Differential absorption flattening optical effects are significant in the circular dichroism spectra of large membrane fragments

The circular dichroism spectra of membrane particles are distorted by effects of differential absorption flattening, which are a consequence of the nonrandom distribution of chromophores in these samples. We have shown that this phenomenon is not significant in small unilamellar vesicles with high lipid to protein ratios [Mao, D., & Wallace, B. A. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 2667-2673]. It has recently been claimed [Glaeser, R. M., & Jap, B. K. (1985) Biochemistry 24, 6398-6401] that absorption flattening effects are also inconsequential in large membrane fragments with high protein concentrations, such as purple membrane sheets. This paper will demonstrate that absorption flattening is significant in these samples and that it causes substantial distortion of the calculated protein secondary structures derived from the uncorrected circular dichroism data.     

Absorption flattening in the circular dichroism spectra of small membrane fragments

The inhomogeneous distribution of chromophore occurring in a particulate suspension can result in a reduction in the apparent molar ellipticity recorded in circular dichroism (CD) spectra. The possibility of such a systematic error has often been a matter of concern when CD spectra of cell membrane proteins are recorded. The recent publication of CD spectra for bacteriorhodopsin in native and sonicated membranes, in detergent-solubilized form, and reconstituted into small unilamellar vesicles [Mao, D., & Wallace, B. A. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 2667-2673] gives a unique opportunity to apply the theoretical analysis of Gordon and Holzwarth [Gordon, D. J., & Holzwarth, G. (1971) Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 142, 481-488] so as to provide a definitive answer to the question of whether absorption flattening is significant for membrane particles. We show here that the data of Mao and Wallace can be combined with the theoretical analysis of Gordon and Holzwarth to rule out significant absorption flattening effects over the range 200-240 nm for submicrometer-sized membranes. In addition, the results show that absorption flattening can be disregarded even at 190 nm for membranous material in the size range below 100 nm. The demonstration that there are no major flattening effects in the CD spectra of bacteriorhodopsin, particularly in the region of 200-240 nm, means that the experimental spectra are incompatible with the proposal that this transmembrane protein contains seven transmembrane helices.     

Circular dichroism analyses of membrane proteins: an examination of differential light scattering and absorption flattening effects in large membrane vesicles and membrane sheets

The circular dichroism spectra of membrane suspensions are distorted by differential light scattering and absorption flattening effects, which arise as a consequence of the large size of the membrane particles relative to the wavelength of light and the high concentration of proteins in the membranes. In this paper, the consequences of these phenomena on the protein spectra of large membrane particles are discussed, and methods for eliminating them are examined. The distortions due to differential light scattering are relatively small in membrane systems, and can be compensated for by use of a large detector acceptance angle geometry. Several methods for correcting for differential flattening, which introduces a substantial distortion, have been evaluated, and a new method, the flattening quotient approach, which produces by far the best results, is described. Since the secondary structures calculated from circular dichroism spectra are highly dependent on accurate spectral shape and magnitude, this method for correcting the spectra may find general application in circular dichroism studies of membrane proteins.     

Estimation of flattening coefficient for absorption and circular dichroism using simulation

The absorbance and circular dichroism (CD) of suspensions is lower than if the same amount of chromophore were uniformly distributed throughout the medium. Several mathematical treatments of this absorption flattening phenomenon have been presented using various assumptions and approximations. This article demonstrates an alternative simulation approach that allows relaxation of assumptions. On current desktop computers, the algorithm runs quickly with enough particles and light paths considered to get answers that are usually accurate to better than 3%. Results from the simulation agree with the most popular analytical model for 0.01 volume fraction of particles, showing that the extent of flattening depends mainly on the absorbance through a particle diameter. Unlike previous models, the simulation can show that flattening is significantly lower when volume fraction increases to 0.1 but is higher when the particles have a size distribution. The simulation can predict the slope of the nearly linear relationship between flattening of CD and the absorbance of the suspension. This provides a method to correct experimental CD data where volume fraction and particle size are known.     

Experimental test of absorption flattening correction for circular dichroism of particle suspensions

There are well established theoretical models for correction for absorption flattening of circular dichroism (CD) measurements on particle suspensions. However, these have not been directly tested experimentally. We describe a test system with the chiral tris(ethylenediamine)Co(III) complex dissolved in water trapped inside sephadex particles, suspended in 1-butanol. Independent measurements of particle size distribution, volume fraction, and the absorbance of the suspension are used to calculate the required CD correction. The corrected CD signal is found to agree rather well with that for the same amount of Co-complex dispersed uniformly throughout the sample cell. This holds for different particle volume fractions and Co-complex concentrations inside the particles. The correction seems to work despite a substantial scattering contribution to the absorbance, which is not considered in the theoretical models.     

Conformation of intercalated DNA plasmids investigated by circular dichroism and dynamic light scattering

Two DNA plasmids, pEGF and pACL29, intercalated with ethidium bromide (EB), have been examined by circular dichroism (CD) and dynamic light scattering (DLS). CD and DLS data show significant changes when the EB/DNA (phosphates) ratio reaches a value of r approximately equal to 0.13. The translational and rotational diffusion coefficients, predicted assuming that plasmids can be described by a string of beads, and the CD spectrum, suggest that a transition from an interwound to a toroidal conformation is likely to occur.     

Photoselection and circular dichroism in the purple membrane.

The transient dichroic ratio D = delta A parallel/delta A perpendicular has been measured in the visible absorption region of bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane by a flash photolysis method. D is found to be wavelength independent throughout the visible absorption band, and reaches a maximum value of 2.75 +/- 0.15 on reduction of the excitation intensity. This value is close to that expected for a single nondegenerate transition dipole moment and is incompatible with the strong exciton coupling model used to explain circular dichroism (CD) spectrum of purple membrane. A time-dependent analysis of the exciton interaction and consideration of the coupling strength suggests an explanation of these observations. It is concluded that excitation interaction between retinals in purple membrane is of the weak or very weak type defined by Förster.     

Differential polarization imaging. V. Numerical aperture effects and the contribution of preferential scattering and absorption to the circular dichroism images.

Chiral objects which scatter and absorb preferentially left versus right circularly polarized light give rise to bright-field circular dichroism (CD) images containing contributions from both these two phenomena. These contributions are separated and characterized mathematically, and the effect of the dimensions of the chiral object on their relative magnitude is discussed. CD images of the long-range chiral organization of the thylakoid membranes in chloroplasts are obtained at two different wavelengths to illustrate the diverse wavelength dependence of the preferential absorption and scattering contributions to the images. The bright field CD images not only depend on the magnitude and sign of the preferential scattering and preferential absorption contributions, but also on the numerical aperture of the lens used. This dependence is obtained formally and a method to extract the angle dependent preferential scattering contributions to the images is presented. The validity of this method is confirmed experimentally.     

Dynamic light scattering and circular dichroism studies on heat-induced gelation of hard-keratin protein aqueous solutions

Animal hairs consist of aggregates of dead cells filled with keratin protein gel. We succeeded in preparing water-soluble hard-keratin proteins and reconstructing the keratin gels by heat-induced disulfide linkages in vitro. Here, the roles of intermolecular hydrophobic interaction and disulfide bonding between the proteins in the gel were discussed. Water-soluble keratin proteins consisting of mixtures of type I ( approximately 48 kDa) and type II ( approximately 61 kDa) were prepared from wool fibers as S-carboxymethyl alanyl disulfide keratin (CMADK). The gelation was achieved by heating an aqueous solution containing at least 0.8 wt % CMADK at 100 degrees C. CMADK solutions with different urea or N-ethylmaleimide concentrations or pH were exposed to dynamic light scattering (DLS) and circular dichroism (CD). DLS clarified the gelation point of CMADK solutions and provided information on the changes in keratin cluster size. DLS suggested two types of gelation mechanism. One was the regenerated chemical disulfide bonding between keratins from CMAD parts of chains. After the gel formed, this bond became important to maintain the gel structure. The other was the physical assembly due to hydrophobic interaction between alpha-helix parts of keratin chains. This hydrophobic assembly also played an important role during gelation. CD confirmed a conformational change in the keratin protein, resulting heat-induced gelation. CD clarified the relationship between keratin protein conformation and gelation, i.e., a rodlike conformation with many alpha-helix structures was necessary to associate keratin chains and form a gel network.     

The differential scattering of circularly polarized light by chloroplasts and evaluation of their true circular dichroism

Chloroplasts isolated from pea leaves display an intense circular dichroism in the range 600 to 720nm. Circularly polarized light is also differentially scattered by chloroplasts, and this effect can be confused with circular dichroism. By using an instrumental modification it was possible to distinguish, and record separately, the ellipticities of the transmitted light (circular dichroism) and of the scattered light in the same c.d. instrument. By means of a light-scattering apparatus, the intensity of unpolarized light scattered by chloroplasts was measured as a function of wavelength and of angle. This measurement allowed the aforementioned ellipticities to be corrected for mutual interference. At a concentration of 4mug of chlorophyll/ml (the optimum practical concentration of chloroplasts at which there was no significant interaction of scattering and absorption effects) spectra of true circular dichroism (circular differential absorption) and circular differential scattering were obtained. The former showed maxima, positive at 688nm and negative at 676nm, with an intensity Deltatheta=8.3m degrees .litre.(mg of chlorophyll)(-1).cm(-1). The latter had a maximum at 683nm with an intensity of +47m degrees with respect to the solvent baseline; this value is independent of the concentration of chloroplasts in dilute suspensions. It is suggested that the intense circular dichroism of chloroplasts reflects specific chlorophyll-chlorophyll interactions in the light-harvesting pigment. The advantages of this method for determining the c.d. of scattering suspensions over those of other investigators are discussed.     

Probing intercalation and conformational effects of the anticancer drug 2-methyl-9-hydroxyellipticinium acetate in DNA fragments with circular dichroism.

Circular dichroism was applied to the analysis of drug-DNA associations. With the octanucleotide d(TGACGTCA) (octanucleotide I), which is the cAMP-responsive element (CRE) in gene promoters and its reverse d(ACTGCAGT) (octanucleotide II), it was demonstrated that the anticancer polyaromatic agent celiptium intercalates into DNA base pairs with its long direction perpendicular to both the DNA-helix axis and the base-pair long axis and induces larger conformational changes in the CpG-containing octanucleotide I CRE than in its reverse-sequence octanucleotide II. It was concluded that CD is a powerful and sensitive technique to discriminate between drug-binding modes of DNA, to define the geometry of the chromophore inserted into base pairs and, finally, to measure sequence-dependent conformational changes induced by intercalation in DNA. We anticipate that these studies will contribute to a better understanding of the molecular bases that underlie the mechanism of action of those cytotoxic drugs which interfere with the DNA-nuclear-protein recognition.     

Near ultraviolet circular dichroism spectroscopy of plasma fibronectin and fibronectin fragments

Comparison of the near uv CD spectrum of human plasma fibronectin with the spectra of the three major leukocyte elastase fragments 25 Kd, 60 Kd and $\text{140}\text{160}$ shows that the aromatic residues of these fragments are in different environments. In particular, the ellipticity bands associated with tryptophan in the 290–300 nm region differ for each fragment. The results also show that intrachain disulfide bridges are important in stabilizing regions of the fibronectin molecule against the structure-disrupting effects of 8M urea.     

On the analysis of membrane protein circular dichroism spectra

Analysis of circular dichroism spectra of proteins provides information about protein secondary structure. Analytical methods developed for such an analysis use structures and spectra of a set of reference proteins. The reference protein sets currently in use include soluble proteins with a wide range of secondary structures, and perform quite well in analyzing CD spectra of soluble proteins. The utility of soluble protein reference sets in analyzing membrane protein CD spectra, however, has been questioned in a recent study that found current reference protein sets to be inadequate for analyzing membrane proteins. We have examined the performance of reference protein sets available in the CDPro software package for analyzing CD spectra of 13 membrane proteins with available crystal structures. Our results indicate that the reference protein sets currently available for CD analysis perform reasonably well in analyzing membrane protein CD spectra, with performance indices comparable to those for soluble proteins. Soluble + membrane protein reference sets, which were constructed by combining membrane proteins with soluble protein reference sets, gave improved performance in both soluble and membrane protein CD analysis.     

An investigation of the dissociation and denaturation of legumin by salts using laser light scattering and circular dichroism spectroscopy

The dissociation of legumin, a 12 S seed storage globulin from Pisum sativum, has been studied by laser light scattering and circular dichroism spectroscopy. Salts from the Hofmeister series, in particular sodium perchlorate, were used as dissociating agents. The Mr 360,000 hexameric protein was found to dissociate first to trimers and further to monomers and the number of amino acids involved in the trimer-trimer interaction estimated to be 23(+/-4). Native legumin appears to be more strongly bound together than some analogous seed storage globulins from other plant species such as Arachis hypogaea or Sesamum indicum and the dissociation process was accompanied by some changes in conformation.     

Computer-aided analysis of infrared, circular dichroism and absorption spectra

Marquardt and Powell optimization methods without constraintson the optimized spectral parameters were employed for decompositionof complex i.r., c.d. and absorption spectra into componentbands. The procedure resolved experimental spectra into eightcomponent bands and it can be easily adjusted for a larger setof component bands. The CPU time required for achievement ofsatisfactory convergence of parameters for eight component bandsis rather large even when using mainframe computers and thereforedivision of spectra into a few non-overlapped parts is advisable.The program also can be used for calculation of absorption,c.d. and difference spectra from formatted raw spectral data. Received on January 13, 1986; accepted on April 7, 1986