Clonal analysis of the T lymphocytes involved in parent versus Fn1 graft-versus-host reaction

A systemic graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) leading to 50% mortality by day 20 was elicited by the injection of CBA (10⁵) or B10 (10⁶) parental T lymphocytes into irradiated (750 rad) and bone marrow protected (CBA x B10)F₁ recipients. Between days 12 and 28 the spleens of the sick mice were analyzed by limiting dilution, performed with irradiated F₁ cells and a source of interleukin-2 (IL-2), to determine the frequency of cells with an antihost proliferative or cytolytic activity and to derive T lymphocyte clones. The frequency of cells with antihost proliferative or cytolytic activity was approximately 10^–3 in either combination. In the CBA vs F₁ GVHR, all eight clones isolated with anti-F₁ activity were Lyt-2^–, noncytolytic, mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) responders and IL-2 producers, three of which mapped to the A ^b locus, while in the B10 anti-F1 combination, eight of the nine anti-F₁ clones isolated were Lyt-2⁺, poor MLR responders and non-IL-2 producers, but cytolytic and mapping to K _k . These findings suggest a much higher frequency of T cells recognizing the A-locus antigens in the CBA than in the B10 strain.     

Selective suppression of the murine autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction by physiological concentrations of hydrocortisone: effects on cell-surface Ia antigens

Strong, adult (Type II) autologous mixed lymphocyte reactions (AMLR) were observed in cultures of lymphoid cells from both A.TH and A.TL mice. These were suppressed by more than 90% in the continuous presence of 7.5 × 10^?8M hydrocortisone-21-sodium succinate. This concentration of hormone had minimal effects on the allogeneic mixed lymphocyte response (MLR) and the mitogenic response to concanavalin A (Con A). Higher concentrations suppressed all three responses. Treatment of autologous cell mixtures for the first 30 hr with 7.5 × 10^?8M hydrocortisone resulted in a 78% suppression of the AMLR. This was not associated with a detectable decrease in the quantity of Ia antigens on the stimulator-cell surface, as evaluated by the susceptibility of treated cells to antibody dependent, complement-mediated lysis, using [A.TH × B.10M]F₁ anti-A.TL antiserum. Hence, this suppression did not appear to result from an alteration of the antigens putatively associated with stimulation of the AMLR. Separate pretreatment of stimulator and responder cells with 7.5 × 10^?8M hydrocortisone followed by culturing with appropriate companion cells had no major effect on the AMLR. Therefore, low-dose hydrocortisone did not appear to selectively eliminate or permanently inactivate subpopulations of responder or stimulator cells. Rather, it appeared to regulate active cellular processes that are initiated by the coculturing of these cells and are required for the early stages of autologous lymphocyte activation.     

Attempt to inhibit cytotoxic alloantibody with specific anti-receptor site antiserum

Utilizing a ⁵¹Cr release cytotoxicity inhibition assay, putative anti-receptor site antisera (anti-A RS_B) were assayed for their capacity to inhibit specific alloantibody, a result predicted by the recent work of Ramseier and Lindenman. Utilizing various isogenic strains of rats, anti-RS antisera prepared by injecting appropriate F₁ hybrid animals (A × B) with either lymph node cells (A) or specific alloantiserum (A anti-B) were found to be inactive in this assay. It appears that the Ramseier-Lindenman phenomenon cannot be corroborated using a ⁵¹Cr release inhibition assay.     

Differential responsiveness to MIs locus antigens in graft-versus-host and host-versus-graft reactions

After (semi)allogeneic transplantation of lymphoid cells into lethally irradiated mice, the development of anti-host directed T effector cells can be demonstrated by means of a simple delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) assay. Using this assay we have shown that in H-2 compatible combinations Mls locus antigens can induce the generation of such T effector cells during a graft-versus-host (GvH) reaction. Other non-H-2 alloantigens are probably of minor importance. The capacity of Mls locus antigens to induce distinct anti-host DTH reactivity correlated with the capacity to induce a one-way mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) response. Mls^a and Mls^c locus antigens initiated a positive MLC response as well as distinct GvH-related DTH reactivity. On the other hand, in the combination DBA/2 versus (BALB/c × DBA/2) F₁, the Mls^b locus antigen was not able to initiate in vitro proliferation, a lack of response which coincided with a marginal and short-lasting GvH-related DTH reactivity. In contrast, the host-versus-graft (HvG) DTH reaction of BALB/c and DBA/2 mice to subcutaneously injected (BALB/c × DBA/2) F₁ spleen cells was equally strong. Here antigens other than those coded for by the Mls locus were mainly responsible for the antigraft DTH response. These results suggest that T effector cells generated in GvH and HvG reactions are specific for largely different sets of minor histocompatibility antigens, with a selective stimulation by Mls locus antigens under GvH conditions.     

Clones of alloreactive T cells

We have developed a method which allows us to clone and reclone primed responder T cells derived from serially restimulated murine mixed lymphocyte cultures. We have derived clones from two such mixed lymphocyte cultures, A anti-B6 [A(B6)] and A anti-(B6XA)F₁ [A(B6A)]. In the A (B6) system, we have isolated clones which can be stimulated by B6 but not by (B6XA)F₁ cells. This implies the presence of a unique parental H-2^b MLR determinant which is absent on semi-allogeneic (B6XA)F₁ cells. In the A(B6A) system, we have isolated clones which can be stimulated by (B6XA)F₁ cells but not by B6 cells. This confirms our previous observation on the presence of unique hybrid MLR stimulating determinants on (B6XA)F₁ cells. Many of the “clones” derived primarily from soft agar seem to be contaminated and contain several different sets of primed responder cells with different reactivity patterns. Experiments in which we subcloned cells exhibiting selected reactivity patterns from such contaminated primary clones suggested that a T-cell growth factor or accessory cell is required for proliferation in soft agar following alloantigen recognition by primed responder cells.     

Specific inhibition of natural killer (NK) activity against different alloantigens

Allogeneic lymphocyte cytotoxicity (ALC), i. e., rapid rejection of i. v. injected allogeneic lymphocytes in unprimed hosts, is an example of NK activity. Apparently anomalous rejection patterns, such as acceptance of F₁ hybrid cells by parental hosts and rejection of parental cells by F₁ hybrid hosts in many strain combinations, would fit the hypothesis that the effector cells in ALC recognize the absence of certain self-molecules (passwords) rather than the presence of nonself determinants. However, cold target inhibition studies showed that ALC displays allospecificity: when a mixture of radiolabeled AO and DA cells were injected i. v. into euthymic or athymic PVG rats, adding a surplus of cold DA cells reduced killing only of labeled DA cells and vice versa. Furthermore, semiallogeneic cold target cells were ineffective in inhibiting elimination of fully allogeneic cells, which supports the argument against a modification of the hypothesis that self-determinants inhibit a postbinding stage of lysis. Finally, (DA × AO)F₁ cells injected into (DA × PVG)F₁ hosts were rapidly rejected, despite the fact that donor and host shared expressed DA determinants. In sum, our results show that a hypothesis based on inhibition of killing by self-determinants can only be sustained with extensive modifications, and favor the alternative mechanism that the effector cells positively recognize the presence of allospecific determinants on the target cell surface.     

Cellular basis of the immunohematologic defects observed in short-term semiallogeneic B6C3F1 -- C3H chimeras: evidence for host-versus-graft reaction initiated by radioresistant T cells

Lethally irradiated C3Hf mice reconstituted with a relatively low dose (2 × 10⁶) of B6C3F₁ bone marrow cells (B6C3F₁ → C3Hf chimeras) frequently manifest immunohematologic deficiencies during the first month following injection of bone marrow cells. They show slow recovery of antibody-forming potential to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) as compared to that observed in syngeneic (C3Hf → C3Hf or B6C3F₁ → B6C3F₁) chimeras. They also show a deficiency of B-cell activity as assessed by antibody response to SRBC following further reconstitution with B6C3F₁-derived thymus cells 1 week after injection of bone marrow cells. A significant fraction of B6C3F₁ → C3Hf chimeras was shown to manifest a sudden loss of cellularity of spleens during the second week following injection of bone marrow cells even though cellularity was restored to the normal level within 1 week. The splenic mononuclear cells recovered from such chimeras almost invariably showed strong cytotoxicity against target cells expressing donor-type specific H-2 antigens (H-2^b) when assessed by ⁵¹Cr-release assay in vitro. The effector cells responsible for the observed anti-donor specific cytotoxicity were shown to be residual host-derived T cells. These results indicate strongly that residual host T cells could develop anti-donor specific cytotoxicity even after exposure to a supralethal dose (1050 R) of radiation and that the immunohematologic disturbances observed in short-term F₁ to parent bone marrow chimeras (B6C3F₁ → C3Hf) were due to host-versus-graft reaction (HVGR) initiated by residual host T cells. The implication of these findings on the radiobiological nature of the residual T cells and the persistence of potentially anti-donor reactive T-cell clones in long-surviving allogeneic bone marrow chimeras was discussed.     

Immune response gene control of antibody specificity

The expression of the histocompatibility-linked PLL Ir gene was investigated in guinea pig B cells. Strain 2 and F₁ (2 × 13) guinea pigs, immunized with the αDnp-Lys₉, produce both T cells and antibody which are equally discriminatory for αDnp-Lys₉. In contrast strain 13 (PLL Ir gene negative) guinea pigs immunized with αDnp-Lys₉ do not develop specific T-cell responses and the antibody produced while restricted in heterogeneity cannot differentiate the immunizing antigen from Dnp-OH. However, if in a F₁ (2 × 13) environment, PLL Ir gene-negative B cells are provided with F₁ (2 × 13) T cells they express the ability to make antibody as specific and discriminatory as the antibody produced by PLL Ir gene-positive B cells. These findings strongly suggest that in the guinea pigs the PLL Ir gene defect is localized to the T cells and that the repertoire of specificity of B cells is similar if not identical in both responder and nonresponder animals. In addition these observations support the notion that the cellular locus for the PLL Ir gene expression in the guinea pigs is limited to T cells and not to macrophages and B lymphocytes.     

Alteration in lymphocyte recognition repertoire during aging: II. Changes in the expressed T-cell receptor repertoire in aged mice and the persistence of that change after transplantation to a new differentiative environment

Changes in the T-lymphocyte alloreceptor repertoire associated with aging by exploring the frequency of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursors (CTLp) available for activation by various major histocompatibility complex (MHC) haplotypes in mice of different ages have been investigated. There was no consistent pattern of change in CTLp frequencies. Thus, for instance, while the frequency of responder C57Bl/6 CTLp for ATH alloantigen decreased with age, the frequency for C3H alloantigen increased. There was no significant change in the overall frequency of splenic CTLp (assessed irrespective of antigen specificity). No evidence was found that CTL produced by activated CTLp of aged mice were less specific in their lytic capacity that CTL produced by CTLp of young mice. However, by assaying responder CTLp cultures at limiting dilution we obtained evidence that the “burst size” (mean lytic capacity per responder well assayed at limiting dilution) was diminished with age of the donor of the CTLp pool. Furthermore, we obtained evidence that the apparent affinity of CTL for their target antigen was consistently decreased when those effector cells were derived from a pool of CTLp of aged mice. All of these changes reflected in mature T cells derived from aged mice were already apparent in the bone marrow stem cell pool of aged individuals and were not due to environmental influences alone, as assessed by the phenotype of T cells derived from young or old bone marrow stem cells transplanted to young or aged recipient mice. A final study has examined evidence for more subtle changes in the T-cell alloreceptor repertoire, reflecting heterogeneity in young or aged mice in the recognition repertoire associated with a given antigenic specificity. By preparing F₁ anti (parent anti-F₁)-suppressor cells directed against CTL from young parental mice (a, b, c), or aged parental mice (x, y, z), we have explored the heterogeneity in the anti-C3H alloreceptor repertoire in individual young or aged C57Bl/6 mice. Suppression by immunized F₁ animals was assessed in tissue culture (inhibition of mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) responses) or in vivo (inhibition of lethal GvHD induced by inoculation of parental lymphocytes into sublethally irradiated F₁ hybrid mice). Irrespective of the assay system used, the data suggests that the receptor repertoire of aged T lymphocytes uses recognition structures different from those of young individuals, and that there is less individual-to-individual variation in the receptor repertoire of aged mice than in young mice.     

T lymphocyte-mediated cytotoxicity against autologous EBV-genome-bearing B cells

We have stimulated human peripheral blood lymphocytes in vitro with autologous EBV-infected or noninfected B cells. A cytotoxic response was obtained only when virally infected cells were used. The activity of the effector cells was restricted by the major histocompatibility complex and was directed against EBV-genome-bearing targets. The highest cytolytic response was obtained when lymphocytes of individuals previously exposed to the virus (EBV-VCA positive) were used. Lymphocytes of noninfected donors (EBV-VCA negative) gave a low response; the relative frequency of their effector cells was at least 4-fold lower. Lymphocytes of newborns did not respond. The cytotoxic activity was mediated by T lymphocytes of the cytotoxic/suppressor subset, as determined by cytofluorographic analysis and antibody plus complement-mediated lysis, using monoclonal antibodies to human lymphocyte surface antigen.     

Adoptive transfer of delayed-type hypersensitivity to sendai virus

TheH-2 restriction pattern of cytolytic T lymphocytes (Tc) and T lymphocytes which mediate a delayed-type hypersensitivity response (Td) directed against infectious Sendai virus was investigated usingH-2 mutant mice. Td and Tc lymphocytes exhibit the same fine specificity for self-recognition, for example, B6.C-H- 2^bm1 effector T cells were unable to recognize viral antigens in association with wild-type K^b and vice versa, B6.-H- 2^bm6 effector cells did not mediate a reaction against virus plus wild-type K^b but, on the other hand, T cells of wild-type K^b recognized virus plus K^bm6.BALB/c-H- 2^dm2 T cells lacked reactivity against virus in association with wild-type D^d, but again wild-type D^d effector cells recognized virus plus D^dm2.Abbreviations used in this paper DTH delayed-type hypersensitivity - EID₅₀ mean egg infective dose - FCS fetal calf serum - HAU hemagglutinating units - LPS lipopolysaccharide - Ly^(–) low amount of Ly antigens - MHC major histocompatibility complex - 2-ME 2-mercaptoethanol - PBS phosphate-buffered saline - Tc cytolytic T cell - Td T cell which mediates a delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction     

Activation of T and B thymus cells to recognize histocompatibility antigens

Lethally irradiated (A × CBA) F₁ or (A × C57BL/6) F₁ mice were injected with 10⁷ A strain thymus cells in attempts to activate donor cells to recognize CBA or C57BL/6 histocompatibility antigens, respectively. Activation could be revealed by injecting activated thymus cells (day 5 irradiated F₁ hybrid spleen cells) into corresponding unirradiated F₁ hybrid hosts. The alloantibody titers formed by these cells and the antirecognition structure (anti-RS) antibody titers induced by them were similar to those observed after injection of normal parental strain spleen cells, indicating that thymus cells had become endowed with recognition structures (RS). Alloantibodies, but no anti-RS antibodies, were present in the serum of F₁ mice given activated thymus cells treated with anti-θ and complement. It, therefore, appeared that activated thymus cells contained sufficient B cells differentiated into antibody-forming cells to give a measurable alloantibody response. On the other hand, receptors responsible for anti-RS antibody induction presumably were located on T cells. Specificity and restriction of antigenic recognition were revealed by negative results obtained when activated thymus cells were injected into F₁ hosts not containing the antigens against which activation had been directed.     

Age-related changes in the cellular immune response of lymph node and thymus cells in long-lived mice.

Relative capabilities of lymph node and thymus cells from (C57BL/6J) × Balb/cJ) F₁-hybrid mice and from (C57BL/6J × 129J)F₁—hybrid mice 6, 20, and 30 mo of age to respond in the mixed lymphocyte reaction were assessed. Both the direct response and the ability to synergize with partner lymph node or thymus cells were studied. Lymph node cells demonstrated an age-related decline both in responding directly to stimulation by allogeneic cells, and in ability to synergize with syngeneic thymocytes. Thymus cells showed an age-related increase in response to direct stimulation, and no clear-cut age-related change in synergizing capability. In these long-lived mouse strains at least one cause of the age-related decline in cellular immunity relates to developing deficiencies in the recirculating lymphoid pool, probably T₂ cells.     

A comparison of H-2 restriction of helper function using T cells from radiation chimeras and nude mice bearing thymus grafts

T cells from nude chimeras and radiation chimeras were tested for ability to cooperate with B cells of the thymus epithelium strain and B cells of the T-stem-cell strain in nude mice of appropriate strain backgrounds and also in irradiated F₁'s together with bone marrow cells of the two relevant strains (i.e., A-nu ← B or A → A × B chimera T cells were tested in A-nu and B-nu and in irradiated A × B F₁ with A bone marrow cells or B bone marrow cells). Whether the donor chimeras were antigen primed or not, all cells, when tested in nudes, provided help for the T-stem-cell type only. In contrast, in most cases, chimera T cells, tested in irradiated F₁'S, provided help for bone marrow cells of both thymus and T-stem-cell strains. These data indicate the involvement of two helper cell populations and an hypothesis to explain their interaction is presented.     

H-Y antigen: No evidence for alleles in wild strains of mice

H-Y antigen(s) coded or controlled by the Y chromosome in a variety of wild mouse strains have been compared with those of the inbred laboratory strains C57BL/6 (B6) and C57BL/10 (B10). H-Y antigen(s) were detected by H-2-restricted cytotoxic T cells from B6 and B10 female mice primed in vivo and boosted in vitro with syngeneic male spleen cells: There was no difference in the degree of H-Y specific lysis of male cells from the C57BL strains and of F₁ hybrids or B6 congenic mice carrying the Y chromosome from the wild mouse strains examined. This result indicated that at the level of target cell specificity the H-Y antigen(s) from wild and laboratory strains were indistinguishable. H-Y antigen(s) were also found to be indistinguishable at the level of the in vitro induction of the anti H-Y cytotoxic response: F₁ female mice, primed in vivo and boosted in vitro with homologous F₁ male cells, all made H-Y-specific responses and where it could be examined, the target cell specificity of the anti-H-Y cytotoxic cells showed that B10 male cells as well as the homologous F₁ male cells (where the Y chromosome was derived from the wild strain) were good targets. Finally, possible differences in H-Y transplantation antigens between the wild strains and the B10 laboratory strain were examined by grafting F₁ male mice, the progeny of B10 females, and wild strain males with B10 male skin. These grafts were not rejected during an observation period of more than 9 months. Taken together, neither the cytotoxic data nor the skin graft data provide any evidence for allelism of H-Y even though the mouse strains examined were collected from widely disparate geographical locations.     

Target level blocking of T-cell cytotoxicity for human malignant melanoma by monoclonal antibodies

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) for autologous malignant melanoma in culture of a patient AV were induced by restimulation of PBL (peripheral blood leukocytes) with AV melanoma cells in vitro and subcultured in interleukin 2 (IL-2) conditioned media. Monoclonal antibodies detecting six antigenic systems on melanoma cell surfaces were tested for blocking activity on the effector function of subcultured cytolytic T lymphocytes for autologous melanoma cells. The monoclonal antibodies R₂₄ (γ3), specific for the G_D3 disialoganglioside on melanoma cell surfaces and I₂₄ (γM), detecting a similar antigenic determinant, blocked autologous T lymphocytotoxicity for malignant melanoma cells on the target level. The effector function of alloantigen activated cytolytic T lymphocytes generated by coculture of allogeneic PBL with Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) transformed AV B lymphocytes, was blocked by monoclonal antibody R₂₄ when tested against AV melanoma targets, but not when tested against AV B lymphocyte targets. It is concluded that blocking by mAb R₂₄ occurs in this system as a nonspecific effect, unrelated to the specific target antigen recognition by cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Steric hindrance or antibody induced membrane changes may account for the blocking effect of monoclonal antibody R₂₄.     

Ontogeny of diversity in the receptor repertoire of murine cytotoxic lymphocytes. I. Comparison of recognition patterns of activated T cells of B10.D2 and B10.BR mice of different ages and analysis of changes in F1 hybrid and bone marrow radiation chimeras

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTLp) from B10.D₂, B10.BR, and (B10.D₂ × B10.BR)F₁ mice of different ages have been activated by irradiated “wild-type” H2K^b antigens (from B10.A(3R) mice) under limiting dilution conditions such that cytotoxic cells in responder wells represent the progeny of a single CTLp. After expansion in the presence of IL₂ and irradiated C57B1/6Kha spleen cells the contents of each well were divided into equal aliquots and tested for lysis with a panel of selected H2K^b mutant targets. As has been observed for the murine B-cell repertoire, there seems to be substantially more homogeneity in the neonatal allo-T-cell repertoire than in the adult mouse. Furthermore, while the adult F₁ repertoire is markedly distinct from that expressed by either parental T-lymphocyte pool, the neonatal repertoire apparently reflects a relatively accurate composite of each parental population, codominantly expressed. These data, combined with studies of adult bone marrow radiation chimeras, suggest that during development of the adult T-lymphocyte repertoire from the initially expressed restricted (germ-line?) recognition specificities, somatic diversification driven by environmental (MHC?) antigenic determinants occurs. In addition to this ontogenetic development, during senescence another “regulation” of the repertoire becomes apparent, and once more the heterogeneity of recognition specificities is diminished. Nevertheless, the homogeneity seen in aged mice does not represent a simple return to the expression of the limited number of allo-specificities encoded in the neonatal repertoire.     

Responses of spleen cells from mice with X-linked B-cell defect to polyclonal B-cell activators, purified protein derivative of tuberculin, and dextran sulfate

Polyclonal responses to LPS, PPD, and DxS of spleen cells from mice expressing a X-linked B-cell defect were examined. Spleen cells from young (CBA/N × BALB/c)F₁ male mice responded slightly lower to LPS, significantly lower to PPD than the cells from age-matched F₁ female mice, and showed no response to DxS stimulation. This hypo- or unresponsiveness of F₁ male cells to PPD or DxS could not be explained by a shift in the dose-response or time kinetics of the responding cells, and also could not be due to the defect in the function of T cells or macrophages. Suppressor T cells to polyclonal response to PPD or DxS could not be shown in F₁ male spleen cells. The response of F₁ male cells to PPD was dramatically improved with age but not to DxS. These results suggest that B cells responsive to DxS may belong to a distinct subpopulation from the cells responsive to LPS or PPD.     

Specificities shared between HLA-A3 and HLA-A11 detected by Fab'2 blocking

Four anti-HLA-A3 sera crossreactive with HLA-A11 were tested with a panel of A3 positive cells pretreated with either Fab'₂ prepared from one of the four anti-A3 sera or Fab'₂ fragments of an anti-A11 serum displaying CYNAP crossreactivity with A3. The anti-A3 Fab'₂ blocked the reactions of all anti-A3 sera with all A3 +, 11– cells; the anti-A11 Fab'₂ blocked the reactions of only some serum-cell combinations. Each of the four anti-A3 sera tested were blocked by the anti-A11 Fab'₂ in a different pattern, indicating that each could have a different anti-A3 specificity. Five different patterns of reactivity were observed among the 21 test lymphocytes. These findings are interpreted as evidence for shared antigenic components between A3 and A11.