Ultra scale‐down approaches for clarification of mammalian cell culture broths in disc‐stack centrifuges

Ultra‐scale down (USD) methodology developed by University College London for cell broth clarification with industrial centrifuges was applied to two common cell lines (NS0 and GS‐CHO) expressing various therapeutic monoclonal antibodies. A number of centrifuges at various scales were used with shear devices operating either by high speed rotation or flow‐through narrow channels. The USD methodology was found effective in accounting for both gravitational and shear effects on clarification performance with three continuous centrifuges at pilot and manufacturing scales. Different shear responses were observed with the two different cell lines and even with the same cell line expressing different products. Separate particle size analysis of the treated broths seems consistent with the shear results. Filterability of the centrifuged solutions was also evaluated to assess the utility of the USD approach for this part of the clarification operation. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2009     

Impact of clarification strategy on chromatographic separations: Pre-processing of cell homogenates

This research focused on how the extent and type of primary solid-liquid separation can affect the performance of guard filtration and chromatography, in this instance hydrophobic interaction chromatography. The system used in the study was yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) with the target molecule being an intracellular protein; alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH). As expected, loading more poorly clarified suspensions (both centrates and primary filtrates) required proportionally larger guard filtration areas. In addition for feed suspensions prepared by centrifugation, increased clarification led to greater column capacity. However, where filtration was used to achieve similar clarification considerably lower column capacity was achieved. These results were attributed to centrifugation leading to the aggregation of lipids and their subsequent removal in this form before application to the column. Clarification by filtration leaves such lipids in their original "soluble" state and hence they are not removed. The importance of the need to examine such interactive effects in bioprocess studies is discussed. This observation was confirmed with further analytical work into the nature of the aggregated material formed in the supernatant under centrifugation conditions. This material was only soluble in an organic solvent, and identified as phophatidylcholine and ergosterol as among the components removed by centrifugation and guard filtration as opposed to filtration and guard filtration.     

Clarification of recombinant proteins from high cell density mammalian cell culture systems using new improved depth filters

Increasingly high cell density, high product titer cell cultures containing mammalian cells are being used for the production of recombinant proteins. These high productivity cultures are placing a larger burden on traditional downstream clarification and purification operations due to higher product and impurity levels. Controlled flocculation and precipitation of mammalian cell culture suspensions by acidification or using polymeric flocculants have been employed to enhance clarification throughput and downstream filtration operations. While flocculation is quite effective in agglomerating cell debris and process related impurities such as (host cell) proteins and DNA, the resulting suspension is generally not easily separable solely using conventional depth filtration techniques. As a result, centrifugation is often used for clarification of cells and cell debris before filtration, which can limit process configurations and flexibility due to the investment and fixed nature of a centrifuge. To address this challenge, novel depth filter designs were designed which results in improved primary and secondary direct depth filtration of flocculated high cell density mammalian cell cultures systems feeds, thereby providing single‐use clarification solution. A framework is presented here for optimizing the particle size distribution of the mammalian cell culture systems with the pore size distribution of the gradient depth filter using various pre‐treatment conditions resulting in increased depth filter media utilization and improved clarification capacity. Feed conditions were optimized either by acidification or by polymer flocculation which resulted in the increased average feed particle‐size and improvements in throughput with improved depth filters for several mammalian systems. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2013; 110: 1964–1972. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Repeated hybridoma batch culture with cell recycle

At the end of a hybridoma batch culture, the cells are usually discarded after separation from the culture broth. If, however, they are aseptically recycled into the reactor, the production process can be resumed simply by the addition of fresh medium. This cycle can then be repeated several times consecutively. In a test case, with a mouse hybridoma, we found antibody yields for each cycle in the same range as for a standard batch. In a 15 1 stirred tank reactor we could, within 6 days, produce 2.8 g of monoclonal antibody (MAb). This type of reactor operation allowed a doubling in the reactor volumetric productivity (mg/l/day).     

Single-stage chromatographic clarification of Chinese Hamster Ovary cell harvest reduces cost of protein production

A single-stage clarification was developed using a single-use chromatographic clarification device (CCD) to recover a recombinant protein from Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) harvest cell culture fluid (HCCF). Clarification of a CHO HCCF is a complex and costly process, involving multiple stages of centrifugation and/or depth filtration to remove cells and debris and to reduce process-related impurities such as host cell protein (HCP), nucleic acids, and lipids. When using depth filtration, the filter train consists of multiple filters of varying ratios, layers, pore sizes, and adsorptive properties. The depth filters, in combination with a 0.2-micron membrane filter, clarify the HCCF based on size-exclusion, adsorptive, and charge-based mechanisms, and provide robust bioburden control. Each stage of the clarification process requires time, labor, and utilities, with product loss at each step. Here, use of the 3M™ Harvest RC Chromatographic Clarifier, a single-stage CCD, is identified as an alternative strategy to a three-stage filtration train. The CCD results in less overall filter area, less volume for flushing, and higher yield. Using bioprocess cost modeling, the single-stage clarification process was compared to a three-stage filtration process. By compressing the CHO HCCF clarification to a single chromatographic stage, the overall cost of the clarification process was reduced by 17%–30%, depending on bioreactor scale. The main drivers for the cost reduction were reduced total filtration area, labor, time, and utilities. The benefits of the single-stage harvest process extended throughout the downstream process, resulting in a 25% relative increase in cumulative yield with comparable impurity clearance.     

Effectiveness of host cell protein removal using depth filtration with a filter containing diatomaceous earth

The increased cell density and product titer in biomanufacturing have led to greater use of depth filtration as part of the initial clarification of cell culture fluid, either as a stand-alone unit operation or after centrifugation. Several recent studies have shown that depth filters can also reduce the concentration of smaller impurities like host cell proteins (HCP) and DNA, decreasing the burden on subsequent chromatographic operations. The objective of this study was to evaluate the HCP removal properties of the Pall PDH4 depth filter media, a model depth filter containing diatomaceous earth, cellulose fibers, and a binder. Experiments were performed with both cell culture fluid (CCF) and a series of model proteins with defined pI, molecular weight, and hydrophobicity chosen to match the range of typical HCP. The location of adsorbed (fluorescently labeled) proteins within the depth filters was determined using confocal scanning laser microscopy. Protein binding was greater for proteins that were positively charged and more hydrophobic, consistent with adsorption to the negatively charged diatomaceous earth. The lowest degree of binding was seen with proteins near their pI, which were poorly removed by this filter. These results provide new mechanistic insights into the factors governing the filter capacity and performance characteristics of depth filters containing diatomaceous earth that are widely used in the clarification of CCF.     

Control of antibody high and low molecular weight species by depth filtration-based cell culture harvesting

Depth filtration-based harvesting is widely used in mAb manufacturing to remove cell and process-related impurities. However, it has not been studied on control of product-related impurities, which are very critical for product quality. In this article, we studied the interactions of depth filter with high and low molecular weight species (HMWs and LMWs) for their direct removal from cell culture. The process parameters (filter, loading, temperature, and flux) were evaluated for adsorption of HMWs and LMWs by depth filters. The adsorption is significantly dependent on filter media and loading capacity and is mainly on the basis of hydrophobic interaction during harvesting. The HMW and LMW species were characterized as HMW1, HMW2, LMW1, and LMW2. The increasing binding from LMW2 to LMW1, HMW1, and HMW2 is correlated with their increasing hydrophobicity score. Adsorption using enriched HMW sample demonstrated similar total protein binding capacity (36–40 g/m²) between depth filters D0HC and X0HC. However, X0HC has stronger HMW binding than D0HC (71% vs 43% of bound protein), indicating more hydrophobic interaction in X0HC. HMW2 DBC on X0HC reached 12 g/m², similar to protein binding on hydrophobic interaction membrane adsorbers. Further study showed LMW can induce HMW formation. This study provides a critical understanding of HMW and LMW interaction with depth filters. The strategy of HMW and LMW control by depth filtration-based harvesting was implemented successfully in mAb manufacturing.     

The effect of protein a cycle number on the performance and lifetime of an anion exchange polishing step

Most mAb platform purification processes consist of an affinity capture step followed by one or two polishing steps. An understanding of the performance linkages between the unit operations can lead to robust manufacturing processes. In this study, a weak‐partitioning anion‐exchange chromatography polishing step used in a mAb purification process was characterized through high‐throughput screening (HTS) experiments, small‐scale experiments including a cycling study performed on qualified scale‐down models, and large‐scale manufacturing runs. When material from a Protein A column that had been cycled <10× was loaded on the AEX resin, early breakthrough of impurities and premature loss of capacity was observed. As the cycle number on the Protein A resin increased, the capacity of the subsequent AEX step increased. Different control strategies were considered for preventing impurity breakthrough and improving AEX resin lifetimes. Depth filtration of the Protein A peak pool significantly improved the AEX resin capacity, robustness, and lifetime. Further, the turbidity of the Protein A pool has the potential for use as an in‐process control parameter for monitoring the performance of the AEX step. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2013; 110: 1142–1152. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Introduction and clearance of beta-glucan in the downstream processing of monoclonal antibodies

β-Glucan process-related impurities can be introduced into biopharmaceutical products via upstream or downstream processing or via excipients. This study obtained a comprehensive process-mapping dataset for five monoclonal antibodies to assess β-glucan introduction and clearance during development and production runs at various scales. Overall, 198 data points were available for analysis. The greatest β-glucan concentrations were found in the depth-filtration filtrate (37–2,745 pg/ml). Load volume correlated with β-glucan concentration in the filtrate, whereas flush volume was of secondary importance. Cation-exchange chromatography significantly cleared β-glucans. Furthermore, β-glucan leaching from the Planova 20N virus removal filter was reduced by increasing the flush volume (1 vs. 10 L/m²). β-glucan concentrations after filter flush with 10 L/m² were consistently <10 pg/ml. No or only limited β-glucan clearance was attained via ultrafiltration/diafiltration (UF/DF). However, during the first run with monoclonal antibody (mAb) 4, β-glucan concentration in the UF/DF retentate was 10.8 pg/mg, potentially due to β-glucan leaching from the first run with a regenerated cellulose membrane. Overall, β-glucan levels in the final mAb drug substance were 1–12 pg/mg. Assuming high doses of 1,000–5,000 mg, a β-glucan contamination at 20 pg/mg would translate to 20–100 ng/dose, which is below the previously suggested threshold for product safety (≤500 ng/dose).     

Enhancing Protein A performance in mAb processing: A method to reduce and rapidly evaluate host cell DNA levels during primary clarification

The use and impact of 3M™ Emphaze™ AEX Hybrid Purifier, a single-use, fully synthetic chromatographic product, was explored to reduce host cell DNA (HC-DNA) concentration during the primary clarification of a monoclonal antibody (mAb). An approximately 5-log reduction in HC-DNA was achieved at an Emphaze AEX Hybrid Purifier throughput of 200 L/m². The appreciable reduction in HC-DNA achieved during primary clarification enhanced Protein A chromatography performance, resulting in a sharper and narrower elution profile. In addition, a 24× improvement in host cell protein (HCP) removal and fewer impurities nonspecifically bound to the Protein A column were observed compared to those resulting from the use of depth filtration for clarification. The use of a rapid, qualitative acidification assay to facilitate HC-DNA monitoring was also investigated. This assay involves the acidification-induced precipitation of HC-DNA, enabling the easy and rapid detection of DNA breakthrough across purification media such as Emphaze AEX Hybrid Purifier by means of turbidimetric and particle size measurements.     

Impact of micro and macroporous TFF membranes on product sieving and chromatography loading for perfusion cell culture

Bioprocess intensification can be achieved through high cell density perfusion cell culture with continuous protein capture integration. Protein passage and cell retention are commonly accomplished using tangential flow filtration systems consisting of microporous membranes. Significant challenges, including low efficiency and decaying product sieving over time, are commonly observed in these cell retention devices. Here, we demonstrate that a macroporous membrane overcomes the product sieving challenges when comparing to several other membrane chemistries and pore sizes within the microporous range. This way, variable chromatography column loading is avoided. The macroporous membrane yielded a 13,000 L/m² volumetric throughput. The membrane's cut-off size results in an increased permeate turbidity due to particles passage, such as cell debris, through pores ranging from 1 to 4 µm. In addition, successful chromatography column plugging mitigation was achieved by employing depth filtration before the chromatographic step. Depth filtration volumetric throughputs were between 600 and 1,000 L/m². Combing a macroporous cell retention device with a depth filter not only provided an alternative to address the challenge of undesired long protein residence times in the bioreactor due to product sieving decay, but also exhibited a throughput increase, making the integration of multicolumn capture chromatography with a perfusion cell culture a more robust process.     

An effective,simple and low-cost pretreatment for culture clarification in tetanus toxoid production

Abstract

Chemically inactivated tetanus toxin (tetanus toxoid, TT), purified from cultures of a virulent Clostridium tetani strain, is the active pharmaceutical ingredient of anti-tetanus vaccines. Culture clarification for TT production and is usually performed by filtration-based techniques. Final clarification of the culture supernatant is achieved by passage through 0.2?µm pore size filtering membranes. Large particles removal (primary clarification) before final filtration (secondary clarification) reduces costs of the overall clarification process. With this aim, chitosan-induced particle aggregation was assessed as an alternative for primary clarification. Three chitosan variants were tested with similar results. Optimal clarification of culture supernatant was achieved by the addition of 8?mg chitosan per l of culture. Extrapolation analysis of filter sizing results indicate that 100?l of chitosan-treated supernatant can be finally filtered with a 0.6 m2 normal filtration cartridge of 0.45?+?0.2?µm pore size. The clarified material is compatible with current standard downstream processing techniques for TT purification. Thus, chitosan-induced particle aggregation is a suitable operation for primary clarification.     

Wide-surface pore microfiltration membrane drastically improves sieving decay in TFF-based perfusion cell culture and streamline chromatography integration for continuous bioprocessing

Although several compelling benefits for bioprocess intensification have been reported, the need for a streamlined integration of perfusion cultures with capture chromatography still remains unmet. Here, a robust solution is established by conducting tangential flow filtration-based perfusion with a wide-surface pore microfiltration membrane. The resulting integrated continuous bioprocess demonstrated negligible retention of antibody, DNA, and host cell proteins in the bioreactor with average sieving coefficients of 98 ± 1%, 124 ± 28%, and 109 ± 27%, respectively. Further discussion regarding the potential membrane fouling mechanisms is also provided by comparing two membranes with different surface pore structures and the same hollow fiber length, total membrane area, and chemistry. A cake-growth profile is reported for the narrower surface pore, 0.65-µm nominal retention perfusion membrane with final antibody sieving coefficients ≤70%. Whereas the sieving coefficient remained ≥85% during 40 culture days for the wide-surface pore, 0.2-µm nominal retention rating membrane. The wide-surface pore structure, confirmed by scanning electron microscopy imaging, minimizes the formation of biomass deposits on the membrane surface and drastically improves product sieving. This study not only offers a robust alternative for integrated continuous bioprocess by eliminating additional filtration steps while overcoming sieving decay, but also provides insight into membranes' fouling mechanism.     

Comparison of host cell protein removal by depth filters with diatomaceous earth and synthetic silica filter aids using model proteins

A number of studies have demonstrated that depth filtration can provide significant adsorptive removal of host cell proteins (HCP), but there is still considerable uncertainty regarding the underlying factors controlling HCP binding. This study compared the binding characteristics of two fine grade depth filters, the X0SP (polyacrylic fiber with a synthetic silica filter aid) and X0HC (cellulose fibers with diatomaceous earth (DE) as a filter aid), using a series of model proteins with well-defined physical characteristics. Protein binding to the X0SP filter was dominated by electrostatic interactions with greatest capacity for positively-charged proteins. In contrast, the X0HC filter showed greater binding of more hydrophobic proteins although electrostatic interactions also played a role. In addition, ovotransferrin showed unusually high binding capacity to the X0HC, likely due to interactions with metals in the DE. Scanning Electron Microscopy with Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy was used to obtain additional understanding of the binding behavior. These results provide important insights into the physical phenomena governing HCP binding to both fully synthetic and natural (cellulose + DE) depth filters.     

Trace metal optimization in CHO cell culture through statistical design of experiments

A majority of the biotherapeutics industry today relies on the manufacturing of monoclonal antibodies from Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells, yet challenges remain with maintaining consistent product quality from high-producing cell lines. Previous studies report the impact of individual trace metal supplemental on CHO cells, and thus, the combinatorial effects of these metals could be leveraged to improve bioprocesses further. A three-level factorial experimental design was performed in fed-batch shake flasks to evaluate the impact of time wise addition of individual or combined trace metals (zinc and copper) on CHO cell culture performance. Correlations among each factor (experimental parameters) and response variables (changes in cell culture performance) were examined based on their significance and goodness of fit to a partial least square's regression model. The model indicated that zinc concentration and time of addition counter-influence peak viable cell density and antibody production. Meanwhile, early copper supplementation influenced late-stage ROS activity in a dose-dependent manner likely by alleviating cellular oxidative stress. Regression coefficients indicated that combined metal addition had less significant impact on titer and specific productivity compared to zinc addition alone, although titer increased the most under combined metal addition. Glycan analysis showed that combined metal addition reduced galactosylation to a greater extent than single metals when supplemented during the early growth phase. A validation experiment was performed to confirm the validity of the regression model by testing an optimized setpoint of metal supplement time and concentration to improve protein productivity.     

Modeling industrial centrifugation of mammalian cell culture using a capillary based scale-down system

Continuous-flow centrifugation is widely utilized as the primary clarification step in the recovery of biopharmaceuticals from cell culture. However, it is a challenging operation to develop and characterize due to the lack of easy to use, small-scale, systems that can be used to model industrial processes. As a result, pilot-scale continuous centrifugation is typically employed to model large-scale systems requiring a significant amount of resources. In an effort to reduce resource requirements and create a system which is easy to construct and utilize, a capillary shear device, capable of producing energy dissipation rates equivalent to those present in the feed zones of industrial disk stack centrifuges, was developed and evaluated. When coupled to a bench-top, batch centrifuge, the capillary device reduced centrate turbidity prediction error from 37% to 4% compared to using a bench-top centrifuge alone. Laboratory-scale parameters that are analogous to those routinely varied during industrial-scale continuous centrifugation were identified and evaluated for their utility in emulating disk stack centrifuge performance. The resulting relationships enable bench-scale process modeling of continuous disk stack centrifuges using an easily constructed, scalable, capillary shear device coupled to a typical bench-top centrifuge.     

Selective removal of ammonia from animal cell culture broth

Serum-free perfusion cultures of hybridoma TO-405 cells were carried out in spinner flasks coupled with zeolite A-3 packed beads. Ammonia was selectively removed from the culture broth by passing cell free permeate from ceramic cross flow filtration, through the zeolite packed bed. Ammonia concentration in the culture broth was effectively maintained between 1 to 4 mmol/l which was below the inhibitory concentration for cell growth. Maximum cell density levels of 10⁷ cells/ml as well as improved percentage cell viability higher than in serum-supplemented cultures were feasible in this system.The possible effects of shear stress, generated by variation of the flow rates of the broth through the ceramic filter module, on the growth of the hybridoma cells were investigated. Backwashing, by reversing the direction of the permeate, was found necessary to prolong the life of the filter. Variation of the flow rates of the broth through the ceramic module between 0.29 m/s to 0.59 m/s did not cause immediate cell damage but growth was repressed at the higher flow rate.This study also showed that glutamine appears to be one of the factors limiting the growth of the hybridoma cells.