 led to the cooperative formation of protein-DNA complexes of higher order than dimer, as further demonstrated by competition experiments and gel mobility-shift assays. In addition to DNA binding, the interaction of both ER subtypes with the Alexa488-labeled SRC-1 coactivator fragment was investigated by fluorescence anisotropy. The agonist ligands estrone, estradiol, estriol, genistein and ethynyl estradiol exhibited distinct capacities for inducing the recruitment of SRC-1 that were not correlated with their affinity for the receptor. Moreover, estrone and genistein exhibited subtype specificity in that they induced SRC-1 recruitment to ERbeta with much higher efficiency than in the case of ERalpha. The differential coactivator recruitment capacities of the ER agonists and their receptor subtype coactivator recruitment specificity may be linked to the molecular structure of the agonists with respect to their interactions with a specific histidine residue located at the back of the ligand-binding pocket. Altogether, these quantitative in vitro studies of ER interactions reveal the complex energetic and stoichiometric consequences of changes in the chemical structures of these proteins and their ligands.     

Evaluation of two- and three-dimensional streptavidin binding platforms for surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy studies of DNA hybridization and protein-DNA binding

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) spectroscopy has been used to study DNA assembly, DNA hybridization, and protein-DNA interactions on two streptavidin (SA) sensor chips. On one chip, SA molecules are immobilized on a biotin-exposed surface, forming an ordered two-dimensional (2D) SA monolayer. The other chip, BIAcore's SA chip, contains SA molecules immobilized within a three-dimensional (3D) carboxylated dextran matrix. Compared to the 2D chip, the 3D SA matrix allows for a slower immobilization rate of biotinylated DNA due to diffusion limitation in the dextran matrix, but with twice the amount of the immobilized DNA due to the greater number of reactive sites, which in turn enables a higher sensitivity for DNA hybridization detection. Interestingly, having a greater DNA probe dispersion in the 3D matrix does not induce a higher DNA hybridization efficiency. In a study of protein binding to immobilized DNA (estrogen receptor to estrogen response elements), aiming at assessing the DNA sequence dependent protein binding behavior, the 2D and 3D chips produce different binding characteristics. On the 2D chip, the protein binding exhibits a better selectivity to the specific sequences, regardless of binding stringency (e.g. salt concentration), whereas on the 3D chip, the liquid handling system needs to be optimized in order to minimize transport limitations and to detect small affinity differences. Through this study we demonstrate that the physicochemical structure of SPR chips affects the apparent binding behaviors of biomolecules. When interpreting SPR binding curves and selecting a sensor chip, these effects should be taken into account.     

Estrogen receptor binding to a DNA response element in vitro is not dependent upon estradiol

Gel shift assays were employed to distinguish between the contribution of 17 beta-estradiol (E2) and a short heating step to the ability of the rat uterine cytosolic estrogen receptor (ER) to bind to the estrogen response element (ERE) from the vitellogenin A2 gene (vitERE). Despite the popularity of models in which the ER is a ligand-activated DNA-binding protein, these studies find that estrogen does not significantly contribute to receptor-DNA complex formation. An avidin-biotin complex with DNA (ABCD) assay was utilized to obtain quantitative measurement of the affinities of the ER for the vitERE and a mutant sequence. Scatchard analysis gave a dissociation constant of 390 +/- 40 pM for the E2-occupied, heated ER to the vitERE. The data fit a one-site model and evidence for cooperatively was not observed. A dissociation constant of 450 +/- 170 pM was obtained for the unoccupied, heated ER, leading to the conclusion that estrogen was not necessary for specific binding to DNA. The percentage of ER capable of binding vitERE varied with each cytosol preparation, ranging from 60 to 100% and estrogen did not appear to affect this variation. Competition against the vitERE with a 2-bp mutant sequence showed a 250-fold lower relative binding affinity of the receptor for the mutant over the vitERE sequence. This ability of the ER to discriminate between target and nonspecific DNA sequences was also not dependent on the presence of estrogen.     

Quantitative characterization of the interaction between purified human estrogen receptor alpha and DNA using fluorescence anisotropy

In an effort to better define the molecular mechanisms of the functional specificity of human estrogen receptor α, we have carried out equilibrium binding assays to study the interaction of the receptor with a palindromic estrogen response element derived from the vitellogenin ERE. These assays are based on the observation of the fluorescence anisotropy of a fluorescein moiety covalently bound to the target oligonucleotide. The low anisotropy value due to the fast tumbling of the free oligonucleotide in solution increases substantially upon binding the receptor to the labeled ERE. The quality of our data are sufficient to ascertain that the binding is clearly cooperative in nature, ruling out a simple monomer interaction and implicating a dimerization energetically coupled to DNA binding in the nanomolar range. The salt concentration dependence of the affinity reveals formation of high stoichiometry, low specificity complexes at low salt concentration. Increasing the KCl concentration above 200 mM leads to specific binding of ER dimer. We interpret the lack of temperature dependence of the apparent affinity as indicative of an entropy driven interaction. Finally, binding assays using fluorescent target EREs bearing mutations of each of the base pairs in the palindromic ERE half-site indicate that the energy of interaction between ER and its target is relatively evenly distributed throughout the site.     

DNA binding analysis of glucocorticoid receptor specificity mutants.

The glucocorticoid receptor (GR) DNA binding domain consists of several conserved amino acids and folds into two zinc finger-like structures. Previous transactivation experiments indicated that three amino acids residing in this region, Gly, Ser and Val, appear to be critical for target-site discrimination. Based on the solved crystal structure, these residues are at the beginning of an amphipathic alpha-helix that interacts with the DNA's major groove; of these, only valine, however, contacts DNA. In order to examine their functional role directly, we have substituted these residues for the corresponding amino acids from the estrogen receptor (ER), overexpressed and purified the mutant proteins, and assayed their binding specificity and affinity by gel mobility shifts using glucocorticoid or estrogen response elements (GRE or ERE, respectively) as DNA probes. We find that all three residues are indeed required to fully switch GR's specificity to an ERE. The contacting valine in GR is of primary importance. The corresponding residue in ER, alanine, is less important for specificity, while glutamic acid, four amino acids towards the N-terminus, is most critical for ER discrimination. Finally, we show that the GR DNA binding domain carrying all three ER-specific mutations has a significantly higher affinity for an ERE than the ER DNA binding domain itself. We interpret these results in the context of both the data presented here and the crystal structure of the GR DNA binding domain complexed to a GRE.     

Lactose repressor hinge domain independently binds DNA

The short 8–10 amino acid “hinge” sequence in lactose repressor (LacI), present in other LacI/GalR family members, links DNA and inducer‐binding domains. Structural studies of full‐length or truncated LacI‐operator DNA complexes demonstrate insertion of the dimeric helical “hinge” structure at the center of the operator sequence. This association bends the DNA ～40° and aligns flanking semi‐symmetric DNA sites for optimal contact by the N‐terminal helix‐turn‐helix (HtH) sequences within each dimer. In contrast, the hinge region remains unfolded when bound to nonspecific DNA sequences. To determine ability of the hinge helix alone to mediate DNA binding, we examined (i) binding of LacI variants with deletion of residues 1–50 to remove the HtH DNA binding domain or residues 1–58 to remove both HtH and hinge domains and (ii) binding of a synthetic peptide corresponding to the hinge sequence with a Val52Cys substitution that allows reversible dimer formation via a disulfide linkage. Binding affinity for DNA is orders of magnitude lower in the absence of the helix‐turn‐helix domain with its highly positive charge. LacI missing residues 1–50 binds to DNA with ～4‐fold greater affinity for operator than for nonspecific sequences with minimal impact of inducer presence; in contrast, LacI missing residues 1–58 exhibits no detectable affinity for DNA. In oxidized form, the dimeric hinge peptide alone binds to O1 and nonspecific DNA with similarly small difference in affinity; reduction to monomer diminished binding to both O1 and nonspecific targets. These results comport with recent reports regarding LacI hinge interaction with DNA sequences.     

Thermodynamic,kinetic, and structural basis for recognition and repair of 8-oxoguanine in DNA by Fpg protein from Escherichia coli

X-ray analysis does not provide quantitative estimates of the relative importance of the molecular contacts it reveals or of the relative contributions of specific and nonspecific interactions to the total affinity of specific DNA to enzymes. Stepwise increase of DNA ligand complexity has been used to estimate the relative contributions of virtually every nucleotide unit of 8-oxoguanine-containing DNA to its total affinity for Escherichia coli 8-oxoguanine DNA glycosylase (Fpg protein). Fpg protein can interact with up to 13 nucleotide units or base pairs of single- and double-stranded ribo- and deoxyribo-oligonucleotides of different lengths and sequences through weak additive contacts with their internucleotide phosphate groups. Bindings of both single-stranded and double-stranded oligonucleotides follow similar algorithms, with additive contributions to the free energy of binding of the structural components (phosphate, sugar, and base). Thermodynamic models are provided for both specific and nonspecific DNA sequences with Fpg protein. Fpg protein interacts nonspecifically with virtually all of the base-pair units within its DNA-binding cleft: this provides approximately 7 orders of magnitude of affinity (Delta G degrees approximately equal to -9.8 kcal/mol) for DNA. In contrast, the relative contribution of the 8-oxoguanine unit of the substrate (Delta G degrees approximately equal to -0.90 kcal/mol) together with other specific interactions is <2 orders of magnitude (Delta G degrees approximately equal to -2.8 kcal/mol). Michaelis complex formation of Fpg protein with DNA containing 8-oxoguanine cannot of itself provide the major part of the enzyme specificity, which lies in the k(cat) term; the rate is increased by 6-8 orders of magnitude on going from nonspecific to specific oligodeoxynucleotides.     

Characterization of estrogen and antiestrogen binding to the cytosol and microsomes of breast tumors

The binding of [3H]estradiol and [3H]hydroxytamoxifen to the cytosol and microsomal fractions of several human breast tumors was investigated. By washing microsomal membranes with a KCl-free or a KCl-containing medium we could distinguish between intrinsic, extrinsic and contaminant estradiol binding sites in these membranes. We observed that treatment of the microsomes with low salt medium removes about 80% of the total estradiol binding sites, whereas 20% are not extractable. The concentration of unextractable [3H]estradiol binding sites in the microsomes varies in proportion to the level of cytosolic estrogen receptors (ER). About 10% of the total extranuclear specific estrogen binding sites was consistently found tightly associated to the microsomal fraction, which displays an affinity for estradiol (Kd = 0.1-0.6 nM) similar to that of the cytosolic ER. The displacement of [3H]estradiol with unlabeled hormone or with the antiestrogens, nafoxidine, enclomiphene and tamoxifen (TAM) exhibits identical IC50 values either in the cytosol or in the microsomal membranes. On the other hand, the microsomal fraction of breast tumors also binds [3H]hydroxyTAM, but with higher capacity and lower affinity than those of the cytosolic fraction. Furthermore, we did not observe correlation between the concentrations of ER and of antiestrogen binding sites (AEBS) in the tumors. These results indicate that microsomal membranes of human breast tumors contain estrogen binding sites which may be related to the cytosol ER recycling and that specific AEBS are predominantly localized in this membrane system. Furthermore, it is shown that the magnitude of estradiol binding to microsomes depends on the ER positive degree of the tumors, whereas the magnitude of the antiestrogen binding to the microsomes is independent of the ER status of the tumors.     

Uterine estrogen receptor-DNA complexes: effects of different ERE sequences, ligands, and receptor forms

Previous studies used the gel retardation assay to examine the binding of the mouse estrogen receptor (ER) to the estrogen-responsive element (ERE) from the vitellogenin A2 gene (VitA2ERE). Multiple specific complexes were formed when the ER was bound to various estrogen agonists or antagonists, or in the absence of bound hormone. The ERE from the human PS2 gene, which varies from the consensus ERE by one base change in the right arm, was used in this study to determine the effect of DNA sequence on ER-ERE interaction with various ligand-receptor complexes. Partially purified ligand-free soluble ER showed a 3-fold lower affinity for the PS2ERE than for the VitA2ERE, suggesting a possible influence of the imperfect DNA sequence on certain binding interactions. However, multiple complexes of similar affinity were formed with the PS2 sequence by nuclear ER regardless of the agonist or antagonist bound. In gel retardation experiments, antagonist (LY117018) nuclear ER complexes bound to either PS2 or VitA2ERE migrated more slowly than agonist complexes, indicating that the slower migrating form of the complex was not due to the DNA sequence. Interestingly, soluble ER bound by LY 117018 did not produce this decreased mobility complex, suggesting that it was specific to the nuclear form of the ER antagonist complex. Receptor activation has been linked with exposure to increased temperature, resulting in an ER form that has an increased affinity for DNA. The binding of molybdate-stabilized nonactivated 8S ER to VitA2ERE was studied to determine the effect of temperature on ER binding.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)