Crystal structure of ovocleidin-17, a major protein of the calcified Gallus gallus eggshell: implications in the calcite mineral growth pattern

Ovocleidin-17 (OC17) from Gallus gallus is one of the best candidates to control and regulate the deposition of calcium carbonate in the calcified eggshell layer. Here, the crystal structure of monomeric OC17, determined at a resolution of 1.5 A, was refined to a crystallographic R-factor of 20.1%. This is the first protein directly involved in a non-pathological biomineralization process resolved by x-ray diffraction to date. The protein has a mixed alpha/beta structure containing a single C-type lectin-like domain. However, although OC17 shares the conserved scaffold of the C-type lectins, it does not bind carbohydrates. Nevertheless, in vitro OC17 modifies the crystalline habit of calcium carbonate (CaCO3) and the pattern of crystal growth at intervals of 5-200 microg/ml. Determining the three-dimensional structure of OC17 contributes to a better understanding of the biological behavior of structurally related biomolecules and of the mechanisms involved in eggshell and other mineralization processes.     

Crystal structure of the carbohydrate recognition domain of the H1 subunit of the asialoglycoprotein receptor

The human asialoglycoprotein receptor (ASGPR), also called hepatic lectin, is an integral membrane protein and is responsible for the clearance of desialylated, galactose-terminal glycoproteins from the circulation by receptor-mediated endocytosis. It can be subdivided into four functional domains: the cytosolic domain, the transmembrane domain, the stalk and the carbohydrate recognition domain (CRD). The galactose-binding domains belong to the superfamily of C-type (calcium-dependent) lectins, in particular to the long-form subfamily with three conserved intramolecular disulphide bonds. It is able to bind terminal non-reducing galactose residues and N-acetyl-galactosamine residues of desialated tri or tetra-antennary N-linked glycans. The ASGPR is a potential liver-specific receptor for hepatitis B virus and Marburg virus and has been used to target exogenous molecules specifically to hepatocytes for diagnostic and therapeutic purposes.Here, we present the X-ray crystal structure of the carbohydrate recognition domain of the major subunit H1 at 2.3 A resolution. While the overall fold of this and other known C-type lectin structures are well conserved, the positions of the bound calcium ions are not, indicating that the fold is stabilised by alternative mechanisms in different branches of the C-type lectin family. It is the first CRD structure where three calcium ions form an intergral part of the structure. In addition, the structure provides direct confirmation for the conversion of the ligand-binding site of the mannose-binding protein to an asialoglycoprotein receptor-like specificity suggested by Drickamer and colleagues. In agreement with the prediction that the coiled-coil domain of the ASGPR is separated from the CRD and its N-terminal disulphide bridge by several residues, these residues are indeed not alpha-helical, while in tetranectin they form an alpha-helical coiled-coil.     

The dipole moment of the electron carrier adrenodoxin is not critical for redox partner interaction and electron transfer

Dipole moments of proteins arise from helical dipoles, hydrogen bond networks and charged groups at the protein surface. High protein dipole moments were suggested to contribute to the electrostatic steering between redox partners in electron transport chains of respiration, photosynthesis and steroid biosynthesis, although so far experimental evidence for this hypothesis was missing. In order to probe this assumption, we changed the dipole moment of the electron transfer protein adrenodoxin and investigated the influence of this on protein-protein interactions and electron transfer. In bovine adrenodoxin, the [2Fe-2S] ferredoxin of the adrenal glands, a dipole moment of 803 Debye was calculated for a full-length adrenodoxin model based on the Adx(4-108) and the wild type adrenodoxin crystal structures. Large distances and asymmetric distribution of the charged residues in the molecule mainly determine the observed high value. In order to analyse the influence of the resulting inhomogeneous electric field on the biological function of this electron carrier the molecular dipole moment was systematically changed. Five recombinant adrenodoxin mutants with successively reduced dipole moment (from 600 to 200 Debye) were analysed for their redox properties, their binding affinities to the redox partner proteins and for their function during electron transfer-dependent steroid hydroxylation. None of the mutants, not even the quadruple mutant K6E/K22Q/K24Q/K98E with a dipole moment reduced by about 70% showed significant changes in the protein function as compared with the unmodified adrenodoxin demonstrating that neither the formation of the transient complex nor the biological activity of the electron transfer chain of the endocrine glands was affected. This is the first experimental evidence that the high dipole moment observed in electron transfer proteins is not involved in electrostatic steering among the proteins in the redox chain.     

The structure of a tunicate C-type lectin from Polyandrocarpa misakiensis complexed with D -galactose.

C-type lectins are calcium-dependent carbohydrate-recognising proteins. Isothermal titration calorimetry of the C-type Polyandrocarpa lectin (TC14) from the tunicate Polyandrocarpa misakiensis revealed the presence of a single calcium atom per monomer with a dissociation constant of 2.6 microM, and confirmed the specificity of TC14 for D -galactose and related monosaccharides. We have determined the 2.2 A X-ray crystal structure of Polyandrocarpa lectin complexed with D -galactose. Analytical ultracentrifugation revealed that TC14 behaves as a dimer in solution. This is reflected by the presence of two molecules in the asymmetric unit with the dimeric interface formed by antiparallel pairing of the two N-terminal beta-strands and hydrophobic interactions. TC14 adopts a typical C-type lectin fold with differences in structure from other C-type lectins mainly in the diverse loop regions and in the second alpha-helix, which is involved in the formation of the dimeric interface. The D -galactose is bound through coordination of the 3 and 4-hydroxyl oxygen atoms with a bound calcium atom. Additional hydrogen bonds are formed directly between serine, aspartate and glutamate side-chains of the protein and the sugar 3 and 4-hydroxyl groups. Comparison of the galactose binding by TC14 with the mannose binding by rat mannose-binding protein reveals how monosaccharide specificity is achieved in this lectin. A tryptophan side-chain close to the binding site and the distribution of hydrogen-bond acceptors and donors around the 3 and 4-hydroxyl groups of the sugar are essential determinants of specificity. These elements are, however, arranged in a very different way than in an engineered galactose-specific mutant of MBPA. Possible biological functions can more easily be understood from the fact that TC14 is a dimer under physiological conditions.     

Purification and functional analysis of a 40 kD protein extracted from the Strombus decorus persicus mollusk shells

A 40 kD protein has been extracted from the biomineral matrix of the calcium carbonate gastropod shell of Strombus decorus persicus. The protein was isolated by decalcification and ion exchange HPLC. We have named this protein ACLS40, i.e., aragonite crossed-lamellar structure protein. A partial sequence of the isolated ACLS40 and amino acid analysis both indicate that it does not belong to the family of very acidic proteins, i.e., rich in aspartic and glutamic residues. The shell-extracted protein shows the ability to stabilize calcium carbonate in vitro, in the form of thermodynamically unstable vaterite polymorph, and to inhibit the growth of calcite.     

Primary structure characterization of Bothrops jararacussu snake venom lectin

The complete amino acid sequence of the lectin from Bothrops jararacussu snake venom (BJcuL) is reported. The sequence was determined by Edman degradation and amino acid analysis of the S-carboxymethylated BJcuL derivative (RC-BJcuL) and from its peptides originated from enzymatic digestion. The sequence of amino acid residues showed that this lectin displays the invariant amino acid residues characterized in C-type lectins. Amino acids analysis revealed a high content of acidic amino acids and leucine. These findings suggest that BJcuL, like other snake venom lectins, possesses structural similarities to the carbohydrate recognition domain (CRD) of calcium-dependent animal lectins belonging to the C-type -galactoside binding lectin family.     

Novel basic protein, PfN23, functions as key macromolecule during nacre formation

The fine microstructure of nacre (mother of pearl) illustrates the beauty of nature. Proteins found in nacre were believed to be "natural hands" that control nacre formation. In the classical view of nacre formation, nucleation of the main minerals, calcium carbonate, is induced on and by the acidic proteins in nacre. However, the basic proteins were not expected to be components of nacre. Here, we reported that a novel basic protein, PfN23, was a key accelerator in the control over crystal growth in nacre. The expression profile, in situ immunostaining, and in vitro immunodetection assays showed that PfN23 was localized within calcium carbonate crystals in the nacre. Knocking down the expression of PfN23 in adults via double-stranded RNA injection led to a disordered nacre surface in adults. Blocking the translation of PfN23 in embryos using morpholino oligomers led to the arrest of larval development. The in vitro crystallization assay showed that PfN23 increases the rate of calcium carbonate deposition and induced the formation of aragonite crystals with characteristics close to nacre. In addition, we constructed the peptides and truncations of different regions of this protein and found that the positively charged C-terminal region was a key region for the function of PfN23 Taken together, the basic protein PfN23 may be a key accelerator in the control of crystal growth in nacre. This provides a valuable balance to the classic view that acidic proteins control calcium carbonate deposition in nacre.     

Crystal structure of neoculin: insights into its sweetness and taste-modifying activity

Although the majority of sweet compounds are of low molecular mass, several proteins are known to elicit sweet taste responses in humans. The fruit of Curculigo latifolia contains a heterodimeric protein, neoculin, which has both sweetness and a taste-modifying activity that converts sourness to sweetness. Here, we report the crystal structure of neoculin at 2.76A resolution. This is the first well-defined tertiary structure of a taste-modifying protein of this kind. The overall structure is quite similar to those of monocot mannose-binding lectins. However, crucial topological differences are observed in the C-terminal regions of both subunits. In both subunits of neoculin, the C-terminal tails turn up to form loops fixed by inter-subunit disulfide bonds that are not observed in the lectins. Indeed, the corresponding regions of the lectins stretch straight over the surface of another subunit. Such a C-terminal structural feature as is observed in neoculin results in a decrease in subunit-subunit interactions. Moreover, distribution of electrostatic potential on the surface of neoculin is unique and significantly different from those of the lectins, particularly in the basic subunit (NBS). We have found that there is a large cluster composed of six basic residues on the surface of NBS, and speculate that it might be involved in the elicitation of sweetness and/or taste-modifying activity of neoculin. Molecular dynamics simulation based on the crystallography results suggests that neoculin may adopt a widely "open" conformation at acidic pH, while unprotonated neoculin at neutral pH is in a "closed" conformation. Based on these simulations and the generation of a docking model between neoculin and the sweet-taste receptor, T1R2-T1R3, we propose the hypothesis that neoculin is in dynamic equilibrium between open and closed states, and that the addition of an acid shifts the equilibrium to the open state, allowing ligand-receptor interaction.     

Crystal structure of human CD69: a C-type lectin-like activation marker of hematopoietic cells

CD69 is a widely expressed type II transmembrane glycoprotein related to the C-type animal lectins that exhibits regulated expression on a variety of cells of the hematopoietic lineage, including neutrophils, monocytes, T cells, B cells, natural killer (NK) cells, and platelets. Activation of T lymphocytes results in the induced expression of CD69 at the cell surface. In addition, cross-linking of CD69 by specific antibodies leads to the activation of cells bearing this receptor and to the induction of effector functions. However, the physiological ligand of CD69 is unknown. We report here the X-ray crystal structure of the extracellular C-type lectin-like domain (CTLD) of human CD69 at 2.27 A resolution. Recombinant CD69 was expressed in bacterial inclusion bodies and folded in vitro. The protein, which exists as a disulfide-linked homodimer on the cell surface, crystallizes as a symmetrical dimer, similar to those formed by the related NK cell receptors Ly49A and CD94. The structure reveals conservation of the C-type lectin-like fold, including preservation of the two alpha-helical regions found in Ly49A and mannose-binding protein (MBP). However, only one of the nine residues coordinated to Ca(2+) in MBP is conserved in CD69 and no bound Ca(2+) is evident in the crystal structure. Surprisingly, electron density suggestive of a puckered six-membered ring was discovered at a site structurally analogous to the ligand-binding sites of MBP and Ly49A. This sugar-like density may represent, or mimic, part of the natural ligand recognized by CD69.     

Structure of a C-type carbohydrate recognition domain from the macrophage mannose receptor

The mannose receptor of macrophages and liver endothelium mediates clearance of pathogenic organisms and potentially harmful glycoconjugates. The extracellular portion of the receptor includes eight C-type carbohydrate recognition domains (CRDs), of which one, CRD-4, shows detectable binding to monosaccharide ligands. We have determined the crystal structure of CRD-4. Although the basic C-type lectin fold is preserved, a loop extends away from the core of the domain to form a domain-swapped dimer in the crystal. Of the two Ca(2+) sites, only the principal site known to mediate carbohydrate binding in other C-type lectins is occupied. This site is altered in a way that makes sugar binding impossible in the mode observed in other C-type lectins. The structure is likely to represent an endosomal form of the domain formed when Ca(2+) is lost from the auxiliary calcium site. The structure suggests a mechanism for endosomal ligand release in which the auxiliary calcium site serves as a pH sensor. Acid pH-induced removal of this Ca(2+) results in conformational rearrangements of the receptor, rendering it unable to bind carbohydrate ligands.     

Interaction of rabbit C-reactive protein with phospholipid monolayers studied by microfluorescence film balance with an externally applied electric field.

C-reactive protein (CRP) is one of the most characteristic acute-phase proteins in humans and many other animals. It binds to phosphorylcholine in a calcium-dependent manner. In addition, CRP activates the complement systems via the classical pathway. The interaction between rabbit CRP (rCRP) and model biological membrane is studied using dimyristoylphosphatidylethanolamine and dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine monolayers. Observations with fluorescence microscopy indicate that rCRP is more likely to be incorporated in the liquid phase of monolayers. Such incorporation does not depend on the presence of calcium and is not inhibited by phosphocholine. The area occupied by the protein when incorporated into the monolayer was estimated. The dipole moment density of the protein crossing the air/water interface was measured by applying an external electric field. Our results indicate that calcium binding leads to a conformational change in CPR, which might modify the orientation of CRP in the monolayer. In addition, a negative charge or negative difference in dipole moment density facilitates the incorporation of CPR into the monolayer.     

X-ray structures of the maltose-maltodextrin-binding protein of the thermoacidophilic bacterium Alicyclobacillus acidocaldarius provide insight into acid stability of proteins

Maltose-binding proteins act as primary receptors in bacterial transport and chemotaxis systems. We report here crystal structures of the thermoacidostable maltose-binding protein from Alicyclobacillus acidocaldarius, and explore its modes of binding to maltose and maltotriose. Further, comparison with the structures of related proteins from Escherichia coli (a mesophile), and two hyperthermophiles (Pyrococcus furiosus and Thermococcus litoralis) allows an investigation of the basis of thermo- and acidostability in this family of proteins.The thermoacidophilic protein has fewer charged residues than the other three structures, which is compensated by an increase in the number of polar residues. Although the content of acidic and basic residues is approximately equal, more basic residues are exposed on its surface whereas most acidic residues are buried in the interior. As a consequence, this protein has a highly positive surface charge. Fewer salt bridges are buried than in the other MBP structures, but the number exposed on its surface does not appear to be unusual. These features appear to be correlated with the acidostability of the A. acidocaldarius protein rather than its thermostability.An analysis of cavities within the proteins shows that the extremophile proteins are more closely packed than the mesophilic one. Proline content is slightly higher in the hyperthermophiles and thermoacidophiles than in mesophiles, and this amino acid is more common at the second position of beta-turns, properties that are also probably related to thermostability. Secondary structural content does not vary greatly in the different structures, and so is not a contributing factor.     

The ligand-binding loops in the tunicate C-type lectin TC14 are rigid

C-type lectin-like domains are very common components of extracellular proteins in animals. They bind to a variety of ligands, including carbohydrates, proteins, ice, and CaCO3 crystals. Their structure is characterized by long surface loops in the area of the protein usually involved in ligand binding. The C-type lectin TC14 from Polyandrocarpa misakiensis specifically binds to D-galactose by coordination of the sugar to a bound calcium atom. We have studied the dynamic properties of TC14 by measuring 15N longitudinal and transverse relaxation rates as well as [1H-15N] heteronuclear NOEs. Relaxation rates and heteronuclear NOE data for holo-TC14 show minimal variations, indicating that there is no substantial difference in rigidity between the elements of regular secondary structure and the extended surface loops. Anisotropic tumbling of the elongated TC14 dimer can account for the main fluctuations in relaxation rates. Loss of the bound calcium does not significantly alter the internal dynamics, suggesting that the stability of the loop region is intrinsic and not dependent on the coordination of the calcium ion. Chemical shift differences between the holo and apo form show that main structural changes occur in the calcium-binding site, but smaller structural changes are propagated throughout the molecule without affecting the overall fold. The disappearance of two resonances for residues following the conserved cis-proline 87 (which is located in the calcium-binding site) in the apo form indicates conformational change on an NMR time scale between the cis and trans configurations of this peptide bond in the absence of calcium. Possible implications of these findings for the ligand binding in C-type lectin-like domains are discussed.     

A simple electrostatic criterion for predicting the thermal stability of proteins

The enhancement of protein thermostability is an important issue for both basic science and biotechnology purposes. We have developed a thermostability criterion for a protein in terms of a quasi-electric dipole moment (contributed by its charged residues) defined for an electric charge distribution whose total charge is not zero. It was found that minimization of the modulus of this dipole moment increased its thermal stability, as demonstrated by surveying these values in pairs of mesostable-thermostable homologous proteins and in mutations described in the literature. The analysis of these observations provides criteria for thermostabilization of a protein, by computing its dipole profile. This profile is obtained by direct substitution of each amino acid of the sequence by either a positive, negative or neutral amino acid, followed by a recalculation of the dipole moment. As an experimental example, these criteria were applied to a beta-glucanase to enhance its thermal stability.     

Crystal structure of the C-type lectin-like domain from the human hematopoietic cell receptor CD69

CD69, one of the earliest specific antigens acquired during lymphoid activation, acts as a signal-transducing receptor involved in cellular activation events, including proliferation and induction of specific genes. CD69 belongs to a family of receptors that modulate the immune response and whose genes are clustered in the natural killer (NK) gene complex. The extracellular portion of these receptors represent a subfamily of C-type lectin-like domains (CTLDs), which are divergent from true C-type lectins and are referred to as NK-cell domains (NKDs). We have determined the three-dimensional structure of human CD69 NKD in two different crystal forms. CD69 NKD adopts the canonical CTLD fold but lacks the features involved in Ca(2+) and carbohydrate binding by C-type lectins. CD69 NKD dimerizes noncovalently, both in solution and in crystalline state. The dimer interface consists of a hydrophobic, loosely packed core, surrounded by polar interactions, including an interdomain beta sheet. The intersubunit core shows certain structural plasticity that may facilitate conformational rearrangements for binding to ligands. The surface equivalent to the binding site of other members of the CTLD superfamily reveals a hydrophobic patch surrounded by conserved charged residues that probably constitutes the CD69 ligand-binding site.     

Electrostatics and electrodynamics of bacteriorhodopsin.

The stationary electric dichroism of bacteriorhodopsin is in qualitative, but not quantitative, agreement with the orientation function for disks having a permanent dipole directed perpendicular to the plane and an induced dipole in the plane. Fits of the orientation function to data measured at low field strengths demonstrate: an increase of the permanent dipole moment mu with the square of the disk radius r2, whereas the polarizability alpha increases with r4; the ionic strength dependence is small for mu and clearly stronger for alpha; the permanent dipole moment is 4x10(6) D at r = 0.5 micron. According to the risetime constants, the induced dipole does not saturate and increases to 4x10(8) D at 40 kV/cm and r = 0.5 micron. The data indicate that the permanent dipole is not of some interfacial character but is due to a real assymetry of the charge distribution. The experimental dipole moment per protein monomer is approximately 55 D, whereas calculations based on the structure of Grigorieff et al. (Grigorieff, N., T.A. Ceska, K.H. Downing, J.M. Baldwin, and R. Henderson. 1996. Electron-crystallographic refinement of the structure of bacteriorhodopsin. J. Mol. Biol. 259:393-421) provide a dipole moment of approximately 570 D. The difference is probably due to a nonsymmetric distribution of charged lipid residues. It is concluded that experimental dipole moments reflect the mu-potential at the plane of shear for rotational diffusion, in analogy to the sigma-potential used for translational diffusion. It is suggested that the permanent dipole of bacteriorhodopsin supports proton transport by attraction of protons inside and repulsion of protons outside of the cell. Dichroism rise curves at field strengths between E = 150 and 800 V/cm reveal an exponential component with time constants tau 3r in the range between 1 and 40 ms, which is not found in Brownian dynamics simulations on a disk structure using hydrodynamic and electric parameters characteristic of bacteriorhodopsin disks. The experimental data suggest that this process reflects a cooperative change of the bacteriorhodopsin structure, which is induced already at a remarkably low field strength of approximately 150 V/cm.     

Crystal structure of coagulation factor IX-binding protein from habu snake venom at 2.6 A: implication of central loop swapping based on deletion in the linker region.

Coagulation factor IX-binding protein (IX-bp) isolated from the venom of the habu snake (Trimeresurus flavoviridis) is a disulfide-linked heterodimer consisting of homologous subunits A and B. The structure of IX-bp has been solved by X-ray crystallography at 2.6 A resolution to a crystallographic R -value of 0.181. The main-chain fold of each subunit is homologous to the carbohydrate-recognition domain of C-type lectins (C-type CRDs) except for the extended central loop. The structure is almost identical with that of factors IX and X-binding protein (IX/X-bp) as expected from the high level of amino acid sequence homology. The functional difference in ligand recognition from IX/X-bp must reside in the amino acid differences. A continuity of different amino acid residues located from the C-terminal of the second alpha-helix to the following loop forms the local conformational difference in this region between the two proteins. This loop participates in the formation of the concave surface between the two subunits, the putative binding site for the Gla-domain (gamma-carboxyglutamic acid-containing domain) of the coagulation factors. Another difference between the two proteins is in the relative disposition of subunits A and B. When the B subunits are superimposed, about a 6 degrees rotation is required for the superposition of the A subunits. A calcium ion links the second alpha-helix region to the C-terminal tail in each subunit and helps to stabilize the structure for Gla-domain binding. The interface created by the central loop swapping in the dimer IX-bp is almost identical with that seen within the monomeric C-type CRDs. This dimer forms as the result of the amino acid deletion in the linker region of the central loop of the original C-type lectins. Such a dimerization disrupts the lectin active site and creates a Gla-domain binding site, imparting functional diversity.     

Electrooptical measurements demonstrate a large permanent dipole moment associated with acetylcholinesterase.

Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) from krait (Bungarus fasciatus) venom is a soluble, nonamphiphilic monomer of 72 kDa. This snake venom AChE has been analyzed by measurements of the stationary and the transient electric dichroism at different field strengths. The stationary values of the dichroism are consistent with the orientation function for permanent dipoles and are not consistent with the orientation function for induced dipoles. The permanent dipole moment obtained by least-squares fits for a buffer containing 5 mM MES is 1000 D, after correction for the internal directing field, assuming a spherical shape of the protein. The dipole moment decreases with increasing buffer concentration to 880 D at 10 mM MES and 770 D at 20 mM MES. The dichroism decay time constant is 90 ns (+/- 10%) which is clearly larger than the value expected from the size/shape of the protein and indicates contributions from sugar residues attached to the protein. The dichroism rise times observed at low field strengths are larger than the decay times and, thus, support the assignment of a permanent dipole moment, although it has not been possible to approach the limit where the energy of the dipole in the electric field is sufficiently low compared to kT. The experimental value of the permanent dipole moment is similar to that calculated for a model structure of Bungarus fasciatus AChE, which has been constructed from its amino and acid sequence, in analogy to the crystal structure of AChE from Torpedo californica.     

A model for the calculation of the dielectric dispersion and the dipole moment of globular proteins in solution

We describe a new procedure whereby the magnitude of the dielectric dispersion of a solution of globular protein molecules can be calculated. The protein molecule is considered to have spherical symmetry and the charged residues are thought to be situated in a medium whose dielectric constant increases continuously as a function of the distance from the centre of mass. The dipole moment of the protein in the solution is made up of two parts: the intrinsic dipole moment due to the charge distribution of the protein and the dipole moment due to polarization of the medium and the ionic cloud. When the model is applied to solutions of cytochrome c it is found that polarization of the medium results in a decrease in the dielectric dispersion amplitude. The mean square dipole moment calculated with the help of this method indicates that the fluctuation of the configurations cannot be responsible for the large dispersion in the megahertz region.     

Interactions between acidic matrix macromolecules and calcium phosphate ester crystals: relevance to carbonate apatite formation in biomineralization.

Control over crystal growth by acidic matrix macromolecules is an important process in the formation of many mineralized tissues. Earlier studies on the interactions between acidic macromolecules and carboxylate- and carbonate-containing crystals showed that the proteins recognize a specific stereochemical motif on the interacting plane. Here we show that a similar stereochemical motif is recognized by acidic mollusc shell macromolecules interacting with four different organic calcium phosphate-containing crystals. In addition, an acidic protein from vertebrate tooth dentin was also observed to recognize a similar structural motif in one of the crystals. The characteristic motif recognized is composed of rows of calcium ions and phosphates arranged in a plane defined by two free oxygens and a phosphorus atom emerging perpendicular to the affected face. These observations may have a direct bearing on the manner in which control over crystal growth is exerted on carbonate apatite crystals commonly found in vertebrate tissues.