A study of the long-term effect of malar fat repositioning in face lift surgery: short-term success but long-term failure

In 1990, the author reported on a series of 403 cases of deep plane face lifts, the first published technique describing the repositioning of the cheek fat, known as malar fat, in face lift surgery. This study examines the long-term results of 20 of the original series in an attempt to determine what areas of the rejuvenated face (specifically, the malar fat) showed long-term improvement. The results were judged by comparing the preoperative and long-term postoperative views in a half-and-half same-side hemiface photograph. The anatomy of the jawline (superficial musculoaponeurotic system [SMAS]), the nasolabial fold (malar fat), and the periorbital diameter were evaluated. The results confirmed that repositioning of the SMAS remained for longer than improvement in the nasolabial fold and that the vertical diameter of the periorbit did not change at all. The early results of malar fat repositioning shown at 1 to 2 years were successful, but the long-term results showed failure of the early improvement, manifested by recurrence of the nasolabial folds. There was, however, continuation of the improved results of the forehead lift and SMAS maneuvers of the original procedure. The conclusion is that only a direct excision will produce a permanent correction of the aging nasolabial fold.     

The high-superficial musculoaponeurotic system technique in facial rejuvenation: an update

The medical charts of 267 patients who had primary high-superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) rhytidectomies were reviewed. The depth of the nasolabial fold was used as an indicator of the degree of descent of the subcutaneous cheek mass, as a guide in procedure selection, and as a method of judging the operative results. Fold depth was assigned a score of 0 to 3, with 3 being most severe. According to their preoperative fold depth, patients were operated on using one of three variants of the high-SMAS technique: sub-SMAS dissection up to the nasolabial fold, sub-SMAS dissection up to the nasolabial fold plus transnasal SMAS graft, or sub-SMAS dissection across the nasolabial fold. An independent trained observer rated the postoperative fold depth in each case from photographs taken at the 6-month follow-up visit. Of patients with fold scores of 2 or 3, 97 percent (183 of 189 patients) showed visible improvement in nasolabial crease depth after the operation.     

Restoration of the upper lip and nasolabial area by means of an intraoral approach

Superomedial repositioning of the superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) in the upper lip is accomplished by means of intraoral incisions. The procedure reestablishes the convexity of the lateral vermilion border, elevates the upper lip, and restores a more youthful appearance to the upper-lip profile. Depth of the nasolabial folds are reduced. We have performed this procedure on 14 patients. Follow-up intervals range from 6 to 20 months, averaging 14 months. All patients received concomitant rhytidectomy; usual operative time was increased by 20 minutes. Results have been rated good to excellent by patients and surgeons. There have been no recurrences of nasolabial fold deepening or upper lip depression, and there have been no complications. In selected patients, this procedure, along with rhytidectomy, may provide a more youthful appearance.     

Anatomic variations of the nasolabial fold.

The nasolabial fold varies considerably from person to person. Three main groups may be distinguished: convex, concave, and straight. It is the muscles of smiling that are directly responsible for the shape and depth of the fold, and in their absence of function, as in facial palsy, the nasolabial fold disappears. Cadavers were selected in accordance with the nasolabial fold they presented and were dissected to analyze the difference in underlying anatomy between one fold shape in one cadaver and another fold shape in another. The study demonstrates that the nasolabial fold is the result of a conflict between soft and dynamic tissues of the middle face or an interaction between the skin and fat envelope on one side and the underlying muscles on the other. The greater this conflict, the more excess there is of cheek skin and the more pronounced a nasolabial fold. The mechanism that creates the nasolabial fold and the anatomy of the fold are described in this paper.     

Composite upper lip repair with V-Y advancement flaps

In two patients, large but superficial partial-thickness resections of lateral upper lip have been repaired by composite island cutaneous flaps. Upper lip and nasolabial fold flaps, along with lateral vermilion, were advanced and closed in a V-Y manner leaving inconspicuous scars and no contour deformity.     

Correction of the nasolabial fold: extended SMAS dissection with periosteal fixation.

The nasolabial fold has defied satisfactory correction with the face lift operation. This is despite variations of the SMAS technique over the last 20 years. In this study, the nasolabial fold is shown to be part of the overall aging deformity that affects the cheek and perioral region. The key to surgical correction, not previously appreciated, is the complete release of the anterior SMAS from the zygoma and zygomaticus major muscle. This allows a dramatic mobilization of the nasolabial fold without tension. The advanced SMAS is then reattached to the zygomatic periosteum by a series of permanent sutures. Each suture, by its location and direction of lift, corrects one of the four nasolabial regions including the jowl. The relevant anatomy is reviewed and the safety of the procedure is assessed in a personal series of 135 patients. It is concluded that the two principles of this technique, i.e., complete SMAS release and reattachment to the zygoma, safely and effectively achieve a natural-appearing rejuvenation of the cheek and nasolabial fold.     

Meloplication of the malar fat pads by percutaneous cable-suture technique for midface rejuvenation: outcome study (392 cases, 6 years' experience)

The aging anterior midface is restored by reversing the contour undulations produced by sagging of the malar fat pad complex toward the nasolabial line. The convex irregularities include the exposed bulges of the post-septal fat, the unveiled malar bag, and the prominent nasolabial fold. The depressed irregularities are represented by the cresent-shaped hollow at the lid-cheek junction, the accentuated nasojugal groove, and the deepening nasolabial line. Repositioning of the ptotic malar fat pad, among other elements of meloplasty, represents a key procedure. In this study, the malar fat pad has been defined as a fan-shaped structure by external anatomic landmarks that correlate closely to the findings in cadaveric dissections and clinical cases, confirmed by the findings of spiral computed tomographic scanning. A simple but powerful adjustable and long-lasting percutaneous suture elevation technique was developed over the past 6 years by the senior author (G.H.S.) to reposition the fat pad in a superolateral direction. Through a dot incision within the nasolabial line, a permanent CV-3 Gore-Tex (or 4-0 clear Prolene) suspension suture, looped through a Gore-Tex anchor graft, suspends the malar fat pad in a direction perpendicular to the nasolabial line. A second suspension system is identically passed through another lower dot incision to broaden the repositioning vectors on the malar fat pad. Tension on each of the paired suture ends elevates the malar fat pad by 1 to 3 mm as measured from the nasolabial dot incisions. The sutures are fixed to the deep temporal fascia through a Gore-Tex tab, effectively stabilizing the soft-tissue repositioning. This maneuver may be performed in younger patients who present with an isolated malar fat pad ptosis without excess facial skin. The procedure may also be incorporated into open rhytidectomies to address this recalcitrant area along with superficial musculoaponeurotic system tightening. A total of 392 patients since 1995 underwent suture elevation of the malar fat pads. An outcome study indicated that the usage of two permanent sutures with Gore-Tex anchor grafts since 1998 resulted in improvement in midface rejuvenation of over 82 percent. Early and late complication rates were small and temporary. Patient acceptance was excellent, indicative of the benefits of anatomic repositioning of the malar fat pad complex.     

A challenge to the undefeated nasolabial folds

Previous attempts to improve the nasolabial folds have been disappointing. By extending the face lift skin dissection to the nasolabial fold and up onto the malar prominence, reducing the fat of this fold by excision, and applying direct posterior retraction to the freed facial skin, rather dramatic improvement in the nasolabial folds have been achieved. This is a preliminary report with a follow-up of 8 months or less.     

SMAS graft of the nasolabial area during deep plane rhytidectomy

The extensive list of treatments for the nasolabial area illustrates that the problem is not solved yet. Although a better understanding of the anatomy and physiology of the nasolabial area has been developed, the ideal treatment has not been found. It seems that a combined approach based on summation of partially effective modalities is the best option. The authors present their experience with combined deep plane rhytidectomy, malar fat lift, and superficial musculoaponeurotic system graft in the treatment of the aging nasolabial area. Results in 70 consecutive patients are presented with this simple, nonscarring, inexpensive technique.     

The midface sling: a new technique to rejuvenate the midface

In the early 1990s, the midface became the focus of facial rejuvenation, and various techniques effected elevation by plicating, or on, the midface. Recent analyses of facial aging demonstrate that selective ptosis of the midfacial tissues lateral to the nasolabial fold results in an infraorbital hollow and deepening of the nasolabial fold. Therefore, the authors propose that the midface, from the lower portion of the cheek mass, will result in superior midface positioning. Since 1996, the authors have elevated the midface in select patients by placing a sling of prosthetic (Gore-Tex) or autogenous (tendon or fascia) material through the cheek mass. The sling is secured medially to the infraorbital rim using a nonabsorbable periosteal suture or a mechanical anchor. As variable tension is applied laterally toward the superficial temporal fascia, the sling functions as a fulcrum to return the cheek mass to a more youthful anatomical position. Elevating the cheek mass in this fashion fills the infraorbital hollow and results in amelioration of deep nasolabial folds and jowling. With a mean follow-up of 18 months, 50 patients treated with the midface sling report satisfaction with the procedure. There have been no instances of nerve damage, infection, or hematoma in the midface. None of the slings have required removal and ectropion has not occurred. Because of postoperative asymmetry in one patient, additional elevation of the ipsilateral cheek mass was performed by increasing the tension on the lateral cheek portion of the midface sling. Mathematical models demonstrate the biomechanical superiority of lift through the use of multiple vectors as compared with linear pull techniques. In this fashion, the midface sling supports the cheek mass, providing rapid, simple, and secure elevation. Because of the limited subcutaneous dissection, there is a reduced risk of facial nerve damage and cutaneous vascular compromise. Unlike with other techniques, the lateral portion of the sling may be easily identified through a small incision in the temporal scalp, facilitating subsequent postoperative adjustment of the midface suspension. Furthermore, because the entire cheek mass is permanently supported with an inelastic sling, the results may last longer than those with techniques that rely on sutures to plicate or lift portions of the superficial musculoaponeurotic system.     

Rhytidectomy and the nasolabial fold.

I describe a technical modification in the Skoog face lift procedure that releases the deep attachments of the SMAS to the muscles of facial expression for maximal mobility of the medial cheek yet elevates the cheek flap as a composite of skin, subcutaneous tissue, and SMAS to enhance skin perfusion. My results with the procedure in 100 patients are analyzed by using functional zones of the nasolabial fold corresponding to underlying musculature and a simple grading system based on preoperative and postoperative photographs. Marked improvement in the nasolabial fold was noted in over 80 percent of patients by 6 and 12 months postoperatively. This effect seemed to last up to 4 years.     

Curette fat sculpture in rhytidectomy: improving the nasolabial and labiomandibular folds

The nasolabial and labiomandibular folds develop with facial aging by an anterior caudal descent of the fat prominences of the same name. Young patients with minimal folding can be corrected by substances inserted in the fold; however, this and other techniques have failed satisfactorily to improve the folds naturally and permanently. Identification of the prominences and removal of the fat superficial to the skin by curettes have proven safe and effective and superior to fat suction. Complications include small hematomas and visible depressions in the sculpted areas. There was no nerve or skin injury. Follow-up of this technique (an improvement of a previous technique) is 3 1/2 years.     

Restoring facial shape in face lifting: the role of skeletal support in facial analysis and midface soft-tissue repositioning

Aesthetic analysis in facial rejuvenation has traditionally been subordinate to technical solutions. While concerns regarding correction of facial laxity, a reduction in the depth of the nasolabial fold, and improvement of both the jowl and the jawline are worthy goals in rhytidectomy, the aesthetic concept of restoring facial shape to a more youthful appearance is equally important. Restoring facial shape in face lifting requires an understanding of how the face ages and then the formulation of a treatment plan that is individualized for the patient. Re-establishment of facial contour is significantly influenced by the re-elevation of descended facial fat through superficial musculoaponeurotic system manipulation; it can be approached through a variety of technical solutions. Underlying skeletal support affects not only the appearance of the face in youth but also how the face ages and influences the operative plan in terms of the requirements for fat repositioning. Formulating a treatment plan that is patient specific and based on the artistic goals as influenced by skeletal support is the key element for consistency in restoring facial shape in face lifting.     

The SMAS and the nasolabial fold.

In a series of histologic sections and clinical and cadaver dissections, the superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) is seen to become the investing fascia of the zygomaticus major and minor muscles in the medial cheek. The pull on the cheek flap during rhytidectomy is diffused by the attachment of the SMAS to these muscles. I believe that this attachment accounts for the minimal change in the nasolabial crease after a Skoog-type sub-SMAS face lift.     

Subperiosteal approach as an improved concept for correction of the aging face

A harmonious facial appearance is determined by a balanced relationship among all tissues of the face. With advancing age, balance is lost among the bone, muscle, fat, and skin as progressive changes occur in their volume, shape, position, and consistency. Study of clinical cases and fresh cadaver dissections has led to better understanding of the superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) and its relationship with the facial muscles and their bony insertions. From these anatomic studies we have developed an improved concept of rhytidectomy with the subperiosteal detachment of all soft tissues from the orbit, upper maxilla, malar bone, and nose. Following this detachment, the soft tissues of the cheek, forehead, jowls, nasolabial folds, lateral canthus, and eyebrows can be lifted to reestablish their youthful relationship with the underlying skeleton. Our 4-year experience includes 105 patients. Sixty percent of these patients were admitted to the hospital and had their procedure under general anesthesia; forty percent, however, had their procedure in an outpatient setting requiring only local anesthesia (lidocaine hydrochloride 1% plus epinephrine) and intravenous sedation (midazolam, ketamine). Complications have been minimal except for temporary paralysis of the frontal nerve in seven patients; guidelines for prevention have subsequently been developed. The subperiosteal rhytidectomy is excellent and appears more natural for rejuvenation of the upper and central face, eyebrows, periorbita, external canthus, cheeks, and nasolabial fold.     

Rejuvenation of the midface by elevating the malar fat pad: review of technique,cases, and complications

The midface is an area where definite and consistent improvement is still hard to achieve. Vertical suspension of the malar fat pad is an effective midface lift that complements facial rejuvenation to obtain an overall appearance of youth and beauty while maintaining the personal features of the patient. To substantiate its effectiveness, the authors evaluated the complications and long-term results of the malar fat pad elevation proper and in conjunction with other facial procedures. A retrospective review of the medical records of 458 consecutive patients who underwent malar fat pad elevation by the senior author (B.C.D.) from January of 1994 to January of 2000 was conducted. Because 14 patients had their malar fat pad re-elevated, the number of midface lifts totaled 472. Of these, 437 had a combined superficial musculoaponeurotic system excision and tightening, 19 had a combined limited superficial musculoaponeurotic system plication/imbrication, and 16 had elevation of the malar fat pad only. Elevating the malar fat pad appears to be a sound, straightforward, and effective means of rendering a youthful midface. It consistently reshapes the malar eminence, softens the nasolabial fold, and rejuvenates the lower eyelid. This technique provides lasting results, with an acceptable complication rate. Facial nerve injury, in particular, was infrequent and temporary. In addition, the prehairline scar happened to be quite inconspicuous, especially in patients older than 55 years. This experience confirms that malar fat pad elevation is a safe and effective method to rejuvenate the central third of the face.     

Multiplane face lift with the subperiosteal dissection for orientals

A subperiosteal face lift rejuvenates the midface and periorbital region by restoring facial muscle tone. Since 1993, the authors have performed this procedure on Oriental patients who have their own distinct facial contours: the brachycephalic cranium and a prominent zygoma and mandibular angle. Although it was thought that these protuberances might disturb the subperiosteal procedure, especially in the anterior midface, the procedure could be performed easily by adopting the ancillary upper buccovestibular and subciliary incisions; the authors found that the protuberances actually act as fulcrums to keep up the lifting vectors reliably. For older patients, the procedure was combined with a deep subcutaneous dissection. A simple lift of the periosteum would not improve a severe nasolabial fold deformity and prominent wrinkles adequately because of "lag-lifting" of the superficial layer. It was concluded that the multiplane face lift, consisting of the subperiosteal and the deep subcutaneous approaches, achieves a natural-appearing rejuvenation of the Oriental aging face.     

Two-step cycle sequencing reduces premature terminations when using primers with high annealing temperatures

Direct cycle sequencing of double-stranded polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products using thermostable polymerase produces fragments that are shorter than expected when the enzyme prematurely detaches as it approaches the 5′-end of the DNA template. These premature terminations result in a substantially reduced reading length of the DNA sequence. Since some DNA templates spontaneously fold and form stable secondary structures at temperatures that are typically used for primer annealing, one factor that may cause premature terminations to occur is the formation of secondary structures in the template during the annealing step of the cycle sequencing reaction. We describe a simple and effective method for reducing premature terminations in DNA sequences. We demonstrate that maintaining the annealing temperature of the cycle sequencing reaction above a critical temperature reduces premature terminations in DNA sequences that regularly contain premature terminations when the temperature of the annealing step is 60°C. In the method described, annealing and extension of the primer along the template take place at the same temperature (72°C). This procedure for reducing premature terminations can be applied when sequencing with primers that are relatively long (at least 27 mer) and have high optimal annealing temperatures.     

Periosteal suspension of the lower eyelid and cheek following subciliary exposure of facial fractures

Following craniofacial procedures that involve stripping of the periosteum and soft tissue over the zygomatic maxillary complex, descent of soft tissue with a decrease in anterior projection over the malar area and increase in fullness in the nasolabial fold have been seen to be a problem by these authors. Simple repositioning of the soft tissues to their normal anatomic position may be used to alleviate this problem.     

The superficial musculoaponeurotic system in the upper lip: an anatomic study in cadavers

Ten cadavers were employed to demonstrate the presence of the SMAS in the upper lip using macroscopic and microscopic techniques. The relationships and attachments of the SMAS to the dermis of the upper lip are described. In cadavers, medial traction on the SMAS in the upper lip in conjunction with superolateral traction on the SMAS in the cheek is found to decrease the depth of the nasolabial fold. Superior traction on the SMAS in the upper lip elevates the interlabial line, reestablishes the convexity of the lateral vermilion border, and partially increases concavity of the profile.