Feed development for fed‐batch CHO production process by semisteady state analysis

Semisteady state cultures are useful for studying cell physiology and facilitating media development. Two semisteady states with a viable cell density of 5.5 million cells/mL were obtained in CHO cell cultures and compared with a fed‐batch mode control. In the first semisteady state, the culture was maintained at 5 mM glucose and 0.5 mM glutamine. The second condition had threefold higher concentrations of both nutrients, which led to a 10% increase in lactate production, a 78% increase in ammonia production, and a 30% reduction in cell growth rate. The differences between the two semisteady states indicate that maintaining relatively low levels of glucose and glutamine can reduce the production of lactate and ammonia. Specific amino acid production and consumption indicated further metabolic differences between the two semisteady states and fed‐batch mode. The results from this experiment shed light in the feeding strategy for a fed‐batch process and feed medium enhancement. The fed‐batch process utilizes a feeding strategy whereby the feed added was based on glucose levels in the bioreactor. To evaluate if a fixed feed strategy would improve robustness and process consistency, two alternative feeding strategies were implemented. A constant volume feed of 30% or 40% of the initial culture volume fed over the course of cell culture was evaluated. The results indicate that a constant volumetric‐based feed can be more beneficial than a glucose‐based feeding strategy. This study demonstrated the applicability of analyzing CHO cultures in semisteady state for feed enhancement and continuous process improvement. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2010     

Enhanced growth of Sf-9 cells to a maximum density of 5.2 x 10(7) cells per mL and production of beta-galactosidase at high cell density by fed batch culture

Significant improvement in cell growth and protein production has been achieved in Sf-9 insect cell cultures using pulse additions of multicomponent nutrient feed concentrates (Bédard et al., 1994; Chan et al., 1998). The present work focuses on investigating an alternative feeding strategy wherein the nutrients are fed in a semi continuous manner. Fed batch culture experiments were carried out to compare the two different feeding strategies, pulse and semi continuous and a process developed to achieve a cell density of 5.2 x 10(7) cells/mL of Sf-9 cells in a 3.5 L bioreactor. Production of recombinant protein beta-galactosidase was carried out by infecting the cells with baculovirus at a MOI of 10 at cell densities of 17 x 10(6)cells/mL. Specific productivity could be maintained at cell densities as high as 14 x 10(6) cells/mL. The results presented indicate that the feeding method can provide significant improvements in the performance with a reduction in the amount of total nutrients added. On-line monitoring of the culture using the capacitance probe showed that the capacitance probe can be used successfully to monitor the biomass and infection process even at higher cell densities.     

Efficient optimization of time-varying inputs in a fed-batch cell culture process using design of dynamic experiments

In cell culture process development, we rely largely on an iterative, one-factor-at-a-time procedure based on experiments that explore a limited process space. Design of experiments (DoE) addresses this issue by allowing us to analyze the effects of process inputs on process responses systematically and efficiently. However, DoE cannot be applied directly to study time-varying process inputs unless an impractically large number of bioreactors is used. Here, we adopt the methodology of design of dynamic experiments (DoDE) and incorporate dynamic feeding profiles efficiently in late-stage process development of the manufacture of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies. We found that, for the specific cell line used in this article, (1) not only can we estimate the effect of nutrient feed amount on various product attributes, but we can also estimate the effect, develop a statistical model, and use the model to optimize the slope of time-trended feed rates; (2) in addition to the slope, higher-order dynamic characteristics of time-trended feed rates can be incorporated in the design but do not have any significant effect on the responses we measured. Based on the DoDE data, we developed a statistical model and used the model to optimize several process conditions. Our effort resulted in a tangible improvement in productivity—compared with the baseline process without dynamic feeding, this optimized process in a 200-L batch achieved a 27% increase in titer and > 92% viability. We anticipate our application of DoDE to be a starting point for more efficient workflows to optimize dynamic process conditions in process development.     

Nutrient Regulation by Continuous Feeding Removes Limitations on Cell Yield in the Large-Scale Expansion of Mammalian Cell Spheroids

Cellular therapies are emerging as a standard approach for the treatment of several diseases. However, realizing the promise of cellular therapies across the full range of treatable disorders will require large-scale, controlled, reproducible culture methods. Bioreactor systems offer the scale-up and monitoring needed, but standard stirred bioreactor cultures do not allow for the real-time regulation of key nutrients in the medium. In this study, β-TC6 insulinoma cells were aggregated and cultured for 3 weeks as a model of manufacturing a mammalian cell product. Cell expansion rates and medium nutrient levels were compared in static, stirred suspension bioreactors (SSB), and continuously fed (CF) SSB. While SSB cultures facilitated increased culture volumes, no increase in cell yields were observed, partly due to limitations in key nutrients, which were consumed by the cultures between feedings, such as glucose. Even when glucose levels were increased to prevent depletion between feedings, dramatic fluctuations in glucose levels were observed. Continuous feeding eliminated fluctuations and improved cell expansion when compared with both static and SSB culture methods. Further improvements in growth rates were observed after adjusting the feed rate based on calculated nutrient depletion, which maintained physiological glucose levels for the duration of the expansion. Adjusting the feed rate in a continuous medium replacement system can maintain the consistent nutrient levels required for the large-scale application of many cell products. Continuously fed bioreactor systems combined with nutrient regulation can be used to improve the yield and reproducibility of mammalian cells for biological products and cellular therapies and will facilitate the translation of cell culture from the research lab to clinical applications.     

Fed‐batch CHO cell t‐PA production and feed glutamine replacement to reduce ammonia production

Industrial therapeutic protein production has been greatly improved through fed‐batch development. In this study, improvement to the productivity of a tissue‐plasminogen activator (t‐PA) expressing Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell line was investigated in shake flask culture through the optimization of the fed‐batch feed and the reduction of ammonia generation by glutamine replacement. The t‐PA titer was increased from 33 mg/L under batch conditions to 250 mg/L with daily feeding starting after three days of culture. A commercially available fed‐batch feed was supplemented with cotton seed hydrolysate and the four depleted amino acids, aspartic acid, asparagine, cysteine, and tyrosine. The fed‐batch operation increased the generation of by‐products such as lactate and ammonia that can adversely affect the fed‐batch performance. To reduce the ammonia production, a glutamine‐containing dipeptide, pyruvate, glutamate, and wheat gluten hydrolysate, were investigated as glutamine substitutes. To minimize the lag phase as the cells adjusted to the new energy source, a feed glutamine replacement process was developed where the cells were initially cultured with a glutamine containing basal medium to establish cell growth followed by feeding with a feed containing the glutamine substitutes. This two‐step feed glutamine replacement process not only reduced the ammonia levels by over 45% but, in the case of using wheat gluten hydrolysate, almost doubled the t‐PA titer to over 420 mg/L without compromising the t‐PA product quality or glycosylation pattern. The feed glutamine replacement process combined with optimizing other feed medium components provided a simple, practical, and effective fed‐batch strategy that could be applied to the production of other recombinant therapeutic proteins. © 2012 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2013     

Concomitant reduction of lactate and ammonia accumulation in fed‐batch cultures: Impact on glycoprotein production and quality

Lactate and ammonia accumulation is a major factor limiting the performance of fed‐batch strategies for mammalian cell culture processes. In addition to the detrimental effects of these by‐products on production yield, ammonia also contributes to recombinant glycoprotein quality deterioration. In this study, we tackled the accumulation of these two inhibiting metabolic wastes by culturing in glutamine‐free fed‐batch cultures an engineered HEK293 cell line displaying an improved central carbon metabolism. Batch cultures highlighted the ability of PYC2‐overexpressing HEK293 cells to grow and sustain a relatively high viability in absence of glutamine without prior adaptation to the culture medium. In fed‐batch cultures designed to maintain glucose at high concentration by daily feeding a glutamine‐free concentrated nutrient feed, the maximum lactate and ammonia concentrations did not exceed 5 and 1 mM, respectively. In flask, this resulted in more than a 2.5‐fold increase in IFNα2b titer in comparison to the control glutamine‐supplied fed‐batch. In bioreactor, this strategy led to similar reductions in lactate and ammonia accumulation and an increase in IFNα2b production. Of utmost importance, this strategy did not affect IFNα2b quality with respect to sialylation and glycoform distribution as confirmed by surface plasmon resonance biosensing and LC‐MS, respectively. Our strategy thus offers an attractive and simple approach for the development of efficient cell culture processes for the mass production of high‐quality therapeutic glycoproteins. © 2018 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 34:494–504, 2018     

Perfusion seed cultures improve biopharmaceutical fed‐batch production capacity and product quality

Volumetric productivity and product quality are two key performance indicators for any biopharmaceutical cell culture process. In this work, we showed proof‐of‐concept for improving both through the use of alternating tangential flow perfusion seed cultures coupled with high‐seed fed‐batch production cultures. First, we optimized the perfusion N‐1 stage, the seed train bioreactor stage immediately prior to the production bioreactor stage, to minimize the consumption of perfusion media for one CHO cell line and then successfully applied the optimized perfusion process to a different CHO cell line. Exponential growth was observed throughout the N‐1 duration, reaching >40 × 10⁶ vc/mL at the end of the perfusion N‐1 stage. The cultures were subsequently split into high‐seed (10 × 10⁶ vc/mL) fed‐batch production cultures. This strategy significantly shortened the culture duration. The high‐seed fed‐batch production processes for cell lines A and B reached 5 g/L titer in 12 days, while their respective low‐seed processes reached the same titer in 17 days. The shortened production culture duration potentially generates a 30% increase in manufacturing capacity while yielding comparable product quality. When perfusion N‐1 and high‐seed fed‐batch production were applied to cell line C, higher levels of the active protein were obtained, compared to the low‐seed process. This, combined with correspondingly lower levels of the inactive species, can enhance the overall process yield for the active species. Using three different CHO cell lines, we showed that perfusion seed cultures can optimize capacity utilization and improve process efficiency by increasing volumetric productivity while maintaining or improving product quality. © 2014 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:616–625, 2014     

Case study: The characterization and implementation of dielectric spectroscopy (biocapacitance) for process control in a commercial GMP CHO manufacturing process

Dielectric spectroscopy (biocapacitance) is an up-and-coming technology for real time monitoring of biomass in cell culture processes and has opened the door for next-generation cell culture process control techniques such as automated on-demand nutrient feeding. In this case study we empirically demonstrate the lower limit of quantitation (LOQ), probe-to-probe consistency, and scalability of in situ biocapacitance probes using data generated from small- and large-scale Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) bioreactor cultures. The process understanding experiments culminated in the use of biocapacitance for process control in the current good manufacturing practices (GMP) manufacturing environment, first to automate the dilution of seed train cultures during scale-up stages and later as a method of predicting future glucose demand. The automated biomass-probe-based inoculation strategy yielded consistent results in six consecutive seed trains in the GMP manufacturing suite. In the process of improving our understanding of the technology we determined that biocapacitance could additionally be used as an indicator of a shift in the salt balance of a cell culture, and that collecting real time biomass data via biocapacitance has the potential to reduce the total timeline for feed strategy development by providing additional insights into culture performance which are not otherwise apparent using conventional optical cell counting methods.     

Quick generation of Raman spectroscopy based in‐process glucose control to influence biopharmaceutical protein product quality during mammalian cell culture

Mitigating risks to biotherapeutic protein production processes and products has driven the development of targeted process analytical technology (PAT); however implementing PAT during development without significantly increasing program timelines can be difficult. The development of a monoclonal antibody expressed in a Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell line via fed‐batch processing presented an opportunity to demonstrate capabilities of altering percent glycated protein product. Glycation is caused by pseudo‐first order, non‐enzymatic reaction of a reducing sugar with an amino group. Glucose is the highest concentration reducing sugar in the chemically defined media (CDM), thus a strategy controlling glucose in the production bioreactor was developed utilizing Raman spectroscopy for feedback control. Raman regions for glucose were determined by spiking studies in water and CDM. Calibration spectra were collected during 8 bench scale batches designed to capture a wide glucose concentration space. Finally, a PLS model capable of translating Raman spectra to glucose concentration was built using the calibration spectra and spiking study regions. Bolus feeding in mammalian cell culture results in wide glucose concentration ranges. Here we describe the development of process automation enabling glucose setpoint control. Glucose‐free nutrient feed was fed daily, however glucose stock solution was fed as needed according to online Raman measurements. Two feedback control conditions were executed where glucose was controlled at constant low concentration or decreased stepwise throughout. Glycation was reduced from ～9% to 4% using a low target concentration but was not reduced in the stepwise condition as compared to the historical bolus glucose feeding regimen. © 2015 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 32:224–234, 2016     

Metabolite profiling of recombinant CHO cells: Designing tailored feeding regimes that enhance recombinant antibody production

Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells are the primary platform for commercial expression of recombinant therapeutic proteins. Obtaining maximum production from the expression platform requires optimal cell culture medium (and associated nutrient feeds). We have used metabolite profiling to define the balance of intracellular and extracellular metabolites during the production process of a CHO cell line expressing a recombinant IgG4 antibody. Using this metabolite profiling approach, it was possible to identify nutrient limitations, which acted as bottlenecks for antibody production, and subsequently develop a simple feeding regime to relieve these metabolic bottlenecks. This metabolite profiling‐based strategy was used to design a targeted, low cost nutrient feed that increased cell biomass by 35% and doubled the antibody titer. This approach, with the potential for utilization in non‐specialized laboratories, can be applied universally to the optimization of production of commercially important biopharmaceuticals. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2011;108: 3025–3031. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Investigation of metabolic variability observed in extended fed batch cell culture

A 13‐day fed‐batch IgG1 production process was developed by applying our proprietary chemically defined platform process. The process was highly reproducible with respect to cell growth and titer, but the cultures exhibited metabolic variability after 12 days of cultivation. This metabolic variability consisted of a subset of cultures exhibiting increased cell‐specific glucose uptake rates and high lactate production rates (LPR) despite identical operating conditions. We investigated the causes of the metabolic variability by manipulating the rate at which feed medium was delivered. Overfeeding directly led to increased LPR. High LPR was found to be associated with increased mitochondrial membrane potential in a subset of cells, as measured through fluorescent staining, and feeding TCA cycle intermediates was found to prevent the high LPR phenotype. This supports the hypothesis that mitochondrial pathways are involved in inducing metabolic variability. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 29:1519–1527, 2013     

Selection of chemically defined media for CHO cell fed-batch culture processes

Two CHO cell clones derived from the same parental CHO^BC® cell line and producing the same monoclonal antibody (BC-G, a low producing clone; BC-P, a high producing clone) were tested in four basal media in all possible combinations with three feeds (=12 conditions) in fed-batch cultures. Higher amino acid feeding did not always lead to higher mAb production. The two clones showed differences in cell physiology, metabolism and optimal medium-feed combinations. During the phase transitions of all cultures, cell metabolism showed a shift represented by lower specific consumption and production rates, except for the specific glucose consumption rate in cultures fed by Actifeed A/B. The BC-P clone fed by Actifeed A/B showed a threefold cell volume increase and an increase of the specific consumption rate of glucose in the stationary phase. Since feeding was based on glucose this resulted in accumulation of amino acids for this feed, while this did not occur for the poorer feed (EFA/B). The same feed also led to an increase of cell size for the BC-G clone, but to a lesser extent.     

Development of a chemically defined platform fed-batch culture media for monoclonal antibody-producing CHO cell lines with optimized choline content

A chemically defined platform basal medium and feed media were developed using a single Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell line that produces a monoclonal antibody (mAb). Cell line A, which showed a peak viable cell density of 5.9 × 10⁶ cells/mL and a final mAb titer of 0.5 g/L in batch culture, was selected for the platform media development. Stoichiometrically balanced feed media were developed using glucose as an indicator of cell metabolism to determine the feed rates of all other nutrients. A fed-batch culture of cell line A using the platform fed-batch medium yielded a 6.4 g/L mAb titer, which was 12-fold higher than that of the batch culture. To examine the applicability of the platform basal medium and feed media, three other cell lines (A16, B, and C) that produce mAbs were cultured using the platform fed-batch medium, and they yielded mAb titers of 8.4, 3.3, and 6.2 g/L, respectively. The peak viable cell densities of the three cell lines ranged from 1.3 × 10⁷ to 1.8 × 10⁷ cells/mL. These results show that the nutritionally balanced fed-batch medium and feeds worked well for other cell lines. During the medium development, we found that choline limitation caused a lower cell viability, a lower mAb titer, a higher mAb aggregate content, and a higher mannose-5 content. The optimal choline chloride to glucose ratio for the CHO cell fed-batch culture was determined. Our platform basal medium and feed media will shorten the medium-development time for mAb-producing cell lines.     

Modeling and optimization of hairy root growth in fed‐batch process

This article proposes a feeding strategy based on a kinetic model to enhance hairy roots growth. A new approach for modeling hairy root growth is used, considering that there is no nutrient limitation thanks to an appropriate feeding, and the intracellular pools are supposed to be always saturated. Thus, the model describes the specific growth rate from extracellular concentration of the major nutrients and nutrient uptakes depend on biomass growth. An optimized feeding strategy was determined thanks to the model to maintain the major nutrient levels at their optimum assuming optimal initial concentrations. The optimal feed rate is computed in open loop using kinetic model prediction or in closed loop using conductivity measurements to estimate biomass growth. Datura innoxia was chosen as the model culture system. Shake flask cultures were used to calibrate the model. Finally, cultures in bioreactor were performed to validate the model and the control laws. © 2010 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2010     

Benchmarking of commercially available CHO cell culture media for antibody production

In this study, eight commercially available, chemically defined Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell culture media from different vendors were evaluated in batch culture using an IgG-producing CHO DG44 cell line as a model. Medium adaptation revealed that the occurrence of even small aggregates might be a good indicator of cell growth performance in subsequent high cell density cultures. Batch experiments confirmed that the culture medium has a significant impact on bioprocess performance, but high amino acid concentrations alone were not sufficient to ensure superior cell growth and high antibody production. However, some key amino acids that were limiting in most media could be identified. Unbalanced glucose and amino acids led to high cell-specific lactate and ammonium production rates. In some media, persistently high glucose concentrations probably induced the suppression of respiration and oxidative phosphorylation, known as Crabtree effect, which resulted in high cell-specific glycolysis rates along with a continuous and high lactate production. In additional experiments, two of the eight basal media were supplemented with feeds from two different manufacturers in six combinations, in order to understand the combined impact of media and feeds on cell metabolism in a CHO fed-batch process. Cell growth, nutrient consumption and metabolite production rates, antibody production, and IgG quality were evaluated in detail. Concentrated feed supplements boosted cell concentrations almost threefold and antibody titers up to sevenfold. Depending on the fed-batch strategy, fourfold higher peak cell concentrations and eightfold increased IgG titers (up to 5.8 g/L) were achieved. The glycolytic flux was remarkably similar among the fed-batches; however, substantially different specific lactate production rates were observed in the different media and feed combinations. Further analysis revealed that in addition to the feed additives, the basal medium can make a considerable contribution to the ammonium metabolism of the cells. The glycosylation of the recombinant antibody was influenced by the selection of basal medium and feeds. Differences of up to 50 % in the monogalacto-fucosylated (G1F) and high mannose fraction of the IgG were observed.     

Improving culture performance and antibody production in CHO cell culture processes by reducing the Warburg effect

Lactate is one of the key waste metabolites of mammalian cell culture. High lactate levels are caused by high aerobic glycolysis, also known as the Warburg effect, and are usually associated with adverse culture performance. Therefore, reducing lactate accumulation has been an ongoing challenge in the cell culture development to improve growth, productivity, and process robustness. The pyruvate dehydrogenase complex (PDC) plays a crucial role for the fate of pyruvate, as it converts pyruvate to acetyl coenzyme A (acetyl‐CoA). The PDC activity can be indirectly increased by inhibiting the PDC inhibitor, pyruvate dehydrogenase kinase, using dichloroacetate (DCA), resulting in less pyruvate being available for lactate formation. Here, Chinese hamster ovary cells were cultivated either with 5 mM DCA or without DCA in various batch and fed‐batch bioreactor processes. In all cultures, DCA increased peak viable cell density (VCD), culture length and final antibody titer. The strongest effect was observed in a fed batch with media and glucose feeding in which peak VCD was increased by more than 50%, culture length was extended by more than 3 days, and the final antibody titer increased by more than twofold. In cultures with DCA, lactate production and glucose consumption during exponential growth were on average reduced by approximately 40% and 35%, respectively. Metabolic flux analysis showed reduced glycolytic fluxes, whereas fluxes in the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle were not affected, suggesting that cultures with DCA use glucose more efficiently. In a proteomics analysis, only few proteins were identified as being differentially expressed, indicating that DCA acts on a posttranslational level. Antibody quality in terms of aggregation, charge variant, and glycosylation pattern was unaffected. Subsequent bioreactor experiments with sodium lactate and sodium chloride feeding indicated that lower osmolality, rather than lower lactate concentration itself, improved culture performance in DCA cultures. In conclusion, the addition of DCA to the cell culture improved culture performance and increased antibody titers without any disadvantages for cell‐specific productivity or antibody quality.     

High‐throughput miniaturized bioreactors for cell culture process development: Reproducibility,scalability, and control

Decreasing the timeframe for cell culture process development has been a key goal toward accelerating biopharmaceutical development. Advanced Microscale Bioreactors (ambr?) is an automated micro‐bioreactor system with miniature single‐use bioreactors with a 10–15 mL working volume controlled by an automated workstation. This system was compared to conventional bioreactor systems in terms of its performance for the production of a monoclonal antibody in a recombinant Chinese Hamster Ovary cell line. The miniaturized bioreactor system was found to produce cell culture profiles that matched across scales to 3 L, 15 L, and 200 L stirred tank bioreactors. The processes used in this article involve complex feed formulations, perturbations, and strict process control within the design space, which are in‐line with processes used for commercial scale manufacturing of biopharmaceuticals. Changes to important process parameters in ambr? resulted in predictable cell growth, viability and titer changes, which were in good agreement to data from the conventional larger scale bioreactors. ambr? was found to successfully reproduce variations in temperature, dissolved oxygen (DO), and pH conditions similar to the larger bioreactor systems. Additionally, the miniature bioreactors were found to react well to perturbations in pH and DO through adjustments to the Proportional and Integral control loop. The data presented here demonstrates the utility of the ambr? system as a high throughput system for cell culture process development. © 2014 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:718–727, 2014     

Controlled release of nutrients to mammalian cells cultured in shake flasks

Though cell culture-based protein production processes are rarely carried out under batch mode of operation, cell line and initial process development operations are usually carried out in batch mode due to simplicity of operation in widely used scale down platforms like shake flasks. Nutrient feeding, if performed, is achieved by bolus addition of concentrated feed solution at different intervals, which leads to large transient increases in nutrient concentrations. One negative consequence is increased waste metabolite production. We have developed a hydrogel-based nutrient delivery system for continuous feeding of nutrients in scale down models like shake flasks without the need for manual feed additions or any additional infrastructure. Continuous delivery also enables maintaining nutrient concentrations at low levels, if desired. The authors demonstrate the use of these systems for continuous feeding of glucose and protein hydrolysate to a suspension Chinese Hamster Ovary (CHO) culture in a shake flask. Glucose feeding achieved using the glucose-loaded hydrogel resulted in a 23% higher integral viable cell density and an 89% lower lactate concentration at the end of the culture when compared with a bolus-feed of glucose.