Atomic resolution structures of bacteriorhodopsin photocycle intermediates: the role of discrete water molecules in the function of this light-driven ion pump

High-resolution X-ray crystallographic studies of bacteriorhodopsin have tremendously advanced our understanding of this light-driven ion pump during the last 2 years, and emphasized the crucial role of discrete internal water molecules in the pump cycle. In the extracellular region an extensive three-dimensional hydrogen-bonded network of protein residues and seven water molecules leads from the buried retinal Schiff base via water 402 and the initial proton acceptor Asp85 to the membrane surface. Near Lys216 where the retinal binds, transmembrane helix G contains a pi-bulge that causes a non-proline kink. The bulge is stabilized by hydrogen bonding of the main chain carbonyl groups of Ala215 and Lys216 with two buried water molecules located in the otherwise very hydrophobic region between the Schiff base and the proton donor Asp96 in the cytoplasmic region. The M intermediate trapped in the D96N mutant corresponds to a late M state in the transport cycle, after protonation of Asp85 and release of a proton to the extracellular membrane surface, but before reprotonation of the deprotonated retinal Schiff base. The M intermediate from the E204Q mutant corresponds to an earlier M, as in this mutant the Schiff base deprotonates without proton release. The structures of these two M states reveal progressive displacements of the retinal, main chain and side chains induced by photoisomerization of the retinal to 13-cis,15-anti, and an extensive rearrangement of the three-dimensional network of hydrogen-bonded residues and bound water that accounts for the changed pK(a)s of the Schiff base, Asp85, the proton release group and Asp96. The structure for the M state from E204Q suggests, moreover, that relaxation of the steric conflicts of the distorted 13-cis,15-anti retinal plays a critical role in the reprotonation of the Schiff base by Asp96. Two additional waters now connect Asp96 to the carbonyl of residue 216, in what appears to be the beginning of a hydrogen-bonded chain that would later extend to the retinal Schiff base. Based on the ground state and M intermediate structures, models of the molecular events in the early part of the photocycle are presented, including a novel model which proposes that bacteriorhodopsin pumps hydroxide (OH(-)) ions from the extracellular to the cytoplasmic side.     

Mechanism of proton transport in bacteriorhodopsin from crystallographic structures of the K,L, M1, M2, and M2' intermediates of the photocycle

We produced the L intermediate of the photocycle in a bacteriorhodopsin crystal in photo-stationary state at 170 K with red laser illumination at 60% occupancy, and determined its structure to 1.62 A resolution. With this model, high-resolution structural information is available for the initial bacteriorhodopsin, as well as the first five states in the transport cycle. These states involve photo-isomerization of the retinal and its initial configurational changes, deprotonation of the retinal Schiff base and the coupled release of a proton to the extracellular membrane surface, and the switch event that allows reprotonation of the Schiff base from the cytoplasmic side. The six structural models describe the transformations of the retinal and its interaction with water 402, Asp85, and Asp212 in atomic detail, as well as the displacements of functional residues farther from the Schiff base. The changes provide rationales for how relaxation of the distorted retinal causes movements of water and protein atoms that result in vectorial proton transfers to and from the Schiff base.     

Understanding structure and function in the light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin

The atomic structure of bacteriorhodopsin and the outlines of its proton transport mechanism are now available. Photoisomerization of the retinal in the chromophore creates a steric and electrostatic conflict at the retinal binding site. The free energy gain sets off a sequence of reactions in which directed proton transfers take place between the protonated retinal Schiff base, Asp-85, and Asp-96. These internal steps, and other proton transfers at and near the two aqueous interfaces, add up to the translocation of a proton from the cytoplasmic to the extracellular side of the membrane. Bound water plays a crucial role in proton conduction in both extracellular and cytoplasmic regions, but the means by which the protons move from site to site differ. Proton release to the extracellular surface is through interaction of a hydrogen-bonded chain of identified aspartic acid, arginine, water, and glutamic acid residues with Asp-85, while proton uptake from the cytoplasmic surface utilizes a single aspartic acid, Asp-96, whose protonation state appears to be regulated by the protein conformation dependent hydration of this region. The directionality of the translocation is ensured by the accessibility of the Schiff base to the extracellular and cytoplasmic directions after the retinal is photoisomerized, as well as the changing proton affinities of the acceptor Asp-85 and donor Asp-96.     

细菌视紫红质的质子传输机理

细菌视紫红质（bR）是嗜盐菌紫膜中的唯一蛋白质成分, 具有质子泵、电荷分离和光致变色功能. bR分子中的发色团视黄醛通过质子化席夫碱以共价键与Lys216相连. bR分子受可见光照射后, 视黄醛发生从全-反到13-顺式构型的异构化, 导致席夫碱的去质子化,继之以可极化基团位置的改变. 力场的变化引起包括蛋白质三级结构在内的诸多变化, 这些变化促进并保证了质子从细胞质侧向细胞外侧的定向传输.     

Suppression of the back proton-transfer from Asp85 to the retinal Schiff base in bacteriorhodopsin: a theoretical analysis of structural elements

The transfer of a proton from the retinal Schiff base to the nearby Asp85 protein group is an essential step in the directional proton-pumping by bacteriorhodopsin. To avoid the wasteful back reprotonation of the Schiff base from Asp85, the protein must ensure that, following Schiff base deprotonation, the energy barrier for back proton-transfer from Asp85 to the Schiff base is larger than that for proton-transfer from the Schiff base to Asp85. Here, three structural elements that may contribute to suppressing the back proton-transfer from Asp85 to the Schiff base are investigated: (i) retinal twisting; (ii) hydrogen-bonding distances in the active site; and (iii) the number and location of internal water molecules. The impact of the pattern of bond twisting on the retinal deprotonation energy is dissected by performing an extensive set of quantum-mechanical calculations. Structural rearrangements in the active site, such as changes of the Thr89:Asp85 distance and relocation of water molecules hydrogen-bonding to the Asp85 acceptor group, may participate in the mechanism which ensures that following the transfer of the Schiff base proton to Asp85 the protein proceeds with the subsequent photocycle steps, and not with back proton transfer from Asp85 to the Schiff base.     

Structure of bacteriorhodopsin at 1.55 A resolution.

Th?e atomic structure of the light-driven ion pump bacteriorhodopsin and the surrounding lipid matrix was determined by X-ray diffraction of crystals grown in cubic lipid phase. In the extracellular region, an extensive three-dimensional hydrogen-bonded network of protein residues and seven water molecules leads from the buried retinal Schiff base and the proton acceptor Asp85 to the membrane surface. Near Lys216 where the retinal binds, transmembrane helix G contains a pi-bulge that causes a non-proline? kink. The bulge is stabilized by hydrogen-bonding of the main-chain carbonyl groups of Ala215 and Lys216 with two buried water molecules located between the Schiff base and the proton donor Asp96 in the cytoplasmic region. The results indicate extensive involvement of bound water molecules in both the structure and the function of this seven-helical membrane protein. A bilayer of 18 tightly bound lipid chains forms an annulus around the protein in the crystal. Contacts between the trimers in the membrane plane are mediated almost exclusively by lipids.     

Specific damage induced by X-ray radiation and structural changes in the primary photoreaction of bacteriorhodopsin

Bacteriorhodopsin, the sole membrane protein of the purple membrane of Halobacterium salinarum, functions as a light-driven proton pump. A 3-D crystal of bacteriorhodopsin, which was prepared by the membrane fusion method, was used to investigate structural changes in the primary photoreaction. It was observed that when a frozen crystal was exposed to a low flux of X-ray radiation (5 x 10(14)photons mm(-2)), nearly half of the protein was converted into an orange species, exhibiting absorption peaks at 450 nm, 478 nm and 510 nm. The remainder retained the normal photochemical activity until Asp85 in the active site was decarboxlyated by a higher flux of X-ray radiation (10(16)photons mm(-2)). The procedure of diffraction measurement was improved so as to minimize the effects of the radiation damage and determine the true structural change associated with the primary photoreaction. Our structural model of the K intermediate indicates that the Schiff base linkage and the adjacent bonds in the polyene chain of retinal are largely twisted so that the Schiff base nitrogen atom still interacts with a water molecule located near Asp85. With respect to the other part of the protein, no appreciable displacement is induced in the primary photoreaction.     

Photochemical properties of a bacteriorhodopsin analog with 13-demethyl-13-trifluoromethyl retinal

It was shown that the substitution of the CF₃ group in the structure of retinal for the methyl group at C13 causes not only a decrease in the affinity of the proton for the nitrogen in the Schiff base (pK ～ 8.4) but also considerably changes the photochemical properties of the bacteriorhodopsin analog. At pH > 6.5, the rate of the Schiff base reprotonation during M decay depends on the proton concentration in the medium. In the photocycle of the yellow M-like form with the deprotonated Schiff base, a long-wavelength product absorbing at 625 nm is formed, which has a similar pH dependence of decay kinetics. The two processes also have similar activation energies (about 15 ± 1 kcal/mol). It is concluded that both cases involve proton transfer from an aqueous medium through the donor part of the channel to the Schiff base and Asp96, respectively. In the analog, however, the structure of water molecules necessary for the stabilization of the proton on the Schiff base is broken. As a result, dehydration of the preparation gives rise to a fraction of M-like form of bacteriorhodopsin with the deprotonated Schiff base.     

Crystallographic Study of the LUMI Intermediate of Squid Rhodopsin

Upon absorption of light, the retinal chromophore in rhodopsin isomerizes from the 11-cis to the trans configuration, initiating a photoreaction cycle. The primary photoreaction state, bathorhodopsin (BATHO), relaxes thermally through lumirhodopsin (LUMI) into a photoactive state, metarhodopsin (META), which stimulates the conjugated G-protein. Previous crystallographic studies of squid and bovine rhodopsins have shown that the structural change in the primary photoreaction of squid rhodopsin is considerably different from that observed in bovine rhodopsin. It would be expected that there is a fundamental difference in the subsequent thermal relaxation process between vertebrate and invertebrate rhodopsins. In this work, we performed crystallographic analyses of the LUMI state of squid rhodopsin using the P62 crystal. When the crystal was illuminated at 100 K with blue light, a half fraction of the protein was converted into BATHO. This reaction state relaxed into LUMI when the illuminated crystal was warmed in the dark to 170 K. It was found that, whereas trans retinal is largely twisted in BATHO, it takes on a more planar configuration in LUMI. This relaxation of retinal is accompanied by reorientation of the Schiff base NH bond, the hydrogen-bonding partner of which is switched to Asn185 in LUMI. Unlike bovine rhodopsin, the BATHO-to-LUMI transition in squid rhodopsin was accompanied by no significant change in the position/orientation of the beta-ionone ring of retinal.     

Consequences of counterion mutation in sensory rhodopsin II of Natronobacterium pharaonis for photoreaction and receptor activation: an FTIR study

In many retinal proteins the proton transfer from the Schiff base to the counterion represents a functionally important step of the photoreaction. In the signaling state of sensory rhodopsin II from Natronobacterium pharaonis this transfer has already occurred, but in the counterion mutant Asp75Asn it is blocked during all steps of the photocycle. Therefore, the study of the molecular changes during the photoreaction of this mutant should provide a deeper understanding of the activation mechanism, and for this, we have applied time-resolved step-scan FTIR spectroscopy. The photoreaction is drastically altered; only red-shifted intermediates are formed with a chromophore strongly twisted around the 14-15 single bond. In addition, the photocycle is shortened by 2 orders of magnitude. Nevertheless, a transition involving only protein changes similar to that of the wild type is observed, which has been correlated with the formation of the signaling state. However, whereas in the wild type this transition occurs in the millisecond range, it is shortened to 200 micros in the mutant. The results are discussed with respect to the altered electrostatic interactions, role of proton transfer, the published 3D structure, and physiological activity.     

Coupling photoisomerization of retinal to directional transport in bacteriorhodopsin

In order to understand how isomerization of the retinal drives unidirectional transmembrane ion transport in bacteriorhodopsin, we determined the atomic structures of the BR state and M photointermediate of the E204Q mutant, to 1.7 and 1.8 A resolution, respectively. Comparison of this M, in which proton release to the extracellular surface is blocked, with the previously determined M in the D96N mutant indicates that the changes in the extracellular region are initiated by changes in the electrostatic interactions of the retinal Schiff base with Asp85 and Asp212, but those on the cytoplasmic side originate from steric conflict of the 13-methyl retinal group with Trp182 and distortion of the pi-bulge of helix G. The structural changes suggest that protonation of Asp85 initiates a cascade of atomic displacements in the extracellular region that cause release of a proton to the surface. The progressive relaxation of the strained 13-cis retinal chain with deprotonated Schiff base, in turn, initiates atomic displacements in the cytoplasmic region that cause the intercalation of a hydrogen-bonded water molecule between Thr46 and Asp96. This accounts for the lowering of the pK(a) of Asp96, which then reprotonates the Schiff base via a newly formed chain of water molecules that is extending toward the Schiff base.     

Connectivity of the retinal Schiff base to Asp85 and Asp96 during the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle: the local-access model.

In the recently proposed local-access model for proton transfers in the bacteriorhodopsin transport cycle (Brown et al. 1998. Biochemistry. 37:3982-3993), connection between the retinal Schiff base and Asp85 (in the extracellular direction) and Asp96 (in the cytoplasmic direction)is maintained as long as the retinal is in its photoisomerized state. The directionality of the proton translocation is determined by influences in the protein that make Asp85 a proton acceptor and, subsequently, Asp96 a proton donor. The idea of concurrent local access of the Schiff base in the two directions is now put to a test in the photocycle of the D115N/D96N mutant. The kinetics had suggested that there is a single sequence of intermediates, L<-->M1<-->M2<-->N, and the M2-->M1 reaction depends on whether a proton is released to the extracellular surface. This is now confirmed. We find that at pH 5, where proton release does not occur, but not at higher pH, the photostationary state created by illumination with yellow light contains not only the M1 and M2 states, but also the L and the N intermediates. Because the L and M1 states decay rapidly, they can be present only if they are in equilibrium with later intermediates of the photocycle. Perturbation of this mixture with a blue flash caused depletion of the M intermediate, followed by its partial recovery at the expense of the L state. The change in the amplitude of the C=O stretch band at 1759 cm-1 demonstrated protonation of Asp85 in this process. Thus, during the reequilibration the Schiff base lost its proton to Asp85. Because the N state, also present in the mixture, arises by protonation of the Schiff base from the cytoplasmic surface, these results fulfill the expectation that under the conditions tested the extracellular access of the Schiff base would not be lost at the time when there is access in the cytoplasmic direction. Instead, the connectivity of the Schiff base flickers rapidly (with the time constant of the M1<-->M2 equilibration) between the two directions during the entire L-to-N segment of the photocycle.     

The surface potential on the purple membrane measured using a modified bacteriorhodopsin chromophore as the spectroscopic probe

The surface potential of the purple membrane was measured by a novel method by using an artificial bacteriorhodopsin whose chromophore was 13-CF₃ retinal instead of retinal. When attached to the apoprotein by a Schiff base, the intrinsic pK of the 13-CF₃ chromophore is around 7.3. The apparent p_K of this pigment depends on the surface potential and thus on the electrolyte concentration. This allowed us to determine the surface charge density using the Gouy-Chapman equation. The surface charge density was found to be −1.65 ± 0.15 × 10⁻³ electronic charges per Ų or about 2 negative charges/bacteriorhodopsin. This large value for the surface potential probably explains both part of the strong apparent association of divalent cations with the membrane and the effect of low salt concentrations on light-induced proton release from the purple membrane.     

Tunable laser resonance Raman spectroscopic investigations of the transduction process in vertebrate rod cells.

Tunable laser resonance Raman spectroscopy has been applied to probe (in vivo) the role of rhodopsin in transducing light energy into the chemical necessary to generate a neural response. These in vivo experiments have suggested that the Schiff base linkage through which retinal is attached to opsin in rhodopsin is protonated. Furthermore, it appears that light eventually stimulates the deprotonation of the Schiff base linkage between the Meta I and Meta II steps in the intermediate sequence which is the result of light interacting with rhodopsin. Our data suggest that this deprotonation of the Schiff base occurs on the same time scale as overall proton release and uptake by the rhodopsin molecule. It is interesting to note that this series of protonations and deprotonations also occurs within the same time scale as the neural response generation in vertebrates and the generation of a proton gradient by bacteriorhodopsin, which is used by the bacterium, Halobacterium halobium, for ATP synthesis. If these data are analyzed within the context of the in vivo resonance Raman experiments (which seem to indicate that proton release is stimulated in the disc membrane during transduction) then there is a strong suggestion that the proton will assume an important role in any working hypothesis of visual transduction. In essence it appears that protons along with ATP and calcium ions must all be essential elements in the transduction process.     

Structure of the bacteriorhodopsin mutant F219L N intermediate revealed by electron crystallography

Bacteriorhodopsin is a light-driven proton pump in halobacteria that forms crystalline patches in the cell membrane. Isomerization of the bound retinal initiates a photocycle resulting in the extrusion of a proton. An electron crystallographic analysis of the N intermediate from the mutant F219L gives a three-dimensional view of the large conformational change that occurs on the cytoplasmic side after deprotonation of the retinal Schiff base. Helix F, together with helix E, tilts away from the center of the molecule, causing a shift of approximately 3 A at the EF loop. The top of helix G moves slightly toward the ground state location of helix F. These movements open a water-accessible channel in the protein, enabling the transfer of a proton from an aspartate residue to the Schiff base. The movement of helix F toward neighbors in the crystal lattice is so large that it would not allow all molecules to change conformation simultaneously, limiting the occupancy of this state in the membrane to 33%. This explains photocooperative phenomena in the purple membrane.     

Photochemical properties of a bacteriorhodopsin analogue containing 13-desmethyl-13-(trifluoromethyl)retinal

It was shown that the substitution of the CF3 group in the structure of retinal for the methyl group in the position C-13 causes not only a decrease in the affinity of the proton to the nitrogen atom in the Schiff base (pK approximately 8.4) but also considerably changes the photochemical properties of the bacteriorhodopsin analogue. At pH > 6.5, the rate of the Schiff base reprotonation during M decay depends on the concentration of protons in medium. In the photocycle of the "yellow" M-like form with the deprotonated Schiff base, the long-wavelenght product absorbing at 625 nm is formed, which has a similar pH dependence of decay kinetics. Both processes had also similar activation energies (about 15 +/- 1 kCal/mol). The conclusion was made that, in both cases, a proton transfer from water medium through the donor part of the channel accordingly up to the Schiff base and Asp96 takes place. In this analogue, however, the structure of water molecules necessary for the stabilization of the proton on the Schiff base is broken. As a result, the dehydration of the preparation gives rise to a fraction of M-like form of bacteriorhodopsin with the deprotonated Schiff base.     

Crystallographic studies of the conformational changes that drive directional transmembrane ion movement in bacteriorhodopsin

Recent advances in the determination of the X-ray crystallographic structures of bacteriorhodopsin, and some of its photointermediates, reveal the nature of the linkage between the relaxation of electrostatic and steric conflicts at the retinal and events elsewhere in the protein. The transport cycle can be now understood in terms of specific and well-described displacements of hydrogen-bonded water, and main-chain and side-chain atoms, that lower the pK(a)s of the proton release group in the extracellular region and Asp-96 in the cytoplasmic region. Thus, local electrostatic conflict of the photoisomerized retinal with Asp-85 and Asp-212 causes deprotonation of the Schiff base, and results in a cascade of events culminating in proton release to the extracellular surface. Local steric conflict of the 13-methyl group with Trp-182 causes, in turn, a cascade of movements in the cytoplasmic region, and results in reprotonation of the Schiff base. Although numerous questions concerning the mechanism of each of these proton (or perhaps hydroxyl ion) transfers remain, the structural results provide a detailed molecular explanation for how the directionality of the ion transfers is determined by the configurational relaxation of the retinal.     

Relationship of proton release at the extracellular surface to deprotonation of the schiff base in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle.

The surface potential of purple membranes and the release of protons during the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle have been studied with the covalently linked pH indicator dye, fluorescein. The titration of acidic lipids appears to cause the surface potential to be pH-dependent and causes other deviations from ideal behavior. If these anomalies are neglected, the appearance of protons can be followed by measuring the absorption change of fluorescein bound to various residues at the extracellular surface. Contrary to widely held assumption, the activation enthalpies of kinetic components, deuterium isotope effects in the time constants, and the consequences of the D85E, F208R, and D212N mutations demonstrate a lack of direct correlation between proton transfer from the buried retinal Schiff base to D85 and proton release at the surface. Depending on conditions and residue replacements, the proton release can occur at any time between the protonation of D85 and the recovery of the initial state. We conclude that once D85 is protonated the proton release at the extracellular protein surface is essentially independent of the chromophore reactions that follow. This finding is consistent with the recently suggested version of the alternating access mechanism of bacteriorhodopsin, in which the change of the accessibility of the Schiff base is to and away from D85 rather than to and away from the extracellular membrane surface.     

Thermodynamics of proton transfer in carboxylic acid-retinal Schiff base hydrogen bonds with large proton polarizability

During the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (BR) the chromophore, a retinal Schiff base, is deprotonated. Simultaneously an asp residue is protonated. These results suggest that this deprotonation occurs via a Schiff base - asp hydrogen bond. Therefore, we studied carboxylic acid - retinal Schiff base model systems in CCl4 using IR spectroscopy. The IR spectra show that double minimum proton potentials are present in the OH ... N in equilibrium with O- ... HN+ H-bonds formed and that the proton can easily be shifted in these bonds by local electrical fields. The thermodynamic data of H-bond formation and proton transfer within these H-bonds are determined. On the basis of these data a hypothesis is developed with regard to the molecular mechanism of the deprotonation of the Schiff base of BR.     

The pKa of the protonated Schiff bases of gecko cone and octopus visual pigments.

A visual pigment is composed of retinal bound to its apoprotein by a protonated Schiff base linkage. Light isomerizes the chromophore and eventually causes the deprotonation of this Schiff base linkage at the meta II stage of the bleaching cycle. The meta II intermediate of the visual pigment is the active form of the pigment that binds to and activates the G protein transducin, starting the visual cascade. The deprotonation of the Schiff base is mandatory for the formation of meta II intermediate. We studied the proton binding affinity, pKa, of the Schiff base of both octopus rhodopsin and the gecko cone pigment P521 by spectral titration. Several fluorinated retinal analogs have strong electron withdrawing character around the Schiff base region and lower the Schiff base pKa in model compounds. We regenerated octopus and gecko visual pigments with these fluorinated and other retinal analogs. Experiments on these artificial pigments showed that the spectral changes seen upon raising the pH indeed reflected the pKa of the Schiff base and not the denaturation of the pigment or the deprotonation of some other group in the pigment. The Schiff base pKa is 10.4 for octopus rhodopsin and 9.9 for the gecko cone pigment. We also showed that although the removal of Cl- ions causes considerable blue-shift in the gecko cone pigment P521, it affects the Schiff base pKa very little, indicating that the lambda max of visual pigment and its Schiff base pKa are not tightly coupled.